Time & Motion Study Presented By: AnupamKumar Reader SMS Varanasi. Email: anupamkr@gmail.com 1 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Time & Motion Study Frederick W. Taylor and his followers developed and refined the Time Study A method created to determine the correct time it takes to complete a certain task Frank B. Gilbreth and his wife Lillian developed and refined the Motion Study A method to establish the one best way to perform a task Historically the two studies are discussed individually, today they generally are discussed as one 2 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Time Study It is a work measurement technique for recording the times and rates of working for the elements of a specified jobs, carried out under specific conditions for analyzing the data so as to obtain the time necessary for carrying out the job at an defined level of performance. 3 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Motion Study It is the science of eliminating wastefulness resulting from using unnecessary, ill-directed and inefficient motion. The aim of the study is to find and perpetuate the scheme of least waste methods of labour. Workers do not enjoy making unnecessary or wasted motions, as they result in needless fatigue. Motion study thus helps in reducing fatigue & waste motions. 4 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Use of Time & Motion Study Historically: T&M Studies were used in the manufacturing industry to evolve pay scales with the thought that money was the only motivation for work. Today: T&M Studies can be effective for performance evaluations T&M Studies can be used for planning purposes in order to predict the level of output that may be achieved T&M Studies can be used to uncover problems and create solutions T&M Studies can be used for time cost analysis 5 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Objectives of Time & Motion Study Estimation of realistic manpower requirement. Comparison of alternative methods of working. Establishment of incentive schemes Improved control over operations. Proper work distribution. Future manpower and cost forecasting. 6 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 4/11/2013 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 2 Steps Involved in T&M Study Selection Obtain all necessary information Divide the job into job-elements Time each element Number of cycles to be timed Rate the operator The rating of the operator to be objective Make provisions for allowances. 7 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Job Element Should be as short as possible and should be conveniently timed. Should be unified and should have logical sequence of basic motions. Constant and variable elements should be separated for generation of data for subsequent studies. Regular and Irregular elements should be separated so as to provide for time allowances. Elements involving heavy and fatigue work should be separated to allow for proper allowances. 8 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Determination of Times Standard Time It is the time required by an operator of average skill who expends an average amount of effort and is working under average conditions. Use of Standard Time To establish minimum performance requirements Control of labour cost Planning wage incentive schemes Product line balancing. 9 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Determination of Times Performance Rating It is the pace of the actual work being done as a percentage of the standard pace of doing the same work. Level of Performance It is the rate of output achieved by a qualified worker as an average for the day. Normal Time It is the productive time needed to perform a task, utilizing appropriate work methods, work area layout and performing at a pace the firm defines as normal. 10 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Determination of Times Actual Time It is the time actually taken in completing the desired task. If the operator works at 100% efficiency then the actual time would be equal to the normal time. Use of Actual Time In method study In plant layout planning In setting realistic starting and finishing times for operator. 11 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Determination of Times Allowance Standard times for elements or jobs are necessary to provide for allowances for compensating fatigue, personal needs, contingencies, etc. These are generally given as a percentage of the standards time or normal time. If allowance is given as a percentage of normal time Standard Time = Normal Time (1+Allowance) If allowance is given as a percentage of standard time Normal Time = Standard Time (1 Allowance) 12 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 4/11/2013 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 3 Allowances or Time Allowances Relaxation Allowance For fatigue and personal needs Contingency Allowance For duties of periodic nature Tools and Machinery Allowance For adjusting machines, sharpening tools, etc. Reject Allowance Time used up in producing items which turn out to be defective Interference Allowance Stoppage of 2 or machines Excessive Work Allowance Due to unforeseen temporary changes 13 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Illustration 1 How many working minutes do you expect would take a worker to produce a part for which the time standard is 10 minutes, if the allowance for this work is 25% of the normal time and the worker is rated at 80%? Click for Solutions 14 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Solution to Illustration No. 1 Standard time = 10 Min Allowance = 25% of N.T. ST = NT (1+All.) NT = ST / (1 + All.) NT = 10/(1+25%) NT = 8 Min Performance Rating = (Normal time) / (Observed time) OT = NT / (Per. Rating) OT = 8/(80%) OT = 10 Min. Standard time = 10 Min Performance Rating = 80% Actual time = ST/Per. Ratg AT = 10/(80%) AT = 12.5 Min. Actual time = Observed time *(1+All.) OT = AT / (1+ All.) OT = 12.5 / (1+25%) OT = 12.5 X 4/5 OT = 10 Min. 15 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Illustration 2 Calculate the standard production per shift of 8 hours duration, with the following data. Observed time per unit = 5 minutes Rating factor = 120% Total Allowance = 33.33% of normal time. Click for Solutions 16 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Solution to Illustration No. 2 OT = 5 Min Per. Ratg. = 120% All. = 33.33% of NT NT = OT * Per. Ratg. NT = 5 X 120/100 NT = 6 Min. ST = NT (1+ All.) ST = 6 (1+33.33%) ST = 6X4/3 ST = 8 Min. 8 Min. is needed for 1 Unit 1 Min. is needed for 1/8 unit 8 Hrs. is needed for 8 X 60/8 Units 8 Hrs. is needed for 60 units. The standard production per shift is 60 Units. 17 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Methods of Time Estimation Study of Past Production Records It is an invaluable source of information regarding the time taken to perform a particular task. It is however assumed that the nature of activities performed in the process does not change over the period of time. Estimation Method It involves the analysis based on the experience & judgment of the observer. 18 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 4/11/2013 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 4 Work Measurement Techniques Direct Time Study Methods Analytical Estimation Work Sampling It is based on statistical estimation of work during various time samples. Indirect Time Study Methods Synthetic Timing Data It is based on the previous data available with the establishment which helps in synthesizing the overall data Predetermined Motion Time Studies (PMTS) It is based on the standard data available based on the various micro motion studies. 19 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Illustration 3 Calculate the standard time per article produced from the following data obtained by a work sampling study. Total No. of observations = 2500 No. of working observations = 2100 No. of units produced in 100 hours duration = 6000 Proportion of manual labour = 2/3 Proportion of machine time = 1/3 Observed rating factor = 115% Total allowance = 12% of normal time. Hint 20 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Hint for Illustration 3 Actual Working time in 100 hours = 100*2100/2500 = 84 Time taken per article = 84*60/6000 = 0.84 Min. Observed Manual time = (2/3) * 0.84 = 0.56 Min. Observed Machine time = (1/3) * 0.84 = 0.28 Min. Normal Labour time = Observed Manual time * Rating Factor = 0.56 * 1.15 Standard Labour Time = (0.56*1.15) * (1+ 12/100) = 0.56*1.15*1.12 Standard time per unit = Standard Labour Time + Observed Machine Time 21 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Illustration 4 After application of work simplification techniques and a direct time study of elements the following time elements in minutes were obtained as in table below. Job Element Cycle 1 2 3 4 5 1 0.16 0.12 0.13 0.15 0.24 2 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 3 0.33 0.50 0.35 0.37 0.35 4 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 5 0.24 0.24 0.25 0.27 0.25 22 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Illustration 4 (Contd.) The following information was also determined about the job. Job Element 2 & 4 are machine controlled and cannot be speeded up by the operator There were 2 irregular occurrences while timing. The operator was rated at 110% when working. Personal allowance 30 min/day; Unavoidable delays 20 min/day & Fatigue 10% of the operators actual physical time. Shift is 8 hour long. Calculate standard time per unit & shift output standard. Hint 23 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Hint for Illustration 4 Identify the Irregular occurrences. Calculate the average time for each job element. Calculate Normal Time and then Standard Time by using the data given for allowances. Job Element Cycle Ave. Time 1 2 3 4 5 1 0.16 0.12 0.13 0.15 0.24 0.14 2 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 3 0.33 0.50 0.35 0.37 0.35 0.35 4 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 5 0.24 0.24 0.25 0.27 0.25 0.25 24 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Solution 4/11/2013 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 5 Solution for Illustration No. 4 OT JE1 = 0.14 NT JE1 = OT JE1 X Per. Rat. NT JE1 = 1.4 X 110/100 NT JE1 = 1.54 Similarly, NT JE3 = 0.385 NT JE5 = 0.275 NT manual = 0.814 T manual = 0.814 * 1.10 = 0.8954 NT total = T manual + T machine NT total =0.8954+0.50+0.60 = 1.9954 ST = NT total / (1 Allowance ST ) Allowance = (30 + 20) / (8 * 60) Allowance = 0.104167 ST = 1.9954 / (1- 0.1042) ST = 1.9954 / 0.8958 = 2.227 min Standard Time = 2.23 minute Shift Output = 8 * 60 / 2.23 Shift Output = 215.25 Units. Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 25 Illustration No. 5 An operator manufactures 50 jobs in 6 hours and 30 minutes. If this time includes the time for setting the machine. Calculate the operators efficiency. Standard time allowed for the job is as follows. Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 26 Sr. No. Job Element Details 1. Setting Time 35 minutes 2. Production time per piece 8 minutes Solution Solution for Illustration No. 5 50 Jobs in 6 hours and 30 minutes 50 Job in (6*60 +30) minutes = 390 minutes Standard Time = Setting time+Production time S.T. = 35 + 8*50 = 35 + 400 = 435 minutes Per. Rating = Standard Time / Actual time Per. Rat. = (435 / 390)*100 = 111.5% Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 27 Illustration 5 Time data taken for a bulk filling activity in Bangalore were recorded on a continuous basis as shown below. The firms labour contract requires a 15% allowance based on total time for all workers on the bulk filling line Compute the standard time for this activity. Cycle Time (in Sec.) Rating Factor 1 2 3 4 5 Grasp Bag 4 37 74 105 338 120 Locate for fill 16 51 84 117 352 120 Machine Fill 26 61 94 127 362 Set on Conveyor 34 68 102 334 369 110 28 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Hint Hint for Illustration No. 6 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 29 Cycle Time (in Sec.) Rating Factor 1 2 3 4 5 Grasp Bag 4 37 74 105 338 120 Locate for fill 16 51 84 117 352 120 Machine Fill 26 61 94 127 362 Set on Conveyor 34 68 102 334 369 110 Grasp Bag 4 3 6 3 4 120 Locate for fill 12 14 10 12 14 120 Machine Fill 10 10 10 10 10 Set on Conveyor 8 7 8 207 7 110 Solution Solution for Illustration No. 6 Allowance = 15% on total time = 15% of Standard Time Normal Time = (OT 1 XPer.Rat. 1 + OT 2 XPer.Rat. 2 +OT 3 + OT 4 XPer.Rat. 4 ) Normal Time = 4*1.2 + 12.4*1.2+10+7.5*1.1 = 4.8 + 14.88 + 10 + 8.25 Normal Time = 37.93 sec. Standard Time = NT / (1 All.) = 37.93 / (1 0.15) = 37.93/0.85 Standard Time = 44.62 sec. Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 30 Cycle Time (in Sec.) Average 1 2 3 4 5 Grasp Bag 4 3 6 3 4 4 Locate for fill 12 14 10 12 14 12.4 Machine Fill 10 10 10 10 10 10 Set on Conveyor 8 7 8 207 7 7.5 4/11/2013 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 6 Further Numericals Assuming that the total observed time for an operation of assembling an electric switch is 1 minute. If the rating is 125%, find normal time. If an allowance of 20% is allowed for the operation for employee fatigue, determine the standard time. Find out the standard time using the following data: Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar 31 Sr. No. Job Element Details 1. Average time for machine element 7 min. 2. Average time for manual element 5 min. 3. Performance Rating 120% 4. Allowance (as a percentage of S.T.) 15% For further details, Contact: AnupamKumar Reader, SMS Varanasi. Email: anupamkr@gmail.com 32 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar Bibliography Buffa, E.S. and Sarin, R.K., Modern Production/Operations Management, Eighth Edition. Singapore: John Wiley & Sons (Asia). 1994. Martinich, J.S., Production and Operations Management: An Applied Approach, Singapore: John Wiley & Sons (Asia), 2003. Badi, R.V. and Badi, N.V., Production and Operations Management, Second Edition, New Delhi: Vrinda Publication, 2008. Chary, S.N., Productions and Operations Management, Third Edition, New Delhi: Tata McGraw Hill, 2004 Kumar Anil, S. and Suresh, N.. Production and Operations Management, New Delhi: New Age International Publishers Second Edition, 2008. Goel, B.S., Production Operations Management, Twenty Second Edition, Meerut, U.P.: Pragati Prakashan, 2010. Kachru, U. Production and Operations Management: Text and Cases, New Delhi: Excel Books, 2007. Rama Murthy, P., Production and Operations Management, New Delhi: New Age International, 2012. Chunawalla, S.A., and Patel, D.R., Production and Operations Management, Mumbai: Himalaya Publishing House, 2006. Jauhari, V. and Dutta, K., Services: Marketing Operations and Management, New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2010. Verma, H.V., Services Marketing: Text and Cases, New Delhi: Dorling Kindersley, Pearson Education, 2009. 33 Copyright 2013 Anupam Kumar