COMMENT SHEET FOR

CONTRACTORS DESIGN &

DRAWINGS
Ref. No. SOL-DR-14-0142 R00
Date 14 July 2014
PROJECT
Sarulla Geothermal Power Project GEOTHERMAL DRILLING CONTRACT
DWG TITLE
(Please see the table below)
Contractor HALLIBURTON
Control No.
Dwg. No. & Rev. No.
(Please see the table below)

Approval Status: 1. Approved, 2. Approved with Comments, 3.Returned for Correction

Drawing title Drawing No Rev Approval status
DRAWING LIST HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-001 0 2. Approved with Comments
LAYOUT FOR DRILLING
FACILITIES IN WELLPAD NIL-2
AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-007 0 2. Approved with Comments
PLAN VIEW & SECTION OF MUD
PIT IN NIL-2 AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-008 0 2. Approved with Comments
PLAN VIEW & SECTION OF WATER
PIT IN NIL-2 AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-009 0 2. Approved with Comments
PLAN VIEW & SECTION
PRODUCTION TEST PIT IN NIL-2
AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-010 0 2. Approved with Comments
PLAN VIEW & SECTION AIR
DRILLING UNIT FOUNDATION IN
NIL-2 AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-011 0 3.Returned for Correction
PLAN VIEW & SECTION
CEMENTING AREA FOUNDATION
IN NIL-2 AREA
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-012 0 3.Returned for Correction
RIG PAD IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN
SECTION & DETAIL
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013
(7 SHEETS)
0 3.Returned for Correction
CELLAR IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN
VIEW, SECTION & DETAIL
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-014 0 3.Returned for Correction
DRAINAGE PLAN WELLPAD IN
NIL-2
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-015
(6 SHEETS)
0 2. Approved with Comments
Preliminary Design for Rig Pad
Foundation
HAL-HPM-SOL-14-CALC-001 B 3.Returned for Correction
a. All documents
Please input the name in the document preparation, reviewer, and approver column.
Please check the drawing title between drawing list (HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-001) and each drawings.
Some title is little bit different.

b. PLAN VIEW & SECTION AIR DRILLING UNIT FOUNDATION IN NIL-2 AREA(HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-011),
PLAN VIEW & SECTION CEMENTING AREA FOUNDATION IN NIL-2 AREA(HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-012)
Please provide the load such as dead load, live load and so on and calculation result and verify whether soil
bearing capacity exceed surcharged load or not.

c. RIG PAD IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN SECTION & DETAIL(HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013)
Please make sure that diameter and spacing of rebar. This drawing mentioned D10-150, in the other
hand, HAL-HPM-SOL-14-CALC-001 of Section D.3 calculated that Bar reinforcement used is D13-100.




d. RIG PAD IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN SECTION & DETAIL (S-14.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013,
S-15.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013)
Please clarify the specification of rebar and provide the calculation report including how to decide the
diameter and spacing of rebar.
Please clarify the strength of concrete to be used and provide the calculation report and verify whether
concrete strength exceed actual stress.
Please mention the thickness of concrete in each cross section.

e. RIG PAD IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN SECTION & DETAIL (S-16.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013,
S-17.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013, S-18.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013, S-19.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013)
Please clarify the specification of rebar and provide the calculation report including how to decide the
diameter and spacing of rebar.
Please clarify the strength of concrete to be used and provide the calculation report and verify whether
concrete strength exceed actual stress.
Please clarify the meaning of 400/600,300/500 7D13, 4D13 in cross section.
Please check the number of 300/500 in cross section BEAM 1=13 (A-F) of
S-17.HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013. In the other hand, BEAM in HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-013 is
400/600 in cross section.

f. CELLAR IN WELLPAD NIL-2 PLAN VIEW, SECTION & DETAIL(HAL-HPM-SOL-14-DWG-014)
Please clarify the strength of concrete to be used such as K-300, K-250.

g. Preliminary Design for Rig Pad Foundation (HAL-HPM-SOL-14-CALC-001)
Please standardize , for thousand separator and . For decimal point. This may cause for
miscalculation/misunderstanding.
Regarding A.1, Please provide the result of soil investigation of CPT and Borehole.
Regarding A.1, Please mention the location of Boring from BH-I to BH-VI.
Regarding A.1 allowable bearing capacity, Please describe how to calculate these number based on soil
investigation result.
Regarding B. 5 Earthquake load 0.232, please make the source clear such as SNI 1726-2012.
Regarding D.1 Overturning Moment stability, please calculate/verify the Eccentricity on the foundation and
its result within 1/6 BF. It is common way of overturning moment stability.
Regarding D.1 the table of unfactored Overturning Moment Stability, please revise Load Comb. from LC
1-1/1-2/1-3 to LC2-1/2-2/2-3.
Regarding D3 Footing flexural reinforcement, please mention/calculate Reinforcement bar ratio, Min
reinforcement bar ratio, Maximum reinforcement, used correctly due to these number is 0.00.

Signature:______________________________________
Name: TETSUYA DEGUCHI
SOL Authorized Representative