J. Behav. Ther. & Exp. Psychiat. Vol. 3, pp. 97-98. Pergamon Press, 1972. Printed in Great Britain.
T R A N S C E N D E N T A L MEDI TATI ON A N D YOGA AS RECI PROCAL
I NHI BI TORS* LI~ONCE BOUDREAU Summary--In t wo cases, one of cl aust rophobi a, t he other of profuse perspi rat i on, t ranscendent al medi t at i on and yoga were t herapeut i cal l y successful aft er at t empt s wi t h syst emat i c desensi t i zat i on had yielded onl y part i al al l evi at i on. IN A RECENT article Gershman and Stedman (1971) suggested that oriental defense exercises could act as reciprocal inhibitors of anxiety. In 15 college students whose practice of trans- cendental meditation had ranged from 6 months to 3 yr, Wallace (1970) reported physiological changes during meditation indicating "a signi- ficant and reproducible decrease in oxygen consumption and metabolic rate", the latter indicated by raised skin resistance and decreased heart rate. In the two cases described here, transcendental meditation and yoga were used because the clients manifested a preference and a reported mastery of them. The transcendental meditation technique (Mahesh Yogi, 1969) is defined as "turning the attention inwards towards the subtler levels of a thought until the mind transcends the experience of the subtlest state of the thought and arrives at the source of the thought". CASE 1 Mr. T., 18, a college student, expressed fears of enlosed places, elevators, being alone and examinations. His avoidance behavior to these situations was extreme, having started when he was 13. The physiological sensations he ex- perienced gave him the additional fear of mental illness. At the beginning of treatment, systematic desensitization with relaxation as the inhibitor was tried with the use of a tape recorder to *Request s f or repri nt s shoul d be addressed t o L6once Monct on, Monct on, Nouveau- Br unswi ck, Canada. 97 suggest both relaxation and scenes. Massed desensitization was attempted again with a tape recorder, the client practicing 3 hr continuously on 3 consecutive days. No noticeable improve- ment was evidenced. At this point, the patient indicated that he was adept at transcendental meditation. He was instructed to practice meditation following imagined phobic scenes for hr every day and also at the actual appearance of fear-evoking situations. Marked improvement followed. Within 1 month, the avoidance behavior to enclosed places, being alone and elevators had all disappeared. Once his tension level had decreased, he did not experience abnormal physiological sensations and this reassured him as to his physical and mental state. CASE 2 Miss L., 40, a school teacher suffered severely from excessive perspiration. Baseline data indicated that she had mild perspiration for about 12 hr each day, all over her body, but mainly on her hands and feet, She also ex- perienced "excessive" perspiration for 3 hr daily. With mild perspiration she felt humidity in her hands and feet, so that rubbing her hands on paper would leave a wet trace. "Excessive" perspiration was described as visible drops of sweat on her hands and feet, accompanied by humidity in various other parts of her body, such as underarms and legs. This behavior Boudreau, Depar t ment of Psychol ogy, Uni ver si t e de 98 LI~ONCE BOUDREAU began when she was 5 yr old and was unal t ered in spite of numer ous medi cal interventions. Wi t h rel axat i on as an i nhi bi t or, t he dur at i on of mild perspi rat i on decreased f r om 12 hr t o 5 hr a day, and t hat of "excessi ve" perspi rat i on f r om 3 t o 1 hr daily, wi t hi n a 4 mont h peri od. Since cert ai n gr oup situations pr ovoked con- sistently mor e perspi rat i on, she was i nst ruct ed t o pract i ce daily rel axat i on pai red wi t h scenes of these gr oup situations or der ed in a hierarchical sequence. The t hemes were meet i ng people, maki ng errors, performi ng in public, and bei ng observed. Six mont hs of practice di d not bri ng t he dai l y dur at i on of mild and excessive pers- pi r at i on bel ow 5 hr and 1 hr respectively. She r epor t ed t hat al t hough rel axat i on hal t ed pers- pi rat i on i nevi t abl y whenever she resort ed t o it in stressful situations, it resumed onl y mi nut es aft er she st opped relaxing. The pat i ent t hen t ook a summer course of t rai ni ng in yoga exercises. Her practice con- sisted of a hr dai l y of yoga exercises, wi t h addi t i onal practice duri ng tense moment s. Af t er 3 mont hs of practice of this technique, her mi l d perspi rat i on decreased t o bel ow 1 hr every day while her "excessi ve" perspi rat i on dis- appeared. A 6- mont h fol l ow-up indicates t hat her perspi rat i on level is mai nt ai ned at below 1 hr daily. REFERENCES GERSHMAN L. and STEDMAN J. M. (1971) Oriental defense exercises as reciprocal inhibitors of anxiety, J. Behav. Ther. & Exp. Psychiat. 2, 117-119. MAHESH YOGi M. (1969) Maharishi Mahesh Yogi on the Bhagavad-Gita: A New Translation and Commentary, Penguin, Baltimore. WALLACE R. K. (1970) Physiological effects of trans- cendental meditation, Science 167, 1751-1754. WOLPE J. (1958) Psychotherapy by reciprocal inhibition, Stanford University Press, Stanford. (First received 13 December 1971; in revised form 23 February 1972)