Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
HIV/AIDS
CHECKLIST
FOR WATER AND SANITATION PR0JECTS
AUGUST 2006
Acknowledgements
HIV/AIDS
CHECKLIST
FOR WATER AND SANITATION PROJECTS
AUGUST 2006
Table of Contents
6 References 19
7 Annexes
DISCLAIMER
The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part
of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area, or of its authorities or concerning delimitation of
its frontiers or boundaries or regarding its economic system or degree of development. The analysis, conclusions and recommendations of the report do
not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT), the Governing Council of UN-HABITAT or its
Member States.
HS/827/06/E
ISBN: 92-1-131823-8
August 2006
3
1. Purpose of the checklist
The largest element of the UN-HABITAT Water and programme or project documents, and CAs and TORs
Sanitation Trust Fund consists of the regional capacity addressing the strategic objectives of HIV/AIDS in the
building programmes, Water for African and Asian Water and Sanitation Trust Fund.
Cities programmes, and specialised investment
initiatives, such as the Lake Victoria and Mekong Water It is a guide to users on appropriate and effective
and Sanitation initiatives. These programmes and HIV/AIDS intervention strategies, throughout the stages of
initiatives are being implemented at national levels a project/programme cycle – giving an opportunity in
through Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed determining:
with the counterpart ministry. The MOU are appended
with programme or project documents. At local level, • Which questions to ask; and
water or sanitation utilities (also independent • How to get answers
providers), local authorities, Non-Governmental
Organisations (NGOs), Community-Based It helps in identifying priorities, in accordance with
Organisations (CBOs) and communities (water user HIV/AIDS in the Water Supply and Sanitation (WSS) sector
groups) are implementation partners. Implementation and more so in designing appropriate and robust
at this level is facilitated administratively through HIV/AIDS sensitive strategies, components and indicators
Cooperation Agreements (appended by a project to respond to the AIDS pandemic.
document) and special service agreements for
individual consultants) and sub-contracts for companies While all efforts have been taken to ensure that the
(appended by a terms of reference). All projects under checklist meets the project cycle, it is emphasised that
the Water and Sanitation Trust Fund follow Project Cycle each project is unique and, therefore, care must be taken
Management (see Annex 1) and include the logical during its use to ensure that the staff and consultants
framework approach (LFA) and results based select the questions that are most relevant in the specific
management (RBM). context of time and place.
This checklist is developed with an intention to be a guide The checklist has been designed for community
and to offer an easy reference point to all programme/ (peri-urban) and urban-based WSS projects, but can also
project staff and consultants tasked with developing be applied in a rural context.
As with any major catastrophe which mitigation measures against the improves the health and status of
poses a great challenge and spread of HIV/AIDS as well as PLWHA. For example, over half of
requires an all-round onslaught, to relevant WSS-HIV/AIDS those infected by AIDS develop
HIV/AIDS calls for sectoral strategies research links. serious and chronic diarrhoea and
which focus on reducing its impact. other water-borne infections. In the
Within the WSS projects alone, there past, throughout many parts of the
In an effort to face this challenge, is an urgent need to review the world, the technologies employed to
the water and sanitation projects possibility of risk factors; for instance, improve access to safe water and
have to add not only a voice but those employed as water sector sanitation were designed for a
meaningful contributions towards professionals are often required to stay completely different environment – an
prevention and addressing the considerable time away from family, environment of the "fit" who can
impacts of HIV/AIDS. as activities like borehole drilling and operate, maintain and even walk to
latrine construction demand a high the facility when required.
Consequently, the importance of the degree of movement from village to
WSS projects can be summed up village. Such periods away from The relationships between accessible
as follows: home can serve as a temptation for safe water and adequate sanitation
some, hence providing opportunities and HIV/AIDS are enormous. In one
"The fight against HIV/AIDS calls to engage in high-risk behaviour. way, their absence or inadequacy can
for a multi-sectoral approach in Significant attention is, therefore, be a cause of infection and in the
which the water and sanitation required to furnish these workers with case where infection has happened, it
sector finds its place and plays its relevant information about the risks can lead to rapid progression of one
role effectively. The sector, and exposures to disease, and ensure phase of the HIV to AIDS as well as
therefore, responds positively to its comprehension to help prevent escalation of stigma as the care
the challenge through its projects the spread of HIV infection and providers find their roles
to utilise its knowledge and other STIs. burdensome.
expertise to face the pandemic."
Findings in the past few decades have Within the WSS, the impact of
The WSS projects, therefore, ought suggested a strong positive link HIV/AIDS epidemic is huge. Its
to provide guidelines/strategies for between the focus on HIV/AIDS and aftermath in the water sector may last
the integration of HIV/AIDS improved lives by addressing for more than a generation, as there
awareness into the water and HIV/AIDS issues in water and will be far fewer skilled people, funds
sanitation sector activities. They sanitation. It is now recognised that for running existing water supplies
have to provide approaches in better access to safe water and and sanitation programmes and
prevention, care and impact adequate/acceptable sanitation building new water supply and
sanitation systems. In turn, this will
likely jeopardise both the quality and
frequency of the supply to the users
who need the services.
Phases of HIV/AIDS (IRC 2003)
First Each WSS project needs to have a
infection Blind period First opportunistic diseases AIDS Death clear understanding of the phase of
the HIV they are dealing with, so as
to enable accurate timely planning
and implementation. For instance,
First disease the implementation of a WSS project
in a low or high prevalence area;
phase one, two, three or four will
have different approaches and
Health Period of requirements.
curve latency 7-9
years or more
5
3. Linkages between
HIV/AIDS and water supply and sanitation
At a glance, the issue of HIV/AIDS and water and Inaccurate estimates of population growth rates and
sanitation would appear to bear very little relation to each mortality rates led to incorrect estimates of water demand
other. HIV/AIDS is a global-scale pandemic that is in specific geographic areas. Consequently, inadequate or
transmitted between people primarily through sexual incorrect demographic information hinders proper
contact, while water is a renewable natural resource of planning and prevents construction schedules from
which the availability depends on a variety of geographic matching and responding to the water demand profiles.
and climatic factors. However, closer inspection of the
features that characterise the spread of HIV/AIDS and its Changes in socio-economic profiles of communities
implications for individuals, communities and societies receiving services such as water supplies and sanitation
reveals several significant linkages with water as HIV/AIDS are such that there is widespread difficulty to pay for
and water and sanitation reflect some of the often these services. New and innovative funding and
unanticipated effects of the pandemic on society. These cross-subsidisation mechanism are required to recover the
have long-term implications for effective water resource operation and maintenance costs of water supply
management and the provision of wholesome water schemes. The decline of the size of the economically active
supplies and acceptable sanitation to communities. population will decline or remain static and the surviving
children or elderly people will be required to shoulder
the burden of providing for their families. Teenage or
How do Water & Sanitation and HIV/AIDS affect child-headed households could have great difficulty in
each other? securing sufficient funds to pay for normal services such as
electricity, water supply and sanitation, while still having to
Inadequate water supply and sanitation facilities provide for food, education and housing for themselves
exacerbate the risk and vulnerability environment for and siblings.
HIV/AIDS through:
• increased risk of HIV infections; Loss of key skilled and semi-skilled staff leads to an
• faster progression from HIV infection to onset of increase in staff turnover in all sectors, with concomitant
AIDS; requirements for increased training of new staff, as well as
• difficult environments for proper treatment of HIV; increased cost implications and possible production
and delays.
• increased socio-economic impacts of AIDS.
Workers infected with HIV/AIDS cause decline in
Illness and death associated with AIDS, in turn, productivity. HIV-positive workers with impaired
undermine sustainable water and sanitation immune systems are more susceptible to common illnesses
services by: such as tuberculosis, influenza, common cold and
• weakening or destroying human capacity (skills, gastro-enteritis.
knowledge, labour);
• depleting control and access to other key assets; Staff members infected with HIV/AIDS show and
• constraining options for productive activities; experience personal dramatic decline in productivity as the
reducing participation in community activities, disease progresses. Additional productivity losses are
increasing time needed for reproductive and caring attributable to workers having to care for sick family
activities. members and relatives, as well as attending funerals.
HIV/AIDS has a great link and impact on the provision Any decline in drinking water quality caused by
and sustainability of water and sanitation services and inadequate water treatment will lead to increased public
can be viewed from two perspectives: health risks, particularly for individuals with compromised
• the consumer perspective immune systems. Health risks will be higher in areas
• the perspective of water supply and sanitation where inadequate sanitation facilities are available,
service providers (including small-scale independent leading to an increase in the incidence of water-borne
providers and community-based systems) diseases and related mortalities.
The following table provides a summary of the supply and demand model
for AIDS impact on the water supply and sanitation sector:
Supply-Side (water supply and Demand-Side (water supply and sanitation users/consumers)
sanitation service providers) Increase in Demand Changing Consumer Profiles
Water supply and Decrease in WS&S coverage due Decrease in WS&S coverage due to
sanitation coverage to increased employee increased employee absenteeism
absenteeism and lack of skilled and lack of skilled staff due to
staff due to increased morbidity increased morbidity and mortality in
and mortality in the face of the face of a changed consumer
increased demand from health profile, increasingly ill households,
stricken consumers and households headed by women,
orphans or elderly
Quality of service (water quality Decrease in quality of service Decrease in quality of service due to
and reliability of service) due to increased employee increased employee absenteeism
absenteeism and lack of skilled and lack of skilled staff due to
staff due to increased morbidity increased morbidity and mortality in
and mortality in the face of the face of a changed consumer
increased demand from health profile, increasingly ill households,
stricken consumers and households headed by women,
orphans or elderly
Performance of water supply and Decrease in performance of sector Decrease in performance of sector
sanitation sector due to reduced quality of services due to reduced quality of services
and decreasing coverage in view and decreasing coverage in view of
of increased demand. reducing ability to pay for or
contribute to services
An increase in the cost of maintaining the performance of the sector, due to an increased cost for medical health
expenditures and cost for access to ARVs, more staff will have to be trained to ensure same level of skilled staff are
available and an increased number of consumers with need for special services, health stricken households,
orphan headed households, etc.
7
4. Project cycle management
in the Water and Sanitation Trust Fund
The water and sanitation projects supported by the Water next stage of project implementation, monitoring and
and Sanitation Trust Fund generally follow the standardised review is equally important as a management tool for
format for project preparation and management. Each ensuring that the project is on track to meet the objectives
water and sanitation project, including normative, training, and to ensure success. Once the water and sanitation
research and operational project passes through six phases projects are completed, all such projects have an
of the project cycle as described in the figure below (see independent evaluation to measure the success of the
also Annex 1). These include programming, project project in terms of achieving the given objectives of the
identification and project designing; project formulation project. To this extent, HIV/AIDS checklist should help
and project appraisal; project approval including funding; define the right interventions at various stages of the project
project implementation; and project completion and cycle management of water and sanitation projects.
evaluation. A detailed scheme of UN-HABITAT's project and
programme management cycle can be found in Annex 1. The project initiatives supported by the Water and
Sanitation Trust Fund are implemented through the
Most projects are demand-led projects based on requests mechanism of Cooperation Agreements and SSAs under
from national/local governments. Generally, field Missions the Water for Asian Cities Programme and Water for
are mounted to identify issues, problems and objectives to African Cities Programme. There are also special initiatives
provide a framework for project design. It is at this stage like the Lake Victoria Water and Sanitation Initiative in
that the HIV/AIDS Water and Sanitation checklist can help Africa and MEK-WATSAN Initiative in Asia. Besides these,
in identifying the issues and problems to be addressed there are normative activities both at the global and
while designing the project. The modalities of intervention, regional levels for knowledge, dissemination, public
institutional arrangements and the legal framework are awareness and advocacy. HIV/AIDS checklist can be
generally explored at the project design phase. For project effectively used as a guideline at the time of preparing
formulation, a logical framework approach is followed terms of reference for various co-operation agreements.
which elaborates on the goal, purpose, outputs, activities, Each co-operation agreement has a project document
indicators and means of verification involving all the which details out the project objectives, the scope and
stakeholders. Project approval stage provides a unique coverage of the project as well as activities and outputs
opportunity of testing new concepts and operationalising besides giving the budget and implementation schedule. In
the normative work of UN-HABITAT. An understanding of preparation of these project documents for every
the various interventions for addressing the HIV/AIDS issues co-operation agreement, an assessment of HIV/AIDS and
in water and sanitation projects at this stage of project its impact on the project implementation at different stages
approval is quite crucial considering the fact that the can be of great help so that the project can work out
project budget is approved by all parties at this stage. The special institutional arrangements in a manner aimed at
minimising the adverse impact of HIV/AIDS.
Project Completion Project Identification To sum up, the project cycle management for various
and Evaluation and Project Designing
initiatives supported by Water and Sanitation Trust Fund
would substantially benefit from these HIV/AIDS guidelines
if these are elaborated in a manner that while preparing
co-operation agreements for various projects, these are
Project Project Formulation
and Project Appraisal kept in view for assessing the impact of HIV/AIDS. Several
Implementation types of questions need to be framed as part of this
Monitoring and Review
checklist so that these questions are asked, understood and
Project Approval the information relating to HIV/AIDS in connection with the
including Funding particular project location, the cost and resource
implications are well understood.
HIV/AIDS continue to pose a great ensure an all-inclusive of the main Questions have to be asked
challenge to the water and steps of the UN-HABITAT Project and appropriate mitigation
sanitation sector. For effective Cycle during inception, deployed within the project
response within the sector, there implementation, end of project and cycle process.
is a need to incorporate and during monitoring and evaluation.
This checklist can be used alongside the UN-HABITAT's Manual for Project and Programme Cycle
Management, and ensuring the adoption of the concept of the Project Cycle as shown in Annex 1, which
would consider HIV/AIDS being addressed at:
9
The emphasis of all water and indisputably relevant. This is
sanitation projects is to ensure that an
5.1 Programming and Project aimed at ensuring the continuous
HIV/AIDS-sensitive institutional Planning relevance of the Fund and its
framework is given the highest focus on the urban poor.
priority. In particular, attention needs Programming and project planning • Review the ongoing operations
to be paid to ensure that poorer for water and sanitation projects is and their conformity with the
communities, who experience being conducted within the overall mandate of the Fund; this gives a
difficulty in paying for service delivery, framework of the Governing Council particular attention to all the
receive assured water supplies. Other and UN-HABITAT policy and projects or programmes approved
arising issues and questions will bi-annual Work Programme. since the previous meeting. The
include the need to test and UN-HABITAT's activities on water and objective is to make sure that the
implement robust and reliable water sanitation are conducted through the Fund remains focussed on
treatment processes that do not activities corresponding to the
Water and Sanitation Trust Fund,
require supervision or management Organisation's core competencies
which was established in 2002.
interventions. These would help to and avoids dispersion in too high
reduce the potential health risk a number of less significant
The goal of the UN-HABITAT Water
associated with ineffective water activities.
and Sanitation Trust Fund is to
treatment that can be expected as a • Take stock of the overall financial
contribute to the achievement of the
result of increased mortality of situation of the Fund and the
internationally agreed goals related
operators of water treatment works. projections for the middle (2-4
to water and sanitation in human
The project must also answer the years) and long (5+ years) terms.
settlements with particular focus on
question of how the WSS is helping If appropriate, the Board will
the national efforts to expand public the urban poor in order to facilitate formulate suggestion on how to
awareness of the dangers associated an equitable social, economic and increase its capitalisation.
with untreated water and inadequate environmental development. • Take stock of all evaluations,
personal hygiene practices. monitoring and audit reports
The Development objective is to produced since the previous
support developing countries to meeting.
achieve sustainable access to safe • Draw lessons learned as
drinking water and basic sanitation appropriate and recommend
for the poor, particularly in actions to disseminate them as
urban areas. extensively as practicable.
• Discuss means of enhancing
A Programme document for the synergy with other organisations/
Water Supply and Sanitation Trust facilities involved in the sector,
Fund provides overall strategic and in other related sectors such
direction. The Programme document as health and environment.
contains a Results-Based • Take stock of progress made
Management (RBM) framework, towards achieving the
which was updated in consultation MDG target.
with the Evaluation Unit in 2005. The
Trust Fund develops an Annual Based on the request of members of
Workplan and, at the end of every the Advisory Board, UN-HABITAT has
year, prepares an Annual Report. been requested to develop a Strategy
on How to Address HIV/AIDS Issues
The Advisory Board of the Trust Fund in Water and Sanitation Projects. The
meets once a year and consists of the Strategy outlines five strategic entry
donors contributing to the Trust Fund, points on how to address HIV/AIDS
selected recipient countries and the (see Annex 2 for strategic direction
secretariat. The main responsibilities diagram):
of the Advisory Board can be
summarised as follows: • To raise awareness and advocate
on how to address HIV/AIDS
• Review the eligibility of new through water and sanitation
proposals for funding to ensure initiatives amongst WSIB staff,
that they continue to be national policy makers, board
HIV/AIDS Vulnerability and Mitigation Matrix for Countries Participating in Water for African and Asian
Cities Programmes (WfC)
LOW Phase 1: Low adult prevalence, Phase 2: High adult prevalence, low impact
low impact
Indicators: low HIV prevalence, Indicators: high HIV prevalence, slightly increasing
low number of orphans, low number of number of orphans, slightly increasing
affected households, low employee number of affected households, slightly increasing
absenteeism employee absenteeism
Focus on: Awareness raising, Focus on: Preparedness, Impact mitigation
advocacy and human values preparation, workplace policies
education
Example WfC Countries: Example WfC Countries: Cambodia, West Africa,
India, PR of China, Nepal Ethiopia
HIGH Phase 4: Levelling or even reducing Phase 3: High adult prevalence, high impact
adult prevalence, high impact
Indicators: stable or even decreasing Indicators: increasing high HIV prevalence, high
HIV prevalence, high number of orphans, number of orphans, high number of affected households,
high number of affected households, high high increasing employee absenteeism and
increasing employee absenteeism and increasing mortality
increased mortality
Focus on: Impact alleviation and Focus on: Impact alleviation
rehabilitation
Example WfC Countries: Example WfC Countries:
Uganda, Tanzania Mozambique, Zambia
11
5.2 Project Identification and capacity-building institutions,
local authorities, banks and
Participatory methodologies (e.g.,
participatory rapid appraisal,
Project Design other financial institutions, etc) focus group discussions,
• How does HIV/AIDS contribute to meetings, walking tours)
The project identification and design poverty and insecure water supply
phase establishes focus and and sanitation conditions? • Collect qualitative information,
conditionalities for the intervention • How does inadequate water which cannot be collected through
and results in the preparation of a supply and sanitation increase surveys.
draft proposal. vulnerability to HIV/AIDS? • Define ways in which people
(Increase in rapes, etc) living with HIV/AIDS, caregivers,
The following key questions could • How does inadequate water beneficiaries and other
be considered: supply and sanitation affect the stakeholders, especially the poor
progression of HIV? (Number of women-and child-headed
• What is the water supply and opportunistic diseases due to lack households can participate in the
sanitation coverage and how of safe water and adequate project.
does that affect vulnerability for sanitation, etc) • Map out the target areas which
HIV/AIDS? (Consider water supply • Has a similar proposed project are the most disadvantaged areas
and sanitation coverage data) been implemented in the area in in terms of access to services and
• Is HIV/AIDS an issue in the area? the recent past? If so, what was its poverty level?
(Consider data on HIV prevalence outcome and impact? • Identify major stakeholder group
and its impact, e.g., number of • What are the current HIV/AIDS and their stake.
orphans and vulnerable children strategies going on in the area
(OVCs), number of households and by whom? Can these
Data to be collected
affected by HIV/AIDS, etc) activities be integrated in the
• What local knowledge of current project?
Macro-institutional framework
HIV/AIDS exists and who transmits • Executing agency's capacity and
this knowledge? The following methodology could be
commitment to mainstreaming
• Who are the important applied for collecting data and
HIV/AIDS into its operations and
institutional stakeholders dealing getting answers:
focus.
with HIV/AIDS? (Consider
Desk review • HIV/AIDS impact of sector policy:
mapping institutions dealing with
prevention, treatment, care and legal and institutional framework
mitigation) Review available information (e.g.,
• Who are the important statistics, HIV/AIDS analysis, and Socio-economic profile
consumer-side (community) documents of previous implemented Economic
stakeholders in relation to WSS projects) on the WSS services • Income level and sources,
HIV/AIDS? (Consider mapping in the project area and the between people living with
those dealing with prevention, socio-economic profile of the target HIV/AIDS and those that are not.
treatment, care and mitigation) population, in addition to the overall • Expenditure patterns and
• Who is affected by HIV/AIDS, in prevalence of HIV/AIDS in the project decision-making, between those
what ways and why? (use the area. homes with people living with
demographic profiles i.e., HIV/AIDS and those that are not.
– People (orphans, elderly, Review the relevant legal, policy (e.g.,
women, chronically ill, etc) water fee subsidy policy), and Health
– Households (orphan-headed institutional framework (e.g., current • HIV risk factors
households, socio-economic administrative system for water supply • Percentage of home-based care
status, access to land and services) and their implications on • Population growth rate
finance, demography and age HIV/AIDS affected persons and • Infant and maternal mortality
of households) families. rates
– Communities (urban slums, • Service availability
squatters), peri-urban, access Household surveys • Fertility level and decision-making
to security of tenure and • Food allocation and nutrition level
finance, access to jobs, • Draw up comparative within households.
livelihoods) socio-economic profiles of people
– Institutions (water supply and living with HIV/AIDS and those Status of PLWHA and Caretakers
sanitation service providers that are not and identify the WSS Political representation and
– small-scale independent practices, constraints, and needs awareness
service providers – of the target population. • Socio-cultural perceptions and
community-based institutions, • Collect quantitative information. practices of the community.
13
• Have activities been proposed by • Review community/user
5.3 Project Formulation and the project or other strategic preferences for; location of the
Project Appraisal partners which could counter the project, types such as for well,
potential negative effects? pumps, latrines, for sharing or
The draft proposal is then appraised • How does the institutional individual use that are culturally
using the LFA process including framework for project sensitise
stakeholder and problem analysis, implementation account for the • Review the people affected by
objectives and output analysis, risk potential impact of HIV/AIDS on HIV/AIDS strengths in determining
analysis, implementation and institutions? (Consider absence the services and preference
sustainability analysis. The end due to increased illness or need to vis-a-vis the financial implication
product of this phase is the attend funerals, loss of staff due on initiation and sustainability.
completed project document. to death, there is also the issue of Consider possible preferential
loss of institutional memory, e.g. treatment for very poor families
The following key questions could be the water engineer with affected by HIV/AIDS, females
considered: knowledge of all the distribution and other disadvantaged families
lines passes away and there are such as OVCs.
• How do intervention strategies no detailed grid maps. If a CBO • Consider whether the project
address the specific problems with a small human resource and includes HIV/AIDS training
faced by HIV/AIDS-affected skills base is the implementing options on awareness for all
groups? Do they build on existing agency, how to safeguard against project staff and, in particular,
opportunities? If so, how? potential collapse due to ill health those that may have to be
• What strategic partnerships are or death?) separated from family members
envisaged with stakeholders • What will be the impact of HIV/ for a considerable time; and
working on HIV/AIDS from other AIDS on the sustainability of the hygiene education; on carers and
sectors (agriculture, health, project? (Impact on vulnerability PLWHAs, etc.
education, etc)? and resources, will people still be • Look for community participation
• How can the impact of the able to pay for services or mechanism strategy in the project
epidemic undermine the contribute to savings schemes that is practical and consultative
assumptions of the proposed (e.g., revolving funds)? Will with set schedules and
intervention? (For example, in an people still be able to attend incorporates all stakeholders.
area of high prevalence and high community meetings or contribute Cross-check for the feedback
impact how will this affect labour to community-based mechanism in the project,
capacity-building efforts for a initiatives?) including those from other
water utility. Here HIV/AIDS might • Have the PLWHAs and others organisations – NGOs/CBOs that
have to be considered a risk been consulted about the project? could facilitate HIV prevention,
factor that could jeopardise the -does it address the local need? response to and mitigation during
success of a project) • Does the project identify key implementation and M&E.
• What is the likelihood that project actors and its targeted
interventions could directly or beneficiaries? (Consider the extent
indirectly aggravate the HIV/AIDS to which their partcipation is).
situation? (For instance, will • Is there an HIV/AIDS task group
interventions contribute to the in place or has it been planned
spread of HIV/AIDS or stigmatise for? Who are the members of this
people living with HIV/AIDS (For task group?
instance, where community
members are requested to How to get answers
provide "sweat equity" and HIV/
AIDS-affected households cannot • When formulating and appraising
provide this counterpart a project, this should include
contribution? Will utility staff or reviewing possibilities of different
public works construction staff scenarios and options such as:
have to be posted for longer
periods away from their families?
15
The PRC should use a checklist on
5.4 Project Approval including All projects of more then
US $ 100.000 are approved by the HIV/AIDS-related issues which
Funding Project Review Committee (PRC). should be considered in the
The PRC should check the projects proposal.
During this phase, the Project relevance and responsiveness to
Document is approved by the the HIV/AIDS context of the
Project Review Committee (PRC) country or local authority.
The following table could be used as a checklist of key questions to be considered by the PRC:
Are PRC members aware of the importance Assess PRC member awareness during opening of meeting
of HIV/AIDS, why it should be considered in planning?
Are PRC members aware of the linkages Assess if PRC members have read the UN-HABITAT Strategy for
between HIV/AIDS and water supply and addressing HIV/AIDS in water supply and sanitation projects
sanitation projects?
Is HIV/AIDS a national or regional issue? Review the table of HIV prevalence for countries covered by
Water for African and Asian Cities Programme and place
country in HIV/AIDS vulnerability matrix
Is HIV/AIDS an issue for the sub-sector? Review the sub-sectoral assessment table
Does the project address any of the strategic Review HIV/AIDS strategy and submitted project document
options for addressing HIV/AIDS in
water and sanitation projects?
Does the project address the needs of
vulnerable groups, such as orphans (OVCs),
widows, women, elderly, etc.?
Does HIV/AIDS have an effect on the project? Review supply and demand model for AIDS impact on the water
and sanitation sector and submitted project document
Does the project have an effect on vulnerability Review supply and demand model for AIDS impact on the water
and the progression of HIV/AIDS? and sanitation sector and submitted project document
17
• How has the HIV/AIDS epidemic How to get the answers
5.6 Project Completion and affected the projects ability to
Evaluation achieve its objectives and outputs, • A clear understanding of the
and how has the project project including its aims,
This phase is of great importance, as addressed such issues? objectives, budget, time frame not
it assesses the relevance, efficacy, • How has the project contributed forgetting its relationship and
effectiveness, impact and to mitigating the impact of HIV/ linkage with HIV/AIDS prevention,
sustainability of the project and AIDS on the Water and Sanitation care and support as well as
allows for drawing lessons. sector and to the prevention impact mitigation.
including opportunistic infections? • Review the project proposal, its
The following key questions could be • How may the project have design, activities, assumptions,
considered: encouraged the spread of the risk factors and methodology to
epidemic, increased the stigma of check if HIV/AIDS was considered
• To what extent was the project people living with HIV/AIDS or at every aspect of the project
able to achieve its goal? (consider aggravated the impact of HIV/AIDS? • Evaluate the TOR for the
HIV/AIDS as a major indicator) • Are the outcomes of the project evaluation team (Consultants) to
• What is the overall opinion of the sustainable in view of the current ensure that it explicitly assess
people infected and affected by and anticipated HIV prevalence? HIV/AIDS concerns
HIV/AIDS on the projects impact (consider outcomes at all levels – • Discuss in detail with the project
on their life? (consider the ways people, households, communities, managers, what worked well;
the project was able to target the local and national institutions) what did not; and get a clear
affected households and • Are the interventions of this understanding of what was a
individuals) project replicable or can they be significant contributing factor.
• Was the methodology deployed scaled up? Would modifications Understand whether the success
for the project the most be required? (for the case of achievement), was
appropriate on preventing, • Did the other stakeholders and realised within the proposed time
supporting and or mitigating HIV/ collaborators participate as frame, if not were there any major
AIDS in the project area? anticipated in this project? reviews undertaken to achieve
(Consider probable and any other • How effective was the HIV/AIDS that.
most effective and could have task group of the project? • Based on the completion of the
been deployed for better • Are the HIV/AIDS intervention project and building on the
affectivity and efficiency for plans reflected in the actual findings of the evaluation,
lessons learnt). expenditure? Was adequate indicate the lessons learnt and
• What type of effect has the project resources allocated (in how they can be used for future
had on people, households and accordance) to the various programming.
institutions, especially those living strategies or was it sidelined?
with HIV/AIDS? • What are the key lessons learnt
about preventing, supporting and
impact mitigation of HIV/AIDS on
water and sanitation supply?
Asian Development Bank, (undated); Gender Checklist, Water Supply and Sanitation
http://www.adb.org/Documents/Manuals/Gender_Checklists/Water/#contents
Asian Development Bank and UNDP, (undated); Toolkit for HIV prevention among mobile Populations in the
greater Mekong Sub-regions.
http://siteresorces.worldbank.org/INTTSR/Resources/462613-1135099994537/toolkit_hiv.pdf
Ashton, P and Ramasar, V, (undated); Water and HIV/AIDS: Some strategic considerations in
Southern Africa;
http://www.irc.nl/page/3520
FAO, (undated); Incorporating HIV/AIDS considerations into food security and livelihood projects;
http://www.fao.org/documents/show_cdr.asp?url_file=/docrep/004/y5128e/y5128e00.htm
Fransen, L and Whiteside, A (undated); Considering HIV/AIDS in development assistance: A toolkit. World
Bank AIDS Economics;
http://www.worldbank.org/aids-econ/toolkit/index.htm
IFAD; (2001); Strategy paper on HIV/AIDS for East and Southern Africa;
http://www.ifad.org/operations/regional/pf/aids_3.htm
IRWSSP, (2003); Zimbabwe Water and Sanitation Sector HIV/AIDS Response. Programme, Strategies and
Guidelines
Kaminga, E and Wengelin-Schuringa, M, (2003); HIV/AIDS and water, sanitation and hygiene. Thematic
Overview Paper - IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre
http://www.irc.nl/page/3272
UN-HABITAT, (2002); Programme Document for the Water and Sanitation Trust Fund
World Bank, (2002); The integration of HIV/AIDS issues into the environmental assessment process for
World Bank-funded development projects
http://www.cadre.org.za/pdf/World-Bank-Report-3.pdf
19
20
Policy & Project
Identification
Evaluation Upscaling Request
Exploration of Policy-led
Annexes
Formulation
Implementation
Goal: The goal of UN-HABITAT Water and Sanitation Programme, supported by the Trust Fund, is to
contribute to the achievement of the internationally agreed goals related to water and sanitation in
human settlements with particular focus on the urban poor in order to facilitate equitable social,
economic and environmental development.
21
Annex 3: HIV/AIDS Data for Asian and African Countries
(UNAIDS, 2006 Report on the Global AIDS Epidemic)
Country Estimated Number of People living with HIV/AIDS, end 2005 AIDS Deaths
Adults Adults Women Infected in
(15-49) (15-49) (15+) Women Adults and
Rate (%) to Infected Children
Adults 2005
(15+)
Rate (%)
Water for Asian Cities Programme and Mekong Water and Sanitation Initiative
Water for African Cities Programme Phase II and Lake Victoria Water and Sanitation Initiative
Notes:
1.
India: Work is ongoing to produce a more precise estimate of AIDS mortality in India. An analysis using adult prevalence in past years and
parameter estimates based on the international literature suggests that AIDS mortality lies within these ranges.
2.
Ethiopia: Figures for Ethiopia are for end 2003. In early 2006, important new data from a national community-based survey and from
rural surveillance sites had become available in Ethiopia. At the time when the UNAIDS report went to Press, those new data had only
partially been analysed. UNAIDS and WHO will make new estimates for end 2005, based on a comprehensive analysis of all data,
available on their websites as soon as possible.
A. Labour Type
C. Sector-specific Questions
23
24 HIV/AIDS CHECKLIST FOR WATER AND SANITATION PROJECTS
Programme Contact Persons: