Cultural Immersion and Agency Assessment Report: Hispanic Culture
Donna Tuohey Wilmington University
2
Populations History and Major Milestones The term culture has different meanings but it is generally used to refer to the set of values, standards, beliefs, art, music, and practices shared by a particular group. Hispanic or Latino culture encompasses the traditions, language, idioms, religious beliefs and practices, legends, arts, music, literature, cuisine, history, social and family values of the Hispanic people. Hispanic culture consists of the traditions and customs of people with Latin American roots and whose primary language is Spanish (Explore Hispanic Culture, 2012). American history emphasizes the founding and growth of the British colonies in North America, their emergence as an independent nation in 1776, and the development of the United States from east to west. History sometimes omits the fact that there was significant colonization by Spain of what is now the American Southwest from the 16th century onward. The whole Southwest, from Texas westward to California, was a Spanish-speaking territory with its own distinctive heritage, culture, and customs for many decades (R. A. Guisepi, 2014). The Spanish-speaking citizens of the United States who were incorporated into the country as a result of the Mexican War are called Mexican Americans. Their numbers have since increased as a result of immigration. Other Spanish-speaking citizens came from Cuba and Puerto Rico, and smaller numbers are immigrants from Central and South America and from the Dominican Republic. Taken together, these people are called Hispanics, or Latinos. Hispanics today form the fastest-growing ethnic minority in the United States. About 60 percent of Hispanics trace their origin to Mexico. 3
The term Hispanic is not an ethnic description. It refers to native language and to cultural background. Within the group called Hispanics are peoples of diverse ethnic origins. There are African Americans and American Indians as well as individuals of purely European background whose families have lived in the Americas for generations. Due to intermarriage, there are descendants who represent a combination of several origins. Hispanics do not necessarily regard themselves as a single group because their attachments are to their specific national origin. In the case of many Mexican Americans, the national origin is within the United States if their ancestors lived in the Southwest before the Mexican War. Puerto Ricans enjoy a different status from other Hispanics in that they are citizens of the United States by birth, whether they were born in their homeland or in the United States. They were granted citizenship in 1917. Citizens from Puerto Rico may go back and forth between the island and the mainland without visas or passports. Mexicans, Cubans, and others must enter the country as immigrants with alien status and must apply for citizenship in the same way as do other immigrants (Mathewson, J. 2008). 33.7 million Hispanics of Mexican origin resided in the United States in 2012, according to an analysis of Census Bureau data by Pew Research Center. This estimate includes 11.4 million immigrants born in Mexico and 22.3 million born in the U.S. who self-identified as Hispanics of Mexican origin. Mexicans are by far the largest Hispanic-origin population in the U.S., accounting for nearly two-thirds (64%) of the U.S. Hispanic population in 2012. Hispanics of Mexican origin are also a significant portion of the U.S. population, accounting for 11% overall. The size of the Mexican-origin population in the U.S. has risen dramatically over the 4
past four decades as a result of one of the largest mass migrations in modern history (US Census Bureau, 2014). In 1970, fewer than 1 million Mexican immigrants lived in the U.S. By 2000, that number had grown to 9.8 million, and by 2007 it reached a peak of 12.5 million. Since then, the Mexican-born population has declined as the arrival of new Mexican immigrants has slowed significantly. Today, 35% of Hispanics of Mexican origin were born in Mexico. And while the remaining two-thirds (65%) were born in the U.S., half (52%) of them have at least one immigrant parent. Although there are Hispanics in most parts of the United States, some areas have especially large concentrations. Eighty-six percent of Mexican Americans make their homes in five Southwestern states: Texas, California, New Mexico, Arizona, and Colorado. Texas and California account for more than 50 percent of the total Hispanic population in the United States. About two thirds of Puerto Ricans residing in the United States are in the New York City area, including nearby New Jersey. About 60 percent of Cuban Hispanics reside in Florida. Another 20 percent are in the New York-New Jersey are. Illinois also has large numbers of Mexican, Puerto Rican, and Cuban Hispanics--mostly in Chicago (Barrerra, A. & Lopez, M., 2013). There are two basic reasons for Hispanic immigration to the United States: economic opportunity and escape from political persecution. Very large numbers of Mexicans and Puerto Ricans entered the country to escape poverty and to find a way to make a living. The 20th- century Cuban migration, which began in 1959 when Fidel Castro took over the government of Cuba, was mainly for political reasons. 5
Major Milestones With more than 37 million speakers, Spanish is by far the most spoken non-English language in the U.S. today among people ages 5 and older. It is also one of the fastest-growing, with the number of speakers up 233% since 1980, when there were 11 million Spanish speakers. As Spanish use has grown, driven primarily by Hispanic immigration and population growth, it has become a part of many aspects of life in the U.S. Spanish is spoken by more non-Hispanics in U.S. homes than any other non-English language (Barrerra, A. & Lopez, M., 2013). In September 1968, Congress authorized President Lyndon B. Johnson to proclaim National Hispanic Heritage Week, observed during the week that included Sept. 15 and Sept. 16. The observance was expanded in 1989 by Congress to a month long celebration (Sept. 15 - Oct. 15), America celebrates the culture and traditions of those who trace their roots to Spain, Mexico and the Spanish-speaking nations of Central America, South America and the Caribbean. Sept. 15 was chosen as the starting point for the celebration because it is the anniversary of independence of five Latin American countries: Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua. In addition, Mexico and Chile celebrate their independence days on Sept. 16 and Sept. 18 (US Census Bureau, 2014). Hispanics have had a significant impact on politics. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen became the first Cuban American elected to the United States Congress in 1989. Henry Cisneros was the first Mexican American to become the mayor of a major city (San Antonio, Tex.). In 1981 he was named secretary of housing and urban development by President Clinton in 1992. Bob Martinez, the first Hispanic governor of Florida, became the Bush Administration's antidrug leader in March 1991. A Mexican American, Lauro Cavazos, became the first Hispanic named to a 6
Cabinet post when President Reagan appointed him secretary of education in 1988. President Bush appointed Antonia Novello, a native of Puerto Rico, to be the first female Surgeon General of the United States in 1989. In science in 1968, Luis Alvarez won the Nobel Prize for his work with subatomic particles. As a teacher and researcher at the University of California at Berkeley, he helped develop microwave beacons, a ground-controlled landing approach for aircraft, and a new theory for why the dinosaurs became extinct. Also, in 1995, Mario Molina, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, along with two other scientists, won the Nobel Prize in chemistry for research that helped the world confront the threat that chlorofluorocarbons pose to the earth's protective ozone layer. As well as having significant influence in literature, the arts and music, the Hispanic culture has had an impact on education. Jaime Escalante, born in Bolivia, may be the nation's most notable math teacher, who transformed Garfield High School in East Los Angeles, California, from a school whose students' math test scores were always in the lowest percentile in the country into a national symbol of academic achievement. His dedication and classroom triumphs, which continue to inspire students and teachers nationwide, were portrayed in the 1988 movie "Stand and Deliver (de Varona, F. 1996). Movie Review: Stand and Deliver The movie Stand and Deliver is based on a true story that takes place in Eastern LA during the early 1980s. The main character, Jaime A. Escalante, is a new teacher at James A. Garfield High School determined to change the system and challenge the students to a higher 7
level of excellence. Escalante leaves a steady job for a position as a math teacher in a school where teachers are more focused on discipline than academics. Escalante initially is not well liked by the students. As the year progresses, he is able to win over the attention of the students by implementing innovative teaching techniques, using humor to illustrate concepts of math and showing the students the necessity of math in everyday life. With persistence, Escalante, is able to transform troublesome teens into dedicated students, ready to learn. Escalante begins teaching basic math, he soon realizes that his students are capable of more than the expectations set forth by the school board. Escalante develops a program in which his students can prepare to take AP Calculus by their senior year. Escalantes intense math program requires that students take summer classes, including Saturdays, from 7 to 12. The contrast between home life and school life is apparent as the teens struggle to find the balance between what other adults expect of them and the goals and ambitions they hold for themselves. The class had a large Hispanic student body and drawing from his own cultural heritage, Escalante forms a bond with the students. He teaches his students previous knowledge of famous Latinos and their great accomplishments, showing them that Latinos have the ability to learn and are able to prove themselves as intellectuals. The students come to realize that the only way they will escape the "barrio" is to improve themselves intellectually. After completing the difficult test and receiving their scores, they are overwhelmed with emotion to find that they have all passed the test. The Educational Testing Service calls into question the validity of their scores when it is discovered that similarities between errors is too high due to all 18 students who took the test answered the same four questions wrong. Angered by implications of cheating, Escalante 8
feels that the racial and economic status of the students has caused the ETS to doubt their intelligence. In order to prove their mathematical abilities and worth to the school, to the ETS, and to the nation, the students agree to retake the test at the end of the summer, months after their last class. With only a day to prepare. After the retake, these students truly stand and deliver when they all pass the exam again, showing they deserve all they have achieved. With each passing year after the first group of 18 students passed the AP Calculus test, the number of students from Garfield High School passing the test increases from 18 to 87 by 1987 (Menendez, R. 1988). Direct Immersion Experience- Comparison of the Hispanic Culture of South America and the United States In 1997 at the age of 22 full of curiosity, a love of traveling and a sincere desire to help others, I traveled to Valencia, Venezuela as a missionary for my church. I completed a two month crash course in Spanish before leaving for South America. I stayed in a small town over an hour away from the city of Valencia and was partnered with a native Venezuelan who did not speak English. I did not know anyone else in the small town other than my missionary companion who only spoke Spanish. Even though my Spanish was very limited and communication was extremely challenging I found the people to be open and appreciative of my efforts to learn their language. I lived in Venezuela for almost three months before being transferred to Los Fresnos, Texas along the southern most boarder of Texas where I lived for eight months. I found a lot of similarities and differences among the Hispanic culture of Venezuela and Texas. The following will be a comparison of my experience living among members of the Hispanic culture. 9
My experience living in Venezuela had a deep impact on my ability to appreciate cultural differences and how much people can take for granted. I struggled every day to communicate basic ideas and words because of my limited knowledge of Spanish. My Venezuelan companion did not speak any English but somehow we were able to communicate enough to get by every day. The people we encountered on a daily basis in the town we lived in were open and giving. Some of the residents had homes with basic electricity, running water and if they were fortunate had a working TV with limited reception and channels. A TV was a big deal and something to be proud of and shared with friends and neighbors. Most of the homes were humble and a source of pride for the owners. In the same town extreme poverty and homeless families were common. Entire families with several generations would make a home out of an abandoned building, cement or mud shacks with thatched roofs and no electricity or running water. Regardless of their means I found Venezuelans to be very giving, affectionate and humble and always offering food or a drink and place to rest out of the hot sun. Some of the best meals I have ever had were prepared and offered by families with nothing else but a few chickens, black beans and cornmeal for arepas while sitting on crates, mats on the floor or outside on makeshift chairs. We carried our own water everywhere because the local water was often not filtered and a source of potential sickness. Time was not a concern when visiting and was never more important than a conversation. I observed the same to be true of the Hispanic families I encountered in South Texas who lived in either extreme poverty, humble and modest to upper class homes. Food was always offered and to say no was an insult, visits and conversations would last for hours and tortillas were homemade and abundant. 10
When greeting a stranger, family member or friend Venezuelans greet with a hug and a kiss on the cheek and show sincere delight and appreciation in their interactions with each other. I found while in Texas most Hispanic individuals would great people in the same manner with some preferring a reserved handshake or a hello without an embrace similar to most Americans. Conversations with Venezuelans were typically polite and casual with the focus being on the person and their families. Even though I spoke very broken Spanish, people in Venezuela seemed genuinely appreciative of my effort and were often willing to teach me the correct pronunciation of words. Venezuelans were fascinated with anything American and would often play American music, wear American clothes with names of famous brands or sports teams. Venezuelans were also quick to criticize American politics and government and believed everyone who lived in America was rich and arrogant. I found language more of a barrier in South Texas with the majority of individuals speaking a combination of both Spanish and English. The area I was living in was predominately Hispanic and Spanish speaking. I always did my best to speak Spanish in front of Spanish speaking individuals. While in South Texas I was partnered with a girl from Utah who spoke English like myself. At times we would speak English while in the company of individuals who spoke Spanish and English and were told that we were rude for doing so. The common interchanging of Spanish and English words during a conversation made communication difficult at times in Texas. There was also a high expectation to speak Spanish well while in South Texas by Hispanic people. I often experienced criticism for my basic Spanish speaking abilities. Families were viewed as the focus and center for people in both Venezuela and South Texas. Hispanic families typically include extended members, multi-generational, neighbors and 11
friends and independence can be viewed as disloyal. Non-Hispanics place an importance on being independent and encouraged to not be reliant on family. The people I encountered in Venezuela were very self-sufficient. They grew most of their own food, what they did not grow they cooked themselves and did not let anything go to waste. Corner stores were very limited and carried items such as flour, rice, cereal and essentials for cooking. A pot was used for cooking, eating, storage and sometimes furniture for sitting. Transportation was either walking or riding an overcrowded bus to the nearest town. In conclusion some of the most striking resemblances between Hispanic Americans and South Americans are their strong familial ties and insistence on that as a normal way of thinking. It seems no matter what religious, or economic differences there maybe this remains the same, as a culture family is a strong and irreplaceable tie for Hispanic Americans. Assessing the Field Agency- Innovative Schools Agencys Community: Innovative Schools provides education related services to schools serving students in grades K-12 in both public and charter schools in all three Delaware counties. IS does not serve a specific demographic or population. Each of Innovative Schools three divisions target specific areas of education and seek to provide services in school leadership, administrative support and as a charter management organization. Innovative Schools is located in the city of Wilmington in the Community Building. Innovative Schools acts as a Charter Management Organization for Founding Boards striving to develop a charter school in their community. Founding Boards can contract with Innovative Schools to complete the charter application process, obtain funding, staffing and adaption of a deeper learning model. IS determines the recipients of their services by vetting applications from Founding Boards based 12
on the strength of the Founding Board, the need of the community in which the proposed school would be placed, and the strength of the school concept (Innovative Schools, 2014). Innovative Schools is currently the CMO for Delawares first bilingual elementary school, La Academia. La Academia will be the first dual language Expeditionary Learning elementary school in Delaware with a focus on nurturing bilingual, biliterate and multicultural children (La Academia, 2014). Administration and Staff Training: Innovative Schools provides charter management organization, school staffing services and leadership training to board members, all public and charter schools, teachers and administrators in the state of Delaware. The agency does not work with a specific population or demographic and does not offer diversity training to its staff. Innovative Schools works with the education community and employs members of different races and cultural backgrounds including the Hispanic population. Funding: Innovative Schools relies on grants from several sources to maintain operations and programs. IS receives a yearly grant and has a sponsorship from the Rodel Foundation of Delaware. Rodel provides the majority of ISs operational funding. IS receives grants from nonprofit organizations and for profit companies such as JP Morgan, Capitol One, The Longwood Foundation, The Welfare Foundation , United Way and several various funders. IS also receives funding as a charter management organization (CMO). Founding Boards engaged in starting a new charter school contract with IS to complete the charter application, adapt a deeper learning model, and acquire facilities and staffing of the new charter school. Innovative Schools will assist Charter Boards in applying for grants to pay for CMO services. 13
IS provides contracted services such as school administration recruitment and staffing services for both public and charter schools. Additional funding is obtained through the Project Based Learning workshops given by IS staff to public and charter school staff and paid for by the schools. Innovative Schools is actively researching and applying for over 30 grants at any given time throughout the year to support agency operations, staffing and programs. Staff Sensitivity: Agency staff has been observed to be a resource for members of the community engaged in improving education and developing successful learning models for all children in grades K-12. Services provided by the agency and staff are directed at meeting an educational need within the community and working with local members who are interested in improving education in their community. Agency Programs and Services: Innovative Schools partners with Founding Boards to navigate charter authorization and launch a high quality, deeper learning charter schools. Innovative Schools provides direct technical assistance through the charter application process, and for those charter applications that are approved by the authorizer - Innovative Schools serve as the Charter Management Organization until the schools first charter renewal. This arrangement extends the Founding Boards capacity to prepare a charter application and obtain charter approval, implement the academic and administrative components of the school successfully during the first year of operation and beyond, and ensure appropriate oversight. Currently Innovative Schools is acting as the CMO for La Academia- bilingual elementary school. Quality: Innovative Schools accepts applications from Founding Boards each year. Applications are vetted based on the strength of the Founding Board, the need of the 14
community in which the proposed school would be placed, and the strength of the school concept. The agency requires board members to be members of the community the charter schools will serve and who are invested and committed to improving education. Effectiveness: The agency has charter school boards in Delaware with establishing a charter, choosing and implementing a deeper learning model, staff recruitment and student enrollment. The agency is in the charter application process to open five more schools in the next three years. Innovative Schools has partnered with schools and school districts in all three counties. Efficiency: Innovative Schools strives to form partnerships with all public and charter schools throughout Delaware. Over seven districts throughout the state have partnered with IS to adapt Project Based Learning, fill administrative positions through the school staffing program, mentor and hire graduates from the Delaware Leadership Program to become principles. The agency has acted as a CMO to twenty two charter schools throughout Delaware. In addition to local schools, IS has partnered with out of state organizations such as the New York City Leadership program to adapt the Delaware Leadership Program. IS also formed a partnership with the Buck Institute for Education to adapt the Project Based Learning program that has been instituted in over eleven DE schools. Acting as a CMO to new charter schools, Innovative Schools works with the Founding Boards to research and adapt a deeper learning model. IS has partnered with four national school design models: Big Picture Learning Model, Early College High School Model, Expeditionary Learning Model and New Tech High School model. Innovative Schools assists Charter Boards with researching, touring and adapting the appropriate deeper learning model to fit the needs of the charter schools target population. 15
The Innovative School Model Initiative is a signature education program started by Innovative Schools and supported through a close partnership with United Way of Delaware. The program is a statewide strategy to launch a network of twenty-five deeper learning schools in Delaware by 2016. To accomplish this goal, Innovative Schools and United Way are working to build a fund of nearly $4 million by 2016, through investments from businesses, foundations and individuals, that can be issued as grants to Delaware public schools that wish to replicate deeper learning models in place of their traditional academic program. Personal Cultural Competencies Engagement, Trust and Relationship building: Understanding and recognizing an individuals cultural background is the first step in the relationship building process. To build a relationship of trust with individuals from the Hispanic cultural it is important to know their families country of origin and not assume. Also, identify with an individuals strong family connection and values may assist in engaging a person from the Hispanic community. Placing an emphasis on showing respect and using a formal way of addressing an individual when first meeting them may assist in the relationship building process. Assessment and Problem Definition: Race and ethnicity have an impact on professional relations, and inadequate cultural competence results in less effective services. A client with a worker of a different ethnicity may assume that the worker will not understand the clients world. This decreases the likelihood that the client will continue services. Workers can often have a poorer opinion of those clients whom they see as having significantly different views from themselves. Culturally sensitive community education may help more Latinos realize the potential benefits of services. 16
Learning and self-examination are critical when developing cultural competence. Reading books about Latino history and culture, attending ethnic specific events can help with cultural awareness. It is also important to examine ones own beliefs, values, and culture, and to determine to what extent clinical interventions are based in Western, middle-class, European American values. Personalismo refers to the value that Latinos place on interpersonal relationships. Non- Latino workers must be sensitive to this, and may need to adapt their style to the expectations of a Latino client. Some modifications may include an increased amount of self-disclosure, accepting gifts (often food), and more physical contact (handshakes, pats on the back), as well as being closer spatially. Latinos value respect, social workers need to understand the hierarchy of power within a family system. It is also important to develop personal relationships before proceeding to a professional relationship. Assessments should include the influence of culture and how the persons community can be helpful. The assessment should also include issues of national origin, birthplace, immigration experience, length of time in the country, language preference, and the meaning of being Latino. The culturagram is an assessment guide for understanding immigrant populations (Seipel, A. & Ineke, W., 2014). Contracting and Goal Setting: Goals: 1. Involve parents and other family members as agency partners and educating them about community resources and services. 2. Recognize the hierarchy of power with a family system. 3. Build a personal relationship of trust before engaging in services. 17
Objectives: Involve parents and other family members as partners and educate them about services and resources. 1. Help family members to become active members of the team and helping staff to recognize the value of those families as a part of the team. 2. Provide services that are driven by the needs and preferences identified by the child and family. 3. Services are based in the community so children can remain connected to their families and to their environmental and cultural norms. NASW Standards for Cultural Competence Standard 5: Service Delivery Social - Workers shall be knowledgeable about and skillful in the use of services available in the community and broader society and be able to make appropriate referrals for their diverse clients. Agency: Innovative Schools is active in providing services to meet the educational needs of the community by acting as the charter management organization for Delawares first bilingual school. The agency serves the education field and seeks to improve education for all children in the state. Program and Services: Innovative Schools programs are available to all schools, staff and administrative school leaders in all communities. The agencys programs are focused on providing deeper learning models and closing the achievement gap for all students. Innovative Schools does not work with a specific demographic, and works to fill education needs within the community by working with community members to serve diverse needs within education. 18
Personal Cultural Competencies: Cultural competence is a work in progress and a continual effort to gain a deeper understanding of other cultures. Personal cultural competence can be achieved and improved through study and personal experience. After completing the cultural immersion project I feel I have gained a deeper understanding, appreciation and connection with the Hispanic Culture through my personal experience living in South America, researching Hispanic history and reviewing a movie focused on a Hispanic individuals contributions to education.
19
References Barrerra, A. & Lopez, M. (2013). A Demographic Portrait of Mexican Origin Hispanics in the United States. Retrieved on August 5, 2014. From http://www.pewhispanic.org/2013/05/01/a-demographic-portrait-of-mexican-origin- hispanics-in-the-united-states/. Barrerra, A. & Lopez, M. (2013). What is the Future of Spanish in the United States? Retrieved on August 5, 2014. From http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/09/05/what-is-the- future-of-spanish-in-the-united-states/. De Varona, F. (1996). Hispanic Contributions Foundations, Inc. Retrieved on August 7, 2014. From http://hispaniccontributions.org/pManager_E.asp?pid=home_E. Explore Hispanic Culture (2012). Retrieved on August 6, 2014. From http://www.explore- hispanic-culture.com/hispanic-culture.html. Innovative Schools (2014). Retrieved on June 15, 2014. From http://www.innovativeschools.org/contact-us. La Academia Charter School (2014). Retrieved on August 9, 2014. From http://academiacharter.com/. Mathewson, J. (2008). Hispanic Culture in the United States. Retrieved on August 6, 2014. From http://www.worldissues360.com/index.php/hispanic-culture-in-the-united-states-54956/. 20
Menendez, R. (Director). (1988). Stand and Deliver (Motion Picture). United States: Warner Bros. R. A. Guisepi (2014). The Story of Hispanics In The Americas. Retrieved on August 6, 2014. From http://history-world.org/hispanics.htm Seipel, A. & Ineke, W. (2014). Culturally Competent Social Work Practice with Latino Clients. Retrieved on August 9, 2014. From http://www.socialworker.com/feature-articles/ethics- articles/Culturally_Competent_Social_Work_Practice_With_Latino_Clients/. United States Census Bureau (2014). Profile America Facts: Hispanic Population. Retrieved on August 5, 2014. From http://www.census.gov/newsroom/releases/archives/facts_for_features_special_editions/c b13-ff19.html