0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
25 Ansichten27 Seiten
The Canmore Community Housing Corporation (CCHC) is committed to the social sustainability of Canmore. CCHC was established as a non-profit municipal corporation with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community. Our vision is one where Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens and where CCHC contributes to this by advancing affordable housing options.
The Canmore Community Housing Corporation (CCHC) is committed to the social sustainability of Canmore. CCHC was established as a non-profit municipal corporation with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community. Our vision is one where Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens and where CCHC contributes to this by advancing affordable housing options.
The Canmore Community Housing Corporation (CCHC) is committed to the social sustainability of Canmore. CCHC was established as a non-profit municipal corporation with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community. Our vision is one where Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens and where CCHC contributes to this by advancing affordable housing options.
The Canmore Community Housing Corporation (CCHC) is committed to the social sustainability of Canmore. CCHC was established as a non-profit municipal corporation with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community. Our vision is one where Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens and where CCHC contributes to this by advancing affordable housing options.
Canmore has some of the highest shelter costs and the highest cost of living in Alberta. 1 There is a housing affordability gap between what Canmore residents and workers can afford and the price of market rental and ownership housing. It is not just a problem for the lower income population. It is also an issue for essential workers in higher paid occupations, such as teachers, nurses, and police officers. They all struggle with the high cost of housing and living in Canmore.
WHAT WE DO
The role of CCHC is to create affordable housing options that complement those provided by existing public and private housing providers. These options are intended to be long-term affordable options for permanent residents and to facilitate the transition of these households along the housing continuum.
At present, CCHC administers the sale and rental of 104 affordable housing units through our Perpetually Affordable Housing (PAH) Program. CCHC also owns land for affordable housing purposes, including 0.867 hectares leased to a housing cooperative that administers its own 44 unit PAH program, and 7.72 hectares of land for future development. Finally, CCHC researches and explores options to increase the availability of and accessibility to affordable housing to best meet current and future demand.
The opportunity exists for CCHC to continue in its efforts to increase availability of affordable housing units through the creation of new units or by utilizing existing market housing given the high number of vacancies and surplus of visitor accommodation units. There are also new opportunities for CCHC to explore, such as innovative finance programs and other programs to address barriers in accessing housing.
To be successful, CCHC will need to improve its organizational capacity to deliver programs and develop properties to respond to changing needs and demands in an uncertain economic and housing environment.
1 2010 Alberta Spatial Price Index published by Alberta Finance and Enterprise.
THE BUSINESS PLAN
CCHC has prepared a three year strategic business plan, which is organized into three sections:
Need and Opportunity: This section identifies and contextualizes the social problem that CCHC is attempting to address, including an analysis of the trends contributing to the problem, and a description of the opportunity that CCHC has identified for putting its unique approach to work. Social Impact Model: This section articulates CCHCs approach to addressing the affordability housing gap by connecting the social problem with the CCHC mission, approach, strategies, intended impact and vision of success. Implementation Strategy: This section outlines the actions needed to put the social impact strategies into action. It includes a timeline, strategies and goals, a general marketing plan, strategy for financial sustainability including operating budgets and a capitalization plan, performance and impact indicators, and discussion of risk management. The business plan serves as a road map to address our targeted social problem: the Canmore housing affordability gap.
II. NEED AND OPPORTUNITY
This section identifies and contextualizes the social problem that CCHC is attempting to address, including an analysis of the trends contributing to the problem, and a description of the opportunity that CCHC has identified for putting its unique approach to work.
A. SOCIAL PROBLEM
Once a small mining town, Canmore has emerged as an upscale recreational based community with an expanded service sector, growth in construction, and considerable in-migration of part-time and more permanent residents making Canmore one of the fastest-growing communities in Alberta to 2008.
A downside to this growth is that for many residents and workers, Canmore has become unaffordable. Canmore has some of the highest shelter costs and the highest cost of living in Alberta. A housing affordability gap exists between what Canmore residents and workers can afford and the price of market rental and ownership housing.
B. TRENDS
Population According to the municipal census, Canmores total population in 2011 was 18,299, of which 67% were permanent residents and 33% non-permanent residents. Over the past decade, permanent population growth has been modest compared to that of the non-permanent population, increasing by 14% between 2001 and 2011 compared to 163% for non-permanent residents. The permanent population continues to grow slowly with annual growth rates of 0-2% since 2006, while the pace of non-permanent population growth has slowed considerably since 2008 to only 2-3%. The municipal census shows that the permanent population is aging and households are getting smaller. The share of residents over 65 years of age is growing, while the share of residents under 15 years of age is shrinking along with the number of households with school-aged children. Moreover, the number of single person households nearly doubled between 2001 and 2011. These household changes are reflected in the decline in the number of permanent residents per dwelling unit between 2001 and 2011 from 2.67 to 2.36. It is unclear what the impact of this pattern and pace of growth will have on the population as Canmore moves towards urban build out, which was estimated to be about 30,000 people and 12,000 dwelling units in the 1998 Municipal Development Plan.
Economy and Employment Canmore transformed from a mining town into an international tourist destination by capitalizing on opportunities presented through exposure at the 1988 Winter Olympics. The result has been rapid physical growth and socio-economic change with expansion of the service and construction sector, and the disappearance of primary industries.
Employment levels are strong. The municipal census reported that 2.7% of Canmore adults were unemployed in 2011. This is consistent with the regional unemployment rate of 2.7% reported in the Alberta Labour Force Statistics Report for July 2011. The regional unemployment rate has increased in the past year to reach 3.7% in July 2012, but the region still boasts the lowest unemployment rate in Alberta.
Canmore is a regional centre with 35-40% of employed adult permanent residents working outside of Canmore at any time, primarily in the Bow Valley and Calgary. This allows Canmore not only to benefit from local initiatives to boost tourism and investment, but also regional investment and development activities, such as the planned expansion of the Lafarge cement plant in Exshaw.
Tourism is the mainstay of the economy. The number of workers in the accommodation and food, retail and wholesale trade, and health and wellness sectors has steadily increased over the past decade to represent 44% of Canmore resident workers and 22% of non-resident workers in 2011.
Construction has been another important but volatile industry, and typically dominated by residential development. Building permit values peaked in 2006-2007, followed by a sharp drop in 2009-2010, and are now at historically low levels. Employment in construction saw similar volatility, and now employs about 12% of resident workers and 8% of non-resident workers.
Income The Alberta Labour Force Statistics Report indicates that as of July 2012, the regional average hourly wage of $20.25 is 18% lower than the provincial average. This is not unexpected in service sector economies. However, despite low wages, Canmore median income levels are comparable to Alberta levels, which suggests that there are regional and/or local income disparities.
Real household incomes appear to be on the decline as median income is not keeping pace with inflation. Median income by household type only increased by 1.6% to 3.6% between 2008 and 2011, while the all-items consumer price index, or inflation, increased by 3.4% for Alberta and 5.1% for Canada.
Table 1: Median Income by Household Type, Canmore and Alberta, 2008-2011 Household Type 2008 2009 2010 2011* % Change 2008-2011 Single person Canmore $34,350 $33,590 $34,050 $34,911 1.6% Alberta $33,150 $32,580 $32,650 $33,476 1.0% Lone-parent families Canmore $43,000 $42,790 $43,450 $44,549 3.6% Alberta $41,470 $40,320 $40,150 $41,166 -0.7% Couple Families Canmore $93,590 $92,510 $93,370 $95,732 2.3% Alberta $94,170 $91,590 $93,820 $96,193 2.1% Source: Statistics Canada, Table 111-0009; *2011 adjusted by % change in 2011 Alberta average weekly earnings of 2.53%.
Housing The volume and median sales price of market homes peaked in 2007 at the same time that construction building permit values peaked. Since then, median sales price of all housing types has declined, but at differing rates and patterns depending on housing type (see Figure 1). Year to date statistics show that median prices of medium density homes are only 5% lower in 2012 than in 2007, while median prices of single family homes and apartments are about 15% lower than in 2007.
In the rental housing market, vacancies were low and rents continued to rise until 2007-08. This changed in 2008-09 as units under construction were completed, speculators could not sell units, renters moved in, and population growth slowed. However, since 2009, rental vacancies have tightened up with 40% fewer units being advertised each month and rental rates increasing by 3- 10% for most unit types, except four or more bedrooms. Figure 2 illustrates this trend. Figure 1 Canmore Median House Sales Prices 2007-2012
Figure 2 Canmore Average Monthly Rental Rates 2009-2012
$0 $100,000 $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $500,000 $600,000 $700,000 $800,000 $900,000 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Single Family Medium Density Apartment $- $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 2009 2010 2011 2012 YTD Shared Studio One Bed Two Bed Three Bed Four+ Bed Source: Dan Sparks, Century 21 Nordic Realty, Canmore Source: CCHC
As rental availability decreased, the number of vacant units reported in the municipal census has steadily increased, from 2.8% of all dwelling units in 2001 to 6% in 2011. Of these 411 vacant units, 44% are apartments and 23% accessory suites. There is also a surplus of commercial condominiums built for visitor accommodation purposes that remain vacant. The homeownership rate of Canmore permanent residents has steadily declined over the past decade, from 69% to 64%. Recent mortgage rule changes limiting amortization periods and future interest rate increases are expected to have an impact on housing sales, affordability and homeownership rates as buyers can afford less. This situation may create a greater demand for rental housing or create downward pressure on housing prices, or both.
C. THE HOUSING AFFORDABILITY GAP
Housing affordability is a multidimensional issue involving income, housing prices and housing availability. A gap exists when households are demanding to buy or rent housing at prices that are not available in the market. Low wage employment, high market housing costs, the lack of affordable units, and the overall high cost of living in a high-amenity mountain community like Canmore all contribute to the problem.
An analysis of available information in Table 2 suggests that homeownership is generally unaffordable for all households, with the median sales price of a medium density home almost 5 times and a single family home at 8 times the medium income for couple households. While rental housing provides more affordable options, the analysis in Table 3 suggests that a gap still exists for median income single person and lone parent households.
These tables show that housing affordability is not just a problem for the lower income population. It is also an issue for essential workers in higher paid occupations, such as teachers, nurses, and police officers. They all struggle with the high cost of housing and living in Canmore. Table 2: Canmore Affordability Gap for Buyers, 2011 Household Type 2011 Median Income 100% # of house- holds Maximum Affordable House Price Median Home Sales Price Gap Apartmt
$329,000 Medium Density $475,000 Single Family $769,000 Single Person $34,911 2,320 $115,000 $214,000 $360,000 n/a Lone Parent $44,549 330 $140,000 $189,000 $335,000 $629,000 Couple $95,732 3,110 $ 370,000 no gap $105,000 $399,000 Source: CCHC. Median income data derived from Statistics Canada, Table 111-0009. Median sales prices from Dan Sparks, Realtor, Century 21 Canmore.
Table 3: Canmore Affordability Gap for Renters, 2011 Household Type 2011 Median Income 100% # of house holds Maximum Affordable Monthly Rent Average Monthly Rental Rate Gap 1BR $954 2BR $1,296 3 BR $1,736 Single Person $34,911 2,320 $796 $158 n/a n/a Lone Parent $44,549 330 $1,009 n/a $287 $727 Couple $95,732 3,110 $2,288 n/a no gap no gap Source: CCHC. Median income data derived from Statistics Canada, Table 111-0009. Rental statistics from CCHC. D. ENVIRONMENTAL LANDSCAPE
CCHC currently administers an inventory of 104 affordable housing units and leases land to a 44 unit affordable housing cooperative project. These 148 affordable units account for 1.8% of the 8,303 Canmore dwelling units counted in the 2011 municipal census.
The role of CCHC is to create affordable housing options that complement those provided by existing public and private housing providers. These options are intended to be long-term affordable options for permanent residents and to facilitate the transition of these households along the housing continuum (see Figure 3).
The Bow Valley Regional Housing Authority (BVRHA) is a public housing provider that provides subsidized social housing to the lowest income groups, with a focus on seniors and family housing, and administers a provincial rental assistance program. The BVRHA currently houses or assists over 300 residents of the Bow Valley in approximately 188 units. Figure 3: Canmore Housing Continuum
E. BARRIERS Housing demand is a response to a set of complex variables. These variables include employment rates, real household incomes, affordability and availability of housing choices, interest rates, availability of finance, and confidence in the economy and housing market. 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% Social Housing Affordable Rental Market Rental Affordable Ownership Market Ownership
Median Income
In Canmore, employment rates are strong but real household income is not growing; market housing prices have declined, but there are still few affordable units available; and although interest rates remain at historically low levels, finance is less available and confidence in the housing market is not strong. These barriers are reflected in CCHCs 2010 Affordable Housing Survey, in which affordability was identified as the main barrier to buying a home (84%), followed by the lack of down payment (49%), instability in employment and/or income (18%), inability to qualify for a mortgage (18%) and instability in the real estate market (15%).
In this environment, households may choose to continue to rent, creating a greater demand for rental housing. Alternatively, downward pressure on housing prices could continue but it is unlikely to be enough to bridge the large affordability gap. Regardless, the lack of availability of and access to affordable ownership and rental options will continue to be barriers in addressing the housing affordability gap.
F. OPPORTUNITIES
The municipality established CCHC as a non-profit arms length corporation in 2000 with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community. The municipality also recognizes that CCHC continues to be at the forefront of community efforts to coordinate and promote the development of affordable rental and ownership homes. In addition, the Canmore Comprehensive Housing Action Plan and other studies suggest that there is a need for 1,000 affordable housing units by build out and up to 2,500 employee housing beds.
At present, the CCHC administers the sale and rental of 104 affordable housing units through our Perpetually Affordable Housing (PAH) Program. The 60 unit purpose built rental development has been at 98-100% occupancy for the past year, with a growing number of inquiries, applications and wait list, particularly for studio/one-bedroom units. Demand for our existing ownership inventory appears to be balanced at this time. This could change with the changing economic environment.
The CCHC also owns land for affordable housing purposes, including 0.867 hectares leased to a housing cooperative that administers its own 44 unit PAH program, and 7.72 hectares of land for future development. CCHC has developed a business plan for a new affordable housing project, but the feasibility and the timing of the project is not yet determined.
The opportunity exists for CCHC to continue its efforts to increase availability of affordable housing units. This could be done through the creation or acquisition of new units as has been done previously, or by utilizing existing market housing, particularly for rental purposes, given the number of vacant units and surplus of visitor accommodation units.
There are also opportunities for CCHC to explore in the area of new finance and housing programs. Innovative finance programs would be intended to address barriers in accessing finance to buy housing. These might include down payment assistance or alternative mortgage insurance options. New housing programs would be intended to meet changing housing demand, and could
include an employee housing program that would require partnerships and collaboration with Canmore employers.
Any projects or programs undertaken by CCHC will need to be small and scalable in order to complement, rather than compete with, existing market and non-market housing options. The organization will need to be flexible to meet changing needs and demands and to ensure the optimal use of our inventory given the uncertainty in the housing market and economy.
To move ahead with these opportunities, CCHC will need to continue to build its organizational capacity to deliver new programs and develop properties.
III. SOCIAL IMPACT MODEL
In this section, the Social Impact Model articulates CCHCs approach to addressing the affordability housing gap by connecting the social problem with the CCHC mission, approach, strategies, intended impact and vision of success.
A. THE ORGANIZATION CCHC was incorporated under the Alberta Companies Act in 2000 as an arms-length municipal corporation wholly owned by the Town of Canmore. It was established with the objective of providing housing solutions to support a healthy and balanced community.
CCHC is committed to the social sustainability of Canmore. Our vision is one where Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens and where CCHC contributes to this by advancing affordable housing options. CCHC identified the housing affordability gap as a significant issue. Our mission is to bridge this affordability gap with long-term options for the well-being of the community to the extent of our ability, resources and mandate.
A Board of Directors appointed by Town Council as Shareholder governs and provides direction to the Corporation. The Managing Director carries out this direction, implements the Business Plan, and oversees the daily operations with the support of a small administration team.
B. SOCIAL IMPACT MODEL The Social Impact Model has four main components (see Figure 4). The social issue, mission and vision of success constitute the foundation of the model and do not change as the business plan is implemented. The fourth component includes strategies, our operating model, and impact and performance indicators. The indicators measure short- and long-term impact and create a feedback loop so that adjustments and corrections to improve our operating model and social impact strategies can be identified over the course of the business plan.
C. OPERATING MODEL Figure 5 illustrates the components and relationships of the Operating Model, specifically, what CCHC does and how it is done. Properties & Programs Our properties and programs are at the core of CCHCs operating model. As an inventory of properties is created through development or acquisition, it is made available to our clients through programs. At present, our properties consist of 44 townhouse and apartment style condominium units, 60 apartment units, a 0.867 hectare land lease to a housing cooperative that administers its own 44 unit property, and 7.72 hectares of land for future development.
MISSION
To bridge Canmores housing affordability gap with long-term options for the well- being of the community.
SOCIAL ISSUE
High cost of housing relative to income Affordability gap exists between what Canmore residents and workers can afford to pay and the price of market housing. Issue is access to and the availability of appropriate affordable housing options.
VISION OF SUCCESS
Canmore is known for the quality of life of its citizens.
CCHC improves the availability of and access to affordable housing options
STRATEGIES 1. Build new units and utilize existing market units to increase availability of affordable housing 2. Innovative finance and housing programs to improve housing access 3. Improve organizational capacity to deliver programs and develop properties OPERATING MODEL 1. CCHC administers, develops and manages affordable housing properties and programs by engaging working partners to deliver programs and manage properties and by engaging clients so that they can access our programs and properties. 2. CCHC researches and advises with respect to: 1) development of housing policy and programs; and 2) planning and development of properties. This work is informed by working partners, clients and government policy.
IMPACT INDICATORS 1. Increase in # and % of affordable housing units. 2. Decrease in households dissatisfied with current housing status. 3. Decrease in households spending over 35% of income on housing.
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS 1. Occupancy rates 2. Applications processed 3. Days in inventory 4. Customer satisfaction 5. Earned program/project revenues as % of costs
Figure 4: Social Impact Model
CCHC currently administers the sale and rental of the 104 affordable housing units through our Perpetually Affordable Housing (PAH) Programs, ensuring that the principles underpinning PAH are adhered to. The three fundamental principles of PAH are: 1) rental and sales prices must be and remain below market prices; 2) PAH homes are available to eligible persons only; and 3) PAH homes must be used as the residents permanent primary residence. Research & Advise CCHC researches and advises with respect to the planning and development of properties, and the development of housing policy and programs. This work is informed by our working partners, clients and government policy. CCHC also advocates to government to effect change to policies so that our programs can better meet our clients needs. Administer, Develop & Manage CCHC administers, develops and manages affordable housing properties and programs. We engage working partners, clients and shareholders to strengthen the operating model and scale social impact. Our working partners include lenders, developers and builders, realtors, lawyers, potential investors, decision-makers and employers, without which we would not be able to create, sell and rent our inventory. CCHC engages clients so that they can access our programs and properties. CCHC is accountable to its Shareholders, the Town of Canmore, for its impact and financial sustainability. Our Shareholders are accountable to provide the necessary support for CCHC so that the corporation is able to achieve success.
Figure 5: CCHC Operating Model
D. SOCIAL IMPACT STRATEGIES
Social impact strategies are the major actions that CCHC will take to carry out our mission and to strengthen our operating model, while working toward achieving our vision of success.
CCHC identified three key strategies to improve availability of and access to affordable housing as informed by the needs and opportunity analysis in Section II. These strategies are: 1. Build new units and/or utilize existing market units to increase availability of affordable housing. 2. Develop and implement innovative finance and housing programs to improve access to affordable housing. 3. Improve organizational capacity to deliver programs and develop properties.
Specific goals and actions to implement these strategies are identified in Section IV Implementation Strategy.
IV. IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY The implementation strategy outlines the actions needed to put the social impact strategies of the previous section into action. It includes a timeline, strategies and goals, a general marketing plan and a strategy for financial sustainability including operating budgets and a capitalization plan. A. BUSINESS PLAN TIMELINE The business plan spans a three year time frame. It is intended that the business plan be a living document where strategies, the operating model, and indicators are reviewed annually to determine if CCHC is targeting the social problem effectively to the extent of its resources and mandate. B. STRATEGIES & GOALS The strategies in this section are derived from the strategies identified in the Social Impact Model in Section III. For each strategy, a first phase and second phase goal is identified, each phase lasting 12- to 24-months. The first phase goal of new strategies is typically an identification, development and pilot phase, followed by assessment and roll out in the second phase. For existing strategies, goals for each phase are dependent on the status of the initiative. STRATEGY 1.1 Increase availability of affordable housing units by building new units Phase 1 (2013-2014) Phase 2 (2014-2015) Pending the feasibility of a new affordable housing project business plan, implement pre- development strategy: secure land, secure funding, design development/building, obtain municipal approvals, and engage partner/builder.
Pending the outcome of pre-development activities, undertake sales and construction of new affordable housing project. Other activities: Initiate planning of Block 6 Palliser Lands in collaboration with Town and Stone Creek Properties
STRATEGY 1.2 Increase availability of affordable housing units by utilizing market units for affordable housing purposes Phase 1 (2013-2014) Phase 2 (2014-2015) Develop a strategy to utilize existing market housing stock for affordable housing purposes, such as visitor accommodation units. Develop and implement a pilot project to test the strategy.
Assess pilot project performance, determine key success factors, and make improvements based on lessons learned.
STRATEGY 2.1 Improve access to housing through innovative finance and housing programs Phase 1 (2013-2014) Phase 2 (2014-2015) Develop and implement an employee housing program in partnership with the Town of Canmore Assess performance of employee housing program, determine key success factors, and make improvements based on lessons learned. Develop a strategy to improve access to purchase housing (ie. mortgage insurance, down payment assistance, rent-to-own) and design and implement a pilot project.
Assess performance of pilot project, determine key success factors, and make improvements based on lessons learned. STRATEGY 3.1 Improve organizational capacity to deliver programs and develop properties Phase 1 (2013-2014) Phase 2 (2014-2015) Review organizational structure and recommend changes to accommodate growth in inventory and programs. Implement changes as required. Identify and foster partnerships with employers to strengthen operating model and scale social impact. Assess effectiveness of partnerships. Develop and implement policy and procedures to re-profile CCHC housing inventory to ensure inventory mix is appropriate for demand. Assess effectiveness of policy and procedures.
C. MARKETING
To increase impact, CCHC needs to communicate in a compelling way to our clients and working partners. CCHC recently rebranded, adopting a simple and professional logo with the message Community Lives Here and marketing materials with images of people to reflect our focus on community. This section includes a description of our target market, our working partners and strategies to engage them. Target Market CCHCs target market consists of people and families who are defined as being in need of affordable housing and having a connection to Canmore.
Need is typically measured by household income and/or net assets and is informed by the affordability gap analysis. CCHC typically defines its primary target markets in terms of income levels, targeting households earning 80% to 120% of median income for its ownership program and households earning 60% to 100% of median income for its rental program.
A connection to Canmore is typically determined by employment and/or residency. The focus of the ownership program has been on the retention of Canmore workers and long-term residents, while the rental program primarily targets new and existing Canmore workers.
CCHC engages directly with prospective clients through information sessions, open houses, at community events, and through email distribution lists. CCHC engages indirectly with these clients through newspaper advertising, community publications, and public posters. Our website is central to our marketing activities. It includes information for clients looking to buy, looking to rent, or simply looking for information about PAH or current listings.
CCHC recognizes the value of referrals, meeting with and providing information to employers and working partners, and inviting our existing clients to refer friends and coworkers. Working Partners CCHCs working partners strengthen our operating model. Our working partners include lenders, developers and builders, realtors, lawyers, potential investors, decision-makers and employers. They provide necessary services to CCHC and our clients in the development and delivery of our properties and programs. CCHC engages with working partners in tailored information sessions, private or group meetings, industry events, and by email. CCHC plans to have a greater focus on employers as a partner with respect to how our programs can better meet their employee housing needs.
D. FINANCIAL SUSTAINABILITY Financial sustainability means that CCHC has adequate revenues to cover its property, program and organizational costs. Revenues can be earned through project, program and organizational activities, or can be cash or in-kind contributions in the form of a grant or loan.
CCHC currently earns revenues from ownership and rental programs. This revenue is restricted by municipal policies that establish maximum sales administration fees and rental rates. Accordingly, CCHC receives an annual cash contribution from the municipality for operations and an in-kind contribution of office space. Other revenues include earned interest revenue from reserve funds and donations and grant monies.
CCHC holds significant land and property assets which have been transferred from the municipality at a nominal cost. These assets include both developed and undeveloped land and The Hector at Palliser Village 60 unit rental property. These assets have holding and development costs, but also have the potential to generate capital or earned revenues to contribute to future financial sustainability and reduce contributions required from the municipality.
A capitalization plan is used to ensure a sustainable balance between programs and our financial and organizational capacity, identifying the total amount of social investment required to execute the business plan and strategies to acquire the necessary resources to cover shortfall. This also ensures a balance between the pace of program growth and pace that financial and organizational capacity can grow. The capitalization plan must be updated regularly as strategies evolve and revenues and expenditures change. E. OPERATING BUDGET: 2013-2015
The 2013-2015 Operating Budget, Reserve Fund Balances and Capitalization Plan are found in Figures 6, 7 and 8. Explanations of changes in revenues, expenditures, and reserve fund transfers are provided in the section below. Revenues Revenues are categorized as general, program or project revenues. General revenues include contributions from the Town of Canmore and unrestricted interest revenues. Program and project revenues include contributions and earned revenues derived from and used for a specific program or project.
General revenues are budgeted to increase in 2013 due to a 10% increase in the annual cash contribution requested from the Town of Canmore, from $250,000 to $275,000. This is subject to approval by Town Council. This amount has not increased since 2008 despite considerable expansion of properties and development of programs over this period. The increase is largely to cover wage increases due to inflationary and performance increases and an amount for program development as per strategies 1.2 and 2.1.
PAH Rental revenues are budgeted to increase in 2013-2014 due to high occupancy rates and rental rate increases in response to higher operating costs. If feasible, CCHC will proceed with the development of a new affordable housing project as part of strategy 1.1. Project development revenues are required for pre- and site development costs budgeted in 2013-14, and construction costs starting in the second half of 2014. These are not committed funds. Instead, the amount includes grants, loans and internal reserve funds that may be accessed as per the Capitalization Plan. Project revenues anticipate sales and occupancy starting in 2015.
Expenditures General expenditures include administration and human resource costs for the organization. PAH Program and Capital Project expenditures are costs directly associated with the programs and projects, excluding general expenditures noted above. However, any contract employment as a result of new project and program activities are allocated to the appropriate program or project expenditure.
No significant changes are expected in general administration, resulting in only a modest increase for inflation. A new line item is included for program development expenditures in relation to the implementation of strategies 1.2 and 2.1. PAH rental program expenditures are expected to increase due to increasing operating expenditures and increasing reserve fund contributions. As noted above, if feasible, CCHC will proceed with the development of a new affordable housing project as part of strategy 1.1 with pre- and site-development costs budgeted in 2013- 2014, and construction starting in the second half of 2014.
Reserve Fund Transfers CCHC has three reserve funds, each for a different purpose: The Capital Reserve can be used for capital project expenditures with transfers approved annually by the Board of Directors. Transfers to and from the Operating Reserve are intended to even out operational cash surpluses and deficits, and optimally is equal to 3 to 6 months of general revenues. The Hector Reserve can only be used for capital expenditures for The Hector rental property as identified in an approved capital reserve fund plan or as approved by the Board of Directors. The end result of reserve fund transfers is an operating budget with a zero cash balance. Projected reserve fund balances after transfers are found in Figure 7. Capitalization Plan The capitalization plan in Figure 8 shows a shortfall for each year specifically with respect to the costs of developing a new affordable housing project (strategy 1.1). Financing arrangements and developer partnership agreements, if necessary, are projected to be finalized in 2013. Sales revenues are projected to be realized starting in the second half of 2015. These amounts are subject to change as this strategy evolves, and as other strategies are explored and implemented.
Figure 6 CCHC Operating Budget 2013-2015 ACTUAL BUDGET 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 REVENUES General Revenues Town of Canmore transfer 250,000 $ 250,000 $ 275,000 $ 275,000 $ 275,000 $ Town of Canmore rent in kind (non cash) - $ 24,000 $ 24,528 $ 25,068 $ 25,619 $ Interest Income and Other 300,826 $ 7,250 $ 12,000 $ 12,000 $ 12,000 $ Total General Revenues 550,826 $ 281,250 $ 311,528 $ 312,068 $ 312,619 $ Program/Project Revenues PAH Rental Revenues - The Hector 590,128 $ 593,792 $ 605,047 $ 635,300 $ 635,300 $ PAH Sale Revenues 26,712 $ 31,250 $ 25,000 $ 25,000 $ 25,000 $ Project Revenues - $ - $ - $ - $ 2,707,676 $ Project Development Funding - $ - $ 438,762 $ 3,102,288 $ 1,773,549 $ Total Program/Project Revenues 616,839 $ 625,042 $ 1,068,809 $ 3,762,588 $ 5,141,525 $ TOTAL REVENUES 1,167,666 $ 906,292 $ 1,380,337 $ 4,074,655 $ 5,454,144 $ EXPENDI TURES General Expenditures Administration Expenditures 50,483 $ 82,850 $ 77,304 $ 76,906 $ 78,543 $ Human Resource Expenditures 199,049 $ 209,150 $ 219,690 $ 228,158 $ 236,964 $ Total General Expenditures 249,532 $ 292,000 $ 296,994 $ 305,064 $ 315,507 $ PAH Program Expenditures ProgramDevelopment Expenditures - $ - $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ PAH Rental Expenditure - The Hector 590,128 $ 599,367 $ 608,259 $ 620,503 $ 627,846 $ PAH Sale Expenditures 16,269 $ 17,500 $ 18,750 $ 18,750 $ 18,750 $ Total PAH Program Expenditures 606,397 $ 616,867 $ 647,009 $ 659,253 $ 666,596 $ Capital Project Expenditures Affordable Housing Project Development - $ - $ 438,762 $ 3,102,288 $ 4,481,225 $ Palliser Lot 7 1,417 $ 3,000 $ 2,044 $ 2,089 $ 2,135 $ Palliser Block 6 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ TSMV Lot 39 7,638 $ 8,000 $ 7,794 $ 7,965 $ 8,140 $ Other 1,756 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Total Property Expenditures 10,812 $ 11,000 $ 448,600 $ 3,112,342 $ 4,491,500 $ TOTAL EXPENDI TURES 866,741 $ 919,867 $ 1,392,603 $ 4,076,659 $ 5,473,603 $ NET CASH SURPLUS/DEFI CI T BEFORE TR 300,925 $ (13,575) $ (12,266) $ (2,003) $ (19,460) $ TRANSFER (TO)/FROM RESERVES CCHC Capital Reserve Fund (278,605) $ 8,000 $ 9,838 $ 10,054 $ 10,275 $ CCHC Operating Reserve Fund (22,320) $ - $ 2,428 $ (8,051) $ 9,184 $ Town PAH Reserve Fund - $ 5,575 $ - $ - $ - $ Total Transfers (300,925) $ 13,575 $ 12,266 $ 2,003 $ 19,460 $ CASH BALANCE AFTER TRANSFERS - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ BUDGET
Figure 8 CCHC Capitalization Plan 2013-2015 BUDGET PROJECTED 2012 2012 2013 2014 2015 Earned Revenues Total General Earned Revenues 1,250 $ 1,372 $ 1,372 $ 1,372 $ 1,372 $ Total Hector Revenues 595,542 $ 611,893 $ 606,919 $ 637,172 $ 637,172 $ Total PAH Sale/Resale Revenues 31,250 $ 24,251 $ 25,000 $ 25,000 $ 25,000 $ Total Project/Property Earned Income 4,250 $ 8,756 $ 8,756 $ 8,756 $ 2,716,432 $ Total Earned Revenues 632,292 $ 646,272 $ 642,047 $ 672,300 $ 3,379,976 $ Expenditures Total General Expenditures 202,650 $ 195,876 $ 207,896 $ 213,545 $ 220,855 $ Total Hector Expenditures 628,317 $ 621,629 $ 637,958 $ 651,009 $ 659,397 $ Total PAH Sale/Resale Expenditures 60,925 $ 64,628 $ 83,299 $ 84,510 $ 86,076 $ Total Project/Property Expenditures 27,975 $ 35,617 $ 463,449 $ 3,127,595 $ 4,507,276 $ Total Expenditures 919,867 $ 917,750 $ 1,392,603 $ 4,076,659 $ 5,473,603 $ Surplus/(Deficit) (287,575) $ (271,477) $ (750,556) $ (3,404,359) $ (2,093,628) $ Committed Contributions Town of Canmore transfer 250,000 $ 250,000 $ Town of Canmore rent in kind (non cash) 24,000 $ 24,000 $ Project Development Funding - $ 10,000 $ Total Committed Contributions 274,000 $ 284,000 $ - $ - $ - $ Surplus/(Deficit) (13,575) $ 12,523 $ (750,556) $ (3,404,359) $ (2,093,628) $ Likely Contributions Town of Canmore transfer 275,000 $ 275,000 $ 275,000 $ Town of Canmore rent in kind (non cash) 24,528 $ 25,068 $ 25,619 $ CCHC Capital Reserve Fund 8,000 $ 9,626 $ 9,838 $ 10,054 $ 10,275 $ CCHC Operating Reserve Fund - $ (22,149) $ 2,428 $ (8,051) $ 9,184 $ Town PAH Reserve Fund 5,575 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ Total Likely Contributions 13,575 $ (12,523) $ 311,794 $ 302,071 $ 320,079 $ Capitalization Amount (shortfall) - $ 0 $ (438,762) $ (3,102,288) $ (1,773,549) $ BUDGET
F. PERFORMANCE & SOCIAL IMPACT INDICATORS
Organizational and program performance indicators assess CCHCs capacity to deliver programs. These are to be reported on a quarterly basis where appropriate, and at a minimum, annually. Performance indicators include the following: 1. Occupancy rates of sales and rental properties 2. Days units for sale held in inventory 3. Number of applications processed by program 4. Customer satisfaction levels 5. Ratio of earned program/project revenues to program/project costs. Social and economic impact indicators are more challenging to develop and measure. These are reported on annually where appropriate, and at a minimum, every three years at the end of the business planning period. Impact indicators include the following measurements: 1. Increase in # and % of affordable housing units. 2. Decrease in households dissatisfied with current housing status. 3. Decrease in households spending over 35% of income on housing. As stated previously, these indicators measure short- and long-term impact and create a feedback loop so that adjustments and corrections to improve our operating model and social impact strategies can be identified over the course of the business plan
G. RISK MANAGEMENT
In this section, external and internal risks are identified, as well as strategies to mitigate the risks.
Risk: Lack of economic and housing market recovery, and growth of permanent population, to support the development of new units and to support the resale and rental of existing inventory. Mitigation: CCHC will continue to monitor economic and housing market statistics, including demographics, market prices and demand and ensure development is appropriately staged and inventory is appropriate for the demand.
Risk: Mortgage rule and interest rate changes further limit access to mortgage insurance and finance for purchasers of PAH units. Mitigation: Advocate with CMHC to secure approval for mortgage insurance for PAH products and with Genworth to retain current mortgage insurance support; and continue to communicate with existing and new lenders with respect to financing PAH properties. Investigate innovative finance arrangements such as self-insuring mortgage and down payment assistance programs. Consider other PAH ownership models as appropriate.
Risk: Lack of committed funds from the Town of Canmore as its annual business planning and budget cycle allows only a one year commitment to CCHC operations. Mitigation: Maintain effective relationships with the municipality through Council representatives appointed to the Board, the Town liaison to CCHC and shareholders. Ensure that CCHC is involved in all discussions and decisions related to affordable housing program, planning and development and that the municipality is aware of all business costs to CCHC associated with municipal policy.
Risk: As a municipal controlled corporation, CCHCs financial position is included in municipal consolidated financial statements, which are subject to provincial regulations with respect to debt limits and servicing. This may impact CCHCs ability to assume debt to finance new affordable housing developments and the acquisition of housing for rental purposes. Mitigation: Explore innovative partnering agreements with developers so that the risk and debt is shared appropriately.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Hans Helder Bob Kocian Sean Krausert Sarah Law Garth Lyon Kimber Meister Cathy Robinson Dan Sparks
203, 600 A 9 th Street Canmore, Alberta T1W 2T2 (403) 609.9983