Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1
2
dW
n
cos a dx P
II
nt
dP
II
nt
y dy 0
7
where, dW
n
=gy dx, Q
nt
II
=P
nt
II
tan F, dQ
nt
II
=dP
nt
II
tan F.
From geometrical considerations, the height of the
block can be expressed as: y=(Lx)tan c;
dy=tan c dx.
Substituting into (7), the dierential equation for
toppling failure is
dP
II
nt
P
II
nt
_
1
tan F
tan c
_
dx
L x
1
2
g L xsin a tan c dx 0
8
With the boundary condition P
nt
I
=P
nt
II
for x=x
o
(the toppling force on the rst block of zone II is the
resulting force on the last block of zone I, given by
Eq. (3)), the solution is
P
II
nt
1
2
g sin a tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
x
o
2
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
L x
tan F=tan c1
1
2
g sina tan c
L x
2
3 tan F=tan c
9
The values of x
o
and L are given by: x
o
H sinc=
tan o sina c; L H=sina c sin c=tan o
cos c
From Eq. (9), one can observe that for c >F, and
as x 4L, the force required for equilibrium goes to
innity. Hence equilibrium is possible only if c <F.
Note that Eq. (9) has singular solutions for c=F and
tan F=3 tanc; these cases will be discussed later.
Sliding equilibrium in zone II can be formulated as
(see Fig. 3(a))
P
II
ns
P
II
ns
dP
II
ns
S
n
dW
n
sin a 0
Q
II
ns
Q
II
ns
dQ
II
ns
dW
n
cos a R
n
0
10
or as the dierential equation
dP
II
ns
tan j tan F 1
g L x tan csin a cos a tan jdx 0
11
In zone II the block movement starts as toppling.
However, as the movement progresses downwards to
the toe of the slope, failure may change to sliding.
Sliding may start at some point `x=z' where the load
necessary for toppling, given by Eq. (9), will be equal
to the load necessary for sliding, which is given by the
solution of (11). Using this condition, which can be
expressed as P
ns
II
=P
nt
II
for x=z, the solution of (11) is
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a
tan c1 tan j=tana
1 tan j tan F
L x
2
1
2
g sina tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
x
2
o
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
L z
tan F=tan c1
1
2
g sin a tan c
_
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
1
3 tan F=tan c
_
L z
2
12
Of all values of `z', sliding will occur at a location
such that P
ns
II
is maximum for x=L. In other words,
@P
II
ns
=@zj
xL
0. With this condition, slippage will be
produced at
L z
tan F=tan c3
g sin a tan c
C 1 tan F=tan c
_
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
1
3 tan F=tan c
_
,
13
A. Bobet / International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences 36 (1999) 971980 974
where
C
1
2
g sina tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
x
2
o
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
Note that for the condition (Lz ) R0, sliding does
not occur, and the solution is given by Eq. (9). In this
case the force at the toe of the slope (for x=L) is
nite only if F >c.
Substituting (13) in (12), the force necessary for
equilibrium at the toe of the slope (x=L) is given by
P
II
ns
g sin a tan c
_
1
1 tan F=tan c
1
2
_
_
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
1
3 tan F=tan c
_
L z
2
14
There is no diculty in nding the critical angle
c
critical
for which P
ns
II
=0 for x=L. That is, the angle
at which the slope will be in equilibrium. Disregarding
the case z=L, and the especial case tan F=3 tan c
(see later), the solution is given by
tan c
critical
tan F 1 tan j=tan a
2 tan j tan F 3 tan j=tan a
15
It can be noticed that the solution is independent of
the angle o and the height H of the slope.
The especial cases F=c and tan F=3 tan c are
included for completeness, and they do not present ad-
ditional diculties. Following the preceding reasoning,
one obtains
For F=c,
P
II
nt
1
2
g sin a tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
1
2
tan o
tan c
_
x
o
2
1
4
g sina tan c L x
2
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a
tan c1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
L x
2
1
2
g sina tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
1
2
tan o=tan c
_
x
o
2
1
2
g sin a tan c
_
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
1
2
_
L z
2
Sliding starts at: (Lz )=0 (i.e. there is no sliding),
which gives
P
II
nt
1
2
g sina tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
1
2
tan o
tan c
_
x
2
o
16
This expression is always greater than zero. Hence,
a slope with F=c will never be stable.
For the case tan F=tan c 3,
P
II
nt
_
1
2
g sin a
tan c
_
ln
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
tan c=tan o
3 tan F=tan o
_
1
2
g sina tan c lnL x
_
L x
2
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a
tan c1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
L x
2
_
1
2
g sina tan c
_
ln
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
tan c=tan o
3 tan F=tan o
_
1
2
g sina tan c lnL z
1
2
g sin a tan c
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
_
L z
2
Sliding occurs for
lnL z ln
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
tan c=tan o
3 tan F=tan o
1
2
1 tan j=tan a
1 tan j tan F
and
P
II
ns
1
4
g sina tan c L z
2
17
3. Water seepage
The preceding solutions can be easily extended to a
slope with water seepage. Fig. 4 shows a slope in
which the water table is at the surface with water ow,
A. Bobet / International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences 36 (1999) 971980 975
as a rst approximation, parallel to the ground sur-
face. Under this condition, the pore water pressure is
linear with depth, and can be expressed by the
equation:
u g
w
k y
The seepage coecient k can be approximated as
k u
m
=d (see Fig. 4).
Figure 3(b) shows the forces acting on a block with
water seepage. As before, the slope is divided into two
zones I and II, and the analysis is carried out through
the same steps. For each zone both sliding and top-
pling equilibrium equations can be written as follows:
Toppling in zone I:
P
I
nt
y dy Q
I
nt
dx
1
2
dW
n
sin a y
1
2
dW
n
cos a dx P
I
nt
dP
I
nt
y U
l
U
r
y
2
0
Sliding in zone I:
P
I
ns
P
I
ns
dP
I
ns
S
n
dW
n
sin a U
l
U
r
0
Q
I
ns
Q
I
ns
dQ
I
ns
dW
n
cos a R
n
U
b
0
Toppling in zone II:
P
II
nt
y Q
II
nt
dx
1
2
dW
n
sin a y
1
2
dW
n
cos a dx P
II
nt
dP
II
nt
y dy
U
l
U
r
y
2
0
Sliding in zone II:
P
II
ns
P
II
ns
dP
II
ns
S
n
dW
n
sin a U
l
U
r
0
Q
II
ns
Q
II
ns
dQ
II
ns
dW
n
cos a R
n
U
b
0
with
U
l
1=2 y dy=2
2
g
w
k
U
r
1=2 y dy=2
2
g
w
k
U
b
=g
w
y k dx.
The solution of these dierential equations is
Fig. 4. Assumed water seepage in the slope.
A. Bobet / International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences 36 (1999) 971980 976
P
II
nt
_
1
2
g sina x
2
o
tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
1
2
g
w
k
x
2
o
tan
2
o
_
1
3 tan F=tan c
1
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
L x
tan F=tan c1
1
2
g sin a g
w
k tan c
tan c
3 tan F=tan c
L x
2
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a cos a tan j g
w
k tan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
tan c
L x
2
_
1
2
gsinax
o
2
tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
1
2
g
w
kx
o
2
tan
2
o
_
1
3 tan F=tan c
1
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
L z
tan F=tan c1
1
2
tan c
_
g sin a cos atan j g
w
ktan j tan c
1 tan jtan F
gsina g
w
ktan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
L z
2
L z
tan F=tan c3
_
g sin a cos a tan j g
w
ktan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
gsina g
w
ktan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
tan c
C 1 tan F=tan c
20
where
C
_
1
2
gsin a x
o
2
tan o
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
tan o=tan c
3 tan F=tan c
_
1
2
g
w
kx
o
2
tan
2
o
_
1
3 tan F=tan c
1
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1tan F=tan c
Note that in Eq. (18), for F <c, and as x 4L,
P
nt
II
41. A nite solution only exists if F >c. As
before, the conditions F=c and tan F=3 tan c are
special cases.
Substituting (20) into (19) and for x=L, the force at
the toe of the slope required for equilibrium is:
P
II
ns
g sin a tan c
_
1
1 tan F=tan c
1
2
_
_
1 tan j=tan a g
w
=g ktan j tan c=sin a
1 tan j tan F
1 g
w
=g ktan c=sina
3 tan F=tan c
_
L z
2
21
P
ns
II
has a value of zero at the toe of the slope (i.e.
P
ns
II
=0 for x=L) for z=L, which is a trivial solution,
for tan F=3 tan c (see later), or for
_
g
w
k2 tan j tan F
_
tan
2
c
_
g sina
_
2 tan j tan F 3
tan j
tan a
_
g
w
k3tan j tan F
_
tan c
_
g sin a
_
1
tan j
tan a
_
tan F g
w
k tan j tan F
_
0
22
Equation (22) is a second order equation in tan c,
which will give the value of c
critical
, at which the slope
is stable. As before, the solution is independent of the
angle o and the height H of the slope.
The especial cases F=c and tan F=3 tan c are
included for completeness.
For F=c,
(18)
(19)
A. Bobet / International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences 36 (1999) 971980 977
P
II
nt
1
4
_
g sin a
_
2
3 tan o tan F
1
tan c
_
g
w
k
_
1
2
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
x
o
2
tan
2
o
1
4
g sin a g
w
k tan c tan c L x
2
and
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a cos a tan j g
w
k tan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
tan c L x
2
1
4
_
g sin a
_
2
3 tan o tan F
1
tan c
_
g
w
k
_
1
2
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
x
o
2
tan
2
o
1
2
_
g sin a cos a tan j g
w
ktan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
1
2
g sin a g
w
k tan c
_
tan cL z
2
Sliding occurs at (Lz )=0, and
P
II
nt
1
2
g sina tan o
_
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
1
2
tan o
tan c
_
1
2
g
w
g
k
tan o
sina
_
1
2
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
x
o
2
23
For the case tan F/tan c=3
P
II
nt
_
C
1
2
g sina g
w
k tan c tan c lnL x
_
L x
2
,
where
C
1
2
_
g sina
_
ln
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
tan c=tan o
3 tan F=tan o
_
g
w
k tan c
_
ln
_
x
o
tan o
tan c
_
1
3 tan F=tan o
_
_
tan c
P
II
ns
1
2
g sin a cos a tan j g
w
ktan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
tan c L x
2
_
C
1
2
g sina g
w
k tan ctan clnL z
1
2
gsin a cos a tan j g
w
ktan j tan c
1 tan j tan F
tan c
_
L z
2
Sliding occurs for
lnL z
2 C
gsina g
w
k tan c tan c
1
2