Raafat Abbas Erick Cunningham Trevor Munk Clamart, France Bente Bjelland Norsk Hydro Bergen, Norway Vincent Chukwueke Nederlandse Aardolie Maatschappij B.V. Assen, The Netherlands Alain Ferri Aberdeen, Scotland Greg Garrison Houston, Texas, USA Doug Hollies EnCana Corporation Calgary, Alberta, Canada Chris Labat ChevronTexaco New Orleans, Louisiana, USA Omar Moussa Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia For help in preparation of this article, thanks to Mario Bellabarba, The Hague, The Netherlands; Leo Burdylo, Roger Keese, Bill Miller, Erik Nelson and Don Williamson, Sugar Land, Texas, USA; Ryan Cammarata, Bill Dacres, Laurent Delabroy, J ames J ackson and Randy Tercero, Houston, Texas; Youssef El Marsafawi, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; Simon J ames, Clamart, France; Brian Koons, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; Christian Mueller, Stavanger, Norway; Ron Schreuder, Coevorden, The Netherlands; and David Stiles, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. CBT (Cement Bond Tool), CemCADE, CemCRETE, CemSTONE, DeepCEM, DeepCRETE, DuraSTONE, FlexSTONE, GASBLOK, GeoMarket, LiteCRETE, MUDPUSH, SCMT (SlimCement Mapping Tool), USI (UltraSonic Imager), Variable Density, VDN (VISION Density Neutron) and WELLCLEAN II are marks of Schlumberger. Improving long-term wellbore integrity is a growing priority. Exploration and production companies recognize that achieving excellent zonal isolation requires superior mud removal and proper cement-system design. New simulation software, environmentally friendly primary cementing systems and worldwide eld support help companies achieve well-construction goals from the outset while enhancing environmental protection. Exploration and production (E&P) companies have been striving for perfect zonal isolation since the earliest days of wellbore cementing. The complex relationships between the geology, chemistry and physics of each oil- or gas-well completion present unique challenges that decades of experience alone may not solve. These challenges manifest themselves in both new and existing wells. The scope of existing zonal-isolation problems is enormous. Worldwide drilling during 2001 led to 74,000 new wells, of which 48,000 were drilled in North America. 1 A major concern is that many existing wells are now experiencing sustained casing pressure, an indication that a path exists between a pressure source and an annulus. In the offshore Gulf of Mexico alone, 11,500 casing annuli in 8000 wells may suffer sustained casing pressure. 2 Remediation costs could be as high as US $1 million per well, including the costs of workover rigs and nding and xing leaks. In Canada, sustained casing pres- sure aficts a wide variety of onshore wells, from shallow gas wells to heavy-oil wells. Correcting these problems worldwide may cost as much as US $2.75 billion over 10 years. Clearly, avoiding these remediation expenses is preferable. Sustained casing pressure may result from many causes, such as poor primary cementing, inadequate requirements in effect when older wells were cemented or deterioration of the cement matrix with time. Regardless of the cause, industry and regulatory bodies recognize the need to protect the environment from leaking reservoir uids. Poor zonal isolation may result in a loss of well control or contamination of water 1. World Trends: Industry Pace Should Quicken, World Oil 223, no. 8 (August 2002): 3337. For more on 2001 drilling data: http://www.worldoil.com/magazine/magazine_link.asp?A RT_LINK=02-08_world-abraham_T2.htm#top. 2. Bourgoyne AT J r, Scott SL and Manowski W: A Review of Sustained Casing Pressure Occurring on the OCS, LSU study funded by the Minerals Management Service, US Department of the Interior, Washington, DC, under Contract Number 14-35-001-30749. 3. For more on remediating existing wellbores: Barclay I, Pellenbarg J , Tettero F, Pfeiffer J , Slater H, Staal T, Stiles D, Tilling G and Whitney C: The Beginning of the End: A Review of Abandonment and Decommissioning Practices, Oileld Review 13, no. 4 (Winter 2001/2002): 2841. Boisnault J M, Guillot D, Bourahla A, Tirlia T, Dahl T, Holmes C, Raiturkar AM, Maroy P, Moffett C, Prez Meja G, Ramrez Martnez I, Revil P and Roemer R: Concrete Developments in Cementing Technology, Oileld Review 11, no. 1 (Spring 1999): 1629. Autumn 2002 17 sources, which can be catastrophic for the environ- ment and the local population. Improving primary cementing in new wells and repairing leaking wells are logical steps toward improving zonal isolation and protecting the environment. 3 In this article, we discuss solutions that improve zonal isolation in primary cementing, beginning with mud-removal technology. Examples from operations demonstrate the impact of new techniques and uids. Innovative simulation software and a worldwide network of eld-support laboratories help engineers opti- mize cement-job designs. Optimizing Mud Removal Effective drilling-uid removal is a prerequisite for primary cementing success. As the cement slurry sets, mud left in the wellbore can prevent develop- ment of a hydraulic seal, which can result in such adverse phenomena as the production of unwanted uids, loss of hydrocarbons to low-pressure zones, sustained casing pressure, underground blowouts or accelerated casing corrosion. These can lead to additional, and usually unexpected, expenses to solve these problems. In addition to the general condition and quality of the wellbore, factors inuencing mud removal include mud conditioning, displacement procedures, well geometry and centralization of the casing. In preparing to cement a casing string, a cementing crew pumps a series of uids down the casing to displace the drilling uid from the interior of the casing and the casing-formation annulus. The rst uid pumped usually is a chem- ical wash or spacer that separates the drilling uid from the cement slurry. Chemical washes have a density and viscos- ity close to that of water or oil; water, diesel or oil may be used as base uids for chemical washes. When pumped ahead of the cement slurry, they promote mud removal by diluting, thinning and dispersing the mud. Chemical washes can be formulated to remove both water- and oil-base drilling uids. Ultimately, chemical washes improve the quality of the bond between the casing and the cement, and between the cement and the formation. Because chemical washes tend to have a low viscosity, they are pumped in turbulent flow (right). Chemical washes are available for a wide variety of applications. Spacer uids also provide a buffer that is chemically compatible with both the drilling uid and the cement slurry during displacement. Complete displacement of drilling uid by the spacer is critical to the establishment of zonal isolation; incomplete displacement may result in a continuous mud channel across the zone of interest, creating communication paths between zones. Such communication results in the pro- duction of unwanted uids, loss of hydrocarbons and even migration of uids to surface. For oil- base muds, the surfactants used in chemical washes and spacers change the wettability of the casing and the formation near the wellbore from oil-wet to water-wet. This contributes to improved cement bonding. MUDPUSH II spacers are compatible with cement slurries, water- and oil-base mud, and fresh water, seawater or brackish water. These spacers can be designed at densities from 10 to 20 lbm/gal [1200 to 2400 kg/m 3 ], and at temper- atures up to 300F [149C]. The spacers have demonstrated excellent reproducibility between laboratory design and eld performance, and are easy to mix at the wellsite. The MUDPUSH II spacer properties are adjusted to minimize environmental impact, including lower toxicity, improved biodegradation and lower bioaccumulation. 4 A smaller quantity of chemicals than that required with other spacers produces the desired performance char- acteristics. Fewer chemicals are discharged or handled as uids return to surface, less storage space is required and less waste is generated. Optimizing the rheological properties of a spacer uid improves zonal isolation and mud dis- placement. Rapid selection and adjustment of additive concentrations in spacer uids now are possible with the WELLCLEAN II Engineering Solution Advisor software. This software reduces the time and effort required to optimize uid prop- erties, whether the uids are designed for turbu- lent or laminar ow. Simulation results from CemCADE cementing design and evaluation soft- ware, which are based on actual data, can be imported into WELLCLEAN II Advisor software. 5 When used to design the cementing job, the output from the WELLCLEAN II Advisor software reduces the risk of error and improves the efciency. When designing a MUDPUSH II spacer for removing mud in turbulent ow, the WELLCLEAN II Advisor software indicates the optimal additive concentration to stabilize the spacer so that weighting agents do not settle out and the rheo- logical properties do not change. At the same time, the software sets uid properties at the best level to achieve turbulent ow at low pump rates. In some cases, pumping-rate restrictions require a laminar ow regime; turbulent ow generally involves higher pumping rates. If the strategy species design of the spacer for lami- nar ow, the software provides optimized spacer properties and additive concentrations at the required density and temperature. The degree of mud removal and the presence of mud channels are more commonly linked to wellbore geometry, rugosity, washouts, uid viscosity and density than to ow regime. Multiple simulations demon- strate the consequences of various additive concentrations on spacer properties. Spacer prop- erties for a particular job are always designed for compatibility with the mud and cement. In addition to a comprehensive database of laboratory tests, the WELLCLEAN II Advisor software provides mathematical models and a reasoning engine that can derive spacer prop- erties by interpolating results at various temperatures, densities and additive concentra- tions (next page). The software incorporates the Bingham plastic, power-law and Herschel- Bulkley rheological models. 6 Field measurements of spacer properties designed using the WELLCLEAN II Advisor soft- ware have proved to closely match predicted design data. For example, on a high-pressure well in the Middle East, the mud density required to kill the well was 18.7 lbm/gal [2240 kg/m 3 ]. A fracture gradient close to the pore pressure resulted in drilling-uid losses across the weaker zones. The operator decided to run and cement 18 Oileld Review 4. Bioaccumulation is the enrichment of a substance in an organism, such as bioconcentration fromexposure to the substance in the environment or uptake fromthe food chain. 5. For more on CemCADE software: Fraser L, Stanger B, Grifn T, J abri M, Sones G, Steelman M and Valk P: Seamless Fluids Programs: A Key to Better Well Construction, Oileld Review 8, no. 2 (Summer 1996): 4256. 6. A Binghamplastic model is a two-parameter rheological model widely used in the drilling-uids industry to describe ow characteristics of many types of uids. Fluids obeying this model exhibit a linear shear-stress, shear-rate behavior after an initial shear-stress threshold has been reached. A Herschel-Bulkley uid can be described mathematically by a three-parameter rheologi- cal model. The Herschel-Bulkley equation is preferred to power-law or Binghamrelationships because it results in more accurate models of rheological behavior when adequate experimental data are available. A power-law uid is described by a two-parameter rheological model of a pseudoplastic uid, or a uid whose viscosity decreases as shear rate increases. Water-base polymer muds, especially those made with XC polymer, t the power-law mathematical equation better than the Binghamplastic or other two-parameter models. 7. Primary cementing operations may involve as many as four slurries, but jobs with two slurries, known as the lead slurry and the tail slurry, are more common. Lead refers to the rst slurry pumped during primary cementing operations. Tail refers to the last slurry pumped during primary cementing operations. Typically, the tail slurry covers the pay zone and is denser than the lead slurry. 8. Bonett A and Patis D: Getting to the Root of Gas Migration, Oileld Review 8, no. 1 (Spring 1996): 3649. 9. For more on the Tampen operations: Bjelland B, Hansen K and Abbas R: Tampen Planning Gets Concrete Results, Harts E&P 75, no. 8 (August 2002): 7072. Static mud layer Flowing fluid Laminar Flow Turbulent Flow > Mud-removal ow dynamics. In laminar ow (left), ow lines are parallel and individual parti- cles move in parallel paths. Mud particles tend to accumulate near the borehole wall, making complete mud removal difcult. In turbulent ow (right), the energetic, swirling eddies entrain more mud particles than laminar owpaths before becoming saturated. The turbulent eddies also move surfactants or dispersants in the chemical wash or spacer uid throughout the borehole to deform and remove the static mud layer at the borehole wall. Autumn 2002 19 a liner, and required an optimized spacer uid on short notice. Typically, designing the spacer for this situa- tion would require a lengthy laboratory process. However, the WELLCLEAN II Advisor software quickly optimized the spacer design using actual well conditions and uid properties. The liner was cemented successfully, and the operator beneted from the efcient process to design an effective spacer for such difcult conditions. There were no indications that any cement was lost during operations. In ordinary cementing operations, the spacer may be followed by multiple cement slurries. 7 The preush-spacer-cement series must displace all uids from the annulus to prevent develop- ment of mud or spacer channels within the cement sheath. 8 Such channels may allow unde- sirable formation-uid migration. The presence of mud also can induce shrinkage cracks, reduce compressive strength or increase permeability, any of which can negatively affect set-cement properties. Once the slurry is pumped, a mechan- ical plug is launched into the casing and displaced to the bottom of the well by another uid, usually the drilling uid needed to drill the next section of hole. At the end of the operation, cement occupies the annular space between the casing and the penetrated formation from the bottom of the hole up to the desired level. Effective mud removal, a crucial part of any cementing operation, cannot be achieved without considering the effects of all relevant parameters. WELLCLEAN II Engineering Solution technology makes use of innovative products and tools to improve cement placement. Together, these optimized chemical-wash systems, custom spacers, innovative software and a testing methodology to evaluate the effectiveness of preushes in displacing drilling uids all enhance mud removal and zonal isolation. Mud Removal in Action In the mature offshore region of Tampen, Norway, Norsk Hydro engineers are increasing oil production by improving zonal isolation with WELLCLEAN II technology. 9 Although the subsi- dence, compaction and high downhole stresses that are common in this area could cause cement failure, engineers suspected that uid channels within the cement were their most signicant problems. These uid channels probably were caused by poor cement placement in wells that were highly deviated to horizontal. WELLCLEAN II simulator results agreed with the cement logs, indicating intermixing of fluids throughout the liner length and poor cement coverage of the annulus. The WELLCLEAN II simulator software is a powerful, two-dimensional numerical-simulation tool for showing critical results such as the percentage of cement coverage, the uid concen- trations, the risk of having a mud lm or channel at the end of the cement job, and the turbulent contact timeall as a function of depth and time. The simulator accounts for such parameters as well geometry and trajectory, downhole uid properties and volumes, pump rates and casing centralization. The simulator then predicts the efciency of mud removal and assesses the likelihood of a mud channel being left in the cement. The simulations are presented as two- dimensional maps that show uid positions and concentrations, uid velocity and ow regime. Animations of the simulations show the entire uid-displacement process for a job. > Optimizing spacer designs. WELLCLEAN II Engineering Solution Advisor software simplies and speeds spacer design. WELLCLEAN II simulator predictions have been validated both by physical laboratory experiments and eld performance. Cementing engineers may use these simulations to alter their designs to optimize zonal isolation. For example, the simulator helps engineers choose between turbulent or laminar ow regimes, or decide how to avoid detrimental contact between drilling mud and cement during pump- ing operations. To improve zonal isolation in a Tampen area well during 2001, Norsk Hydro engineers selected an innovative preush system with low-toxicity spacers, more complete biodegradation and lower bioaccumulation than other systems. The new well was horizontal, similar to previous prob- lematic wells. Additional centralizers were placed to improve standoff and cement distribution around the casing. Output from the CemCADE software showed that the additional centralizers would not lead to excessive running forces, which are an indication of the potential for the casing to become stuck as it is run into the wellbore. Norsk Hydro also wanted to improve the mechanical properties of the cement system. Norsk Hydro engineers selected CemCRETE concrete-based oilwell cementing technology a system with a high solid-fraction, high plastic viscosity, low permeability and low porosity. 10 Simulations indicated that no formations would be fractured using a 14-lbm/gal [1679-kg/m 3 ] CemCRETE slurry-system blend. Also, 300 bbl [48 m 3 ] of fresh mud at a relatively lower density and viscosity would be pumped to dilute the mud in the hole and reduce its gel strength. Prior to the operation, simulations predicted that the modied design would improve mud removal signicantly. In addition to predicting cement coverage of greater than 95% over the majority of the production-liner length, simulator data indicated no risk of leaving mud behind the cement. The cementing operation was executed successfully. Cement-bond logs of the 7-in. liner demonstrated that the results were superior to 20 Oileld Review Raw Acoustic Impedance Cement Map with Impedance Classification Minimum of Acoustic Impedance Mrayl 10 0 Average of Acoustic Impedance Mrayl 10 0 Maximum of Acoustic Impedance Liquid Bonded Microdebonding Mrayl 10 0 -500.0000 0.3125 0.6250 0.9375 1.2500 1.5625 1.8750 2.1875 2.5000 2.8125 3.1250 3.4375 4.0625 4.3750 4.6875 5.0000 -500.0000 0.3125 0.6250 0.9375 1.2500 1.5625 1.8750 2.1875 2.5000 2.8125 3.1250 3.4375 4.0625 4.3750 4.6875 5.0000 Liquid Gas or Dry Microannulus Gas or Dry Microannulus Bonded Raw Acoustic Impedance Cement Map with Impedance Classification Microdebonding -1000.0 -500.0 0.3 2.6 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 -1000.0 -500.0 0.3 2.6 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 > Improving bonding in horizontal wells in Norway. Ordinary spacer designs resulted in inadequate cement bonding, as shown in the cement-evaluation log at left. In particular, there is a dearth of yellow, or bonded, section in Track 2. More effective cement-job designs, including more complete mud removal using MUDPUSH II spacers, resulted in improved bond, as shown in the abundant yellow section in Track 3 (right). Autumn 2002 21 those from previous cementing jobsexcellent bonding and no indication of any uid channels (previous page). Since then, additional wells have been completed successfully in Tampen using this improved methodology, and more are planned during 2002. In the Gulf of Mexico, achieving effective zonal isolation was crucial for five costly extended-reach wells with an oil-water contact in the hydrocarbon-bearing zone. Adequate cement- to-casing and cement-to-formation bonding within these pay sands had proven challenging; good bonding existed only across shale sections. Any new cement-job designs would have to accommodate well deviations up to 77 degrees, synthetic-base drilling mud and gas inux from the formation. Failure to isolate the water zones within the pay sand resulted in lower oil produc- tion and additional disposal costs for produced water. ChevronTexaco spent as much as $200,000 per well for squeeze-cementing operations and rig time to repair awed primary cement jobs in three of the ve wells. With the aid of the WELLCLEAN II simulator package, CemCADE software and the while- drilling acquisition of caliper logs using the VDN VISION Density Neutron tool, Schlumberger engineers were able to alter design parameters to improve mud removal. 11 The engineers consid- ered the acquisition of caliper data particularly important because previous job designs depended on assumptions about hole shape and volumeparameters that signicantly inuence mud removal and predictions of the required slurry volume. CemCADE results led to changes in centralizer placement, spacer uids, cement- slurry properties, uid volumes and pumping rates. The cement slurry incorporated the GASBLOK gas migration control cement system and an expanding agent. These additives eliminate gas influx from the formation, control fluid loss to the formation and minimize bulk-volume reduction during cement placement and setting. The upgraded job designs and uids greatly improved zonal isolation in the next three wells. Outputs from the WELLCLEAN II simulator pro- gram were in complete agreement with the cement-evaluation logs (right). The three new wells did not produce water and did not require remedial cementing operations. Elsewhere in the 10. For an introduction to CemCRETE technology: Boisnault et al, reference 3. 11. The VDN device provides compensated neutron and azimuthal lithodensity measurements while drilling. The resulting density image also enables structural analysis. Discriminated CCL 0 3 100 -1 API V Gamma Ray 0 360 degrees SCMT Relative Bearing 0 100 mV 200 1 . 2 5 2 . 5 0 3 . 7 5 5 . 0 0 6 . 2 5 7 . 5 0 8 . 7 5 1 0 . 0 0 1 1 . 2 5 1 2 . 5 0 1 3 . 7 5 1 5 . 0 0 1 6 . 2 5 1 7 . 5 0 1 8 . 7 5 2 0 . 0 0 1200 s Cement Map Image Min Max Amplitude CBT 5-ft Variable Density CBT 3-ft Amplitude 0 10 mV Amplified CBT 3-ft Amplitude 0 100 API CBT 3-ft Transit Time 11,800 11,900 12,000 12,100 12,200 12,300 D e p t h ,
f t 12,400 12,500 W i d e Mud Tail CW100 MUDPUSH WHTO N a r r o w W i d e 12,600 12,700 12,800 12,900 11,800 11,900 12,000 12,100 12,200 12,300 D e p t h ,
f t 12,400 12,500 W i d e High Medium Low None N a r r o w W i d e 12,600 12,700 12,800 12,900 Fluids Concentration Map Risk of Mud on the Wall 12,000 12,100 > Improving mud removal in the Gulf of Mexico. WELLCLEAN II simulator results (top) indicated that changes in centralizer placement, spacer uids, cement-slurry properties, uid volumes and pumping rates would improve mud removal and primary cementing. The simulated cement map at left indicates a high concentration of cement (gray) around the wellbore; the green area in the simulation indicates complete mud removal. The cement map in Track 5 of the SCMT Slim Cement Mapping Tool log (bottom) conrms excellent cement placement around the casing. The Variable Density display in Track 4 shows good cement bonding. Gulf of Mexico, WELLCLEAN II Engineering Solution results have improved primary cement- ing (right). The Role of Advanced Cementing Technology Mud removal plays a crucial role in the success of cementing operations, but the selection of an appropriate type of cement also is critical. Since the rst primary cementing operation in 1903, service companies have developed many types of oil- and gas-well cements to address the extremes of subsurface conditions. 12 Cement sys- tems must withstand the effects of subsurface pressures, temperatures and formation uids to provide lasting zonal isolation. Even when a conventional slurry is properly placed and initially provides adequate zonal iso- lation, changes in downhole conditions can induce stresses that compromise the integrity of the cement sheath. Tectonic stresses and large increases in wellbore pressure or temperature can crack the sheath, and can even reduce it to rubble. Radial displacement of casing, caused by cement bulk shrinkage or temperature or pres- sure decreases, can cause the cement to debond from the casing or formation and create a microannulus. 13 Decreases in uid weight during drilling and completion also cause debonding. Routine well-completion operations, including perforating and hydraulic fracturing, negatively affect the cement sheath. 14 The most recent advance, CemSTONE advanced cementing technology systems, pro- vides reliable, long-term zonal isolation despite changing downhole conditions. These systems have predictable set-cement properties, such as exibility, expansion and impact resistance after setting, so they can be designed to withstand stresses that would destroy ordinary cements. Proprietary additives and proven, engineered- particle blends in CemSTONE systems meet specic mechanical-property requirements, such as elasticity, expandability, compressive and ten- sile strength, durability and impact resistance. Like CemCRETE slurries, the particle-size distri- butions of CemSTONE systems make them easy to mix and pump. The cement integrity achieved routinely with CemSTONE systems helps cut maintenance costs, ensures isolation for stimulation treatments, reduces the possibility of annular pressure during the producing life of gas wells, and extends the productive life of steamood wells and wells in tectonically active areas. This high degree of cement integrity also improves isolation for multilateral junctions, saves time and reduces 22 Oileld Review 56 Cement coverage, % 60 64 68 72 76 Original Job Without Optimization Wide Narrow Wide Fluids concentration map Mud Spacer Cement 22,000 23,000 24,000 D e p t h ,
f t D e p t h ,
f t Wide Narrow Wide Risk of mud on the wall High None 70 Cement coverage, % 80 90 100 22,000 23,000 24,000 Wide Narrow Wide High None Optimized Job Using WELLCLEAN II Simulator Software Wide Narrow Wide Mud Spacer Cement Fluids concentration map Risk of mud on the wall Cement coverage, % 60 80 100 Fluids concentration map CBT log Variable Density log Wide Narrow Wide D e p t h ,
f t 23,600 23,540 23,480 23,420 Diesel Chemical wash Spacer Cement > More mud-removal success in the Gulf of Mexico. In another part of the Gulf of Mexico, simulation of initial design plans with the WELLCLEAN II simulator package indicated a mud channel was likely to form in the cement sheath (top). After optimizing centralizer placement, spacer and slurry properties, and displacement rates and volumes, the simulator demonstrated that the new job design would avoid channel formation (middle). Cement-evaluation logs conrm improved zonal isolation (bottom). Autumn 2002 23 difculty in setting mechanical whipstocks, and eliminates cement sloughing behind casing when opening windows and drilling out in incompetent formations (see New Aspects of Multilateral Well Construction, page 52). There are two types of CemSTONE technol- ogy in use now, DuraSTONE advanced durable cement technology and FlexSTONE advanced exible cement technology systems. Each system combines specially sized particles with special material, resulting in a cement system that offers enhanced flexibility and durability. As of September 2002, more than 90 FlexSTONE sys- tems and 25 DuraSTONE systems have been pumped worldwide to combat a wide variety of operational challenges. Designed for multilateral junctions, kickoff plugs and wells requiring impact-resistant cement, DuraSTONE systems blend engineered particles of different sizes with high-strength metallic microribbon technology. The result is a set cement that is two to three times tougher and has impact resistance up to 20 times higher than ordinary Portland cements. In Abu Dhabi, UAE, DuraSTONE cement plugs have substantially improved kickoff success rates in more than 20 jobs to date. 15 The improvements included reduced time required to achieve kickoff and an increase in the success rate of kickoff plugs because DuraSTONE plugs are so difcult to drill. FlexSTONE systems combine the engineered particle-size distribution of CemCRETE systems with exible particles that accommodate wide ranges of temperature, pressure and uid den- sity. These special particles lower the Youngs modulus, increasing the exibility of the set cement (right). 16 When expansion is desirable, these systems can be designed to produce as much as 3% linear expansion after full cement hydration; ordinary expanding cement systems allow less than 1% linear expansion. Improved mechanical properties make FlexSTONE systems ideal for wells in steamoods and tectonically active regions. Formation properties play a critical role in the performance of wellbore cements. Optimizing the relationship between the mechanical properties of the formation and the mechanical properties of the cement sheath is a requirement for long- term cement integrity during pressure changes, temperature changes or cement expansion. Because it is not possible to alter the properties of the formation, engineers instead must manipu- late the mechanical properties of the set cement to achieve the correct combination of exibility and expansion. FlexSTONE technology and care- ful cement-job design make this possible. A new two-dimensional modeling package helps engineers simulate the behavior of the cement sheath in different pressure and tem- perature regimes and wellbore congurations. The software inputs include well conguration, points of interest, cement properties, formation properties and casing properties. The software combines this information with a database of cement properties to generate an optimized cement design. Known as the Stress Analysis Model (SAM), the software calculates the properties necessary for the cement to main- tain integrity and detects risks of cracking in tension, rupture in compression or formation of a microannulus. 12. Smith RC: Preface, in Nelson EB: Well Cementing. Sugar Land, Texas, USA: Schlumberger Dowell (1990): 16. 13. For more on cement bulk shrinkage: Thiercelin M, Baumgarte C and Guillot D: A Soil Mechanics Approach to Predict Cement Sheath Behavior, paper SPE/ISRM 47375, presented at the 1998 SPE/ISRM Eurock, Trondheim, Norway, J uly 810, 1998. 14. For more on cement mechanical response to downhole stress: Thiercelin MJ , Dargaud B, Baret J F and Rodriguez WJ : Cement Design Based on Cement Mechanical Response, paper SPE 38598, presented at the 1997 SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, San Antonio, Texas, USA, October 58, 1997. 15. For more on DuraSTONE kickoff plugs: Al-Suwaidi A, Hun C, Babasheikh A and CunninghamE: Cement Aids Challenging Sidetracks, Harts E&P 75, no. 2 (February 2002): 5153. 16. Le Roy-Delage S, Baumgarte C, Thiercelin M and Vidick B: New Cement Systems for Durable Zonal Isolation, paper IADC/SPE 59132, presented at the 2000 IADC/SPE Drilling Conference, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA, February 2325, 2000. F F F F r l l r l l Poissons ratio v = l r A x i a l
s t r e s s
F
( t e n s i o n ) Axial strain l (tension) Youngs modulus (e) Tensile strength Axial strain Axial stress e = > Cement properties. Youngs modulus describes the relationship between stress and strain in a uniaxial stress test (top). For cement, the lower the Youngs modulus, the more exible the cement is. Poissons ratio is the ratio of transverse strain (r) to axial strain (l) (bottom). Tensile deformation is considered positive, and compressive deformation is considered negative. The denition of Poissons ratio contains a minus sign so that ordinary materials have a positive ratio, ordinarily between 0.15 and 0.25 for cement. Tensile strength refers to the ability of material to be stretched before rupturing. Isolating Depleted from Productive Formations Isolating formations with widely varying pres- sures is challenging but imperative. In The Netherlands, Nederlandse Aardolie Maatschappij B.V. (NAM, a joint venture of Shell and Exxon) wrestled with the difficulty of isolating the depleted Zechstein 2 carbonate formation from the producing Limburg formation. Fracture stimulation of the Limburg presents an additional challenge to maintaining the integrity of the cement sheath. The Coevorden-57 well, located onshore in the northeastern Netherlands, deviates as much as 64 degrees from vertical on its way to a mea- sured depth of 3998 m [13,117 ft] in the Limburg sandstone (below left). Critical elements for suc- cessful cementing of the 4 1 2-in. liner included complete mud removal and a cement system that would withstand the pressure increase during a hydraulic-fracturing operation while maintaining long-term isolation of formations with distinct reservoir pressures. Casing centralizers were placed such that there were three centralizers for every two casing joints from 3386 to 3923 m [11,109 to 12,871 ft] and two centralizers per joint of casing from 3924 to 3998 m [12,874 to 13,117 ft]. This centralizer placement ensured that cement would surround the casing even in highly devi- ated sections where casing tends to lie on the low side of the borehole. The cement would extend from total depth to 150 m [492 ft] above the top of the liner hanger located at a depth of 3372 m [11,063 ft]. Cementing engineers used the WELLCLEAN II simulator and CemCADE software to optimize the job design (next page). At the beginning of the operation, 20 bbl [3.18 m 3 ] of fresh mud would be pumped to begin cleaning the hole. MUDPUSH spacer would follow the mud to provide addi- tional hole cleaning and to prevent the drilling uid from contaminating the cement slurry. This displacement train would be followed by 1.63 g/cm 3 [13.6 lbm/gal] FlexSTONE slurry, the rst application of FlexSTONE technology in Europe. The SCMT device was used to evaluate the cement bond following the job and conrmed excellent cement-casing and cement-formation bonding (below right). The SCMT device is a mul- tisensor cement-logging tool that produces a 360 map image of the cement. 24 Oileld Review Surface Depth, m North Sea Group Chalk Group Rijnland Altena Keuper Zechstein Limburg 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 13 3 8-in. casing 9 5 8-in. casing 4 1 2-in. liner 7-in. liner Coevorden THE NETHERLANDS BELGIUM GERMANY FRANCE N o r t h S e a 0 50 100 150 miles 0 80 160 240 km > Location of the Coevorden-57 well, The Netherlands. The Coevorden-57 well penetrates depleted Zechstein carbonate rocks and produc- tive Limburg reservoir, as shown in the cross section. Permanently isolating these formations from each other in a deviated, fracture-stimulated well is challenging. > FlexSTONE evaluation in The Netherlands. The SCMT log shows excellent results, with map amplitudes (long dashes in Track 3) ranging from 3 to 10 mV, which indicates excellent bonding between the cement and casing. The Vari- able Density display (Track 4) shows strong formation arrivals, which demon- strate good bond between the formation and cement. Amplitude Variable Density Cement Map Image mV s Min Max 200 1200 Minimum Map Amplitude mV 0 100 Amplitude Gamma Ray Discriminated CCL V 3 -1 API 0 150 CBT Amplitude mV 0 100 Relative Bearing degrees 0 360 Maximum Map Amplitude mV 0 1000 CBT 3-ft. Transit Time s 100 600 Average Map Amplitude mV 0 100 Minimum Map Transit Time s 100 600 CBT Amplitude mV 0 10 Maximum Map Transit Time s 100 600 1 .2 5 2 .5 0 3 .7 5 5 .0 0 6 .2 5 7 .5 0 8 .7 5 1 0 .0 0 1 1 .2 5 1 2 .5 0 1 3 .7 5 1 5 .0 0 1 6 .2 5 1 7 .5 0 1 8 .7 5 2 0 .0 0 Autumn 2002 25 1 2 3 4 5 6 > Simulation of uid-pumping sequence for the Coevorden-57 well. WELLCLEAN II simulator runs helped optimize uid selections and the pumping schedule for the Coevorden-57 well. In all illustra- tions, each pair of illustrations from the simulator shows the effectiveness of mud removal (right) and predicts cement distribution (left). In all illustrations of uid concentrations, brown represents drilling uid, blue is chemical wash, green is MUDPUSH spacer and gray is FlexSTONE slurry. In the nal illustration (6), the simulator predicts that all other drilling uids will have been removed and that FlexSTONE slurry will completely cover the wellbore wall, results that were conrmed by the well logs. Cementing Wells for Steamooding In northeastern Alberta, Canada, EnCana Corporation is constructing the rst phase of its Christina Lake Thermal Project (right). This venture currently is expected to produce more than 70,000 barrels per day [11,123 m 3 /d] of bitumen from the Athabasca oil sands in the Cretaceous-age McMurray formation using steam-assisted gravity drainage (SAGD). The rst phase of the project will allow the company to evaluate SAGD performance and ow barriers within the reservoir. This information will help the company optimize well designs, well place- ment and uid recovery in subsequent phases of the project. 17 SAGD is an emerging technology that is sim- ple in concept but complex in application (see Heavy-Oil Reservoirs, page 30). SAGD wells are drilled in pairs. The wells are parallel to each other, with anywhere from 20 to 200 m [66 to 656 ft] of separation between the horizontal reservoir sections of the wellbores (below right). The upper horizontal well is used to inject steam. The heat from the injected steam allows the thick crude to ow more freely, with the assistance of gravity, to the lower producing well. A awless primary cement sheath is critical for SAGD success. Annular gas inux as the cement sets can result in steam breakthrough. SAGD wells typically experience thermal expan- sion and contraction of the wellbore, which can lead to cement failure. When cement failure occurs, the operator must choose between expensive remedial efforts with unpredictable results or well abandonment. EnCana sought to improve the quality of the primary cement so that it would not confront either steam breakthrough or cement failure. 26 Oileld Review 17. For more on the Christina Lake Thermal Project: Suggett J , Gittins S and Youn S: Christina Lake Thermal Project, paper SPE/PetroleumSociety of CIM 65520, presented at the 2000 SPE/PetroleumSociety of CIM International Conference on Horizontal Well Technology, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, November 68, 2000. 18. For more on SAM simulations: Stiles D and Hollies D: Implementation of Advanced Cementing Techniques to Improve Long TermZonal Isolation in SteamAssisted Gravity Drainage Wells, paper SPE/PetroleumSociety of CIM/CHOA 78950, presented at the 2002 SPE International Thermal Operations and Heavy Oil Symposiumand International Horizontal Well Technology Conference, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, November 47, 2002. 19. GASBLOK systems control annular gas migration while cementing. These systems include a nonretarding liquid that provides uid-loss control and gas-migration control properties for cement slurries at temperatures from80 to 160F [27 to 71C] across a wide range of densitiesas low as 10.5 lbm/gal [1258 kg/m 3 ]. The GASBLOK additive is a suspension of polymeric microgels that act as uid- loss reducers by rapidly plugging the pore throats of the cement lter cake. The microgels in the interstitial water of the cement matrix reduce cement-matrix permeability and decrease the continuity between pores during the critical liquid-to-solid transition phase, further limiting gas migration. 20. Although CSLs support both cementing and stimulation, this article focuses on their role in cementing. C A NA D A ALBERTA Christina Lake 0 0 400 800 1200 1600 km 200 400 600 800 1000 miles > Location of Christina Lake Thermal Project, Alberta, Canada. Lead top of cement at surface 13 3 8-in. surface casing to +/ 175 m TVD Flexible tail top of cement at +/ 250 m MD Kickoff point at +/ 200 m 7-in. slotted liner +/ 750 m horizontal 9 5 8-in. intermediate casing to +/ 590 m TVD > Typical SAGD well pair. Conventional cement protects the 13 3 8-in. surface casing, which is set 175 m [574 ft] deep. The intermediate section, where the well builds angle from vertical to horizontal, extends to 590 m [1936 ft] and presents mud-removal and cementing challenges. The 9 5 8-in. casing is cemented with a LiteCRETE lead slurry that provides a low density and high compressive strength. A FlexSTONE tail slurry provides exibility across most of the openhole and maintains zonal isolation across the 9 5 8-in. casing shoe. The FlexSTONE systems pumped at Christina Lake were mixed on sitethe rst location in the world to do so. Below the 9 5 8-in. shoe, the 8 3 4-in. horizontal section extends 750 m [2461 ft] across the reservoir, which is 20 to 58 m [66 to 190 ft] thick. The wells are then completed with an uncemented, slotted liner for sand control. Autumn 2002 27 Engineers used the SAM software to evaluate potential for cement failure from com- pression, tension or formation of a microannulus, and to design the best possible slurry for the Christina Lake SAGD wells. SAM simulations indicated that thermally stabilized Class G Portland cement would suffer tensile failure when exposed to the 14 to 260C [57 to 500F] temperatures predicted for the SAGD wells. 18 Another SAM simulation, incorporating the same temperature, pressure, time and other conditions used in the previous simulation, demonstrated that a exible cement system would not experi- ence tensile failure. In the Christina Lake area, three pairs of wells have been cemented using a combination of LiteCRETE lead slurry and FlexSTONE tail slurry. EnCana selected FlexSTONE systems because of their superior mechanical properties, particularly their capability to survive the thermal expansion of the casing and the cement sheath. To counter shallow-gas migration problems typical of west- ern Canada, the LiteCRETE and FlexSTONE systems incorporated GASBLOK technology. 19 The LiteCRETE lead system typically is placed from 250 m [820 ft] to surface. The FlexSTONE tail system is pumped from approximately 590 m [1936 ft] up to 250 m. Cement logs of the six SAGD wells indicated good bond across the zones considered critical for reservoir isolation. During a workover opera- tion on one of the wells, the slotted liner was removed and the USI UltraSonic Imager tool and the CBT Cement Bond Tool device were run to evaluate the isolation quality of the cement following steam exposure (above). The log indi- cates no degradation of cement quality and strong formation-cement and cement-casing bonds. There are no indications of gas migration or casing-vent ows to surface. Another SAGD well pair is planned during the last quarter of 2002 to complete Phase I of the Christina Lake project. The Role of Client Support Laboratories in Well Cementing Successful implementation of new cementing technology depends heavily on an international network of cementing specialists. Schlumberger operates Client Support Laboratories (CSLs) in Houston, Texas, USA; Aberdeen, Scotland; and Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. 20 The CSLs form an essential link between product development and eld operations by supporting the intro- duction of new technology, assisting in training eld personnel and providing feedback during product development. Whenever possible, CSLs undertake short-term projects so that the product centers can concentrate on longer term activities. CSL staff work with the Schlumberger GeoMarket organization to support bid or tender processes for E&P companies and collaborative product-development opportunities. All this results in higher quality products and services in addition to t-for-purpose innovations. Typical CSL projects involve low-cost develop- ments, but some projects have been established to support alliances. Customers often initiate short-term projects to meet their specic techni- cal or environmental requirements. Many of these involve collaboration with regional product suppliers to match readily available products with specic operator requirements. To support eld operations, all CSLs are equipped to follow standard procedures outlined by the American Petroleum Institute (API) to conduct extensive formulation studies. These procedures include quality assurance and quality control of cement, uid-compatibility tests, and measurements such as thickening time, compres- sive strength, uid loss and free water under the pressure and temperature conditions found in the Discriminated Bond Index Sonic Variable Density Curve Amplitude 0 1 Mrayl 10 0 mm 122 92 mm 92 122 mm Tool Eccentricity Internal Radius Average mm 92 122 Internal Radius Maximum mm 92 122 External Radius Average mm 92 122 Internal Radius Minimum mm 122 92 Internal Radius Average mm 122 92 Internal Radius Maximum mm 122 92 Internal Radius Minimum External Radius Average Amplitude of Echo Minus Max Average of Acoustic Impedance dB/m 50 0 mm 13 3 dB/m 50 0 Discriminated Attenuation Cement Map with Impedance Classification -0 1 s 1200 200 Max Min -500.0 -1000.0 -500.0 0.3 2.6 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 0.5 -0.4 -0.8 -1.2 -1.6 -2.0 -2.4 -2.8 -4.8 -5.2 -5.6 -6.0 -3.2 -3.6 -4.0 -4.4 API Gamma Ray 100 0 mm Casing Collar Locator Process Flags 10 1 0.5000 1.5000 2.5000 3.5000 6.5000 dB/m 50 0 Near Pseudo- Attenuation Short Pseudo- Attenuation Average of Thickness Microdebonding Gas or Dry Microannulus Liquid Bonded < Cement evaluation in a steamood well. The USI UltraSonic Imager tool and the CBT Cement Bond Tool device were run to evaluate the isolation quality of the cement following steam expo- sure. The log indicates no degradation of cement quality and strong formation- cement and cement- casing bonds. subsurface (above left). Equipment exists to sim- ulate virtually all downhole cementing conditions by applying high temperatures and pressures to cement slurries. Evaluation of slurry performance under dynamic, downhole conditions ensures that the slurry will remain uid until properly placed in the wellbore (above right). Technology transfer is a key function for the CSLs because disseminating the lessons they learn also helps the worldwide network of approximately 100 area and district laboratories improve their operations. While many courses offered by the CSLs are designed for Schlumberger engineers, some courses are offered to customers. CSLs also evaluate new equipment and techniques before these are deployed locally. For example, the Houston CSL participates in the design of all FlexSTONE sys- tems pumped in North and South America. The Houston CSL provides technical training, new-technology implementation and cementing support for international eld operations and clients in North and South America. The labora- tory completes short-term engineering projects on request from clients and develops specic solutions for local problems. Recently, cementing experts from the Houston CSL and the Schlumberger Riboud Product Centre, Clamart, France, developed the DeepCEM deepwater cementing liquid-additive package for worldwide application. This technology, which includes a nonretarding dispersant and a cement-set enhancer, has proven to be an optimal solution for cementing shallow strings in deep water. It has been implemented successfully in deepwater markets around the world. The CSL offers a basic laboratory course, an advanced service module for cementing, new technology introductions at training courses in the Kellyville Training Center, Oklahoma, USA, and training for nonspecialists. Due to its location, equipment and proximity to oileld product suppliers, the Houston CSL plays a vital role supporting international operations for Houston-based companies. The Houston CSL also has specialized labora- tory equipment for cement-slurry design and performance evaluation over a wide range of temperatures and pressures35 to 600F [2 to 316C] and up to 40,000 psi [276 MPa]. Recently, the Houston CSL acquired a twin-cell ultrasonic cement analyzer (next page, left). Other recent equipment acquisitions include the uid-migration analyzer and the high-pressure, high-temperature (HPHT) rheometer (next page, right). The HPHT rheometer helps evaluate uid performance over a wide range of downhole conditions to ensure opti- mal mud removal under extreme conditions. Supporting operations in a region extending through eastern Africa, the Middle East and Asia, the CSL in Kuala Lumpur covers the broadest terri- tory of the three CSLs. Typical projects at the Kuala Lumpur facility include high- and low-temperature cementing-uids testing, compatibility testing and uid mixingall to API specications. Recent pro- jects include FlexSTONE system designs for the Middle East, high-pressure LiteCRETE systems for China, geothermal well cementing and a low- density, saline DeepCRETE deepwater cementing system used in India, with a density of 10 lbm/gal [1198 kg/m 3 ]. Because the Kuala Lumpur CSL sup- ports more than 23 eld laboratories serving 35 countries, the training of laboratory engineers and technicians is a signicant activity. 28 Oileld Review > Predicting cement performance. The consis- tometer shown here has a wide pressure and temperature operating rangeup to 22,000 psi [150 MPa] and 400F [204C]. This unit, located in the Houston CSL, can be attached to a chiller for controlled cooling. Other consistometers at this facility can achieve higher temperatures and pressures. The CSLs in Aberdeen and Kuala Lumpur also have consistometers. > Analyzing uid migration. Liquid or gas migra- tion through hydrating cement slurries is a major cause of well-completion failures. The uid- migration analyzer shown here offers state-of- the art data acquisition and analysis and can run the test cell at any angle to simulate wellbore deviation. This device, located in the Houston CSL, can measure uid loss through standard screens or actual rock core samples. Data dis- play and analyses are enhanced by capture of more than a dozen data channels, including absolute and differential pressures, gas and liquid ows, and temperature. Autumn 2002 29 The Aberdeen CSL offers client support and testing similar to the Houston and Kuala Lumpur facilities, and participates extensively in training activities. The Aberdeen facility supports Europe, the CIS and western Africa. Its work in the North Sea offers many challenges and opportunities to achieve environmentally friendly solutions in the worlds most demanding regulatory environment. In Norway, for example, all oileld chemicals must be biodegradable, so the Aberdeen CSL helped develop biodegradable antifoam agents, surfactants and retarders. For other areas, this center has supported introduction of specialized cementing technology, such as FlexSTONE, LiteCRETE and DeepCRETE technologies. Quality control of cement-slurry additives, novel blend- performance optimization and development of new, customized cement additives for local cus- tomers are key functions of the Aberdeen CSL. The Aberdeen CSL also offers training in proper use and calibration of equipment and testing pro- cedures. Basic and advanced courses are offered several times each year, and personalized training is offered when appropriate, particularly for the introduction of new technology. For example, eld engineers might be offered specialized training when their district acquires new equipment. The Aberdeen CSL also performs regular audits of testing procedures and results. For these audits, each district performs specic tests, which are checked for consistency of results. While the three CSLs have different capabili- ties and slightly different focuses, they share the goals of continually improving service quality, transferring and supporting technology, and training personnel to better serve customers. The CSL leaders meet twice each year with the cementing product-development group at the Schlumberger Riboud Product Centre. These meetings allow cementing practitioners from around the world to present current eld pro- jects, discuss pressing needs, exchange ideas about implementation of new technology and provide input to current and future research and development projects. Improving Zonal Isolation at the Outset In a future dominated by development of mature, or brown, elds, operating companies will need to produce oil and gas more efciently and with better economic returns than ever before. Each well plays a crucial role in this business environ- ment. Each operation, whether it is the actual drilling of the well, mud removal, cementing, stimulation or any other, plays a key role in well performance: every operation must be successful at the outset to avoid costly remediation. As the examples in this article demonstrate, judicious implementation of new technology solves problems that were too expensive or technically demanding to overcome with older technology. Operators are committed to eliminating problems such as sustained casing pressure whenever pos- sible, in many cases by devoting more attention to mud removal and cementing-system optimization in the earliest stages of well design. Schlumberger continues to support technology development to assure unprecedented product effectiveness and competence in eld operations. With innovations that complement existing prod- ucts and services, ultraefcient technologies will abound to tackle the tough brown-eld reservoirs of the coming years. GMG > Evaluating cement-strength development. This twin-cell ultrasonic cement analyzer provides nondestructive determination of cement-strength development as samples cure under downhole temperature and pressure conditions. The device measures the change in velocity of ultrasonic signals transmitted through the cement specimens as they harden. As the strength of the cement specimen increases, the transit time of the ultra- sonic signal through the sample decreases. The relative strength of the cement is then calcu- lated using proprietary empirical algorithms. > Measuring rheological properties. This HPHT rheometer, located in the Houston CSL, offers broad viscosity measurement capability due to the wide range of the torque (shear stress) transducer and the extended motor speed (shear rate). This allows the measurement of the rheological properties of a variety of different uids with pressure and temperature limits of 20,000 psi [138 MPa] and 450F [232C]. For well cementing, it is crucial to understand the rheo- logical properties at downhole pressure and temperature conditions to correctly place the cement without jeopardizing well integrity.