Dual band presentation Fabrice Robin +33 1 55 22 11 36 Fabrice.Robin@orangefrance.com Agenda Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 2 Dual-band management principles Dual-band implementation strategy Selection/Reselection principles Alcatel handover algorithm Description of the 3 main 1800 Mhz templates of Orange France QoS indicators (examples from the operational unit of Paris) Dual band network optimisation with GPRS Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 3 Dual-band management principles Dual-band implementation strategy
Ti me Traffi c densi ty initial capacity TRX addition/ Sectorisation Densification Functionalities: Concentric cells, Directed retry, FRP, ... micro-cells Band Extension: E-GSM, 1800, ... Traffic density Evolution vs Time and radio solutions Traffi c subscri bers evol uti on Network max capaci ty devel opment Capacity handling solutions Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 4 1800 layer: Field prediction & Capacity Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 5 1800 MHz frequency band usually larger than 900 MHz band > Large capacity > Frequency Planning much easier (more 1800 channels than 900 channels) 1800 channels propagation is lower than 900 MHz radio channels > Outside: 1800 field level is lower than 900 (roughly 6 dB to 10 dB ) > Indoor : seems to be better 900 coverage Dual-band versus mono-band Mobile Stations Ratio > low Dual Band MS ratio : the operator will force dual-band MS to the 1800 layer 1800 cells : Implementation Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 6 Reuse of the 900 design > 1800 cells co located with the 900 cells Try to have the same service area for 1800 and 900 cells > limited number of neighbouring declarations for the 900 and 1800 cells > for the 900 layer : reuse of the existing 900 neighbour declarations, completed by the colocated and adjacent 1800 cells Traffic balance between 1800 and 900 layers Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 7 One access layer instead of two : better traffic handling efficiency (1800 layer is the access layer) Preventing the congestion of the 900 layer => Dual band MS are directed and kept to the 1800 layer > Idle mode: selection / reselection (C2 parameter) > PBGT Hand Over 1800/1800 rather than to the 900/1800 Preventing the congestion of the 1800 layer => Directed Retry (Forced) to the 900 layer (assignation phase) Dual Band Strategy Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 8 900 Mhz layer for Coverage Existing network with very good coverage Layer to rescue 1800 Mhz emergency calls (quality, coverage reasons mainly) 1800 Mhz layer for Capacity New layer Solution to reduce the congestion of the 900 Mhz layer Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 9 Dual-band management principles Selection/Reselection principles Early Classmark Sending (Call setup) Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 10 Activation of the feature (GSM 04.08) on all BSCs and MSCs of the network > tells to the Dual Band MS that during the call set-up phase, it should send a Classmark Change just after the CM service request, containing the information of band capabilities (Classmark 3). This message is sent up to the MSC and follows the MS during all the communication inter, intra BSC and inter, intra MSC > MSCs and BSCs must know the dual band capabilities of the Dual Band MS > The support of the Classmark 3 should be set by default on all the MSCs in the network in order to authorise dual band capabilities after external HO > On all BSCs to allow later HO on the 1800 layer during the call when the MS has initiated a call on a BSC far away from the dual band area IDLE mode : accessibility of the 2 bands Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 11 With dual band, no restriction for roamers who only have mono band handset with the band not accessible Parameters to be tuned to manage the band allocation on selection or reselection : Cell reselect Offset CRO (describe on the next slide) Cell reselect hysteresis CRH (application in Orange France in the LAC border) Barred cell (inhibition of one layer, could be bad for customer, especially for roamers) Parameter : C2 (idle mode) Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 12 ! The activation of the C2 parameters (per cell) allows to favour the reselection on the 1800 cells even and while the signal strength is bellow the 900 cells: C2 = C1 + Cell_Reselect_Offset - Temporary_Offset * H(Penalty_Time-T) H(Penalty_Time-T) = 0 when T > Penalty_Time H(Penalty_Time-T) = 1 when T Penalty_Time Parameter : C2 (idle mode) Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 13 ! The C2 parameter has an effect only if the cell is part of the 6 better channels measured by the MS. ! No consideration of band preference is possible in idle mode, of course if the cell is not barred. C2 (idle mode) parameter on the 1800 cells Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 14 ! CELL_RESELECT_PARAM_IND (cell basis): lock per cell that enable the broadcast of cell reselection parameters on the BCCH of the cell (set to true). ! CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET (cell basis): set to 16 dB in Orange France (if no GPRS). 1800 macro cells are favoured of 16 dB, Orange France consider that the real value is 6 dB because the difference of propagation between 900 and 1800 is estimated to 10 dB. ! PENALTY_TIME (cell basis): set to 0 = 20s in Orange France ! TEMPORARY_OFFSET (cell basis): set to 0dB in Orange France. No penalty is applied on the 1800 macro cells ! RXLEV_ACCESS_MIN (cell basis): set to -99 dBm in Orange France for 1800. The MS can camp on the 1800 macro cell only if the C1>0 CRO values examples Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 15 In Orange France, some tests have been performed in 2002 for GPRS : With nearly 100% dual band compatible MS BSS Motorola CRH=8 dB Twin cells With CRO = 16 dB -> 50%of the call init on the 1800 layer With CRO = 18 dB -> 56%of the call init on the 1800 layer With CRO = 20 dB -> 62%of the call init on the 1800 layer In dedicated mode : Multi-band reporting Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 16 Definition : Multi_band_reporting is a per cell basis broadcast parameter on the Sys_Info5ter layer 3 message indicating how many cells of the opposite band must be measured among the 6 neighbours in the Multiband Reporting : 0 : 6 neighbours of the best signal strength 1 : the best neighbour of the non serving band,the neighbours of the serving band, the others neighbours per signal strength order 2 : the 2 best neighbours of the non serving band, the neighbours of the serving band, the others neighbours per signal strength order 3 : the 3 best neighbours of the non serving band, the neighbours of the serving band,the others neighbours per signal strength order In dedicated mode : Multi-band reporting Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 17 Orange France : Macro 900 and 900 : set to 1. Only one 1800 neighbour is sufficient to allows an HO on the 1800 layer without to compromise the 900 neighbouring resources for HO. Macro 1800 : set to 3. In order to favour the HO on the 1800 neighbours without to compromise a rescue HO on the 900 layer. Remark : during idle mode the reselection process is only applied on the 6 best neighbours measured by the mobile. Even if the reselection process intends to favour 1800 macro in reselection, it will only work when 1800 macro is among the 6 best. Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 18 Dual-band management principles Alcatel handover algorithm Alcatel Algorithms (1/5) Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 19 Handover preparation consists of 2 different phases : 1) Detection of the handover need (detection function by comparing the average values with the thresholds) 2) Determination of the target cell list (evaluation function sorts the candidate cell) Then T_filter begins : the target cell list is provided to the HO execution function All the HO causes belong to 2 categories : Emergency causes Comfort handovers Alcatel Algorithms (2/5) : Emergency causes Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 20 To differentiate the simultaneous alarms, all the causes have priorities. In the less important priority order : UL Quality (cause 2) DL Quality (cause 4) UL Level (cause 3) DL Level (cause 5) Distance (cause 6) Inner to outer for UL level (concentric cell and Single BCCH) (cause 10) Inner to outer for DL (concentric cell and Single BCCH) (cause 11) Alcatel Algorithms (3/5) : Comfort HO Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 21 Comfort Hand Over : Capture for the 1800 layer (Load of the serving cell is taken into account) (cause 21) Capture from type upper to type lower, the speed of the MS have an impact in the decision (Load of the serving cell is taking into account) (cause 14) Generalise Capture (parameters set with charge and traffic repartition) (cause 24) PBGT (Power BudGeT) (cause 12) Traffic HO (cause 23) Outer to inner UL and DL level (concentric cell) (cause 13) Forced Directed Retry (cause 20) The cause 24 is used for optimisation in Orange France. In Micro presence, the cause 20 is generalised for the Alcatel 1800 and used in optimisation on the 900 Alcatel Algorithms (4/6) : Determination of the target cell list Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 22 The potential candidates list (except for an intracell HO) are sorted by the evaluation function of the BSC In a monoband network, the cell list consists of : > All neighbouring cells in case of emergency HO > The neighbours that verify the cause in case of better cell HO In a dual band network, it is based on a hierarchical mechanism : > A cell list is received by the evaluation function > And also the prefered layer for the target cell (PREF_LAYER = none or upper or lower or upper+single) > And also the CELL_BAND_TYPE Alcatel Algorithms (5/6): Evaluation of the candidate cells Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 23 Cells keeping in the list are placed in the order described below: 1) Case of emergency HO : > Cells with CELL_LAYER_TYPE = PREF_LAYER. > Cells with growing order of PRIORITY(0,n). > Cells with CELL_BAND_TYPE = CELL_BAND_TYPE serving cell > Ranking by ORDER or GRADE. > With presence of MS in outer area, HO to the serving cell. Alcatel Algorithms (6/6): Evaluation of the candidate cells Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 24 2) Case of comfort HO : > Cells with CELL_LAYER_TYPE = PREF_LAYER. > Cells by growing order of PRIORITY(0,n). > Ranking by ORDER or GRADE. Remarks : > It is a hierarchical evaluation : First all cells with Pref_layer value. If EN_PRIORITY_ORDERING = disable, evaluation is not made by PRIORITY(0,n). The final ranking of cells is made with ORDER or GRADE. We filter finally potential neighbouring cell by level received (absolute criteria) (AV_RXLEV_NCELL(n) > RXLEVmin(n) + max (0, [MS_TXPWR_MAX(n) - P]). Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 25 Dual-band management principles Description of the 3 main 1800 Mhz templates of Orange France Dual-band management principle Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 26 Orange France has defined 3 major templates for 1800 cells: > Umbrella template > TWIN template > Single BCCH template And also : > Umbrella Macro 1800 modified to be compliant with TWIN or Single Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 27 Umbrella template for 1800 cells Umbrella characteristics 1800 900 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 28 Principle : 2 different layers : 900 and 1800 Dual Band cells have one BCCH in 900 and one in 1800 Service area of a 1800 cell may cover several 900 cells Cells can open one by one Many outgoing neighbourhoods have to be declared Umbrella characteristics TCH allocation Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 29 All the traffic is guided by assignment on the 1800 layer as much as possible. To do this, the 1800 cells are in favour in idle with the C2 criteria in selection and reselection : CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET = 16 dB in Orange France. In communication, the traffic is taken from the 900 layer to the 1800 layer by capture. Cross parameter threshold L_RX_LEV_CPT_HO(0,n) = -85 dBm in Orange France. Umbrella characteristics 1800 900 HO PBGT HO by alarm Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 30 The communications stay on the 1800 layer as much as possible > HO between 1800 cells are only made by PBGT : EN_MULTIBAND_PBGT_HO = DISABLE (but no matter because upper-lower PBGT HO impossible) HO_margin(0,n) = 5 dB The return to the 900 layer is only possible by alarm > Quality : L_RXQUAl_DL_H > 3.9 (offset : +1 if FH TS) > DL level : L_RXLEV_DL_H < -98 dBm > UL level : L_RXLEV_UL_H < - 107 dBm with diversity and - 104 dBm without diversity > Distance : U_TIME_ADVANCE > 4 (*550m) Alcatel settings Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 31 The 1800 cells is set as Mini , so CELL_LAYER_TYPE = lower. EN_PRIORITY_ORDERING = TRUE in all the network. For cells with type lower , evaluation is made by ORDER. Emergency HO Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 32 List of neighbouring cells = all neighbouring cells, without 900 umbrella macro cells which level thresholds is below of OUTDOOR_UMB_LEV(0,n) = -95 dBm PREF_LAYER = upper (because CELL_LAYER_TYPE= lower and EN_RESCUE_UM=enable), No PRIORITY(0,n) so the priority is for the 900 umbrella macro cell then the 1800 macro then single + micros. Cells ranking by ORDER = PBGT(n) - HO_MARGIN_XX(0,n). Absolute filter of neighbours by RXLEVmin(n) = -98 dBm. Comfort HO Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 33 Forced Directed Retry is activated : EN_FORCED_DR = enabled It allows to guide the communication from the 1800 layer to the 900 cells in case of queuing Trafic HO is not activated (traffic is taken into account in PBGT(n) criteria) No generalised capture, so the only case of comfort HO to consider is: PBGT (only be done to other 1800 umbrella macro because the PBGT stay in intra layer algorithm only). The maintained neighbours which respect the PBGT conditions are ranked with the rule ORDER = PBGT(n) HO_MARGIN(0,n). Absolute filter of neighbouring cells by RXLEVmin(n) = -98 dBm Umbrella template conclusion Advantages Drawbacks Quick fill of the 1800 layer Declaration of outgoing neighbours numerous (wide 1800 coverage area) Plate deployment required for spectral efficiency and intra layer PBGT Quick blocking of the 1800 layer (Forced DR is essential) Outflow from 1800 only in case of emergency -> bad impact on voice quality Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 34 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 35 TWIN Template for 1800 cells TWIN characteristics Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 36 Dual-band handsets proportion increase The Dual-band MS will reach 100% in Orange France, so umbrella setting is not enough to absorb all the 1800 traffic. Evolution of the umbrella parameters In order to improve the quality of the dual band network, new parameters need to be defined in order to : > improve the neighbouring management (reduce the number of neighbours to declare) > Allow the interband PBGT HO and so on improve the QoS. TWIN characteristics Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 37 Twin : two cells > 1800 : BCCH and TCHs > 900 : BCCH and TCHs Share the traffic between the two layers by threshold optimisation, and without hardware change (tilts) Copy the 900 coverage to the 1800 coverage on the co-located sites Improvement of spectral efficiency on 1800 with an equal radius of 900 cells To have the nearer coverage on each band, Orange France put the same output power and the same tilt in 900 and 1800 MHz (mechanical + electrical) Neighbours of the TWIN 1800 cells : co located 900 cells, neighbour TWIN and the 900 neighbours of the 900 co located cell 1800 MHz 900 MHz BCCH BCCH TWIN characteristics 1800 900 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 38 1800 outgoing and incoming neighbours are copy to the 900 co located site. 1800 declaration is needed upper (to make PBGT HO with the 900 neighbouring cells). So CELL_LAYER_TYPE = upper with Cell_type = umbrella at the OMC. EN_PRIORITY_ORDERING = Enable. To preserve a nominal comportment in case of emergency alarm, Priority(0,n) = 1 toward 900 is declared. Because otherwise, only the other TWIN cells would be sorted in priority in case of emergency. CELL_EV = GRADE (recommended for an upper cell type). ORDER is better recommended for lower cell (HO_MARGIN_XX(0,n) is used in that case in the case of interband PBGT HO) TWIN characteristics Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 39 Selection / reselection on 1800 (idle mode) : C2 criterium CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET = 16 dB for 1800 cells Inhibition of 1800 capture : EN_PREFERRED_BAND = disable HO from the 1800 to the 900 by PBGT criteria or comfort HO (better for voice quality). The activation of inter layer PBGT is made at the cell level by the flag EN_MULTIBAND_PBGT_HO = Enable. Cells must have the same cell_type. Directed Retry (assignation) > 1800 => 900 Forced Directed Retry to avoid congestion of the 1800 layer EN_FORCED_DR = Enable > 900 => 1800 Directed Retry ( = on alarm only) TWIN characteristics With HO_MARGIN(0,n) = 16 dB, it roughly makes a difference of threshold received of 9 dB (Rxlev_access_min = -102 dBm for 900 and -95 dBm for 1800). The return to the 900 layer is possible by alarm > Quality : L_RXQUAl_DL_H > 3.9 (offset : +1 if FH TS) > DL level : L_RXLEV_DL_H < -98 dBm > UL level : L_RXLEV_UL_H < - 107 dBm with diversity and - 104 dBm without diversity > Distance : U_TIME_ADVANCE > 4 (4*550m) HO_MARGIN(0,n) = 16 dB or 10 dB for a macro with fast MS Priority(0,n) = 1 HO_MARGIN(0,n) = 0 or 6 dB for a rural macro with fast MS Priority(0,n) = 0 HO_MARGIN(0,n) = 5 dB Priority(0,n) = 0 1800 900 Cross parameters Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 40 Emergency HO Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 41 PREF_LAYER = upper + single (CELL_LAYER_TYPE= upper) Without Priority (0,n) modification, the TWIN cell would sort in priority the other TWIN cells Not efficient So Priority (0,n) = 1 to favour emergency HO towards 900 cells GRADE evaluation (PBGT ranking with neighbour load information) Absolute filter of neighbouring cells by RXLEVmin(n) = -95 dBm Comfort HO Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 42 Activation of inter band PBGT from 900 cells toward all Twins neighbouring with HO_MARGIN(0,n) = 0 dB. Inhibition of 1800 capture : EN_PREFERRED_BAND = disable. PREF_LAYER = none Priority (0,n) = 1 towards 900 cells GRADE evaluation (upper) Absolute filter of neighbouring cells by RXLEVmin(n) = -95 dBm TWIN template conclusion Advantages Drawbacks Same neighbours declaration for the 1800 and the 900 Interband Ho generates numerous Ho if the 1800 plate is small Cell by cell deployment possible Traffic balance : to be tuned by the neighbour parameters setting Same counters & indicators for the 1800 layer (like 900) Isotilt 900/1800 required Interband HO on PBGT Umbrella template on several cells impossible Better spectrum efficiency on the 1800 layer because of the better uniformity of the cells Pas de TWIN en B5 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 43 Expected results on Twin parameter against Umbrella parameter Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 44 Lower blocking on the 1800 layer due to the service area diminution Improvement of the vocal quality because : The service area is shorter HO can also be made by PBGT and not only because of bad radio conditions Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 45 Single BCCH Single BCCH Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 46 ! Same principles as the concentric cells ! Only one cell with one 900 BCCH and TRXs 900 and 1800, no 1800 BCCH > 1 Outer area on 900 > 1 Inner area on 1800 > each TRX is allocated at one area ! BCCH ,CCCH, et SDCCH channels must be on the Outer area on 900. The PDCH also (Orange France decision on B6 for Alcatel). ! Queuing is possible only on the Outer area ! Directed Retry can be made only on the Outer area ! Direct allocation of TCH on the Inner area if the threshold level measured on SDCCH is better than thresholds fixed on template, on UL and on DL at the assignation, with incoming HO on DL 1800 MHz 900 MHz BCCH Single BCCH template Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 47 Cells are declared as oncentric : CELL_PARTITION_TYPE=Concentric Single BCCH : FREQUENCY_RANGE = GSM-DCS EN_MULTIBAND_PBGT_HO = Enable if the MS is in the inner zone, 900 level extrapolated from the 1800 level OFFSET_HO_MARGIN_INNER : 10 dB (average propagation offset between 900 and 1800) applied. ZONE_TYPE = 0 (resp. 1) outer TRX (resp. inner TRX) Single BCCH cells are monitored as a macro 900 cell in terms of priority and eligibility Single BCCH parameter setting HO Inner towards Outer if DL < -94 dBm PBGT : to another Single BCCH or to a Macro 900, if its mean level is 5 dB higher 1800 900 Incoming HO: direct assignation on 1800 inner if mean DL level reception from the originating cell > -82 dBm otherwise: assignation on TCH 900. Call initiation: direct assignation on TCH 1800 if UL > -107 dBm and DL > - 82 dBm otherwise: TCH 900 HO Outer towards Inner if UL > -107 dBm and DL > -82 dBm Intercell HO if DL < -95 dBm or UL < -97 dBm intercell HO if UL < -97 dBm PBGT : to another Single BCCH or to a Macro 900, if its mean level is 18 dB higher Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 48 Single BCCH Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 49 To avoid ping pong HO between layers : ZONE_HO_HYST_DL = 12 dB Functionality description Intracell HO 900->1800 : This mechanism is identical to the concentric cell algorithm but the Timing Advance condition is not checked for dual band cells sites. Intracell HO 1800->900 : In case of lack of resources in the Outer GSM 900, the dual band MS stays on the inner 1800 TRX till it finds a GSM 900 or 1800 neighbouring cell which satisfies the conditions for PBGT, RXQUAL, RXLEV or DISTANCE (interferences HO inhibited). PBGT HO from inner to outer not forseen Alarm thresholds : > Quality : L_RXQUAl_DL_H > 3.9 (offset : +1 if FH TS) > DL level : L_RXLEV_DL_H < -95 dBm > UL level : L_RXLEV_UL_H < - 97 dBm > Distance : U_TIME_ADVANCE > 19 (*550m) Single BCCH template conclusion Advantages Drawbacks Only one CI, one cell to the OMC and in the SI Investment cost : needs for G3 or G4 multiband BTS Deployment : 1800 cells can be deployed one by one Large band repeaters => no 900 repeaters Frequency planning : 1800 frequency for TCH only Aerials : same tilt for 1800 and 900 antennas SFH : frequency hopping on the whole 1800 band QoS monitoring : NO specific counters to the 1800 cell (congestion, drop calls) Parameter setting : only for the 900 cell (less neighbours to be declared) Access : roamers with only mono band 1800 handsets can't access to the network Increase of the 1800 capacity (BCCH TS,.) BTS activation one by one (1 hour), with site moving and 10 minutes off Less neighbours to be declared -> better BCCH neighbour level estimation in idle -> TCH assign secured Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 50 Advantages and drawbacks of the different solutions
Umbrella template TWIN template Single BCCH New sites preparation before opening (CI,BSIC) - - + Inter band neighbours -- - + Frequency planning - = + Spectrum efficiency 1800 -- - + Easiness to fill the layer 1800 ++ + - Repeaters compatibility + + - BTS configuration compatibility + + - Assessment 2 - 0 + 1 +
Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 51 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 52 Umbrella macro 1800 modified Umbrella macro 1800 modified Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 53 To become compatible with new eventual Twin or Single BCCH neighbouring. Modifications to set : 1800 macro as upper (Cell_type = umbrella) > So that PBGT toward Twin or inner area is possible > Priority changes from 0 to 1 toward the 900 neighbours, to keep the current behaviour for emergency HO. Otherwise, the QoS of this lower cell would not be optimum (no PBGT HO with 1800 TWIN or inner area of single). An activation by PRC takes a long time, it is necessary to find a way to make it automatically Dual-band availability on Alcatel Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 54 B5.1 for Alcatel BSS Single BCCH : > BSS B6.2 on 25i for on optimal work on Alcatel with BSC G2 - BTS Evolium (G3 or G3.8 or G4.2) => available > BSS B7 to be able to monitor at the TRX level single BCCH cells Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 55 QoS indicators used (examples from the operational unit of Paris) Alcatel Ho causes without Ho better cell 900 Mhz layer Alcatel Ho causes repartition without Ho better cell - 900 layer (3214 cells) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 2 0 0 2 - W 1 0 2 0 0 2 - W 1 2 2 0 0 2 - W 1 4 2 0 0 2 - W 1 6 2 0 0 2 - W 1 8 2 0 0 2 - W 2 0 2 0 0 2 - W 2 2 2 0 0 2 - W 2 4 2 0 0 2 - W 2 6 2 0 0 2 - W 2 8 2 0 0 2 - W 3 0 2 0 0 2 - W 3 2 2 0 0 2 - W 3 4 2 0 0 2 - W 3 6 H O
c a u s e s
( % ) 0 10000000 20000000 30000000 40000000 50000000 60000000 70000000 N u m b e r
o f
H O HO_DR Nb_HO %CAP_MICRO %CAP_1800 %TRAFIC %DIST %ULS %DLS %ULQ %DLQ Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 56 Alcatel Ho causes 900 Mhz layer Alcatel Ho causes repartition - 900 layer (3214 cells) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 2 0 0 2 - W 1 0 2 0 0 2 - W 1 2 2 0 0 2 - W 1 4 2 0 0 2 - W 1 6 2 0 0 2 - W 1 8 2 0 0 2 - W 2 0 2 0 0 2 - W 2 2 2 0 0 2 - W 2 4 2 0 0 2 - W 2 6 2 0 0 2 - W 2 8 2 0 0 2 - W 3 0 2 0 0 2 - W 3 2 2 0 0 2 - W 3 4 2 0 0 2 - W 3 6 H O
c a u s e s
( % ) 0 10000000 20000000 30000000 40000000 50000000 60000000 70000000 N u m b e r
o f
H O HO_DR Nb_HO %CAP_MICRO %CAP_1800 %TRAFIC %DIST %ULS %DLS %ULQ %DLQ %Better _Cell Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 57 Alcatel Ho causes without Ho better cell 1800 Mhz layer Alcatel Ho causes repartition without Ho better cell - 1800 layer (1967 cells) 0,00% 5,00% 10,00% 15,00% 20,00% 25,00% 2 0 0 2 - W 1 0 2 0 0 2 - W 1 2 2 0 0 2 - W 1 4 2 0 0 2 - W 1 6 2 0 0 2 - W 1 8 2 0 0 2 - W 2 0 2 0 0 2 - W 2 2 2 0 0 2 - W 2 4 2 0 0 2 - W 2 6 2 0 0 2 - W 2 8 2 0 0 2 - W 3 0 2 0 0 2 - W 3 2 2 0 0 2 - W 3 4 2 0 0 2 - W 3 6 H O
c a u s e s
( % ) 0 5000000 10000000 15000000 20000000 25000000 30000000 35000000 40000000 45000000 N u m b e r
o f
H O DR_FORCED Nb_Total %HO_CAP_MICRO %HO_CAP_1800 %HO_TRAF %HO_Dist %HO_ULS %HO_DLS %HO_ULQ %HO_DLQ Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 58 Alcatel Ho causes 1800 Mhz layer Alcatel Ho causes repartition - 1800 layer (1967 cells) 0,00% 10,00% 20,00% 30,00% 40,00% 50,00% 60,00% 70,00% 2 0 0 2 - W 1 0 2 0 0 2 - W 1 2 2 0 0 2 - W 1 4 2 0 0 2 - W 1 6 2 0 0 2 - W 1 8 2 0 0 2 - W 2 0 2 0 0 2 - W 2 2 2 0 0 2 - W 2 4 2 0 0 2 - W 2 6 2 0 0 2 - W 2 8 2 0 0 2 - W 3 0 2 0 0 2 - W 3 2 2 0 0 2 - W 3 4 2 0 0 2 - W 3 6 H O
c a u s e s
( % ) 0 5000000 10000000 15000000 20000000 25000000 30000000 35000000 40000000 45000000 N u m b e r
o f
H O DR_FORCED Nb_Total %HO_CAP_MICRO %HO_CAP_1800 %HO_TRAF %HO_Dist %HO_ULS %HO_DLS %HO_ULQ %HO_DLQ %HO_better_cell Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 59 Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 60 Dual-band network optimisation with GPRS Dual-band and GPRS Re-selection in GPRS As long as NC2 functionality is not implemented, selection/reselections are decided by the MS Without PBCCH, C1 and C2 criteria are used : MS is in Idle state : not connected to GPRS MS is in Stand-by state : The network is not aware of the cell change of the MS, but only RA change (today 1 RA = 1 LAC in Orange France). > A RA update is executed > A Cell update is executed : the neighbouring cell must respect : C2(n) > C2(s) + CELL_RESELECT_HYSTERESIS MS is in Ready state : The MS is localised at the cell level > A cell update is executed : the neighbouring cell must respect : C2(n) > C2(s) + CELL_RESELECT_HYSTERESIS Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 61 Dual-band and GPRS Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 62 The GPRS transfert drop duration during a reselection is several seconds. Each reselection causes a throughput decrease (so also GPRS QoS). In a dual-band environnement, the neighbours are numerous. There is a risk of degrading the GPRS QoS in Dual-band environnement The GSM setting has an impact on the GPRS QoS because the GPRS cell selection/reselection is the same as the GSM one Optimisations Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 63 CELL_RESELECT_HYSTERESIS : 4dB -> 8 dB To reduce the number of intra-band reselections 8 dB used in dense urban and urban environnement 6 dB (optimised value) can be used for the LAC border cells 4 dB remains the rural value Favouring the access to the 900 layer (CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET = 0dB) In some cases, particularly in indoor, 900 coverage is better than 1800 coverage. By favouring the 900 layer for the selections/re-selections and by capturing the voice communications to the 1800 layer, GPRS MS stay on the 900 layer. Reserved TS only on the 900 Mhz layer and maybe some dynamic TS on the 1800 layer Strong capture algorithm on the 1800 layer to avoid 900 saturation CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET : 16 dB -> 20 dB With RxLevAccess_Min=-95 dBm This is the best solution to optimise the GPRS performance and not to decrease the circuit QoS. In that case, static TS must be reserved in both bands Conclusion Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 64 In dense urban and urban, with TWIN and RxLevAccessMin = - 95 dBm, the Orange France recommendations are : CELL_RESELECT_HYSTERESIS = 8 dB, but 6 dB or optimised value can be used for the LAC border cells CELL_RESELECT_OFFSET1800 = 20 dB The use of the 900 layer for circuit and GPRS access cant be used in environement with micro cells because of the risk of saturation for the 900 layer. Moreover the 900 layer load increases whereas the 1800 spectrum is the largest So this solution is not used in Orange France Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 65 Thank you Bibliography Orange Technical GTF/CoE RA/IRS ,july 24&25th 2003 - 66 Alcatel B6.2 AQ 25i-6 parameter setting in Orange France Ref : Orange France/DOD/DAT/RRA/02.11/JMB Alcatel Algorithms B6.2 Ref : Orange France/DTRS/DRA/CPR/03.91/FRO Stratgies de paramtrage TWIN Ref : FTM/DOD/DTFI/TCE/01.211/J MB Compte rendu des zones radio GPRS Ref : OF/DOD/RRA/A&F/02.206/PG