Abstract A recent survey at the big data Retail forum summit in Chicago suggests 80% of the retailers are aware of big data and 67% are either already in the process of building a big data strategy. With data collection at various touch points ever-growing, and technology enabling data collection and analysis, companies have raced towards adopting BI (Business Intelligence) and big data solutions to earn competitive advantage. The term big data refers to solutions that can handle data that characterizes 4Vs viz., Volume, Velocity, Variety and Veracity. While insights on to merchandising, procurement was nothing new, customer analytics has unleashed the real big data capabilities enabling companies to arrive at insights that were earlier close to impossible. In retail parlance, consumer shopping behavior, preferences etc. are data that was a rarity in itself. Thanks to changing consumer mindset. Consumers are increasingly ready to share data and also allow data capturing by retailers; but a recent IBM study concludes that all such acceptance is with expectations that the retailers would honor their privacy and provide value in return. Big data solution provides have been able to demonstrate ROI (Return on Investment) for retail firms that have invested into these technologies. Changes in consumer buying modes, increased purchasing power in a hypercompetitive industry has coerced the industry to adapt to such changing patterns. Omnichannel retailing is the norm of the 21 st century. Retailers are continuously bothered by this multichannel importance that customers showroom but yet dynamically change the channel where the ultimate sale is completed. The intrinsic change in patterns around shopping behavior has been a source of research for retailers and their big data solution vendors. CRM (Customer Relationship Management), loyalty programs and corporate data responsibility are some of the key focus areas today. Keywords: Omnichannel retail, consumer shopping behavior, big data, analytics, ROI, CRM 2 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
What is big data? Big data is the label provided to extreme forms of BI systems that are constrained by increased frequency of data capture combined with ever increasing touch points in the market. The new channels of distribution contributes to the complexity on the variety dimension.
Retailers handle huge volumes of structured and unstructured data. This is inherent nature of the industry which is transaction intensive. Data from various touch points are collected and stored in Hadoop clusters (or any other storage systems) [1]. Through technologies like Hive, special big data analysts help in generating innumerous insights. The need for such analyst capable of combining industry expertise with technological acumen are in need. Firms that are looking forward to gaining competitive advantage through big data are already focusing on some the big data functionalities through hiring analysts in large numbers. Ability of correlate sensibly and
Figure 2- Big data functional view arrive at insights is the key capability expected from such analysts. McKinseys CMAC (Consumers Marketing Analytics Center) for example has a team that provides consulting and tools that can enable firms to generate actionable insights. Retailers according to various commentaries and discussion in the big data retail forum summits, have been focusing more on the areas of CRM, loyalty for value creation to retain customers. Figure 1-Hadoop representation of big data [1] 3 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Traditional Business intelligence and big data Traditional BI has been focusing on operations, consumer expectation, mismatch around value perceptions and competition as the key areas for optimization [1]. The dimensions that big data brings in include the predictive analytics, machine learning, and social behavior of consumers that have become attractive sources of insights. Retailer understand the increased need to personalize their online and offline store operations for consumers. Informed data collection are various interactive points and observatory learning systems ([10] application of video analytics) have been under usage during the last 5 years. The advantage that big data offers is the benefits of machine learnings to connect individual observations into global insights with great levels of granularity.
Make or Buy decision The decision process to creating competitive advantage through big data starts with WHAT are the areas that can be improved using big data. Once there is a conviction to invest into analytics, the next decision point is whether to develop a solution using the in-house expertise or procure an off-the-self, customizable solution from a vendor like say CMAC from McKinsey [14]. Our study suggests that this decision has to be purely contextual for any firm. Some of the factors that retail firms need to consider before investing into such a solution are summarized below. Figure 3 Traditional BI and Big data Big data adds Traditional BI Big data 4 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Make decision Factors to consider If you see it as a Long term strategic asset and core competency Cost of operation increases due to need in house expertise. Lead time available to develop Flexibility and selectivity Security concerns around the data collected Fixed cost model Buy decision Factors to consider Initial period of ROI Lull Payment may be for features not required. Off-the-shelf in most cases; can be setup and be running quickly Can be less flexible due to constraints with customization Data security and privacy can be an issue Variable cost model Omnichannel retailing Retail industry has two sectors primarily viz., unorganized and organized. These are called General trade and modern trade in retail parlance. In developing countries, the proportion of unorganized retail is usually higher vis--vis developed countries. The adoption of big data is predominant as expected in the developed countries, where accessibility is not a major concern. The ability to retain and satisfice consumers is the key challenge that has forced retailers in the developed countries to focus on CRM, loyalty programs etc. The data collected at various interaction points with the consumer (cognizant and observatory) are collated and analyzed 5 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
usually to personalize their experience during shopping at their outlets (online portals as well as retail stores). The resultant insights are fed to other operations like merchandising (merchandise assortment and planning (MAP), procurement, inventory forecasting, warehousing and vendor engagement etc. Changes in lifestyle has created new avenues of convenience and value for consumers. Brick-and-mortar companies have been forced to now consider online competition from online retailers. Price parity is a key challenge. Creating the right value to compensate inherent disparity in cost structures through differentiation is inevitable. There is a challenge for brick-and-mortar companies with venturing into the online space. They further need investments into a whole new vertical and traverse through the learning curve to compensate the disadvantage. Instead, brick-and-mortar companies could embrace other in-store data capture technologies and develop teams that span the competition and its offerings constantly. IBM Research Results: Although a large amount of consumers are willing to share personal data, the key finding is that they expect a personal experience in return. It is imperative that retailers go about using data in such a way that it results in customers trust and loyalty - IBM Research [5, 8]. 19% 40% 29% 12% Tech based buyers and prefer multiple channels. Choose retailers that offer those channels Info search and buy online Info Search But no purchasing online Does not use technology to shop
6 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Figure 4 Shopper categories based on purchase decision process Key takeaways from global retailers Key takeaways from the commentaries of global retailers include the following: Time sensitive decisions, Monitor emerging trends and taking corrective actions are critical for generating value out of big data investments
Spend most of your time on WHAT and not HOW [1] Spend 70% on WHAT to analyze and only 30% on HOW to analyze Ability of gather relationships across variables in structured data is immense Build a solution to drive data gathering at various touch points into a common repository. Consumer Insights Business Insights Product Insights & Social Insights When you create a Big Data team: Form teams comprised of right people Partnership with your IT department is critical Concrete goals (else leads to analysis paralysis) Success with Big Data is primarily through Choosing simple ways to compute insights Knowing how much to complicate Insights Decisions Execution 7 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Honest data management practices that does not tamper with the privacy promises made to the consumer How do you begin with Big Data? Augment to enhance insights Do not treat it as a revenue handling system Improve quality of existing decisions Improve time to market
Big Data - Retail Use cases During course of this term paper we conducted a literature review [3] and existing business solutions from customers case studies to see various places where big data technologies are used in retail Industry. Apparently, we seem to notice that a lot of multinational retail brands already kick started their efforts to leverage value out of big data. Through this study, we were able to bin most of these uses into following categories CRM & Customer Experience A customer interacts with company during number of times to buy, use and avail product/services. Whenever a customer interacts with an organization during various touch points, it is vital that amount of information available on customer informs and guides process that will help maximize their experience. For this to happen, retail companies need a 360 degree view of customers. A 360 degree view of customer includes aspects related to past, present and future. The following are sources from which retailers can capture such information. Empowered with large volumes of information relating to customers, retailers can improvise by personalizing their services. To help customer buy a new smart phone, 8 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
retailer can analyze data from his previous transactions, their click stream activity, social media activity, geospatial & demographic information and push highly targeted real time promotion through search engine and social media advertisements.
Figure 5 - A general overview of various sources from which we can capture customer data. Ecommerce websites can come up with better recommendation systems to suggest relevant products that customers might be willing to buy. Merchandizing, Pricing Merchandizing deals with retail activity which primarily focuses on promoting sales of goods especially by presentation in retail outlets. Big data can aid retailers to manage merchandizing by effectively making use of data aggregated from a variety of sources. With the profusion of social networking sites and user activity, a lot of social media buzz is generated online which could be valuable for companies. Using big data technologies, companies 9 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
can figure out latest trends, fashion styles promoted by public icons & movies and push these merchandize to storefront. Using Big Data technologies, retailers can use data captured from news related to local events and launch promotional buzz. Retail managers can also get information from disparate data sources and fine tune their pricing strategies accordingly resulting in competitive edge in their respective industries. Supply chain & Operations In addition to improving CRM and merchandizing, big data technologies can also be leveraged to improve supply chain and regular day to day operations. Armed with huge volumes of real time data, retailers can use real time tracking options to track order shipments. In case of any major political, natural or social events, companies can react spontaneously and by efficiently rerouting their shipments, they can improve their logistics. On similar lines, big data technology can be harnessed to improvise day to day operations. For instance, looking at data trends from local news and events and data demand and supply patterns, companies can work on dynamically staffing people which could result in cost savings. Marketing Big data delivers competitive advantage for retailers in marketing activities too. Empowered with Big data, retailers can indulge more effectively in targeted marketing, micro segmentation, location based selling and cross selling. In addition to targeting, retailers can also pull out valuable insights of their product performance or product launches if any from social media. 10 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
A lot of context specific insights related to customer activity is captured day to day by many sources. This data can be used for marketing and delivering ads to users based on digital footprint and context in which user performs digital activities. Social With the rise of social networking activity online, social networking sites capture phenomenal amount of social activity from public. This information could provide valuable insights on customer perceptions related to various products and services they consume. Companies can conduct sentiment analysis on social networking sites and get various insights on how customers feel and perceive about their products. Visual Analytics This is another trending domain under big data umbrella. Although in its nascent stages, mining real time in store closed circuits cameras and other offline video content could provide useful insights onto how can retailers improve their customer service. For instance, firms like IBM are coming up with augmented virtual reality shopping application that will automatically deliver personalized coupons, offers, customer reviews and hidden product details. This would close the gap between wealth of product information on internet and traditional retail stores [10]. On similar lines, a lot of face matching analytics technology is being developed which can identify customers walking into store and pass their profiles to sales representatives so that retailers can deliver personalized customer service. Some Key Issues in Big Data Communication & co-ordination of disparate data silos: 11 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
One of the most critical issues with big data is related to managing sheer quantity of data produced by various sources. Owing to large volumes and variety of data, organizations build huge data silos to capture and mine data. Most of the time, coordinating and consolidating these massive silos could issue potential problems pushing existing infrastructure to its limits. Technology and research could eventually deal with this problem but however, a lot of streamlining work needs to be done in this area so that systems can co-ordinate and efficiently process this information. Regional, Cultural & linguistic factors Weather it is Social Network Analysis or Analysis of data from news and newsgroups, there are always regional, linguistic and cultural factors that kick in and need to be accounted for. Since Big Data technology deals with a diverse wealth of information, systems that handle and process this data should be flexible enough to account for all these factors. Privacy & Regulation issues Historically, most of the data collected does not attribute to specific individuals. This is more often de identified information and big data is traditionally used for tracking interests of customer groups in de-identified form. Information in this form is not regulated across many nations and companies are free to conduct their business using this. However, with technology evolution, we have enough analytical tools developed which could track and attribute data to specific individuals. This resulted in number of governments regularly coming up with legislative acts like Privacy Act, The Spam Act etc. (Australia). All these issues complicate environment in which companies operate business with big data technologies. These factors have to be strictly honored and technology needs to flexibly encompass all the same. 12 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Corporate responsibility on Customer data Another issue that gets frequently highlighted whenever people talk about big data is related to the issue of corporate responsibility on customer data. There is a growing concern on to what extent corporate are responsible in making ethical use of data at their expense [9]. With profusion of data, corporate look for many ways with which they can monetize this. As the case study The dark side of customer analytics discusses, when a company gets hands on data, marketers can be tempted to use information in ways that seem attractive but ultimately end up damaging relationships with customers. Also, with the amount of data that companies collect, they would be able to profile customers more accurately without possibly having any direct interaction with them. All these actions call for an ethical business conduct which is critical when retailers do their business. Some Radical trends that we could foresee going forward. Significance of Context Awareness Going forward, since data will be all around us, the context in which it exists and its relevant starts to matter more. Empowered with contextual information, companies can produce better analytical insights into data which is more pertinent to customer. With the increase in number of devices like the mobiles, tablets and more trending wearable the capability to collect context specific information becomes easier and companies would use this to obtain better insights from data [12]. Focus on real problems rather than product selling; Semantic shift Right now, most of business vendors are in mode of selling big data technology applications and services. Empowered by these, retailers usually focus on selling their products to individuals. 13 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
With the evolution of new research areas like semantic technologies, deep data mining etc, and retailers will be riding on tools with which they will be able to go beyond selling to solving more real world problems like solving customers needs, proactively reacting to their demands etc. Visualization driven insights Visual communication aids in simplifying and understanding large number of insights processed from data. Companies like Trulia, a real estate website, can use a single visualization to display many data sets like crime maps, school districts and neighborhood prices etc. Likewise, GE extensively uses visualization in its strategic information systems to reach its goals because it makes data comprehension easier for senior executives. Thus, visualization driven insights would be a commonplace. Improvements in raising status quo bar of existing technologies Academia research, Company collaborations and events and annual summits like Big Data & Analytics for Retail Summit etc would constantly improvise on existing big data and related technologies thereby raising status quo bar. For instance, the key themes of 2014 summit will be relating to areas like Customer Engagement, E-Commerce, Consumer Insight, Data Analytics, Web Analytics, and CRM etc.
14 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
Conclusion Retail firms could increase operating margins by up to 60% for those pioneers that maximize their use of Big Data. McKinsey The retail industry is different from other industries in that it has intrinsic structure to capture huge volumes of data. It is important for companies to understand the importance of this data and apply analytics in a sensible way to achieve positive improvement. Some of the key learning have created retailers to optimize their cost of operation immensely. While the data analytics has helped the operations in a positive way, an oversupply of analytical surge has also caused detrimental results for firms. Most of these failure scenarios are attributed to cognizant or nonsensical application of correlative relationships to arrive at insights. More problems arise through reporting of such insights. Key issues dangling around today, discussed above have been confirmed by multiple retailers, confirming the veracity of these issues. Our observations indicate that data analytics on the operational front has immense potential to improve and bring about a structure to the operations. Most retailers in developing countries that collect/have started collecting information about shopper behavior and personal information have to consider these insights and escape this curse of analytics. Big data enables firms to gather finer details about data that they already have. This includes customer data as well. Usage of customer data has to be in line with the privacy policies promised to the customer. Any violation can be detrimental to the business [9]. Questions that retailers face today on customer privacy have to be dealt without prejudice keeping customers at the center of the business. This must be despite the fact that legal restriction are in place or not.
15 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
References 1. Big data Calculating ROI http://www.bigdataretailforum.com/FormDownloadThankYou.aspx?target=http://www.bigd ataretailforum.com/media/7832/14512.pdf&eventid=7832&m=14512# 2. Connecting consumer experience across all retail touch points http://www.retailbiz.com.au/2013/03/11/article/Opportunities-along-the-digital-breadcrumb- trail/GJNDBBKEAL 3. Big data uses for retail http://www.ngdata.com/solutions/solutions-and-use-cases-for-retail-companies/ http://wikibon.org/wiki/v/Big_Data_in_the_Retail_Industry 4. Retail efficiency using big data http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hub/173001/docs/boosting_retail_revenue_wpp.pdf?t=0 5. Personalizing in the world of Omnichannel retailing http://in.teradata.com/retail/?LangType=16393&LangSelect=true 6. http://www.slideshare.net/srinivasbobby/big-data-trends-in-retail-industry-31724077 7. http://www.forbes.com/sites/barbarathau/2014/01/24/why-the-smart-use-of-big-data-will- transform-the-retail-industry/ 8. Result of IBM Retailers survey, originally Published January 13, 2014 on Retail- Merchandiser.com 9. The dark side of customer analytics : A HBR Case Study 10. Video Analytics for Retail http://www.securitymagazine.com/ext/resources/2012/September-2012/Retail-Video- Analytics---feat.doc 11. Volumes of information on big data for retail www.bigdataretailforum.com http://theinnovationenterprise.com/summits/big-data-analytics-retail-2014- chicago#sthash.odh83E3y.dpuf 12. Ideas economy: Finding value in big data 16 BIG DATA FOR RETAIL
http://www.oracle.com/us/technologies/big-data/finding-value-in-big-data- 1991047.pdf?ssSourceSiteId=ocomin 13. Gartner research reports 14. CMAC at McKinsey http://www.mckinsey.com/client_service/retail/expertise/~/media/mckinsey/dotcom/client_se rvice/retail/articles/cmac_creating_competitive_advantage_from_big_data.ashx