100%(1)100% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (1 Abstimmung)
507 Ansichten2 Seiten
Vygotsky believed that development could only be understood by considering individual, interpersonal, and cultural-historical factors that mutually influence each other. Some strengths of this sociocultural view are its emphasis on how social and cultural contexts shape development, and its acknowledgement that development may differ between or within cultures. However, it also has some weaknesses, such as the zone of proximal development concept being ambiguous, a lack of attention to how development changes at different ages or ability levels, and not having prototypical tasks commonly associated with the theory.
Originalbeschreibung:
Originaltitel
State Several Strengths and Weaknesses in Learning Carried Out Intrapersonally and Interpersonally Based on Vygotsky
Vygotsky believed that development could only be understood by considering individual, interpersonal, and cultural-historical factors that mutually influence each other. Some strengths of this sociocultural view are its emphasis on how social and cultural contexts shape development, and its acknowledgement that development may differ between or within cultures. However, it also has some weaknesses, such as the zone of proximal development concept being ambiguous, a lack of attention to how development changes at different ages or ability levels, and not having prototypical tasks commonly associated with the theory.
Vygotsky believed that development could only be understood by considering individual, interpersonal, and cultural-historical factors that mutually influence each other. Some strengths of this sociocultural view are its emphasis on how social and cultural contexts shape development, and its acknowledgement that development may differ between or within cultures. However, it also has some weaknesses, such as the zone of proximal development concept being ambiguous, a lack of attention to how development changes at different ages or ability levels, and not having prototypical tasks commonly associated with the theory.
State several strengths and weaknesses in learning carried out
intrapersonally and interpersonally based on Vygotskys view.
-Interpersonal: To do with interaction with others. -Intrapersonal:To do with oneself. Vygotskys view was that development could only be understood by focusing on individual, interpersonal and cultural-historical factors as they mutually influenced each other. Strengths: -Emphasis on Social-Cultural Context Vygotosky is the main developmental theorist to emphasize the broader socio- historical context of development. In many ways, sociocultural theory thus "corrects" theories focused on individuals, and gives a different perspective on major topics of development. According to Vygotsky, society shares its cognitive goals with the child, and the child shapes the environment. Concepts such as the zone of proximal development and internalization refer to the cognitive exchanges that occur at this border. The task for developmental psychologists is to focus on the specific processes that occur in the interface betwen the child and the environment. In other words, "What do a child and other people actually do together moment-to- moment in a particular setting, and how does this interaction affect the child's environment?" -Sensitivity to Diversity of Development In contrast to many developmental theories that focus on universal aspects of development, sociocultural theory acknowledges both differences between cultures, and differences within a single culture (e.g., wide versus narrow zones of proximal development for different children). Sociocultural theory questions whether there is a universal endpoint of development, given that ideal thinking and behavior may differ for different cultures based on their particular social and physical circumstances and tools available. In addition, different historical and cultural circumstances may encourage different developmental routes to any given developmental endpoint. Weakness: -Ambiguity of Zone of Proximal Development
The first main ambiguity within Vygotsky's concept of the zone is that only knowing the width of chidren's zones doesn't provide an accurate picture of their learning ability, style of learning, or current level of development compared to other children of the same age and degree of motivation. -Insufficient Attention to Developmental Issues
A more developmental account of both contexts and children is needed. Vygotsky's theory offers little description of contexts of children of various ages or developmental levels. Along similar lines, children's abilities, needs, and interests at each age influence the nature of the settings they seek out and the effect that a particular setting has on them. We have little idea how the child's cognitive level permits or constrains processes in the zone. Sociocultural research rarely addresses the nature of the cognitive skills that are required for responding to prompts, joint attention and etc. Ultimately, a major issue is that children of different developmentat levels seems to be overlook.
-No Major Prototypic Tasks Associated with the Theory
The sociocultural approach to development appears to lack any major prototypical tasks that others immediately associate with the theory. While Vygotsky did develop scenarios involving the use of the Vygotsky blocks and other double-stimulation methods, contemporary researchers seldom utilize these processes to examine sociocultural developmental theory. This may be in part due to the fact that when Vygotsky did conduct experiments, he typically provided very sparse descriptions of his procedures and little or no data, relying instead on general summaries. As a result, sociocultural psychologists today look at a vast array of topics in their research.
Dark Psychology & Manipulation: Discover How To Analyze People and Master Human Behaviour Using Emotional Influence Techniques, Body Language Secrets, Covert NLP, Speed Reading, and Hypnosis.
Raising Mentally Strong Kids: How to Combine the Power of Neuroscience with Love and Logic to Grow Confident, Kind, Responsible, and Resilient Children and Young Adults
Summary: It Didn't Start with You: How Inherited Family Trauma Shapes Who We Are and How to End the Cycle By Mark Wolynn: Key Takeaways, Summary & Analysis