SCUND An argumenL LhaL ls valld and has only Lrue premlses Chapter 2 2.1 araphras|ng and D|agramm|ng 2.2 kecogn|z|ng Arguments
CCNCLUSICN INDICA1Ck A word or phrase LhaL Lyplcally lnLroduces an argumenL's concluslon.
kLMISL INDICA1Ck A word or phrase LhaL Lyplcally lnLroduces a premlse ln an argumenL.
knL1CkIC ULS1ICN A quesLlon whose answer ls assumed Lo be obvlous.
CCMMAND A dlrecLlve sLaLemenL.
LN1nMLML An argumenL conLalnlng an unsLaLed proposlLlon Chapter 6: Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons 6.1 1he 1heory of Deduct|on
DLDUC1IVL AGkUMLN1 An argumenL LhaL clalms Lo esLabllsh lLs concluslon concluslvely, one of Lhe Lwo classes of argumenLs.
VALID AkGUMLN1 A deducLlve argumenL ln whlch, lf all Lhe premlses are Lrue, Lhe concluslon musL be Lrue.
6.2 C|asses and Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons
CLASS 1he collecLlon of all ob[ecLs LhaL have some speclfled characLerlsLlc ln common
6.3 1he Iour k|nds of Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons
CA1LGCkICAL kCCSI1ICN A proposlLlon, used ln deducLlve argumenLs, LhaL asserLs a relaLlonshlp beLween one caLegory and some oLher caLegory.
UNIVLkSAL AIIIkMA1IVL kCCSI1ICNS (A kCCSI1ICNS) roposlLlons LhaL asserL LhaL Lhe whole of one class ls lncluded or conLalned ln anoLher class. All S ls .
UNIVLkSAL NLGA1IVL kCCSI1ICNS (L kCCSI1ICNS) roposlLlons LhaL asserL LhaL Lhe whole of one class ls excluded from Lhe whole of anoLher class, no S ls .
Ak1ICULAk AIIIkMA1IVL kCCSI1ICNS (I kCCSI1ICNS) roposlLlons LhaL asserL LhaL Lwo classes have some member or members ln common, Some S ls .
Ak1ICULAk NLGA1IVL kCCSI1ICNS (C kCCSI1ICNS) roposlLlons LhaL asserL LhaL aL leasL one member of a class ls excluded from Lhe whole of anoLher class, Some S ls noL .
6.4 ua||ty, uant|ty, and D|str|but|on
UALI1 Ann aLLrlbuLe of every caLegorlcal proposlLlon, deLermlned by wheLher Lhe proposlLlon afflrms or denles some form of class lncluslon.
UAN1I1 An aLLrlbuLe of every caLegorlcal proposlLlon, deLermlned by wheLher Lhe proposlLlon refers Lo all members (unlversal") or only some members (parLlcular") of Lhe sub[ecL class.
DIS1kI8U1ICN A characLerlzaLlon of wheLher Lerms ln a caLegorlcal proposlLlon refer Lo all members of Lhe class deslgnaLed by LhaL Lerm.
LefL (Aff): ls undlsLrlbuLed 8lghL (neg): ls dlsLrlbuLed 1op (unl): S ls dlsLrlbuLed 8oLLom (ar): S ls undlsLrlbuLed A: S only L: 8oLh l: nelLher C: only unlversal Amrmauve unlversal negauve arucular Amrmauve arucular negauve
6.S 1he 1rad|t|ona| Square of Cppos|t|on
CCSI1ICN Any loglcal relaLlon among Lhe klnds of caLegorlcal proposlLlons (A, L, l, and C) exhlblLed on Lhe Square of CpposlLlon
CCN1kADIC1CkILS 1wo proposlLlons LhaL cannoL boLh be Lrue and cannoL boLh be false.
CCN1kAkILS 1wo proposlLlons LhaL cannoL boLh be Lrue, lf one ls Lrue, Lhe oLher musL be false. 1hey can boLh be false.
SU8CCN1kAkILS 1wo proposlLlons LhaL cannoL boLh be false, lf one ls false Lhe oLher musL be Lrue. 1hey can boLh be Lrue.
SU8AL1LkNA1ICN 1he opposlLlon beLween a unlversal proposlLlon (Lhe superalLern) and lLs correspondlng parLlcular proposlLlon (Lhe subalLern) ln classlcal loglc, Lhe unlversal proposlLlon lmplles Lhe LruLh of lLs correspondlng parLlcular proposlLlon.
SUAkL CI CCSI1ICN A dlagram showlng Lhe loglcal relaLlonshlps among Lhe four Lypes of caLegorlcal proposlLlons (A, L, l, and C). 1he LradlLlonal Square of CpposlLlon dlffers from Lhe modern Square of CpposlLlon ln lmporLanL ways.
IMMLDIA1L INILkLNCL An lnference drawn dlrecLly from only one premlse.
MLDIA1L INILkLNCL An lnference drawn from more Lhan one premlse, Lhe concluslon ls drawn from Lhe flrsL premlse Lhrough Lhe medlaLlon of Lhe second.
G|ven as a true A Ll, l1, Cl L Al, ll, C1 I Ll, ACuu C Al, Lluu A C1, Lluu L l1, CAuu I Al, L1, C1 C A1, Ll, l1
6.6 Iurther Immed|ate Inferences
CCNVLkSICN A lnference formed by lnLerchanglng Lhe sub[ecL and predlcaLe Lerms of a caLegorlcal proposlLlon. noL all converslons are valld.
vALlu CCnvL8SlCnS CCnvL81Lu CCnvL8SL A: All S ls . I: All ls S (by llmlLaLlon) L: no S ls L: no ls S. I: Some S ls . I: Some ls S C: Some S ls noL . (converslon noL valld)
CCMLLMLN1 CI A CLASS 1he collecLlon of all Lhlngs LhaL do noL belong Lo LhaL class.
C8VLkSICN An lnference formed by changlng Lhe quallLy of a proposlLlon and replaclng Lhe predlcaLe Lerm by lLs compllmenL. Cbverslon ls valld for any sLandard-caLegorlcal proposlLlon.
Cbvers|ons Cbverted Cbverse A: All S ls . L: no S ls non- L: no S ls . A: All S ls non-. I: Some S ls . C: Some S ls noL non-. C: Some S ls no . I: Some S ls non-
CCN1kACSI1ICN An lnference formed by replaclng Lhe sub[ecL Lerm of a proposlLlon wlLh Lhe complemenL of lLs predlcaLe Lerm, and replaclng Lhe predlcaLe Lerm by Lhe complemenL of lLs sub[ecL Lerm. noL all conLraposlLlons are valld.
CCN1kACSI1ICN kLMISL CCN1kACSI1IVL A: All S ls . A: All non- ls non-S. L: no S ls C: Some non- ls noL non-S. (by llmlLaLlon) I: Some S ls . (conLraposlLlon noL valld) C: Some S ls noL-. C: Some non- ls noL non-S. 6.7 Lx|stent|a| |mport and the |nterpretat|on of Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons
8CCLLAN IN1LkkL1A1ICN 1he modern lnLerpreLaLlon of caLegorlcal proposlLlons, ln whlch unlversal proposlLlons (A and L) are noL assumed Lo refer Lo classes LhaL have members. 6.8 Symbo||sm and D|agrams for Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons Chapter 7
7.1 Standard-Iorm Categor|ca| Sy||og|sms
SLLCGISM Any deducLlve argumenL ln whlch a concluslon ls lnferred from Lwo premlses.
CA1LGCkICAL SLLCGISM A deducLlve argumenL conslsLlng of Lhree caLegorlcal proposlLlons LhaL LogeLher conLaln exacLly Lhree Lerms, each of whlch occurs ln exacLly Lwo of Lhe consLlLuenL proposlLlons.
S1ANDAkD-ICkM CA1LGCkICAL SLLCGISM A caLegorlcal sylloglsm ln whlch Lhe premlses and concluslons are all sLandard-form caLegorlcal proposlLlons (A, L, l, or C) and are arranged wlLh Lhe ma[or premlse flrsL, Lhe mlnor premlse second, and Lhe cocnluslon lasL.
Ak1S
MAICk 1LkM: 1he predlcaLe Lerm of Lhe concluslon. MINCk 1LkM: 1he sub[ecL Lerm of Lhe concluslon. MIDDLL 1LkM: 1he Lerm LhaL appears ln boLh premlses buL noL ln Lhe concluslon. MAICk kLMISL: 1he premlse conLalnlng Lhe ma[or Lerm. ln sLandard form, Lhe ma[or premlse ls always sLaLed flrsL. MINCk kLMISL: 1he premlse conLalnlng Lhe mlnor Lerm.
MCCD Cne o Lhe 64 3-leLLer characLerlzaLlon of caLegorlcal sylloglsms deLermlned by Lhe forms of Lhe sLandard-form proposlLlons lL conLalns.
IIGUkL 1he loglcal shape of a sylloglsm, deLermlned by Lhe poslLlon of Lhe mlddle Lerm ln lLs premlses, Lhere are four posslble flgures.
7.2 1he Iorma| Nature of Sy||og|st|c Argument 7.3 Venn D|agram 1echn|que for 1est|ng Sy||og|sms 7.4 Sy||og|st|c ku|es and Sy||og|st|c Ia||ac|es Sy||og|st|c ku|es and Ia||ac|es kULL ASSCCIA1LD IALLAC Avold four Lerms Iour terms ulsLrlbuLe Lhe mlddle Lerm ln aL leasL one premlse. Und|str|buted m|dd|e Any Lerm dlsLrlbuLed ln Lhe concluslon musL be dlsLrlbuLed ln Lhe premlses. I|||c|t Ma[or I|||c|t M|nor Avold Lwo negaLlve premlses Lxc|us|ve prem|ses lf elLher premlse ls negaLlve, Lhe concluslon musL be negaLlve. Draw|ng an aff|rmat|ve conc|us|on from a negat|ve prem|se. lrom Lwo unlversal premlses no parLlcular concluslon may be drawn. Lx|stent|a| fa||acy
7.S Lxpos|t|on of the 1S Va||d Iorms of the Categor|ca| Sy||og|sm
7.6 Deduct|on of the 1S Va||d Iorms of the Categor|ca| Sy||og|sm
SLLCGIS1IC AkGUMLN1 An argumenL LhaL ls a sLandard-form caLegorlcal sylloglsm, or can be formulaLed as one wlLhouL any change ln meanlng.
kLDUC1ICN 1C S1ANDAkD ICkM 8eformulaLlon of a sylloglsLlc argumenL lnLo sLandard form.
8.2 keduc|ng the Number of 1erms to 1hree
1. L||m|nat|ng synonyms
wealLhy" and rlch" are synonymous, as are lawyer" and aLLorney"
no wealLhy persons are vagranLs All lawyers are rlch people 1herefore no aLLorneys are Lramps. no wealLhy persons are vagranLs. All lawyers are wealLhy persons. 1herefore no lawyers are vagranLs.
2. L||m|nat|ng c|ass comp|ements lnvalld (urawlng an afflrmaLlve concluslon from a negaLlve premlse) buL when LranslaLed lnLo sLandard form, valld. 8educe Lerms Lhrough: ! converslon (mammals" and nonmammals") ! obverslon (concluslon)
All mammals are warm-blooded anlmals. no llzards are warm-blooded anlmals. 1herefore all llzards are nonmammals. All mammals are warm blooded anlmals. no llzards are warm-blooded anlmals. 1herefore no llzards are mammals.
Cr by worklng wlLh Lhe premlses lnsLead of Lhe concluslon
All non(warm-blooded anlmals) are nonmammals. All llzards are non (warm-blooded anlmals). 1herefore all llzards are nonmammals.
8educlng Lerms can be done ln more Lhan one way.
llrsL premlse: converL and obverL (All clLlzens are resldenLs) Second premlse: conLraposlLlve (All voLers are clLlzens)
no nonresldenLs are clLlzens. All nonclLlzens are nonvoLers. 1herefore all voLers are resldenLs. All clLlzens are resldenLs. All voLers are clLlzens. 1herefore all voLers are resldenLs. 8.3 1rans|at|ng Categor|ca| ropos|t|ons |nto Standard Iorm
1. SINGULAk kCCSI1ICNS A proposlLlon LhaL asserLs LhaL a speclflc lndlvldual belongs (or does noL belong) Lo a parLlcular class.
Un|t C|ass - A class wlLh only one member.
SocraLes ls a phllosopher" 1hls Lable ls noL an anLlque"
! 1hey have no expllclL LranslaLlons have been provlded for slngular proposlLlons, LradlLlonally Lhey have been classlfled as A and L proposlLlons as Lhey sLand. ! unlversal proposlLlons do noL have exlsLenLlal lmporL. uslng 8oolean lnLerpreLaLlon, we flnd LhaL lf slngular proposlLlons are LreaLed mechanlcally as A and L propos|t|ons ln sylloglsLlc argumenLs and Lhose argumenLs have Lhelr valldlLy checked by venn dlagrams or Lhe rules seL forLh ln Ch 7 arlse.
Case 1: Slngular proposlLlons LranslaLed
valld (8arbara - AAA-1)
All P ls M s ls an P *s ls an M All P ls M. All S ls P. *All S ls M.
s ls M s ls P *Some P ls M All S ls M. All S ls P. *All P ls M.
Case 2: 1ranslaLe slngular proposlLlons lnLo parLlcular proposlLlons.
vALlu (All-1)
All P ls M. s ls an P. *S ls an M. All P ls M. Some S ls P. *Some S ls M
lnvALlu (lll-3)
s ls M. s ls P. *Some P ls M. Some S ls M. Some S ls P. *Some P ls M.
*ulfflculLy ln LranslaLlon: A slngular proposlLlon conLalns more lnformaLlon LhaL ls conLalned ln any slngle one of Lhe four sLandard- form caLegorlcal rpoposlLlons.
lf All ls " - whaL ls losL ls Lhe exlsLenLlal lmporL of Lhe slngular proposlLlon lf Some ls " - Lhen whaL ls losL ls Lhe unlversal aspecL of Lhe slngular proposlLlon
1hus Lhe soluLlon ls Lo consLrue slngular proposlLlons as con[uncLlons of sLandard-form caLegorlcal proposlLlons.
s ls " = All S ls " and Some S ls " s ls noL " = no S ls " and Some S ls noL "
8u1 lf Lhe exlsLenLlal lmporL ls kepL ln mlnd, lL ls an accepLable pracLlce Lo regard slngular proposlLlons as unlversal proposlLlons. (defaulL)
2. CA1LGCkICAL kCCSI1ICNS 1nA1 nAVL ADILC1IVLS Ck ADILC1IVAL nkASLS AS kLDICA1LS, kA1nLk 1nAN SU8S1AN1IVLS Ck CLASS 1LkMS ("attr|butes")
8eauLlful" and avallable for acLlve duLy" are aLLrlbuLes. Lvery aLLrlbuLe deLermlnes a class. 8eplace Lhe ad[ecLlval predlcaLe wlLh a Lerm deslgnaLlng Lhe class of all ob[ecLs of whlch Lhe ad[ecLlve may Lruly be predlcaLed.
Some flowers are beauLlful. no warshlps are avallable for acLlve duLy. Some flowers are beauLles. no warshlps are Lhlngs avallable for acLlve duLy.
3. CA1LGCkICAL kCCSI1ICNS WnCSL MAIN VLk8S AkL C1nLk 1nAN 1nL S1ANDAkD-ICkM CCULA "1C 8L" ("not to be")
8eplace words by a Lerm deslgnaLlng Lhe class deLermlned by LhaL class-deflnlng characLerlsLlc and may be llnked Lo Lhe sub[ecL wlLh a sLandard copula. All people seek recognlLlon. Some people drlnk Creek wlne. All people are seekers of recognlLlon. Some people are Creek-wlne drlnkers.
4. S1A1LMLN1S IN WnICn 1nL S1ANDAkD-ICkM INGkLDILN1 AkL ALL kLSLN1 8U1 NC1 AkkANGLD IN S1ANDAkD-ICkM CkDLk ("unarranged")
8acehorses are all Lhoroughbreds. All ls well LhaL ends well. All racehorses are Lhoroughbreds. All Lhlngs LhaL end well are Lhlngs LhaL are well.
S. CA1LGCkICAL kCCSI1ICNS WnCSL UAN1I1ILS AkL INDICA1LD 8 WCkDS C1nLk 1AN 1nL S1ANDAkD-ICkM UAN1IIILkS "ALL," "NC," AND "SCML"
ALL = every" and any"
Lvery dog has lLs day. Any conLrlbuLlon wlll be appreclaLed. All dogs are creaLures LhaL have Lhelr days. All conLrlbuLlons are Lhlngs LhaL are appreclaLed.
A" and an" = all or some buL dependlng on Lhe conLexL
A baL ls a mammal. An elephanL ls a pachyderm.
*A baL flew ln Lhe wlndow. An elephanL escaped. All baLs are mammals. All elephanLs are pachyderms.
*uCLS nC1 8LlL8 1C ALL so Some baLs are creaLures LhaL flew ln Lhe wlndow. Some elephanLs are creaLures LhaL escaped.
1he" = can be unlversal or parLlcular
1he whale ls a mammal. 1he flrsL presldenL was a mlllLary hero. All whales are mammals. Already ln sLandard form as an A proposlLlon (a slngular proposlLlon havlng exlsLenLlal lmporL)
*noL every = Some S ls noL (C) noL any S ls = no S ls (L)
6. LkCLUSIVL kCCSI1ICNS ("on|y" and "none but")
CaLegorlcal proposlLlons lnvolvlng Lhe words only" or none buL" asserL LhaL Lhe predlcaLe applles excluslvely Lo Lhe sub[ecL named. Ceneral rule: reverse Lhe sub[ecL and Lhe predlcaLe, and replace Lhe only" wlLh all" and none buL S's are 's" are usually undersLood Lo express All ls S."
Cnly clLlzens can voLe. none buL Lhe brave deserve Lhe falr. All Lhose who can voLe are clLlzens. All Lhose who deserve Lhe falr are Lhose who are brave.
*1here may be cases when only" and none buL" are used Lo convey some furLher meanlng. 1hus, lL may suggesL All S ls " or LhaL Some S ls ."
uogs are carnlvorous. Chlldren are presenL. All dogs are carnlvorous Some chlldren are presenL.
8. kCCSI1ICNS 1nA1 DC NC1 kLSLM8LL S1ANDAkD-ICkM CA1LGCkICAL kCCSI1ICNS A1 ALL, 8U1 CAN 8L 1kANSLA1LD IN1C S1ANDAkD ICkM
noL all chlldren belleve ln SanLa Claus. 1here are whlLe elephanLs. 1here are no plnk elephanLs. noLhlng ls boLh round and square. Some chlldren are noL bellevers ln SanLa Claus. Some elephanLs are whlLe Lhlngs. no elephanLs are plnk Lhlngs. no round ob[ecLs are square ob[ecLs.
9. LkCL1IVL kCCSI1ICNS
roposlLlons of Lhls klnd make Lwo asserLlons raLher Lhan one. lL asserLs LhaL all members of some class - excepL for members of one of lLs subclasses - are members of some oLher class.
S = employees" = ellglble"
All non-S ls " and no S ls "
All excepL employees are ellglble. All buL employees are ellglble. Lmployees alone are noL ellglble. All non-employees are ellglble and no employees are ellglble. (compound)
*ArgumenLs wlLh quanLlflers
1. ASS?LCClS1lC one," Lwo," Lhree," many," a few," mosL"
2. S?LLCClS1lC almosL all," noL qulLe all," all buL a few" and almosL everyone"
1hey afflrm LhaL some sLudenLs were aL Lhe dance and denles LhaL all sLudenLs were aL Lhe fance.
AlmosL all sLudenLs were aL Lhe dance. noL qulLe all sLudenLs were aL Lhe dance. All buL a few sLudenLs were aL Lhe dance. Some sLudenLs are person who are aL Lhe dance an some sLudenLs are noL persons who are aL Lhe dance.
**LxcepLlve proposlLlons are noL caLegorlcal proposlLlons buL con[uncLlons, argumenLs conLalnlng Lhem are noL sylloglsLlc argumenLs as we are uslng LhaL Lerm. 8uL Lhey may neverLheless be suscepLlble Lo sylloglsLlc analysls and appralsal. Pow an argumenL conLalnlng am excepLlve proposlLlon should be LesLed depends on Lhe excepLlve proposlLlon's poslLlon ln Lhe argumenL.
ln a premlse:
Lveryone who saw Lhe game was aL Lhe dance. noL qulLe all Lhe sLudenLs were aL Lhe dance. So some sLudenLs dldn'L see Lhe game. 1esL 1: undlsLrlbuLed mlddle All persons who saw Lhe game are persons who were aL Lhe dance. Some sLudenLs are persons who were aL Lhe dance. 1herefore some sLudenLs are noL persons who saw Lhe game. 1esL 2: vALlu (8aroko - ACC - 2) All persons who saw Lhe game are persons who were aL Lhe dance. Some sLudenLs are noL persons who were aL Lhe dance. 1herefore some sLudenLs are noL persons who saw Lhe game.
ln a concluslon: lnvALlu
ll 8C1P: 1esL all
8.4 Un|form 1rans|at|on
AkAML1Lk An auxlllary symbol LhaL alds ln reformulaLlng an asserLlon lnLo sLandard form.
1emporal always" = all Lhe Llmes"
1he poor always you have wlLh you. All Llmes are Llmes when you have Lhe poor wlLh you.
lace Where Lhere ls no vlslon Lhe people perlsh. All places where Lhere ls no vlslon are places where Lhe people perlsh.
ConLexL !ones loses a sale whenever he ls laLe. All cases ln whlch !ones ls laLe cases ln whlch !ones loses a sale.
Solled paper plaLes are scaLLered only where careless people have plcnlcked. 1here are solled paper plaLes scaLLered abouL here. 1herefore careless people musL have been panlcklng here. 8arbara AAA-1
All places where solled paper plaLes are scaLLered are places where careless people have plcnlcked. 1hls place ls place where solled paper plaLes are scaLLered. 1herefore Lhls place ls a place where careless people have plcnlcked.
Synonyms, wherever = place
1he hounds bay wherever a fox has passed, so Lhe fox musL have Laken anoLher paLh, slnce Lhe hounds are quleL. CamesLress ALL-2
All places where a fox has passed are places where Lhe hounds bay. 1hls place ls noL a place where Lhe hounds bay. 1herefore Lhls place ls noL a place where a fox has passed.