Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PROJECT TYPE:
CASE STUDY
NAME:
ADMISSION NO:
110343238385
SUPERVISER:
DR.A. KILIMO
DECLARATION
I, ALFRED. P .MTUI, declare that ,to the best of my knowledge the project presented here as a
part of the fulfillment for the award of Bachelor Of Engineering is a work of my origin .All
references used from books ,articles,reports,papers etc in preparation of this project have their
sources acknowledged in the reference list.
Signature..
Alfred. P. Mtui
May, 2014
Supervised by
Signature
Dr. A. Kilimo
May, 2014
ii
DEDICATION
I dedicate this project to my lovely parents, Mr. and Mrs. Pius Mtui, to my beloved sisters Flavia.
P. Mtui, Fides. P.Mtui and Glory. P.Mtui and my beloved brothers Lodigard.P.Mtui and
Innocent. Mtui, who were always in front way to give me support, Also I dedicate this to all my
friends.
iii
ABSTRACT
Mbahe village is located in Moshi Rural District 60 kM from MOSHI town in Kilimanjaro
region. Peoples living in this area have no access to electricity. It is about 4kM from the place
where an 11kV high tension line pass through to Kilimanjaro National Park (KINAPA).This
village experiences underdevelopment and low economy. So my plan is to perform a case study
for the possibility to electrify. Mbahe village by checking whether an 11kV line is viable to
supply the load of the village and if not the line will be upgraded to fulfill the load requirements
of the village.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express my gratitude thanks to my Supervisor Dr .A. Kilimo of Electrical
Engineering Department for his valuable guidance during the planning and implementing of this
project.
My deep appreciation goes to all staff members of Electrical Engineering Department for their
assistance towards making this project as successful one.
Im very grateful to my parents Mr. and Mrs. Pius. Mtui, my beloved sisters Flavia, Fides and
Glory. P. Mtui and my young brothers Lodigard and Innocent. P. Mtui for their support and
encouragement throughout my study period. Also I express my special thanks to my fellow
students and those who support me to accomplish this project.
Above all, thanks GOD for giving me life, strength and energy.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION .......................................................................................................................................... ii
DEDICATION ............................................................................................................................................. iii
ABSTRACT................................................................................................................................................. iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................................................ v
TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................. vi
LIST OF TABLES ..................................................................................................................................... viii
ABBREVIATIONS ..................................................................................................................................... ix
CHAPTER ONE ........................................................................................................................................... 1
INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................ 1
1.1: BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................... 1
1.2: PROBLEM STATEMENT ................................................................................................................ 1
1.3: PROJECT OBJECTIVES .................................................................................................................. 1
1.3.1: MAIN OBJECTIVE................................................................................................................... 1
1.3.2. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................... 2
1.4: SIGNIFICANCE OF THE PROJECT .............................................................................................. 2
1.5: PROJECT METHODOLOGY........................................................................................................... 2
CHAPTER TWO .......................................................................................................................................... 3
LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................................................................................. 3
2.1.1. DIFFERENT TYPES OF LOAD ................................................................................................ 3
2.1.3. LOAD FORECAST. ................................................................................................................... 5
2.1.4. LOAD SURVEY METHODS .................................................................................................... 5
2.1.6. BALANCING OF PHASES ....................................................................................................... 7
2.1.7. PLANNING ................................................................................................................................ 8
2.1.8. TYPES OF CABLES AND MATERIALS .................................................................................. 10
2.1.9. OVERHEAD LINE CONDUCTOR AND SPECIFICATIONS .................................................. 10
2.2.1. CONDUCTOR SELECTION ....................................................................................................... 11
2.2.2. VOLTAGE REGULATION ....................................................................................................... 12
CHAPTER THREE .................................................................................................................................... 13
DATA COLLECTION ............................................................................................................................... 13
CHAPTER FOUR....................................................................................................................................... 14
vi
vii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Load Consumption.......................................................................................................................... 5
Table 2: TANESCO Electricity Charges ...................................................................................................... 8
Table 3: Tariffs ............................................................................................................................................. 9
Table 4: Load evaluation for assessed prospective customers .................................................................... 15
Table 5: Cost estimates for construction of 11kV HT line to prospective customers ................................. 17
Table 7:Cost estimates for construction of LT line to supply power to M/S exact line at Mbahe RC
Church area ................................................................................................................................................. 21
Table 8: Total cost to fund the project ........................................................................................................ 23
viii
ABBREVIATIONS
KINAPA-Kilimanjaro National Park.
HT -High-tension.
TANESCO-Tanzania National Electricity Supply Company.
ERA-Electrical Research Association.
DF-Diversity factor
PTR- Proposed transformers.
LT Low tension line
ix
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1: BACKGROUND
Tanzania Electric Supply Company (TANESCO) is the utility company that deals with the
Generation, Transmission, Distribution and Sale of electrical energy in the Country. In Tanzania
only 15 percent of the countrys total populations of about43 million have access to electricity,
so the Company needs to do much effort to speed up the rate of electrification in the Country.
For TANESCO to electrify an area, the following conditions must be fulfilled.
1. The connected load of the area is substantial.
2. People living in the area are able to pay bills.
3. The infrastructure of that area allows construction of HT lines, establishment of substations
and the construction of three phase distribution lines.
4. There is high tension (HT) line nearby to an area to tap power for feeding that area, and also
the high tension (HT) line must be capable of supplying the new load.
1.2: PROBLEM STATEMENT
Mbahe village is located in Moshi Rural District 60 kM from MOSHI Town in Kilimanjaro
Region. People living in this area have no access to electricity. About 4 kM from Mbahe village
there is an 11kV high tension line passing to Kilimanjaro National Park (KINAPA).The Village
is underdeveloped and has low economy i.e. low income per person, however it satisfy the
conditions of the utility company for being electrified, as there is a large number of prospective
customers who needs electricity and also the infrastructures of that area allows construction of
high tension (HT) lines, establishment of Substations and construction of three phase distribution
lines and finally there is High tension line nearby for the Village to tap power and feed the area.
My plan is to perform a case study for the possibility to electrify Mbahe Village by using
Electrical power from TANESCO. This can only be confirmed by a case study.
1.3: PROJECT OBJECTIVES
1.3.1: MAIN OBJECTIVE
The main objective of this project is to establish the technical and economic viability of
Electrifying Mbahe Village.
1
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
New electrification is done in an area after the area is fully surveyed. It is necessary to find out
the load requirement of the area where electricity is to be supplied. This depends on these:
1. Nature of the area.
2. The population of the town or village under consideration.
3. The density of the population.
4. The standard of living of people in the locality.
5. Industrial development in the area.
The load requirements of an area can be forecasted by means of a load survey. For
standardization on a natural basis, the load survey and load development directorate of the
central water and power commissions in Tanzania have classified some of the loads to a certain
extent of the lines given in the last section. Some average can also be assumed for preliminary
prediction. (E .O.Taylor, G.A.Boal; 1996)
2.1.1. DIFFERENT TYPES OF LOAD
1. Residential or domestic load-This consist mainly of lights and fans, domestic appliances
such as heaters, electric iron, refrigerators, air conditioners for rooms, radio receivers, television
sets, electric cookers.
2. Commercial load-This consist mainly of lighting for shops, advertisements shops, fans and
electrical appliances used in commercial establishments-shops, restaurants, market places etc.
3. Industrial load-This type of load can be subdivided into sections depending on the power
range required.
4. Water supply-This load may be approximately estimated from the following data.
The requirements of water for rural area may be taken as 45 liters per day per person; for
semirural areas 70litres per day per person; and for urban areas, 90 liters per day per person.
3
These are minimum requirements. If municipalities can provide better facilities, the cases may be
surveyed and estimated individually. Duplicate dumping sets should be installed, and the spare
sets should always be ready for use because water supply is an essentially service and must be
available continuously without failure
5. Irrigation-The power requirements for this type of load is dependent on the number of
watering required for each kind of the crop, the area of the land to be irrigated, the nature of the
soil, the working hours and the gross head. The demand factor may be taken as 80% to 90% for
tube well irrigation and 50% to 60% for privately owned individually controlled pump sets .Date
applicable to loamy soil and crops requiring 4 to 5 watering per season. (Depshande.M.V, 1979)
2.1.2. LOAD ASSUMPTION
The salient feature in planning an electrical distribution system is to ensure that adequate supply
is available to meet the estimated load demand near future and more distant future. The most
difficult task is the estimation of the future load. In general approach there should short term
estimates, long term estimates and load forecasting (E.O.Taylor, G.A.Boal, 1966)
Short term estimates-The shortest possible term over which the load forecast should made is
the length of time required to construct and omission a reinforcement of the system occurs
during winter. Consequently no forecast covering a short period than one year can possibly serve
any purpose, for if there is adequate capacity at other seasons. Normally a 415V or 11kV
reinforcement scheme can be planned, constructed and put into operation within twelve months,
so as short term forecast of twelve months meets the minimum requirements.
Long term estimates-If for example, a reinforcement of an 11kVsystem is considered, the
minimum time concept of one year establishes the time by which the reinforcement must be
completed .Immediate economic consideration would then suggest that the minimum works
should be carried out in that reinforcement and the possible result of action on this line is that
within a year so further reinforcement will be necessary and the work already carried out
becomes either redundant or departs from ideal. If however the tentative sites of all the33/
11kVsubstations in say seven years time were known and the associated11kVsystems based on
those substations were designed now, an orderly plan would be achieved. If now reverting to the
short term load forecast, the existing system based is considered, the places which will be over
4
loaded within the next year and the appropriate part of it reinforced in accordance with the
minimum money is being spent at any time will result. Thus it can be seen that the minimum
forecast for the generation purposes of six or seven years can be used as the long term estimate
for an 11kVsystem .Long term 33kVsystem load forecasts would need to cover at least 10 years
ahead.
2.1.3. LOAD FORECAST.
Load forecasting is not an exact science and most such forecasting is done by studying trends or
history .A simple forecast of a future load in a small locality can be made if is known that a
specified number of houses are to be built on a vacant site. History shows that if there are more
than 50 houses in a group, the load to be met will vary between 1.5 and 7 kW per house,
depending on the degree of electrification and the type of house. A formula in common use for
estimating maximum demand is, After Diversity Maximum Demand (A.D.M.D) = (aN+8) kW.
Where a is a constant depending on the type of the property and the installed capacity and
N is the number of houses connected to distributor or a substation (E.O.Taylor, G.A.Boal, 1996)
CONNECTED LOAD/CONSUMER(W)
Below 2000
100
2000-5000
200
5000-10000
300
10000-20000
350
20000-50000
400
50000-100000
500
Up to 25kW
.Load Factor plays an important part on the cost of generation per unit. The higher the Load
Factor the lesser will be the cost of generation per unit for the same maximum demand.
Capacity Factor (Also called Plant Factor)
Is the ratio of the average load on the plant for period of time considered to the aggregate rating
of all the generating equipment
Capacity factor and Load factor became identical when the peak load is equal to the capacity of
the station.
Plant use Factor (also called Utilization Factor) Is the ratio of the kWh generated to the
product of the capacity of the plant in kW and the number of hours the plant has been in actual
use.
Diversity factor
Is the ratio of the sum of the individual maximum demands of the system to the overall
maximum demand of the whole system
It is always greater than one. The diversity factor of a station should be as high as possible because the
station max demand depends on the diversity of that load. If the diversity factor increases, the maximum
demand of the station becomes less and consequently capital cost of the station will be reduced.
2.1.7. PLANNING
When planning a new extension of a distribution system it is necessary to keep the following
main factors continuously in mind.
1. The regulation of voltage at the terminals of the consumers installations.
2. The sufficiency of the supply for the consumers present and future.
3. The cost of the supply both to the consumers and to the Electricity board.
The statutory requirement that the voltage at the consumers terminals should be maintained
within plus or minus six percent of the declared value must be adhered.
(E.O.Taylor, G.A, Boal; 1996)
Table 2: TANESCO Electricity Charges
Domestic low usage Tariff(D1)
tariff (T2).
tariff (T3).
Table 3: Tariffs
Domestic
General
law
usage(T1)
max(T2)
usage(D1)
Zanzibar
voltage
max(T2)
Tshs 273.00
3841.00
14223.00
14,233.00
14233.00
16,944.00
14,520.00
12,079.00
132.00
118.00
106.00
month
Demand charge per
kVA
Energy charge per kWh
221.00
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
10
Such comparison must however be treated in more depth ,since they must take into account
rights of way, clearance problems and planning permissions associated with the unsightly nature
of erecting bare conductors in rural and urban areas.
2.2.0. ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS
i.
Temperature
ii.
Humidity
iii.
Solar radiation
iv.
Rainfall
v.
Wind velocity
vi.
Altitude
vii.
viii.
Atmospheric pollution
ix.
Soil characteristics
x.
Lighting
xi.
Seismic factor
xii.
General loadings.
i.
The maximum power transfer capability must be in accordance with system requirements
ii.
The conductor cross-sectional area should be such as to minimize the initial capital cost
and the capitalized cost of losses
iii.
The conductor should conform to standard sizes already used elsewhere on the network
in order to minimize spares holdings and introduce a level of standardization
iv.
v.
The conductor diameter or bundle size must meet recognized international standards for
radio interference and corona discharge
vi.
The conductor must be suitable for the environmental conditions and conform to
constructional methods understood in the country involved
11
100%
Obviously, it is desirable that the voltage regulation of a transmission line should be low i.e., the
Increase in load current should make very little difference in the receiving end voltage.
(V. K. Mehta, 2002)
12
CHAPTER THREE
DATA COLLECTION
Mbahe village is located 4 kM from the distribution line
Number of prospective customers are 612 arrived to as follows;
Residential single-phase customers =500.
Commercial single phase customers (shops, groceries, bars, schools), =102
Commercial three phase customers
Milling machines =4
Dispensaries =2
Wood workshops =2
Water supply Schemes =2
Types of people living in the area are:
1. Workers.
2. Business peoples.
3. Peasants.
Type of the area: unsurveyed area.
13
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA ANALYSIS
14
LIGHT
FAN
RADIO
COOKER
E.IRON
FRIDGE
W/ PUMP
MILLING
SUBTO
M/C
TAL
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
Rate
No
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.45
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
4.07
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
0.38
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.5
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.38
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.36
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.24
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.39
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
1.45
10
0.06
0.07
0.02
1.5
22.38
2.38
TOTAL
16.6
Average load
1.66
NOTE
15
16
UNIT
QTY
PRICE
TOTAL
EA
MT
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
16
2760
4
8
76
8
6
6
12
426,229.60
1,536.08
39,650.00
8,500.00
4,616.09
633.00
7,500.00
17,720.39
10,000.00
EA
36
7,000.00
252,000.00
EA
EA
EA
MT
EA
EA
76
4
4
48
4
12
450.00
18,500.00
1,600.00
2,308.25
20,046.00
3,041.00
34,200.00
74,000.00
6,400.00
110,796.00
80,184.00
36,492.00
EA
EA
ROLL
EA
EA
MT
KG
KG
EA
4
6
3
6
16
16
10
10
16
16,522.12
6,500.00
272.61
7,500.00
3,250.00
462.72
1,240.80
3,500.00
1,250.00
66,088.48
39,000.00
817.83
45,000.00
52,000.00
7,403.52
12,408.00
35,000.00
20,000.00
12,784,853.41
6,819,673.60
4,239,580.80
158,600.00
68,000.00
350,822.84
5,064.00
45,000.00
106,322.34
120,000.00
1,278,485.34
14,063,338.75
843,800.33
17
14,907,139.08
STAFF
DAYS
RATE
1
1
1
4
8
1
1
2
5
5
5
5
5
5
10,100.00
8,400.00
7,100.00
5,600.00
5,769.00
5,600.00
5,600.00
TOTAL
20,200.00
42,000.00
35,500.00
112,000.00
230,760.00
28,000.00
28,000.00
496,460.00
KM
DAYS
RATE
TOTAL
2
2
5
5
2500
1250
25,000.00
12,500.00
37,500.00
SUMMARY
MATERIAL COST
LABOUR & SUPERVISION
TRANSPORTATION COSTS
SUB TOTAL IN TSHS
ADD 10% OVERHEAD
CHARGES
14,907,139.08
496,460.00
37,500.00
15,441,099.08
16,985,208.98
1,544,109.91
MATERIALS DESCRITPION
UNIT
QTY
PRICE
EA
EA
EA
1
4
6
268,675.00
39,650.00
4,616.09
EA
750.00
3,000.00
EA
EA
MT
4
15
3
450.00
6,500.00
4,500.00
1,800.00
97,500.00
13,500.00
SET
EA
MT
1
1
3
700,000.00
3,250.00
60,000.00
700,000.00
3,250.00
180,000.00
EA
SET
EA
20
2
1
2,421.92
1,000,000.00
1,250.00
MT
10
70,000.00
700,000.00
MT
EA
EA
10
6
6
70,000.00
7,500.00
7,500.00
700,000.00
45,000.00
45,000.00
EA
13,365,093.00
11kV
TOTAL
268,675.00
158,600.00
27,696.54
48,438.40
2,000,000.00
1,250.00
13,365,093.00
18,358,802.94
21,406,364.23
1,835,880.29
20,194,683.23
1,211,680.99
STAFF
DAYS
RATE
TOTAL
1
1
2
3
3
3
8,400.00
7,100.00
5,600.00
25,200.00
21,300.00
33,600.00
19
SPECIAL TASKS
EMPLOYEES
MAINS LORRY DRIVER
6
1
3
3
5,769.00
5,600.00
103,842.00
16,800.00
200,742.00
KM
DAYS
RATE
TOTAL
2,500.00
15,000.00
15,000.00
SUMMARY
MATERIAL COST
LABOUR & SUPERVISION
TRANSPORTATION COSTS
SUB TOTAL IN TSHS
ADD 10% OVERHEAD
CHARGES
21,406,364.23
200,742.00
15,000.00
21,622,106.23
23,784,316.85
2,162,210.62
20
MATERIALS DESCRITPION
UNIT
QTY
PRICE
TOTAL
EA
11
268,675.00
2,955,425.00
EA
39,650.00
158,600.00
EA
44
4,616.09
203,107.96
EA
48
1,349.31
64,766.88
EA
750.00
3,000.00
EA
450.00
1,800.00
SHACKLE INSULATORS
EA
15
6,500.00
97,500.00
base plate
EA
34,871.81
244,102.67
Stay insulator
EA
850.00
Stay wire
MT
70
2,308.23
161,576.10
EA
16,522.12
115,654.84
21
5,950.00
EA
21
6,884.21
144,568.41
4,156,051.86
415,605.19
4,571,657.05
274,299.42
4,845,956.47
STAFF
DAYS
RATE
TOTAL
MAINS SUPERVISOR
8,400.00
25,200.00
MAINS FOREMAN
7,100.00
21,300.00
MAINS LINESMAN
5,600.00
33,600.00
5,769.00
103,842.00
5,600.00
16,800.00
200,742.00
TRANSPORTATION
MAINS LORRY
SUB TOTAL IN TSHS
KM
DAYS
RATE
TOTAL
2,500.00
15,000.00
15,000.00
SUMMARY
MATERIAL COST
4,845,956.47
200,742.00
TRANSPORTATION COSTS
SUB TOTAL IN TSHS
15,000.00
5,061,698.47
22
506,169.85
5,567,868.32
COST
High tension lines
67,940,835.92
=16,985,208.984
2.0
166,242,207.4
=4,156,051.864
3.0
Substations
329,320,310.5
=23,784,316.84
Total cost due to fund the project
329,320,310.5
23
CHAPTER FIVE
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1: CONCLUSION
The project introduces about the feasibility study to electrify Mbahe Village, by performing a
case study for the possibility to check weather an 11kV high tension line passing to Kilimanjaro
National Park( KINAPA) is viable to supply the the load of the Village.
Since the proposed load obtained for the Village is 1,180kVA and the number of proposed
transformers obtained are four each of 315kVA, then according to the standards of the Utility
Company an 11kV high tension line is viable to supply the load of the village.
5.2: RECOMMENDATION
In Tanzania most of the rural areas are not electrified, due to this problem some of them miss
suitable development programs and other benefits associated with electricity such as Schools,
Hospitals, Churches, Commercial activities and other social services.
Therefore by electrifying Mbahe Village, the peoples standard of living will be improved in the
Village and other benefits associated with electricity such as Commercial banks and other
activities will be obtained. So by electrifying rural areas, the development of the Country will be
improved by improving personal economy.
24
Nov
Dec
Jan
Selection of Project
Title
Title Defending
Literature Review
& Consultations
Data collection
Data Analysis
Report Writing
Submission of the
Report
25
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
REFERENCES
1) Baylis C.R, (2005)Transmission and Distribution of Electrical Engineering Manchester,
Antony Rewe Ltd.
2) Boal G.A, (19660)Electrical Power DistributionOpenshaw, Edward Arnold Ltd.
3) Depshande M.V, (1979)Elements of Electrical power station Design McGraw-Hill.
4) Woodruff L. F, (1986) Principles of Electric Power Transmission, John Wiley &Sons, Inc.
Second Edition.
26