Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Edition No. 14
December 2002
ENGINEERING
S
T
For comments or suggestions, please call or write:
Chris Sackrison, Editor
McQuay International
13600 Industrial Park Boulevard
Minneapolis, MN 55441
Phone: (763) 553-5419
E-mail: chris.sackrison@mcquay.com
For more information on McQuay products and services, or to speak with your local representative, call (800) 432-1342, or visit our web page at www.mcquay.com.
2002 McQuay International
AGZ-A
(10 to 39 tons)
AGZ-B
(26 to 130 tons)
Chiller
Chilled Water
Coil
Fan
Run Capacity Perform Temp Range Pump APD Rows/fins TSP Motor size
Tons kW/ton
(F)
HP (in.w.c.)
(in.w.c.) (HP)
1
400
0.546
10
38.5 0.62
5/10
3.0
94.8
Total
Power
(HP)
426.1
3
4
400
400
0.547
0.547
14
16
27.5
24.0
0.70
0.79
6/10
6/12
3.08
3.15
97.3
99.5
417.6
416.3
6
7
8
400
400
400
0.543
0.543
0.543
20
22
24
19.2
17.5
16.0
0.94
1.10
1.25
8/11
10/10
12/10
3.32
3.48
3.63
104.9
109.9
114.7
415.3
418.6
421.9
C.W. Range
(F)
10
12
14
Chiller
($/yr)
40,035
40,034
40,224
Pumps
($/yr)
19,842
18,013
16,728
Tower Fan
($/yr)
2,821
2,821
2,831
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
70,957
71,954
72,396
Total
($/yr)
133,655
132,822
132,179
5
6
7
8
18
20
22
24
40,174
40,285
40,526
40,772
15,025
14,429
13,963
13,692
2,852
2,863
2,884
2,912
75,455
76,715
79,595
82,283
133,506
134,292
137,193
139,659
20
40
29,351
Total
($/yr)
71,115
70,033
70,689
11,002
70,081
1,596
28,872
18
20
22
24
Chiller
($/yr)
26,074
26,096
26,167
Pumps
($/yr)
15,175
13,784
12,792
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
1,593
1,594
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,275
28,560
28,846
Total
($/yr)
71,115
70,033
69,399
26,081
26,126
26,259
26,358
11,489
11,034
10,784
10,487
1,601
1,604
1,619
1,625
30,070
30,574
31,726
32,810
69,241
69,338
70,388
71,280
Moral:
Chiller
Capacity
Tons
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
400
Perform
kW/ton
0.546
0.546
0.547
0.547
0.543
0.543
0.543
0.543
Chilled Water
Temp Range
(F)
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
Pump
HP
38.5
32.1
27.5
24.0
21.4
19.2
17.5
16.0
Coil
Fan
APD Rows/fins TSP Motor size
(in.w.c.)
(in.w.c.) (HP)
0.62
5/10
3.0
94.8
0.66
5/11
3.04
96.0
0.70
6/10
3.08
97.3
0.79
6/12
3.15
99.5
0.87
8/9
3.25
102.7
0.94
8/11
3.32
104.9
1.10
10/10
3.48
109.9
1.25
12/10
3.63
114.7
Total
Power
(HP)
426.1
420.9
417.6
416.3
415.3
415.3
418.6
421.9
Chiller
($/yr)
26,074
26,096
26,167
26,211
26,081
26,126
26,259
26,358
Pumps
($/yr)
15,175
13,784
12,792
12,055
11,489
11,034
10,784
10,487
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
1,593
1,594
1,597
1,601
1,604
1,619
1,625
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,275
28,560
28,846
29,350
30,070
30,574
31,726
32,810
Total
($/yr)
71,115
70,033
69,399
69,213
69,241
69,338
70,388
71,280
C.W. Range
(F)
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
Chiller
($/yr)
40,035
40,034
40,224
40,327
40,174
40,285
40,526
40,772
Pumps
($/yr)
19,842
18,013
16,728
15,765
15,025
14,429
13,963
13,692
Tower Fan
($/yr)
2,821
2,821
2,831
2,839
2,852
2,863
2,884
2,912
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
70,957
71,954
72,396
73,657
75,455
76,715
79,595
82,283
Total
($/yr)
133,655
132,822
132,179
132,588
133,506
134,292
137,193
139,659
Total
($/yr)
71,115
70,033
70,689
69,981
71,011
70,081
71,465
71,556
Chiller
($/yr)
26,074
27,084
27,517
28,094
28,527
29,057
Pumps
($/yr)
15,175
14,562
14,049
13,616
13,245
12,923
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
1,592
1,592
1,592
1,592
1,593
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,275
28,283
28,286
28,290
28,293
28,297
Total
($/yr)
71,115
71,521
71,444
71,592
71,657
71,870
A Review So Far
Between tables 2 and 4, we designed a VAV office
building 16 ways and could only manage a 3%
improvement from worst to best. In this example, the
best was a 16F temperature range with 44F supply
water temperature.
Moral: There is not a huge amount of operating cost to
be saved by varying temperature and range parameters.
C.W. Range
(F)
10
Chiller
($/yr)
26,072
Pumps
($/yr)
9,915
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,273
Total
($/yr)
65,851
Chiller
($/yr)
26,074
27,084
27,517
28,094
28,527
29,057
Pumps
($/yr)
15,175
14,562
14,049
13,616
13,245
12,923
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
1,592
1,592
1,592
1,592
1,593
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,275
28,283
28,286
28,290
28,293
28,297
Total
($/yr)
71,115
71,521
71,444
71,592
71,657
71,870
A Review So Far
Between tables 2 and 4, we designed a VAV office
building 16 ways and could only manage a 3%
improvement from worst to best. In this example, the
best was a 16F temperature range with 44F supply
water temperature.
Moral: There is not a huge amount of operating cost to
be saved by varying temperature and range parameters.
C.W. Range
(F)
10
Chiller
($/yr)
26,072
Pumps
($/yr)
9,915
Tower Fan
($/yr)
1,591
S.A. Fan
($/yr)
28,273
Total
($/yr)
65,851
Edition No. 14
December 2002
nothing
AGZ-A
(10 to 39 tons)
AGZ-B
(26 to 130 tons)
Edition No. 14
December 2002
not
AGZ-B
(26 to 130 tons)