6/5/2014

25 Years Later: In the Crash of 1987, the Seeds of the Great Recession | TIME.com

FINANCIAL REGULATION

25 Years Later: In the Crash of 1987, the Seeds

of the Great Recession

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

By Christopher Matthews @crobmatthews

Meet the Disfigured Man Kissed by Pope Francis | TIM

Like

39

Tw eet

Oct. 22, 2012

51

3 Comments
Share

by Taboola

Ariel Castros Neighbor Sentenced To 445 Years In

The Netherlands Tells Immigrants to Learn Dutch o

Read Later

A Portrait of Domestic Violence

LATEST FROM OUR PARTNERS

Bowe Bergdahl 'Improving Daily' at German

Hospital, Pentagon Says NBC News
Men Charged With Toppling Ancient Rock
Formation Avoid Jail Time Huffington Post
Comet Outlives Predictions Weather.com
'Slender Man' Victim's Parents: 'Our Little Girl
Is a Fighter' NBC News
Legacies are on the line in Heat-Spurs II Sports
I llustrated

Scott Eells / Bloomberg / Getty Images

History doesnt repeat itself, but it does rhyme. This quote, often attributed
to Mark Twain, resonates with us for its pithy description of an irony we
encounter everyday: In a world marked by rapid technological, political and
social change, certain themes remain eternal.
Wall Street is not immune to this phenomenon. There have been few periods

Mario Batali Says His Sons Have Been

Cooking 'Since They Were Walking' People

RELATED

Black Monday: The 1987 Market

Crash Revisited Yahoo Finance
10 lessons from the 1987 stock
market crash MarketWatch

POPULAR AMONG SUBSCRIBERS

SUBSCRIBE

Japan's Booming Sex Niche:

Elder Porn

in its history that have been more dynamic than the past quarter century.
Since the 1980s, Wall Street has seen the emergence of computerized trading,
the application of advanced mathematical techniques and theories to trading,
and the total upheaval of the very structure of the markets on which
securities are traded. Yet even with all these changes, the essence of The
Street has stayed the same.

Email

Print

Share

Comment

Young Kids, Old Bodies

Follow @TIMEBusiness

This may be best illustrated by the great crash of October 1987. Twenty-five
years ago this week, American stock markets suffered one of its largest three-day declines in history, with the S&P
500 loosing 28.5% of its value between October 14 and 19. The total loss of wealth over that period was

Benedict Cumberbatch Talks

Secrets, Leaks, and Sherlock

approximately $1 trillion, according to a Presidential Task Force report on the crash.

At first glance the convulsions in the market in 1987 bear little resemblance to the financial problems we face
today. The 1987 crash was not the result of a financial crisis, nor did it lead to a prolonged recession. Look more

Obama's Trauma Team

deeply at the causes and repercussions of the crash, however, and you find many that rhyme with those of the
2008 crisis.
(PHOT OS: Occupy Wall Street, One Year Later: Protesters Return to the Movements Roots)
For instance, some of the main causes of the 1987 crash were new and untested financial instruments deployed in
the market by computer programs. In addition, it was the first modern economic crash to be a truly international
phenomenon, as it spread from New York across the globe almost instantaneously. Finally, the crisis of 1987 was
coincidental with Alan Greenspan taking over the Federal Reserve and Greenspans attitude towards crisis

http://business.time.com/2012/10/22/25-years-later-in-the-crash-of-1987-the-seeds-of-the-great-recession/

Get all access to digital and print

SUBSCRIBE

Most Popular
FROM BUSINESS & MONEY

5 Credit Cards You Dont Want In Your Wallet

1/4

6/5/2014

25 Years Later: In the Crash of 1987, the Seeds of the Great Recession | TIME.com

coincidental with Alan Greenspan taking over the Federal Reserve and Greenspans attitude towards crisis

management and regulation greatly influenced the 2008 panic. With these themes in mind, I spoke with Charles
Geisst, a professor of finance at Manhattan College and author of Wall St: A History, to discuss what the 1987 crash

5 Surprising Things You Can Buy With Food Stamps

What You Should Save By 35, 45, and 55 To Be On

Target

The Real Reason New College Grads Cant Get

Hired

Sizing Up the Big Question: How Much Money Do

says about the stock market today.

Its impossible to pin down for certain the cause of the 87 market crash, but the most important ingredient was an
overvalued stock market. The years leading up to the crash had seen incredible gains in the market. But as a
Federal Reserve paper from 2006 puts it:

The macroeconomic outlook during the months leading up to the crash had become somewhat
less certain. Interest rates were rising globally. A growing U.S. trade decit and decline in the

You Need To Retire?

value of the dollar were leading to concerns about ination and the need for higher interest rates
in the U.S. as well.

According to Geisst, there were two triggers, in addition to an overvalued market and deteriorating
macroeconomic environment, that led to an initial market break on October 17 and then a more-than 20% decline

FROM TIME.COM

Russian Forces Double Along Ukraine Border

Gangs of Powerfully Built Women Are Mugging

Tourists on the Streets of Hong Kong

Putin Phones Obama To Discuss Ukraine, White

House Says

Colbert Tweet Draws Accusations of Racism and

Theres A Scientific Reason for Why You Look Weird

In Selfies

in the S&P 500 a couple days later on the 19. One was the rumor of imminent interest rate hikes in defense of the
dollar by the new Fed chairman, Alan Greenspan. The market had experienced very high interest rates between
1980 and 84, and was spooked by talk of a return to those rates, says Geisst.
(PHOT OS: The Recession of 1958)

#CancelColbert

Another cause of the initial break was legislation filed by the House Ways and Means Committee that would have
eliminated tax breaks on debt used for mergers and acquisitions. Tax laws figure very prominently into valuations
of companies, and this caused investors to reconsider the value of their holdings.
Complex Financial Instruments
These factors caused investors to reevaluate their holdings, but one of the main reasons this market correction

MORE ON TIME

turned into a full-fledged crash was the arrival of new, complex financial instruments on the scene. As during the
run-up to the financial crisis of 2008, Wall Street was in the 1980s growing enamored with new methods for
hedging risks. The shiny new financial instrument back then was a derivative called a stock index future, which is
tied to the value of stocks that make up the S&P 500 and other indexes.

No such pipe, or this

pipe has been deleted

Money managers would use these index futures as a means to hedge their portfolios, through the use of computer
programs that would automatically sell index futures if the market declined. But these new techniques hadnt been
tested in volatile conditions. The automatic selling of the computers, combined with the efforts of other traders to
take advantage of precipitous declines in the market, helped create an atmosphere of panic which eventually led to
so much loss of wealth.
Its a parallel with 2008, says Geisst. There was new stuff being developed like stock index futures and the
techniques of arbitraging between them and developing portfolio insurance that stuff did not fall under
regulation. That was the outer edge of regulation and nobody saw it and all of a sudden in causes an enormous

CONNECT WITH TIME

Follow @TIME

5.7M follow ers

Like

5m

TIME
Follow

+1

+ 5,917,755

problem.
(PHOT OS: The Global Financial Crisis)
OUR CONTENT PARTNERS

Computerized T rading
It wasnt just that the derivatives being traded were themselves poorly understood by many market participants.
The fact that computer programs were being used to trade them was also a prime contributor to the crash. And
twenty-five years later, computers continue to play a crucial but controversial role on Wall Street. In fact, some
estimate that upwards upwards of 75% of all trades made on a given day are initiated by computers. This so-called
high-frequency trading has caused numerous problems in the markets over the past two years from the 2010
flash crash to an incident earlier this year that nearly caused the broker Knight Capital to go bankrupt.
International Financial Markets
We now take it for granted that financial markets are global. Multinational banks dominate the landscape and
investors can buy stocks and bonds across borders with relative ease. But this was not always the case. It was in the
1980s that stock markets around the world became deeply interconnected, with American companies increasingly
searching for capital abroad and vice versa. According to Geisst, the 1987 crash spread internationally in a matter
of hours, and was quickly a global phenomenon. Global regulations and standard practices increasingly allowed
trading stocks away from their home exchanges, Geist says.
This internationalization of the capital markets, of course, has only accelerated. One need only look to Europe
and to the fear with which bankers and policy makers eye the possibility of financial contagion spreading from

http://business.time.com/2012/10/22/25-years-later-in-the-crash-of-1987-the-seeds-of-the-great-recession/

2/4

6/5/2014

25 Years Later: In the Crash of 1987, the Seeds of the Great Recession | TIME.com

and to the fear with which bankers and policy makers eye the possibility of financial contagion spreading from
European to American banks to see how this issue remains a problem today.
Central Bank Intervention

Alan Greenspan assumed the role of Federal Reserve Chairman in August 1987, just a few months before the crash.
The dollar had been declining for several years due to an international agreement in 1985 to devalue the dollar in
order to help American exporters. Fearing that the dollar had fallen too far, Greenspan took measures to raise
interest rates to defend the dollar. According to Geisst, this action spooked the markets, which had gone through a
painful period of high rates in the early 80s. Greenspan learned his lesson, Geisst says. He didnt want to get
blamed for something like that again.
(MORE: Are We Already Planting the Seeds of the Next Financial Crisis?)
Greenspan and the Federal Reserve attacked the panic aggressively, issuing public statements confirming their
commitment to stabilizing the markets, and adjusting interest rates downwards. In fact, over the years, Greenspan
developed a reputation for aggressively combatting recessions and market convulsions so much so that traders
began to feel that the Federal Reserve would bail them out whenever the going got rough. As a report in 2000 from
The Financial Times described the phenomenon:

Some stock traders now call it the Greenspan put. It is a label borrowed from the world of options
trading for a widely held view: when financial markets unravel, count on the Federal Resere and
its chairman Alan Greenspan (eventually) to come to the rescue.

The 1987 crash was the debut of the Greenspan Put, and some critics argue that the complacency it fostered in
market participants economists call it moral hazard helped foment the sort of risk taking that led to the 2008
crash.
Back to the Future
The Wall Street of 1987 was surely a very different place than it is today. Computers were an auxillary tool in the
late 1980s, while today they dominate every aspect of the business. Complex financial instruments have only
become more so financial engineering the in late 80 looks quaint to the hypereducated quants of todays
Street. And financial markets across the globe are interconnected in a way that would have seemed inconceivable
twenty five years ago.
At the same time, all panics are essentially made of the same stuff. No matter how much the Street changes, there
will always be a tug of war between overconfident traders armed with new hedging mechanisms and the regulators
tasked with keeping them in check. Increasingly, humans will struggle with how to deploy computers to make
markets more efficient without having those computers hijack the process. And central banks will walk a tightrope
between protecting the public from economic calamity and distorting natural market mechanisms.
Sure, nobody will ever accuse Wall Street of being overly poetic, but even this industry full of hard-nosed capitalist
does, on occasion, rhyme.
MORE: Are We Already in A Recession?

Christopher Matthews @crobmatthews

Christopher Matthews is a Writer and Reporter for TIME.

WE RECOMMEND

The Eiffel Tower at 125: A Paris Landmark Captured

in a Classic Photo

The Battered Face of Germany: Ruins of the Reich,

Pictured From the Air

Sudden Death in Vietnam: One Ride With Yankee

Papa 13

LIFE With Jayne Mansfield: Vintage Photos of a PopCulture Icon

Girl Power: Photos of the Worlds Strongest

Seventh-Grader

ELSEWHERE ON THE WEB

http://business.time.com/2012/10/22/25-years-later-in-the-crash-of-1987-the-seeds-of-the-great-recession/

3/4

6/5/2014

25 Years Later: In the Crash of 1987, the Seeds of the Great Recession | TIME.com
Recommended by

3 Comments
2 people listening

Sign in

Subscribe

Sign In
+Follow Conversation

Subscribe
Share

Post comment as...

Newest | Oldest | Top Comments

MacroMusings

Oct 24, 2012

This is an excellent article, Scott Conner's post is astute. The Great Recession was not caused by "subprime"
mortgages. The seeds of the Great Recession had been built up over 20 years. Now in the past 5 years, the
financial authorities are trying to use old tools to fight a new problem. We need a "Great Reset." If Obama isn't
the one to put through the required initiatives, then find a replacement, but it's not Romney. I 100% blame the
problems of today on what George Bush called "Voodoo Economics."
Like

ScottConner

Reply

Oct 23, 2012

The common component is the lowering of capital gains, which encourages speculation and liquidation of
capital. Higher cap gains would be tantamount to a financial transactions tax, and would mitigate some of the
value of speculation, which has created the only "inflation" we see today in oil, debt instruments and the like.
Why do none of you look at this? Is it because you keep asking the perps why we're in the mess we're in?
Like

JamieWong

Reply

Oct 22, 2012

The Great Recession was caused by subprime mortgages. Computerized trading only accelerated it, but it's at
most an "accomplice". The problem was that many banks took subprime mortgages into their porfolios (through
security holdings or complicated derivative instruments, for example) and when the real estate price went down
their value plunged.
Like

Reply

Quotes delayed at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Interactive Data. ETF and Mutual Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. Dow Jones Terms & Conditions:
http://www.djindexes.com/mdsidx/html/tandc/indexestandcs.html. S&P Index data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions. Powered and
implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions.

2014 Time Inc. All rights reserved.

http://business.time.com/2012/10/22/25-years-later-in-the-crash-of-1987-the-seeds-of-the-great-recession/

4/4