Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
vs
4 ees who are not members of Beneco (not members of any labor
Ferrer-Calleja
Facts:
- June 21, 1985: Beneco Worker's Labor Union (BWLU) filed a
- Beneco protested but the same was dismissed by the med arbiter
rep of all the rank and file ees of P Beneco, alleging that: (copy)
(SC: Member-consumers of Beneco could form, assist or join a labor
- Beneco Ees Labor Union (BELU) opposed the petition on the
union)
grounds that:
1. It was the sole and exclusive bargaining rep of the sunject
- P asserts that the Certification Election was null and void because
A. Bargaining deadlock
mem-ees of P Coop who are not eligible to form and join union were
allowed to vote
- R Dir. and PR BELU submit that mem of a Coop who are also rank
and file ees are eligible to form, assist or join a labor union
Issue:
Held:
It cannot be determined if R Union was duly elected by the eligible
voters of the bargaining unit since "even ees whi are ineligible to
among the rank and file ees of P who are "non-members and
Only 37 ees are not mem of coop but 83 voted and 49 voted for R
Union
- SC: Dismissed
Issue 2:
Whether or not ees (rank and file) of a coop are qualified to form or
Held:
- 3 Jurisprudence:
- The labor union receiving the majority of the valid votes cast
based on the fact that as members of the Coop, they are co-owners
thereof