Microsoft Excel 10.

0 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [Case 8 AMARCO.xls]Solution
Report Created: 9/20/2014 6:20:20 PM

Adjustable Cells
Cell
$C$6
$D$6
$E$6
$F$6
$G$6
$H$6
$I$6
$J$6
$K$6
$L$6
$M$6
$N$6
$O$6
$P$6
$Q$6
$R$6

Name
Values of Variables X11
Values of Variables X12
Values of Variables X13
Values of Variables X21
Values of Variables X22
Values of Variables X23
Values of Variables X31
Values of Variables X32
Values of Variables X33
Values of Variables X41
Values of Variables X42
Values of Variables X43
Values of Variables X1
Values of Variables X2
Values of Variables X3
Values of Variables X4

Final
Value
2175.3424658
0
5424.6575342
0
6780.8219178
6219.1780822
8523.1164384
5476.8835616
0
2301.5410959
742.29452055
356.16438356
6400
0
0
7600

Reduced
Cost
0
-1.74623E-005
0
-1.81885E-006
0
0
0
0
-1.36241E-005
0
0
0
0
-1.9000000005
-3.7000000003
0

Objective
Coefficient
15
15.99998213
16.5
14.9999978
16
16.5
15
16
16.49998594
15
16
16.5
17
14.5
13.5
14

Allowable
Increase
0.2411894276
1.74623E-005
0
1.81885E-006
0
0.1929515421
0
2.42513E-006
1.36241E-005
0
7.27540E-006
0
34.906862813
1.9000000005
3.7000000003
2.9999999997

Constraint
R.H. Side

Allowable
Increase
32630.136986
11108.397856
79200
1.0000E+030
925.69982132
694.27486599
1.0000E+030
1000
3692.3076923
7384.6153846
7384.6153846
13839.212329
4273.1164384
13515.217391

Constraints
Cell
$S$10
$S$11
$S$12
$S$14
$S$15
$S$16
$S$17
$S$19
$S$20
$S$21
$S$22
$S$24
$S$25
$S$26

Name
Gas A LHS
Gas B LHS
Gas C LHS
Alkalyte LHS
Cat Crack Gas LHS
Str Run Gas LHS
Isopentane LHS
Gas A LHS
Gas B LHS
Gas C LHS
Marketing LHS
Gas A LHS
Gas B LHS
Gas C LHS

Final
Shadow
Value
Price
7.275958E-012
0.2
-7.27596E-012
0.2
0
0.2
14000
17
13000
16.4
14000
17.2
11000
14
13000
0
13000 -2.2000000002
12000 -0.1000000001
-2.04636E-012 -1.6000000001
13839.212329
0
4273.1164384
0
-1.81899E-012
0

0
0
0
14000
13000
14000
11000
12000
13000
12000
0
0
0
0

Allowable
Decrease
0
1.0000E+030
1.0000E+030
1.0000E+030
1.81885E-006
0
2.42513E-006
0
1.0000E+030
7.27540E-006
0
3.0206896556
0.1153846155
1.0000E+030
1.0000E+030
0.750000001

Allowable
Decrease
34523.116438
3255.7077626
5379.3103448
6400
5697.4885845
6000
7600
1.0000E+030
456.30044771
1786.1520782
979.18955156
1.0000E+030
1.0000E+030
26000

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
blended in gasoline
A
B
C
X11 X12 X13
2175
0
5425
15
16
16.5

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X21
X22
X23
X31 X32
X33
X41 X42
0
6780.82 6219.18 8523 5477
0
2302 742
15
16
16.5
15
16
16.5
15
16

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C not blended in gasoline
X43 X1 X2 X3 X4
LHS
356 6400 0
0 7600
16.5 17 14.5 13.5 14
816200

13
1
1
1
1

Sign

RHS

0
7.3E-012
-3E-012

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
1.6E-012

12000
13000
12000
0

13839.21
4273.116
4.5E-012

0
0
0

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline
Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X11 X12 X13
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33
X41 X42
0
4844 9156
9750
3250
0
3250 3583 7167
0
1322
30
32
33
30
32
33
30
32
33
30
32

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C
not blended in gasoline
X43
X1
X2
X3
X4
LHS
3062
0
0
0 6615
33
17 14.5 13.5 14 1538308

13
1
1
1
1

Sign

RHS

0.003793
-0.00024
0.000109

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
19384.62
0.000124

12000
13000
12000
0

9750.009
94576.92
0.000254

0
0
0

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
X11 X12 X13
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33
2175
0
5425
0
6780.82 6219.18 8523 5477
0
30
32
33
30
32
33
30
32
33

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
A
B
X41 X42
2302 742
30
32

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C not blended in gasoline
X43 X1 X2 X3 X4
LHS
Sign
356 6400 0
0 7600
33
34
29
27
28 1632400

13
1
1
1
1

RHS

7E-012
-7E-012
0

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
-2E-012

12000
13000
12000
0

13839.2
4273.12
-2E-012

0
0
0

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
blended in gasoline
A
B
C
X11 X12 X13
6775
0
5425
30
32
33

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33 X41 X42
0
4780.82 6219.18 3117 5883
0
1762 990
30
32
33
30
32
33
30
32

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C not blended in gasoline
X43 X1 X2 X3 X4
LHS
356
0
0
0 7892
33
34
29
27
28 1339523
0

13
1
1
1
1

Sign

RHS

4.8E-008
2.4E-009
9.1E-013

0
0
0

12200
11000
9000
11000

12200
11000
9000
11000

11653.85
11653.85
12000
-2E-008

12000
13000
12000
0

102578.2
2857.251
6.8E-012

0
0
0

ANS.5)

The solution to Question 2 has 6,400 barrels per day of alkylate, zero catalytic cracked gasoline,
straight run

gasoline, and 7,600 barrels per day of isopentane left over. Thus, additional quantities of alkylat
isopentane will
increase revenues only by their values, 17, and 14, respectively. This can be seen also from the
prices in Excels
sensitivity report below. The other two feedstocks increase revenues by more that their value

because the shadow prices are 16.4 for catalytic cracked gasoline and 17.2 for straight run gaso

The allowable increase column gives the largest increase in the feedstock amounts for which the
answers remain

valid: 925.7 barrels for catalytic cracked gasoline and 694.3 barrels for straight run gasoline . Th
are no upper limits for the other two feedstocks.

ANS.5)
The solution to Question 2 has 6,400 barrels per day of alkylate, zero catalytic cracked gasoline, zero
straight run
gasoline, and 7,600 barrels per day of isopentane left over. Thus, additional quantities of alkylate and
isopentane will

increase revenues only by their values, 17, and 14, respectively. This can be seen also from the shadow
prices in Excels
sensitivity report below. The other two feedstocks increase revenues by more that their value
because the shadow prices are 16.4 for catalytic cracked gasoline and 17.2 for straight run gasoline

The allowable increase column gives the largest increase in the feedstock amounts for which the above
answers remain
valid: 925.7 barrels for catalytic cracked gasoline and 694.3 barrels for straight run gasoline . There
are no upper limits for the other two feedstocks.

ANS. 6)
From the above portion of Excels Sensitivity Report, 1,000 more barrels than the minimum dem
A are produced

and gasoline B and C production is equal to their minimum demand . Thus, with the economy we
decrease in the
minimum demand for gasoline A does not affect the solution,

whereas, decreases in the minimum demands for gasoline B or C do affect the solution. The dec
revenues are given by

the shadow prices . The shadow price for aviation gasoline B is $2.20 per barrel and is valid until
decreases

by 456.3 barrels and the shadow price for gasoline C is $0.10 and it is valid until demand decrea
barrels

That is, each barrel per day decrease in the minimum demand for B and C increase revenue by $
respectively.

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline
Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X11 X12 X13
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33 X41 X42
2175
0
5425
0
6780.8 6219.2 8523 5477
0
2302 742
10
11
11.5
10
11
11.5
10
11
11.5
10
11

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C not blended in gasoline
X43 X1
X2
X3
X4
356 6400 0
0 7600
11.5 17 14.5 13.5 14

13
1
1
1
1

LHS

Sign

RHS

7.3E-012
5.5E-012
3.6E-012

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
1.6E-012

12000
13000
12000
0

13839.2
4273.117
0

0
0
0

626200

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked Gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
Variables
X11 X12 X13
X21
X22
X23
Values of Variables
0
0
7600 3250
9750
0
Objective function
10
11
11.5
10
11
11.5
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
1
Gas B
-2
1
Gas C
-2
1
Availability
Alkalyte
1
1
1
Cat Crack Gas
1
1
1
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
1
Gas B
1
1
Gas C
1
1
Marketing
1
-1
1
-1

Straight Run Gasoline

Isopentane
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
X31
X32
X33
X41 X42
8125 3250 2625 1625
0
10
11
11.5
10
11

-3

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

-1

-1

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C
not blended in gasoline
X43
X1
X2
X3
X4
1775 6400
0
0
7600
11.5
17
14.5 13.5
14

13
1
1
1
1

LHS

Sign

RHS

0
0
0

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
0

12000
13000
12000
0

626200

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked Gasoline Straight Run Gasoline
Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X11
X12
X13
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33 X41 X42
3133 684.21 6316
2250 6328.95 4421.05 6750 5987 1263 867
0
15
16
16.5
15
16
16.5
15
16
16.5
15
16

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-1
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

2
-1

-2
2

-1
1

14
-2

14
-2

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

-1

-1

-6
2

7.5

1
1

3
16.5

1
1

1
1

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C
not blended in gasoline
X43
X1
X2
X3
X4
0
3867
0
0
10133
16.5
17
14.5 13.5
14

14
1
1
1
1

LHS

Sign

RHS

-7E-012
-4E-012
-3E-012

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
0

12000
13000
12000
0

23116.67
-7E-012
-7E-012

0
0
0

808600

Case 4.1 AMARCO

Alkylate
Catalytic Cracked GasolineStraight Run Gasoline
Isopentane
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline
blended in gasoline blended in gasoline
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
X11
X12
X13
X21
X22
X23
X31
X32
X33 X41 X42
2175
0
5425
0
6780.8 6219.2 8523 5477
0
2302 742
15
16
16.5
15
16
16.5
15
16
16.5
15
16

Variables
Values of Variables
Objective function
Constraints
Reid Vapor Pressure
Gas A
-2
Gas B
Gas C
Availability
Alkalyte
1
Cat Crack Gas
Str Run Gas
Isopentane
Demand
Gas A
1
Gas B
Gas C
Marketing
1
Octane
Gas A
14
Gas B
Gas C

1
-2

-3
1

-2
1

13
-3

13
-3

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
1

1
-1

1
1

1
1

-1

1
1

3
16.5

-1

-6
2

7.5

-1

15
-4

-7

17
-13

New MKT constraint

1

-1

-1

-1

Isopentane
blended in gasoline
Feedstock
C
not blended in gasoline
X43
X1
X2
X3
X4
356 6400
0
0
7600
16.5
17
14.5 13.5
14

Sign

RHS

7.3E-012
3.6E-012
8.2E-012

0
0
0

14000
13000
14000
11000

14000
13000
14000
11000

13000
13000
12000
-2E-012

12000
13000
12000
0

13839.21
4273.116
3.6E-011

0
0
0

-1

14000

13
1
1
1
1

LHS
816200