Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A telecommunication company sells talk time through scratch cards. No revenue is recognized when
the scratch card is sold, but it is recognized when the subscriber makes a call and consumes the talk
time.
A monthly magazine receives 1,000 subscriptions of $240 to be paid at the beginning of the year.
Each month it recognizes revenue worth $20,000 [($240 12) 1,000].
A media company recognizes revenue when the ads are aired even if the payment is not received or
where payment is received in advance.
Bob's Billiards, Inc. sells a pool table to bar on December 31 for $5,000. The pool table was not paid
for until January 15th and it was not delivered to the bar until January 31. According to the revenue
recognition principle, Bob's should not record the sale in December. Even though the sale was
realizable in that the sale for $5,000 was initiated, it was not earned until January when the pool table
was delivered.
Johnson and Waldorf, LLC is an accounting firm that provides tax and consulting work. During
December, JW provides $2,000 of consulting work to one of its clients. The client does not pay for the
consulting time until the following January. According to the revenue recognition principle, JW should
record the revenue in December because the revenue was realized and earned in December even
though it was not received until January.
Pat's Retail, Inc. sells clothing from its retail outlets. A customer purchases a shirt on June 15th and
pays for it on a credit card. Pat's processes the credit card but does not actually receive the cash until
July. The credit card purchase is treated the same as cash because it is a claim to cash, so the
revenue should be recorded in June when it was realized and earned.
For example, a snow plowing service completes the plowing of a company's parking lot for its standard
fee of $100. It can recognize the revenue immediately upon completion of the plowing, even if it does
not expect payment from the customer for several weeks.
A variation on the example is when the same snow plowing service is paid $1,000 in advance to plow
a customer's parking lot over a four-month period. In this case, the service should recognize an
increment of the advance payment in each of the four months covered by the agreement, to reflect
the pace at which it is earning the payment
If there is doubt in regard to whether payment will be received from a customer, then the seller
should recognize an allowance for doubtful accounts in the amount by which it is expected that the
customer will renege on its payment. If there is substantial doubt that any payment will be received,
then the company should not recognize any revenue until a payment is received.
Also under the accrual basis of accounting, if an entity receives payment in advance from a customer,
then the entity records this payment as a liability, not as revenue. Only after it has completed all work
under the arrangement with the customer can it recognize the payment as revenue.
Motors PLC is a car dealer. It receives orders from customers in advance against 20% down payment.
Motors PLC delivers the cars to the respective customers within 30 days upon which it receives the
remaining 80% of the list price. In accordance with the revenue realization principle, Motors PLC must
not recognize any revenue until the cars are delivered to the respective customers as that is the point
when the risks and rewards incidental to the ownership of the cars are transferred to the buyers. - See
more at: http://accounting-simplified.com/financial/concepts-andprinciples/realization.html#sthash.9xGcoUUN.dpuf
Contractors PLC entered into a contract in June 2012 for the construction of a bridge for $10 million.
The total costs to complete the project are estimated to be $6 million of which $3 million has been
incurred up to 31st December 2012. Contractors PLC received $2 million mobilization advance at the
commencement of the project. No further payments have been received.
How much revenue should Contractors PLC recognize in the income statement for the year ended 31st
December 2012? - See more at: http://accounting-simplified.com/financial/concepts-andprinciples/realization.html#sthash.9xGcoUUN.dpuf
$10 million x 50%* = $5 million
*($3 million / $6 million) x 100% = 50%
Contractors PLC must recognize revenue based on the percentage of completion of the contract. Cost
incurred to date in proportion to the estimated total contract costs provides a reasonable basis to
determine the stage of completion - See more at: http://accounting-simplified.com/financial/conceptsand-principles/realization.html#sthash.9xGcoUUN.dpuf
agreed upon but the cash collection is subject to the risk of the buyer's financing falling through. As a
result, gross profit is only calculated in proportion to cash received.
For example, assume a developer spent $500,000 improving an apartment. He sold the property for
$750,000 but the buyer is going to pay in two installments one on January 1st and one on July 31st.
On the first payment due date, the developer receives a check for half of what he is owed, or
$375,000. His income statement is now going to reflect fifty-percent of the revenue and gross profit
earned since he has collected fifty-percent of the cash (i.e., $375,000 revenue, $125,000 gross profit
($250,000 total gross profit [$750K selling price - $500K cost = $250K] x 50% = $125,000.) (Realize
the actual rules governing accounting for real estate sales are more complex; this example is for
simplicity sake only to illustrate the concept of the installment method.)
Ways Management Can Manipulate the Income Statement Using Revenue Recognition
As you can see, management can, with only a change of revenue recognition accounting, drastically
alter the appearance of the income statement, over or understating revenue and profit. The exact
same contract using the percentage-of-completion method for revenue recognition instead of the
completed contract method will result in higher assets, higher stockholder equity, lower liabilities, and
a lower debt-to-equity ratio. The income statement will show much smoother earnings over a several
year period despite the fact that the economic substance and health of the business would be exactly
the same. This is where the investor must dig in and compare the revenue recognition of two
companies in the same industry to truly get an idea of who is performing better. The irony is that,
with certain exceptions, a business that uses the completed contract method is going to report no
income in the first years of the contract, meaning no taxes will be paid. The result is that the
shareholders of this business are going to be told they are earning less but their wealth is going to be
greater because there is capital being used in the business tax-deferred; a phenomenon very similar
to the use of LIFO for inventory valuation.
For most businesses, income is recognized as revenue whenever the company delivers or performs its
product or service and receives payment for it. However, there are several situations in which
exceptions may apply. For example, if a company's business has a very high rate of product returns,
revenue should only be recognized after the return period expires.
Companies can sometimes play around with revenue recognition to make their financial figures look
better. For example, if XYZ Corp. wants to hide the fact that it is having a bad year in sales, it may
choose to recognize income that has not yet been collected as revenue in order to boost its sales
revenue for the year.