Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
I NDIA O PINES
Search
18.9k
IndiaOpinesisAboutFreedomof
SpeechandTheRightToOpenly
ExpressOne'sOpinions
Contribute
ShareonFacebook
TweetonTwitter
YouMustCheckThemOut
SHARES
ActressShenazTreasurywalahaswrittenanopenlettertoPM
NarendraModi,AmitabhBachchan,SalmanKhan,ShahRukh
Khan,AamirKhan,andAnilAmbaniappealingagainstrapesinIndia.
MostSharedPosts
SelfPublishYourOpinions,Submit
YourLinks
Community
UnderstandingtheUberTaxi
Rapist
Hereistheletter
DearNarendraModi,AmitabhBachchan,SachinTendulkar,
ShahrukhKhan,SalmanKhan,AamirKhanandAnilAmbani,
IamwritingtoYOUspecificallybecauseyouarethemostpowerfuland
influentialMENinourcountry.
IamwritingtoyouasawomanwhogrewupinamiddleclassfamilyinMumbai.
ShwetaBasuPrasadWrites
OpenLettertoMedia,Reveals
Truth
IamwritingtoYOUforHELP!
Myparentsmaynotlikemesayingthis.Iapologizetothemiftheyare
readingbutthisisNOTMYSHAME.ItsTHIERSHAME.
Myfirstexperiencewiththeoppositesex,waswhenIwasjust13andgropedbya
man(neversawhisfacebutwillneverforgethishand)whilewalkinginthe
vegetablemarketwithmymom.Shehadjustgivenmetheworsthaircutandas
anangryteenagerIwasupsetatherandwaslaggingbehindasshewalkedahead.
IstillrememberwhatIwaswearing.Itwasherdress,mustardwithflowersand
littlebowinthefront.HowIhatethatdress!Asif,itwasthedresssfault.
Iwasshockedatfirst.Speechless.Hedisappeared.Ijuststoodthere.Tears
startedpouringoutofmyinnocenteyes.Itoldmymomwhowentmad
screaminginthemarketbutwhoknewwherethatmandisappearedto.Istill
rememberthedirtyfeelingIhadandthenumberoftimesIshoweredinmy
grandmomsbathroomafter.Thatfeelingneverwentaway.
8ReasonsWhyWeLove
BengaliWomen
ReasonsWhyWeLove
PunjabiWomen
Sincethenitwasnonstop.Iwouldtrytoarticulatethistomyparentsandwhile
mymomunderstood,mydadandunclestoldmeIwasimaginingit.Maybethey
justcouldntdealwithit.CANYOU?
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
1/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
WhenIwas15,IstartedgoingbytrainandbustoSt.XaviersCollege.Iwas
gropedandtouchedandfromallanglesandthiswasjusthowIgrewup.NotJust
MebutMOSTINDIANWOMENwhodonthavetheluxuryofcarsanddrivers.
AsateenagerIwoulddreamofandstillsometimesdreamthatIhada
machinegunandcouldkillallthemenwhotriedtogropeme.Avery
disturbingdreamforakid,dontyouthink?
AncientIndiaPreferredDark
Skin,NotFairSkin!
IgotmyfirstassignmentasamodelintheFYJCandIhadtogotoscreentests
straightfromcollege.SoIhadtodressnice,didntmakeitanyeasier.I
specificallyrememberthetimeIwentforanauditioninaredbodysuitanda
blacklongskirtwithslits.ItwasHELL!Ineverworethatagain.Asifitwasthe
dresssfault.
Idevelopedwaystodefendmyself,Ialwayscarriedabaginfrontof
me,myfistwasalwaysclenched,Ialwaysturnedaroundevery20
secondstocheckwhowasbehindmeandafewtimesIslappedmen
whotouchedme,Igotslappedbackmanytimestoo.Sometimessaved
bythepublic,MOSTTIMESNOT.
Mymombeggedmenottopickfightswithmenwhotouchedme,she
wasafraidofacidbeingthrownatmeorthatsomebodysomeday
wouldhurtmebadly.SheisSTILLAFRAIDandtodayshetoldmenot
totakeanUBERtomymeetingtomorrow.Hellya.BANUBER!Make
everyonetakeresponsibilityforthis.
MysistergotintoSophiascollege,wewereallexcited.Shewentbybusbutthe
firstdayshecamehome,shesobbedtraumatized.Amanhadputhishandinher
teeshirtthroughhersleeve,theentirebusride.Shejustfroze.Shewasakidtoo
andwasntequippedtoevenunderstandthis.IwasLIVID.Imsorrysisfor
tellingtheworldthis,pleasedontstopspeakingtome.ITSNOTOurShame.Its
THEIRS!
OneofmyfriendsincollegewasRAPEDonthetrainonherwayhomeinthe
ladiescompartment.Shewassickandwasgoinghomeinthe11:15break.There
wasnobodyinthefirstclasscompartmentgoingbacktoBandraatthattime,it
wasasuperfastmeaningitdidntstopatmoststations.Herapedherandthen
jumpedoffafterusingherscrunchy(hairtie)towipehimself.Shewastheonly
oneonthetrainandhadtolimpherwaybacktoherhomeinBandra,bleeding
profusely.Shewasjust16.Thisshefeltwashershamesoshedidnot
sayanythingtoanyone.
HolyCow!MindBlowing
FactsAboutIndia
IndianWomenThatInspire
andMakeUsProud!
ThePowerofWomeninBJP
Government
BUTITISNTHERSHAME,itsTHEIRSHAME.
MymomaccompaniedmetoHyderabadonashootonce.Inchuribazaar,a
cyclistgropedMyMOM.MydearrespectedandlovelyMOM.
INDIANWOMENINSPORT
SorryMom,ITSNOTOurShame,ItsTHEIRSHAME.
WhyamItellingyoumypersonalstory?
WellfirstIwantallwomentoSpeakUp.
LetsmakethisourMOTTO
ItsnotOURSHAME,itsTHEIRSHAME.
DivasofIndianDecor
WhoareTHEY?
THEYARETHEMENINOURCOUNTRY.
NotjusttherapistsandthesexualoffendersandgropersbutalsoourFathers
(sorrydad)andUnclesandBrothersandMOVIESTARSANDCRICKETERS
ANDPOLITICIANSfornotSAVINGUSorPROTECTINGUSbyinsistingand
protestingfortheLAWSTOCHANGEandRapistsandGroperstoBE
PUNISHEDSEVERELY!
Whydoweaswomenhavetofeelsothreatened?WHYhastherebeennosevere
actiontaken?Thishasgoneonforyearsnow.NotjustinDelhibutalloverour
countryandyeseveninBOMBAYORMUMBAIORWhateverthehellyouwant
tocallit!ItsNOTSAFE.NO!
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
RecentComments
PopularDiscussions
POPULAR TOPICS
TRENDINGNARENDRAMODI
JODHAAKBARMAHARANA
PRATAPARVINDKEJRIWAL
2/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
MybiggestfeareversinceIwaskidandeventodaywhenIwalkback
homeatnightfromyogaorwhenItakearickshawfromafriends
homeisbeingRAPED.Istillfeelthatfear.Iamstillamonguard.I
stillfantasizeofhavingthatMACHINEGUN.
Inthepast4yearsIhavebeenlivingandworkinghalfinIndiaandhalfinNew
YorkandletmetellyouIhavewalkedthestreetsofHarlem,theBronxand
Brooklyn(perceivedasthemostdangerousinNYC)at3amafterpartiesinshort
skirtsandfeltsaferthanIfeelinBandraat10pmonaquietroadfullycovered.
WHY??
LetstalkaboutDelhiourCapital.Iwasthere2daysagoandthedayoftherape.I
wantedtogooutandwalkbyIndiaGateandadmireourgreatmonumentsbut
couldI?!Why??
WhatgoodareallyourspeechesintheUSorJapanorAUSTRALIA
NAMO,ifnowomancanwalkfreelyinthestreetseveninbroad
daylightbyherselfintheCAPITALOFOURCOUNTRY.Isntthisa
SHAME?SHAMEONYOUSIR.
RELATIONSHIPSRELIGION
BOLLYWOODWOMEN
JAMMU&KASHMIR
TVSERIALSCRICKET
COMMUNITY
SEARCH
SEARCH
CustomSearch
SOCIAL MEDIA
ThisisourNO1issue.FIXTHISbeforeanythingelse.
ThisisaSHAME.AnditsYOURSHAME.YouarenowRESPONSIBLE
FORUS.
DISCLAIMER
Allviews,includingthoseexpressedinaffiliated
IbegallofyoufinegentlementhatIhaveaddressedtohelpchangetheLAW.
socialmediapagesofthewebsite,arepersonaland
Youarepowerfulmen.Isay,SHAMEandPUNISHTHEGropersandSexual
offendersseverely.KILLTHERAPISTS.
withourfundamentalrighttofreedomof
IwontaskforpubliccastrationwhichiswhatIwantandallthewomenwant
becauseIknowthisisunrealisticandthingsmoveSODAMNSLOWinourFINE
NATION.
anyview.Tocontributepleaseusethislink.
AllIaskforistheDeathPenaltyPlease.NOW!QUICK!
belongtotheirrespectiveownerstheyareused
IfthatstoohardorwilltaketoolongthenatleastLIFEIMPRISONMENT.
claimnoownershiponthem.
belongtothecontributingauthor(s)inaccordance
speechgiventousbyourconstitutionunder
Article19(1a).IndiaOpinesinnowayendorses
Tocontactuspleaseusethislink.Allimages
usedonthissite(barringtheonespurchasedbyus)
havebeencreditedwitha'ImageSource'andduly
forillustrativeandcommentingpurposesandwe
Putthemawayforever.
Whywasthismanwhohadrapedtwicebeforeoutonbail?
Andthengivenadriverslicense?YES,BANUBERTOO.Makeeveryone
responsible.
Imreadytodoanything.ImnotabigenoughcelebbutyouSachin
Tendulkar,AmitabhBachchan,SalmanKhan,SharukhKhan,Aamir
Khan,AnilAmbaniSIRSneedtospeakupasMEN(youarethemen
withthepower)
SAVEUS!
PleasedemandtheDeathSentencefortheRapists.
NOBAIL.JustDeath.
SuperstarsIbegyou,pleasetakeastand.UseyourSuperstardomandPowerand
MONEYandsavethewomenofourcountry.SAVEUS!
IurgeyoutoprotestorgoonafastordosomethingDRASTICsopeopletake
notice,thegovernmentwakesupandCHANGEStheLAWsothesemenare
terrifiedtotouchus.
Deathtorapists.Nobail.Justdeath.
ImagineAmitabhBachchanSir,AamirKhan,SalmaanKhan,Sachin
Tendulkar,AnilAmbaniifyouwentonafastorwalkedtothe
RashrtrapatiInDelhi.Ifyou,tookthisstandandmadethisYOURNO
1issue,howmuchchangetherewouldbe?!
Whyshouldweaswomenfeelsounsafeinourmotherland?!
Whyshouldweaswomenbeterrifiedandonguardallthetime.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
3/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Whywasthismanoutonbailaftercommittedtworapesalready?
MakeanExampleOfHim.
Anymanwhoeventouchesawomanshouldbeimprisonedforlife.
Bestrict,makeexamplesofthesemen,scarethosewhodaretotouchus.
SCARETHEMBYMAKINGANEXAMPLEOUTOFTHEM.
SAVEUS,Saveyourmother,daughter,sisterplease!
ThisisNOTOURSHAME.
THISISYOURS.
SHAMEONYOU.
DontsleeptillyouSAVEYOURWOMEN!
Withallrespect,
ShenazTreasury
Source
ImageSource
ShareonFacebook
Dec 11, 2014
By EDITORIAL TEAM
TweetonTwitter
in TRENDING
ShareonGoogle
97comments
Addacomment
RiteshThakurArmySchool
NowIamnotagainsther.Groping,molestationistheroot.weallagreetothis.Butifgovernmentmakes
amendmentinlawtopunishmolesters,gropers,rohtakgirlslikeincidentswillonlyincrease.Thisgivethose
criminalmindedgirlsawaytostopaguyandaskhimtogiveherathousandbucksotherwisehewillbetaken
topolice.Also,investigationforallthosecaseswillonlyincreasenumberofcasesandassuchcasearevery
muchinnumber,policewillbedoingonlyonething,monitoringpublicareasandcatchingmolesterswhichwill
affecttheirotherduties.
Butyes,ifpunishingaguytwicedoesn'tstophim,putabulletthroughhisheadnexttimeheiscaught(uber
case).Ifweareseeingcaseslikethis(ubertaxicase),nexttimeonwardsifsomeoneisfoundguiltyofsucha
crime,shoothimintheheadotherwisehe'llbespoilingmorelivesinfuture(wehavelearntthisnowthatdeath
torapeguiltyisamust).
Talkingaboutmolestation,thereisoneandonlyoneway,"toteachyousonswhiletheyaregrowing".
ChangeTHEIRminds,notlaws.
ReplyLike
74FollowPostEditedYesterdayat8:25pm
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Verywellsaidmate!
ReplyLike
423hoursago
RiteshThakurArmySchool
GandharvMohanthanksbrother.
ReplyLike
522hoursago
GurpreetSinghMultani
FollowSalesforce.com,inc.
Agreewithyoubro.Harsherpunishmentsisakneejerkreactionanditisnotalongtermsolution.
TheONLYlongterm(andpainfullyslow)solutionischangeinmindsetofIndians.Everyfamily
needstoteachitssonstorespectwomenandseethemasindividualsratherthanobjectstobe
usedfortheirownpleasure.ThisishowithashappenedintheWestandthisishowit'llhaveto
happenheretoo.
MostEuropeancountriesdonothavedeathpenaltybuttheystillhaveverylowcrimerate.
ReplyLike
220hoursago
View10more
MayankVedAryal
Follow
Well....allmen....howmanymendoyouknow....ItakestandsIhavedonethat....whonoticedorfollowed....
insteadIwasbeatenbypublicforbeingthehero....andthegirlintroublemovedbacksaying...Idintaskhimto
beatthatguy....somissshehnaazIamnotjustifiedbyyouaddressingallmen....andthismorningonlyIwas
travelingandtherewasthiswomenwhowasrubbingherreartomyarmscontinuouslyuntilIgotupandsaid
mamdoyouhaveanyproblem......whatdoyoucallthismenbeinggropedbyawomeninabus....itsjust
individualchangeswillleadustochangesotherwise...staywhereweare...noonhearsno.one....
ReplyLike
16FollowPost23hoursago
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Everyparentsasktheirdaughterstobesafe,nottowearthattypeofclothes,nottogoaloneetc.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
4/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Everyparentsasktheirdaughterstobesafe,nottowearthattypeofclothes,nottogoaloneetc.
Why?
Becausetheydonotasktheirsonstorespectothergirls.Parentsneverasktheirboysnottostareatagirlwho
issomeone'sdaughter/sister.
Doesallconditionsappliestogirlsonly?Boysdonothavemoralvalues?Boysdonotneedgoodparenting,
boysdonotneedtobetaughtwhattodoornot?
Iaskyougirls,doyourparentstreatyourbrotherssameastheytreatyou?
Answerisabig"NO".
Andwhenparentsstarttodoit,Ihopenotonlythistypeofcrimeswilldecreasebutgirlswillhaveahealthy
surroundingtolivetheirlifebeingtreatedashumansnotplaythings.
ReplyLike
8FollowPostEdited23hoursago
RizulDewanWorksatStudent
Yobrothyhvetherighttowearanythingoanywearitsuhwhosegonnachangeuaselfndonttouch
thewomenuntillunlesssheallowsuh...
ReplyLike
715hoursago
MohammadYaqoobDirectoratJammu&Kashmir
Asamatteroffact,itisalwaysMaledominatedsocietywithEgo&itisjustlotistalked&promised
esp.inourpoliticaladminstrativesetuppurelyforpoliticalgainsinsupportofourfemalegender
.OtherwiseentirenationalsetupshouldACT&ensureTheirSAFETY&DIGNITYwithoutanylacuna
,delayorexcuse.
ReplyLike
110hoursago
RuchiAroraWorksatGECapitalInternationalServices(GECIS)
Lifeofeverygirlislikethis....whatwebear,wearetoldnottotell....ordiscuss....Thepain,fearandanguish
staysbutnochangetakesplace.It'sawayboysareraised.Theyareallowedtoteasegirls,partyat
night....becausetheyaresafenotknowingtheiractswithothergirls.Somanywomansay"it'sokayformen"but
:why?Youhavewrittenthisletterveryboldly.Howmanyofuscanevenconfess???ButItrulywantachange
forallgirls...Formyfriendsanddaughters.
ReplyLike
6FollowPostYesterdayat4:44pm
JacobEmmanuelMKamladeviGaurduttMittalCollege
Ucan'tremainsilentbectheboyisastrongergeneIbeingmansaythat,relationoranymatterwith
forceisrobbery,andnolawgivesafreewaytorobber.
ReplyLike
GandharvMohan
112hoursago
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
Salutetoyousisterforstandingforacause(y).
AlsoIfeelsorryforyouandyoursister,friendwhogotwhattheydidnotdeserved:(
Itsashameforallmenwhodoitorwatchitdone.
Problemiseveryonewanttograbagirlwhoisnothissister,motherordaughter.Allelsearejustathingto
satisfytheirlust.
IMOtheyarenotrealmen.Theyareworstthandogsandtheyonlydeserveaslowdeath.
ReplyLike
4FollowPost23hoursago
UpasanaMathur
Pleasesir,don'tinsultdogsbysayingthat
ReplyLike
1522hoursago
GandharvMohan
Follow TopCommenterWorksatRoorkee
UpasanaMathur^^
ReplyLike
122hoursago
JacobEmmanuelMKamladeviGaurduttMittalCollege
Iwouldsayamputethemwhichmakesthemtobesaidasmen
ReplyLike
112hoursago
SumitaChatterjeePatna,India
Breakthespinalcordofsexualoffenders,letthemexperiencethehellandbecomeanexampleforotherswho
areagainstwomen'sdignity.
ReplyLike
4FollowPostYesterdayat4:53pm
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
Yes!Shootthemalldown,wedontneedthemalepopulation....right.
ReplyLike
KyrieTirzahMedlyn
211hoursago
FollowSr.CustomerserviceprofessionalatAmericanExpress
DeathshouldbethereactiontotheirAction!
ReplyLike
KapilDev
4FollowPostYesterdayat5:55pm
FollowSeniorPartneratKDAggarwal&Associates
IrememberyearsagowhenmydivorcecasewasgoingonandIhadtakenadrinktoomany.myfriendswould
alwaysmakeitsuretodropmepersonallyathome.andoncewhenIwasgoingtosimlainmycarandhad
takenafewdrinkstoomanythepubowneraskedifIneededadriver.Isaidnobutheinsistedandsenda
drivertodropmeatmyhotel.girlsmaybefoolishbutthepubownerandfriendsshouldhavemadesurethat
girlwhowasunabletostandonherlegsissafelyhome.otherwisewhyevenlockhomesandhaveIPCifthere
arenobadpeoplearound.weshouldeducatepeoplenottosteal.askingustolockourhomesorvehiclesis
infringementofourfreedom.
ReplyLike
3FollowPost23hoursago
RabindraBasuSIESCollegeofManagementStudies
HopethisletterreachesNAMOandsuchabilloramendmentorlegislationispassednfasttrackcourtsareset
up.
ReplyLike
3FollowPostYesterdayat4:40pm
HarshaliSatveMumbai,Maharashtra,India
Aboldsteptakenbyaresponsiblecitizen,butawomen1st.......Andnowtheresponsibilitylieswithallthe
biggiesshehasaddressedto,notassuperstarsorinfluentialpeoplebutasresponsiblecitizens!
Stardomandpoweristhemeanstoaccomplishthisverymuchrequiredtaskorinamoreresponsiblewayof
sayingit.....ADUTY!tobecarriedonbythefathers,brothersandhusbandsoutthere!
ReplyLike
2FollowPostYesterdayat3:52pm
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
5/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
JayPrakash TopCommenterWorksatSelfEmployed
Amongst100molestationcases10aresimilartorohtakcase.whenithasbeenproveduwilllight
candlesforthoseinnocent?
ReplyLike
415hoursago
View58more
Facebooksocialplugin
46Comments
IndiaOpines
Login
Share Favorite
SortbyNewest
Jointhediscussion
ArunNair 6hoursago
Ifprovedbeyonddoubt,therapistshouldbecastrated.Ifthereisnolawthenamendthe
lawsofthelandtoprotectourwomen.Molestersshouldbeimprisonedforlife.Ifthe
judiciaryisnotwillingtotakeaction,leaveittothepublictotakeaction.Afterall,ifthelaw
makerscannottakecareofus,wehavetotakecareofourselves.
Reply Share
vicks 6hoursago
Shenaz,thanxforthisheartrenderingletter,allmylifeIhvvotedfrthecongress,butthis
timeIhdvotedfrmodinthepromiseshemade,oftheotherg8peopleumentionIhvhigh
regardnthyaremyrolemodels,Iseriouslyhopewhtthypromissedoruaskthydeleiver,as
afatherof2growingupgirlsmyworstinternalfeariswhtunmanyothershvfaced,plsmr
primeministerdntletusdown.
1
Reply Share
Nz 6hoursago
Itisnotthelackoflawsthatactuallypromotescorruptionbutthelackofwillingnessto
implementthem.Makingmorelawswouldonlyhelpinfalsifyingthecrimes.
Dearwomen,ratherthanwhiningonmen,
makesureureproduceonlygoodmen,
andifyouarenotsureyoucanbringthemupgood,
thendontreproduceatall.
Reply Share
Deeps 6hoursago
Amputationistheonlyprevention!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!thesemonsterscanneverchange......
Reply Share
Deeps 6hoursago
Amputationistheonlyprevention!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!thesemonsterscanchange......
1
Reply Share
Tarun 6hoursago
Ms.Treasury,miserably,failedtonoticethatMANYcases.....whererapecasesare
falsified......whathappenstothem?IamnotagainstdeathpenaltyBUThowaboutlotof
existinglawsbeingmisusedbywomen?e.g.Dowrylaws?Soifawomenlawis
misused.....whoisculprit?womenthemselves?
BUT,nowayimeantosaythatthereshouldnotbeadeathpenaltyforrapist.Butithasto
betakenjudiciously.....notforeachandeverycases.Inthiscase,itwassortofclearthat
driverwasresponsible,sohanghim.........
Meanwhile,tillthelawisnotsostringent.......girls.....becautious.Gosafe.!!!
Reply Share
plaboni 6hoursago
ForallthosemenwhotakeastandagainstwhatSahanazhaswrittenIhaveaquestionfor
you.Whatisyouraccountabilityinprotectingthewomenofourcountry?
Ifashiftinyourthinkingdoesn'ttakeplacethenIndia
isdoomed.
Rapemustbeanonbailableoffence.Exampleshavetobesetsothattheseguysdonot
roamthestreetsfreely.Rapeissocialandemotionalterrorism.
Reply Share
Nz>plaboni 6hoursago
Itisnotlackoflaws,butlackofwillingnesstoimplementthem.
Reply Share
Pallav>plaboni 6hoursago
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
6/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
Pallav>plaboni 6hoursago
Seethevideoofwhatshouldalsobeanonbailableoffence.Whatisyour
accountabilityinprotectingthemenofourcountry?
ThestandisnotagainstwhatSahanazhaswritten.Itsagainstthecollateraldamage
thatitwillentail.
Reply Share
raddhaa 6hoursago
Whatkindofanimalsarethesemen?Dotheynotrealizethattheytoohavetheirown
motherandsisters.Unlessstrictlawsarenottakenagainsttheseterriblementheywill
continuebeingevil.Whyarestrictactionnottakenagainstthemandwhyisthegovernment
notdoinganythingaboutthis?
Reply Share
PallavSaxena>raddhaa 6hoursago
...andwhatkindofanimalarethosewomenwhowouldmisutilizetheselawstoget
theirway?Justlikethosewholedtomisutilizationofantidowrylaw?Thesemen
don'tonlyhavemothersandsisterstheyhavefathers&brothersandsonstoo.Lets
notportraywomendroppingfromheavenandmenfromhell.Lawsneedstobe
draftedonbalanceandtoensurethatnoinnocentispunished.Iamnotagainst
strictactions,Iamsimplyagainststupidsuggestions!
Whyputtingitonthesemen?Whatwerethewomendoingwhentheywereinpower
positions?WhynotwriteittoSoniaforlast10years?
1
Reply Share
PallavSaxena 7hoursago
IndiacameupwithlawtocurbDowry.Astrictoneleadingtoimprisonmentonreporting
alongwithwholefamily.NowSupremeCourthasadvisedagainstitasitwasbeingmis
utilizedbywomenfortheiradvantage.Howwouldthosemencomeoutofsickfeelingof
whattheywentthrough?Thementalagony&pain?Askingforpunishingforgroperscan
againbemisutilizedbywomenlookingforbenefits.Makingsuchstatementswithout
thinkingofwhatitentailsandwhatwouldbetherepercussionsisjustnotgoingtocreate
solution.Itsjustnoise.Therearealreadycaseswherewomenaretakingadvantagesandnot
allofthemarereportedjustlikenotalltherapesarereported.Notallmendeservethe
backlashofwhatafewdid.
IamafatherofagirlandyesIamafraidforwhatwouldhappentoher.IfIhadason,I
wouldhavetaughthimtorespectwomen.ButYes,Iwouldhavebeenafraidforhimtoofor
whatsomegirlcoulddobymisutilizingthelaworpublicsympathywhichwouldnevergo
hiswayirrespectiveofhisdeeds.
Reply Share
anonymous 7hoursago
Deathtorapists.Nobail.Justdeath.
MakeanExampleOfHim.
Anymanwhoeventouchesawomanshouldbeimprisonedforlife.
Bestrict,makeexamplesofthesemen,scarethosewhodaretotouchus.
SCARETHEMBYMAKINGANEXAMPLEOUTOFTHEM.
SAVEUS,Saveyourmother,daughter,sisterplease!
ThisisNOTOURSHAME.
THISISYOURS.
SHAMEONYOU.
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
7/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
DontsleeptillyouSAVEYOURWOMEN!
Whilereadingthis,icouldeasilyrelateitnotjustwithmebutalsoeverywomaniknownear
anddearone's.
ReallyhatsofftoyouShenaz..youareawesome:)
Reply Share
Deeps>anonymous 6hoursago
Shameonuguystowritelikethisforherrecommendations.....thisonlyshowsthe
illiterateandrottenIndianmentality!!!thisisthetruthanducanfeelitonylyifyour
sisterwouldhavebeenopenaboutherencounters.
Reply Share
Deeps>Deeps 6hoursago
MyreplyisforNaveenSharmaandkoko!!!!!ihopeiwasquiteclearand
audible....
Reply Share
NavinSharma 9hoursago
Againapublicitystuntbyastrugglingactressintheindustry.Whatcouldweexpectfrom
thesekindapeoplewhotakeseveryissuestocomeatthelimelightsopeoplecouldgetto
knowthatyestherewasapersonwhousedtobethepartofindustryandnowtheyareout
ofwork.Imeanwhothehellisshetoblamethesepersonalities.Sheisjustpretendingtobe
nestRakhisavant.
Reply Share
lamesharma>NavinSharma 6hoursago
LameSharma,sheisnotblamingthem.....nurcommentinghere,,,,y?Toprovethtu
existonplanetearth
3
Reply Share
mukta>NavinSharma 6hoursago
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
Goshyouarelame..@NavinSharma.
anditsnextnotnest..Lame
Ihavemoretosay....LAMEcontinued
1
Reply Share
NavinSharma 9hoursago
Againapublicitystuntbyastrugglingactressintheindustry.Whatcouldweexpectfrom
thesekindapeoplewhotakeseveryissuestocomeatthelimelightsopeoplecouldgetto
knowthatyestherewasapersonwhousedtobethepartofindustryandnowtheyareout
ofwork.Imeanwhothehellisshetoblamethesepersonalities.Sheisjustpretendingtobe
nestRakhisavant.
Reply Share
venkat 12hoursago
Completelyagree...thereshouldbeamedicaltest...liedetectortest....Onboththeculprit
andthevictim.....immediatepunishmenttobegiveniffoundguilty......nobail......theculprit
shouldbehanged.....
1
Reply Share
koko 16hoursago
Utalkonchannelswithsomuchofenergy..Useittokickoffendersaswell..don'tdepend
onanybody...
Reply Share
shaan>koko 5hoursago
killalloftheminfrontofpublic
Reply Share
SK 17hoursago
Hatsofftoyoushenaz...allthesemenshouldbehangedtilldeath.
4
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel adayago
ThisisthemostidioticletterIhaveread..Thisladysaidnorthingnew.Problemisnotwith
thesystembutitswithupbringing..Nmisseverymanonearthisnotsameihopeyougot
this.APMorsomefewpeoplecannotgotoall65millionmensincountryandaskthemto
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
8/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
this.APMorsomefewpeoplecannotgotoall65millionmensincountryandaskthemto
behave!Ihopeyouhavebraintogetthisthinginmind.Andourtargetshouldbehowto
stoprapefirstlyandthereshouldbeminimumcasesofrape.Thecountryyouaretalking
aboutUSAifseenin%wiserapearemuchmorewhencomparedtoanyothercountry.
AgainIamsayingitsallproblemwithupbringing.Ifthisthingisgoodthentheywillnot
becomecriminalbutnationbuilders.Sostopaccusingallmenoutthereandthiswillonly
makethegoodonesfeelshamenotthebadones.
5
Reply Share
prabiii>BhaveshPatel 13hoursago
Youmustdefinitelybeoneofthosewhogropeduswomen.Beashamedofyourself!
2
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>prabiii 11hoursago
Thisiswhatyourupbringingtoabuseanyoneandforyourkindinfomation.
LikeIdon'thaveanythinglefttodoonthisearthsoIwouldstockwomen.I
havemuchbetterthingstodoandalsomuchbetterupbringing.Iwouldnot
wastemytimeongirls.
1
Reply Share
Rebecca>BhaveshPatel 17hoursago
Shutthefuckupasshole.Youmustbeoneofthosegropers.Feelingbad'causeshe
toldafuckingtruth?Well,gofuckyourself.
1
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>Rebecca 11hoursago
Thisiswhatyourparentshavetaughtyoutoabuseanyone?
Hopegodblessyou.IdidnotfeelbadoftruthIfeltbadthatjustbecause
yourmovieisgoingtobereleasedtomorrowyouwritealettertomost
influentialpeopleofcountrybutwherewereyouwhenalltoseworstkinda
thingshappendinDelhiinMumbaiinUP.
1
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 21hoursago
TheFatherofournationandtheworldrenownedMahatmaGandhisaid:
Threequartersofthemiseriesandmisunderstandingsintheworldwouldfinishif
peopleweretoputontheshoesoftheiradversariesandunderstoodtheirpointsof
view.
Icannotbelievehowyoucanhavethegalltocallherrecountingofherown
experienceidiotic.Howmanytimeshaveyouwalkedintheshoesofthesewomen
whohavetolivelikepreyinajungle?Youaresoclueless.Letsjusthopeforyoursake
thatyouneverhavetofeellikeprey.
3
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 11hoursago
IdidnotsupportedthatmolestersbutwhatIsaidwasthelawisalready
there.Ifwewouldstartgivingdeathpenaltytoeveryonethensomepeople
fromyourhighsocietywillcallitImmoralprosecutionandwillcallfor
humanrights.Ihopeyouknowthereality.WhatIsaidwaswhycan'twe
teachourchildrenjustastheygrowup.Thisiscalledpreventionisintitbetter
thencrime?
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 11hoursago
Ifyouwouldstartbynotinsultingsomeonemaybesomebodymight
havethepatiencetoreadwhatyouhavetosay.Itdoesn'thelpany
conversationforonesidetostartcallingtheothersideidiotic.
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 9hoursago
CanyoupleasetellwhenIsaidthatthewomeniswrong?Iquestioned
thewaytoputthematter.Ididnotquestionedthetopicandalsonot
herpain.IguessIdidn'tknowhowitfeelsbutIknowitwouldbe
worstofonecanfeel.ButIdontthinkbysayingsomepeople"shame
onyou"woulddoeverything.Lawsaretherebutwhatitwilldoifcase
arenotbeingreported(inmanycases).
1
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 8hoursago
Womenarebroughtuptofeelshamewhentheyareviolatedandyou
callheridioticwithyourfirststatement.
Thenyouaresayingtoher"Ihopeyouhavebraintogetthisthingin
mind"whotalkslikethattoanotherpersoninreallife?
"Sostopaccusingallmenoutthere"doyouevenunderstandwhat
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
9/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
"Sostopaccusingallmenoutthere"doyouevenunderstandwhat
sheisaccusingall"thegoodmen"outthereabout?Sheisaccusing
themofstandingidlybywhilewomenandgirlsareviolateddaily,
probablyhourlyinthecountry.Surelyyouwouldagreethatweshould
feelsomeshamethatsomanywomenandgirlsmaybegetting
violatedbysleazymeninthelandyouaresoproudof.
Nobodyisaccusingyouofbeingsleazy,norissheaskingyoutofight
forherhonorbutatleastdon'ttrashherheartrendingtale.Sheis
boldtofightstereotypesandallyoucanthinkofishowshemight
causegoodmentofeelshame.
1
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 7hoursago
ThatiswhatIwastryingtosaythatfromthestartingitsupbringingof
kidsnotboys.AboyshouldbetaughttogiverespecttoEVERYONE
notonlyparticulartoopp.Sexandalsotogirlstospeakandbegiven
everythingthataboyis.ButcanyoupleasetellmeonethingIamnot
questioningherpainbutIamworriedaboutthetimingtodayher
moviereleasedandIfthisiswayofpublicitythatmostcheapestwayto
doso.Icansayyouonethingthatmyparentsandeldershavealways
taughtmetonottoanyonebeingsuppressedormolested.Andnot
mealmostmywholefamilyandrelativesfollowthis.
Reply Share
whomedoyou>BhaveshPatel 21hoursago
ThecountriesyoucompareIndiatoatleastattempttoprovideprotectiontotheir
women.
WhatprotectiondoyouclaimIndiaprovidestoourwomenandgirlswhenitlets
rapistsoutonbailtoroamfreeandrapeastheyplease?
2
Reply Share
BhaveshPatel>whomedoyou 11hoursago
Yehtheyaretryingtobutisthathelping?NoIguessthenumberdoesnotsay
it.YehIknowthereisnotanyprotection.Soforthisyouthinkgovernment
willputapolicemanforeverywomen?Wouldthisbelogic!
Insteadofwritingletterstopeopleoneveofyourmoviereleaseyoushouldgo
tosocietyandaskpeopletoteachtheirchildwhichwillhelpmost.
Reply Share
KapilDev adayago
IrememberyearsagowhenmydivorcecasewasgoingonandIhadtakena
drinktoomany.myfriendswouldalwaysmakeitsuretodropme
personallyathome.andoncewhenIwasgoingtosimlainmycarandhad
takenafewdrinkstoomanythepubowneraskedifIneededadriver.I
saidnobutheinsistedandsendadrivertodropmeatmyhotel.girls
maybefoolishbutthepubownerandfriendsshouldhavemadesurethat
girlwhowasunabletostandonherlegsissafelyhome.otherwisewhy
evenlockhomesandhaveIPCiftherearenobadpeoplearound.we
shouldeducatepeoplenottosteal.askingustolockourhomesor
vehiclesisinfringementofourfreedom.
Reply Share
shilpa adayago
Itsoootrueeeitssrealityywomenfacethisnjstcryhelplesslyybuttnowweshouldtakeestep
forourselfinstedofcryinggweshouldstronglyyfaceethem....nooneecanhelpifweourself
notputsteppforwardd...
Reply Share
MeghanaApte adayago
Notimpressed.ThoughitisatruthShenazTreasurywala,youaretroubledbysomeother
peopleandyouareholdingwrongpersonsresponsibleforcontrollingit.
Youmustbeaware,thatthisisnotthefirstyearofsuchincidences,thenwhydidyounot
say,"Shameonyou"forallthepreviousgovernmentswhoseapathybroughtdownthe
moralityofIndians?Theearliergovernmentneverallowedamendmentsinthelawsjust
becauseitwillhurtcertaincastes.Aretheynottobemoreshamefultobringourcountryto
thisstage?
WhyareyounottalkinganythingabouttheillfamousIndiannewsmedia,whoactually
earn,outofsuchincidences?Themedialikesandyesenjoysthedetailingoftherapeand
harassmenttowardswomensogaudilythatinsteadoffeelingguilty,themenbecome
curiousabouttheact.
Infactyougotcouragetowritethisopenlynowbecauseyounowfeelthatyessome
changeispossible.SoitisthefaithinModiandthelikesyouhavementioned,causingyou
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
10/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
changeispossible.SoitisthefaithinModiandthelikesyouhavementioned,causingyou
toexpectsomethinggoodtohappen.
2
Reply Share
StupidMeghanaApte>MeghanaApte adayago
Areyounuts?Doyouevengetthemeaningofherletter?Theletterisnottothegovt,
youmyopic.....itisforalltheinfluentialmeninIndiawhoarelookeduponthe
KhansofBollywood,theBigB,thegodofcricketSachin,thecorporategiantand
socialactivistAmbani,......Don'tpoliticizethings....Stupid!
11
Reply Share
StupidMeghanaApte>StupidMeghanaApte adayago
Andofcourse,thePMModi
Reply Share
chiragshah>MeghanaApte adayago
.......................Whenapersondoesn'tspeakwewillcomplainabouttheirobedience
andfear....Whenapersonspeaks,wewillaskthem,"Whydidn'tyoudoit
earlier?"....Peoplehavethistendencytoalwayscriticizeinsteadoflookingatthings
asastepintherightdirection.YoubasicallyreflectthetypicalIndianmentalityand
it'spathetic.Also,sheisspeakingonaparticulartopicsowhywouldshebringthe
mediaintothisletter?Whywouldshesay"Shameonyou"tothegovernmentwhen
she'stalkingabouttheoverallenvironmentandmentalityofsociety?Whyshouldshe
unnecessarilyconvolutetheentireletterwhenit'sbettertostayfocusedonactual
pointthatsheismaking........Youareonepatheticandsadindividual...Seriously.
Peoplelikeyouareholdingthiscountrydown.
2
Reply Share
anonymous adayago
whenyoureadthecommentsgivenonthisarticle,yourealisewhyourcountryisinthis
state.allthemenhaveattheendofithavesaiditisthewomen'sfault.Andwewonderwhy
thingsaren'tchanging....
3
Reply Share
AnonymousIndian>anonymous adayago
DontKillthePersonresponsibleforit.Killthediseasesocalledthemindsetand
attitudesofthepeoplewhocommittosuchacts.killingarapistdoesnotmakesure
thecountryissafer,therearemostcasesofincestrapeswhichdonotcometo
limelightduetofamilyhonouryetthevictimbecomesmentallyunstable...............
itsbetterwenwecomeupwiththeIDEAtochangepeopleandrealisethepreyed
womenissomeoneelsesister,mother,orbetterhalf......................justhinkwether
heisahumanoramundanebeast.....................
Reply Share
me>anonymous adayago
True
Reply Share
Oneofu>me adayago
Iagree...Killthecausenottheperson...Bloodythecauseishangingwiththe
man..Chopoffhispartandlethimlive.
Itstimewhenpeopleshouldunderstandwhatrespecteveryindividual
deserves.Yiseveryonearguingwitheachother.Bettertakeapledgetohelp
andsupportotherpeople.Thisletteris.Surelyanoutburstofagirlsemotion..
Everygirldreamsofcarryingagunandkillingsuchpeopleonspot.Thatis
thefearmenhaveimplantedinwomen.Hightimepeopleworkontheir
mentalityandbecomemorehuman.
Subscribe
Reply Share
AddDisqustoyoursite
Privacy
INDIA OPINES
India Opines 2014
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
11/12
12/12/2014
ItsNotOurShame,ItsYourShameSaysShenazTreasurywalatoPMModi
http://indiaopines.com/openletternarendramodisalmankhananilambanishenaztreasurywala/
12/12