Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The staircase method is more efficient for estimating the threshold, because the level
samples are adaptively clustered around the psychometric threshold (Dixon & Mood
1948). The method works as follow:
The session starts with trials at suprathreshold levels, then, depending on the
subject's responses, the next trials use either a higher or lower stimulus level based
on a simple rule: the level is lowered after a given number of consecutive correct
responses and raised after a number of consecutive incorrect responses. A reversal
occurs when the stimulus level has been lowered and then subsequently raised. This
process is repeated until a given number of reversals has been reached. The
threshold is then estimated by averaging the values of the stimulus levels obtained
for the last few reversals.
The increase and decrease rates, the number of reversals, and the number of
consecutive responses can be customized in the properties panel (see Kaernbach
1991, Brown 1996, Garcia-Prez 1998 for recommendations on the design of
efficient and reliable staircases):
Initial value (mean range) value for the parameter will be chosen in
the interval defined by mean range. The starting interval should
correspond to a suprathreshold level. Note that both mean and range
parameters can be specified using either numbers, variables, or
any mathematical expression.
First and last reversals define the set of reversals used to determine
the threshold estimation. The response collection ends when the last
reversal occurs.
Step size indicates how the parameter value is changed across trials,
either in terms of relative rate expressed in % or in terms of absolute
units. Note that for absolute step size in particular, it is important to
make sure the resulting values make sense in terms of stimulus
properties. For example, if negative values are produced it may be
needed to use a "clamping" expression to limit the parameter to some
minimum values when specifying some stimulus properties:
min+rect([parameter]-min) where min is the minimum value
for [parameter]
so the evaluation results in:
min if [parameter] < min
[parameter] otherwise
Decrease rates before and after the first reversal are the decrease
rates either in % for relative step size or absolute units to apply before
and after the first actual reversal (not the one with its index specified
above). They can be set so the parameter decreases faster at the start
of the staircase until the first actual reversal occurs (first incorrect
response), then so the decrease rate is reduced to a level which
minimizes the risk of getting stuck at a level far below the psychometric
threshold.
Increase rate is the increase rate either in % for relative step size or
absolute units to apply to the parameter value after each incorrect
response.
If you are not very familiar with the staircase method, we highly recommend
that you experiment with this interactive widget. This widget illustrates how
the various staircase parameters affect the data collection and the threshold
estimation (using a psychometric function as model of the decision process
performed by a subject in a 2AFC task): 1) set the up/down rule of your
staircase method by specifying the number of consecutive incorrect and
correct responses as well as the increasing and decreasing rates. The
indicated performance criterion is derived from these properties. 2) Select a
psychometric function to model the decision process with some values for its
alpha and beta parameters (the indicated data point in the right plot indicate
the theoretical threshold at performance criterion for the decision process). 3)
The left plot shows a simulated experiment using the specified staircase
method and the decision model. Compare the estimated and theoretical
thresholds as a function of the various parameters!
Here are few examples of plot obtained using this method once it is completed
(see Plotter panel):
Note that, once plotted, the staircase results can be further customized by selecting
how the threshold average is estimated:
whether the troughs, the peaks or both are used in this estimation (only
troughs are used by default).
The staircase method is relatively efficient, but at a cost: it does not generate the
same amount of information regarding the shape of the psychometric function as do
a method of constant stimuli. Despite this, it would be still possible to estimate the
threshold and slope by fitting psychometric functions to the obtained data, although
estimates of psychometric slope are likely to be more variable than those produced
by the method of constant stimuli (for a reasonable sampling of the psychometric
function).
The next method provides an efficient way to estimate both threshold and slope by
fitting a psychometric function on the fly using a Bayesian approach.