Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Boston University is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Studies in
Romanticism.
http://www.jstor.org
IN ROMANTICISM
STUDIES
VOLUME
AUTUMN
Blake
ROBERT
BLAKE'S
NUMBER
I965
F. GLECKNER
Yet
Until quite recently, the average view has been that of J.G. Davies:
over and above his five senses a latent power
"possesses
by
man
of which
i. Auguries
Natural
Religion),
in the Keynes
AR
edition
on which
the quotation
appears. Abbrevia
onMan), NNR
Aphorisms
(There Is No
(All Religions Are One), NB
(Rossetti ms. or Notebook
poems),
(Annotations
to Lavater's
Vision
legro" and
Translation
2. The
Theology
ofWilliam
Blake
(Oxford,
1948), p.
132.
[1]
"L' Al
"New
ROBERT
F. GLECKNER
have come to see that the imagination is not something used in lieu of
the senses, not a transcendent faculty, but rather one which is inex
senses.
Frye showed
tricably bound up with the operation of the
to the
most
in
that
Blake's
major objection
clearly
Fearful Symmetry
was
to
he
Locke's
inherited,
sep
eighteenth-century Weltanschauung
aration of existence from perception: "If there is a reality beyond our
we must increase the power and coherence of our percep
perception
we
shall never reach reality in any other way." Yet, while
for
tion,
of existence and perception is
Frye's analysis of Blake's reintegration
his
of
the relationship Blake saw
correct,
undoubtedly
explication
as it
between the senses and imagination seems to me misleading
stands, or perhaps, merely incomplete. "We use five senses in percep
tion," he writes, "but ifwe used fifteen we should still have only a
not see: the eye is a lens for themind to
single mind. The eye does
look through. Perception,
then, is not something we do with our
a
is
it
act."3
Blake did say that "Mental Things are
mental
senses;
as
but
alone Real"
Frye cautions, for Blake "mental,"
(VLJ, K617),
all mean
the same thing.4 More
and "intellectual"
"imaginative,"
terms do tend to deny the validity of an
all
three
of
these
important,
Frye's discussion of the
opposition between body and soul. However,
denial
and
his description of the
between
this
implicit
relationship
to
separate rather than integrate the
perceptual process tends oddly
not how much more
senses and
the
Further,
question is
imagination.
man would seewith fifteen eyes instead of one, but rather how much
more
senses than five, or with his
more he would
perceive with
senses "cleansed."
For Blake imaginative or total perception is not
as
amatter of
to "vision"; it is a fourfold in
opposed
"sight"
merely
man
(what Blake calls "the human form di
tegration of thewhole
senses.
vine"), and this involves all the
on a passage from The
his
Thus Harold Bloom,
analysis
basing
to
look at further in a mo
Marriage ofHeaven andHell which I wish
Y.,
1963),
p. 89.
BLAKE
AND
THE
SENSES
too draws
to Blake's
The Marriage Nurmi
particular" attention
key
"
& numerous senses,' while also pointing out a
'enlarged
phrase,
in the second "Memorable
(on "Isaiah
neglected key "detail
" Fancy"
'I saw no God, nor heard any,'
'in a
and Ezekiel):
says Isaiah,
finite organical perception; but my senses discover'd the infinite in
"6 A further
every thing ....'
step still is taken by Peter Fisher:' Vi
he writes, "was knowledge
based on senses
sionary knowledge,"
which surpassed our senses. . . and an intellect which surpassed our
For Blake "Reality was not to be
ratio of the things of memory."
nor
as
as pure
as vision of
the
idea
of
conceived
spirit,
subjectivity, but
which spiritwas an abstraction, and the subject-object relationship,
a
as
some
degree."7 If, Ortega says, "Every object of depth withholds
secret from us," this is
of
because
the
only
externality
object is in
to the
or
point of (or, indeed, because of) the obscuring
obliterating of its relationship with subject.
The point that I shall try to make is considerably more than an
not
matter
only the central
epistemological quibble, since it involves
of perception, but also such other subjects as the origins of religion
sisted upon
I shall do so
I shall touch upon thesematters in the
following pages,
not with the intention of
or
explicating Blake's poems and prophecies,
his mythography;
neither am I interested here in tracing the possible
sources of his ideas
(others have done this better than I could). What
I shall do is analyze closely a key passage in The Marriage and by ref
erence to Blake's other uses of the same basic ideas, in his poetry and
and the cumulative
prose, demonstrate his consistent development,
senses and
of
the
between
the
significance,
Imagination,
relationship
or between sense
perception and what he called "Spiritual Sensation."8
The
passage
I refer to should be
quoted
in full:
and adorning
them with the properties of woods,
and whatever
their enlarged & numerous
rivers, moun
senses could
percieve.
6. Martin K. Nurmi, Blake's "Marriage ofHeaven
andHell"
(Kent, Ohio,
1957), pp.
is on Ki 53-154.
41, 43. The second "Memorable
Fancy"
7. The Valley of Vision, ed. Northrop
Frye (Toronto,
1961), pp. 245, 239.
8. Letter to Trusler, August
also uses the phrase "Spiritual
23, 1799 (K794). Blake
both of these to "bodily
sensation*' (AR, K98).
Perception''
(AfR, K473),
opposing
4
And
particularly
itsmental deity;
Till
system
by attempting
ROBERT
they studied
F. GLECKNER
the genius
country,
placing
it under
was
some took
the vulgar
formed, which
of, & enslav'd
advantage
to realize or abstract the mental
deities from their
thus be
objects:
gan Priesthood;
Choosing
forms of worship
from poetic
tales.
Eden
that "All deities reside in the human breast" and their "poetic
were
accounts of
tales" (or mythologies)
imaginative
imaginative
true. These "mental deities" were alone real; in
thus
reality?and
knew
to
In his Annotations
(AR, K98).
Reynolds he puts it another way:
"All Forms are Perfect in the Poet's Mind, but these are not Abstract
from Nature, but are from Imagination."10
ed nor Compounded
This capacity to discern mental reality Blake also attributes to the
Biblical prophets and to the disciples: they described "what they saw
inVision as real and existing men, whom they saw with their imagi
native and immortal organs."11 Thus to all true artists (and for Blake
all men are judged as artists),12 such asMilton, "Mountains, Clouds,
indeed
Rivers, Trees appear Humanized,"13
11. DC, K576. That Blake was early attracted by this idea is evident from his ap
statement: "Him, who humanises
all that iswithin and around
of Lavater's
probation
himself, adore . . ." (AL, K71).
12. "The Whole
Is The Arts"
Business of Man
(The Laocoon, K777).
and the famous poem in
13.MI, K618. Cf. FZ, K315; DC, K576; f, K665, K709;
the letter to Thomas
Butts, October
2, 1800
(K804-806).
BLAKE
AND
THE
SENSES
Divine
nation, inAll Religions Are One, written at the same time, he implies
a distinction between
"bodily sensation" and what he calls later "Spir
itual Sensation," the latter phrase clearly implying the union of sense
In the Visions of theDaughters ofAlbion
and spirit (or imagination).
the same contrast ismade
again: Oothoon,
decrying the uniformity
of the existence perceived by the five senses, postulates numerous
other senses beyond fallen man's, while Bromion, her tyrannical ad
versary, proclaims the totality of aworld of five senses, "spread in the
inwhich there is "one law for both the lion and
infinitemicroscope,"
the ox"
The microscope,
the telescope, and all
(VDA, K191-192).
optical devices intensify the senses, then, without expanding them.
ratio of the Spectator's
Or, as Blake writes inMilton, "they alter The
|
vision is
but
leave
untouch'd"
Organs,
(K516). Newton's
Objects
the "reality" it yields is surface, its heaven "a
(L, K818),
"Single"
seen thro' a Lawful
Lawful Heaven,
Telescope"
(AT, K787). Finally,
to
must be
in his Annotations
Berkeley's Siris, Blake writes: "Forms
or the
Eye of Imagination"
apprehended by Sense
(K775), the "or"
context an identification rather than an al
clearly indicating in the
ternative.
The
relationship
the Lockean world
might
ROBERT
F. GLECKNER
man
senses is a reflection
perceives with his
of inner,mental reality. Total vision, or imagination, is thus impos
sible as long as there are only a limited number of senses to serve as
inlets to, or outlets for perception by, soul or mind, or as long as the
basic senses remain "closed,"
uncleansed, bound, or unexpanded.
or
same as
Opening
expanding man's eyes inward is the
opening his
senses
man's
outward.
of
each
eye
"vegetable"
Diagrammatically,15
is the point of intersection, or vortex, of two cones, the open ends of
the cones continuing into outer (sensory) and inner (imaginative) in
tion of vortexes.14 What
. . .when
In
deluge
Into two
and,
as
o'er
the earth-born
stationary
orbs,
man;
the five
senses whelm'd
then turn'd
concentrating
all
the fluxile
things
eyes
(E, K241);
result,
all the vast of Nature
Before
their shrunken
eyes.
shrunk
(SL, K246;
cf.M,
K516).
When
BLAKE
AND
THE
SENSES
Forms
in
Of Man
Ever
expanding
to open
the Immortal
Eyes
ofThought, intoEternity
of God,
the Human
Imagination.
C/,K623)
For "What isAbove is
Within" (J,K709) just as inEternitywhat is
second part of the passage from The Marriage has to do with the
a
origin of organized religion and priesthood, the organization of
in
for
Blake
This
all
of
includes,
effect,
system
systems
"system."
The
not
thought,
merely religions. "All sects of Philosophy," he writes in
All Religions Are One, "are from the Poetic Genius adapted to the
weaknesses
of every individual"
(K98). The process of adaptation is
the important element here for it implies that sectarianism, or the
one true
comes about as a result of the
fragmentation of the
religion,
limitation invision discussed above. "The
trueMan,"
we
know
as to
Blake's
Descriptive
Catalogue
"the Grecian
F. GLECKNER
ROBERT
and Locke
(SL, K246).
a result of this process
is
Songs ofExperience
as the
priests
Image of Songs of Innocence. Just
the vulgar by abstracting "the mental deities
teachings of Newton
to The Divine
applied
in The Marriage enslave
from their objects," so
replete with
heart"
And
wondrous
workmanship,
whosoever
The
hidden
wonders,
He
ordain'd
Inspiring
&
cloth'd
Priestesses,
. . .
(FZ, K333)
in
disguises
beastial,
secrecy.
chang'd
. .
was
the serpent temple form'd,
image of infinite
an
and man became
Shut up in finite revolutions,
Angel,
a
a
crown'd.
circle
God
Heaven
tyrant
turning,
mighty
Then
(E, K241)
man's
rational mind
(priests)
who
"in Selfhood"
BLAKE
AND
THE
SENSES
appropriate
nature of
personifications."22 With his idea of the essentially creative
states the case for the
perception, Coleridge
falsity of these gods with
admirable clarity and succinctness: "If themind be not passive, if it be
indeed made inGod's Image, and that, too, in the sublimest sense, the
Image of theCreator, there is ground for suspicion that any system
built on the passiveness of themind must be false, as a system."23
p. 41 n.
19. Letters Concerning Mythology
1748), p. 275.
(London,
20. Archaeologiae
or, the Ancient Doctrine
Philosophicae;
concerning the Originals
1692), pp. 160 f.
Things (London,
18. Nurmi,
21. Millennium
of
and Utopia
(New York,
1964), p. 170.
A Reading of the Shorter Poems, p. 224; Fearful Symmetry, p. 119.
23. Letters of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, ed. E. H. Coleridge
(London,
1895), 1, 352.
22. William
Blake:
F. GLECKNER
ROBERT
10
re
enunciating the basis of the religious system against which Blake
belled. This basis is rational abstraction, the product of which is per
as Earl Wasserman
sonification. Although,
points out, this figure
reach
of
the
the
imagination" for the eighteenth
"represents
highest
stance by which alone it has existence for man and can be compre
hended by him."25 The imagination functions, then, as a collecting
and assimilating power, a function Blake relegates to thememory
(as
to the
fancy). For Blake, it is the person that
relegates it
Coleridge
the corporeal substance being only
and
exists, really
unchangeably,
that "portion of Soul [or reality] discern'd by the five Senses" (MHH,
K149),
which
what Blake
constitute
thing; what
similitude.
and
The
is "created"
"forms of worship"
by the eighteenth-century
poet
is a
tales,"
(J,K735),
to which
personifications,
out of which
445, 450.
PMLA,
lxv
BLAKE
AND
THE
SENSES
11
to the invisible.
to shadows,
visualizability
far remote, in a little & dark Land"
(FZ,
In
rise of religions, Blake singles out partic
of
the
the
history
K281).
age as the one "which began to
ularly the pre-Biblical Druidical
turn ... mental
(DC, K578).
signification into corporeal command"
to
phantasms, solidity
"They become Natures
What
(J,K681)
sacrifice in a Stonehenge-like
building of "Natural Reli
on its "Altars of Natural
then, is properly seen by
Morality,"
as a
senses.
In
closing of the
Jerusalem, "As the Senses ofMen
Druidical
gion"
Blake
Ah! alas! at the sightof theVictim & at sightof thosewho are smitten,
see become
All who
With
veils
Their
The
Of
ear bent
ear shrunk,
the heavens
shrunk away:
First a burning
flame, then a column
then an awful fiery wheel
earth & heaven,
surrounding
Divine
fire,
they behold;
their nostrils &
outwards;
And
what
of tears and
became
of mortality,
Six months
fled away,
night the mountains
a summer, and six months
of
mortality,
a winter.
. . .
to be alter'd
form began
to be
into the Indefinite.
the perceptions
dissipated
The Human
And
. . .
(J,K702-703)
fallen state of man,
The
26.
In Blake's
"To
Tirzah"
(Songs ofExperience),
part" who
With
bind my Nostrils,
Didst
close my Tongue
in senseless clay,
toMortal
Life betray.
(K220)
And me
of my Mortal
ROBERT
12
F. GLECKNER
which
he bows
to the hu
ofUrizen: after the "net" of religion ("twisted like
man with "shrunken
brain") is formed and eternal
eyes" and
contracts
"narrowing perceptions"
Book
man
Of
in
reptile forms shrinking
seven feet stature
they remain'd.
Six days
together,
existence,
self-enslaved and blind, they give thanks for all their blessings,
And theybless'd the seventhday, in sickhope,
And forgot theireternal life. (K236)
ill
to The Marriage, "the whole creation will be con
When,
according
sumed and appear infinite and holy, whereas it now appears finite &
an
event "will come to pass
by
improve
corrupt," this apocalyptic
ment
seems tome to
to their
imaginative wholeness. Peter Fisher
come as close as anyone, however: "The improvement of sensation
that is, a
included the restoration of the faculties and their powers,"
communis sensus.27 Blake was no doubt aware of the eighteenth-cen
of man
tury search, by Berkeley and others, for some principle by which the
senses could be united with each other, a kind of total synaesthesia
reflective of total coinstantaneous perception. As early as 1788 Blake
27. The Valley
of Vision,
p. 241.
BLAKE
was
attracted to Lavater's
(coup d'oeil),
THE
AND
SENSES
13
extent of
of "copiousness,
glance
at once"
intuition of the whole
notion
and instantaneous
{AL,K69).
the two ideas are but opposite sides of the same coin. The union of
the five senses (or, as Blake more often has it, four senses)28 into one
imaginative eye precludes any distinction, in Eternity, between the
as I have said above,
senses and
of the
imagination;
multiplication
senses ad
in
of
man's
would
the
number
chinks
infinitum
multiply
cavern to the
cavern itself is annihilated, or
point where the
bodily
ceases to obscure. So too,
and
cleansing the "doors of perception"
same result. In
senses
five
the
the
(or four)
yields precisely
expanding
can write: "Four
A Vision of theLast
Living
Judgment, then, Blake
... I
to
Creatures [i.e. the Zoas]
have
the chief agency in re
suppose
the old heavens & the old Earth tomake way for theNew
moving
Heaven & theNew Earth . . ." (K612). In Eternity these four
living
creatures constituted the fourfoldness of "the Immortal"
(i.e. Albion,
the Grand Man, Christ, Imagination), who, before the Fall, "ex
IOr contracted his all flexible senses" at will (BU, K223).
panded
...
for contracting
Senses
their Exalted
call Jesus
the Christ_(FZ,
thing isHuman"
"Every
stood
One
toward
K277;
(J, K665)
Fourfold;
each Four
Faces
to theWest,
. . .
to the North.
had: One
cf.J, K664-665)
U K745)
"Around
North, Urizen
West
to the
to the
(M,K500);
And
the
Eyes
and
the Nostrils
U, K632)
14
ROBERT
F. GLECKNER
Every
Form was
Universal
become
barren mountains
of Moral
a heart,
or an
eye.
...
(BU, K234)
Lord my
Saviour,
open
bringing
thou
the Gates
(f,K715)
together magnificently
many
of
apocalypse:
The
labyrinthine
Ear:
Circumscribing
&
Circumcising
the excrementitious
BLAKE
AND
THE
15
SENSES
"This will
come
to pass by an
improvement
in sensual enjoy
ment."
UNIVERSITY
OF CALIFORNIA,
RIVERSIDE