Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1. INDUSTRIAL PROFILE
1.1 INTRODUCTION
In the last fifty years tyre industry has been saddled with the unviable
reputation of manufacturing a commodity. Not only were the products black and
boring but the industry itself was also considered to be black and boring- with profits
to match this reputation. However, things are changing in the industry, and changing
rapidly. Tyre manufacturing might not be attracting much attention from Wall Street
but it is very different from the industry of a decade ago and in 10 years time it will
be different again. The new technology application has a disruptive effect on the
industry
Consumption ratio of natural rubber and synthetic rubber is 80:20 in India and
in world it is 40:60.
It is a delicensed industry.
New tyres and raw materials of tyres are under the open general license
(OGL)i.e. they can be imported and exported freely
Excise duty on tyre ranges from 16% to 24% and for raw material (excluding
natural rubber) at 16%.
While the tyre industry is mainly dominated by the organized sector, the
unorganized sector holds way in bicycle tyres
Radialisation
The technological advancement has increased the usage of Radial Tyres. In
USA, 70% of tyres used are radials. In Europe, it is estimated at 97%. Even many
developing countries are shifting over to 75% of passenger car tyres as radials. The
level of radialisation in light commercial vehicles is 10% and in trucks and buses it is
an only 2%.
EFFECTS OF BUDGET ON INDUSTRY
Budget Impact
The reduction of customs duty surcharge by 10% will benefit those tyre
manufacturers who import rubber and carbon black feed stocks. However it will
negatively impact tyre companies who are facing stiff competition from cheaper
imports from China, as the removal of surcharge will encourage them more.
Industry Wish Lists
As imports of tyres are a threat to the growth of the industry, a hike in customs
duties form 38.5% currently would be a welcome measure. As Chinese tyre
manufacturers are flooding the market, this will be a welcome measure.
Elimination of Import duty on key Raw materials such as Polyester Tyre Cord
Fabric, Steel Tyre Cord Fabric and Butyl Rubberon the grounds that there is
no domestic production of these items.
Tyres suffer from a high incidence of excise duty. Considering that various
committees appointed by the Government have recommended reduction, a
reduction in the rate of excise duty would by very welcome
KEY POSITIVES
Since the liberalization of the early 90s, the tyre industry has seen demand rise
as the automobile sector has grown tremendously in terms of market size and
production capacities.
As second hand car market has picked up, this will lead to higher demand
from tyre manufacturers as replacement demand rises.
KEY NEGATIVES
The automobile sector has reported a sharp decline in volumes in FY01 due to
uniform sales tax rate, drought conditions and lower freight demand. This has
resulted in lower demand for tyres.
Tyres companies are saddled with pressure on operating margins as the prices
of rubber and carbon black; two important raw materials have been increasing.
Threat of cheaper imports from Chinese tyre companies is looming over the
industry.
being offered at LIBOR, which is the London Inter-bank Offered Rate. It is the rate of
interest at which banks borrow funds form other banks.
Other Petro Chemical Based Material (Carbon black, Nylon Tyre Cord etc.)
The power of suppliers is high in this category as India is limping back in case
of petro based raw materials like carbon black and chemicals which account low in
quantity terms but are high cost generators. Also the price of NTC fluctuates in line
with the prices of Caprolactam (a petroleum derivative) its main raw material. The
prices of these materials are beyond the control of tyre industry.
Bargaining Power of Buyers
This can be segregated into two parts as follows
OEMs
The OEMs are always in strong position when the bargaining power of
buyers is concerned. The reason behind this is most of them are having contact with
their relative tyre manufacturer under which the prices of tyre remains stable for this
OEM irrespective of market price. The benefits are given to them as they are buying
in bulk and the relation gives the tyre firms thing called brand association.
Replacement
The scene in replacement segment is quite reverse as the bargaining power for
the replacement segment is moderate due to the fact that the buyers are not that strong
as compared to OEMs. The demand in buses and truck segment is always high
because of Indian poor road conditions apart form this purchase is made in small
units.
The company is also renowned for its exports, which have also been
improve with the revival of the auto industry. Thus, MRF Ltd. Can be expected to
retain its position in this segment. However, investors can move out of the scrip,
considering the outlook for the industry as a whole.
1.9.2 CEAT
Being the second largest selling brand in India with a market share of 14.6
percent, Ceat caters primarily to the replacement market. Due to the strong growth in
the OEM sector, the share of the replacement market in the total revenue of the
company has fallen. However, the production growth in the automobile sector over
the past few years should provide a boost to the replacement market in the coming
years and Ceat could be a major beneficiary thereof.
considerable part of its turnover comes from automotive tubes and flaps, for which it
has commissioned a plant in Pune. Despite a reversal in the fortune of the automobile
industry, the chief user base of the companys products, the demand for truck tyres,
particularly in the replacement market, was not encouraging. Even as tyre producers
grapple with over-capacity and high levels of inventory, the government stirred a
hornets nest by proposing free imports of used and second-hand tyres. ATL has
conversion agreements for small tyres with TCIL, Stallino Tyres and Rado. Its
10
exports are routed through Apollo International to the US, Germany, Brazil, Sudan,
Egypt, etc.
1.9.4 J.K.Tyres
J.K. Organization founded over 100 years ago ranks within the elite private
groups in India in terms of assets and sales. The Group's operations can best be
characterized as multi-business, multi-product and multi-location with head office in
New Delhi, the Capital of India. The Group has a distinguished record of being
pioneers in introducing several new products and processes into India for the first
time. It comprises of a number of industrial and commercial companies, exceeding 70
in number, most of them public limited, in which J.K. Organization has controlling
interest ranging from 35 to 70%.. In the major public limited companies, there are a
large number of public shareholders aggregating over 8,00,000
J.K. Organization has very diversified manufacturing activities such as
Synthetic Fibres like: Nylon, Polyester, Acrylic; Paper & Boards; Cement;
Automobile Tyres & Tubes; Cotton, Woollen and Jute Textiles; Engineering; Plastic
Processing; Agrochemicals; Hybrid Seeds; Cosmetics; Audio & Video magnetic
tapes; Power transmission including V-Belts and Conveyor Beltings, Automotive
Belts, Oil Seals; System Engineering, Industrial, Electronics and Material handling
systems, etc
The Group is further diversifying in other fields like Petrochemicals, Steel,
Drugs & Pharmaceuticals, Food & Dairy Products, Electronics, Computer Software,
Power generation, Rubber hoses, etc.
11
12
recording profits in 1991-92 and. by 1994 the entire accumulated losses were wiped
off. The Company carried out one of the most remarkable turnaround in the Indian
corporate history and by 1995-96; it emerged as the highest profitable company in the
Indian Tyre Industry with a net profit ratio of over 7%.
With the continuing boom of the Automobile Industry, experiencing an
annualized growth of 15%, the company chalked out an ambitious expansion
programme in the year 1994-95. The first phase of expansion programme has already
been completed (i.e., expanding the capacity from 2.20 lakh tyres to 3.00 lakhs per
month) and in the second stage the capacity is stated to go upto 4.50 lakh tyres per
month. The turnover of the company for the financial year 2000-01 has crossed the
Rs.100crore mark and during 2001-02 it is Rs.145crore, making a tremendous
increase in the sales by 41%. The company has made a further growth of 25% during
the financial year 2002-2003 to make the sales reach Rs.182crore. The turnover for
the financial year 2003-04 is Rs.180crore and the company achieved a turnover of Rs
224crores for the year ended 31st march 2005.
During March 2003 company has been awarded with ISO 9001; 2000
certification from TUV SUDDEUTSCHLAND INDIA PVT. LTD.
Product-Line
FALCON TYRES LTD, manufacture two and three wheeler Tyres, it also
manufactures tuber for the above said product line. It also manufactures four-wheeler
Tyres that are only for Maruti.
Customers
F.T.L classified its market into three segments they are as follows
1. OEM- Original equipment market.
13
2. Replacement Market
3. Export Market
1.
OEM means F.T.L directly sell its product to manufacture to two and three
wheeler vehicles.
2.
Replacement market means it sells its product to the whole seller or distributor
through this channel it will reach to the consumer.
Present status of the company is shown in Table 2.1
14
employees
SYDICATE BANK,
Bankers
Board of Directors
Komal C. Wazir.
Mr. Mohan M.Thakur
Niranjan Thakur.
Prakash M. Nene.
Ravindra Pal Bhatia
15
16
17
Additional ranges and patterns were available as a better choice for the
customer as the market place.
7. Falcon tyres.
3. CEAT ltd.
8. MRF
18
25,80,000 tubes per annum, now the company is manufacturing an average of 13,115
tyres and 10,750 tubes per day. This includes both 2 and 3 wheelers.
The factory is on the threshold of massive expansion coupled with
modernization. This expansion covers the introduction of additional product range
like tyres and tubes for cars, light truck, tractor front, power tiller, etc.,
Total Quality
Falcon Tyres meets 150, 815, JI5, T & RA and ETRTO standards wherever
applicable. The quality accreditations are:
DOT Marketing for all 2 and 3 wheeler sizes for export to U.S.A.
DG5 & D certification for all 2 & 3 wheeler sizes for supply to Government
Organizations.
19
Strength
Marketing requirement
Economies of size
R & D backup.
Flexibility in Production
Weaknesses
Non-participation in OEM's like TVS, Honda Motors etc., the fast growing
Companies
Opportunities
Entry of Honda, Japan, directly in Indian market and our long association with
their Indian counterparts
20
Threats
Strategy
Staff
Structure
Skills
Systems
Shared Values
Style
21
22
customer satisfaction.
Alternative Sources - The sustained rise in raw material prices is making the
cost of production more expensive and it will adversely impact on the
profitability of the company in this intense competitive scenario. In order to
overcome this competition, FTL has framed the strategy that it shall continue to
develop alternative sources of raw material suppliers.
Future Plan
A long term wage settlements with the work men will herald a new
era of efficiently high productivity & harmonious industrial
relation.
2.2.2. Structure
Structure refers to the organization structure, which provide information about
who reports to whom and how tasks are both divided and integrated.
FTL has a tall organization structure that is usually pyramid shaped , this
23
24
25
Marks average.
Good
65-75
Very good
75-85
Excellent
85 and above
Extraordinary
26
incremental committee for the second review. The above said appraisal system is only
for management staffs and operational staff, but the executive director himself will do
the appraisal.
2.2.4. Style
In FTL the shareholders' grievances committee meets at frequent intervals to
consider shareholder / investors complaints. The committee deals with grievances
pertaining to transfer of shares, non-receipt of Balance Sheet, non-receipt of
dividends, dematerialization of shares, complaints letters received from stock
exchange etc. During the year, 3 complaints were received from shareholders. All
complaints have been resolved to the satisfaction of the complainers and no transfers
were pending.
The company has a practice of communicating with the stakeholders Quarterly
results of the company are normally published in The New Indian Express and
Prajavani and are displayed in the company's website, apart from providing to stock
exchanges and press.
The company has formed a remuneration committee. The committee decides
on the remuneration of the executive directors.
2.2.5. Staff
The company is accommodating various employees, they comprise of
personnel, staff, workers and trainees. Most of them are from the Mysore city. The
company continues to have cordial and harmonious relations with its employees. The
company has various training programs organized to be in line with changing
business environment. Several training programs structured to the needs of the
individual employees.
Regular audit on safety and environment are done by the competent professional
27
and the recommendations are followed to provide a safe and clear work environment.
Regular training programs on safety are conducted to increase awareness and
commitment for safety. The total number of employees on the roles of the company as
on 31 July is 1139 is distributed in different departments
The company has successfully formalized in long-term settlement that is valid
for 39 months from 1st April 2003. The long-term wage settlements include better
productivity optimization of output and continuing harmonious industrial relation.
The staff in the FTL will come under human resource department under the
senior general manager. The department is looking after three sub departments, they
are
Human resource department
Personnel and industrial relations department
Safety and security department
2.2.6. Skills
Skills are considered as One of the most crucial attributes or capabilities
possessed by the organization.
28
Human Resource:
29
Quality - Good
Brand name
30
Items
I. AGRICULTURAL TYRES
JAP 910 T.F
Power Tiller
JAP 930
JAP 940 Reaper
MAHAAN LR5
II SCOOTER TYRES
JAP 200
JAP 220
JAP 230
III MOTOR CYCLE TYRES
Geo-Crusher F50
Ezee Crusher XLF 318
JAP 350
JAP 370
JAP 410
31
32
Tyre Building:
The bands are assembled over tyre building drum, after fixing the side beads.
Breakers are placed with pressure. The tread is also applied over the bands to make a
Raw Tyre.
Air Bags / Bladders:
Air Bags / Bladders are made by moulding the extruded slugs in a particular
size mould and these are used as a shaping tool in the tyre moulding operation.
Air bag Bagging:
Bagging is the process of inserting the Air Bags in Raw Tyres before curing.
Tyre Curing:
The Raw Tyre is moulded in a specified heated mould and also shaped by
using an Air Bag or a Bladder through which steam is passed.
Finishing:
This is a process of inspection, trimming and buffing of tyres to ensure for
better performance.
Tube Making:
Mixed rubber compound is milled and sheeted out. This is loaded in an
Extruder to extrude tubes and passed through conveyor in chilled water and then cut
into the required lengths. After this valve is fixed and the tube ends are spliced.
These Raw Tubes are steam cured in a specified mould placed in the presses. They
are packed in bags and dispatched after inspection.
33
Inbound logistics.
Operations.
Outbound logistics.
Service.
34
3.1.1.2. Operations:
Operations with reference to value chain include the activities associated with
converting inputs into final products.
The Company recorded a turnover of Rs.224 crores and a net profit of Rs.0.92
crores during the financial year 2004-05, despite severe competition in the industry.
An all round increase in input costs and inability to pass on such increase to
the customers adversely impacted the performance of the company during the
financial year under review.
Production of Tyres & tubes during the year 2004-05 stood at 19381 M.T. as
against 15684 M.T. in 2003-04. Necessary infrastructure and additional capacities
were created during the year to cater to the marketing requirements. New patterns
and designs of tyres introduced during the year were well received by the customers.
The company has increased its presence in the tube market as well as in the exports.
Even though the tyre industry continued to be affected on account of sustained
increase in input costs the intense competition within the industry to protect the
market shares has prevented tyre companies in our segment of business from passing
on the effect of the increase to the customers. Recognizing the role that distribution
strength is likely to play in the success of companies in a highly competitive scenario,
the company has charted out ambitious plans to consolidate in this area.
3.1.1.3. Outbound Logistics:
Outbound logistics include activities dealing with physically distributing the
product to buyers, specially this deals with finished goods warehousing, order
processing, order packing, shipping & delivery vehicle operations.
35
In FTL all the tyres are kept in separate room in control department checked
and inspected separately, in that process all the parameters of manufactured tyres are
checked whether they are satisfying all the requirements of customers.
Consignments of tyres are dispatched to customers through road and rail
transport to customers.
The finished goods processed by FTL are wide range of nylon bias ply tyres &
butyl tubes for two & three wheelers, passenger cars, jeep, light commercial vehicles
& farm vehicles.
3.1.1.4. Marketing & Sales:
Marketing & sales in value chain is related to sale force efforts, advertising &
promotion, market research & planning & dealer / distribution support.
In FTL there is a separate department for performing the marketing activities.
Manager (marketing) heads this department who is under the direct control of general
manager.
The actual work of marketing department starts when they receive enquiries
from the customers .the marketing department sends the checklist of products to
customers produced in the company.
After receiving purchase order from the marketing department send customer
customer order to production control department based on this order production
control department first prepares the work order and the bill of material, the bill of
material sent the finance department to fix prices and payments terms, them the work
order is sent to the marketing department and production starts.
36
After the inspection the product is ready and dispatched to customer along
with the document containing delivery terms and payments conditions.
The prospects of tyre exports from India appear healthy, the efforts by Indian
companies to increasingly enter into outsourcing agreements with tyre producers in
South East Asia, Eastern Europe, Latin America is proved fruitful, overall tyre
producers in India are likely to top export market in future.
3.1.1.5. Service:
Falcon tyres limited maintains good relationship with customers, FTL is
providing the after sales service to the customers.
The company is also providing replacement facility and spare parts to the customers
when there is any damage. Falcon tyres limited has dedicated services staff to attend
customers complaint.
The products of FTL are marketed & sold through transport facilities &
warranty. The company provides service to its customers in the form of prompt
delivery of goods as per the schedule drawn.
3.1.2. Support Activities:
Firm infrastructure.
Technology development.
Procurement.
3.1.2.1.
Firm Infrastructure:
Firm infrastructure includes all the activities & costs in general management,
accounting & financing, safety & security & the overhead functions.
37
38
39
40
ii.
Commercial accounting
iii.
Costing
iv.
Secretarial
v.
System
41
42
Raw material specification (rubber, Nylon, Carbon black, Bead wire etc)
That in the preparation of the accounts for the financial year ended
31st March, 2005 the applicable accounting standards have been followed
along with proper explanation relating to Material departures;
(ii)
(iii)
That the Directors have taken proper and sufficient care for the
maintenance of adequate accounting records in accordance with the
provisions of the Companies Act 1956 for safeguarding the assets of the
Company and for preventing and detecting fraud and other irregularities;
(iv)
That the Directors have prepared the accounts for the financial year
ended 31st March 2005 on a going concern basis.
43
44
5.1.6 Impairment
Fixed assets are reviewed at each balance sheet date for impairment. In case
events and circumstances indicate any impairment, recoverable amount of fixed
assets is determined.
amount of assets either belonging to cash generating unit (CGU) or otherwise exceeds
recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is the greater of assets net selling price
or its value in use. In assessing value in us, the estimated future cash flow from the
use of the assets is discounted to there have been a change in the recoverable amount
and such loss either no longer exists or has decreased. Impairment loss / reversal
thereof, which in case of CGU, are allocated to its assts on a pro rata basis, is adjusted
to carrying value of its respective assets.
45
5.1.7 Investments
Long term investments are considered at cost excepts where there is a
permanent diminution in value thereof in which case, adequate provision is made
against such shortfall.
5.1.8 Inventory
Inventories are valued ate lower of cost or estimated net realizable value.
Cost in case of raw materials, stores and spares have been computed on weighted
average basis.
46
47
that future taxable income will be available against which such deferred tax asset can
be realized.
5.1.15 Dividend
On 31st march 2005 the company has paid the dividend of Re. 1.00 per equity
share of Rs. 10/- each. It is 10% on share value of the company.
5.1.16 Warranties
Warranty costs are accrued in the year of sale, based on past experience.
B.
Notes on Accounts
1.
b.
c.
2.
3.
4.
Raw material consumption includes Rs. 161 lakhs (including R. 25.12 lakhs
towards interest) being Additional Excise Duty (AED) benefit availed in
earlier years, now becoming refundable as per the Finance Act, 2004.
48
49
31st March
2005
(Rs.in lakhs)
31st March
2004
(Rs. In lakhs)
568.09
2304.47
2271.35
130.00
336.45
568.09
2286.22
945.30
5610.36
4153.44
5
6
2727.89
406.96
2762.17
406.96
7
8
9
10
2970.74
2468.37
443.60
475.41
2103.11
1884.41
671.43
392.93
6358.12
5051.88
3201.97
680.64
3324.14
743.43
3882.61
2475.51
984.31
5610.36
4153.44
Schedule
1. SOURCES OF FUNDS
Share Capital
Reserves & Surplus
Secured Loan
Unsecured Loan
Deferred Taxation (NET)
1
2
3
4
353.83
2. APPLICATION OF FUNDS
Fixed Assets
Investments
3.Current Assets, Loans &
Advances
a.
b.
c.
d.
Inventories
Sundry Debtors
Cash & Bank Balances
Loans & Advances
11
12
50
Table 5.2: Profit and Loss Account for the Year Ended 31st March 2004-05
Particular
INCOME
EXPENDITURE
Raw Materials Consumed
Purchases of Finished Goods
Increase / Decrease in Stock
Manufacturing, Administrative, Selling
&Distribution Expenses
Interest (Net)
Depreciation
PROFIT BEFORE TAXATION
PROFIT AFTER TAX
Profit brought forward from previous year
Profit available for appropriation
Appropriation :
Add : transfer from debenture redemption
reserve
Less: Transfer to General Reserve
Proposed Dividend
Corporate Dividend Tax
BALANCE CARRIED TO BALANCE
SHEET
Schedule
13
14
15
16
17
31st March
2005
(Rs.in lakhs)
19467.52
31st March
2004
(Rs. In lakhs)
15689.14
11885.37
442.74
-421.54
8776.06
240.69
-125.51
7020.84
139.29
244.40
19311.10
156.42
64.05
92.37
162.68
255.05
6183.59
124.83
231.08
15430.74
258.40
96.91
161.49
199.46
360.95
100.00
56.81
7.42
90.82
47.86
408.81
150.00
85.21
10.92
162.68
51
Standard Ratio
Year 2004-
Year 2003-04
05
1. LIQUIDITY RATIO
Current Ratio
1.33:1
1.63
1.24
1:1
0.90
0.72
10-15%
11.42
15.87
--
0.91
0.35
--
0.88
--
4.23
Coverage ratio
--
3.87
4.92
--
10.29
10.92
--
8.83
9.14
8 times
7.10
18.33
5 times
9.10
7.28
--
50.48
27.93
3 times
0.94
1.24
--
3.52
3.59
--
0.004
0.01
Return on equity
--
0.032
0.06
--
Quick Ratio
Cash ratio
Net Working Capital Ratio
2. LEVERAGE RATIO
0.11
1.62
3.ACTIVITY RATIO
1.630
2.84
52
I. INTRODUCTION
Working capital may be regarded as the lifeblood of a business. Working
capital management is an important aspect in the study of financial management. Its
effective provision can do much to ensure the success of a business while its
inefficient management can lead not only to loss of profits but also to the ultimate
downfall.
The goal of working capital management is to maintain the firm current assets
and liabilities in such a way that a satisfactory level of wording capital is maintained.
This is so because if the firm cannot maintain a satisfactory level of working capital,
it is likely to become insolvent and may even be forced into bankruptcy. The
interaction between current assets and current liabilities is therefore, the main theme
of the theory of working capital management.
1.1 MANAGEMENT OF WORKING CAPITAL ENCOMPASSES THE
FOLLOWING PROBLEMS:
Problems of deciding the optimal mix of shortterm funds in relation to longterm capital.
53
54
1.5 OBJECTIVES:
1. To know the role-played by the working capital management in the
smooth and fast working of FTL.
2. To know how efficiently working capital management is managed at FTL.
3. To study the overall financial position of the company over 5 years.
4. To have an idea of the practical appreciations of Working Capital
Management.
55
3. Inventory Management
Inventories are the stocks of the products and the components of those
products that a company manufactures for sale. It is one of the major current asset, it
has been proved that an average about 60% of current assets are constrained of
inventories in most of the companies in India.
II REVIEW OF LITERATURE
56
57
58
59
60
business may be profitable on paper but has insufficient funds available to pay debts
as they become due may arise.
(Source: www.beginnerinvestor.com)
2.10. FUND FLOW ANALYSIS OF WORKING CAPITAL
The working capital can be analyzed through ratios. Further, it can be analysis
through fund flow, Fund flows analysis is the study of the sources and application of
the funds in the business. By the use of this analysis, changes in the working capital
between two dates can be very easily analyzed by studying the changes in current
assets and current liabilities.
(Source: chudawat, 2003)
2.12. THE IMPACT OF INFLATION ON CAPITAL BUDGETING AND
WORKING CAPITAL
A major impact on both financial theory and the practice of financial decision
making has been the economic instability, especially in prices, evidenced in the U.S.
economy since the mid 1960s. Inflation in the past few years has not been a major
macro economic problem, but its specters, as demonstrated by the Feds recent
increases in interest rates, is never for the agendas of financial decision makers.
Macro economic instability has necessitated that expectations about the future rate of
inflation be taken into consideration in making decision(s) about which capital
projects will be undertaken by a firm. Nominal cash flows determine its degree of
profitability. However, in making the capital budgeting decision both real and
nominal concepts must be considered.
(Source: Geofrey T. Mills)
61
62
ESTIMATION
OF
MINIMUM
WORKING
CAPITAL
FOR
63
III. METHODOLOGY
Methodology consists of different techniques adopted in data collection.
Much needed information for the study was collected through various means.
3.1. LOCATION OF THE STUDY:
The study was conducted at Falcon Tyres Limited, Metagalli, K.R.S Road,
Mysore 570 016.the studies were done in the finance department of the FTL.
3.2 DURATION OF THE STUDY:
The duration of the study was six weeks.
3.3 DATA COLLECTION METHOD
In order to fulfill the objectives of the study, the data was collected from
primary and secondary sources.
3.3.1 Secondary Source
Journals, magazines
Newspapers
Internet
64
3.4 ANALYSIS
The data collected for the study of working capital management is analyzed
through general analytical method. Ratio analysis is used for the purpose .the analysis
is depicted in tables and graphs.
3.5 TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES
There are several tools of analyzing working capital, they are
1. Statement of changes in working capital.
2. Working capital ratios.
3.6 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
The study is purely of academic interest. The inexperience makes the analysis
less precious when compared to professional analysis. Hence conclusions
from analysis of statement are not sure indicators.
The study in this project does not solve into the problems of capital budgeting
fund flow analysis tax and finance planning foreign exchange, management
and treasury operations.
The study is limited as it being a study of static positional figures and is not a
study of patters of peaks and tough.
Though a complete attempt has been made to include all the factors affecting
the case study putting into writing, there is every possibility of some factors
being left out due to the shortage of time and some due to the policy of the
management to keep them confidential.
65
66
67
Under the net working capital concept. Table 4.7. Shows the Working capital of
FTL under Net concept.
i.
Net working capital includes other current assets and current liabilities.
ii.
iii.
68
Table 4.1: Statement of Changes in Working Capital for the Year 2000-01 When
Compared to 2001-02.
Particulars
2000-01
2001-02
Increase
Decrease
CURRENT ASSETS
Inventories
1297.67
1273.92
23.75
Sundry Debtors
1511.06
1305.74
205.32
Cash at Bank
512.94
572.59
59.65
386.94
474.76
88.76
3707.67
3627.01
2808.32
2499.55
899.35
1127.46
228.11
TOTAL
1127.46
368.87
228.11
1127.46
457.28
457.28
69
Table 4.2: Statement of Changes in Working Capital for the Year 2001-02 When
Compared to 2002-03
Particulars
2001-02
2002-2003
Increase
Decrease
CURRENT ASSETS
Inventories
1273.92
1844.16
570.24
Sundry Debtors
1305.74
1420.58
114.84
Cash at Bank
572.59
454.46
418.82
474.76
893.58
82.48
3627.01
4612.78
Current liabilities
2499.55
2913.98
1127.46
1698.80
118.13
571.34
1698.80
1698.80
414.43
1130.9
571.34
1130.9
70
Table 4.3: Statement of Changes in Working Capital for the Year 2002-03 when
Compared to 2003-04
Particulars
2002-03
2003-04
Increase
Decrease
CURRENT ASSETS
Inventories
1844.16
2103.11
258.95
Sundry Debtors
1420.58
1884.41
463.83
Cash at Bank
454.46
645.80
191.34
893.58
392.93
4612.78
5026.25
3941.90
4067.57
670.88
958.68
287.80
500.65
TOTAL
958.68
125.67
287.80
958.68
914.12
914.12
71
Table 4.4: Statement of Changes in Working Capital for the Year 2003-04 when
Compared to 2004-05
Particulars
2003-04
2004-05
Increase
Decrease
CURRENT ASSETS
Inventories
2103.11
2970.74
867.63
--
Sundry Debtors
1884.41
2468.37
583.96
--
Cash at Bank
671.43
443.60
--
227.83
392.93
392.93
82.48
--
5051.88
6358.12
Current liabilities
3324.14
3201.97
1727.74
3156.15
1428.41
TOTAL
3156.15
122.17
1428.41
3156.15
1656.24
1656.24
72
Products
Tyres
Quantity [In No]
Volume [Rs. In Lakhs]
Tubes
Quantity [In No]
Volume [Rs. In Lakhs]
2004-05
4279124
14414.42
5057483
17244.58
4603296
3617.70
6399993
5128.35
2003-04
2004-05
2103.11
1884.41
2970.74
2468.37
645.80
392.93
443.60
475.41
5026.25
6358.12
2003-2004
5026.25
2004-2005
6358.12
3324.14
743.43
4067.57
958.86
3201.97
680.64
3882.61
2475.51
73
A ratio is a statistical yardstick that measures the relationship between the two
concerned terms. The important of the ratio analysis lies in the fact that it presents
facts on a competitive basis and enables the drawing of influences regarding the
performance of the given terms.
4.3. WORKING CAPITAL ANALYSIS THROUGH RATIO OF FTL
The liquidity position of FTL can be determined by application of the
following ratios. The financial executive to check upon the efficiency with which
Working Capital is being used in the enterprise can use ratio analysis of working
capital following are the important working capital ratios.
4.3.1. Liquidity Ratio
Liquidity ratios are those ratios, which are intended to measures the liquidity
or short term solvency of an enterprise. They indicate whether it will be possible for
an enterprise. They indicate whether it will be possible for an enterprise to meet the
short-term obligation out of its short-term resources.
1. Current Ratio:
The current ratio is the ratio of total current assets and current liabilities, it is
calculated by dividing current assets by current liabilities.
The ideal current ratio is 2:1, but it differs from company to company. This
ideal ratio has set because the current liabilities are certain and on the other current
assets are uncertain. but in this company it is 1.63, though it is lower than standard
when it is compared with the previous year it is growing from 1.24 to 1.63.
The current Ratio are shown in Table no 4.8 and fig 4.1
74
3.
Quick Ratio:
It establishes a relationship between Quick or Liquid assets and current
liabilities.
Normally Quick Ratios standard is 1:1; it is more rigorous and penetrating
rest of liquidity position. The quick ratio of FTL in 2004-05 is 0.90 lower than the
standard. We can also observe that the organizations quick ratio is 0.72 of previous
year. So it is nearing to the standard. here low quick ratio represents that FTLS
liquidation position is good ,but a low quick ratio doesnt necessary mean a bad
liquidity position as inventories are not absolutely non liquid
The Quick Ratio are shown in Table no 4.9 and fig 4.2
3. Cash ratio:
Cash is the most liquid asset, a financial analyst may examine cash ratio and
its equivalent to current liabilities.
Generally, a cash percentage of 10% to 15% of current liability is preferred. The cash
position was bit a down in the years of 2000-01 to 2004-05 as the cash position is
above 158. It may be noted that more than 15% of the proposition of cash position is
good. comparing to last year cash position of the FTL is decreasing, which may effect
the FTL in the short run.
The Cash Ratio are shown in Table no 4.10 and fig 4.3
75
The difference between current assets and current liabilities, excluding shortterm bank borrowing, Net working capital is sometimes used as a measure of a firms
liquidity.
This ratio indicates the ability of the organizations net working capital, which
can be financed by the net assets only. The FTL is having 0.91 this year as net
working capital ratio as against 0.35 previous year.the ratio has increased due to
increasing the current asset
The Net Working Capital Ratio are shown in Table no 4.11 and fig 4.4
76
Current Assets
3707.67
3627.01
4612.78
5026.25
6358.12
Current Liability
3094.97
3151.78
3941.91
4067.57
3882.61
Ratio
1.201
1.151
1.71
1.24
1.63
Quick Asset
2410.00
2353.05
2768.62
2923.14
2910.60
Current Liability
2808.32
2454.11
2913.98
4067.57
3201.97
Ratio
0.851
0.951
0.881
0.72
0.90
77
Cash
512.94
572.59
454.46
645.80
443.60
Current liabilities
3094.97
3151.78
3941.91
4067.57
3882.61
Ratio
19.97
22.90
15.59
15.87
11.42
Net Assets
2589.04
2816.41
2762.17
2762.17
2727.89
Ratio
0.42
0.49
0.65
0.35
0.91
78
Leverage ratios are calculated to judge the long term financial position of
the firm.
1.
firm may be interested in knowing the proportion of the interest-bearing debt in the
capital structure.
This ratio indicates percentage of amount with the lender as invested in the
current assets; FTLs total debt ratio 0.88 in this year as against 0.11 previous year.
This says that the lenders invest only 0.88 of the net fixed assets.
The Total Debt Ratio are shown in Table no 4.12 and fig 4.5
2. Debt-Equity Ratio:
Debt Equity ratio is used to analyze the long-term solvency of the firm. DebtEquity ratio expresses the relationship between debt and equity.
The standard ratio for the debt equity mix is 2:1, compaired to that of the last
year, the debt equity ratio has increased, which implies that the financial structure of
the company is unsound. This ratio indicates the contribution in the business i.e. 4.23
is the creditors contribution in the Business of FTL.
The Debt-Equity Ratio are shown in Table no 4.13 and fig 4.6
79
Total Debt
518.18
638.32
826.42
919.67
2401.35
Net Assets
2589.04
2816.41
7910.46
8195.38
2727.89
Ratio
0.20
0.23
0.10
0.11
0.88
Total Debt
518.18
638.32
826.42
919.67
2401.35
Total equity
600.00
600.00
568.09
568.09
568.09
Ratio
0.86
1.06
1.45
1.62
4.23
80
3. Coverage Ratio
It is used to firms debt-servicing capacity, It is computed by dividing earnings
before interest and taxes by interest charges.
This ratio indicates the coverage of interest payable from the total profit
earned by the company. This year FTL has got the profit 3.87 times with respect to
4.92 times of previous year. Which shows that the FTL returns comes down by 1.05,
with this decreases the FTLs find it difficult to pay the interest in time.
The Coverage Ratio are shown in Table no 4.14 and fig 4.7
4.3.3. Activity Ratio:
A turnover ratio is the ratio, which indicates the effective utilization of the
various assets by a concern. They help the management to judge how effectively the
facilities available at its command have been utilized.
1. Debtors Turnover Ratio:
This is the ratio, which indicates the relationship between average debtors and
sales. It shows, how many times the bills are collected in a year.
This ratio indicates the number of times the debtors are collected in a year. In
FTLs case it will collect 10.29 times or in 33 days with respect to 10.92 or 27 days of
previous year.this shows that the debtors are either granted more days or the capacity
of the debtors to pay the amount come down.
The Debtors Turnover Ratio are shown in Table no 4.15 and fig 4.8
81
EBIT
664.33
965.78
1429.30
614.31
540.11
Interest
284.20
567.31
1086.78
124.83
139.29
Ratio
2.33
1.70
1.31
4.92
3.87
4.
Credit Sales
10328.46
14480.15
18246.99
18042.45
22395.84
Average Debtor
1291.43
1408.40
1363.16
1652.50
2176.39
Ratio
8.00 Times
10.28 Times
13.39 Times
10.92 Times
10.29 Times
82
This ratio indicates the extent to which cash resources are efficiently utilized
by the enterprise. The company as a cash turnover ratio of 504.20 for the year 2005,as
compaired to 2003-04 i.e,279.3, which indicates the cash in the firm is being used
efficiently.the increasing the cash ratio is due to increase in total sales.
The Cash Turnover Ratio are shown in Table no 4.16 and fig 4.9
3.
case it will convert the inventory into sales 8.83 times as against the 9.14 times in a
year. A high ratio is good from the viewpoint of liquidity and vice versa.
The Inventory Turnover Ratio are shown in Table no 4.17 and fig 4.10
4. Inventory to Working Capital Ratio:
This ratio indicates the relationship between inventory and working capital.
the standard ratio is 75%. The year 2003-04 is 124% compaired to the current year of
94% it shows the inventory and working capital is good, the firm is able to pay off its
current liabilities, the ratio will increases with the standard ratio.
The Inventory to Working Capital Ratio are shown in Table no 4.18 and
fig 4.11
5.
83
This ratio shows the firms ability in generating sales from all financial
resources committed to total assets. Total assets include net fixed assets and current
assets.
The net asset turnover of FTL is 8.21 times as against 6.53 times of previous
year. It indicates that FTL is producing 8.21 of sales for a rupee of capital employed
in net assets.
The Assets Turnover Ratio are shown in Table no 4.19 and fig 4.12
84
Sales
10322.46
14480.15
18246.99
18042.45
22395.84
Cash
512.94
572.59
454.46
645.80
443.60
Ratio%
201.2
252.8
401.5
279.3
504.8
Sales
10520.89
14626.19
18350.12
18042.45
22395.84
Average Inventory
1466.87
1733.27
1934.63
1973.64
2536.93
Ratio
7.71
8.44
9.485
9.14
8.83
Years
2000-2001
2001-2002
2002-2003
2003-2004
2004-2005
Inventory
1297.67
1273.92
1844.16
2103.11
2970.74
Working Capital
899.37
1127.46
1689.80
1702.11
3157.00
Ratio (%)
1.44
1.12
1.09
1.24
0.94
Ratio
4.06
5.193
6.64
6.53
8.21
85
The standard norm is 8 times.This ratio indicates that for one rupee of sales
the amount the organization need for net current assets. This year FTL needs 7.10 of
net current assets as against 18.33 of previous year, which was heavier than this year,
this ratio decreased it indicates there is no proper utilization of working capital i.e.,
7.10.
The Working Capital Ratio are shown in Table no 4.20 and fig 4.13
7. Fixed Asset Turnover Ratio:
This ratio indicates the relationship between the sales and net fixed assets.
The standard norm is 5 times. In year 2000-01 it is less than 5 times. It
indicates under utilization of fixed asset and from the year 2002 to 2005 it is more
than 1.82 times effective utilization of fixed assets.
The Fixed assets Turnover Ratio are shown in Table no 4.21 and fig 4.14
8. Current Assets Turnover Ratio:
If the ratio is high then it indicates the firm is in good position. It shows the
over or under trading position is relation to the quantum of working capital.
The FTL Current Assets Turnover Ratio is 3.591 for the year 2003-04 as
compaired to 3.522 in 2004-05, This shows that the company is very quick in
converting the sales into liquid assets either as debtors or as cash. Hence the ratio is
quite high. The Current Assets Turnover Ratio has increased due to increased in credit
sales.
The Current Assets Turnover Ratio is shown in Table no 4.22 and fig 4.15
86
Sales
10322.46
14480.15
18246.99
18042.45
22395.84
Ratio
16.85 Times
30.47 Times
27.20 Times
18.33 Times
7.10 Times
Sales
10520.89
14626.19
18350.12
18211.06
22562.78
Ratio
4.87 Times
6.42 Times
7.00Times
7.28 Times
9.10 Times
Sales revenue
10322.46
14480.15
18246.99
18042.45
22395.84
Current assets
3707.67
3788.70
4612.78
5026.25
6358.12
Ratio
2.781
3.821
3.951
3.591
3.522
87
88
Sales
10520.89
14626.19
18350.12
18042.45
22395.84
Ratio
0.015
0.02
0.03
0.01
0.004
Net worth
2544.92
2475.54
2798.64
2854.31
2872.56
Ratio
0.066
0.142
0.186
0.06
0.032
89
4.4 FINDINGS
The company has better WCM; we have seen that the co. has capability to
raise outsiders funds easily.
Even though the EPS is decreased compared to previous year, the co. is
earning sufficient net profit that is shared by shareholders, and at present EPS
is Rs. 1.63.
4.5 SUGGESTIONS
The Company is expanding day by day to meet the challenges of competitions
in the market. Thus, with a good infrastructure and efficient human forces the
company is moving towards the success rapidly.
A still better efficient planning of the working capital management can raise
more profits for the company taking it to the heights of prosperity, which make to
reduce the companies working capital.
1) The net working capital has been fluctuating, so this would be beneficial to
the firm to some extent.
2) The debtors turnover ratio has been increasing. So this will reduce the
working capital requirement to the company, if the trend is continued.
3) The inventory turnover ratio has been increasing. So this will reduce the
working capital requirement to the firm.
4) As to the company profiles, the company had a capacity to extend their
production activity and expansion.
5) The liquidity position with respect to current assets and current liability is not
satisfactory.
6) Current ratio and acid test ratio is not up to the standard.
90
FTL has good working capital position. Company can meet its short-term
obligations.
The various ratios calculated shows that company has good financial position.
Liquidity and Profitability ratios are increasing.
Activity ratios show that company is not using its operational efficiency to the
fullest extent. But in the year 2004-2005 it is showing some signs of
improvement.
The leverage analysis of Falcon Tyres Ltd. gives an impression that it is not a
risky company.
Conclusion
The study of working capital management at F.T.L revealed that the
management of working capital has been greatly responsible for level of profits
earned by the firm along with tremendous expansion activities. The turnover of
current assets employed by F.T.L efficiently used its working capital funds, which
91
happens to be most important factor for the running of business enterprise with
normal profits.
The basic objective of working capital management is to have a balanced
liquidity position. The company has a positive net working capital during all the
years of its operation. This indicates the companys good liquidity position. This is
also made clear by the current assets ratio, which is greater than one all the years. It
means that the investment in current assets is more sufficient to meet its obligations.
The company is expanding its operations and need more working capital to
support the growing needs of the operation. At present the company has taken up
several expansion programs such as production of cycle and farm tyres to cater need
of our rural factors.
92
VI. REFERENCES
Anon, (2003), Working Capital, www.bizhelp 24.com.
Anon, (2003) , Measurement of Working Capital, www.ft.com.
Anon, (2003),Working Capital and Financing Problems of the Small Business,
www.ft.com.
Anon, (2003), Ways to Improve of Working Cash Flows, www.ft.com.
Anon, (2003), Problems in Working Capital, www.biginnerinvestor.com
Anon, (2003), Estimating of Working Capital, www.abnamro.com.
ASCE/July/August 2003, Estimation of Minimum Working Capital for Construction
Projects in Malaysia, Journal of Construction Engineering And Management,
Vol. 5, pp 56-60.
Chudawat, (2000), Fund Flow Analysis, Financial Management ,Eight Edition,
Vikas Publication, pp 32-38.
Geofrey.T.Mills,(2002) The Impact of Inflation on Capital Budgeting and Working
Capital, www.ft.com.
Henry.H.Jorden, (1997), Inventory Management in the jit age, center for Inventory
Management, Vol. 12, pp 28-30.
I.M.Pandy, (2004), Concepts of Working Capital, Financial Management, Eight
Editions, Vikas publication, pp 37-40
I.M.Pandy, (2004) Permanent and Variable Working Capital,
Management Eight Editions, Vikas publication, pp 42-45.
Financial
93