Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
Lawgic (http://lawgic.info/)
a little logic in law
(http://lawgic.info/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/blackmagic.png)
Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrice and Other Inhuman, Evil
and Aghori Practices and Black Magic Ordinance
Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and Other Inhuman, Evil and
Aghori Practices and Black Magic Ordinance (Maharashtra Ordinance XIV of 2013)
Published in the Maharashtra Ordinary Gazette on 26-August-2013.
What is the status of this law? When did this law come into effect?
The Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrice and other Inhuman, Evil and Aghori Practices Bill,
2011 (L. A. Bill No. XLI of 2011), was introduced in the Legislative Assembly, in the Monsoon Session of the State
Legislature, 2011, on the 10th August 2011. This law came into eect on 26-Aug-2013 upon publication into the
1 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
Why should we have a new law? Were the existing Criminal Laws not enough?
Not really. Religion has such an elevated status in India and in most parts of the world, that even clearly illegal, unethcial or immoral acts done in the name of religion were ignored or even encouraged. (Eg: Noise Pollution, Air
Pollution, Water Pollution, Cruelty to Animals etc. etc.)
Till date, newspapers contain numerous ads, which assure a cure for anything and everything, through Black
Magic and similar practices. Trains are lled with advertisements on Black Magic Healers who can x anything,
from a broken marriage to a troublesome employee, to a lm star or a politicians career.
The laws of the country are so fragile, that they cannot always stand up to acts done in the name of religion. To
make people think, a strong law needs to be implemented.
While all the penalties exist, the police and other authorities are too cautious to tread on the religious line, lest
they be targeted for hurting religious sentiments.
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
I have heard that this law seems to be targeted against Hindus. Will it impact only Hinduism?
Ofcourse not. This rumour is being spread by persons with ulterior motives in all these practices. These practices
are big money spinners and prevention of these practices will stop the ow of money to these con men.
It is dicult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon
his not understanding it! -Upton Sinclair
Blind Faith and superstition is promoted in the name of almost every religion. Exorcism, fake remedies, charms,
bracelets etc. have been practiced in the name of every God and every religion.
The faithful of all and any religion resort to these options as a last resort, making them most vulnerable and
agreeable to do anything to achieve their wish. The victims do not look at religion or faith when being subject
to these con men/con women. The con men maybe of any religion, social background or philosophy, but
will still attract people from all faiths, beliefs and religions.
In the beginning it was said that this Law would apply to all the religions. Why was this sentence removed?
Application of this Act to all religions, would not necessarily cover the actions done under the general guise of
black magic and jaadu tona, without a religious banner. By excluding all religions the Act applies universally to all
acts done in the name of religion or even excluding the name of a particular religion / God / Belief System. This includes practices done by Atheists (not that atheists practice anything) / Devil Worshippers etc.
Many people are saying that the second point in the Schedule is unclear?
So-called miracles means acts which the black magic practitioner claims to be by a superior / super-natural
force of which he has knowledge or control. Such acts may make it dicult for a common man to explain or justify, but are well known to science and technology.
Eg: In villages, the Black Magicians produce smoke from an ordinary coconut, or produce a blood-like substance
3 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
from a whole lemon to show the people that they have magical powers to perform miracles. These so-called
miracles are easily explained by science, with a little knowledge of chemistry.
Other common examples are:
Walking on glass
Sleeping on a bed of nails
Enduring whip lashes
For more examples: http://60minutes.9msn.com/article.aspx?id=8376295 (http://60minutes.9msn.com/article.aspx?id=8376295)
Bare Act:
Whoops!
There was a problem previewing this document.
4 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
5 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
..the State and its ocers are entitled to reasonably restrict such activity if it tends
to oend security, public orders, decency, morality and sovereignty and integrity of
India. This includes reasonable restrictions on the basis of public health and public
tranquility; such restrictions being imposable in the interest of the general publicArticle 51 A(h) provides that it shall be the duty of every citizen of India to
develop a scientic temper, humanism and the spirit of enquiry and reform.
Balancing the duties of the petitioner in this regard and her fundamental rights referable to Part III of the Constitution, it has necessarily to he held that the impugned orders, to the extent they require the petitioner to desist from oering cures for illness
on the basis of prayers, is a reasonable restriction imposed on grounds of public
health, morality etc., particularly when she has no authentic scientic certication
in support of any claim of such ability to cure.
Interesting Links:
Bhanamati sorcery and psychopathology in south India. A clinical study. (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
/pubmed/2635890)
http://www.siasat.com/english/news/2-burnt-alive-suspicion-practicing-bhanamati-probe-ordered
(http://www.siasat.com/english/news/2-burnt-alive-suspicion-practicing-bhanamati-probe-ordered)
Related Posts
Noise Pollution Complaint in Mumbai (http://lawgic.info/noise-pollution-complaint-in-mumbai/)
This entry was posted in Bare Acts (http://lawgic.info/category/bareacts/), Useful Information (http://lawgic.info
/category/useful-information/) on August 22, 2013 [http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradicationof-human-sacrice-and-other-inhuman-evil-and-aghori-practices-and-black-magic-bill/] .
6 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16
http://lawgic.info/maharashtra-prevention-and-eradication-of...
One thought on Maharashtra Prevention and Eradication of Human Sacrifice and Other Inhuman,
Evil and Aghori Practices and Black Magic Ordinance
Pingback: Quando un omicidio muove la politica: in Maharashtra al varo la legge contro la magia nera |
Crocevia tra Oriente e Occidente (http://krishna.deltoso.net/2013/quando-un-omicidio-muove-la-politicain-maharashtra-al-varo-la-legge-contro-la-magia-nera/)
7 of 7
31/12/2014 14:16