Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
EXCLUSIVEHEAD-TO-HEAD
ART
FREE WALLCHEKLY
NEW JAG
JAG XE
&BMW3SERIES
HOT-HATCH
SHOOTOUT
PLU
LUSS
BMWI3S
TEST
EXCLUSIVE IMAGE
PORSCHES
5
SERIES
We reveal plans for Pajun super saloon
VOLVO XC90 Full preview & exclusive picss
www.autoexpress.co.uk
TOUGHEST
Optimum stability
Perfect grip
Contents
Newsweek
All the key stats as new Brit meets its arch rival
10
13
14
16
18
Features
Getting in shape for Dakar
22
26
50 Electric chargers: Kias all-new Soul EV and BMWs i3 battle for class honours
New cars
COVER Hyundai i20 hits Britain
28
Mercedes B200
30
VW Polo GTI
33
35
36
38
14 Leaked shot could reveal MINI sports car 10 Full preview of new Volvo XC90
Online
this week
Road tests
COVER Hot hatch shoot-out
40
Soul EV vs BMW i3
50
Our cars
58
Products
New on the shelves
64
68
BEST
28 First UK drive of new Hyundai i20 MOTORING
APPS FOR
2015
Page 68
autoexpress.co.uk
Buying cars
Kia Ceed buyers guide
72
74
78
All the info you need before you head to the showroom
Regulars
Consumer news
20
37
Sport
88
Back chat
90
www.autoexpress.co.uk
BMW Winter
Tyres
www.bmw.co.uk/
winter-tyres
The Ultimate
Driving Machine
Thisweek
News
Road tests
Consumer
Production
Subscriptionenquiries0844 8440026
Digital
E-mailfirstname_lastname@dennis.co.uk
Special Contributors
CONTENT SYNDICATIONSALES
www.autoexpress.co.uk
facebook.com/autoexpress
@AutoExpress
youtube.com/autoexpress
STEVE FOWLER
Editor-in-chief
Steve_Fowler@dennis.co.uk
@stevefowler
News02079076205
Consumer02079076217
Tests 020 7907 6209
Products 020 7907 6212
Fax 020 7907 6234
Advertising02079076745
Advertising E-mail
ads@autoexpress.co.uk
Subscribe and
save 46 per cent
nt
Get all the motoring news EVERY week
Subscription to Auto Express and save
46% on the shop price. See Page 37
Basic annual rate UK: 79.99 Europe: 110 Restof world: 180
Online subscriber service Change your address
and renew your subscription at
www.subsinfo.co.uk
www.subscribe.autoexpress.co.uk/print-ipad/
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driverpower
31 December 2014 5
Top story
First for news every week
JAGUAR
XE
vs BMW
3 SERIES
Jame
James_Batchelor@dennis.co.uk
6 31 December 2014
EXCLUSIVE
Otis Clay
IN DETAIL: XE vs 3 Series
Jaguar XE Prestige
2.0 163 man (auto)
BMW 320d ED
Business man (auto)
31 December 2014 7
Top story
STILL WORKS WELL Theres nothing wrong with the 3 Series driver-focused cabin,
with its high-grade plastics and top-quality finish. Business edition offers decent kit, too
www.autoexpress.co.uk
News
Volvo XC90
James Batchelor
James_Batchelor@dennis.co.uk
Jame
@JRRBatchelor
OFFICIAL
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Three-cylinder engine
Lightweight three-cyl
engine made our test
car feel quite agile
News
XXX
Volvo3-cylprototype
FIRST DRIVE New engine shows real potential
0-62mph:
Top speed:
Economy:
CO2:
21,000 (est)
1.5-litre 3cyl turbo
156bhp
Six-speed manual,
front-wheel drive
8.5 seconds (est)
130mph (est)
69mpg (est)
95g/km (est)
Jame
James_Batchelor@dennis.co.uk
@JRRBatchelor
Nathan Morgan
or action
highlights include two world firsts.
A run-off road protection package
tightens seatbelts and activates energyabsorbing tech in the seats when the
car detects challenging terrain ahead.
Auto braking cuts in if a driver pulls
out in front of oncoming traffic.
Order books are open and the range
starts at 45,550. R-Design cars get
underway at 49,050, while Inscription
starts at 49,950. The plug-in T8 Twin
Engine is around 14,000 more than
the entry-level D5 models in each trim.
PAGE 18: Volvo motor show shock
www.autoexpress.co.uk
QUICK FIX
Verdict
OUR drive was short and in the
only current prototype, but with
new investment from Chinese
owner, Geely, Volvo is clearly
back on form when it comes to
creating great engines. It was
punchy and enjoyable to use in
our V40 Cross Country now
the firm just needs to build it.
31 December 2014 11
AA callouts 2014
News
Joe_Fi
Joe_Finnerty@dennis.co.uk
@AE_Consumer
child in a
car, while...
1,014
have locked
40,072
incidents of
a pet in car
Forgetful parents who locked toddlers in cars called the AA 2,410 times in
2014. A host of animals were freed, too, including snakes and guinea pigs
Our table shows the problems patrols most regularly had to sort this year
Batteries 427,586
Tyres
373,746
Lights
131,527
Alternator 106,857
Clutch
103,229
misfuelling
615miles
longest
recovery
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Automedia
SPIED
31 December 2014 13
News
Jonath
ath
Jonathan_Burn@dennis.co.uk
@Jonathan_burn
COOL CONCEPT
Superleggera Vision
made its debut
in Italy last May,
and speculation
has been feverish
since regarding the
possibility of a
production version
Leaked shot from European patent office appears to suggest car will be made
14 31 December 2014
OFFICIAL
NO
DRINK
NO
DOUBT
DIY breathalysers are common, but police are getting roadside drug test kits
www.autoexpress.co.uk
News
EXCLUSIVE
Mike
M Rutherford
mail@autoexpress.co.uk
Autocentre netwo
network is set to grow from around 300 to 320 and will feature Apple Store-like pods and wifi
Routin
Routine servicing work is pretty
much tthe same. The big difference is
the pri
price the customer has charged
Andy Ran
Randall Managing Director of Halfords Autocentre
16 31 December 2014
Milos Dvorak
Image shows
how Bentley
SUV could look
and itll be
built at newly
expanded
Crewe HQ
www.autoexpress.co.uk
News
Porsche Pajun
EXCLUSIVEIMA
Poblete
Lawrence_Allan@dennis.co.uk
La
Concept Estate
was displayed
at Geneva this
year, but Volvo
is set to scale
down motor
show debuts
18 31 December 2014
Automedia
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Porsche Pajun
News
Mat
Watson
Mat_Watson@dennis.co.uk
@mat_watson
A GES
N E E D TO KN O W
comer is
Under the skin, new the MSB
of
n
sio
ver
on
sit
to
set
cur rently
platform Porsche is
amera
Pan
the
for
g
pin
elo
dev
Porsche 911 vs
Bentley Conti GT
d running
Ferrari will
favour the turbo
route with the
458 M, using a
version of the
California Ts V8
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 19
Watchdog
We get behind the stories that affect you
Joe
Finnerty
Idea to switch off traffic
lights has real merit,
but wont happen soon
Two-day-old Audi A1
in brake fault shock
CASE STUDY Buyers dismayed at problem on new car and at makers sluggish response
Joe Finnerty
20 31 December 2014
Imagine turning
off traffic signals
outside rush hour,
easing congestion
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Inbox
mail@autoexpress.co.uk
@AutoExpress
Under new
NCAP rules,
only cars
with kit like
autobrake
will be able to
get five stars
Joe Finnerty
Contacts
THE following provide help with
motoring problems. Some
services are free, others charge
a fee or operate on premiumrate lines (p), while some offer
advice for members only (m).
Legal
AA: 0906 010 1300 (p)
RAC: 0870 5533 533 (m)
Which?: 01992 822 800
Consumer Direct:
0845 404 0506
Local Trading Standards
Local Citizens Advice Bureau
www.autoexpress.co.uk
@drpaulripley
FROM: Shaun34 CREATING a two-tier scoring system (Issue 1,347) will make crash
testing far too complex. Euro NCAP tests should be about how well cars protect
occupants in the event of a crash, not how good they are at avoiding them.
These safety systems may be great when the cars are new, but what happens
a few years down the line? What happens when the third, fourth or even fifth
owner has skimped on servicing, and is driving on worn brakes with cheap tyres?
Autonomous braking is reliant on the serviceability of the brakes and tyres,
so you cant say its a five-star car if its not working to its maximum level.
Car registration/history
HPI: 01722 422422
AA: 0800 316 3564
DVLA: 0300 790 6802
RAC: 0800 975 5867
Traffic information
AA: 09003 401100 (p)
RAC: 09003 444999 (p)
Financial problems
Financial Ombudsman:
0800 023 4567
Safety concerns/recalls
Vehicle and Operator
Services Agency (VOSA):
0117 954 3300
31 December 2014 21
Inside story
A different take on the world of motoring
the road to
dakar
Our man joins the X-Raid Dakar Rally team on its boot camp
in tenerife, as it prepares for 2015s instalment of one of
the most demanding races in the world of motorsport
X-raid uses MINI All4 Racing for the 2015 Dakar Rally, with Nani
Roma (pictured far right with co-driver Michel Prin) hoping for a second consecutive win
22 31 December 2014
Henry_Willis@dennis.co.uk
H
@WineryHills
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 23
Inside story
MORALE BOOST
While activities
such as sailing,
hiking and mountain
climbing are a
physical test, they
succeed in bringing
team closer together
www.autoexpress.co.uk
SETTING THE
NEW STANDARD
#loveyourjourney
www.facebook.com/KenwoodUK
Chris_Ebbs@dennis.co.uk
Chr
Popularity
Rex
w1ll5Kat
rona7d0
beck5AM
che7se4
GETTING
PERSONA
REG RESEARCH
Buying a plate is
simple enough at a
DVLA auction, and
many celebrities,
such as Tamara
Ecclestone, have
taken the plunge.
But selling is a
trickier business
and its important
to do your research
tejayz
0po5hn
MS1Dino
4rom4n
iantvr
ALoveu
AL
Auction websites
Private sale
Buying a
personalised plate
31 December 2014 27
New cars
Hyundai i20
30
MERCEDES B200
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
of 22 new or
The i20 is the third dai will
un
updated models Hy
of 2017
introduce by the end
Jonathhan_Burn@dennis.co.uk
@Jonathan_burn
Performance is mediocre
1.4 engine needs to
be worked hard
28 31 December 2014
In such a conservatively
styled sector, the i20s
design is bold enough
to really stand out
www.autoexpress.co.uk
33
VW POLO GTI
35
TESLA MODEL S
36
38
ELECTRIC MPV
Nissans e-NV200
Combi offers space
and eco credentials.
Essentials
Hyundai i20
Price:
Engine:
Power:
Transmission:
0-62mph:
Top speed:
Economy:
CO2:
14,325
1.4-litre 4cyl petrol
99bhp
Six-speed manual,
front-wheel drive
11.6 seconds
114mph
51.3mpg
127g/km
ON SALE Now
Otis Clay
Verdict
Interior is tidy,
with headroom
a real plus, and
rear seats are
very spacious.
The 16-inch
alloys make for
an occasionally
bumpy ride
31 December 2014 29
New cars
Richa
Richard Ingram
Richa
Richard_Ingram@dennis.co.uk
@cutt_ings
Mercedes B-Class
MercedesB-Class
FIRST DRIVE Updates aim to help MPV keep pace with new rivals
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Mercedes B-Class
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
New cars
Essentials
Mercedes B200 CDI Sport
Price:
Engine:
Power:
Torque:
Transmission:
0-62mph:
Top speed:
Economy:
CO2:
25,695
2.1-litre 4cyl turbodiesel
134bhp
300Nm
Seven-speed auto,
front-wheel drive
9.8 seconds
130mph
70.6mpg
107g/km
ON SALE Now
Verdict
THE tweaks help the B-Class
keep up with newer rivals. An
even more efficient B180 CDI
Eco model is available, with
CO2 emissions of 95g/km,
but this B200 CDI is the pick
of the range, with just enough
power to make driving it fun.
Ultimately the B-Class is about
practicality, though, and in that
respect its as good as ever.
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 31
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
Xxxxxxxxxxx
ter 250bhp
We drove eve n hot
back in
4WD Polo R prototype no
has
Issue 1,254, but VW
build it
immediate plans to
New cars
Essentials
VW Polo GTI 5dr DSG
Price:
Engine:
Power:
Transmission:
0-62mph:
Top speed:
Economy:
CO2:
20,725
1.8-litre 4cyl turbo
189bhp
Seven-spd twin-clutch
auto, front-wheel drive
6.9 seconds
142mph
47.9mpg
139g/km
ON SALE Now
VolkswagenPoloGTI
FIRST DRIVE We see if DSG auto box detracts from hot hatch fun
Dean Gibson
Dean_Gibson@dennis.co.uk
Verdict
BY offering manual and DSG
boxes, plus three and five-door
options, the Polo GTI has all its
rivals covered. If you must have
an auto hot hatch, the DSG is a far
better option than Renaultsports
twin-clutch Clio. It delivers rapid
gearshifts, and is great to use in
manual mode, although the GTI
lacks that last degree of driving
fun to make it a clear class leader.
31 December 2014 33
New cars
Essentials
Tesla Model S 60kWh
ON SALE Now
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
TeslaModelS60kWh
Jonat
nat
Jonathan
Burn
Jonath
th
Jonathan_Burn@dennis.co.uk
@Jonathan_burn
www.autoexpress.co.uk
PRACTICALITY As theres no
transmission tunnel, the Model S
feels incredibly spacious inside
especially for those in the back
Verdict
THE Model Ss refinement,
performance and practicality
always impress. A more forgiving
set-up and accessible price point
make this 60kWh version a more
obtainable real-world prospect
than the flagship. But only
with a more comprehensive
recharging infrastructure will
it be described as faultless.
31 December 2014 35
New cars
Essentials
Audi A1 Sportback
1.4 TFSI S line
Price:
Engine:
Power/torque:
Transmission:
0-62mph:
Top speed:
Economy:
CO2:
20,100
1.4-litre 4cyl turbo
148bhp/250Nm
Six-spd manual,
front-wheel drive
7.9 seconds
134mph
58.9mpg
112g/km
ON SALE Now
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
AudiA11.4TSI
Running costs
58.9mpg (official)
52 fill-up
Richard_Ingram@dennis.co.uk
Richa
@cutt_ings
Well equipped
S line tops A1
range; 1.4 CoD
engine ideally
matches its
classy character
Verdict
POWERFUL enough for every
eventuality and whisper-quiet,
this higher-powered 1.4 TFSI
is a great match for the A1s
sophisticated character. We
still think the new 1.0 TFSI is the
best all-rounder, while the MINI
Cooper S is faster and more fun
to drive. Yet if quality, refinement
and style are key, this A1 should
definitely be on your shortlist.
www.autoexpress.co.uk
New cars
Nissan e-NV200
Pete Gibson
Coming soon
SKODA FABIA
ESTATE 2015
The practical Fabia
Estate will boast a
huge 530-litre boot.
Thats bigger than
many cars in
the class above.
SUPERMINIS
Nissane-NV200Combi
FIRST DRIVE Electric MPV is big, but is it clever?
Price: 26,309
(after 5,000 Govt. grant)
Engine: Single electric motor
Power/torque: 108bhp/254Nm
Transmission: Single-speed,
front-wheel drive
0-62mph: 14.0 seconds
Top speed: 76mph
Range: 106 miles
ON SALE Now
Extra kit
cant disguise
the plug-in
e-NV200s
van roots,
but at least
that means
theres plenty
of boot space
Richard Ingram
Ri
Richard_Ingram@dennis.co.uk
Ric
38 31 December 2014
Verdict
EQUIPMENT
Fiat 500
Ford Ka
Honda Jazz
Hyundai i20 Coup
Mazda 2
Renaultsport Twingo
Renault Zoe update
SEAT Ibiza
Skoda Fabia
Smart ForTwo
Smart ForFour
Suzuki Celerio
Vauxhall Adam S
Vauxhall Corsa VXR
Vauxhall Viva
2016
mid 2015
early 2015
March 2015
spring 2015
late 2015
spring 2015
2016
early 2015
early 2015
early 2015
February 2015
April 2015
spring 2015
spring 2015
FAMILY CARS
Alfa 4CStradale
2015
Alfa 6C
2016
Aston Martin DB9
late 2016
Aston Martin V8 Vantage
early 2016
Audi RS3
spring 2015
Audi A5
spring 2016
Audi R4
2016
Audi R8
mid 2015
Audi TT Sportback
2016
Audi TT Sport Quattro
2016
BMW M1
2016
BMW M2
mid 2015
Caterham sports car
2016
Chevrolet Corvette Z06
spring 2015
Ferrari 458M
spring 2015
Fiat Spider
late 2015
Ford Focus RS
2016
Ford Mustang
early 2015
Honda Civic Type R
March 2015
Honda NSX
mid 2015
Infiniti Q60
2016
Jaguar XE SVR
early 2016
Kia GT4 Stinger
2016
Lamborghini Asterion LP910-4
2017
Lexus GS-F
late 2015
Lexus RC
late 2015
Lexus LF-LC
2016
Maserati Alfieri
2016
Maserati GranTurismo
late 2017
McLaren P13
2015
Mercedes-AMG GT
early 2015
Mercedes C 450 AMG Sport spring 2015
MG TF replacement
2015
MINI JCW
early 2015
Nissan Pulsar Nismo
mid 2015
Peugeot 308 R
mid 2015
2015
mid 2015
late 2015
2017
2017
late 2015
late 2015
2015
early 2016
2017
2016
2016
2016
mid 2015
2017
late 2016
2016
2016
2018
2016
2015
2015
2015
late 2015
2016
early 2015
2017
2016
2016
mid 2015
2015
2015
2017
2016
2017
early 2015
2015
spring 2015
2016
mid 2015
2016
2016
2016
2015
2015
2015
2017
2015
2016
2016
2018
late 2015
early 2015
early 2015
spring 2015
spring 2015
early 2015
2016
March 2015
CABRIOLETS
Audi TT Roadster
2015
Alfa Romeo 4CSpider
early 2015
Ford Mustang Convertible
2015
Lamborghini Huracn Spyder late 2015
Mazda MX-5
early 2015
Mercedes C-Class Cabriolet
2015
Mercedes S-Class Cabriolet
2015
MINI Convertible
late 2015
Range Rover Evoque Cabriolet
2015
Rolls-Royce Wraith Drophead
2016
VW Beetle Dune cabriolet
late 2015
LUXURY CARS
BMW 7 Series
mid 2015
Cadillac ELR
late 2015
Infiniti Q80
2020
Jaguar XF
late 2015
Mercedes-Maybach S600 spring 2015
Mercedes S-Class Pullman
2015
Rolls-Royce Phantom
2017
VW Phaeton
late 2016
Volvo S90
2016
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road tests
50
ELECTRIC CAR
SHOOT-OUT
Kias new Soul EV
goes head-to-head with
BMWs pioneering i3.
40 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
58
60
Pole
position
Can Alfas new MiTo QV hot hatch
forge ahead of Ibiza and 208 rivals?
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 41
Road test
Styling 3.8/5
EVEN after six years on sale, the MiTo
stands out. Its distinctive styling draws
inspiration from the 8C Competizione
sports car, while the shield grille is a nod
to classic Alfas of the past.
The bulging wheelarches and small
windows add to the sporty looks, while the
QV model has gloss-black detailing to help
it stand out. You also get two-tone 18-inch
alloys, twin exhausts and cloverleaf badges
on the front wings. Our cars Matt Magnesio
Grey paint is 800, but it only really looks
good when the car is clean, because when
its dirty, it simply looks like dull paint.
Inside, there are more sporty touches. The
dashtop and armrests get carbon bre-effect
plastic, and there are sports seats and a
at-bottomed steering wheel. As is tradition,
theres Italian acqua and benzina labelling for
the water temperature and petrol gauges,
although the QVs mix of red-lit controls and
white dials looks messy. Our car also featured
2,000 optional Sabelt carbon-bre bucket
seats, which give the cabin a race-bred feel.
Overall, the quality of plastic is on a par
with the SEAT, but thats not saying much, as
both cars feature hard materials that arent as
good as those in the Peugeot. The build quality
also feels imsy compared to the Peugeot.
Driving 2.7/5
POWER for the MiTo QV comes from Fiats
1.4 MultiAir turbo petrol. It makes 168bhp,
and sounds sporty when you rev it, but its
10bhp down on the SEAT and a 29bhp behind
the Peugeot, although it makes up for this
with the same 250Nm of torque as the Ibiza.
The MiTo recorded slower acceleration
gures through the gears, but it was closer to
its rivals in-gear, and we managed 0-60mph
in 7.6 seconds, which was three-tenths slower
than Alfas claimed 0-62mph time. Our efforts
were hampered by the MiTos TCT twin-clutch
gearbox, and the transmission manages to
spoil the whole driving experience.
Unlike the SEATs DSG box, manual
mode doesnt give full control, because the
electronics throw in their own shifts when
youre not expecting them, so youre never
sure if a shift was one of yours or the cars. The
Reliability 3.5/5
ALFA Romeo has had a reputation for poor
reliability, but the latest models shouldnt be
tarred with the same brush. Minor niggles
have been reported by MiTo owners, but
theres a three-year warranty and breakdown
cover which should give added peace of mind.
Our car had some quality issues, though.
The dash cubby to the right of the drivers
knee kept falling open, while a broken zip on
the right-hand back seat cover had clearly
been stapled together to keep it in place.
The MiTo earned a ve-star Euro NCAP
score, but this was achieved when it was
launched in 2008, and the test is tougher now.
However, you do get seven airbags, traction,
stability and hill-hold control, while the QV
features Brembo brakes as standard.
Exterior
DEA N GIBS ON
DEPUTY Road test editor
Alfa Romeo
Interior
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road test
Styling
MITOS unique style, based on the 8C Competizione
sports car, means it really stands out. Cloverleaf
badges adorn the wings and bulging wheelarches
and small windows accentuate the sporty look.
Distinct, two-tone 18-inch alloys are standard.
o MiTo QV
!
CO2/tax
Practicality
Performance
Braking
Running costs
124g/km
0-60/30-70mph
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
110 or 17%
270/950 litres
7.6/6.6 seconds
55.1/40.9/11.0m
55 fill-up
Practicality
2.8/5
Touchscreen
TOUCHSCREEN is easy
to use but grey plastic
surround looks out of place
Steering wheel
FLAT-bottomed steering
wheel and sports seats
give cabin a racier feel
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 43
Road test
Styling 4.2/5
THE standard Peugeot 208 is a familiar shape
in the supermini class, while the GTi version
has been given enough of a makeover to help
it stand out from lower-spec models. Its
offered exclusively as a three-door, while GTi
badges are added to the chrome trim on the
C-pillars, in a nod to the original 205 GTi.
Elsewhere, you get a chequered pattern
for the grille, plus a red GTi badge on the
lower lip, chrome wing mirror caps, a
sporty bodykit and 17-inch alloy wheels
with bright red brake calipers. The Prestige
model gets black paint on the wheels
between the polished spokes, while
panoramic glass and cornering lights are
also included on this higher spec model.
Overall, the 208 GTis proportions give it a
sportier look than the rather upright MiTo.
Inside, theres the same solid build quality
as other models in the 208 range, with some
sporty upgrades to the GTi. The optional sports
seats arent as distinctive as the Alfas Sabelt
items, but theyre more comfortable, although
the 208s awkward driving position is in
evidence. Some of our testers needed to move
the small steering wheel down to their lap to
be able to see the dials, which feels unnatural.
At least the dash looks attractive, particularly
the glowing red LED surrounds for the speedo
and rev counter. The touchscreen multimedia
system is a bit of a ddle to use on the move,
although the steering column-mounted
audio controls go some way to helping that.
Driving 4.1/5
WITH a 197bhp turbocharged four-cylinder
engine under the bonnet, the 208 GTi is one
of the most powerful superminis you can buy.
Its 29bhp up on the MiTo, while the six-speed
manual gearbox helps you to put the power to
the road far easier than both its rivals here.
You can turn off the traction control, and
we managed 0-60mph in 6.8 seconds on a
slippery surface. That matched Peugeots
claimed 0-62mph time, and was nearly a
second faster than the MiTo, although this
was no surprise due to its power advantage.
The GTi was faster through the gears, too,
although acceleration in-gear was similar
between all three contenders.Theres no auto
Exterior
Reliability 3.8/5
THERE have been electrical niggles in the
past with the 208, although with production
running for over two years, you would
expect these gremlins to be ironed out over
time. The 208 did well to nish 49th in our
2014 Driver Power survey, although it only
had an average score for reliability.
According to Euro NCAPs test scores,
the 208 is safer than the SEAT Ibiza,
although it only gets six airbags to the
MiTos seven. Still, hill hold and a speed
limiter feature on the list of standard kit.
Peugeot 20
Interior
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road test
Styling
CHEQUERED pattern on grille denotes the sportier GTi model. Chrome
wing mirrors caps and 17-inch alloys with red brake calipers help the
Peugeot to stand out, although it still retains the familiar shape of
the standard 208. Prestige model in our pictures also features
black paint on wheels and panoramic glass and cornering lights.
08 GTi
T EST ErS n ote s...
!
CO2/tax
Practicality
Performance
Braking
Running costs
139g/km
0-60/30-70mph
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
130 or 20%
285/1,076 litres
6.8/6.0 seconds
54.5/39.9/9.6m
61 fill-up
wheel is
The small steering
ition
pos
but
ch,
tou
rty
a spo
t
can
you
and
h
it hig
see the dials, like the
.
digital speedometer
Touchscreen
TOUCHSCREEN is ddly, but
screen size is larger than the
MiTos and audio controls on
steering column are handy
Trim
RED touches around the
cabin set the sportier 208
apart from its siblings and
add a real dose of style
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Practicality
3.5/5
THERES a 285-litre boot, which is
the biggest on test, while the wide
opening hatch and low boot lip
mean its easy to load, too. Back
seat space is also good, and is
helped by the 208s longer
wheelbase compared to its rivals
here. Theres more headroom than
in the SEAT, while legroom is
better than in the Alfa as the front
seats dont cut into kneeroom.
Up front, you need to sit
with the small steering wheel in
your lap to see the dials, but there
are cup-holders and decent door
bins. However, one door bin will
be taken up by the owners
manual, as the narrow glovebox
ts in around the fusebox, and
isnt big enough for it. The Prestige
model features a panoramic glass
roof as standard, which makes
the cabin feel spacious, and
doesnt cut into headroom.
31 December 2014 45
Road test
Styling 4.1/5
SEATs latest models feature sharp styling that
helps them stand out from their VW Group
siblings. The Ibiza was one of the rst models
to use the companys current design
philosophy when it was launched in 2008,
and it still looks smart today. Its compact
dimensions mean it looks taut and athletic
compared to its slightly bulbous rivals here.
The SC badge is a bit of a misnomer for
the three-door Ibiza, because while it has a
distinctive look, its more hatchback than
sports car. Whats more, the Cupra model
could do with a bit more visual impact to help
it stand out from lower-spec models. You get
bigger bumpers with gaping air vents, large
17-inch alloys with low-prole tyres and a
centre exit exhaust out back, but unless youre
a diehard SEAT fan, youd struggle to tell the
difference between the Cupra and the lowerspec FR model. Only the Cupra lettering
across the bootlid distinguishes it, while the
chequered ag badges are on the small side.
Inside, the Ibiza Cupra gets sports seats
with a distinctive black-and-white fabric
trim, plus gloss-black trim on the dashboard.
However, hard plastics and a slightly
confusing design let the interior down.
It seems as if the centre console has
been designed without consideration for
all of the functions required. As a result,
most of the climate buttons are on the dash,
but the heated rear screen button is placed
down by the gearlever. Add in a stereo that
takes practice to navigate properly, and the
SEAT is harder to get on with than the
touchscreen-equipped Peugeot or Alfa.
Reliability 3.7/5
SEAT dealers performed poorly in the
2014 Driver Power survey, nishing
rock-bottom of our dealer survey. The
manufacturer is trying to address this by
upgrading its network, but we will have to
wait and see if the changes make a difference.
The Ibiza has been in production for a
few years now, so most electrical and
mechanical problems should be ironed out,
although there have been reports of the sevenspeed DSG gearbox being troublesome and
proving quite costly to x. Like the 208, the
Ibiza has a ve-star Euro NCAP safety rating,
although its percentage scores are lower.
There are only four airbags curtain bags
are a 200 option but you do get tyre
pressure monitors and hill hold control.
Driving 3.9/5
Exterior
SEAT Ibiza C
Interior
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road test
seven-speed DSG
The Ibiza Cupras
ad of Alfas TCT
auto is light years ahe ection is smooth,
sel
transmission. Gear
puts the driver in
while manual mode
t small auto out
control. Its the bes
208 GT is
there although the ter.
bet
manual box is even
dean gibs on
deputy road test editor
Head-to-head
CO2/tax
139g/km
130 or 20%
Practicality
Boot (seats up/down)
236 litres/N/A
details
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Performance
Engines
ALL three cars use turbo petrol
engines, while the SEAT adds a
supercharger. The 208 GTi is the
most powerful with 197bhp and
275Nm of torque, compared to
168bhp/250Nm for the MiTo and
178bhp/250Nm for the Ibiza.
Despite its extra power and
manual box, the 208 accelerated
slower than the SEAT the Ibizas
close-ratio DSG box and a broad
powerband gave it an edge.
0-60/30-70mph
6.6/5.8 seconds
Braking
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
49.4/35.7/9.4m
/9.4m
Options
Running costs
36.6mpg (on test)
55 fill-up
Cupra
Practicality 3.3/5
Trim
Badge appeal
THE Green Cloverleaf name is part
of Alfas history (see P49), but
Peugeots GTi badge arguably has
more appeal in this sector, thanks
to the companys 30 years of hot
hatch history. In contrast, SEATs
Cupra badge is relatively new, rst
appearing in the nineties, when
SEAT was involved in rallying.
Seats
SPORT seats feature
white trim to help create
an eye catching interior
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 47
Alfa Romeo
omeo MiTo vs rivals
Figures
Peugeot
208 GTi Prestige
tige
19,950/20,245
45
9,097/45.6%
10,853
791/1,581
1,683/2,805
33/394/E/130
16.99p/m (3yr/30k)
Length/wheelbase
Height/width
Engine
Peak power/revs
Peak torque/revs
Transmission
Fuel tank capacity/spare wheel
Boot capacity (seats up/down)
Kerbweight/payload/towing weight
Turning circle
Basic warranty (miles)/recovery
Service intervals/UK dealers
Driver Power manufacturer/dealer pos
Euro NCAP: Adult/child/ped./stars
3,962/2,538mm
1,460/1,739mm
4cyl in-line/1,598cc
197/5,800 bhp/rpm
275/1,700 Nm/rpm
6spd man/fwd
50 litres/space saver
285/1,076 litres
1,160/490/1,150kg
11.4 metres
3yrs (unlimited)/1yr
20k miles (1yr)/300
14th/9th
88/78/61/5 (2012)
0-60/30-70mph
30-50mph in 3rd/4th
50-70mph in 5th/6th/7th
Top speed/rpm at 70mph
Braking 70-0/60-0/30-0mph
Auto Express econ (mpg/mpl)/range
Noise outside/idle/30/70mph
Govt urban/extra-urban/combined
Govt urban/extra-urban/combined
Actual/claimed CO2/tax bracket
6.8/6.0 secs
3.1/4.1 secs
5.5/6.8 secs/N/A
143mph/2,500rpm
54.5/39.9/9.6m
39.7/8.7/437
62/46/61/71dB
34.4/60.1/47.9mpg
7.6/13.2/10.5mpl
164/139g/km/20%
Airbags/Isofix/park sensors/camera
Auto/stability/cruise control
Auto climate ctrl/leather/heated seats
Met paint/xenon lights/sunroof
Sat-nav/USB/DAB/Bluetooth
Results
Six/yes/rear/no
No/yes/yes
Yes/part/yes
495/no/yes
Yes/yes/yes/yes
SEA
SEAT
Ibiza SC Cupra
Ibi
PRICE
THE standard
208 GTi is 850
less and ditches
the heated
seats, sat-nav,
panoramic
glass, cornering
lights and black
painted alloys.
BIGGEST ENGINE
THE 208 has the
largest capacity
and produces the
biggest power
figures of this trio.
ACCELERATION
THE GTis manual
gearbox takes
more driver
skill to get it off
the line, but its
more rewarding
as a result.
OPTIONS
ONLY factory-fit
extras on 208 GTi
Prestige are
metallic paint
and front central
armrest with
storage (70).
1st
PEUGEOT
18
18,980/19,990
990
8,067/42.5%
10,914
752/1,504
1,826/3,043
27/371/E/130
19.99p/m (3yrs)
4,055/2,469mm
1,420/1,693mm
4cyl in-line/1,390cc
178/6,200 bhp/rpm
250/2,000 Nm/rpm
7spd DSG/fwd
45 litres/space saver
236 litres/N/A
1,259/411kg/N/A
10.5 metres
3yrs (60,000)/2yrs
10k miles (1yr)/128
24th/32nd
82/77/59/5 (2011)
6.6/5.8 secs
2.6/3.4 secs
4.8/6.3/7.8 secs
142mph/2,500rpm
49.4/35.7/9.4m
36.6/8.1/362 miles
62/41/64/70dB
37.7/55.4/47.9mpg
8.3/12.2/10.5mpl
178/139g/km/20%
Four/yes/220/no
Yes/yes/yes
Yes/part/345
490/yes/495
Yes/no/175/yes
SEAT
Road test
Al Romeo MiTo
Alfa
iTo
Quadrifoglio Verde
Qua
rde
SERVICING
SEATs monthly
service plan is
payable over
two years, but
the scheme
covers the car for
three services.
NO TOWING
CENTRE-exit
exhaust means
you cant do any
towing with the
Ibiza Cupra.
OPTIONS
HEATED seats are
part of Winter
Pack, which also
adds heated
washer jets and a
height-adjustable
passenger seat.
2nd
20
20,210/25,020
020
7,053/34.9%
13,157
685/1,371
2,265/3,775
27/321/D/110
214/313/214
DEPRECIATION
MITO has poorest
residuals here,
and will be worth
2,000 less than
the Peugeot after
three years.
4,063/2,511mm
1,446/1,720mm
4cyl in-line/1,368cc
168/5,500 bhp/rpm
250/2,500 Nm/rpm
6spd TCT/fwd
45 litres/space saver
270/950 litres
1,145/N/A/500kg
11.3 metres
3yrs (unlimited)/3yrs
18k miles (1yr)/46
21st/18th
5/3/2 (2008)
7.6/6.6 secs
3.0/4.3 secs
5.4/6.8 secs/N/A
136mph/3,000rpm
55.1/40.9/11.0m
29.5/6.5/292 miles
62/44/60/69dB
40.4/64.2/52.3mpg
8.9/14.1/11.5mpl
221/124g/km/17%
Seven/yes/rear/no
Yes/yes/yes
450/1,050/250
475/no/750
Yes/yes/yes/yes
EURO NCAP
QV is a new
model, but MiTo
itself was tested
back in 2008, so
Euro NCAP score
isnt comparable
to rivals here.
PAINT OPTIONS
THE only standard
colour is black, or
you can splash out
800 for the
Matte Magnesio
Grey paint of the
car in our pictures.
ALFA ROMEO
3rd
*Joint options. Bold = equipment fitted to our test car. Insurance quotes from AA (Tel 0800 107 0680 or www.theAA.com) for a 42-year-old living in Banbury, Oxon, with three penalty points. Residual values provided by CDL VIP Data.
Worth considering...
Ford Fiesta ST
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 49
Road test
Charging
ahead
Kia is the latest manufacturer
f
to enter the
h all-electric
ll l t i
small car market with its new Soul EV. But can it really
take the fight to the current class leader, BMWs i3?
Pictures: Pete Gibson Location: Longcross Proving Ground, Chobham, Surrey
50 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
BMW i3
Kia Soul EV
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road test
31 December 2014 51
Road test
Styling 3.4/5
WITH its upright lines, boxy proportions
and bold detailing, the standard Soul doesnt
exactly blend into the background. The EV
model is even more eye-catching, thanks to
its faired-in grille, contrasting roof nish and
streamlined, body-coloured wheel trims.
While the Kias exterior stands out, the
cabin is more traditional. A gloss white nish
is used for the centre console and gearlever
surround, while the analogue dials are
replaced by digital versions. Otherwise the
interior is carried over largely unchanged
from the standard Soul. It certainly feels
more conventional than the futuristic BMW
the block graphics on the LCD instruments
look dated next to the i3s classy TFT screens.
Still, thats no bad thing, as the dashboard
is clearly laid out and the touchscreen
infotainment system is easy to use.
Where the Kia really scores over the
BMW is with its generous standard kit list.
In fact, not many luxury saloons can match
the Kias impressive tally, which includes
sat-nav, keyless entry, heated front seats
and steering wheel and a DAB radio.
Driving 3.2/5
WITH its seamless, near-silent power
delivery, light controls and quiet ride, the
Soul serves up a remarkably relaxing driving
experience. This can be partly explained by
the EVs 109bhp power output and hefty
1,565kg kerbweight, which combine to
blunt acceleration. In fact, compared to
the lighter and more powerful BMW, the
Kia felt sluggish at the track. It completed the
0-60mph sprint in 10.7 seconds, which was a
yawning 3.6 seconds slower than the BMW.
However, in the real world the Soul feels
brisk enough, particularly around town,
where it responds sharply to the throttle.
Its only at speeds above 60mph that the
Kias rate of acceleration starts to slow, so it
doesnt have the same condence-inspiring
reserves of overtaking pace as the i3.
On the plus side, this lack of performance
means that the Kia never feels anything less
than safe and predictable on the move. Yet
while theres not much fun to be had behind
Kia Soul
Interior
Reliability 4.2/5
THIS is Kias rst attempt at an electric
production model, but with the brands good
reputation for building reliable cars, and fewer
mechanical parts to go wrong, the newcomer
should prove fault-free. Even so, the seven-year
and 100,000-mile warranty adds peace of mind.
Like the BMW, the Soul lost valuable points
in Euro NCAPs tough pedestrian protection
tests on account of its upright styling, so the
EV was awarded a disappointing four stars
in the overall ranking. However, all versions
still get six airbags, stability control and a
pedestrian warning sound generator.
Sat-nav
White trim
y bold
Theres nothing ver
the
but
l,
Sou
the
about
ry
rened power delive g
and easy-going drivin
experience make it
a great urban car.
www.autoexpress.co.uk
EV
Exterior
Road test
!
CO2/tax
Practicality
Performance
Braking
Electric motor
0g/km
0-60/30-70mph
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
Power/official range
0 or 0%
281/891 litres
10.7/11.4 seconds
55.0/40.7/10.0m
109bhp/132 miles
On the road
Practicality 3.9/5
WITH its traditional ve-door layout and three
rear seatbelts, the Kia edges ahead of the BMW
for versatility. The Soul also has a fraction more
headroom for passengers in the back, although
the small side windows and lower seating position
mean the cabin doesnt feel quite as airy as its rivals.
Open the Kias upright tailgate and youll
nd a well shaped 281-litre load bay, while lifting
the boot oor reveals a handy hidden compartment
for the cars charging cables. Plug these into a
domestic socket and youll need around 12 hours
for a full charge. However, installing
a fast-charging 6.6kW wallbox at
your home means the batteries
can be topped up in around
four to ve hours.
Kia claims that the Soul can
travel up to 132 miles between
charges, but like the BMW,
80 to 100 miles is more
realistic for day-to-day
driving, while the recent
cold weather reduced
our test cars estimated
range to just 70 miles.
www.autoexpress.co.uk
toexpress.co.uk
, but
Its a minor niggle
theres a frustrating
ng
delay between pluggi
ins
the Soul into the ma
rge
and the dashtop cha
indicator confir ming g
that cur rent is flowin
e
into the batter y. Th
its
BMW lets you know
charging as soon
as you connect
the cable.
Styling Boxy dimensions and bold detailing ensure Soul doesnt fade into background,
and contrasting roof nish and LED running lights help it to stand out further
31 December 2014 53
Road test
Exterior
Styling 4.5/5
EVEN when parked alongside the bold Soul,
the i3 manages to stand out. Taking its cues
from the BMW Coup Concept that debuted
in 2012, the battery-powered car looks like
its driven straight off a motor show stand.
Tall and narrow proportions give the i3 the
look of an MPV rather than a family hatch, but
you could argue it stands in a class of its own
like the Kia. Lightweight plastics are used
for the heavily sculpted body panels, while the
bonnet and glass tailgate get a distinctive
gloss black nish. Other highlights include
the angular window line, swept-back
headlamps and metallic blue trim for
the faired-in grille and lower sills.
The futuristic feel continues inside.
Access is easy thanks to the rear-hinged
doors and lack of a B-pillar although
you have to step over the wide sill. Once in,
youll be able to enjoy the cleverly packaged
and imaginatively designed layout thats
easy to use and beautifully nished.
When you climb into the high-set drivers
seat, the rst thing youll spot is a pair of large
TFT screens one ahead of the driver and one
that appears to oat above the centre of the
dashboard. These display everything from
speed to sat-nav info and are controlled
via BMWs trademark iDrive dial.
There are four interior nishes to
choose from standard, 1,000 Loft, 1,500
Lodge and 2,000 Suite and all get brightly
coloured seat and carpet trims, with many
made from sustainable materials. Metallic
blue trim inserts add the nal ourish.
Driving 4.0/5
IT doesnt take long behind the wheel of
the i3 to realise that its infused with BMWs
trademark driving fun. With its powerful
168bhp electric motor and lightweight 1,270kg
carbon bre structure, it showed the Kia a
clean pair of heels at the track. For instance,
the BMW goes from 0-60mph in a brisk 7.1
seconds, which was a full 3.6 seconds faster
than the less powerful and heavier Soul.
The cars lower kerbweight pays dividends
when it comes to braking performance, too,
and despite its skinny, low-rolling-resistance
tyres, the BMW stopped in a shorter distance
Reliability 3.9/5
ALTHOUGH BMW is new to electric car
technology, it has worked hard to make the
i3 as reliable as its traditional models. In a
bid to reassure buyers, the brand provides
an eight-year and 100,000-mile warranty for
the lithium-ion battery pack, while the rest
of the car is covered by a standard three-year,
unlimited-mileage guarantee. Your car will
also be maintained by specialist i dealers.
The combination of a strong, carbon
bre-reinforced plastic structure, six airbags
and standard stability control gives the BMW
some excellent safety credentials on paper.
However, bluff front-end styling cost it points
in Euro NCAPs pedestrian assessments
resulting in a disappointing four-star score.
Still, you can add a raft of advanced safety
options, such as the 790 Driving Assistant
Plus pack. This brings together adaptive
cruise control, forward collision alert and
Trafc Jam Assist, which will accelerate, steer
and brake the car at speeds up to 24mph. A
pedestrian warning noise generator is 85.
CO2/tax
0g/km
0 or 5%
Practicality
Boot (seats up/down)
260/1,100 litres
Performance
0-60/30-70mph
7.1/6.5 seconds
Braking
70-0/60-0/30-0mph
49.5/38.1/8.7m
Electric motor
Power/official range
168bhp/120 miles
BMW i3
Interior
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Road test
Head-to-head
Performance
details
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
here please
Caption into space
Charging
BOTH cars can be charged using
a mains socket, with each reaching
80 per cent charge between seven
and eight hours. Theres also the
option of installing a fast charger
the Kia is compatible with the
free British Gas unit, but the i3
requires BMWs 315 i Wallbox.
on
asiion
cas
se of occ
nse
eall sen
You get a rea
futuristic
its
th
Wi
i3.
the
g
drivin
id,,
id
pid
interior and rap
n,,
ion
rattio
era
silent accele
ga
ng
its like runnin
s.
spaceship on wheel
dean gibs on
deputy road test editor
Practicality 3.7/5
Materials
THE interior trim
and most of the
materials are made of
sustainable resources
iDrive
iDr
TRADEMARK
TRA
iDrive controller
iDr
used to access
use
functions on
fu
two TFT
tw
screens;
scr
they display
the
information such
info
speed and sat-nav
as spe
www.autoexpress.co.uk
to
k
Standard kit
YOU wont be short of gadgets
in either of our contenders, as
both are equipped with sat-nav,
Bluetooth, a DAB radio and climate
control. On top of this, the Kia
adds heated seats and steering
wheel, as well as metallic paint.
31 December 2014 55
Road test
Figures
Kia Soul EV
25,680/31,470
10,453/30.9%
23,377
0/0
N/A
21/332/A/0
375 (5yrs/60k)
24
24,995/29,995
N/A
N/A
0/0
N/A
18/445/A/0
199 (three services)
Length/wheelbase
Height/width
Engine
Peak power
Peak torque
Transmission
Battery warranty (miles)/spare wheel
Boot capacity (seats up/down)
Kerbweight/payload
Turning circle/drag coefficient
Basic warranty (miles)/recovery
Service intervals/UK dealers
Driver Power manufacturer/dealer pos.
Euro NCAP: Adult/child/ped./stars
3,999/2,570mm
1,578/1,775mm
AC electric motor
168bhp
250Nm
Single speed/rwd
8yrs (100k)/sealant
260/1,100 litres
1,270/425kg
9.9 metres/0.29Cd
3yrs (unltd)/3yrs
Variable/47
10th/22nd
86/81/57/4
0-60/30-70mph
30-50mph
50-70mph
Top speed
Braking 70-0/60-0/30-0mph
Noise levels 30/70mph
Claimed range
Full charge time (mains)
80% charge time (rapid charger DC)
CO2/tax bracket
Airbags/Isofix/park sensors/camera
Automatic box/stability/cruise control
Climate control/leather/heated seats
Metallic paint/LED lights/keyless go
Sat-nav/USB/DAB radio/Bluetooth
Results
7.1/6.5 secs
2.3 secs
4.2 secs
93mph
49.5/38.1/8.7m
64/73dB
120 miles
13 hours (est)
30 minutes (est)
0g/km/0%
Six/yes/yes/790
Yes/yes/yes
Yes/2,000/260
530/no/yes
Yes/yes/yes/yes
WEIGHT
THE BMWs clever
carbon fibrereinforced plastic
structure helps
keep weight down
to 1,270kg, which
is a whopping
295kg less
than the lowerpowered Kia.
PERFORMANCE
LOW weight and
168bhp output
allowed the i3
to clean up at
the track. On the
road it feels
even faster than
figures suggest.
BENEFIT IN KIND
ELECTRIC cars are
currently exempt
from company
car tax, but from
April 2015 theyll
be rated at five
per cent.
STANDARD KIT
PARKING sensors
are included, but
you dont get as
much kit as in Kia.
Still, slick design
and bold materials
give i3 a more
upmarket feel.
1st
BMW
Switching
to electric
How makers are trying to
ease the pain for buyers
struggling with EV move
SERVICE PACK
KIAS Care-3
maintenance pack
is great value at
199 for three
years coverage.
Price increases
to 329 for the
five-year plan.
4,140/2,570mm
1,593/1,800mm
AC electric motor
109bhp
285Nm
Single speed/fwd
7yrs (100k)/sealant
281/891 litres
1,565/395kg
10.6 metres/N/A
7yrs (100,000)/1yr
10,000 miles (1yr)/170
7th/10th
84/82/59/4
DEALERS
CURRENTLY, only
13 of Kias 170
dealers have
the facilities and
training to sell and
maintain the Soul
EV. By contrast,
BMW boasts 46
franchises that can
deal with its i range
of electric cars.
10.7/11.4 secs
4.1 secs
7.2 secs
90mph
55.0/40.7/10.0m
61/66dB
132 miles
11-14 hours (est)
33 minutes (est)
0g/km/0%
NO OPTIONS
HEATED seats and
steering wheel are
among welcome
standard features
on the Kia. There
are no options
even metallic
paint is included,
as are keyless
entry and start.
Six/yes/yes/yes
Yes/yes/yes
Yes/no/yes
Yes/no/yes
Yes/yes/yes/yes
2nd
KIA
In red = equipment fitted to our test car. Insurance quotes from AA (Tel 0800 107 0680 or www.theAA.com)
for a 42-year-old living in Banbury, Oxon, with three penalty points. Residual values provided by CDL VIP Data.
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driverpower
Worth considering...
Range-extending i3?
Kia options?
Nissan Leaf
THE bold Nissan set the electric family car ball rolling
back in 2011. Its not as daring as the BMW, but its
spacious, well equipped and good to drive. Prices
start at 16,490 if you take out a monthly battery
lease, or you can pay more and buy it outright.
56 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Our cars
po i n t s . ..
G o o d & Bad poi
Essentials
HANDLING
St
Steve
Walker
St
Steve_Walker@dennis.co.uk
@Steve_cars
58 31 December 2014
On fleet since:
Price new:
Engine:
CO2/tax:
Options:
Insurance*:
Mileage/mpg:
Any problems?
January 2014
21,749
1.6-litre 4cyl, 118bhp
110g/km/20
Metallic paint (430)
Group: 19 Quote: 334
8,920/53.5mpg
Faulty exhaust pressure sensor
(covered under warranty)
Suzuk
Our cars
T E S T E r S n o t e s . .. er diesel
The Suzukis eag
iver
and six-speed box del
warm hatch pace and
y.
reasonable econom
ki SX4 S-Cross
CO2/tax
Practicality
Running costs
110g/km
20 or 18%
430/875 litres
60 fill-up
MY RATING
PRACTICALITY
Decently sized
430-litre boot is easily expanded,
thanks to removable oor and
cubbyhole dividers on either side
31 December 2014 59
Our cars
Stuart Milne
St
Stuart_Milne@dennis.co.uk
Stua
@stuartjmilne
poii n t s ...
G o o d & Bad po
is
Attention to detail
bies
superb, including cub neat
and
s
ket
jac
vis
hifor
ips
ambient lighting str
d.
which can be dimme
Additions
MY RATING
Audi A3 Saloon
STEREO
If youre planning
g
to buy a smallish
Audi saloon soon, it
ought to be this one
ne
60 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Essentials
Audi A3 1.4 TFSI CoD
S line 150PS S tronic
On fleet since: May 2014
Price new: 26,925
Engine: 1.4-litre 4cyl, 148bhp
CO2/tax: 109g/km/20
Options: LED headlights (795),
interior lighting (170), technology package
(1,795), electric front seats (550), heated
front seats (260), Advanced key (425),
electric, folding and heated mirrors (150),
electric lumbar support (195), Comfort
pack (605), Bang & Olufsen stereo (750)
Insurance*: Group: 21 Quote: 329
Mileage/mpg: 5,831/40.2mpg
Any problems? Broken headlight unit
*Insurance quote provided by AA
(0800 107 0680) for a 42-year-old living
in Banbury, Oxon, with three points.
Our cars
Fleetwatch
Dacia Duster
Our fleet
Derek Goard
T E S T E r S n o t e s . ..
on the A3 driving to
I put over 700 miles 24 Hours in
ns
Ma
Le
and from the
complaints,
France. I had no big tem wouldnt
although the MMI sys iPod
er
interface with my old
CO2/tax
109g/km
20 or 14%
425/880 litres
Running costs
40.2mpg (on test)
65 fill-up
www.autoexpress.co.uk
BMW i3
ONE of the perils of
electric car ownership is
the relative scarcity of
public charging points.
When editor at large
Mat Watson needed
some juice for our i3,
he thought hed hit the
jackpot with a Camden
Council bay run by
supplier Source London.
However, it turns out
you only get three hours
of charging time before
the point switches off!
It wasnt a fast-charge
bay, either, so the measly
seven-amp supply meant
our 180-minute slot only
added an extra 16 miles
of range. Thankfully our
i3 is a range extender, so
Mat could drive off to
nd a more generous
electricity supply.
1,330, 1,339
Hyundai i10
Issues 1,332, 1,338, 1,348
Jaguar F-Type
Iss. 1,307, 1,319, 1,329, 1,344
Kia Soul EV
Issue 1,350
Lexus IS 300h
Iss. 1,312, 1,320, 1,329, 1,340
Mazda 3
Issues 1,311, 1,334, 1345
MINI Cooper D 5dr
Issue 1,346
Peugeot 308 SW
Issue 1,342
SEAT Leon SC Cupra
New arrival
Skoda Superb Estate
Issue 1,347
Suzuki SX4 S-Cross
Issues 1,310, 1,321, 1,334
Vauxhall Corsa
New arrival
Volkswagen Golf GTI
Issues 1,320, 1,332, 1,341
31 December 2014 61
Products
se new
Gtechniq claims the as we ll
m
products will per for
rket, but
as the best on the ma money
offer better value for
THIS WEEKS
Henry
Willis
HOT KIT
Got a query?
Henry_Willis@dennis.co.uk
@WineryHills
Q
PRICE FROM 4.99 (W8 BUG REMOVER)
Q
A
TOP TIPS
www.autoexpress.co.uk
31 December 2014 63
Products
BESTPRICE 103.68
BESTPRICE 39.99
64 31 December 2014
news,
deals&
events
TomTom teams up
with Acer for app
SAT-nav company TomTom has
partnered with smartphone
manufacturer Acer, allowing its
navigation software engine to
be used in an exclusive app.
Available on selected new
Acer handsets, AcerNAV enables
users to navigate anywhere in the
world without having to pay extra
roaming charges and additional
TomTom maps can be downloaded
for free. TomToms app, with which
the Acer version will share many
features, was second in our
Issue 1,313 sat-nav app test.
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
gameplay in
The main focus of
as you for m a
The Crew is online,
But its had
rs.
use
er
clan with oth
launch day
server issues since
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Products
Mini test
NEW PRODUCT
The Clay Cloth Company
Polymer Clay Cloth
n e e d t o k n o w. . .
remove
Clay products help
bodywork.
contaminants from
th is a
The Polymer Clay Clo job
new way of doing the
STILLTHETOPOPTION
Bilt Hamber auto-clay regular
RRP: 9.95
Contact: 01277 658899, www.bilthamber.com
books,
apps&games
Pieces of Silver
Mike Breslin (Pie Shop Publishing, bresmedia.co.uk)
RRP: 11.99 (paperback) Rating:
Everyday Modifications
for your MGB, GT, GTV8
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Products
Auto Express
AA Parking
Price: Free
Available for: iOS (iPad only)
Price: 1.99
Available for: iOS, Android, Windows Phone
GoPro
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android,
Windows Phone
XLR8
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android
68 31 December 2014
Price: 7.99
Available for: iOS
Asphalt 8:
Airborne
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android, Windows Phone
INRIX XD Traffic
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android, Windows Phone
www.autoexpress.co.uk
APPY
NEW
YEAR
Henry Willis
Products
Find My Car
Price: Free
Available for: iOS
CoPilot Premium
Price: From 19.99 (UK maps)
Available for: iOS, Android, Windows Phone
Waze
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android, Windows Phone
TyreSafe
Price: Free
Available for: iOS, Android
www.autoexpress.co.uk
auto
au
toex
to
expr
ex
pres
pr
ess.
es
s.co
s.
co.u
co
.ukk
.u
31 December 2014 69
Buyingcars
Joe
Finnerty
Got any car queries?
Joe_Finnerty@dennis.co.uk
@AE_Consumer
Q
YOUR VIEWS ON YOUR CARS
2014 Results
Giulietta Factfile
Years: 2010 to present CO2: 114g/km
Fuel economy: 64mpg (1.6 JTDM Turismo)
Best features: DNA driving system, parking
sensors, Bluetooth, stop/start, heated seats
86.99%
RELIABILITY
BUILD QUALITY
RUNNING COSTS
PERFORMANCE
ROAD HANDLING
RIDE QUALITY
EASE OF DRIVING
SEAT COMFORT
PRACTICALITY
IN-CAR TECH
www.autoexpress.co.uk
107
145
46
8
32
92
146
141
95
90
76
th
PLACE
PLAC
A E
AC
NOT SO GOOD
Im very pleased
with the cars economy
and appearance.
A responsive engine
and well balanced
suspension make it
a pleasure to drive.
Brilliant car stunning
to look at, great interior
and fantastic handling.
Wonderful engine,
drive and handling.
Like all Alfas, its
involving to drive and
a pleasure to get
behind the wheel of.
A
Q
A
The engine is
agricultural and drinks
oil even for a diesel.
It was a massive
disappointment in
terms of build quality
and attention to detail.
Im not happy at all
about the amount of
road noise transmitted
into the cabin by the
low-profile tyres.
Ive grown weary of
how unreliable it is.
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driverpower
Q
A
31 December 2014 71
Buying cars
NEED
TO KNOW
NEED
TO KNOW
NEED
TO KNOW
John Colley
History
72 31 December 2014
Which one?
Alternatives
Verdict
How much?
MANY Cee
eeds come
with
h stop-start
(Intellligent Stop
& Go). It ca
can be slow
to activate
te usually
becausee the battery
is low
w on charge.
14
13
63
2014
2013
2013
62 12
2012
2012
Model
1.4 1
1.62
1.63
1.6GT
1.4CRDi1
1.6CRDi2
1.6CRDi4
Wi
Windows
WHE
HEN its cold,
some o
owners have
found theeircar suffers
from cond
condensation
on the inside of
the wi
windows, and
poo
poor demisting.
11,750
13,795
14,695
14,895
12,995
15,295
16,995
THE earliest base Ceeds are 8,000, but most of the cars
available are 10,000-plus. Asking prices are all over the
place; one dealers Ceed diesel may be cheaper than
anothers petrol-engined car. You can also buy a Ceed 3
for less than a 1 elsewhere if you are prepared to travel.
Only one in five cars has a petrol engine; the same
proportion of those available which have an auto. Youll
be doing well to find one of these for less than 11,000
most are over 12,000. About a third of the Ceeds for
sale are estates; these are generally priced from 11,000.
Battery
Running costs
CO2
emissions
Annual
road tax
1.4
1.6 ISG
1.6 auto
1.6 T
1.4 CRDi
1.6 CRDi ISG
1.6 CRDi auto
THE headlights
can suffer from
flickering usually
when theyre switched
to auto mode, but
it can happen in
manual mode, too.
Performance
Running costs
CO2/tax
0-60mph/top speed
97-112g/km
11.5 secs/122mph
67 fill-up
Free-30
7-8
12-15
12-15
29
6
12-15
13
46-47mpg
52mpg
46mpg
38mpg
68mpg
74-76mpg
51mpg
139-143g/km
124-137g/km
140g/km
171g/km
109-114g/km
97-112g/km
145g/km
130-145
110-130
130
205
20-30
Free-30
145
Partwatch
www.autoexpress.co.uk/driverpower
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Independent price
66.00
132.00
50.48
22.99
27.00
71.88
N/A
15.00
Part
OUR VIEW
YOUR VIEW
Dealer price
Prices for a 2012 Ceed 1.6 CRDi. Dealer prices from Fish
Brothers in Swindon, Wiltshire (www.fish-bros.co.uk/kia).
Independent prices from Euro Car Parts (www.eurocarparts.com)
Recalls
Interior
Contacts
Official
www.kia.co.uk
Forums
www.kiaownersclub.co.uk
www.kia-forums.com
31 December 2014 73
Insurance group
Fuel
economy
Model
Headlights
Stopp-start
Buying cars
Buying cars
Best buys
Car hunter
7,000 for a spacious, no-frills MPV
Citroen Berlingo
Hyundai ix20
Vauxhall Zafira
Mercedes E-Class
74 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Buying cars
XF Sportbrake
520d Touring
A6 Avant
55.4mpg (official)
56.1mpg (official)
58.9mpg (official)
86 fill-up
80 fill-up
86 fill-up
Premium brands add a touch of class to the humble estate. But which is the best used?
JaguarXFSportbrake
BMW520dTouring
AudiA6Avant
Verdict
1
BMW 520d
XF Sportbrake 2.2d
520d Touring
Prices from:
24,500
76 31 December 2014
Prices from:
16,395
BMWs reputation for making greatdriving cars also extends to its estate
range. The Touring shares the same
precise, fun handling, refined ride and
excellent cabin as the 5 Series saloon.
The 2.0-litre diesel is punchy and the
most efficient here. Practicality is strong,
too although the A6 pips it for size,
a 560-litre boot, split-glass tailgate and
a versatile boot floor ensure that the
5 Series is the best true estate.
The 5 Series was voted best executive
car in our Driver Power 2014 survey,
faring well for reliability and build quality.
Prices from:
17,695
2
Audi A6 Avant
3
Jaguar XF
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Sport
UKs top
motorsport
events
4 & 6 April
12 April
2015
Silverstone, Towcester,
Northants, NN12 8TN
Tickets: www.silverstone.co.uk
9-10 May
Stephen Errity
Stephen_Errity@dennis.co.uk
24 May
27 June
FIA Formula E
London (TBC)
Battersea Park,
London, SW11 4NJ
Tickets: www.fiaformulae.com
5 July
Formula One
British Grand Prix
Silverstone, Towcester,
Northants, NN12 8TN
Tickets: www.silverstone.co.uk
Oulton
Park
Donington
30 August
Silverstone
Rally GB
11-13 September
Goodwood Revival
Goodwood Motor Circuit,
Chichester, West Sussex, PO18 0PH
Tickets: www.goodwood.com
or 01243 755055
13-15 November
Wales Rally GB
Battersea
Brands Hatch
Goodwood
Lydden
Hill
Tickets:
www.walesrallygb.com
88 31 December 2014
www.autoexpress.co.uk
Backchat
Mike
Rutherford
next
week
TESTED
New Renault
Twingo vs rivals
Flagship turbo city car takes ght
to Peugeot 108 and Hyundais i10
TESTED
Adam vs DS 3
DRIVEN
Ultimate guide
to road signs
on sale
Wednesday 7 January
www.autoexpress.co.uk
HAS YOUR
CAR WARRANTY
EXPIRED?
If your car is over 3 years old, chances are your car warrant
expired. Why risk wallet busting car repair bills?
Protect your motor with my award-winning car warranty
Warrantywise.
Ive designed it to offer the UKs highest level of car warrant
protection - bar none!
Call or go online for a quote and get total
peace of mind for any car up to 12 years old*.
Designe
warrantywise.co.uk/guide
Call us on Freephone
Like us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
warrantywise.co.uk
@Warrantywise