FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 01/15/2015 05:25 PM

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 49

INDEX NO. 152723/2014

RECEIVED NYSCEF: 01/15/2015

[UPDATE] E-Cigs Banned In NYC Public

Spaces

(Getty Images)
A bill that would ban the public use of electronic cigarettes everywhere traditional cigarettes are
prohibited is likely to become law. Yesterday the legislation was approved by the City Council's
Health Committee by a vote of 9-0, and it's expected to pass when the full council votes later this
evening. [UPDATE: The measure passed 43-8]
During a contentious City Council hearing two weeks ago, e-cigarette advocates heckled Health
Commissioner Dr. Thomas Farley and the bill's primary sponsor, Councilmember James
Gennaro, for claiming that bartenders would have a tough time distinguishing e-cigs from their
traditional counterparts, and for urging the passage of the bill despite the dearth of evidence on
the health effects of e-cigarettes.
"I tried to give both sides an opportunity to be heard, but every study provided by one side is
countered by the other side, which shows the exact opposite thing," Councilmember Peter F.
Vallone, Jr. said. Vallone had shown some sympathy for e-cigarette users at the hearing, noting
that some of his staff members used them to quit smoking, but he ultimately voted in favor of the

bill yesterday. "You heard the Commissioner say it: we just don't know enough right now...to
allow them to be smoked in restaurants and other similar places."
The bill's opponents, some of them puffing e-cigarettes in the gallery, claim that the product's
primary purpose is to help smokers quit (there is some preliminary evidence to suggest this).
E-cigarette executives from NJOY, Lorillard, and Logic also testified against the bill. Former
Surgeon General and current NJOY board member Dr. Richard Carmona submitted written
testimony panning the bill, and again sent letters to the City Council this week restating his
position.
Following the hearing, a Times op-ed from two Columbia professors voiced support for ecigarettes, and Joe Nocera all but embraced NJOY's corporate philosophy: to make combustible
cigarettes obsolete.
"Electronic cigarettes are an unregulated product that threaten to turn back the important gains
we as a city have made in the last decade to de-normalize the act of smoking and to maintain a
clean air environment to live, work, and play," Councilmember Gennaro said after the Health
Committee's passage.
Julie Woessner, the spokeswoman for Consumer Advocates for Smoke-Free Alternatives,
warned that the bill could provoke smokers to switch back to combustible cigarettes.
"Banning the use of e-cigarettes in public places does not further public health, and, in fact,
would actually work against the interests of public health by discouraging smokers from using
smoke-free e-cigarettes, which pose an estimated 1% of the risk of smoking," Woessner said,
citing a study from Drexel University [PDF].
The bill is one of 25 that the City Council is scheduled to vote on today, and would tack on ecigarettes to the Smoke-Free Air Act of 2002. The bill will go into effect four months after the
mayor signs it into law, with signage requirements kicking in after six months. Notably,
Commissioner Farley admitted during the hearing that enforcement would be mostly up to the
establishment's owners.
Contact the author of this article or email tips@gothamist.com with further questions, comments
or tips.
Christopher Robbins in News on Dec 19, 2013 2:55 pm

gothamist.com/2013/12/19/ecigs_likely_to_be_banned_in_publi.php