Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Two echniques
of Supportive Psychotherapy
SUMMARY
RESUME
_ _e_~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - - -
function. It also avoids the real possibility that the physician may give
wrong advice and consequently be
blamed or even sued.
It is unnecessary to elaborate on
the wholesale dispensing of friendliness. This cannot be done, and where
it is attempted I believe that it is generally motivated by feelings relating
to the "dispenser's", not the patient's, emotional needs. It follows
that the therapist who is full of love
for his or her patient must be fooling
the patient or him/herself or both, often, again, for his/her own reasons.
On the other hand, a certain basic
friendliness in the therapist is a necessary condition to any psychotherapy
- necessary but not sufficient. Some
standard theory and application of
technique, whether supportive, behavioural, analytic or other, is also required.
It is unnecessary to belabour the
notion that the essence of patient
support is encouragement and reassurance. It is difficult to reassure
one's patients when unable to predict
the future oneself. Moreover, reassurance can have the same infantilizing effect on the patient that inappropriate advice can have.
Perhaps giving advice, reassurance
and encouragement, and being
friendly have been considered important aspects of supportive psychotherapy because these behaviours are important in other relationships. In
particular, they constitute the nurturing that parents quite legitimately
provide to their children. It does not
follow, however, that these same behaviours, when performed by physicians, will help their patients, even if
this nurturing was exactly what the
patients were deprived of in their
early years. I do not wish to deprecate appropriate encouragement and
reassurance that are based on the
physician's knowledge of the patient
and of his/her situation, but I believe
that such reassurance should be given
as part of a supportive psychotherapy: that is, in order to increase the
patient's awareness of reality, when
there are positive factors that the patient is ignoring, in the event, for example, that a patient could take action to help himself and is not doing
so. I disapprove of giving encouragement without taking into consideration the individual patient's personality and circumstances, factors which
1140
The Literature
Werman,3 Kernberg,1 and Winston
and colleagues4 have recently made
cogent reviews of the literature on
supportive psychotherapy. They comment on the paucity of that literature,
despite its wide use among psychotherapists. Winston and colleagues indicate the confusion between "supportive psychotherapy" and the
supportive aspects of any therapy.
They discuss the mechanical misapplication of psychoanalytic techniques in some therapists' handling of
supportive psychotherapy.
Kemberg believes that in supportive psychotherapy, primitive ego defenses, such as denial and projection,
ought not be left undisturbed, as has
been suggested by many earlier authors. He proposes that primitive defensive operations themselves weaken the patient's ability to deal
constructively with the problems he
faces, and that these defences should
be tactfully confronted.
Arnold and Chapman,' in a comprehensive review, describe different
forms of psychotherapy and what
those psychotherapies have in common, and discuss the appropriate
provider of psychotherapy and seek
to define its effectiveness. Goldberg
and Green6 attempt to outline "medical psychotherapy" as a specific approach using reassurance, suggestion,
and manipulation. They discuss the
value of catharsis, of initiating
changes in the patient's environment,
and of clarifying the patient's problems. Abrahams7 describes the work
of a Balint-trained family physician
who conducted an independent psychotherapy practice.
MacDonald and Brown9 describe a
brief psychotherapy, enlarging on
characteristics of the therapist and
patient, and the use of a specific developmental model and a process of
therapy. Pelton9 emphasizes the need
for the physician to change if he is to
become a psychotherapist. Hazzard10
describes a series of general practice
patients who received brief psychotherapy and indicates the importance
of helping the patient to discover the
connections between his present
relationship
symptoms,
recent
events, and past relationship events.
Zigmondt1 surveys the principles of
psychopathology and outlines aspects
of the self known and unknown to
self and others. He suggests that the
therapist must first support the patient's present modus vivendi and
cautions that interpretations may appear "correct" to the therapist without helping the patient. Zigmond defines confrontation and outlines the
importance of transference. He also
outlines criteria for accepting patients
into psychotherapy.
Andrews and Brodaty12 document
the high proportion of patients who
present with psychological symptoms
and discuss the cost-effectiveness of
psychotherapy. They advocate a better organized approach to education
in psychotherapy for family physicians. Eleff and Prosen13 differentiate
indications for short-term and longterm therapy, and. compare three
forms of short-term therapy. Lieberman and Stuart14 describe an approach to psychosocial assessment
that focuses on the patient's feelings,
and suggest the establishment of a
contract with the patient. Walker15
describes specific therapeutic techniques for different conditions, rather
than outlining a general approach to
patients.
Two Techniques of
Supportive Psychotherapy
What Supportive
Psychotherapy Is
It is important to distinguish between telling the patient what is
wrong and what to do, and helping
him to understand how certain automatic ways of functioning are detrimental to his interests: that is, there
is a difference between giving advice,
and employing the techniques of clarification and confrontation. These
techniques encourage the patient to
raise questions and find solutions for
problems he may never have considered. Giving advice does nothing to
encourage the patient to improve his
ability to deal with the external
world.
I would like to emphasize how a
supportive therapeutic approach, in
supporting the patient's optimal ego
functioning, fosters the patient's per-
A Non-Thinking Patient
Mrs. Q. complained of depression;
she had recently left her alcoholic,
physically abusive, unfaithful husband for the third time. She related
that she had known during her en1141
A Provocative Patient
Miss Z., an 18-year-old student living with her parents, believed that
she was pregnant, and her belief was
confirmed by her family physician.
Her boyfriend initially planned to
marry her after the baby's birth but,
instead, dropped her. Miss Z. had
hoped to keep the fact of the preg1142
nancy from her parents, despite expecting to live with them during the
full term of pregnancy. Eventually
she agreed to having the baby adopted away, which was done shortly
after the birth.
Miss Z. was subsequently seen by a
social worker at a community agency,
to whom she complained of insomnia
and difficulty with her studies. She
was then assessed by a psychiatrist,
certified for involuntary admission,
and taken to a provincial psychiatric
hospital. Shortly after discharge, Miss
Z. consulted her family physician,
asking whether her sleeping pill could
cause apathy, depression and decreased appetite. She indicated that
she just wanted the doctor to answer
her questions, that she was afraid to
talk about anything personal, for fear
she would be recertified to the provincial hospital. During this interview
she also informed the doctor that she
knew the lethal dosage of several
medications, including over-thecounter preparations. This revelation
was immediately followed by a request for "something for her nerves".
By this time the family physician was
quite suspicious of Miss Z.'s real
goals in the interview, and refused to
prescribe any medication. She was
left feeling very anxious when Miss
Z. abruptly terminated the interview,
complaining that doctors "didn't
care", and that her doctor was impersonal and gave only textbook answers. The physician was aware of
growing frustration and even resentment in herself towards this patient
who complained of a lack of involvement in the doctor, although she herself was unwilling to give a proper
history.
The physician knew from previous
interviews that Miss Z. was reluctant
to discuss her pregnancy with her parents because she "knew they
wouldn't understand". Miss Z., in
previous interviews, had indicated
how uncaring, critical, and hostile she
considered her parents. She also stated that she began feeling more depressed on the anniversary of having
been coerced into sexual intimacy
some years before, by another boyfriend who had also subsequently
dropped her.
Miss Z. refused regular follow-up
appointments that her physician, by
now anxious, several times offered.
Nevertheless, Miss Z. requested fre-
Acknowledgement
The author wishes to thank Ms.
Lynne Dunikowski for her help in
collecting relevant literature.
References
1. Kernberg 0. Severe personality
disorders. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1984: 153, 147-64.
2. Steinberg PI. Psychiatry of family
practice: personality disorders. Part II.
Interviewing the patient. Can Fam
Physician 1983; 29:1953-7.
3. Werman DS. Practice of supportive
psychotherapy. New York: Brunner/
Mazel, 1984.
4. Winston A, Pinsker H, McCullough L.
Review of supportive psychotherapy.
Hospital Community Psychiatry, 1986;
37(11):1105-14.
5. Arnold JF, Chapman RJ. Primary care
physician and psychotherapy. In: Rakel
RE, ed. Textbook of family practice. 3rd
ed. Toronto: Saunders, 1984: 1330-47.
6 Goldberg RL, Green S. Medical psychotherapy. Am Fam Physician 1985
(Jan); 31:173-8.
7. Abrahams S. Psychotherapy in general
practice: an early experiment. The
Practitioner 1985 (Dec); 229:1117-20.
8. MacDonald PJ, Brown A. Brief psychotherapy in family practice. Can Fam
Physician 1986; 32:1333-8.
9. Pelton CL. Family physician as psychotherapist. Postgrad Med 1985;
78(2):227-30.
SeldaneI
Merrell Dow