Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abu Bekr ibn Muhammad ibn al-Husayn Al-Karaji was born on 13 April 953 in
Baghdad, Iraq and died in about 1029. His importance the field of mathematics is
debated by historians and mathematicians. Some consider that he only reworked
previous ideas, while others see him as the first person to use arithmetic style
operations with algebra as opposed to geometrical operations.
1 1 1
In his work, Al-Fakhri, Al-Karaji succeeded in defining x, x2, x3, p and , 2 , 3 , p
x x x
and gave rules for finding the products of any pair without reference to geometry. He
was close to giving the rule xnxm xmn for all integers n and m
10
10
5
1
509
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
LHS a r
RHS
r1
1
1122
2
1
Mathematical induction is based on the idea of proving the next step to be true if the
previous one is true. If the result is true for an initial value, then it is true for all values.
This is demonstrated by the following metaphor.
Consider a ladder that is infinite in one direction. We want to prove that the ladder is
completely safe, that is each rung on the ladder is sound.
4 For n k 1,
k1
r1
r1
Adding on the
1k 12th term.
a r a r 1k 12
k 1k 12
1k 12
2
k 1k 12
21k 1 2
2
2
k 1k 12 21k 12
2
1k 12 1k 22
2
which is the required form.
k+1
k
3
2
1
First, test the bottom rung on the ladder and check that it is sound. Then assume that a
rung on the ladder, somewhere further up, is also sound. Call this the kth rung. Using
this assumption, show that the next rung up, the 1k 12th rung, is also sound if the
assumption is true. Since we know the first rung is sound, we can now say the second
one is sound. As the second one is sound, the third one is sound and so on. So the
whole ladder is safe.
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result is
true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
This communication is
identical for virtually all
induction proofs. It is
worth learning its form.
Example
n
Prove that
2
a 3r 5r n 1n 12 1n 22 n H
by mathematical
r1
induction.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
We cannot use the standard results for a r and a r2 here as we are being
r1
r1
LHS a 3r2 5r
Example
r1
n 1n 12
Prove a r
n H by mathematical induction.
2
r1
n
510
RHS 111 12 11 22
3112 2 5112
1122 112
35
2
2
Since LHS RHS, the result is true for n 1.
511
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
4 For n k 1,
k1
1
a r 1r 12
r1
i.e. a 3r 5r k 1k 12 1k 22
2
Adding on the
1k 12th term.
r1
1
1
a
r
1r
12
1k
1
2
1k 22
r1
k1
2
a 3r 5r 1k 12 1k 1 12 1k 1 22 1k 12 1k 22 1k 12
r1
4 For n k 1,
k1
2
a 3r 5r
r1
Adding on the
1k 12th term.
r1
k 1k 12 1k 22 31k 12 2 51k 12
1k 12 3k 1k 22 31k 12 54
1k 12 3k2 k 24
k
1
k1
1k 12 1k 22
k 1k 22
1
1k 1 2 1k 22
1k 12 1k 2 2
k2 2k 1
1k 1 2 1k 22
1k 12 2
1k 1 2 1k 22
k1
k2
which is the required form.
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result
is true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
1k 12 1k 22 1k 12
which is the required form.
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result is
true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
Example
n
3
Prove that a 3r 13n 12n H by mathematical induction.
2
r1
1 For n 1,
1
Example
3 1
13 12
2
3
122
2
3
LHS a 3r
RHS
r1
1
n
n H by mathematical induction.
Prove that a
n1
r1 r 1r 12
31
1 For n 1,
1
1
LHS a
r1 r 1r 12
RHS
1
1122
1
11
1
2
1
2
Since LHS RHS, the result is true for n 1.
1
k
i.e. a
r
1r
12
k
1
r1
3
a3
r1
a3 3
r
k1
512
k1
r1
3 k
13 12 3k1
2
Adding on the
1k 12th term.
Using the
assumption.
513
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
3# k 3
3 3.3k
2
2
4 For n k 1,
k1
a r 1r 32
3
3
3k 3
2
2
r1
Adding on the
1k 12th term.
a r 1r 3 2 1k 12 1k 42
9
3
3k
2
2
r1
1
19.3k 32
2
3
13.3k 12
2
3
13k1 12
2
1
k 1k 12 1k 52 1k 12 1k 42
3
1
1k 12 3k 1k 52 31k 42 4
3
1
1k 12 3k2 8k 124
3
Using the
assumption.
1
1k 12 1k 22 1k 6 2
3
which is the required form.
It can be seen from these examples that sigma notation is very useful when proving a
result by induction.
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result
is true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
Exercise 1
Prove these results n H by mathematical induction.
Example
1
1
Prove that 1.4 2.5 3.6 p n 1n 32 n 1n 12 1n 52 n H .
3
r1
It is simpler to express the LHS using sigma notation. Hence the result becomes
n
1
a r 1r 32 3 n 1n 12 1n 52.
r1
1 For n 1,
2
ar
a 8 3r
r1
RHS
r1
4
1
112 11 12 11 52
3
2
2
a 6 2r r 6n 141 3n n 2
1
122 162
3
4
n
1 2
3
2
a r 4 n 1n 12
r1
10
r1
11
k
1
i.e. a r 1r 32 k 1k 12 1k 52
3
r1
n
4 n
r
a 4 3 14 12
r1
14
n 1n 32
1
a r 1r 1 2 1r 22 41n 12 1n 22
r1
1
1k 12 1k 22 1k 62
3
1
a r 1r 1 2 3 1n 12 1n 22
r1
13
1
a r 1r 32 3 1k 12 1k 1 12 1k 1 52
r1
k1
n
1
a r 1r 1 2 1r 22 4 n 1n 12 1n 22 1n 32
r1
2
2
a 12r2 3 n 1n 12 12n 12
r1
3
2
2
a 12r 12 n 12n 12
12
4
2
2
a 4r 3 3 n 14n 6n 92
r1
n
1
a 5r 2 2 n 15n 12
r1
r1
LHS a 112 11 32
1
n 11 3n2
2
2
a 2r 1 n
r1
n
11
a 3r 4 2 n 13n 12
r1
n
1
n 1n 12 12n 12
6
15
r
1 n
2
1n 22
a r
2
r1 2
16 4 5 6 p 1n 32
1
n 1n 72
2
17 5 3 1 p 17 2n2 n 16 n2
514
515
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
18 3 6 11 p 1n2 22
1
n 12n2 3n 132
6
1
n 1n 12 1n 22
3
n
n
Prove the binomial theorem, i.e. 1x y2 n a xnry r.
r0 r
1
20 4 0 6 p 1n 22 1n 32 n 1n2 3n 162
3
1 For n 1,
1
1
RHS a x1ry r
r0 r
LHS 1x y2 1
1
1
x1y 0 x0y1
1
0
xy
xy
In earlier chapters, it was stated that proofs would be provided using mathematical
induction for the binomial theorem and de Moivres theorem. In this syllabus,
knowledge of the proof of de Moivres theorem is expected but not for the binomial
theorem.
This was proved in Chapter 17 using calculus, but this method must also be known.
k1
k 1 k1r r
3 Consider n k 1. We want to show that 1x y2 k1 a
x
y
r
r0
4 For n k 1,
k
k
1x y2 a xkry r
r0 r
Substituting 1k 12 for k in
the result.
k
k
xkryr p x0y kR
r
k
k
k
k
k
k
x k1y 0 xky1 x k1y 2 p
xkry r1 xk1ry r
0
1
2
r1
r
k
p x1y
k
k
k
k
k
kr1 r1
y
1x y2 B xky 0 x k1y1 x k2y 2 p r 1x
0
1
2
n k by 1cos u i sin u2
4 For n k 1,
1x y2 1x y2 k
2 Assume the result to be true for n k, i.e. 1cos u i sin u2 k cos ku i sin ku
1x y2 k1
1 For n 1,
k
k
k
k
k
xky1 xk1y2 xk2y3 p
xkr1y r xkry r1
0
1
2
r1
r
k
p x0yk1
k
k
k
k
k
k
xk1 B Rxky1 B Rxk1y2 p
0
1
0
2
1
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result is true for
n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
516
k
k
k
k
k
B
R1xk1ry r 2 p B
Rxy k y k1
r
r1
k
k1
k
517
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
n
n
n1
We can now use the result that
(which was proved in
r
r1
r
There are other algebraic results that we can prove using mathematical induction, as
exemplified below.
Chapter 6).
k
k
So the general term becomes B
R1xk1ry r 2
r
r1
Example
k 1 k1r r
x
y
r
x
x y
x y p
1x
y 2 p
0
1
2
r
k 1 k1r r
x
y
r
r0
which is the required form.
7
k1
a
RHS 213 2 1
LHS 23
8
k1
k 1 k1
xy k
y
k
k1
For n 3,
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result is true for
n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
We also use mathematical induction to prove divisibility. This is demonstrated in the
example below.
1 2k1 7 2k 3
4 For n k 1,
2k1 2.2k
7 212k 12
2k 2k 2
Example
Induction can also be used to prove results from other spheres of mathematics such as
calculus and matrices.
Example
4 For n k 1,
21k12
7 3
2k2
Prove that
7
3232k 7
913 7 72 7
This allows us to
use the assumption.
918p 72 7
9.8p 63 7
9.8p 56
819p 72
Since 19p 72 H , we can say that t 9 p 7 which is the required
form.
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result is
true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
518
1 For n 1,
9.32k 7
2k
d n
1x 2 nxn1, n H .
dx
LHS
d 1
1x 2
dx
1
RHS 112x11
x0
1
We know the LHS is equal to 1 as the gradient of y x is 1. However, we
should prove this by differentiation by first principles as part of a proof.
Let f1x2 x
f1x h2 f1x2 x h x
h
h
h
h
1
519
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
f1x h2 f1x2
1
hS0
h
1
0
Hence lim
10
00
1
0
d k
1x 2 kxk1
dx
1 1
1
0
d k1
1x 2 1k 12xk.
dx
k
k 1
01
1k 12
5 So the result is true for n k 1 when true for n k. Since the result
is true for n 1, it is true n H by mathematical induction.
1.xk x.kxk1
xk kxk
xk 11 k2
Exercise 2
Example
1
Prove that
0
n
n H using mathematical induction.
1
1 For n 1,
1
LHS
0
1
1
0
1
1
RHS
0
1
i.e.
0
1
0
1
3 Consider n k 1. We want to show that
1 k1
1
1
0
1k 12
.
1
4 For n k 1,
1
0
1
0
520
12 Prove that
1 k
0
n H .
1
dn px
1e 2 pnepx, n H .
dxn
13 Prove that
1n 12p
dn
1sin 2x2 2n1 sin2x
, for all positive integer
dxn
2
values of n.
1
14 For M 0
0
1 k1
1
1 1
1
0
0
2n
, prove that An n
1
2 1
2
1
11 For A
2
p
0
211 pn 2
1p
pn
0
1
0
0, prove that Mn
0
3
0
0
0
3n
, n H .
4
15 For T
0
4n
t
, prove that T n
1
0
r1
a4
r1
, n H .
521
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
k 1k 22 1
1k 12 1k 22
k2 2k 1
1k 12 1k 22
1k 12 2
1k 12 1k 22
k1
k2
which is the required form.
Example
Form a conjecture for the sum
1
1
1
1
p
.
12
23
34
n 1n 12
In order to form the conjecture, consider the results for the first few values of n.
n
sum
1
2
1
1
2
2
6
3
2
1
3
3
12
4
3
1
4
4
20
5
4
1
5
5
30
6
Example
Form a conjecture for the pentagonal numbers as shown below. Prove your
conjecture by mathematical nduction.
12
22
1 For n 1,
1
1
1
LHS a
RHS
11
r1 r 1r 12
1
1
12
2
1
2
Since LHS RHS, the conjecture is true for n 1.
Remembering that these are formed by adding a new layer each time, we
can consider this as a sum,
1 4 7 10 p 13n 22
We are trying to find a formula for this. This is an arithmetic progression and
so we can apply the formula for the sum to n terms with a 1, d 3.
Hence Sn
n
13n 12
2
3n2 n
2
n
12 31n 12 2
2
k1
4 For n k 1,
a 3r 2
r1
k1
1
a r 1r 12
r1
LHS a 3r 2
522
1 For n 1,
1
1
a
r
1r
12
1k
12
1k 22
r1
k
1
k1
1k 12 1k 22
k 1k 22
1
1k 12 1k 22
1k 12 1k 22
3n2 n
2
r1
32
1
3112 2 1
2
31
2
1
RHS
523
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
3k k
2
i.e. a 3r 2
1 For n 1,
r1
a 3r 2
r1
31k 12 2 1k 12
2
3k2 6k 3 k 1
2
3k2 5k 2
2
0 1
3
0
LHS
3
0
RHS
3
0
3
0
0 k
3k
2
0
2k
3
0
a 3r 2
r1
3k1
0 k1
0
2
k1.
4 For n k 1,
a 3r 2 31k 12 2
r1
3
0
3k2 k
3k 1
2
3
0 k1
0
2
0 3
2 0
0 k
3
0
0 3k
2 0
2k
6k 2
3k k
2
2
2
3.3k 0
00
00
0 2.2k
3k 5k 2
2
2
k1
21
4 For n k 1,
31
0
3k1
0
k1
Example
3
For the matrix A
0
0
, form a conjecture for An, n H . Prove your
2
9
A2
0
27
A3
0
81
A
0
16
1
1 For the matrix D
0
1
, form a conjecture for Dn. Prove your conjecture
2
3n
From this we can make a conjecture that An
0
524
Exercise 3
0
.
2n
5 Make a conjecture about the sum of the first n odd numbers. Prove your
conjecture using mathematical induction.
525
18 Mathematical Induction
18 Mathematical Induction
6 Find an expression for the nth term of the sequence 5, 10, 17, 26, 37, p .
Prove this result to be true using mathematical induction.
7 For the sequence below where each new pattern is made by adding a new
layer, make a conjecture for the number of dots in the nth term of the
pattern. Prove this result to be true using mathematical induction.
M+
CE
ON
X
a 1r 122
r1
r1
positive integers.
C
M+
CE
ON
px
1x 12,
where p H .
b Let f 1n2 1x2 denote the result of differentiating f(x) with respect to x,
13
20
29
M+
ON
CE
Review exercise
M+
CE
M
C
M+
CE
ON
X
M+
CE
ON
X
M+
CE
ON
X
n
1
1 Prove that a r 4
n 1n 12 12n 12 13n2 3n 12, n H .
30
r1
M
C
M+
CE
0
112 n
n
0, prove that T 0
s
0
3
2
0
ON
2n 11 2 n
2n
0
0
0 , n H
sn
a2 1
1
1
an1
to prove that Qn
an
1
14 For T 0
0
ON
1
use the principle of mathematical induction
0
an
M
C
M+
CE
ON
X
2
5 Prove, using mathematical induction, that for T
p
Tn
2n
p 12 12
n
M+
ON
CE
M+
CE
M
C
ON
X
M+
%
ON
X
M+
ON
CE
M+
ON
CE
M+
%
ON
X
1
.
0
sin2 nu
, n H .
sin u
dn
np
, for all
n 1cos x2 cos x
dx
2
M
CE
0
, n H .
1
CE
0
,
1
2 1 n
2n
10 a Prove using mathematical induction that
0 1
0
positive integer values of n.
b Determine whether or not this result is true for n 1.
2n 1
for all
1
M+
CE
ON
X
526
527