Yoga Darmawan & Nadya

Product : X-Box 360

Skala : 1 5 (Paling Buruk Paling Baik)

Manufacture
Direct Shipping
Response Time
Product Variety
Product
Availability
Customer
Experience
Time to Market
Order Visibility
Returnability
Inventory
Transportation
Facility
Information

Storage

in

Transit Merge

Storage

4
3

5
5
5
1
5
5
4

4
4
4
2
5
4
3

Direct Shipping

Storage

3
3
3
3
3
3
2
Distributor

Transit Merge

in

with

Package Carrier Last

5
3

Manufacture

Distributor
with Storage

Delivery
3
3

Manufacture

High-Demand

Distributor

Manufacture

Storage

Mile

Delivery
2
3

with

Storage Manufacture
Customer Storage

Pick Up

with

Pick Up

1
3

1
3

1
1
1
5
3
1
1

1
1
1
5
2
1
2

2
2
2
4
1
2
3
Distributor
with Storage

Package Carrier Last

Delivery

Retail

Delivery

with
Mile

Retail
with

Storage Manufacture
Customer Storage

Pick Up

Pick Up

with

Product
Med-demand
Product
Low-demand
Product
Very

Low-

demand Product
Many Product
Source
High
Product
Value
Quick

Desired

Response
High
Product
Variety

Secara keseluruhan apabila di total penilaiannya, maka X-Box 360 lebih cocok dengan jaringan distributor Manufacture Storage in
Transit Merge. Hal ini dikarenakan X-Box berasal dari luar negri yang di import langsung ke Indonesia, sehingga apabila pelanggan
dari seluruh dunia ingin membeli produk ini, mereka dapat membeli di distributor/retailer.

Response Time
Product Variety
Product Availability
Customer Experience
Time to Market

Paling Baik
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Semua Sama
Distributor Storage with Last
Delivery
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Direct Shipping

Paling Buruk
Manufacture Storage with Pick Up
Semua Sama
Mile Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Storage with Pick Up
Manufacture Storage with Pick Up

Order Visibility
Returnability
Inventory
Transportation
Facility
Information
Med-demand Product
Many Product Source
High Product Value
Quick Desired Response
High Product Variety

Manufacture Direct Shipping

Manufacture Direct Shipping
Retail Storage with Customer Pick Up
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Retail Storage with Customer Pick Up
Manufacture Storage in Transit Merge
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Storage in Transit Merge

Manufacture Storage with Pick Up

Manufacture Storage with Pick Up
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Retail Storage with Customer Pick Up
Retail Storage with Customer Pick Up
Manufacture Direct Shipping
Manufacture Storage with Pick Up
Manufacture Storage with Pick Up

Produk : PS4

Response Time

Product Variety

Manufacture
Direct
Shipping
0

Manufacture
Storage in
Transit

Distributor
Storage With
Package Carrier
Delivery
3

Distributor
Storage With
Last Mile
Delivery
2

Retail Storage
With
Customer Pick
Up
5

Manufacture
Storage With
Pick Up
3
0
Customer
Responsive,
cant directly
There are delay
There are delay Not a high
because
buy to
time when
time when
demand and
customer go
manufacture,
Manufacture information flow information flow consumable
derectly to the warranty
d in China,
to warehouse
to warehouse
product
shop.
policy
0
5
5
3
2
0
Warehouse
number is
Customer
small, can turn Small variety, cant directly
Can store high
Can store high
the
need
buy to
number of
number of
investment
investment to manufacture,
Manufacture product in one
product in one
into larger
store product
warranty
d in China,
place
place
warehouse
in retail
policy

Product
Availability

Manufacture
d in China,
Customer
Experience

5
Always
available,
flexible to
demand

Order Visibility

Returnability

Always
available,
flexible to
demand
2

0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy

Sometimes
out of stock
due to lead
time in
restocking

Always
available,
flexible to
demand
2

Customer
cant directly
Customer can buy to
experience
manufacture,
Manufacture
the product
warranty
d in China,
directly
policy
0
4
0
Customer
Need longer
Need longer
Can directly
cant directly
time to deliver
time to deliver deliver the
buy to
Need time to
the product,
the product to product to
manufacture,
Manufacture deliver the
because of
all the
customer in
warranty
d in China,
product
information flow customer
no time
policy
0
5
5
5
2
0
Customer
cant directly
Customer
buy to
Customer can
Customer can
Customer can
dont know
manufacture,
Manufacture obtain stock
obtain stock
obtain stock
the retail
warranty
d in China,
information
information
information
stock
policy
0
2
2
2
4
0
Manufacture Need time to
Need time to
Need time to
Fast response
Customer
d in China,
return the
return the
return the
cant directly
product
product
product
buy to
manufacture,
Customer can
only obtain the
product
information
indirectly

Time to Market

Customer can
only obtain the
product
information
indirectly
3
2,5

Customer can
only obtain the
product
information
indirectly
2

warranty
policy
Inventory

5
Always
available,
flexible to
demand

5
Always
available,
flexible to
demand

Transportation

Manufacture
d in China,
0

Facility

Manufacture Need dedicated

Need dedicated
d in China,
transport
transport
0
5
5

Information

Efficient to only
Efficient to only
Manufacture build several
build several
d in China,
facility
facility
0
5
5

High-Demand

Nowadays we
can use internet
to deliver
Manufacture information to
d in China,
customer
0
4

Nowadays we
can use internet
to deliver
information to
customer
4

0
Customer
Need
cant directly
Always
investment to buy to
available,
stock large
manufacture,
flexible to
quantity of
warranty
demand
product
policy
5
4
0
Customer
cant directly
Low cost,
buy to
Can deliver
customer
manufacture,
large quantity
come to the
warranty
to customer
retail
policy
5
2
0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
Efficient to
Need a lot of
manufacture,
only build
cost to build
warranty
several facility many retail
policy
5
3
0
Flow of
Nowadays we
information
Customer
can use
from
cant directly
internet to
manufacture
buy to
deliver
to retailer and manufacture,
information to to customer is warranty
customer
long
policy
5
4
0

Product

Manufacture
d in China,
Med-Demand
Product

Manufacture
d in China,
Low-Demand
Product

Many Product

Transportation
cost will slightly
higher if
demand is high

Flexible to
demand

Manufacture
d in China,
Very LowDemand Product

Transportation
cost will slightly
higher if
demand is high

Low inventory
cost, and has
better interval
to restock

Flexible to
demand

Availability can
adjust to
demand

Availability can
adjust to
demand, but the
inventory will
Manufacture take long time
d in China,
to restock
0
2

Efficient in
transportation
cost, but there
is a chance
shortage

Flexible to
demand

Availability can
adjust to
demand

Efficient in
delivering high
demand
product to
customer

Ther is a
chance of out
of stock
because retail
dont want to
store
unmoving
product

Availability
can adjust to
demand
3

0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy
0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy

Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy
4
0

Availability
can adjust to
demand, but
the inventory
will take long
time to
restock

Availability can
adjust to
demand, but
the inventory
will take long
time to restock

Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy

Rarity in
product
availability

Source

Manufacture
d in China,
High Product
Value

Manufacture
d in China,
Quick Desired
Response

Can minimize
inventory cost
by just store it in
one facility and
only response to
customer's
order

5
Can minimize
inventory cost
by just store it
in one facility
and only
response to
customer's
order

Low response
time to
customer

Manufacture
d in China,

Response time
is slow, hard to
compete with
direct source
5

Manufacture
d in China,
High Product
Variety

Response time
is slow, hard to
compete with
direct source

Low response
time to
customer

Low cost in
stocking high
variety of
product in one
facility

5
Low cost in
stocking high
variety of
product in one
facility

Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy
0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy

Has risk of
overstock,
and increase
in inventory
cost

Can deliver
large quantity
to customer
5

With high
response
time, can
compete with
direct source

Not high
quantity
product
3

5
Low cost in
stocking high
variety of
product in one
facility

Response time
is slow, hard
to compete
with direct
source

0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
Response time manufacture,
to customer is warranty
low
policy
3
Need
investment to
stock high
variety

0
Customer
cant directly
buy to
manufacture,
warranty
policy