Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1.1 Introduction
The term cataract is derived from the Greek word cataractos, which means water fall.
Cataract is opacity or clouding of the crystalline lens which prevent light rays from
reaching the retina. Cataract is the main cause of low vision and blindness in the world
Majority of cataract (85%) is regarded as senile or age related with uncertain etiology.
However, it is a preventable cause for blindness rectified by the use of appropriate surgical
services. The absence of effective utilization of such services leaves many of those affected
by it with severely impaired vision. Significantly, a majority of those living with blindness
due to cataract and poor access to services are in the developing World.1,2,3
1.2Back ground
1.2.1 World
According to WHO estimates of global data on blindness, there are an estimated 38
million blind people worldwide, and a further 110 million with low vision who are
at risk of becoming blind. Cataract is the leading cause of blindness; accounting for
about half of all blindness in the world4 and average prevalence of blindness is
about 0.7% in the world.4 Age-related cataract accounts for nearly half of these
blind individuals, and is particularly common in developing countries5. WHO
reports that there is a backlog of cataract of approximately 15.8 million people
with an annual increase of over 2 million newly cataract-blind patients6.The World
Health Organization (WHO) estimates that nearly 18 million people are bilaterally
blind from cataract in the world, representing almost half of all global cases of
blindness. Cataract remains the leading cause of blindness and an important cause
of visual impairment across the globe.5, 6
1.2.2 Pakistan
Pakistan, a developing country situated in the World Health Organizations (WHO)
Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR-D), is bordered by India, China, Iran, and
Afghanistan is the sixth most populous country in the world. According to the
Pakistan National Blindness and Visual Impairment survey the prevalence of
blindness among individuals of all ages in Pakistan is 0.9%.Cataract accounts for
the most common cause (51.5%) of avoidable blindness in Pakistan.7
1.3 RISK FACTORS
The main non-modifiable risk factor for cataract is aging. Other frequently
associated risk factors are trauma, uveitis, diabetes, ultraviolet light exposure, and
smoking. Children are occasionally born with cataracts, mainly due to genetic
disorders. Women are at greater risk than men for developing cataracts and are less
likely to have access to services5.
1.4 Types of Cataract
Types of cataracts include:
A sub capsular cataract occurs at the back of the lens. People with diabetes
or those taking high doses of steroid medications have a greater risk of
developing a subcapsular cataract.
A nuclear cataract forms deep in the central zone (nucleus) of the lens.
Nuclear cataracts usually are associated with aging.
A cortical cataract is characterized by white, wedge-like opacities that start
in the periphery of the lens and work their way to the center in a spoke-like
3
fashion. This type of cataract occurs in the lens cortex, which is the part of
the lens that surrounds the central nucleus.8
incision in the cornea. After surgery, an artificial intraocular lens is placed where
the natural lens was.8
Visual functioning and quality of life have been recognized as important measures
of treatment effectiveness in addition to the more traditional outcome parameter
visual acuity. The difference between the more traditional definition of success of
cataract surgery from the doctors perspective and the patients defined success is
demonstrated by the following quotations. Citing an ophthalmologist: My patient
has 20/20 Snellen vision and reads Jaeger 1. A patient may translate this medical
outcome into Subtitles on the television are not blurred anymore, and I have taken
up my needlework. This patient translation shows satisfaction levels are clearly
related to clinical outcome10.Quality of vision is the patients ability to see well in
6
the context of his or her own individual visual requirements, that is, patients
satisfaction with the surgery
According to World Health Organization (W.H.O) the standard category for Visual outcome is
good vision is 6/6 to 6/18, borderline vision is less than 6/18 to 6/60 and poor vision is less than
6/60.12
Rationale
Cataract is one of the most frequently occurring causes of visual impairments among the ocular
disorders
in
the
world
and
is
the
most
important
cause
of
reversible
visual
impairment.13,14Cataract in elderly patients can cause progressive painless vision loss 13, Because
of the demographic shift in developed countries toward older age, the prevalence over the whole
population has increased. In Pakistan approximately 570,000 adults are estimated to be blind as a
result of cataract 14. The major indication for cataract surgery is to improve as many aspects of
the visual function as possible, such as contrast sensitivity, disability glare and even visual fields.
The goal is not only to improve functional vision, but also to improve performance in daily
living activities. Despite this, controversy remains regarding the effectiveness of surgery in
improving visual acuity (VA) in the elderly15,16. In cataract patient's 40 years old, there is a
relationship between postoperative VA and the ability to enjoy activities of daily life.
17,18
Previous reports
have focused primarily on the patients VA, while the effect of surgery on the patients quality of
life with respect to vision-dependent activities (visual function) or satisfaction with the final
outcome of surgery has received less evaluative attention. The decision to perform cataract
surgery should not be based solely on VA results.20
A growing body of research indicates that visual acuity (VA) alone is an inadequate measure of
visual impairment. The impact on visual function (VF) is closely related to patient-perceived
outcomes and has become a significant factor in the evaluation of the outcome of surgical
interventions. Although patients may benefit from an increase in VA and VF after cataract
surgery, their satisfaction may be limited. Assessment of patient satisfaction gives additional
9
information on the result of surgery and is therefore of further importance in evaluating surgical
outcome.13
There have been a number of previous studies to find out only VA after cataract surgery with
intraocular lens implants,19 but no study is done on a combination of all these criteria in
Peshawar region, that is, VA and satisfaction regarding the effect of VA on the patients ability to
participate in their daily living activities after cataract surgery. So the present study planned with
the objectives of assessing the visual outcomes of patients after cataract surgery with intraocular
lens implants and to assess the patient satisfaction with surgical outcome. This work is also
required for the partial fulfillment of BVS (Hons) course at Pakistan Institute of Community
Ophthalmology (PICO) HMC Peshawar.
10
11
AIM:
Assessment of patient satisfaction level after cataract surgery in population
having age 40 years.
OBJECTIVES:
To evaluate the patient satisfaction level amongst patients operated for
cataract in HMC.
12
13
Patient satisfaction with surgery is an important outcome measure to include in the assessment of
surgical outcomes.
The retrospective study carried out using operation theater records at the Rural Health Training
Centre (RHTC), Paithan, during 2007. Out of 819 cataract surgery patients operated in 2007 a
total of 50 were selected randomly.post-operative VA was 6/18 or better in n=9(19.6%), while 21
(45.7%)patients had
46
patients.According to score 24 (52.1%) good, 14 (30.4%) normal and 8 (17.3%) were poor
satisfied with their visual outcome.21
According to a study conducted in the Level II hospital UN mission, Feb 2006 to Nov 2006 , A
total of 141 eyes of 136 patients who completed the minimum 6 weeks. A vision of 6/18 or
better was obtained in 102 eyes (72.3%), 6/24-6/60 in 23(16.3%) and >6/60 in 16 (10.3%) at
their last follow up visit.122 (86.5%) good, 14 (9.9%) normal and 5 (3.5%) were poor satisfied
with their visual outcome.
A study conducted at Department of Ophthalmology, Medical University of Vienna, Vienna,
Austria Improvements in visual outcomes were significantly higher Three months
postoperatively, 94.2% of the patients reported improved VA and 92.5% reported improvements
in visual function.
Heritage Medical Research published a study through BJ Ophthalmology found that out of 166
patients
62.4%
were
Very
satisfied,19.5%,Somewhat
satisfied
n=74(49%), while 60 (39%)patients had vision (<6/18-6/60) and 17 (12%) had vision < 6/60in
151 patients.The questionnaire also indicated good patients satisfaction with the results
achieved.22
According to study conducted in in tribal region of Surat district of Gujaratstate, India,There
were 62.3% cataract operated people having good visual outcome (PVA 6/6-6/18), 24.5% had
(PVA <6/18-6/60) and 13% had <6/60 and The satisfaction level was high among operated in
the sample (79%),15.5 % were in normal level and Only 5.5% were dissatisfied with respect to
surgery.23
At Kikuyu Eye Unit, to assess the visual outcome of patient undergoing cataract surgery and the
result were: BCVA of 6/18 or better was obtained in 94.3% of eyes and an uncorrected vision of
6/18 or better in 78.2% of eyes. Six eyes (1.5%) had BCVA of < 6/60 and almost patients were
satisfied.
Significance of the study
Calculates the visual outcome and assesses the quality of cataract surgery.
Encouraging eye surgeons to monitor their own results, over time, in itself will lead to
better outcomes of cataract surgery.
Provide base line data for the eye unit to design appropriate strategies in order to provide
the highest level of satisfaction and improve results of cataract surgery as improved
outcome will motivate more patients to come forward for surgery.
15
16
I.
METHODOLOGY
17
future fieldwork and data analysis and interpretation was made through
supervisor guidance.
2. Training on IBM SPSS Statistics 20 and Ms Excel:
One week module was attended and creating Questionnaire, Data Entry and
Data Analysis was learnt. Mr. Zia, I.T. Expert, PICO, was the supervisor.
3. Prior Communication:
Through communication with the concerned authority prior approval and
cooperation was sought.
4.
Variables in the Performa were selected according to the aims and objectives of
the study and was tested in eye O.P.D at Hayatabad Medial Complex, Peshawar
in one day pilot survey and then finalized for survey.
5. Pilot Study:
A one day pilot was conducted to get an idea of the number of patients of the
required age group in O.P.D, for making arrangements.
6. Sample size:
18
All patients aged 40 years who are operated for cataract and visiting eye OPD
for follow up during 2
2014.
7. Study design:
Descriptive Cross-Sectional
8. Study Location:
9.
I myself performed and recorded Visual Acuity, and filled the Performas at
lower O.P.D, while performas were also given and fellow students, working at
other stations.
10. Budgeting
As this was a hospital-based research, so there was no amount needed for
transport. Estimated amount needed for stationary, printing of data and report
assembling of final report extra was approximately RS 10,000/II.
SURVEY METHODOLOGY
19
This cross-sectional study was conducted for patient aged 40 years who
operated for cataract and visiting for follow up.
1. Data Collection Methodology:
This hospital-based, descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted at Eye
department;HMC
Peshawar
for
three
months,
from
sep2014
to
2. Inclusion Criteria:
All patients aged 40 years who are operated for cataract and visiting eye
O.P.D H.M.C after 1st follow up.
3. Exclusion Criteria:
Mentally retarded patients.
Cataract survey is done for other purpose than visual.
Patients who have no preoperative ocular examination record.
Patients who are not willing to participate in study.
4. Fieldwork Duration:
Fieldwork was from 13th October to 25th October 2014.
5. Ethical Consideration:
The proposal was submitted to Research Supervisor, Mr. Faheem
Marwat.
Before including in the study, verbal Consent was taken from each and
every subject.
The patients were not delayed for undue tests to save the time of patients
as well as the examiner.
Confidentiality was maintained in record keeping.
Performas were distributed to other stations.
21
1. Data Entry:
Collected data was then entered in the pre created questionnaire in IBM SPSS
Statistics 20 and then was finally analyzed to get the results.
2. Final Report Writing:
Finally the report is written and submitted to the Research Supervisor, Mr.
Azmat Jahan.
22
23
Preoperative VA
Visual Acuity
6/6-6/18
Frequency Percent
Nil
<6/18-6/60
12.5
<6/60
49
87.5
Total
56
100.0
Pre-Operative VA
50
40
30
20
10
0
6/6-6/18
<6/18-6/60
<6/60
24
Post-Operative VA
Visual Acuity
Frequency Percent
6/6-6/18
36
64.3
<6/18-6/60
12
21.4
<6/60 8
14.3
Total
56
100.0
Post-Operative VA
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
6/6-6/18
<6/18-6/60
<6/60
25
Gender Distribution
Gender
Frequency Percent
Female
18
32.1
Male
38
67.9
Total
56
100.0
Gender Distribution
40
35
30
25
32.10%
20
15
10
5
0
Females
Males
26
Preoperative
Nil
7(12.5)
49 (87.5)
56 (100.0)
Postoperative
36 (64.3)
12 (21.4)
8 (14.3)
56 (100)
36
Pre-Operative
Post-Operative
12
8
06/6-6/18
<6/186/60
<6/60
27
Number(%age)
60 80
Good
27 (48.2%)
30 50
Normal
18 (32.1%)
10 20
Poor
11 (19.6%)
30-50 Normal
10-20 Poor
28
The study was conducted for three months from Sep2014 to Sep2014,data
collection period was 2 weeks. Total 56 patients studied in this study which
conducted at Eye OPD Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar. Mean age was
61 years. Gender distribution was analyzed as n=38(67.9%) of 56 patients were
males and n=18(32%) were females.
Visual outcome after cataract surgery
There were 36 (64.4%) cataract operated people having good visual outcome (PVA
6/6-6/18), 12 (36.4%) had (PVA <6/18-6/60) and 8 (14.3%) had PVA <6/60.
Visual acuity
6/6-6/18
<6/186/60
<6/60
Preoperative
Nil
7(12.5%)
49 (87.5%)
Postoperative
36(64.3%)
12 (21.4%)
8(14.3%)
Total
56 (100%)
56 (100%)
Score
Number
(%age)
10 - 20
Good
27
48.20%
30 - 50
Normal
18
32.10%
60 - 80
Poor
11
19.60%
30
The WHO suggests that 85% of eyes undergoing cataract surgery should have
good outcome (6/66/18), 10% have borderline outcome (6/186/60), while less
than 5% havepoor outcome (6/60).24The visual results are similar to other
studies.This study showed that visual outcome in most of the operated eyes was
good (PVA 6/18) in (36) 64.4% cases,12(21.4%) was at Borderline, while in some
8(14.3%) respectively after cataract extraction. However our study was no similar
to WHOs standard but revealed good outcome results than population based
studies in Lower Dir, Pakistan (37.3%), Chakwal, Pakistan (32.2%), Nepal (21%),
China (39%)24
According to Mubashir R, Asim A S et al studies post-operative VA 6/18 or better
in n=74(49%), while 60 (39%)patients had vision (<6/18-6/60) and 17 (12%) had
vision < 6/60in 151 patients. which is comparable to our results that was 64.4%,
21.4% and 14.3%.
Proportionately high number of people who had undergone cataract surgery and
were satisfied 48.2% which can associated with
31
vision < 6/60 in total 46 patients and our results were (PVA 6/18) in (36) 64.4%
cases,12 (21.4%) was at Borderline, while in some 8(14.3%) respectively.
Patient satisfaction with surgery is an important outcome measure to include in the
assessment of surgical outcomes The satisfaction level was high among operated in
the sample 27 (48.2%), normal level studied 18 (32%), while 11 19.6% were poor
satisfied.
According to study conducted in the Level II hospital UN mission , vision of 6/18
or better was obtained in 102 eyes (72.3%), 6/24-6/60 in 23(16.3%) and >6/60 in
16 (10.3%) at their last follow up visit, which were comparable to our study,
The presenting visual acuity was similar and comparable to those in other reviewed
studies. It showed that most of our patients only seek medical attention when they
are blind or almost blind in the two eyes, or at least one eye. This is slightly
different from what obtains in developed countries, where patients seek medical
attention earlier and therefore present with better visual acuity.25
The present study revealed that cataract surgery is an effective treatment in terms
of improvement of visual acuity, postoperative functioning, and patients opinion
about the quality of life. Around 50% of the operated patients showed their score in
the range of 60-80 for visual satisfaction, more than 2/3 patients found to be
satisfied after cataract surgery.
32
33
This study clearly shows the beneficial and favorable outcomes. The patients who
are operated for cataract were fully satisfied from their surgery because they
having better visual acuity after cataract surgery and were able to perform their
daily life activities.
34
35
RECOMMENDATION:
There is need to focus more on quality of the cataract surgery which in turn may help in
sustaining the surgical services at base hospital. Training of surgeons, good instruments
and equipments and regular clinical audits in the hospital must be in place to ensure the
quality.
There is a need to provide effective cataract surgical services in the rural areas at country
level.
There is a need to have outreach programs (screening at village and surgery at base
hospital or satellite Centers with free transportation facility or paying them for the cost of
their return travels.
36
Awareness regarding cataract surgery is not enough in the community. Peoples may
educate and advertise in their villages about eye care and facility available and refer
them. The local print and electronic media, handbills-flyers and health talks by health
workers may help.
37
1. World Health Organisation. Approaches to prevent visual impairment In:vision 2020 the right
to sight .Global initiative for elimination of avoidable blindness action plan 20062011.WHO.Geneva:IAPB;2008
2. Limburg H, World Health Organisation Manual for rapid assessment of cataract surgical
services Prevention of blindness and deafness, Geneva, WHO Switzerland 2001;1-604
3. World Health Organisation. Strategies for the prevention of blindness in national programmea primary health care approach Geneva, 2nd Edition WHO 1997;67-73
4. Salahuddin Ahmad, Khawaja Khalid Shoaib et al. Positive Impact of Good Visual Outcome
on the Acceptance of Cataract Surgery in Sub-Saharan African Population..Pak J Ophthalmol
2010, Vol. 26 No. 3.
38
6. Muhammad Tariq Khan, Sanaullah Jan et al. Visual Outcome and Complications of Manual
Sutureless Small Incision Cataract Surgery.Pak J Ophthalmol 2010, Vol. 26 No.1
7. Mir Zaman, Tariq Farooq Babar Khan Marwat, Sanaullah Dawar.et al .OUTCOME OF
SUTURELESS MANUAL EXTRA CAPSULARCATARACT EXTRACTION. J Ayub Med Coll
Abbottabad 2009;21(1)
8.GretchynBailey.Cataracts.Availableat http://www.allaboutvision.com/conditions/cataracts.htm
Ehab I Wasfi1, P Pai2 and Alaa A Abd-Elsayed. Patient satisfaction with cataract surgery
11. MuhammadWaseem, Sadia Humayun,et al. Comparison of Patients Satisfaction Level after
Different Types of Posterior Chamber Intraocular Lens Implantation. ISRN SurgeryVolume
2012, Article ID 629158
12. Mubashir Rehman, Asim Ali Shah et al. Visual Outcome after Extra-Capsular Cataract
Extraction with Intraocular Lens Implantation of Patients with Age Related Cataract.
Ophthalmology Update Vol. 12. No. 4, October-December 2014)
13.
Datiles III MB, Magno BV. Cataract: Clinical Types. In: Tasman W, Jaeger EA, editors.
39
14.
the very old, American Journal of Ophthalmology,vol. 137, no. 1, pp. 145155, 2004.
15.
and barriers to uptake of cataract surgical services in Pakistan: the Pakistan National Blindness
and Visual Impairment Survey, British Journal of Ophthalmology,vol. 91, no. 10, pp. 1269
1273, 2007.
16.
Wong TY. Effect of increasing age on cataract surgery outcomes in very elderly patients.
BMJ. 2001-2009;322:1104-1106.
17.
Brenner MH, Curbow B, Javitt JC, Legro MW, Sommer A. Vision change and quality of
life in the elderly. Response to cataract surgery and treatment of other chronic ocular conditions.
Arch Ophthalmol.1993;111:680-685.
18.
Monestam E, Wachmeister L. Impact of cataract surgery on the visual ability of the very
19.Bourne R, Dineen B, Jadoon Z, Lee PS, Khan A, Johnson GJ, et al. Outcomes of cataract
surgery in Pakistan: Results from the Pakistan national blindness and visual impairment survey.
Br J Ophthalmol 2007;91:420-6.
40
21. *Vijay K. Domple, Arvind V. Gaikwad,et al. A Study on Visual Outcomes after Cataract
Surgery with Intraocular Lens Implants at the Rural Health Training Center,Paithan, Maharashtra
Indian Journal of Public Health, Volume 55, Issue 1, January-March, 2011.)
22. Mubashir Rehman, Asim Ali Shah et al. Visual Outcome after Extra-CapsularCataract
Extraction with Intraocular Lens Implantation of Patients with Age Related Cataract.
Ophthalmology Update Vol. 12. No. 4, October-December 2014
23. Candidate Number: 100905.Rapid assessm ent of Avoidable Blindness and willingness to
pay for cataract surgery in tribal region of Surat district of Gujarat state, India.available at
http://www.lshtm.ac.uk/library/MSc_CEH/2010-11/100905.pdf )
24. K M Anjum, M B Qureshiet al Cataract blindness and visual outcome of cataract surgery in
a tribal area in Pakistan. Br J Ophthalmol 2006;90:135138
25.
SURGERY AT THE UNIVERSITYCOLLEGE HOSPITAL, IBADAN Ann Ibd. Pg. Med 2011.
Vol.9, No.1 8-13.
41
42
Name______________
Gender
1): Teacher
8: Driver
Age______________
Area
3: doctor
9: Computer Operator
VA Before Surgery:
4: Engineer
_____________
Occupation
5 : Mechanic
OD
6: Housewife
11: Businessman
7: Farmer
12: Other
OS
[1] 6/6 [2] 6/9 [3] 6/12 [4] 6/18 [5] 6/24 [6] 6/36 [7] 6/60 [8] < 6/60
Surgery Done in
VA After Surgery:
[2]
Left Eye
OS
[1] 6/6 [2] 6/9 [3] 6/12 [4] 6/18 [5] 6/24 [6] 6/36 [7] 6/60 [8] <6/60
43
night?
Yes/No
Do you have any trouble in recognizing specific colors? Yes/No
Is there any trouble pouring liquid or going downstairs? Yes/No
Do you see rings around light during night?
Yes/No
Any problem during TV watching, playing or working outdoor, reading time on watch and wall
clock, driving at night and during rain, and using computer and cell phone? Yes/No
8. Will you persuade other patients to come for surgery?
Satisfaction Score:
(1) 60-80 Good
44