Sie sind auf Seite 1von 12

Daily Herald the Brown

vol. cxliv, no. 96 | Friday, October 30, 2009 | Serving the community daily since 1891

Prostitution ban passes, E y es I n D isguise Tomatoes,


but college taxes falter porn and
By Ben Schreckinger
Senior Staf f Writer
tion bill in May and June respec-
tively, but were unable to reach a
compromise before the General
now a book
The Rhode Island Senate Thursday Assembly adjourned this summer.
night passed a compromise version The House version of the bill car-
Alum dishes on his
of a bill banning indoor prostitu- ried harsher sentences for prosti- X-rated career
tion, which now awaits Gov. Donald tutes than did the Senate version,
Carcieri’s ’65 signature. which did not mandate criminal By Rachel Arndt
The legislature also passed sev- penalties until a third offense. Senior Editor
eral other bills, including The compromise ver-
one that would strip the Metro sion of the bill, which What is porn?
governor’s authority to had passed the House For Sam Benjamin Stern ’99, it
fill vacant United States Senate seats Wednesday, makes prostitution — was the possibility of pursuing art
by appointment. whether indoors or outdoors — a while making money. It was also a
Notably absent was any action misdemeanor carrying a minimum way out of the pot-smoking grind
on two bills to tax private colleges fine of $250 and up to six months of his first post-college job as an
and universities — the bills, which in prison for a first offense. Clients organic farmer in California.
would have extracted millions from can receive up to a year in prison
the University and other Ocean for a first offense. FEATURE
State nonprofits, were not on the Penalties are much stiffer for
agenda, meaning that their propo- the operators of brothels, who will Last but not least, it was a way
nents will need to start at square receive a minimum sentence of one into publishing: His self-published
one when the legislature recon- year for a first offense. first book, “Confessions of an Ivy
Nick Sinnott-Armstrong / Herald
venes in January. Outside of part of Nevada, the League Pornographer,” was re-
The Ladd Observatory is decked out for Halloween this week,
The House and Senate passed glowing mummies and all. leased this May.
their own versions of the prostitu- continued on page 2 See News, page 2 Benjamin, who used his last
name, Stern, while at Brown but
now goes by just his first and middle

New URI president makes overtures to Brown names, “Sam Benjamin,” chronicles
in the memoir his journey in and out
of the porn industry — from direct-
By Alex Bell eration, including possibilities or other initiatives. as opportunities for us to work ing videos to starring in them.
Staf f Writer for cross-registration between Dooley, who said he left his together, and what the potential The book is told from the point
the two schools. position as provost of Montana might be,” Dooley said. of view of a “highly educated Jewish
Just four months into his presi- “When I came in, it looked to State University with a mission According to Provost David kid from North Carolina,” wrote
dency at the University of Rhode me like Brown and the Univer- to bolster URI’s reputation for Kertzer ’69 P’95 P’98, the meet- Benjamin’s publicist, Shane Mahon-
Island, David Dooley has big plans sity of Rhode Island could do a lot research, wasted no time in ap- ing at Simmons’ house, which ey, in an e-mail to The Herald. The
for his school — plans he hopes more together,” Dooley said. proaching Brown administrators took place a few weeks ago, was book is for the “postmodern, jaded,
will include Brown. But “nothing specific is being with his proposals. a dinner in honor of Dooley’s ar- Gen-X crowd,” he added.
Dooley’s vision includes in- explored at this time,” President “We had a ver y, ver y produc- rival to URI and not specifically Indeed, Benjamin writes his story
creasing collaboration on re- Ruth Simmons wrote in an e-mail tive meeting that involved me, a session to strategize about col- with no lack of self-consciousness,
search opportunities — sharing to The Herald, adding that admin- President Simmons and members laboration. calling his decision to choose film-
research sites and equipment, for istrators have not had talks on of our senior leadership teams, ing sex over harvesting tomatoes
continued on page 3
instance — and academic coop- campus about cross-registration where we discussed what we saw the “fantasy shared by every upper-
middle-class, semi-hipster, slightly

A spirited tour of the


awkward Jew who’s ever done time
in a college classroom.”
From 2000 to 2005, Benjamin

East Side’s major haunts made about 10 independent por-


nographic films and filmed hun-
dreds of scenes for professional
By Talia Kagan is filled with ghosts in unexpected companies.
Staf f Writer nooks and crannies, according to His interest in pornography goes
the guides who use their super- back at least as far as his years at
During the Revolutionar y War, natural knowledge of Providence’s Brown. A concentrator in art-semi-
University Hall was temporarily paranormal to lead visitors and otics, he toyed around with editing
converted to an army hospital. locals alike through the city’s existing porn films. He also drew a
While the building’s administra- haunted side. Drawing on archi- comic strip for The Herald called
tive offices bear little val research and “Anxiety Comix.”
evidence of this grue- SPOTLIGHT local history, both “I was super passionate about
some past in which the Providence being a working artist,” he said, but
soldiers received painful surgeries Ghost Tour and the Providence “I wasn’t really talented.”
such as leg amputations, on the Ghost Walk divulge College Hill’s Benjamin wanted to bring an
right night a passerby might see spooky secrets to give customers a uncharted level of artistic thought
a contorted soldier’s face staring taste of Providence’s otherworldly to porn, pairing postmodernist
out a second-floor window — ac- thrills. thoughts — and even a bit of hu-
cording to the Providence Ghost manity — with eroticism. He tried
Tour, one of the walking tours that Quoth the Raven his hand at it on and off from 2000
explore the city’s various “haunted” The eerie tales of Edgar Allan to 2005.
locations. “Porno was this land of undiscov-
In fact, Rhode Island’s capital continued on page 4
Claire Huang / Herald
continued on page 5
inside

News.....1-5
Sports.....6-7
News, 3 Sports, 7 Opinions, 11
Ar ts.........8 beyond borders Ground down Early Exclusion
Editorial..10 Former European leaders Zach Tronti ’11 has iced Jared Lafer ’11 wants past
Opinion...11 discussed the future of the recent foes late, but Penn discrimination against Jews
Today........12 European Union will be a tough new test by elite colleges examined

www.browndailyherald.com 195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island herald@browndailyherald.com


Page 2 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Friday, October 30, 2009

C ampus N EWS “We’re going to cover Wriston with gravestones plus a few surprises.”
— Troy Shapiro ’10, an AEPi brother, on the Wriston Rising party Saturday

crossword Spooky slate of events in store


By Emily Kirkland
Contributing Writer

A haunted house, an organ concert,


a decoration-bedecked observatory
and a screening of the “Rocky Hor-
ror Picture Show.” Not to mention
frat parties, house parties and stand-
up comedy. It’s all in the cards for
this weekend — evidence that, for
many Brown students, Halloween
is serious business.
“I’ve been planning my costume
for a month,” said Nic Mooney ’11,
head of publicity for the Special
Events Committee, which plans
free campus-wide events. “I don’t
even want to think about how much
I’ve spent on it.”
This year, he said, he’ll be dress-
ing as “a skanky sun,” using sup-
plies purchased at the Garment
District, a store in Boston.
Mooney will showcase the outfit
trick-or-treating on College Hill.
“It’s fun,” he said, “especially Nick Sinnott-Armstrong / Herald
when you’re all decked out.” A makeshift dungeon in the Ladd Observatory for the holiday.
Chio Yokose ’10 and Kenji Mo-
rimoto ’11, co-presidents of the cluded student performances, a be held in a tent, allowing AEPi to
Japanese Cultural Association, said costume contest and free food. admit 300 people at a time. Last
creating this year’s haunted house, “We’ve been planning since the year, a 250-person capacity meant
in the basement of Sayles Hall, was beginning of the year,” he said. they had to turn away dozens of
a “huge time commitment.” And a lot went into planning partygoers.
After much deliberation, the Alpha Epsilon Pi’s Wriston Rising The party’s $5,000 budget in-
group settled on a hospital theme party, which will take place Satur- cludes a DJ, a dance floor, lights,
with “plenty of blood,” they said, but day night. an open bar and decorations.
specific decorations and elements “This is our biggest party of “We’re going to cover Wriston
will be a secret until the event is the semester,” Troy Shapiro ’10, (Quadrangle) with gravestones,”
unveiled on Friday night. an AEPi brother said, adding that Shapiro said, “plus a few surpris-
In his role in the Special Events the frat had been organizing the es.”
Committee, Mooney said he was party for “over a month.” His costume, on the other hand,
also busy organizing Thursday’s All that planning has paid off, will be anything but spooky. “I’m
Live on Lincoln event, which in- he said: This year, the party will going as a teddy bear,” he said.
Editor’s note: Due to a corrupted file, The Herald’s daily crossword puzzle was illegible on
Monday. Above is the puzzle as it should have appeared. Have at it! (Today’s crossword
puzzle is on the back page, as usual.) The Herald regrets messing up your Monday.

sudoku
U. dodges tax bullet, for now
continued from page 1 that criminal penalties for prosti- desk.
tutes would place “an unfair and Also on its way to Carcieri is a
Ocean State is the only jurisdiction heavy burden on the victim.” She bill banning reading or sending text
in the United States where indoor was one of only two dissenters in messages while driving, passed by
prostitution is currently legal. last night’s vote, according to the the assembly yesterday.
Over the summer, Attorney Gen- Providence Journal. The General Assembly also
eral Patrick Lynch ’87, State Police The Democrat-controlled legis- passed a bill that would allow Uni-
Superintendent Brendan Doherty lature’s move to strip the governor’s versity of Rhode Island, Rhode
and Carcieri expressed opposition office — currently occupied by Car- Island College and Community
to what they considered excessive cieri, a Republican — of the power College of Rhode Island students
lenience in the Senate version of to apply Advanced Placement and
the bill. METRO other credits towards an acceler-
But local human rights organi- ated three-year bachelor’s program.
zations asserted that burdening to fill Senate vacancies comes on the The bill aims to ease the financial
prostitutes with a criminal record heels of the Massachusetts legisla- burden of higher education for
would serve only to diminish their ture’s decision to reverse a similar students at Rhode Island’s public
prospects for legitimate employ- measure. The Massachusetts law, colleges.
ment. passed by a Democratic legislature Bills that would allow cities to
An amendment to the bill that during Republican Mitt Romney’s slap large nonprofits — including
was finally passed allows courts to governorship, was amended to al- Brown — with partial property

Daily Herald
expunge convictions for prostitutes low Gov. Deval Patrick, a Democrat, taxes and levy a $150 tax on out-
the Brown
— but not for clients or brothel op- to quickly appoint a successor to of-state students at private colleges
erators — after a year, at judges’ Edward Kennedy, who died this did not come up during the special
Editorial Phone: 401.351.3372 | Business Phone: 401.351.3260 discretion. summer. session. The bills would need to
Stephen DeLucia, President Jonathan Spector, Treasurer State Sen. Rhoda Perr y P’91, The Rhode Island bill, which be re-introduced at the beginning
Michael Bechek, Vice President Alexander Hughes, Secretary D-Dist. 3, whose district includes passed by a veto-proof majority of the next session in Januar y to
The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serv- College Hill, told The Herald in July Thursday, will be sent to Carcieri’s remain active.
ing the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday
through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during
Commencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily
Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each members of the community.

read | share | recycle


POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI
02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Offices are located at 195
Angell St., Providence, R.I. E-mail herald@browndailyherald.com.
World Wide Web: http://www.browndailyherald.com.
Subscription prices: $319 one year daily, $139 one semester daily.
Copyright 2009 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.
Friday, October 30, 2009 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Page 3

C ampus N EWS “Language in the European Union is an instrument of power.”


— Romano Prodi, former Italian Prime Minister

Researchers question
prevailing HIV wisdom
By Kristina Klara gating HIV, poverty, migration, lack
Contributing Writer of circumcision and lack of access
to health care and education also
Current beliefs about the spread of affect the epidemic, they said.
HIV in sub-Saharan Africa may be “We are not saying that (con-
unfounded, according to a paper currency) is not important or …
published recently by two Brown is not happening,” Lurie said, “but
researchers. the hypothesis that’s out there that
Assistant Professor of Commu- people are taking as fact is flawed
nity Health and Medicine Mark in many ways .”
Lurie and Samantha Rosenthal GS, The United States Agency for
a masters student in public health, International Development has re-
found that there is insufficient sci- cently spent millions of dollars on
Claire Huang / Herald
entific evidence to prove that con- mass media campaigns to discour-
Romano Prodi, former Italian prime minister, spoke about the European Union’s future at panel this week.
currency — the practice of having age concurrent sexual networks in

Former E.U. leaders discuss way forward multiple sexual relationships at the
same time — is the main driving
force behind the HIV epidemic in
sub-Saharan Africa, the researchers
said.
Rosenthal and Lurie are wary
By Monique Vernon the current state of the union and Mark Blyth, who also spoke at the sub-Saharan Africa. of pulling money from tried and
Staff Writer alternatives that should be adopted event, framed the discussion of “We’ve challenged an otherwise true methods of preventing the
to help the union move forward. the EU’s future by saying that the unchallenged assumption about spread of HIV — like condom use
The relevance and future of the Eu- The institution must focus on EU risks stagnating if it does not the impact that overlapping sexual and circumcision — to funnel into
ropean Union were the focus of two achieving unanimity and on obtain- evolve. partners has,” Rosenthal said. discouraging concurrency.
former European leaders on campus ing more stable sources of funding, “What the European Union has The prevailing assumption that “Money may well have been
this week. the panelists said. done in the past has defined what it concurrency is driving the epidem- spent better elsewhere on an in-
In four panels, former Italian Gusenbauer said EU members can do,” he said. “It has exhausted ic, Lurie said, is “a great big leap tervention that we already know
Prime Minister Romano Prodi and must agree to “abolish the system its future possibilities.” of faith.” is efficacious,” Lurie said.
former Austrian Chancellor Alfred of intergovernmental financing” by Audience members asked the About one year ago, Lurie Both Lurie and Rosenthal said
Gusenbauer identified ways to make taxing European citizens directly, not leaders questions that touched on, read an article by Harvard public they wanted to force people to think
the economic and political group of relying on member governments to among other topics, whether Ukraine health researchers Timothy Mah a little more carefully about how
27 countries more effective. supply funds. would ever enter the union and the and Daniel Halperin that presented HIV spreads and not jump to con-
The two-day event entitled, “The The panelists also said that hav- EU’s politicization. the evidence supporting the central clusions.
European Union in a Moment of Cri- ing English as a common language Those who attended the event role of concurrency in HIV trans- “There are still a lot of question
sis,” hosted by the Watson Institute would serve to unify and strengthen said they enjoyed listening to the in- mission. marks,” Lurie said.
for International Studies. the union. formative and engaging speakers. “I did not feel like there was The pair wants to discourage
Thursday evening’s panel, “What “Language in the European Union “Very distinguished panelists,” strong evidence at all,” Lurie said. non-profit organizations and poli-
Is the EU’s Future?,” served as a “cul- is an instrument of power,” Prodi said Rich Maher GS. They were “able “A lot of problems or shortcom- cy makers from rushing to tackle
mination of a pretty serious and ex- said. to provide an interesting and excel- ings (of the concurrency theory) concurrency until they have more
tensive conversation about the Euro- A common language would lead lent analysis.” were not mentioned or identified,” evidence.
pean Union,” said Michael Kennedy, to a more level playing field, Gusen- The two-day event served as “a Rosenthal said. “The evidence at “We want to encourage better
director of the Watson Institute. bauer agreed. point of contact between practitio- best is mixed.” study and research, agree upon
The approximately 90-minute The EU has 23 official languages ners, students and academics,” Blyth Lurie and Rosenthal concluded consistent definitions of concur-
panel centered on the idea that the — a number that is likely to increase told The Herald after the panel. that the cause of the HIV epidemic rency and then do research and
European Union must be revamped as more countries join the union, ac- “I hope it will serve as a model for could not be traced back to one multiple studies to show that this
for it to be a more effective govern- cording to the European Commis- other events that the Watson Institute factor. is going on,” Rosenthal said. “We
ing body. sion’s Web site. In the past, EU lead- holds,” he added. Though Lurie and Rosenthal do need to ask, ‘What do we know?’
Prodi, a professor-at-large at the ers have called for requiring citizens Though the panels only lasted two not deny that concurrent sexual re- and realize that we need to do more
Watson Institute for International Re- of an EU member country to speak at days, “the commitment to understand lationships can play a role in propa- work.”
lations and a former president of the least two foreign languages besides the European Union” will continue in
European Commission, and Gusen- their mother tongues. the future, Kennedy told Thursday
bauer identified the problems with Professor of Political Science night’s audience.

Brown, URI look for common ground


continued from page 1 Dooley said URI’s plans to build other universities,” Kertzer said.
its own research park near its According to Ker tzer, URI
The gathering was “a nice thing Kingston campus had to be put of fers courses in areas such as
Ruth did to welcome a colleague,” on hold because of the economic pharmacology, marine research
he said. downturn and a dispute over the and nursing that Brown students
The basis of the proposals for proposed location. might be interested in taking. But
increased collaboration, Dooley Dooley told The Herald he because of the distance between
said, is to expand the already high would also like Brown and URI Brown’s campus and URI’s cam-
level of research cooperation be- students to benefit from joint cur- puses around the state, Kertzer
tween the universities. Faculty ricular programs. said joint curricular programs
members from both universities “I don’t know if that’s something might make more sense for gradu-
have already worked together not that can work or not, but I think it’s ate students than for undergradu-
only on research projects but also worth exploring,” he said. ates.
on proposals for federal funding Brown already has joint cur- The next meeting for adminis-
that have benefited both institu- ricular programs with a few other trators from both universities to
tions, he said. schools, including the Brown- discuss collaboration will probably
Research collaboration so far Rhode Island School of Design be in Januar y, though a date has
“has been very successful and very five-year dual degree program not yet been set, Kertzer said.
productive,” Dooley said. and the Brown/Wheaton Fac- “As the two research universi-
Kertzer said transforming the ulty Fellows Program that sends ties in Rhode Island — as close
Jewelry District into a “knowledge Brown graduate students to teach as we are together — we might
district” to house research and at Wheaton College, where they find ways to par tner that would
health institutions is appealing to are mentored by Wheaton staff. benefit both institutions,” Dooley
both Brown and URI because such Students who wish to take languag- said. “We have programs here that
a research park would contribute es not offered at Brown can also are ver y strong that complement
positively to Providence and Rhode register at other schools under the programs at Brown, and Brown
Island. certain circumstances. obviously has a set of programs
In an inter view with the Provi- “Recently, Brown has been col- that is complementar y to what
dence Business News last week, laborating more and more with we’re doing here at URI.”
Page 4 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Friday, October 30, 2009

F eatures “I’ve actually seen a full torso’s apparition.”


— Howard Hewitt, amateur archaeologist, on encountering spirits

Ghost walk shows city’s spooky side


continued from page 1 and the yellow colonial house de- Rhode Island School of Design
scribed in horror writer H.P. Love- campuses. The tour’s stops include
Poe are always popular during the craft’s short story “The Shunned a haunted admissions office, the
Halloween season, but Providence House.” Brown Faculty Club and a former
residents may not know that Poe Raven said visitors often react funeral parlor that has been turned
once roamed the streets of Col- to his creepiest stories with “ner- into an art studio — where artists
lege Hill with his fiancee, local vous laughter.” A guest once faint- now wash their paintbrushes in
poet Sarah Helen Whitman. They ed, he said — because she hadn’t sinks previously used for embalm-
conducted much of their courtship eaten breakfast. “It wasn’t anything ing, said Kelly McCabe, who has
in the Providence Athenaeum on spooky, just low blood sugar,” he worked as one of the tour’s guides
Benefit Street, and Poe even wrote said. for two years.
her a poem, one of the two he titled Raven works full-time as a practi- Like Raven, Gertrudes and Edge
“To Helen.” tioner of mentalism — stage magic turned to local history for material.
“They fell in love in that Gothic, that presents the illusion of clair- Gertrudes spent so much time re-
cosmic kind of way only the Victori- voyance — and gives lectures on searching in the Rhode Island His-
ans could,” said Rory Raven on one occult topics such as seances and te- torical Society archives that he was
of his Providence Ghost Walks last lepathy. But when asked whether he even offered a job as an independent
week. Tragically, Poe’s alcoholic actually believes in the supernatural researcher, he said.
habits proved to be a deal-breaker tales he spins, the self-described Early on in the walk, McCabe
for Whitman’s family, and she ended “mindbender” was evasive. offers a quick primer on the spiritual
their engagement, said Raven, au- “I pass them on as stories,” he manifestations that she encourages
thor of “Haunted Providence,” a col- said. her tours’ attendees to photograph.
lection of local legends about ghosts She outlines their various forms,
and strange happenings. Invisible histories which include “orbs,” “apparitions”
This is Raven’s tenth year run- Courtney Edge, who co-founded and “poltergeists.” Pictures of orbs,
ning the Providence Ghost Walk, Providence Ghost Tour, freely ad- or “balls of energy” without ex-
but he isn’t the only one who knows mits to personal experience with the plained light sources, are the most
his repertoire of stories by heart. paranormal. There was “a tremen- common, she said.
Some attendees keep coming back dous amount of paranormal activity” Howard Hewitt, an amateur
— it “keeps the stories fresh in my in her childhood home, including archaeologist with a self-described
mind,” said Jocelyn Smyth, who at- unexplained footsteps and sounds, “passion” for the paranormal, took
tended Raven’s tour for the fourth she said. Monday’s tour with a camera in Frederic Lu / Herald
time Saturday afternoon. Edge and Mike Gertrudes, the hand and high hopes for encoun- Kelly McCabe, pictured in front of the Annmary Brown Memorial, gives
tours of “haunted” Providence locales for Providence Ghost Tours.
Attired in a long black jacket, a tour’s other founder, often went tering some ghostly activity. Hewitt,
vest and a top hat, Raven focuses his ghost hunting in local cemeteries, who has studied “parapsychology” first-time guest Shayla Fortin. season also means more discernible
tour on stories from the 19th cen- a shared interest that led to the cre- for years, said he had encountered Though some skepticism of supernatural activity, McCabe said.
tury, based on historical accounts ation of the Providence Ghost Tour spirits in the past, though never be- paranormal phenomena is neces- “There’s a reason that Halloween is
from local archives. four years ago. Business has been fore in Providence. sary, doubting visitors can affect when it is.”
The walk travels mostly along booming since its founding — Edge “I’ve actually seen a full torso’s the tour experience, McCabe said.
Benefit Street, once a back alley in and Gertrudes now employ nine apparition,” he said. “Sometimes you get tours where The Providence Ghost Walk is of-
which city residents buried family tour guides, and last Saturday over During the tour, Hewitt filled people are so closed off that it just fered Saturdays and Sundays until
members, Raven said. The many 100 people showed up for the tour in his entire roll of film with shots of drains the energy,” she said. the end of October at 3 p.m. Tours
graves have since been reinterred the pouring rain, Gertrudes said. windows and dark corners. He even Gertrudes expects a large crowd leave from the Providence Athenae-
in another cemetery, though some The tour starts at Prospect Ter- sensed the presence of a Revolu- this weekend — which could be a um, and tickets cost $7. Providence
bones may still remain on College race Park around dusk on Friday tionary War soldier on the steps of boon to ghost hunters, according Ghost Tours are offered Friday and
Hill, he said. and Saturday nights. Guides hold University Hall, he said. to McCabe. Larger crowds often Saturday nights through Novem-
The Ghost Walk’s other stops lanterns as they recount tales of But not all guests had Hewitt’s attract a greater spiritual presence, ber 14 at 7 p.m. Tours leave from
include a cemeter y, the haunted haunted dormitories and lead at- level of belief. she said. Prospect Terrace Park, and tickets
site where a sanitorium once stood tendees through the Brown and “I wanted to, but I didn’t,” said Of course, the haunted holiday cost $12.

blogdailyherald.com
Updates, photos, comments!
Page 5 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Friday, October 30, 2009

F EATURES “It was a failure. But it was a funny failure.”


— Sam Benjamin Stern ’99, on his porn career

From organic farm to L.A. porn scene, alum avoided beaten path
continued from page 1

ered opportunity,” he said. “I just


knew I could do something better
with it.”

Humble beginnings
After graduating from Brown,
Benjamin left rainy Providence for
California’s sun, taking a job at an
organic tomato farm. The sun and
home-grown marijuana took their
toll, though, and Benjamin moved
on.
“Brown, like most American lib-
eral arts institutions operating in
the latter part of the 20th century,
had adopted the post-modern way
of thought as a virtual religion,”
Benjamin writes in the book.
That “splendidly pretentious lexi-
con” taught him to play “the Creativ-
ity game, and play it to win.” He
decided he could make art to make
money — “I could use my brain to
Courtesy of Shane Mahoney
make a buck,” he writes. Sam Benjamin Stern’s ’99 self-published “Confessions of an Ivy League Pornographer” was released in May.
Benjamin wanted to make “porn
with soul,” according to Mahoney. ternet company needed a producer Lysette penetrated me from behind, movies to be “degraded,” he said, modern art, “Small-town freaks on
So, while working at a juice bar, he and director for low-budget erotic and I rode the wave of her desire.” but in gay porn, the men are not a leash” and alternate careers he
struck up conversations about porn films. Benjamin “lucked into the Benjamin’s on-screen debut moti- imposed upon to have sex. might have pursued, among other
with anyone who would listen. job,” he said, and kept it for about vated him to stay in the industry. He Now, with a book “far cheaper explicit and artistic explorations.
“I’m really surprised I didn’t get a year and a half. continued working in L.A. — behind than actual porn, and only 50 per- Though Benjamin is self-pub-
fired,” he said. “I was running the show — I was the camera once more — and even cent as shameful,” according to Ben- lishing the book for now, he hopes
The start to his new career came hiring people, I was getting paid told his father what he’d been up to jamin’s Web site, his goal of success- to find a publisher and is working
in the form of a porn-loving 45-year- good money,” he said. But “it was since college. fully mixing sex, money and art may to drum up interest through social
old named Dennis, whom he met at the opposite of what I had come into Then, the ubiquitous sex began be about to reach its climax. media sites, he said.
the juice bar. porn to do.” to drag. Instead of changing things Benjamin has a literary agent in
Dennis offered to be in Benja- Business slowed down, and the as he had intended, he was “doing Translating flesh to text New York, according to Mahoney,
min’s first video at no cost. (“I’ll work Benjamin was doing for the exactly the same thing.” “Burnt out” Benjamin wrote the bulk of and his goal is to find a publisher
never forget him, because he was softcore company Wett Channel from the work, he said, “I didn’t feel “Confessions of an Ivy League Por- by mid-next year.
my first,” Benjamin said.) fizzled. Benjamin was broke. like being around people having sex nographer” in six months in 2006, “Several hundred copies of the
But Benjamin “had to troll the Soon he was stuck riding a bike that much.” moving “forward in fits and starts,” book” have been sold, Mahoney
Internet” to find Dennis’ counter- in L.A., after his car broke and he he said. Now, while publicizing the said, since it was released for the
part. Eventually, he found a “super- had no cash to get it fixed. Benjamin Pulling out book, he’s also at work on another Amazon Kindle last May and as a
smart, super-interesting” dominatrix didn’t want out, though, and he got To sort himself out, Benjamin volume. paperback last August.
named Janay, star of the “Debbie his next chance, he said, “sooner traveled to Asia, where he medi- “The whole project of writing this What’s more, Mahoney wrote,
Does Whip-Ass” series. than I expected.” tated and fasted. Then he applied to book is my artistic redemption,” the book is already profitable, since
Besides actors, Benjamin also A sex-shop salesperson he’d the California Institute of the Arts, he said. “our margins on digital products
needed a camera. He spent $1,000 met a year before in San Francisco where he graduated in 2005 with a He went into porn hoping to do are so low.”
on a “one-chip digital camera,” he called Benjamin with a request. She master’s degree in critical studies something new with the genre, but Though Benjamin calls himself
said, after asking the salesman if he was directing a movie for the porn and integrated media. he found the medium to be static. a “hack” — and admits he’ll always
could return it after, which he did. company Good Vibrations — her But that wasn’t the end of making Porn is the same — “besides the be one — he cites a “creative force”
Benjamin’s first movie, “We first — and she wanted Benjamin. porn for Benjamin. While pursuing aesthetic differences,” he said — as the impetus behind his continued
Always Want,” was “hardly even a But he wasn’t going to be behind his degree, he also pursued the gay again and again. pursuit of artistry.
porno,” he says, but it was “the best the camera, she said. Instead, he’d porn industry. The tale features his stories of “It was a failure,” Benjamin said
film I ever made.” The film featured be one of the actors. The switch from heterosexual to Viagra use — “penises get scared, of his porn career. “But it was a
interviews with the actors to put Benjamin’s role in “Slide Bi Me” homosexual porn was “refreshing,” too,” Benjamin writes — and theoret- funny failure.”
“their personalities into the film” — was fairly straightforward, he writes he said. ical examinations of a “world where And, when it comes to Benja-
something that most porn movies in the memoir. “My dreadlocked “For some reason, in mainstream women existed only as props.” min’s artistic redemption, the book
lack, he said. lover kissed me on the head, then porn there’s an agenda,” he says. The chapters are separated by may provide a happy ending.
He tried to sell copies of the pushed me towards a pink blanket. Women in straight porn are in the photo-comics dealing with post-
video on eBay for $5.99 each. But
success was hard to come by. He
sold only five of his home-mastered
VHS tapes.
“Hardly anyone’s ever seen it,”
Benjamin says of the movie. “It’s my
masterpiece.”

The porn industry, writ large


After nine months of hawking his
homemade creation and working at
his dream of independent erotic-
film producing, Benjamin decided
to move on to bigger things.
So he moved from Santa Cruz to
Los Angeles, where he pushed his
way into the industry with “chutz-
pah.”
Meanwhile, he had to make
money and took odd jobs to make
ends meet — including a stint as a
go-go dancer in a gay bar.
His entrance into the “high-pro-
file porn industry” came when an In-
SportsWeekend
The Brown Daily Herald

Friday, October 30, 2009 | Page 6

Ivy’s top offense,


defense to battle
By Dan Alexander his. With a 27-17 lead over Princ-
Senior Staff Writer eton two weeks ago, the Bears ran
a 19-play drive that chewed up 11:08
Running back Zach Tronti ’11 prob- in the fourth quarter. Tronti ran 14
ably won’t get many carries in the times on the drive, including a three-
first three quarters of the Brown- yard touchdown to cap it off.
Penn game Saturday. And that’s OK In the fourth quarter against
with him. Cornell last Saturday, Tronti ran 10
“Everyone’s attitude is, let’s just times on a 12-play touchdown drive
do what we have to do to win games,” that took 7:12 off the clock.
Tronti said. “If that means me block- “That’s how any team would love
ing the first three quarters and then to write it up — to get ahead and then
trying to run the clock out at the end, try to burn the clock running the ball
I’m fine with that.” in the fourth quarter,” Tronti said.
Tronti is used to being a running But it probably won’t be that easy
back in a passing offense. His high this weekend.
school team was known for its spread
offense. It was also known for a quar- The matchup
terback who graduated a year ahead Tronti and the rest of the Bear Jesse Morgan / Herald File Photo
Running back Zachary Tronti ’11 has sealed victories in the Bears’ last two games. Brown will face Penn at
of Tronti — Florida’s 2007 Heisman offense will go up against the Quak- home this Saturday, hoping to improve its 2-1 Ivy League record.
Trophy Winner, Tim Tebow. ers this weekend, a team that ranks
Tronti got many of his high third in the nation in rushing yards Yale last weekend. The previous Penn Head Coach Al Bagnoli. “Ob- “They’re basically going to try to
school carries when his team was and total yards against. week, Columbia managed nega- viously, something’s going to have run it down our throats,” said safety
ahead in the fourth quarter and he “They’re very strong up front,” tive-20 yards on the ground against to give.” Chris Perkins ’10. “They’ll run it
had to help run out the clock. said Brown Head Coach Phil Estes them. The Bears are averaging 290 right at you.”
That’s exactly what he has done of the Penn defense. “They can beat Penn’s pass defense has given up passing yards per game, and it is Penn has started three quarter-
for Brown the last two weeks. He you with the four-man rush, and they only 149.7 yards per game, making likely they will stick with what has backs in the last three games. In two
had only four rushes in the first half put a lot of pressure on the quarter- it the best in the Ivy League. But worked so far on Saturday. of Penn’s last four games, the team
of Bruno’s win over Cornell last Sat- back. Their secondary is outstand- the Bears’ offense leads the league “Our strength is Kyle Newhall- has managed fewer than 100 yards
urday. The previous week, another ing. They really come to play week in scoring and yards. Caballero (’11) at quarterback and passing. But with a defense that has
victory, 14 of his 29 rushes came in in and week out.” “On paper, you’re facing a very, then our receivers,” Estes said. held its opponents to just 12.3 points
the fourth quarter. The Quakers gave up only 25 very explosive offense against a But if the Bears need to run out per game, Penn has not needed high
Lately, the final quarter has been rushing yards in their 9-0 win over pretty good, sound defense,” said the clock at the end of the game, offensive production to win.
Tronti will likely be called on again Both teams will come into the
to grind it out. game on a four-game winning streak
“What he has been able to do the and with identical 4-2 records. Brown
last couple of weeks in the fourth has yet to lose at home.
quarter has been tremendous,” Es- “Everybody is playing with a real
tes said. “We have a lot more confi- confidence, a real swagger that win-
dence in our run game.” ning teams need to have,” said wide
But not as much as Penn. The receiver Bobby Sewall ’10. “We go
Quakers focus their offense around out on the field, whether it’s home
the run. Last week, Penn gained 177 or away — and especially at home
yards on the ground and only 94 — and say, ‘No one is going to come
through the air. in here and beat us.’ ”
Page 7 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Friday, October 30, 2009

S ports W eekend “We’re going to be in your face, we’re going to be physical.”


— Men’s Hockey Coach Brendan Whittet ’94

Coach Whittet ’94 awaits excitement on ice, in stands


By Dan Alexander nal Four Championship in 1993 and didn’t fill the stands, and it didn’t Brown’s fourth captain, Jeremy mente eventually replaced him.
Senior Staf f Writer 1994 and got an at-large bid to the win games. Brown went 5-23-5 Russell ’11, will lead the Bears’ de- “It’s a clean slate,” Whittet said.
NCAA tournament in 1993. overall and 3-15-4 in ECAC play un- fense. “I don’t really care what happened
New men’s hockey Head Coach For the last 11 years, Whittet der Head Coach Roger Grillo. The Whittet said he plans to play an last year.”
Brendan Whittet ’94 remembers has seen the rink from behind Bears finished with the league’s aggressive style of defense, attack- Volpatti said the competition
when Meehan Auditorium was the visitors’ bench, as an assis- worst record, fewest goals per ing at the blue line and overloading for ice time has been intense this
filled ever y Friday and Saturday tant coach with the Dar tmouth game and most goals against per in the corners. preseason.
night the hockey team played at Big Green. game. “I want there to be some sem- “Ever yone has a new oppor-
home. He remembers students “I was shocked when I would But Whittet said he doesn’t want blance of guys that are physical and tunity,” he said. “It’s just a new
singing the national anthem, Bruno come in here and see the lack of to dwell on last season. tough and nasty and guys that, you breath of life.”
the mascot running around the attendance, the lack of support,” This season, the Bears will be know what, if somebody comes in Volpatti also said Whittet’s ar-
stands, the Brown band playing he said. without Matt Vokes ’09, who led their corner and they have a puck rival has caused a buzz around
on the ice. In order to bring more people the team in goals (10) and assists — that’s fine. But you’re not going Brown hockey that he hasn’t seen
And he wants it back. into the stands, Whittet slashed (17) a year ago, but they hope to to possess it for the next two min- in his time at Brown.
Whittet will get his first chance season ticket prices for the com- get more ice time from another utes,” Whittet said. “We’re going to “It’s a little bit of a culture
to refill Meehan Saturday night, munity in half and hosted 60 local potent offensive threat. Captain knock you through the wall, take change,” said forward Jarred Smith
when the Bears take on the Univer- children for a skate with Brown Devin Timberlake ’10 — who was the puck, and go the other way.” ’12. “It’s a little more upbeat and
sity of Ontario Institute of Technol- players, he said. sidelined with injuries for much of Who will stand behind Brown’s energetic.”
ogy in an exhibition game. While these ef for ts will get last year — will return after a sea- defense still remains somewhat of a The Bears will get their first
The game will be the Bears’ sec- people to the rink, Whittet said, son in which he had four goals and mystery. Although goalie Mike Cle- chance to show their new upbeat,
ond in an opening weekend that he hopes the hockey will keep four assists in just ten games. mente ’12 will start against Princ- energetic style of play this after-
will begin in Princeton, N.J. Friday them there. Still, the goal-scoring this year eton, Whittet said he doesn’t know noon in Princeton at 4 p.m. The
afternoon. The Bears will take on “We’ve got to bring an excit- will have to come by committee, whether Clemente, Dan Rosen ’10 puck will drop in Meehan for the
the Tigers in the Ivy Showdown — ing brand of hockey, and we will,” Whittet said. or Anthony Borelli ’13 will eventu- first time since Whittet took over
a game that will count toward the Whittet said. “We’re going to be Assistant captain Aaron Volpatti ally become the No. 1 goalie. the program at 7 p.m. tomorrow
teams’ overall records but not the ver y much up-tempo, we’re going ’10, who had the second-most goals “They’re all ver y good goalten- against UOIT.
ECAC standings. to be in your face, we’re going to on the team last year with six, said ders,” Whittet said. “Unfortunately, “It’s sort of a new era, I guess,
Whittet remembers Meehan be physical, we’re going to try and that committee must be led by the only one can play. There’s only one in Brown hockey,” Volpatti said.
from his years as a Brown defense- generate offense, and I think that’s three captains who play forward — net.” “And we want to pack that building
man. His team won an Ivy League a good brand of hockey to play.” Timberlake, Volpatti and Jordan Rosen was the star ter at the like it was when ... Coach Whittet
title in 1992, went to the ECAC Fi- Last season’s brand of hockey Pietrus ’10. beginning of last season, but Cle- was here.”

Herald Mail: Morning Mail’s cooler cousin.


Sign up at browndailyherald.com/register
Arts & Culture
The Brown Daily Herald

Friday, October 30, 2009 | Page 8

Want to know R.I.? Read the ‘fine print’ Mediocre performances


By Anita Mathews with a chasm between legislative de- the fact that unions have lost on many
Contributing Writer
dim ‘Shooting Star’
tails and public awareness, Sgouros
said he decided to use his statistical
important legislative issues.
Instead, he urges Rhode Island’s
Criticized by the locals and pitied knowledge to relay commonly missed inhabitants to consider their own
by its neighbors, Rhode Island is subtleties that affect individuals’ daily contributions to what hurts the state By Kristina Fazzalaro While Reed is the calm, put-
frequently written off as too small lives. most. Contributing Writer together man, Elena is all over the
to combat the titanic issues it faces. “So often, a line of some subpara- “A lot of what I write is about how place, spouting advice and using
But despite the state’s soaring unem- graph B-96 turns out to be the ful- what’s bankrupting us are basically “I drink to excess, smoke a lot of the airport — and Reed’s abused
ployment and economic stagnation, crum around which some of the most popular choices, things that have dope, but I still can’t forget any- cell phone — like her personal play-
one Ocean State native is getting the important issues revolve,” Sgouros popular consent,” he said, pointing thing. It’s horrible.” ground, always seeking out some
word out about what can be done to said. to costly enforcement of “draconian” The female lead of “Shooting form of entertainment.
bolster a struggling state. From the first page of his book, drug policy as an example. “What’s Star,” now running at Trinity Rep- For example, upon first seeing
Tom Sgouros, editor of the Rhode he contends that Rhode Island’s sort of funny is that people want to ertory Theatre, isn’t the only one his ex-flame, Reed tries his best to
Island Policy Reporter, a newsletter problems are more complex than deny (that their contribution) mat- feeling horrible after sitting through hide, dispassionately telling the au-
on governmental goings-on, recently the common critic is willing to ac- ters at all.” Steven Dietz’s intelligently scripted dience that Elena “really let herself
published an incisive volume entitled knowledge. Sgouros also challenges the notion but poorly executed romantic com- go.” Meanwhile, Elena is prancing
“10 Things You Don’t Know About Sgouros said too many people buy that Rhode Island is worse off than edy. about the stage, attempting to ap-
Rhode Island.” The book, whose into what he calls the “conventional nearly every other state in the nation. This two-person, 80-minute pear profound and beautiful by
tagline reads, “A skeptical look at tale” of villainous labor unions and He takes a closer look at statistics that production offers up an interesting practicing yoga in the middle of
government, economics and recent politicians as the sole cause of the are frequently cited in this argument concept: Reed McAllister and Elena the airport, trying to get Reed’s at-
history in one lively little state,” tack- state’s troubles. — and just as frequently misused. Carson, former college sweethearts, tention without his knowing.
les both the political quagmire and the “The world craves a story that ex- He gives the example of public run into each other 25 years later at At times, though, this trope can
attitudes impeding recovery, ending plains what’s going on,” said Sgouros. fire protection: Rhode Island spends a snowed-in airport with nothing but be a bit overbearing. We all have sat
with advice for both policymakers and As a result, “the facts don’t really twice as much money per capita on its time to kill and the knowledge that through films or plays or read books
Rhode Island citizens about how to speak for themselves — they speak fire departments as any other state. they probably won’t see each other about the archetypal “taming of the
improve the state of the state. within a story.” At first, this seems alarming and has ever again. How will they react — shrew.” When one of these is crafted
Sgouros, who has done statistical Sgouros said he finds that this given critics fodder for accusations of ask the questions they never did? in such black-and-white terms, the
research for various groups over the “master narrative” leads to an incor- financial mismanagement. Hash out old problems? Ignore each story gets old very fast.
last 20 years, said he took an interest rect interpretation of facts, and that But upon closer inspection, other completely? This problem is not helped by
in subjects “nerdy and obscure, but he is seeking to correct a question- Sgouros found that, unlike most Well, Reed and Elena definitely Williamson’s tendency to overact
central to all our lives,” after he real- able diagnosis of Rhode Island’s af- states, Rhode Island classifies am- do not ignore each other. Reed her already flamboyant charac-
ized that public policy was seldom flictions. He points out that blaming bulance personnel as part of the fire (played by Kurt Rhoads) is a typical ter, making her seem more like
reported clearly because of a general labor unions, for example, may be department. So while Rhode Island businessman running off to close a personality than a person. Con-
lack of technical expertise with num- convenient, but says that this argu- ranks first in fire protection spending, the biggest deal of the year while versely, McAllister’s deadpanning
bers and their meanings. Frustrated ment falls apart when one considers it also ranks near the very bottom his family is left to wonder if they’ll of the script with little emotion
in ambulance spending. Though it ever get that kind of attention. Elena leaves his character flat and one-
is a detail few people care to notice, (Nance Williamson) has retained dimensional.
Sgouros said the example illustrates her hippie persona from when she The best moments in the drama
how looking into the fine print can and Reed dated, walking around the unfold when the couple speak di-
make a big difference. airport with a rainstick and yoga rectly to the audience. In these mo-
“What I continue to be surprised mat in tow. ments, the emotion really does come
at is how every rock I encounter re- It’s red versus blue in this tale through, and viewers get a chance
wards being turned over,” Sgouros of boy meets girl — again. to connect with the couple.
said. Throughout the play, Reed and “Shooting Star” is about the coin-
Another lens through which Elena share stories long into the cidences and near misses that make
Sgouros examines public policy is early hours of the morning. Reed life worthwhile and about the fear of
that of economic incentives. He said admits his shortcomings as a father trusting someone else completely.
the recently controversial “student and a husband. Elena bares all as Deitz’s conception could have been
tax” on those enrolled in private uni- she reveals her past jealousies and fun and entertaining, but, like the
versities is an effort, albeit a “dumb” fears to Reed. The two help each drug-addled Elena who “still can’t
one, for the city to capture the mon- other see life in a different light forget anything,” viewers may find
etary advantage of having a university and reconnect through the joyful themselves wishing they could wipe
within its limits. pain that comes with opening old the nauseating performances from
“The way that Brown contributes wounds. their memory. But as Reed says,
to the city is pumping up the income The script itself is sharp and “Those little plastic bottles do come
and sales tax, which are state taxes,” entertaining, with some hilarious in handy.”
said Sgouros said. one-liners and interesting layers. It
“The state then turns around and also builds well off traditional male- “Shooting Star” runs at Trinity
stiffs the city. It has less to do with female dynamics, making audience Rep (201 Washington St.) through
Brown than with the broken relation- members recall fights they may Nov. 22.
ship between city and state.” have had with a partner.
World & Nation
The Brown Daily Herald

Friday, October 30, 2009 | Page 9

Shootings shake up L.A. synagogue


By Andrew Blankstein, led by local North Hollywood detec- gregant noticed the commotion and
Robert Faturechi and tives, not Downing’s elite anti-terror approached the gunman, who then
Richard Winton squad. shot both men in their legs. The gun-
Los Angeles Times For a few hours, though, the man did not speak, according to LAPD
shooting in the synagogue garage set Deputy Chief Michael Moore.
LOS ANGELES — When the sound of nerves on edge throughout the city. The shooter fled, and witnesses
gunfire shattered the peace of morn- Word traveled fast from temple goers called 911.
ing prayer Thursday at a North Hol- to police to city leaders to members of The victims, Maor Ben-Nissan, 37,
lywood synagogue, the shock waves a joint regional terrorism taskforce. and Allen Lasry, believed to be in his
traveled fast and far. The LAPD responded in force. Calls 40s, were taken to hospitals, where
Was it an anti-Semitic hate crime? and email alerts spun out to temples they were listed in good condition.
An act of terrorism? An isolated inci- and Jewish organization across the Detectives were working with
dent or part of a wider plot? These city. Word was relayed by news agen- them to understand what happened,
were all real fears in a city where, cies and television channels nation- Moore said. They do not believe the
10 years ago, a white supremacist wide. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa motive was robbery, according to
gunman had terrorized a Jewish rushed to the scene, as did two of LAPD sources, who spoke to the Los
preschool and murdered a postal the three candidates to succeed Po- Angeles Times on the condition they
Al Seib / Los Angeles Times
carrier, and where police have been lice Chief Richard Bratton as the next not be named because the investiga- Zvika Brenner, center, a volunteer Emergency Medical Technician for the
on alert for acts of terror since Sept. head of the LAPD. tion was open. community rescue team, is assisted by a Los Angeles Police Department
11, 2001. And then, gradually, investi- Rabbi Amran Gabay described officer as police continued their search for a suspect and a motive in the
By day’s end, authorities had come gators began ramping down the both men as regulars at the temple. shooting of two men Thursday morning in North Hollywood.
to believe that the shooting, in which excitement. He said one works in home improve- source later said detectives were not victim may have been shot because
two men were injured, was probably According to police, the shooting ment and the other in tile sales. The certain of the suspect’s race. he witnessed the attack.
a far more mundane crime with no occured at 6:19 a.m., after the victims rabbi said he knew of no reason why “This investigation is wide open,” Speaking to reporters outside the
implications for national security. had parked their cars in the under- either would be targeted. said LAPD Capt. Sharyn Buck, who taped-off synagogue, Los Angeles
“There is abolutely no evidence to ground garage of Adat Yeshurun Val- “They’re regular people,” oversees the North Hollywood Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa called
support any connection to terrorism ley Sephardic Synagogue, a small con- he said. Division. the incident “a senseless act of vio-
or a hate crime,” said Mike Downing, gegation on a quiet residential street. A 17-year-old who was detained for Several law enforcement sources lence.” But the mayor was careful to
Deputy Chief of the Los Angeles Po- Morning services were under way. questioning shortly after the shooting told the Times that investigators temper worries that the shooting was
lice Department’s Counter Terrorism A young gunman, dark-skinned and was released hours later, and police were looking at whether the shoot- a hate crime.
and Intelligence Bureau. wearing a dark hooded sweatshirt, backed away from initial claims that ings were related to a business or “None of us should presume
The gunman, whose image was approached one man near a stairwell the attack was motivated by religious personal dispute. The sources said or speculate more about this other
captured by video cameras, remained and attempted to shoot, police said, hate. Although the shooter was first detectives believe one of the victims than it was a random act of violence,”
at large, with the investigation being but his gun jammed. The second con- described as a black man, a police was the target, and that the second he said.

House Democrats unveil health bill


By Shailagh Murray and poorest children and adults would with a debate on the House floor
Lori Montgomery enroll in Medicaid. Another 21 mil- expected to begin late next week,
The Washington Post lion would purchase coverage on a most major differences appear to
new national insurance exchange, have been bridged.
WASHINGTON — After six months where private plans would compete Before the official unveiling,
of dealmaking, Democratic leaders with a “public option” backed by the House Democrats gathered in the
introduced Thursday a health care federal government. basement of the Capitol for a final
reform bill that would expand cov- An analysis of the House bill re- briefing with Pelosi and other lead-
erage to almost all Americans and leased late Thursday by the nonpar- ers, where they agreed that the time
overhaul the insurance industry, tisan Congressional Budget Office for compromise had arrived. Rep.
while asking the wealthiest taxpayers estimated that just 6 million people Earl Pomeroy, D-N.D., a prominent
to pay much of the tab. would choose a public plan, making fiscal hawk, stood up to announce
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of it a relatively small player, despite that he would support the measure,
California announced the 10-year the issue’s outsize role in the health- drawing a round of applause loud
$894 billion package on the Capitol care debate. enough to be audible outside the
steps, surrounded by Democrats The House bill would require room. “At the end of the day, we’ve
from all factions of her diverse cau- most individuals to purchase insur- got to pass something,” said Rep.
cus. “Leaders of all political parties ance and would require employers James McGovern, D-Mass.
starting over a century ago with to provide health coverage to their The House measure would pare
President Theodore Roosevelt, have workers or face a penalty, although $104 billion from projected budget
called and fought for health-care re- firms with payrolls below $500,000 deficits over the next decade, ac-
form and health insurance reform,” annually would be exempt. cording to the CBO, and would
Pelosi said. “Today we are about to House Minority Leader John “slightly reduce” projected deficits
deliver on the promise.” Boehner, R-Ohio, mocked the bill’s in the following decade. The CBO’s
The House bill is similar to its 1,990 pages as 620 pages longer than forecast for the House bill is less
Senate counterpart, although a hand- President Bill Clinton’s failed reform rosy than for the bill that passed the
ful of key differences could make plan 15 years ago. The conserva- Senate Finance Committee earlier
for protracted negotiations later tive Republican Study Committee this month, but it is significantly
this year. For example, the House’s warned of “higher taxes, job-killing more favorable than the analysis of
surtax on those earning more than employer mandates, choice-restrict- the original House package, which
$500,000 per year is a nonstarter in ing individual mandates, govern- predicted that costs would exceed
the Senate. Yet House Democrats ment-run insurance, budget-busting revenues after 2019.
oppose the Senate’s main revenue entitlement expansions, and count- In addition to expanding cover-
measure, an excise tax on high-val- less provisions that set Washington age, the House bill would impose
ue, or “Cadillac,” health-insurance bureaucrats firmly between you and strict new rules on insurance com-
plans. And while both bills include your doctor.” panies, including a ban on denying
a government insurance plan, the For weeks, House Democratic coverage based on pre-existing con-
Senate version would allow states leaders have huddled behind closed ditions. The legislation would end a
to opt out of participating. doors, seeking to stitch together federal antitrust exemption that has www.browndailyherald.com
Under the House bill, 36 million a 218-vote majority from disparate long protected the industry from
uninsured Americans without ac- Democratic blocs. Up to 40 conser- investigations into price-fixing and
cess to affordable health benefits vative Democrats remain unhappy other practices, and would institute
at work would become eligible for with abortion-related provisions, and a review process into premium in-
coverage. About 15 million of the are still threatening to vote no. But creases.
Editorial & Letters
The Brown Daily Herald

Page 10 | Friday, October 30, 2009

J ulia S treuli

e d i to r i a l

Letters make the The Green Light


world go ’round. On Oct. 19, the Justice Department circulated a
memorandum to federal prosecutors in Rhode Island
August. Is there anything to prevent the same thing
from happening in Rhode Island?
and the other 13 medical marijuana states, instruct- Yes: More transparency. The more open Rhode
Keep us spinning. ing them not to prosecute individuals using medical
marijuana or those involved in dispensary operations
Island makes the operations of its proposed dispensa-
ries, the less pretext federal prosecutors will have to
that are “in clear and unambiguous compliance” with raid them on trumped-up charges. More transparent
letters@browndailyherald.com state laws. The move was hailed by medical marijuana operations will significantly decrease the incentives for
advocates such as Stephen Gutwillig, California state players in the illegal drug trade to get involved with
director of the Drug Policy Alliance, who called it “an dispensaries, as it will make them more vulnerable to
extremely welcome rhetorical de-escalation of the prosecution.
federal government’s long-standing war on medical Significant transparency is possible in the status quo.
marijuana patients.” We generally approve of ending According to the Rhode Island Patient Advocacy Coali-
wars but, as Americans have learned recently, winning tion, the amendment allowing for dispensaries contains
t h e b r o w n d a i ly h e r a l d
the peace can be just as important. In this context, provisions requiring “good oversight and recordkeeping
Editor-in-Chief Managing Editors Deputy Managing Editors Senior Editors
that would be Rhode Island taking advantage of the procedures.” Once Rhode Island officials have cleared
Steve DeLucia Michael Bechek Nandini Jayakrishna Rachel Arndt
Chaz Firestone Franklin Kanin Isabel Gottlieb unprecedented window of opportunity created by the that hurdle, possibilities for innovation abound.
Michael Skocpol Scott Lowenstein Justice memo to develop a superior medical marijuana As we’ve noted before, there are a number of flaws
editorial Business distribution system. in the dispensary systems used by California. Now that
Ben Hyman Arts & Culture Editor General Managers Office Manager
Sophia Li Features Editor Alexander Hughes Shawn Reilly We should first be clear that the new federal guide- Rhode Island knows exactly what the federal govern-
George Miller Metro Editor Jonathan Spector lines do not forbid all prosecution. Dispensaries and ment expects from it (at least during President Obama’s
Joanna Wohlmuth Metro Editor
Seth Motel News Editor
patients that are in violation of state laws can be still term), it has a chance to develop policies that improve
Directors
Jenna Stark News Editor Ellen DaSilva Sales raided by local authorities. Additionally, not all federal on the current model.
Andrew Braca Sports Editor Claire Kiely Sales prosecution has been taken off the table. The two most Rhode Island should consult with law enforcement
Han Cui Asst. Sports Editor Katie Koh Finance
Alex Mazerov Asst. Sports Editor Jilyn Chao Asst. Finance important loopholes allow federal prosecutors to go after and patient advocacy groups such as RIPAC as to what
Katie Wood Asst. Sports Editor Christiana Stephenson Alumni Relations dispensaries otherwise in compliance with state laws these new guidelines might permit in terms of policies
Graphics & Photos Managers
if they either believe the dispensaries are selling mari- the state might not have implemented in a climate of
Chris Jesu Lee Graphics Editor Kelly Wess Local Sales
Stephen Lichenstein Graphics Editor Kathy Bui National Sales juana for profit (as opposed to the standard non-profit uncertainty about federal action. Such consultation
Kim Perley Photo Editor Alex Carrere University Sales model) or if a prosecution would further “important would help the state to develop procedures that could
Max Monn Asst. Photo Editor Matt Burrows Credit and Collections
Jesse Morgan Sports Photo Editor federal interests,” presumably meaning the arrest of benefit local patients and governments and, by serving
production Opinions drug traffickers. as a model, patients and state governments nationwide.
Ayelet Brinn Copy Desk Chief Alyssa Ratledge Opinions Editor One might wonder whether, given such broad ex- If so, the Justice memo will mark a huge step forward in
Rachel Isaacs Copy Desk Chief Sarah Rosenthal Opinions Editor
ceptions, the new memo really is good news for Rhode the United States’ twisted history with drug policy.
Marlee Bruning Design Editor
Jessica Calihan Design Editor Editorial Page Board Island. San Francisco’s crusading federal attorney,
Anna Migliaccio Asst. Design Editor James Shapiro Editorial Page Editor Joseph Russoniello, has gone after San Francisco dis- Editorials are written by The Herald’s editorial page board.
Julien Ouellet Asst. Design Editor Matt Aks Board member
Neal Poole Web Editor Nick Bakshi Board member pensaries on the grounds that they make a profit since Send comments to editorials@browndailyherald.com.
Post- magazine Zack Beauchamp Board member
Arthur Matuszewski Debbie Lehmann Board member
Editor-in-Chief
Board member
correction
Kelly McKowen William Martin
Editor-in-Chief

Anna Migliaccio, Nick Sinnott-Armstrong, Katie Wilson, Designers


Nick Boucher, Brendan Burke, Joe Milner, Copy Editors An article in Tuesday’s Herald (“Officials detail carbon cuts, education outreach at BUCC,” Oct. 27.) incorrectly
Dan Alexander, Nikki Friedman, Ben Hyman, George Miller, Hannah Moser, Night Editors
reported that $10 million of a loan for energy efficiency has been approved. In fact, $20 million has been approved
Senior Staff Writers Dan Alexander, Mitra Anoushiravani, Ellen Cushing, Sydney Ember,
Lauren Fedor, Nicole Friedman, Brigitta Greene, Sarah Husk, Brian Mastroianni, Hannah and $10 million has been allocated.
Moser, Ben Schreckinger, Anne Simons, Anne Speyer, Sara Sunshine, Alex Ulmer, Suzannah
Weiss, Kyla Wilkes
Staff Writers Shara Azad, Emma Berry, Alicia Chen, Zunaira Choudhary, Alicia Dang, C O R R E C T I O N S P olicy
Juliana Friend, Anish Gonchigar, Sarah Julian, Matt Klebanoff, Etienne Ma, Christian The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Correc-
Martell, Heeyoung Min, Jyotsna Mullur, Lauren Pischel, Kevin Pratt, Leslie Primack, Luisa tions may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.
Robledo, Dana Teppert, Gaurie Tilak, Caitlin Trujillo, Monique Vernon, C ommentary P O L I C Y
Senior Business Associates Max Barrows, Jackie Goldman, Margaret Watson, Ben Xiong The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily
Business Associates Stassia Chyzhykova, Marco deLeon, Katherine Galvin, Bonnie Kim,
reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.
Cathy Li, Allen McGonagill, Liana Nisimova, Thanases Plestis, Corey Schwartz, William
L etters to the E ditor P olicy
Schweitzer, Kenneth So, Evan Sumortin, Haydar Taygun, Webber Xu, Lyndse Yess
Design Staff Gili Kliger, Jessica Kirschner, Nicholas Sinnott-Armstrong, Kate Wilson Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for
Photo Staff Qidong Chen, Janine Cheng, Alex DePaoli, Frederic Lu, Quinn Savit length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may
Copy Editors Jenny Bloom, Brendan Burke, Sara Chimene-Weiss, Miranda Forman, Sarah request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed.
Forman, Casey Gaham, Anna Jouravleva, Geoffrey Kyi, Jordan Mainzer, Joe Milner, Claire advertising P olicy
Peracchio, Lindor Qunaj, Madeleine Rosenberg, William Tomasko
The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.
Opinions
The Brown Daily Herald

Friday, October 30, 2009 | Page 11

A history of discrimination against Jews


and insular. They displaced the sons of should all sound familiar. Indeed, this appli- haven’t done the necessary research to know
wealthy WASP alumni, which did not bode cation construction is still used today. Thus whether Brown particularly discriminated.
Jared Lafer well for fund-raising.” when we apply to college, we are participat- Perhaps it was the exception — a distinct
Opinions Columnist Gladwell reports that measures were tak- ing in the very process originally intended to possibility in light of the liberal philosophies
en by Harvard to remedy the situation, in- weed out Jews. on which it was founded. Nevertheless, giv-
cluding a 15 percent Jew quota, a decrease Now, I’m not going to evaluate the admis- en that Brown was an elite institution, com-
in scholarship funds available for Jews and sions system at Ivy League schools. Its abil- peting with and conforming to the standards
In 2005, the New Yorker published an arti- a large effort to recruit students from pub- ity to determine the best candidates for ad- of peer institutions (e.g., uniform admissions
cle by Malcolm Gladwell called “Getting In,” lic schools in the West, where there were mission is beside the point. But I feel it is im- practices), and the fact that anti-Jewish senti-
which discussed admissions at elite univer- fewer Jews. But these were collectively un- portant to acknowledge and investigate the ment was pervasive at the time, we likewise
sities. It cited Jerome Karabel’s book “The successful. This led to the realization among relationship between anti-Jewish discrimina- cannot deny the contrary possibility. Either
Chosen,” which argues that discrimination Ivy League universities “that if a definition of tion and modern-day admissions practices. way, I believe uncertainty about our connec-
against Jews in the early 20th century gave merit based on academic prowess was lead- In fact, I believe it is even more important tion with such an injustice alone should be
rise to modern day admissions practices. I ing to the wrong kind of student, the solution to acknowledge and investigate the relation- enough to motivate us to do something.
believe Karabel is correct, and a greater ef- Second, while I may not know for sure
fort to acknowledge this unjust past is in or- whether Brown discriminated, other elite
der. It is important to acknowledge and investigate schools sure did. So whatever is done should
According to Gladwell by way of Karabel, be done intramurally.
the current era of admissions can be traced the relationship between Jewish discrimination With regards to what exactly to do, we
back to 1905, when Harvard “adopted the should look to precedent. In 2003, President
College Entrance Examination Board tests and modern day admissions practices. Ruth Simmons appointed the University
as the principal basis for admission, which Steering Committee on Slavery and Justice.
meant that virtually any academically gifted According to the Steering Committee Web
high-school senior who could afford a private was to change the definition of merit.” ship between anti-Jewish discrimination and site, it “was charged to investigate and to
college had a straightforward shot at attend- And so admissions underwent a major higher education at large. I believe this for prepare a report about the University’s his-
ing.” Other schools that would later form the shift. The emphasis on academic prowess two reasons: torical relationship to slavery and the trans-
Ivy League followed. was supplanted, at least in large part, by an 1) It will be historically valuable. No sig- atlantic slave trade.”
With a bit of pride I can say that this gave emphasis on personal character. According nificant effort has been taken by Ivy League A lot of good came from the Steering
rise to a major increase in the Jewish popula- to Gladwell by way of Karabel, applicants schools to examine their historical relation- Committee’s investigation, and I think the
tion at Harvard — and presumably other fu- were mandated to provide letters of recom- ship with Jewish students. Outsiders like formation of a similar committee is warrant-
ture Ivy League schools — over the next 20 mendation, personal essays and a list of ex- Karabel have certainly taken the initiative, ed in the present context. To spell it out: the
years. In 1908, Jews composed 8 percent of tracurricular activities, and asked to submit but only in the narrow scope of admissions. Ivy League should form an intramural com-
Harvard’s student body; by 1922, that num- to an interview and supply personal informa- Furthermore, internal reviews would un- mittee to investigate its ties with anti-Jewish
ber rose to over 20 percent. (This propor- tion like “Race and Color,” “Religious Prefer- doubtedly bring a fuller light to the story. discrimination. Let us wash away the injus-
tion was determined by searching through ence,” “Birthplace of Father,” etc. To top it 2) We owe it to the victims and ourselves tice through enlightenment.
admissions records and rating students on off, Harvard suggested that applicants send to learn from the past and never let this hap-
their likelihood of being Jewish.) a photograph. pen again. Jews are still susceptible to dis-
Gladwell says, “The administration and By 1933, “the percentage of Jews at Har- crimination today and so this effort will be a Jared Lafer ’11 is a philosophy
alumni were up in arms. Jews were thought vard was back down to 15 percent.” vehicle for self-reflection and edification. concentrator from Manhattan. He can
to be sickly and grasping, grade-grubbing To experienced college applicants, this So what can we do? First, I concede that I be reached at jared_lafer@brown.edu

Brown is more than just Facs, Man


conveniencing parents and alumni visiting ber the incident, and would surely have po- like forgetting that University Hall is where
campus. litely reminded FacMan ... if they had been President Ruth Simmons works.
Mike Johnson FacMan was obviously aware of the ram- consulted. Now I’m not trying to be the one to
ifications of closing one of the most-used However, FacMan needs no consulta- throw a ladder up against the side of 295
Opinions Columnist pedestrian paths on campus. Yet they re- tion. Like a circular tyrant gobbling up dots, Lloyd Ave. Nor am I proposing student in-
mained steadfast in their self-importance, FacMan plods along, approving projects and volvement in decisions regarding construc-
and needless barriers loom on the horizon. handing down edicts on sleep schedules tion projects or their timetables. I’m by no
While reading The Herald the other day, In a recent Herald exclusive, FacMan was and pedestrian paths, and now even impor- means advocating an overthrow of the des-
I read an interesting article about an ap- said to have “recognized that the closing tant academic research. It seems blatantly potic FacMan. I’m merely pointing out that
parent “oversight” on the part of Facili- of the arch would be a significant inconve- obvious to me that FacMan should consult FacMan has no clothes.
ties Management in approving a T-Mobile nience for students and faculty” (“In boon with the people who work in the building It’s quite clear that people are not among
cell tower on the roof of Barus and Holley for pedestrians, Faunce Arch to stay open,” that’s about to have a giant tower on its roof FacMan’s top priorities, despite its nice em-
(“Profs to FacMan: Can you hear us now?” Oct. 22). This recognition seems a little to beam radio waves into its hallowed halls. ployees who come to fix our heaters at all
Oct. 19). My initial response was laughter. I hours of the night. But FacMan as an entity,
can think of numerous occasions in the re- FacMan as the keeper of the keys, needs
cent past when Facilities Management, or to realize that people use its playthings,
FacMan, seemed alarmingly out of touch Like a circular tyrant gobbling up dots, FacMan the buildings. People walk these sidewalks;
with University needs. they aren’t just for show.
In 2007, FacMan, as part of renovations plods along, approving projects and handing Instead, I propose a sobering, drastic
to Gardner House, decided it was a good change in FacMan policy — communica-
idea to break out the jackhammers at 7 a.m.
down edicts on sleep schedules and pedestrian tion. Maybe if FacMan had actually talked
every day directly outside of Littlefield Hall, paths, and now even important academic to Barus and Holley researchers, they’d
a freshman dormitory. Initial complaints re- have known about sensitive equipment that
ceived a curt response, claiming that the research. might be affected by a giant cell tower spew-
contract day started before the students ing out radiation. Little oversights like this
would like, urging the alleged crybaby won’t have to be commonplace anymore.
freshmen to stop complaining. It was only Instead of blindly going about business
after a grassroots movement of flooding late, based on the details; sounds to me like FacMan’s apology for the oversight left a as usual, perhaps FacMan should reflect
FacMan with phone calls that the jackham- enough people complained. little to be desired as well — they said that on its communication policy and whether
mers started at a more reasonable — but But this most recent “oversight” of the they “did miss” the fact that Barus and Hol- it needs to expand upon what’s there. It’s
still ridiculously early for students — time fact that FacMan provides support for ac- ley was a research facility. clear that when discussing transformative
of 9 a.m. tual people, not just buildings immune to Inexcusable. FacMan is a part of this Uni- building projects, FacMan needs to take a
Just this month, the University was in- the effects of screaming, early-morning versity, and needs to become more aware of small step back, look at the big picture and
formed via e-mail that Faunce Arch was to jackhammers, is clearly the worst. Why? the impact of its actions. How, despite be- pay attention to the little people.
be closed to pedestrians until the opening It’s happened before. Just 19 years ago, a ing a vital cog in the educational machine,
of the spring semester. This closure was radio transmitter on the Sciences Library is it even possible for FacMan to forget that
dated for Oct. 19, conspicuously after Fam- shut down equipment in Barus and Holley. Barus and Holley is a research facility, com- Mike Johnson ’11 has the high score on
ily Weekend — probably meant to avoid in- There are still professors here who remem- plete with real research equipment? That’s the lesser-known Ms. FacMan.
Today 6
to day to m o r r o w
Football prepares for Penn faceoff
The Brown Daily Herald

‘Shooting Star’ at Trinity Rep


8
Friday, October 30, 2009
59 / 49 70 / 50
Page 12

t h e n e w s i n i m ag e s d i a m o n d s a n d c oa l

A cubic zirconium to activist students participating in a “climate action” rally and promot-
ing the number 350 as the maximum sustainable level of atmospheric carbon dioxide. We love
your passion, but we’re concerned that you think 350 is also a sustainable number of days per
year on which to protest.

A diamond to the state’s Department of Elderly Affairs, which created a support system
for abused elders. That’s a much better idea than that other DEA had (spraying abused elders
with pesticide).

2
Coal to the swine-inspired art exhibit “Contagious,” which featured artists’ interpretations
of the deadly flu. We’re still mad you rejected our found-art submission, “Pile of Tissues and
Trash Can Full of Vomit.”

A diamond to ex-pornographer Sam Benjamin Stern ’99, the alum whose post-Brown tra-
c a l e n da r jector y truly embodies school spirit. Organic tomato farming, being disillusioned, dabbling in
softcore “art,” being disillusioned again — bravo, sir.
Today, october 30 saturday, october 31
A pair of diamond-studded earrings and a backless velvet gown to the vice president at all-
3 pm — Edible Car Competition, 9 PM — “Chest Fest,” male Morehouse College for defending a controversial new policy banning “clothing normally
Manning Walk Grad Center Lounge associated with women’s garb” on campus. Even grouchy administrators deser ve to feel fabu-
lous sometimes.
4 pm — “The Virtuosity of Structure,” 11:55 PM — Halloween Midnight
Ashamu Dance Studio Organ Recital, Sayles Hall A cubic zirconium to Rhode Island judge and Obama nominee to the federal bench Ojetta
Rogeriee Thompson ’73, who received lukewarm ratings of “satisfactor y” from most members
of the American Bar Association’s advisor y committee. In an S/NC world, your credentials
have never been in doubt. The real question is how you pronounce “Rogeriee.”
menu
Coal to the malicious, PDF-corrupting demons of the Internet tubes for thrice ruining the
Sharpe Refectory Verney-Woolley Dining Hall Herald’s crossword this month. We’ll get you yet, you qjcerpa)r wmxbw*=_2

Lunch — Barbecue Beef Sandwich, Lunch — Chicken Fingers, Vegan Last but not least, a pumpkin full of diamonds to anyone who resists the temptation to
Swiss Corn Bake, Lobster Bisque, Nuggets, Sticky Rice, Halloween dress as swine flu, Michael Jackson or balloon boy tomorrow. Instead, may we suggest an eco-
Worms in Mud Cookies and Cupcakes logically friendly (and much more original) alternative that makes for a clever re-use for your
favorite campus daily: Cover yourself in old Heralds, splattered with organic ketchup. Bam!
Dinner — Baked Stuffed Pollock, Dinner — Cajun Baked Fish, Grilled You’re the demise of print journalism.
Noodle Kugel, Zucchini and Summer Chicken, Golden Corn and Rice Ca-
Squash, Birthday Cake serole, Halloween Candy

crossword comics

Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline

Hippomaniac | Mat Becker

Classic Deep-Fried Kittens | Cara FitzGibbon

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen