Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY
ERNST KENNDLER
Institute for Analytical Chemistry, University of Vienna
FURTHER READINGS............................................................................................................................ 34
Ernst Kenndler
Version 19/01/2004
1.1
In Gas Liquid Chromatography the analytes are distributed between a liquid stationary phase
and an ideal gas as the mobile phase as schematically shown in Figure 1.
<v>
cim (t)
GAS
LIQUID
cis (t)
c il
c im
(1)
However, for practical reasons the concentration in the liquid is expressed by the mole
fraction, xi, and that in the gas phase by its partial pressure, pi.
For the concentration in the liquid we express the vapour pressure of the solute, i, over
the binary mixture consisting of liquid phase and analyte by Henry`s law
p i = H p i0 = i0 x il p i0
(2)
Where H is the Henry constant, xil the mole fraction of analyte, i, in the liquid phase, i0 is
the activity coefficient (at infinite dilution), pi0 is the vapor pressure of the analyte (as pure
compound) at the given temperature.
The partial pressure, pi, of the analyte in the ideal gas phase is given by Dalton`s law
pi =
n ig
RT
Vg
(3)
RT
p ioVs ,mol
(4)
o
i
i0
the activity coefficient of the analyte in the stationary liquid (at infinite
dilution).
Separation selectivity of two consecutively eluting components, i and j, is defined in
chromatography by the selectivity factor, ji, the ratio of the distribution constants, K.
However, measurement of the values of K is complicated compared to k` values. As in a
certain chromatographic system the phase ratio is the same for all components, the selectivity
coefficients can be expressed by the ratio of the k` values of the pair of separands
ji =
k j,
(5)
k i,
ji =
pio io
p oj
(6)
o
j
the ratio of the activity coefficients the in stationary phase (at infinite
dilution).
Whereas the temperature only influences the first, the second reflects the difference in the
chemical interactions of the two separands in the stationary liquid. Insofar it is in fact a kind
of molecular recognition, which determines selectivity. This is exactly what makes the use of
different stationary phases meaningful.
K on T is more than overcompensated by the exponential increase of the vapour pressure, pio ,
with temperature, according to the Clausius-Clapeyron equation. For this reason the
distribution constant, and the capacity factor as well, decreases strongly with increasing
temperature. In fact the following linear approximation can be found
1
T
(7)
lok k
10
etbenzoat
C7ol
0,0023
0,0024
0,0025
0,0026
0,0027
0,0028
0,0029
1/T
Figure 2 Relation of the logarithm of ethylbenzoate and 1-heptanol on the reciprocal of the
absolute temperature.
log k n, = A + B. n
(8)
log k`
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
"n" = 11,63
4
4
10
12
14
16
18
number of C atoms
Figure 3 Logarithm of the retention (capacity) factor, k`, of the homologues series of the nalkanes as function of the number of carbon atoms
For each analyte with a certain capacity factor a pair of n-alkanes exists, between that the
analyte is eluted in the chromatogram. This analyte is considered as a fictive n-alkane with a
hypothetical number of C-atoms, in the example in Figure 3 with 11.63 C-atoms. This number
(and the number of C-atoms of the n-alkanes as well), multiplied by 100, is the retention
index. The analyte in the example given consequently has the retention index 1163. It is
obvious that n-alkanes have always retention indices with full hundreds, n-hexane e.g. 600, nundecane 1100, n-eicosane 2000, etc.
Obviously the retention index of analyte i is normally determined with higher
accuracy than it would be possible by graphical interpolation. For this reason the following
equation is used that can be derived simply from Figure 3 by comparison of similar triangles:
I Ri = 100 z
log k i, log k n,
+ 100n
log k n, + z log k n,
(9)
t RiN = t Ri t R 0
(10)
leads to an expression convenient for measurement and determination of the retention index
log
I Ri = 100 z
log
t RiN
N
t Rn
t RN( n + z )
+ 100n
(11)
N
t Rn
Here (n+z) and n are the numbers of C-atoms of the n-alkanes eluting after and before the
analyte. Usually, but not necessarily, z is 1. If e.g. due to economic reasons only the (cheaper)
even-numbered higher n-alkanes are used (e.g. C26 and C28), z is 2 in that case.
It is the advantage of the retention index that it is independent of certain, often varying
experimental parameters:
It depends on:
It is therefore a very well suited number for the characterization of an analyte on a certain
stationary phase. Retention indices are used for identification of an analyte by comparison of
the value of the index with either that found in tables, or determined previously with the help
of reference compounds. Retention indices of an unknown compound on different stationary
phases allow further conclusions about the polarity of the analyte.
Table 1 Retention indices and IR values of differently polar C8 compounds on apolar
polydimethyl siloxane (OV1) and polar polyethylenglycol (PEG) as stationary phase
Compound
IR (OV1)
IR (PEG)
IR =IRpolar IRunpolar
n-octane
800
800
n-dibutylether
864
966
102
n-hexylacetate
963
1101
138
n-octanon-2
957
1295
338
n-octanol-1
1038
1545
507
For this purpose the indices are determined at two columns with different polarity, e.g. with
methylsiloxane and polyethylenglycol as stationary liquids. Obviously n-alkanes have always
a IR -value of zero. The more polar the functional group is, the larger is the IR value.
IR value values of selected reference compounds are used to describe the polarity of
stationary phases as well (see concept of the Rohrschneider / McReynolds index, chapter
2.3.2.).
Conclusion for the use of retention indices:
Retention indices at one phase
IR =IRpolar IRunpolar
zero for n-alkane
1.2
Dispersion in capillary GC
Hex,m that stemming from the kinetics of mass exchange from the mobile phase to the
interface between mobile and stationary phase
Hex,s that from the kinetics of mass exchange from the stationary phase.
Consequently the total plate height is the sum of the four contributions:
H = H diff + H conv + H ex ,m + H ex ,s
(12)
(ad Hdiff )
The contribution of longitudinal diffusion, that in direction of zone migration, is caused by the
concentration gradient occurring between the sample and its surrounding in this direction.
According to the Einstein equation the resulting peak variance in the space domain is given by
(13)
z2 = 2 Dmi t
Broadening of the peak with time according to eq. 13 is shown in Figure 4.
The equivalent expression for the relation between plate height and variance is
(14)
z2 = Hz
1,2
concentration
1,0
function
t0
lim z = 0
t1
0,8
concentration
10 0
1 50
200
0,6
t2
0,4
0,2
t3
0,0
Figure 4 Development of peak broadening with increasing time due to diffusion. The
concentration zone was infinitely narrow at time 0 ( - or Dirac function)
This contribution is as more pronounced as larger the diffusion coefficient, Dm,i , of the
analyte in the mobile phase is, and as longer the time is available for diffusion. Consequently,
this increment increases with decreasing velocity of the mobile phase; it is proportional to 1/v.
It follows that the plate height contribution due to longitudinal diffusion is
H diff =
2 Dm,i
(15)
It should be mentioned that longitudinal diffusion in the stationary phase does not
significantly contribute to peak broadening, because the diffusion coefficients in the
stationary phase are 5 to 6 orders of magnitude smaller than those in the gas phase.
(ad Hconv )
The radial velocity profile of the mobile phase flowing through the column introduces an
effect to peak broadening due to convective mixing. In case of an open tube (as it is in
capillary GC) the flow profile can be analytically described in a simple way, in contrast to
packed beds. It has a parabolic shape with zero velocity at the capillary wall, and maximum
velocity at the centre of the tube with radius rC. For a non-retained component the
contribution to the plate height is described by the so-called Taylor-dispersion
H conv =
rc2
v
24 Dm ,i
(16)
radius, r
v ma x
30 00 0
25 00 0
2000 0
15 000
10 00 0
5 00 0
-5 000
velocity
- 10 00 0
Figure 5 Profile of the velocity, v, of the mobile phase in an open tube as function of radius, r
The resulting dispersion due to the parabolic flow profile and the radial diffusion would give
the following peak for a non-retained component
2 ,4
2 ,2
2 ,0
concen tration
1 ,8
1 ,6
1 ,4
1 ,2
parabolic
1 ,0
flow profile
0 ,8
0 ,6
flo w profile
0 ,4
ra dial diffusion
0 ,2
0 ,0
-0,2
20
10
-10
-20
Figure 6 Peak profile resulting from parabolic flow and radial diffusion
(ad Hex,m )
Both mass exchange terms have their origin in the finite rate of mass transport from the inner
part of the mobile or stationary phase, respectively, to the interface between these two phases.
Roughly it can be said that at the front of the peak in the mobile phase a higher concentration
exists than the equilibrium concentration. At the rear side the opposite situation occurs. From
these kinetic reasons peak dispersion occurs, which increases with increasing velocity of the
mobile phase. The effect in the mobile phase is connected to the flow situation. Therefore the
contribution of the finite mass transfer in the mobile phase is combined with that stemming
from the flow profile, which enlarges eq. 16. The combination of both effects leads to
Hconv + ex ,m =
(1 + 6k i, + 11k i,2 )
rc2
(1 + k i, ) 2
24 Dm,i
(17)
(ad Hex,s )
The term which stems from the finite kinetics of mass transport in the stationary phase is
given by
H ex ,s
d 2f
k i,
2
=
v
3 (1 + k i, ) 2 Ds,i
(18)
10
where df is the thickness of the stationary phase layer, and Ds,i is the diffusion coefficient in
the stationary phase.
H =
2 Dm,i
(1 + 6k i, + 11k i,2 )
rc2
(1 + k i, ) 2
24 Dm,i
v+
d 2f
k i,
2
v
3 (1 + k i, ) 2 Ds,i
(19)
This equation shows the dependence of the particular increments, and thus the total plate
height, as a function of the velocity of the mobile phase, apparently one of the most important
experimental variables to influence peak dispersion. Eq. 19 can be rewritten in a simplified
form as
H=
B
B
+ (Cm + C s ). v = + Cv
v
v
(20)
1,0
0,8
0,6
0,4
C.v
0,2
0,0
B/v
0
20
40
60
80
100
Figure 7 Plot of the plate height as a function of the mobile phase velocity (Golay equation).
The depiction of the plate height in relation to the mobile phase velocity is given in Figure 7.
It results in the summation of the hyperbolic B-term of eq. 15, that depends on 1/v, with the
C-term, which increases linearly with v. From Figure 7 it can be seen that a singular velocity
exists where the plate height exhibits a minimum value. Here peak dispersion is smallest. If
minimum dispersion (highest efficiency) is necessary for sufficient separation, this particular
velocity has to be selected. On the left-hand side of the H vs. v curve the plate height steeply
11
increases due to pronounced diffusion and the time of analysis increases as well. Insofar there
is no cause to select such velocities in practice. On the right hand side of the minimum, in
contrast, the plate height increases considerably slowly, and approaches the C-term
asymptotically at high velocity. In this range the working conditions are selected favourably
when the separation is large enough due to sufficient selectivity. In this case the time of
analysis, which is often an important analysis parameter, will be reduced with not too high
loss in efficiency.
1.2.1.1 Gas as compressible fluidum
It was pointed out that in GC there is an average linear velocity, <v>, which differs from the
local velocity, v, at a certain position at the longitudinal coordinate of the column due to the
compressibility of the gaseous mobile phase. The particular velocity depends on the pressure
drop across the column.
p0
(21)
where p and p0 are the pressures at the top and the end of the capillary.
Consequently the minimum plate height is observable only in a small part of the
separation capillary, where the particular mobile phase velocity is optimal. All other velocities
12
deviate in principle from this value for minimum plate height. However, under usual
conditions in capillary GC (for columns not too narrow and long) p does not exceed p0 by
more than 1.5 fold. In this case the difference between the average linear velocity (which is
measured by <v> = L/tR0) and the actual velocity at any section inside the capillary is
negligible, and the plate height does not change significantly across the capillary. For this
reason the variation of the velocity due to the compressibility of the gaseous mobile phase
normally is not a matter for consideration.
10
8
,2
, 2
12
6
4
2
0
0
10
Figure 9 Dependence of the second term of the Golay equation (eq. 19) on the capacity
factor.
This term reaches values between 1 (for k` of zero; here peak broadening is given by Taylor
dispersion) and approximately 11 at large values for k`. This means that for otherwise equal
experimental conditions the plate height of the peaks within one chromatogram can vary by as
much as one order of magnitude.
If the stationary phase of the capillary column has not such a thin film, the Cs-term
may play a role as well. For such cases the dependence of this term on the k` of the analytes is
shown in Figure 10.
13
0,30
k`/(1+k`)
0,25
0,20
0,15
0,10
0,05
0,00
0
10
k`
N=
L
H
(22)
The plate number of the particular components of a sample can simply be calculated from
their retention time, and the corresponding standard deviation (or the half peak width w), all
parameters taken in the time domain, and in the same units by
2
t R ,i
t
= R ,i * 5.54
N i =
w
t ,i
t ,i
(23)
14
A gas chromatograph consists of several parts, which are described in the following in more
detail (cf. e.g. refs.
1-13
They are schematically shown in Figure 11. Roughly, a chromatograph is composed from the
carrier gas supply, the sample inlet, the column, positioned in a column oven, the detector(s)
and a device for data collection, acquisition and processing.
Carrier
Gas
Supply
Sample
Inlet
Column Oven
Detector
Data
Collect.
Acquis.
Process.
2.1
Carrier gas
As mobile phase an inert gas is used, which is delivered by a gas generator, or a gas cylinder.
The most common carrier gases are H2, N2, He. They must be of very high purity, because
traces of water or oxygen may decompose the stationary phase, which leads to column
bleeding and finally destruction of the column. Therefore special devices for gas purification
are installed often prior to the sample inlet.
The choice of the carrier gas depends on several demands, e.g. the appropriate
operation of the detector (for the combination of GC with MS e.g., He is needed), on safety
reasons (H2 is explosive), or on the price (N2 is the cheapest gas), but also on demands on
separation efficiency and speed. Due to its lowest viscosity of all gases, H2 e.g. allows to
operate the column with the highest mobile phase velocity - and therefore lowest analysis
time - at comparable efficiency (see below).
Summary of the demands on the carrier gas:
Chemically inert
High purity (water, oxygen)
15
Detector compatibility
Economic / Safety reasons
Efficiency / Speed
Concerning efficiency and speed depending on the kind of carrier gas we ask for the condition
of plate height minimum. This is
dH
=0
du
(24)
rc
(25)
It can be seen that this plate height is independent on the kind of mobile phase (see Figure
12). It is depending on the radius of the capillary only. This plate height is reached at the
mobile phase velocity
u min = B C
(26)
7 Dmi rc
The velocity where minimum plate height is reached depends on the gas used as mobile
phase, because the diffusion coefficient is related to the gas viscosity. Therefore hydrogen as
mobile phase reaches minimum plate height at higher mobile phase velocity than e.g.
nitrogen. Faster analyses can be achieved therefore.
10
plate height, H
H2
4
N2
0
0
10
15
20
Figure 12 Peak height vs. mobile phase velocity for hydrogen and nitrogen as carrier gases
16
2.2
Sample inlet
In GC the sample is normally brought into the separation system in liquid solution (sampling
techniques for vapours, e.g. head space or adsorption / thermodesorption injection, or for solid
samples, e.g. pyrolysis injection, are not discussed here). The sample is dissolved in an
organic solvent, which is normally injected into the carrier gas flow by the aid of a syringe or
a valve. Indeed the quantitative and non-discriminating introduction of the sample into the
column is the most critical part of all experimental steps in capillary gas chromatography.
Although GC is a well-developed and established method, sample introduction in capillary
GC is still a non-trivial task due to practical limitation. This results in a number of different
injector types, which should be selected in practice according to the nature of the sample and
the demands in accuracy and reproducibility of the analysis.
In contrast to capillary GC, sample introduction in packed column GC is not a
problem. This is due to the fact that in packed bed GC the column volume is large, and the
phase ratio is considerably large, too. Here the sample, dissolved in a volatile organic solvent,
is simply injected into a heated and thermostatted injector cell, where it is evaporated, and the
vapour is transported by the carrier gas into the column. Note that 1 l of liquid sample
delivers several hundred L vapour after evaporation. It is clear that such a large volume
would overflow the entire column in case of a capillary column. As an example: a capillary
with 0.2 mm I.D. and 25 m length has a total volume of less than 800 L. It is obvious that it
is not possible to introduce the entire evaporated sample directly into the column in capillary
GC. Therefore mainly two possibilities are proposed to overcome this problem in practise:
(i)
In case of the evaporating injectors the sample is inserted by a syringe into the
heated injector and evaporated. Either only a part of the evaporated sample is allowed
to enter the capillary this is realised with the split injector; or the main part of the
solvent (and a small part of the sample as well) is separated in the injector from the
sample components. In this splitless mode the sample components normally are
recondensed at the top of the column either by cold trapping or by solvent
trapping.
(ii)
the total liquid volume is brought into the cold injector by the aid of a syringe, and
solely the solvent is evaporated carefully first and usually recondensed either at the top
of the column, or in the retention gap. Due to careful selection of the temperature
conditions the sample remains at the top of the separation system. Then the sample is
evaporated, too, and introduced into the separation capillary.
17
18
A)
B)
10
with permission).
(B) Schematic drawing of an on-column injector. 1 Carrier gas inlet, 2 Sealing; 3 Capillary
column, 4 Cooling gas (from ref.
14
with permission).
The recondensation of the solvent at the top of the capillary can be critical by damaging the
stationary phase (because it might be partially dissolved by the condensed liquid), and
therefore only columns with chemically bonded phases should be used. Another limitation is
the necessary wettability of the stationary phase by the condensed solvent, otherwise droplets
are formed rather than a liquid layer. These problems may be overcome by the use of an
empty (widebore) capillary without stationary phase, mounted between injector and
separation column. In this capillary indeed both refocusing processes solvent trapping and
cold trapping as described above can be established. This construction is named retention
gap, and is used in the splitless mode and, more common, with the on-column injection
technique.
19
SPLIT INJECTOR
Advantage
Injected zone narrow
Small sample aliquot avoids overloading
Limitations
Mass discrimination of sample components
(different range of volatility)
Systematic errors for quantitative analysis
In trace analysis: only part of analytes to detector
SLITLESS INJECTOR
Advantage
Avoids large tailing of solvent peak
Allows transfer of main part of sample
components into detector
Trace analysis: favourable technique for
insertion of diluted samples
Limitations
Recondensation of solvent at top of capillary:
possible damaging stationary phase
Only columns with chemically bonded phases
Necessary wettability of stationary phase for
condensed solvent (droplets)
20
The capillary for the retention gap is mounted in the column oven, whose temperature must be
adjusted to the boiling point of the solvent. If the temperature is below the boiling point,
solvent trapping takes place. If it is selected slightly above the boiling point, cold trapping of
the sample components occurs. In both cases the chromatogram must be developed with an
adequate temperature program of the column, which is an essential step when using this
injector type.
Advantage of on-column injector:
2.3
Columns
In gas chromatography packed bed columns and capillary column are used. Packed columns
are tubes made of glass or metal with 2-4mm I.D. and 1-6 m length. They are filled with
porous particles, which act as support of the stationary liquid phase, which is coated on the
porous material.
Capillary columns are open tubes with 0.1 to 0.5 mm I.D. and 5 to 100 m lengths.
Most common dimension, however, are 0.3 mm I.D. and 25 m length. Originally the
capillaries were made from metal or glass; in the last decade fused silica replaced all other
materials. Fused silica has the advantage of a very inactive inner surface, which avoids
adsorptive interactions between analytes (especially when they are polar) and adsorption
centres, leading otherwise to tailing peaks or even loss of material due to irreversible
adsorption (see note below on Grob`s test mixture). It has the further advantage of extremely
high mechanical stability that reduces breakage of the columns.
The stationary phase is coated as a thin layer (with 0.1 to 5 m film thickness) onto
the inner wall of the open tube. Normally this phase is a liquid. Due to modern column
technology, which enables cross-linking of the polymer molecules of the liquid, and even
attachment of the phase at the silica surface due to chemical bonding, the initially liquid phase
might behave as large, single, polymeric molecule. Interestingly these cross-linked phases
thermodynamically behave very similar to the initial liquid.
21
PACKED COLUMN
CAPILLARY COLUMN
Stationary phase
Packing
It should be mentioned that a mixture of solutes, which allow conclusions about specific
adsorptive sites, could test the adsorptivity of columns. The most common is the so-called
Grob test mixture, which consists of octan-2-on, octanol-1, 2,6-dimethyl phenol, 2,4-dimethyl
anilin, naphthalin, tridecan and tetradecan.
2.3.1
Stationary phases
Stationary phases must cover a wide range of polarity as indicated in the following Table.
Apolar phase
vapour pressure
Polar phase
intermolecular forces
dispersion
polarisation
dipole-dipole
hydrogen bonding
Besides being the source for separation selectivity in GC, the demand on stationary phases is
thermal stability. It is clear that polymeric compounds best fulfil the latter restrictions.
Especially siloxane polymers have a high thermal stability, caused by the Si-O backbone of
the silicon chain. The type of the substituents attached at this chain implements selectivity.
CH3 groups as substituents give the lowest polarity, resulting in a polymer that is nearly as
22
A)
Si
Si
Si R1
H3C CH R1 R2
R2
3
CH3
H3C
B)
Si
R1,
CH3,
R2 =
CH3
CH3
Or R1, R2=
or
C N
B) Polyethyleneglycol
b) Silarylen polymer
23
(27)
To characterise the stationary phase polarity in a more general manner, the concept uses 5
special solutes, which are considered to represent typical chemical interactions. For each of
them, the constants x, y, z, u and s are defined accordingly; they are shown in Table 2.
24
The polarity of the stationary phase is expressed by the sum of the constants, the
Rohrschneider / McReynolds index,
= x+ y+ z+u+ s
(28)
Examples for stationary phases most common in practice are given in Table 3. If two phases
do not differ in their indices by more than about 200, their polarity can be considered as
nearly equal. In general it is not meaningful to use two such phases. This does not mean,
however, that probably their selectivities concerning one special type of interaction are
negligible.
Rohrschneider/
McReynolds
constant
Type of interactions
Typical for
Dipole
-complex
H-bond
benzene
donor
butanol-1
donor
2-pentanon
acceptor
1-nitropropane
pyridine
u
s
acceptor
donor
olefines, aromatic
compounds
alcohols, phenols, acids,
amides
aldehydes, ketones,
esters, ethers
nitro-, nitrilo compounds
Amines, aromatics
Cyanopropylphenyl
(cpph) dimethy silicon
Composition
100 % methyl
5 % phenyl
50 % phenyl
75 % phenyl
6 % cpph
50 % cpph
100 % cpph
PEG 20 M
x
0
17
32
119
178
50
y
0
57
72
158
204
115
z
0
45
65
162
208
107
u
0
67
98
243
305
164
s
0
43
67
202
208
103
Index
0
229
334
884
1103
539
227
523
322
373
757
536
336
659
368
489
942
572
398
801
510
1823
3682
2308
25
2.4
Column oven
The column oven has the function to adjust the column temperature to an accurate and
reproducible value. It is prerequisite in practice to establish these temperature conditions for
the column over the entire length, not only where the temperature sensor is located in the
oven. The column oven should not only meet these demands in the isocratic manner; it must
also enable the application of appropriate gradients, either a single linear or ballistic, or
multiple gradients by temperature programming. It should be noted that after such
programming a very important but often underestimated aspect is the establishment of the
exact initial column temperature after cooling. The inappropriate re-establishment often is the
source of systematic measuring errors.
2.5
Special Detectors
For GC a number of detectors have been developed. For trace analysis, however, not all of
them have increased importance. Most important detectors in this area are (beside the mass
spectrometer)
26
Reaction of the radicals with the excited molecules leads to the formation of positively
charged ions and electrons, e.g. according to
(29)
C + OH = CHO + + e
Consequently the positively charged molecular ions (e.g. CHO+) and the electrons formed
increase the current when organic molecules are entering the detector flame, and the analytes
are detected in this way (note that there is not full combustion to CO2).
15
with permission).
The more CH-groups a molecule contains, the larger is the detector response.
Heteroatoms in the molecule lead to a smaller response. Molecules without CH-groups do not
deliver a signal, except due to overloading effects of the detector. The FID is therefore not
universal, as e.g. water, CO2, NOx , CS2, CCl4, etc. are not or only poorly detected. The same
is the case for the lower alcohols or substances with many heteroatoms.
Beside the analyte properties, the detector response is also dependent on its geometry,
and on the flow rate of the burning gases. Favourable flow rates for H2 are in the range of 2530 mL/min, those for the air are by a factor of 10 higher. Especially the H2 flow must be
selected carefully, because its optimal range is narrow (see Figure 16). The use of so-called
make-up gas is normally advisable in capillary GC for the improvement of the detector
response. It is also favourable to avoid loss in separation efficiency due to extra-column
27
effects caused by the dead volume of the detector. Because the FID is mass flow dependent,
the make-up gas does not negatively influence the detector sensitivity.
Figure 17 Dependence of the sensitivity of the FID on the flow rates of H2 and N2,
respectively. N2 is added as make-up gas (from ref.
14
with permission).
ElectronAffinity [eV]
0.72
1.2
2.34
3
3.9
X
J
Br
Cl
F
28
Roughly, the detector principle is based on the property of analytes, AX, containing
such atoms or groups, X, to attract electrons according to
(30)
AX + e = AX + energy
63
electrons exhibit a too high energy (and therefore too high speed) to be captured from the
affine groups in the analytes. They interact first with carrier gas, which is present in very large
excess compared to the trace analytes; thus the chance for interaction with the -particles is
much greater for the former than for the latter molecules. As carrier gases (cg) those with
large mass are used, e.g. N2 or Ar (mixed with 5% CH4). According to the reaction scheme
given in eq. 31 the -particles generate thermal, secondary electrons by interaction with the
carrier gas molecules (these electrons have much lower, namely only thermal energy).
(31)
+
(therm )
cg cg + e
The current produced from these low energy electrons in the detector cell is measured and
amplified. As long as there is no analyte with electron affine groups in the carrier gas, the
background current (the blank) with about 10-8 A is delivered. When analytes with e.g.
halogen substitution are eluted from the column and enter the detector, electrons from the
basic current are captured according to eq. 30, and the current is decreased, detecting the
analytes in this way. In principle the number of charged particles is not changed in this
reaction, because instead of an electron a negatively charged sample ion is generated.
However, the velocity of these molecular ions (10 cm/s) is many orders of magnitude smaller
than that of the electrons (105 cm/s). For this reason the ions do not reach the collector
electrode; they recombine faster with positively charged carrier gas molecules under
formation of the neutral molecules according to
AX + cg + = AX + cg
(32)
However, under such conditions no signal would be obtained. For favourable measuring
conditions a pulsed voltage is applied, as indicated in Figure 18.
For a closer insight into the signal generation of the ECD we have to differentiate two
processes: the one is the simple addition of an electron, as expressed by eq. 30. The more
common process, on the other hand, includes a dissociative reaction of the product formed
after electron addition according to
AX + e = A + X
(33)
29
Figure 18 Schematic drawing of the ECD with pulsed polarisation voltage. b pulse width, e.g.
3s; D pulse distance, e.g. 10-200 s; h pulse height, e.g. 50 V (from ref.
15
with permission).
Therefore not only the electron affinity, but also the binding energy between the carbon atom
and the electron affine atom or group decides over the extent of reaction. This fact explains
the result of the relative sensitivity, rel. Si, of different compounds as given in the following
Table.
Rel. Si
Fluorobenzene
Chlorobenzene
Bromobenzene
Iodobenzene
1
100
600
37 000
C-F
C-Cl
C-Br
C-I
538
391
281
210
Electron
Affinity [eV]
F 4.1
Cl 3.78
Br 3.52
I 3.12
30
(34)
The alkali cation A+ formed is collected at the negatively charged pearl, whereas the electron
is migrating to the collector electrode. In this way the background current of the detector is
formed in the P mode.
Phosphorus containing molecules, when present, are transformed to phosphorus oxide
radicals, R, in the flame of the detector. These radicals react in a double collision (which is
more probable than a triple collision with H and OH) with excited A*
(35)
R + A = R + A+
e.g.
O = P = O + A = [O = P = O ] + A+
(36)
(37)
e.g.
31
[O = P = O ]
(38)
+ OH = HPO3 + e
This reaction delivers the electron for the signal current specific for P-containing analytes.
Figure 19 Schematic presentation of the thermionic detector in the P mode (from ref.
15
with
permission).
Note that the flame jet is grounded, and has therefore a positive potential. For this reason the
electrons formed by reaction of CH- containing molecules due to the same processes as with
the FID are not interfering the detector signal, because they are conducted to ground, and do
not reach the collector anode.
2.5.3.2 NP mode
The N analogous oxides formed from N-containing molecules would decompose rapidly in
the flame of the detector, and would therefore not react with alkali. For this reason the
detector is run in the NP mode under reducing conditions, leading to CN radicals instead.
These conditions are established by decreasing the flow rates of hydrogen to about 1-3
mL/min, and that of air to less than 100 mL/min. The flame goes out then, but the remaining
free hydrogen is ignited at the electrically heated pearl. It forms a kind of plasma around the
pearl, where a CN radical formed adds an electron taken from excited A*, forming a cyanide
ion and alkali cation (see P-mode, eq. 35)
CN + A = CN + A+
(39)
32
The CN anion formed finally reacts either with H or OH radicals to HCN or HCNO,
respectively.
Figure 20 Schematic representation of the thermionic detector in the NP mode (from ref.
15
with permission).
This reaction delivers the electron for the signal current analogous to eq. 37. As the
formation of CN radicals is essential, such a structure must be present initially in the analytes
to enable detection. Therefore e.g. organic nitro compounds are detectable, but not nitrogen
oxides, or nitrate esters.
In the following table some data for the performance of the detector in both modes are
given.
Typical performance data for the NPD in P- and NP- mode, respectively.
Parameter
P mode
NP mode
Sensitivity
1 C/g P
5 C/g P
0.5 C/g N
Limit of detection
5.10-14 g P/s
10-14 g P/s
10-13 g N/s
106
105
104
Linearity
105
105
105
33
FURTHER READINGS
(1)
(2)
Jennings,
W.
G.;
Mittlefehldt,
E.;
Stremple,
P.
Analytical
Gas
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
34