You are on page 1of 5

1255

Environment & Ecology 31 (3) : 12551259, JulySeptember 2013


Website: environmentandecology.com
ISSN 0970-0420

Length-Weight Relationship and Condition Factor of


Puntius sophore (Hamilton, 1822) Collected from
Kolkata and Sub Urban Fish Markets
Monalisa Pal, B. K. Mahapatra,
Basudev Mondal

Received 1 April 2013;

Accepted 16 May 2013;

Published online 15 July 2013

Abstract Puntius sophore is an important species


due to its high nutritive status, delicacy and market
demand both in fresh and dried conditions. Lengthweight relationships are important in fisheries science,
notably to raise length-frequency samples to total
catch, or to estimate biomass from underwater length
observations. It is reported that P. sophore is declining rapidly due to heavy fishing pressure from the
Indian waters, it is categorized as lower risk near threatened. In the present study length-weight relationship
and condition factor of P. sophore (Hamilton) were
estimated from 483 individuals collected from Kolkata
and sub-urban fish markets during February 2012 to
February 2013 to assess the two most biological parameters of the species. The total length ranged from
4.90 to 11.10 cm and the total body weight ranged
from 1.37 to 21.11 g. The scatter diagram showed the
linear relationship in between the log length and log
weight of the fish. The relationship of logarithm values of length and weight was found positive and

M. Pal*, B. K. Mahapatra
Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Sector-V, Salt Lake
City, Kolkata 700091, India
B. Mondal
Aquaculture Management and Technology, Vidyasagar University, Midnapore, India
e-mail: monalisapal08@gmail.com
*Correspondence

highly significant justifying a strong relationship between L-W of P. sophore (r=0.934). The functional
form of relationship between L-W of the species is
established as Log W= 2.130 + 3.242 Log L. The
fitted equation is a good fit as can seen from the coefficient of determination value (R2 = 0.871). The mean
condition factor of the fish was found to 1.10 indicating good condition of the fish.
Keywords Sophore barb, Length-weight relationship, Puntius, Correlation, Condition factor.

Introduction
Length weight relationship as well as the condition
factors is useful parameters for assessing the wellbeing of the individuals and for determining possible
differences among different stocks of the same species (1). It helps for estimating the weight from the
known length and vice-versa, duration of gonadal
maturation, increase or decrease in feeding activity,
possibly due to modifications in food resources (2).
In fisheries science, the condition factor is used to
compare the condition, fatness or well being of
fish. It is based on the hypothesis that heavier fish of
a particular length are in a better physiological condition. Condition factor is also a useful index for monitoring of feeding intensity, age, and growth rates in
fish. It is strongly influenced by both biotic and abiotic environmental conditions and can be used as an
index to assess the status of the aquatic ecosystem

1256

in which fish live. The pool barb, Puntius sophore (3)


belongs to the family Cyprinidae, locally called jatpunti
is widely distributed in freshwaters of India,
Bangladesh, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan the waters of
South Asia tropical climate ranging 390 N-880 N (4).
This shoaling fish is an important species due to its
high nutritive status, delicacy and market demand
both in fresh and dried conditions (4,5). As P. sophore
inhabits rivers, streams, ponds, beels, floodplains,
baors, haors in plains and sub-montane regions dominantly (5, 6) it is an important target species for small
scale fishers (7). This commercially important small
indigenous fish species (SIS) has both ornamental
(8) and food value (7). However, P. sophore is declining rapidly due to heavy fishing pressure, and in
recent studies from the Indian waters, it is categorized as lower risk near threatened (911). Proper
management of the species can play vital role in the
national economy of the country. In view of the importance of length-weight relationship, condition factor and other biological factor of this fish species,
considerable attention has been paid by many workers (4, 1217) to this aspect of fishery biology. Therefore, keeping in view of the importance of this species, in the present study the length weight relationship and condition factor of Puntius sophore was
studied to assess the biology of the species.

est centimeter from the tip of the snout to the tip of


the caudal fin. The weights were taken to one tenth of
a gram. The length-weight data were analyzed according to the method given by Le Cren (18). In the present
study, the equation of the parabolic relationship of
the form W=aLb was used where W represents weight
of the fish in gram. L being the total length in centimeter and a the constant and b an exponent to which
L can be raised. The equation expressed in logarithmic form becomes: Log W = Log a + b Log L. The
equation was calculated for combined sample and a
linear relationship between the logarithm length and
logarithm weight was found from the examination of
scatter diagram. The coefficient of correlation was
calculated from the formula given by (19). The regression line was calculated and drawn from the following equation (19). The calculations were based on log
values length and weight of the fish species. To test
the regression coefficient, t test was done according to the method given by (20). All calculations are
done using SPSS and MS Excel.
Condition index
The following formula was used to express the condition factor: K=W/Lb. Where W denotes the observed weight; L = total length and b = regression
coefficient.

Materials and Methods


Results and Discussion
Collection of the sample
Length-weight relationship
A total number of 483 specimens belonging to all
available size classes and both male and female were
taken into account to study of length-weight relationship. They were collected at random mostly
from Kolkata and sub-urban fish market (Behala,
Garia, Shaorafully fish market) during February-2012
to February-2013. All samples were frozen until processing.

In the present study the length weight data were anaTable 1. Descriptive statistics of P. sophore (combined group)
length-weight characteristics.

Computational formula for lengthweight relationship


The fishes were cleaned, blotted and air dried. The
measurements for length and weight were taken using an accurate scale and an electrical balance respectively. The total length was recorded to the near-

Sta
tistic

Std.
error

Std.
deviation
Statistic

483 4.90 11.10

6.7706

0.03958

0.86981

483 1.37 21.11

3.9275

0.08873

1.95009

MiniN
mum
Sta- Statis- tistic
tic
Length
(cm)
Weight
(g)

Maximum
Statistic

Mean

1257

Table 2. Model summary, a. Predictors : (Constant), C


Logl.

Model

R
square

Adjusted
R
square

0.934 a

0.871

0.871

Std.
error
of the
estimate
0.06684

lyzed on the combined group of P. sophore fish


collected throughout the year.
Descriptive statistics
The descriptive statistics of combined group of length
weight data is presented in Table 1. It appeared that
the length of the combined groups of P. sophore
fishes ranges from the 4.90 to 11.10 cm and weight
ranges from 1.37 to 21.11 g. The observed mean length
+ standard errors is (6.7706 cm 0.03958) and the
mean weight is observed (3.93 g 08873) respectively.
Further in case of length, the standard deviation is
0.86981 and in case of weight, the standard deviation
is 1.95009. The present study recorded the maximum
size of the P. sophore was 11.1 cm TL, which was
lower than the maximum record value of 18.00 cm TL
in India (8). The maximum TL for P. sophore were recorded by various workers such as 9.02 cm (17), 10.20
cm (12), 9.9 cm (13), and 12.4 cm (7). However, habitat
wise it varied such as TL max 6 cm at Ruili, Yunnan
(China), 6.3 cm at Tamilnadu (India) and 13 cm at the
Krishna river (India) (21). In the present study the
female was found significantly larger than male P.
sophore fish which supports the observation of (13).
In addition, the maximum weight of P. sophore observed in this study was 21.11 g which was lower
Table 3. ANOVAb. a. Predictors: (Constant), C LogL, b.
Dependent Variable: C LogW.
Sum
of
Mo- squdel
ares
1

Regression
Residual
Total

df

Mean
square

14.567

2.149
16.717

481 0.004
482

Fig. 1. Length-weight relationship of P. sophore (logarithmic scale).

than the maximum recorded value of 70.0 g in


Maharastra, India (22). The maximum weight of the P.
sophore fish were recorded by various workers were
13.20 g (17), 17 g (23) and 14.25 g (13).
Scatter diagram
The length weight data of Puntius sophore was
collected and converted into logarithm form to estimate the length weight relationship and make it linear
form for estimation of regression parameters. The
length weight data was presented in the form of scatter diagram. From the scatter diagram we see that the
relationship is linear (Fig. 1).
Calculation of correlation
coefficient (r)
Calculation of coefficient of correlation along with R
square, adjusted R square and standard error of the
estimate are presented in Table 2. From Table 2 it
appears that the values of coefficient of correlation
r is 0.934 and test shows a highly significant value.
This justifies the fact that there is a strong significant
Table 4. Testing of constant and regression coefficienta. a.
Dependent Variable: CLogW.

Sig.
Model

14.567 3.260E3

Unstandardized
coefficients
Std.
B
error

Standardized
coefficients
Beta

Sig

0.000 a
(Constant)
Log L.

- 2.130
3.242

0.047
0.057

0.934

- 45.259
57.099

0.000
0.000

1258

relationship between length and weight.

and market arrival. The result of the study will be


useful for future researchers and policy planners.

Calculation of regression coefficient


(b) and testing for significance
References

SPSS output for estimation and testing the significance of regression (ANOVA) is presented in Table 3.
Thereafter, the significant of calculated regression is
tested through ANOVA which is represented in Table
4, we found that this regression co-efficient (b) was
highly significant. The functional form of relationship between length and weight was calculated based
on formula W = aLb (log W = log a + b logL). In this
case a was found to be 2.130 and b was 3.242 (Table
4). Further b was found to be highly significant as
evidenced from t test presented in that table no-4.
Here the calculated value of t is found to be 57.099
which is much higher from the tabulated value of t
justifying that the regression co-efficient calculated
based on L-W data of P. sophore is significant. Now
established between length-weight relationship based
on empherial data as

1.
2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.
Log W = 2.130 + 3.242 Log L

The coefficient of determination R2 is 0.871 that indicates a very good fit of model.

9.

10.

The correlation coefficient was found to be 0.934a


which was already presented in Table 2 showing a
high degree of correlation between the two parameters. The exponential value of 3.242 was tested
against 3 showed in Table 4 and was found to be
significantly different (t = 57.099) at 1% level. In the
present study the logarithm relationship between the
total length and weight of P. sophore directs towards
strong positive correlation (r2= 0.934 for LT-W) that
agreed with the report r2 = 0.93 (13), r2 > 0.945 (17). In
the present study the b value of P. sophore was
3.242 which was within the limits 2.53.5 reported by
(24) for most fishes. This indicates that the growth
was positively allometric. The mean values of condition factor were calculated as 1.10 for combined sex
group that indicated healthy condition of fish collected mostly from the nature which support the observation value of 1.07 (13). The fact suggest that
environment is congenial for growth of the species
but there may be habitat destruction for lower catch

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

King M (2007) Fisheries biology, assessment and management. 2nd edn. Blackwell Sci Publ, Oxford.
Bhattacharya P, Banik S (2012) Length weight relationship and condition factor of the pabo fish Ompokpabo (Hamilton, 1822) from Tripura, India: Ind
J Fish 59 : 141146.
Hamilton F (1822) An account of the fishes found
in the river Ganges and its branches. Fishes of Ganges.
Edinburgh & London, pp. 405.
Talwar PK, Jhingran AG (1991) Inland fishes of India
and adjacent countries. Oxford and IBH Publ Co Pvt
Ltd, India. 1 & 2 : 1158.
Samad MA, Galib SM, Flowra FA (2009) Fish drying
in Chalan Beel areas, Bangladesh J Sci Ind Res
44 : 461466.
Craig JF, Halls AS, Barr JJF, Bean CW (2004) The
Bangladesh floodplain fisheries. Fish Research 66 :
271286.
Rahman AKA (2005) Fresh fishes of Bangladesh.
2nd eds, Zool Soc of Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh,
pp. 364.
Froese R, Pauly D (eds). (2011) Fish base 2011.
World Wide Web electronic publication. Available at:
http://www.fishbase.org
Balasundaram C, Arumugam R, Murugan PB (2000)
Fish diversity of Kolli hills, Western Ghats, Salem
district, Tamil Nadu. Zoos Print J 16 : 403406.
Dua A, Parkash C (2009) Distribution and abundance
of fish populations in Harike wetland-A Ramsar site
in India. J Environm Biol 30 : 247251.
Sarkar UK, Gupta BK, Lakra WS (2010) Biodiversity,
ecohydrology, threat status and conservation priority
of the fresh water fishes of river Gomti, a tributary
of river Ganga (India). Environm entalist 30 : 317.
Hossain MY, Ahmed ZF, Leunda PM, Islam AKMR,
Jasmine S, Oscoz J, Miranda R, Ohtomi J (2006)
Length-weight and length-length relationships of
some small indigenous fish species from the Mathabhanga River, southwestern Bangladesh. J Applied Ichthyol 25 : 301303.
Tareque AMHB, Biswas B, Hossain MS, Rahman MM,
Rahman MM (2009) Some aspects of biology of
Puntius sophore (Hamilton) collected from the
Mouri river Khulna, Bangladesh. Bangladesh Res
Publ J 2 : 406422.
Bhuiyan AS, Parveen AS (1998). Fecundity of Puntius
sophore (Hamilton) (Cyprinidae : Cypriniformes). J
Bio-Sci 6 : 153154.
Srivastava R, Singh HR (2003). Length-weight relationship of Puntius sophore (Ham.) from Allahabad
region. Proc Nat Acad Sci India, 73B : 1318.
Phukon HK, Biswas SP (2012) Observation on
the Maturity index and fecundity of Puntius sophore

1259

17.

18.

19.

20.

(Ham-Buch) from Upper Assam. Asian J Exp, Biol


Sci 3 : 247250.
Rahman MM, Hossain MY, Jewel MAS, Rahman
MM, Jasmin S, Abdallah ME, Ohtomi J (2012) Population structure, length-weight and length-length
relationships, and condition and form-factors of the
Pool barb Puntius sophore (Hamilton, 1822) (Cyprinidae) from the Chalan Beel, North-Central Bangladesh. Sains Malaysiana 41 : 795802.
Le Cren ED (1951) The length-weight relationship
and seasonal cycle in gonad weight and condition in
the perch (Percafluviatilis). J Anim Ecol 20 : 201
219.
Spiegel MR (1972) Schaums outline of theory and
problems and statistics of SI units. Mc GrawHill Publ Co Ltd, New York pp. 359 .
Snedecor GW (1961) Statistical methods applied to
experiments in agriculture and biology. Allied Pacific

Pvt Ltd, Bom bay, pp. 534.


21. Fish Base (2006) List of population characteristics
for Puntius sophore. Retrieved on 10-10-2006
from www.fishbase.org
22. Archarya P, Iftekhar MB (2000) Freshwater ichthyofauna of Maharashtra State. In : Ponniah AG, Gopalakrishnan A (eds). Endemic fish diversity of Western
Ghats. NBFGR-NATP Publication. National Bureau
of Fish Genetic Resources, Lucknow, UP, India, pp.
136144.
23. Alam MM, Galib SM, Islam MM, Flowra FA, Hussain
MA (2012) Morphometric study of the wild population of pool barb, P. sophore (Hamilton, 1822)
in the river Padma, Rajshahi, Bangladesh, Trends in
Fisheries Research. Vol. 1 No. 2.
24. Froese R (2006) Cube law, condition factor and weight-length relationships: History, meta-analysis and
recommendations. J Applied Ichthyol 22 : 247251.