Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Health
VOLUNTARY
EUTHANASIA:
TOO HOT TO
HANDLE?
graham adams IS NORTH & SOUTH s chief subeditor.
getty
Professor Sean Davison was sentenced to five months home detention in Dunedin on charges
of assisting his mothers suicide after she had tried to starve herself to death.
mike white / north & south
a similar proposal.
Street cited to North & South the results
of a 2012 Horizon Research poll which
showed a huge majority in favour of her
bill, with 62.9 per cent approving it and
just 12.3 per cent opposed.
In October this year, Nationals Phil
Heatley an avowed moral conservative found to his surprise that 66 per
cent of 977 respondents he polled in his
electorate of Whangarei favoured some
form of assisted suicide.
Whats more, the courts reflecting
public sentiment often adopt a lenient
position when sentencing those who
help hasten the deaths of loved ones who
are dying. In a widely reported case in
late 2011, Sean Davison, a South Africabased microbiologist, was sentenced to
five months home detention in Dunedin
after he pleaded guilty to a charge of
inciting and procuring the attempted
suicide of his 85-year-old mother,
Patricia, in 2006. (He gave her crushed
morphine tablets in a glass of water, at
her request.)
In September 2012, Evans Mott was
discharged without conviction in the
High Court at Auckland after he assisted
Despite its long Catholic history, however, France also has a tradition of personal liberty and secularism, in which
church and state are clearly separated.
And, obviously, French politicians are
a lot braver than ours.
In New Zealand, our parliamentarians
have preferred to leave the question of
voluntary euthanasia to the lottery of a
members bill, which means any bill might
not be picked to go before Parliament for
weeks, months, years or never at all.
Brown says that although he was reluctant to continue pursuing the issue
after his bills defeat, he was persuaded
by the many people contacting him in
support to re-present it in 2004. But
when he retired from politics five years
NORTH & SOUTH | jANUARY 2014 | 65
Lake Kaniere.
In 2007, Pope Benedict XVI signed an apostolic exhortation at the Vatican in which he decreed celibacy remained obligatory
for priests. He also urged Catholic lawmakers to oppose laws favouring divorce, abortion and euthanasia.
ARTURO MARI / OSSERVATORE ROMANO/AFP/Getty Images
Dr John Pollock, an Auckland GP, wrote a paper in 2010 calling for the
legalisation of voluntary euthanasia. Suffering from terminal cancer, he died
peacefully at home with his family two months after this photo was taken.
Presspix / Paul Estcourt
suffering
is integral
to the
catholic
churchs
teachings
about
salvation.
Ending a Life
Is withdrawing the necessities of life simply euthanasia by another name?
Perhaps one
of the most
interesting
lessons comes
from Oregon,
where around
40 per cent of
those given
a lethal
prescription
dont use
it. the
reassurance
they can have
a painless
death is
sufficient.
the manner of their deaths. Adrian, a
local body politician, had terminal
stomach cancer. Handwritten suicide
notes were found, but it was unclear
whether they were parties in each others
deaths or just their own.
Some voluntary euthanasia advocates
now operate an underground movement
with advice on how to kill yourself as
painlessly as possible. But, as Dr Pollock
noted, anyone suspected of having a
hand in the suicide, including even providing materials such as helium and
plastic bags, risks being charged with
aiding a suicide even if they are not present at the time of death.
If the nation developed a well-regulated
and entirely voluntary euthanasia policy,