Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Content
1. Introduction
2. Brief History
3. Spiritual and Ritualistic Cannibalism
4. Survival Cannibalism
5. Criminal Cannibalism
5.1 Sexual Cannibalism
5.2 Aggression Cannibalism
5.3 Ritualistic and Epicurean Cannibalism
6. Psychological Perspectives
7. German Cannibal's Trial and how the Media Presented It
8. Teenage Killer Cannibal
9. Cannibalism in Popular Culture
10. Bibliography
1. Introduction
Cannibalism amongst modern humans and their ancestors has always been a taboo topic
which modern society finds to be both controversial and uncomfortable. By definition, a
cannibal is "a person or animal that eats any type of tissue of another individual of its own
kind". References to cannibal practices have been suggested all over the world in both
prehistoric and historic periods. Despite the controversy cannibalism invokes, it has always
been a topic of morbid interest and heated debate, with many ethnographic and
anthropological studies reporting instances of cannibalism.
2. Brief History
Except from Herbert Ward's "A Voice From the Congo" as found in Gary Hogg's
book, "Cannibalism and Human Sacrifice":
Do you people eat human bodies? I said one day, upon entering a native village, and
pointed to a quantity of meat, spitted upon long skewers, being smoke-dried over
numerous smouldering fires. Io; yo te? was the instant reply - Yes; don't you? And a
few minutes later the chieftain of the village came forward with an offering, which
consisted of large and generous portions of flesh, only too obviously of human origin.
He seemed genuinely disappointed when I refused.
Historically shrouded in mystery, myth, symbolism, fear and
speculation, cannibalism remains in most cultures one of the
ultimate taboos. According to William Aren's book "The ManEating Myth: Anthropology & Anthropophagy", the first
known account of cannibalism came following an expedition
to the West Indies, led by Christopher Columbus. Columbus
and his crew supposedly discovered that the Carib West Indies
tribe participated in a particularly gruesome practice of
ritualistically eating the flesh of other humans.
The explorers mispronounced the name of the tribe and
referred to them as Canibs, which was overtime changed to canibales, meaning thirsty and
cruel in Spanish. The English translation of the Spanish word became cannibalism, which is
3
integrative
dimension.
Upon
Throughout the world, anthropologists have discovered that cannibalistic tribes incorporate
many different forms of cannibalism. It is not uncommon for one particular group, culture or
tribe to practice a mixture of ritualistic endo and exo-cannibalism, as well as other forms such
as survival and epicurean/nutritional cannibalism (consumption of human flesh for the taste or
nutritional value).
The ancient Aztecs in Mexico were believed to have sacrificed and cannibalized thousands of
humans on an annual basis. The Aztecs were believed to have practiced exocannibalism, as
well as endocannibalism and survival cannibalism. Human sacrifice and cannibalism was
practiced in an effort to create a universal balance between of the world and the cosmos.
Aztecs believed that sacrificing humans, either from their own culture or from an outside
culture, would appease the gods and if they failed to do so, it would mark the destruction of
all humanity. Cannibalism was considered a holy act, which allowed men to obtain divine
powers through communication with their gods. Cannibalism was also practiced during times
of great famine.
Other cultures participated in endo-cannibalism and exo-cannibalism for similar reasons, such
as The North American Indians, known as the Iroquoian. They believed that sacrificing and
consuming the bodies of their enemies would satisfy their war god and lead to their spirit
being transferred and absorbed into their own bodies. The absorbed spirit was believed to
empower the cannibal with the attributes of the dead person.
There have also been reports of tribes in Papua, New Guinea,
known to have practiced endo- and exo-cannibalism up until the
1960s for ritualistic purposes. Some of the tribes partook of
cannibalism for purposes other than ritual reasons, such as for
the taste. However, a majority of the tribes were known to
mostly consume their dead relatives tissues and brains in a
ceremonial and traditional display of respect. The practice did
have deadly repercussions.
It was discovered that many of the tribes people were suffering from a fatal disease believed
by scientists to be related to their cannibalistic activities. According to anthropologist
Margaret Mackenzie, a scientific team led by Carleton Gajdusek and Baruch Blumberg
discovered that women were passing on a disease to their children, believed to be the human
equivalent of Mad Cow Disease in the late 1970s.
The disease, which became more wide-spread over a short period of time was due to an
infectious agent introduced by the consumption of deceased human tissues, especially that of
the brain. The disease, referred to as Kuru, was highly infectious and was transferred in a
variety of methods, including through bodily fluids. The spread of this disease only began to
diminish when the practice of cannibalism decreased.
Ritualistic cannibalism is frowned upon by most cultures; however it plays an integral part of
those cultures that do practice it. In many ways, the act has been a traditional custom
representing their values and belief system for hundreds and perhaps thousands of years.
6
However, with the fear of disease, which has the possibility of extinguishing cultures
permanently, tribes are forced to find away around their practices and possibly incorporate a
more symbolic and less literal form of ritual.
It is not disease alone, which has caused a reduction in many forms of ritualistic and spiritual
cannibalism. The spread of Christianity by missionary agencies has also led to a significant
decrease in the practice. In fact, the spread of Christianity is believed to have significantly
diminished cannibalism worldwide.
4. Survival Cannibalism
Perhaps the only generally accepted form of cannibalism is when humans eat the flesh of
other humans in an attempt to stay alive in desperate situations. Survival cannibalism is rare
and explicable in many cases, yet is still an act that is often punishable by law. There have
been several prominent cases of survival cannibalism over the last two hundred years,
including that of the Donner Party expedition and the more recent cases that occurred in the
Andes Mountains following a plane crash.
In 1846, a group of eighty-nine men, women and children led by a man named George
Donner set out across the Sierra Nevada Mountains enroute to California. During the journey,
the weather took and unexpected turn and they were forced to take an alternative route. The
travelers began to run out of food and other resources. Many died from exposure and
starvation.
Half of the travelers died before the remaining people eventually gave in to their situation and
began to feed on the flesh of the dead in an attempt to survive. The forty-six survivors were
eventually rescued, however upon reaching civilization they were regarded as monstrous
criminals and were held on trial for their actions. The travelers served around six months
before they were re-released back into their communities.
In 1972, a group of rugby players, their friends and families left on an airplane for Chile from
Uruguay. The plane crashed into the snow-covered Andes Mountains killing thirteen of the
forty-five passengers onboard the aircraft. Many of the passengers died over the weeks from
crash-related injuries. Without any supplies, those left alive resorted to cannibalizing the dead.
Those who refused to eat the human flesh died of starvation. After seventy days in the
mountains, sixteen survivors were rescued and taken home.
Even in the most extreme cases, the act of cannibalism is treated with disgust by many
cultures and is sometimes punishable by institutionalization in a mental facility, arrest,
imprisonment or even death. Cannibalism is most commonly believed to be the perfect
example of savage behavior. Although disease and religion have greatly diminished the
practice, it continues to be practiced worldwide.
Disorganised cannibalistic practices amongst criminals have been steadily increasing over the
last century, especially in the Western Hemisphere. Lawmakers around the world have been
forced to update laws pertaining to cannibalism or establish new laws where none existed
before. Criminal cannibalism has become the concern of the future.
5. Criminal Cannibalism
In modern times, the murder of a person or the use of a corpse for the purpose of consumption
by another human in any situation, outside that of conditions of starvation, is considered to be
a form of criminal cannibalism or anthropophagy. However, the definition of and laws
concerning criminal cannibalism vary considerably from culture to culture.
In many parts of the world cannibalism is not considered a crime and it is often only
recognized in concurrence with another crime. For example, in Great Britain and the United
States of America, cannibalism is not considered to be a felony, but is socially unacceptable.
Those who have been found to participate in the gruesome act are usually charged with
8
another crime that is directly related to the act of cannibalism, such as murder, grave robbery
or necrophilia.
In other cultures, what some believe to be an act of criminal cannibalism may be an
acceptable element of another culture. For example, Japanese enemies were allegedly
consumed during the height of World War II by tribes in Papua New Guinea, which was
acceptable in the culture during that period.
There are many who refuse to believe that cannibalism is practiced in this modern, civilized
age. However, there is much evidence suggesting that it does occur and with some frequency.
There have been many documented cases of cannibalism, especially within the last 100 years.
There are four primary forms of criminal cannibalism:
sexual cannibalism
aggression cannibalism
spiritual and ritual cannibalism
epicurean/nutritional cannibalism.
These various forms mainly go together with one another. For example, one may consume
human flesh for several purposes, such as to achieve a sense of power and control (aggression
cannibalism), yet one may also like the taste of it (epicurean/nutritional cannibalism). Another
may give into cannibalism in order to reach a higher spiritual affinity with the person they
have devoured, simultaneously achieving sexual pleasure.
from a nearby cemetery. Gein was believed to have had sexual contact with the corpses.
Gein was also an admitted transvestite, who found delight in dismembering the bodies and
peeling away the skin of the corpses so that he could wear them around the house. Gein was
known to have cannibalized some of the bodies, including Worden's whose heart was in a pan
10
on the stove at the time police conducted their search of the house. Whether Gein sexualized
the consumption of his victims was not proven. However, there was a strong relationship
between his necrophilia and cannibalistic behavior.
Some people that claim to be cannibals have admitted to feeling a sense of euphoria and/or
intense sexual stimulation when consuming human flesh. Some anthropophagists compared
eating human flesh with having an orgasm. The experience was further believed to cause an
out-of-body-experience causing effects comparable to taking mescaline.
According to some psychologists, eating human flesh can cause an increase in levels of
vitamin A and amino acids, which can cause a chemical effect on the blood and in the brain.
This chemical reaction could possibly lead to the escatic states that some cannibals have
claimed to have experienced. However, this theory has not been confirmed by scientific
evidence.
Study conducted on sex and cannibalism at Easter Illinois University in 2002 by Steven Scher
surveyed several groups of people who were asked questions pertaining to cannibalism and
sexual interests. The results of the study found that people were more likely to eat someone
that they were sexually attracted to than not. This suggests that there might be a significant
sexual component in the practice of cannibalism.
11
In 1981 Anna Zimmerman, 26, a German mother of two, murdered her boyfriend out of anger
and revenge and then dismembered his body. She froze his remains and over-time defrosted
portions of his body and consumed them with her children. She represents one of the few
known cases of female criminal cannibals.
Edmund Kemper was found guilty of the murders of six
young women, his two grandparents, his mother and a
mothers friend. Kempers killing spree and cannibalism was
believed to be the result of his hatred for his mother and an
unhappy childhood. According to Kemper, his mother
psychologically abused him and at one point forced him to
sleep in the cold and dark basement when he was a child.
While in the basement, his hate for his mother began to
grow. In order to release suppresed anger he would often
have murderous fantasies.
Edmund Kemper
Many of the murders Kemper committed had a large sexual component to them: he raped
some of his victims, killed them and then sexually molested the corpses. However, it is
believed that the murders were primarily motivated by his feelings of anger and revenge,
directly and indirectly towards his mother. In fact, Kemper claimed that the unpleasant
relationship with his mother was what influenced him to realise his violent fantasies, which
included cannibalism.
12
Jones also mentions another case where a young girl succumbed to a similar Satanic ritual. In
1999, a man named Dmitry Dyomin and two other accomplices abducted a fifteen-year-old
girl in Kiev. The girl was eventually murdered and her tongue was removed and eaten by
Dyomin. He and the other two assistants decapitated the girl and kept the skull as a trophy.
Spiritual and ritualistic cannibalism is not necessarily limited to groups. Many cases of
individual cannibalism incorporate spiritual and ritualistic aspects into their practice.
Cannibals such as Dahmer and Kemper claimed that when they consumed their victims, they
believed that they spiritually became a part of them. They also believed that their cannibalism
allowed them to absorb some of their attributes, such as power.
Epicurean and nutritional cannibalism refers to the consumption of human flesh, which is
primarily motivated by the taste of the flesh or for the nutritional value. This form of
cannibalism is believed to be rarer and is usually considered to be a sub-motivation of other
forms of cannibalism, such as survival and sexual cannibalism. However rare, there are
several cases that fall into this category which have had significant media attention.
In 1981, Japanese student Issei Sagawa was arrested in
France for satisfying his fantasies of cannibalism. One
day he approached a Dutch friend who rejected him.
Sagawa shot and killed her and then sexually assaulted
her corpse. Sagawa then carved away pieces of his
victim's body, including her breasts and buttocks and
consumed them. Sagawa was determined to be mentally
incompetent to stand trial in a French court. He was held
in a mental institution for a little over a year before being
returned to Japan, where he has been released for a
number of years and enjoys a kind of celebrity status.
Issei Sagawa
Also in France, Nicolas Claux was convicted of the 1994 murder of 34-year-old Thierry
Bissonier. However, murder was not his only lust. Claux, who at one time worked at a
13
Nicolas Claux
6. Psychological Perspectives
Within the field of psychology there is a debate on what factors lead a person to practice
criminal cannibalism. There are a many theories which have been presented, ranging from the
over nurturing of a child during the first few months of their life to sudden stress. However,
there is little evidence to support most of these theories. Nevertheless, the theories presented a
shell in which one is able to gain a better understanding of the possible psychological factors
behind cannibalism.
In an article by Sally Talwani titled "Experts Debate What Forces Create A Cannibal", Dr.
Clancy McKenzie, a psychology professor at Capital University in Washington, D.C. believes
that cannibalism is a result of trauma, especially that experienced in childhood. He states that
a child, after it is no longer fed from the breast, experiences separation anxiety and fantasizes
about devouring the mother. A person who has experienced this may regress back to this stage
in adulthood due to stress or trauma and lead the individual to seek out the fulfillment he has
been denied by resorting to cannibalism.
McKenzie believes that children who are excessively dependent on their mothers, due to
maternal over nurturing, are more likely to experience oral aggression and frustration due to
separation. Moreover, he claims that the adult who subconsciously carries this oral aggression
is likely to express it in an clearly dominant fashion against women by turning to cannibalism.
Evidence taken during psychological interviews with cannibals supports to a degree the
contention that aggression towards the mother may be one possible factor in a persons
cannibalism, such as with the case of Ed Kemper. However, it is unclear whether that
aggression directly leads to cannibalism. Furthermore, there is little evidence available which
14
can confirm this theory in whole and such evidence, if it existed, would be difficult to obtain.
Even if there are some strong points to this theory, it is unlikely that all cannibals, especially
criminal cannibals fit into this context.
There are other theories, as yet unsubstantiated, that suggest cannibalism to be a sexual
disorder and even an eating disorder. What seems to be a common characteristic among many
cannibals is that many of them have been diagnosed with schizophrenia or some other form of
personality disorder.
This theory suggests that there may be an underlying a neurochemical component related to
cannibalistic behavior. Many cannibals, such as Andrei Chikatilo, Albert Fish, Edward Gein,
and Issei Sagawa, had been diagnosed with schizophrenia. .
Moreover, schizophrenia may also be a significant component in historical accounts of tribal
cannibalism. The psychotic features related to schizophrenia have been found to have a
significant genetic component, thus it can be passed from generation to generation. Therefore,
it is not unlikely that schizophrenia may take root in some small indigenous tribes, which pull
from a small gene pool. However, this theory is speculative and has not fully been explored.
Although there are many theories, few are able to fully explain why some people resort to
eating human flesh. Therefore, more research is crucial in understanding the factors that lead
to criminal cannibalism.
15
Armin Meiwes
Bernd came to me of his own free will to end his life, Meiwes told the court in his trial, which
began December 3, 2003. For him, it was a nice death.
Before his death Brandes consumed a large quantity of liquor and 20 or more sleeping pills.
Cannibalism may not be against the law in Germany, but it guarantees one a free mental
examination. What the court found out after Meiwes psychiatric exam was very interesting.
He claimed that watching horror films is what initiated the fantasies that he had as a child
about eating people. Initially, he wanted to eat his school mates, he told the court.
The defense has been arguing that there was no murder because Brandes volunteered to be
killed. The prosecution, however, feels that Meiwes hobbies are very dangerous and that he
should be locked up permanently.
16
The court in Kassel had ruled that there were no "base motives" in the crime - sparing him a
murder conviction. He has been sentenced to eight and a half years in jail.
Robert Ackermann
yard howling at the moon, or dumping what appeared to be blood from his window, realized
the teen was dangerous.
Ackermann was once a normal, friendly, intelligent boy. In early adolescence, with
psychological problems woke up either by the physiological changes of puberty or perhaps his
father's abandonment of the family, he changed drastically. Ackerman began hearing voices
and manifesting serious behavioral problems. At 15, he left home. He experimented with
methamphetamines, ecstasy and harder drugs, and with crime. He stole, sometimes pretending
to be a businessman in order to decieve banks.
Ackermann's history of severe mental illness was marked by several hospital visits, and he
was diagnosed with schizoaffective psychosis. German authorities declared him too ill for
17
prison, but not quite sick enough to be placed in a state hospital for his protection or of
society. Ackermann was on his own, despite his mother's desperate pleas and evidence that his
disease could be controlled with medication, which he tended not to take if left
unsupervised. He ended up in Vienna, where, earlier in 2007, he was arrested at a local
hospital. He had been impersonating a doctor, hoping that, disguised as a member of the
hospital staff, he might be able to sneak into an operating room and take part in surgery - his
boyhood dream.
10. Bibliography
19