Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
TO DIANA
THE GODDESS OF MAN AND BEAST
12
A C TA H Y P E R B O R E A
2009
ACTA HYPERBOREA
12
Edited by
Tobias Fischer-Hansen and Birte Poulsen
CONTENTS
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
I
Artemis in the Near East and in Greece
marie louise nosch: Approaches to Artemis
in Bronze Age Greece . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
21
41
51
61
79
inge nielsen: The Sanctuary of Artemis Brauronia. Can Architecture and Iconography Help to Locate the Settings of the Rituals? . .
83
II
Artemis Regional Aspects
lone wriedt srensen: Artemis in Cyprus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195
tobias fischer-hansen: Artemis in Sicily and South Italy:
A Picture of Diversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 207
marjatta nielsen and annette rathje: Artumes in Etruria
the Borrowed Goddess . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 261
pia guldager bilde: Quantifying Black Sea Artemis:
Some Methodological Reflections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 303
luis ballesteros-pastor: Bears and Bees in Themiscyra:
A Sanctuary for Artemis in the Land of the Amazons? . . . . . . . . . . 333
III
Artemis / Diana during the Late Republic,
Imperial Period and Late Antiquity
mette moltesen: Diana and her Followers in a Late Republican
Temple Pediment from Nemi. A Preliminary Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . 345
jesper carlsen: Sanctuaries of Artemis and
the Domitii Ahenobarbi . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 369
rubina raja: The Sanctuary of Artemis in Gerasa . . . . . . . . . . . . . 383
birte poulsen: The Sanctuaries of the Goddess of the Hunt . . . . 401
niels hannestad: The Last Diana . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 427
IV
The Post-Antique Artemis
marjatta nielsen: Diana Efesia Multimammia: The Metamorphoses
of a Pagan Goddess from the Renaissance to the Age of Neo-Classicism
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 455
Forum
alexandra-fani alexandridou: Offering Trenches and Funerary
Ceremonies in the Attic Countryside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 497
Current Danish Archaeological Fieldwork
A gazetteer of Danish Classical Archaeological Fieldwork 2002-2006
with contributions by S. Dietz; B. Loven, D. Davis, M. Mller Nielsen &
M. Schaldemose; P. Pedersen; P. Guldager Bilde; S. Handberg, J. Kindberg Jacobsen & G.P. Mittica . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 523
Book Reviews
kim b. jessen: Rev. of Peter Attema (ed), Centralization, Early Urbanization and Colonization in First Millenium BC Italy and Greece. Part 1: Italy
(BABesch Suppl. 9). Leuven-Paris-Dudley 2004 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 559
stine schierup: Rev. of S.L. Solovyov, Ancient Berezan. The Architecture,
History and Culture of the First Greek Colony in the Northern Black Sea.
Brill 1999 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 567
Indices
Index of sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 573
Index of names . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 578
Index of sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 582
FORUM
OFFERING TRENCHES AND FUNERARY
CEREMONIES IN THE ATTIC COUNTRYSIDE
alexandra-fani alexandridou
alexandra-fani alexandridou
Attic Sites
referred to
in the text
Marathon
Menidi
Athens
Vourva
Vari
finds suggest that Vari was an important sub-centre with urban features.5
Another settlement was established during the eighth century on the hill
of Lathouriza, bordering the Vari plain. The site offered easy access to the
rich plain, whose cultivation might have been one of the main activities
of the settlers.6 Seventh-century graves associated with the settlement of
Lathouriza were explored at the foot of the hill.7
A systematic excavation of the North necropolis of Vari was carried out
from 1935 to 1938 under the directorship of G. Oikonomos and Ph. Stavropoulos, after the evaluation of illegally excavated ceramic material from
the site. Some of the finds and parts of the plan of the necropolis were
briefly published in archaeological reports.8 Due to the importance of the
discovered vases for the study of the Attic early black-figure, the publication by Semni Karouzou in 1963, including only part of the finds, focused
on the stylistic development, shapes and iconography of the vessels.9 Their
role in the mortuary practices was only assumed, since the details from the
excavations diaries were not known.10 The lack of a detailed publication
of the excavation still prevents scholars from studying the necropolis extensively. Therefore, the research on trench-ceremonies has largely been based
on the evidence from the well-published Kerameikos and the excavated
498
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
alexandra-fani alexandridou
Fig. 1 Plan of the North necropolis of Vari (after Karouzou 1963, 47, Fig. 40).
and under its south wall, two parallel trenches were discovered.21 Another
long trench, parallel to the east wall of the enclosure revealed a layer of
ashes.22 A large number of burnt vessels and offerings, dating from the late
seventh to the fifth century were found. Although it is not completely clear
whether they should be related to the trench parallel to the wall or those of
the built tomb, the former case seems more probable.23
Most of the early black-figured vases, found in association with the large
500
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
tumulus I, have been published.24 The earliest, many of which have been
assigned to the Nessos Painter, date to the last quarter of the seventh century.25 The latest reach the second quarter of the sixth, as implied by an
unpublished lekane by the Polos Painter.26 A wide variety of shapes was
recovered: a column-krater (Fig. 3), standed and lidded skyphos-kraters
(Fig. 4), almost forty lekanai, large louteria (Fig. 5), neck-amphorae, some
of very large dimensions and two horsehead amphorae.27 The majority
501
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
dates to the last quarter of the seventh century and is probably contemporary with the burial. The vases are of exceptional quality, decorated in
many cases with rich mythological and generic scenes. Herakles freeing
Prometheus (Fig. 4), Herakles pursuing the Centaurs (Fig. 6), Bellerophon and the Chimaira (Fig. 7), running Gorgons, as well as a procession
of women flanked by Doric columns and a female protome are characteristic examples.28 The two episodes with Herakles, both attributed to the
Nessos Painter, are the earliest known in the Attic repertory.
The vessels are supposed to come from the offering trench next to the
tumulus.29 Offering trenches are a late eighth-century Attic funerary innovation, which ceased around 560 BC. These long, shallow ditches were dug
into the ground and were mainly filled with ashes, bones of small animals
502
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
Fig. 4
Athens, National
Museum, 16384.
Standed skyphoskrater. Courtesy
National Museum
of Athens.
or birds, burnt and broken vases. The best preserved examples were found
at the Kerameikos and revealed a large part of the seventh-century Protoattic pottery known from Attika. The vessels were probably placed on a
wooden table-like structure before being set on fire. Stratigraphic observations indicate that the ritual took place, while the grave was still open. The
mixing, pouring, eating and drinking shapes point to a funerary ceremony
503
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
504
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
Fig. 7
Athens, National
Museum, 16389.
Neck-amphora.
Courtesy National
Museum of
Athens.
alexandra-fani alexandridou
trenches is high, the amount of the vases found is very limited.31 In many
cases, they only contained Corinthian drinking and oil vessels,32 while in
others a restricted number primarily of Attic drinking and eating shapes.33
The pottery evidence suggests that trench-ceremonies in the cemetery were
already declining from the last quarter of the seventh century.
The finds from the trench of the Vari tumulus create a completely different impression. The number of the vases recovered is remarkable, while the
shapes differ significantly from their contemporaries in the Kerameikos
(Table 1). Skyphos-kraters of exceptional quality are largely represented
in the Vari trench, but they are absent from the late seventh, early sixthcentury Kerameikos trenches. There, they are only used as grave-markers,
while standed or lidded examples are not known.34 Although an important number of neck-amphorae and louteria were found in the trench of
tumulus I, they are rare in the Kerameikos, where they served as markers.35 Moreover, the Vari lekanai are the earliest known Attic black-figured
examples. The shape appears in the Kerameikos by the first quarter of the
sixth century and only two examples were found.36 The Vari column-krater
is unique, not attested elsewhere in late seventh-century Attika. The shape
reappears in the Attic repertory by the first quarter of the sixth century. On
the other hand, drinking, pouring and eating vessels, like skyphoi, olpai or
plates, all common shapes in the Kerameikos trenches, are missing from
the Vari trench.
Some of the Vari shapes are represented in the wells of the Athenian Agora and can be related to domestic contexts (Table 2). Louteria are present
at the site already from the end of the eighth century, but the known examples are few.37 According to the publication of the black-figured pottery,
only three date to the late seventh and early sixth century, indicating that
the shape was mainly destined for funerary purposes.38 Many skyphoskraters were found in the late seventh-century Agora wells, suggesting that
if they are not secondary fills, the shape was not confined to funerary, but
also to domestic purposes. Some might have been standed, like the Vari
examples, as indicated by the discovered fragmentary supports. Unlike the
large concentration of neck-amphorae at Vari, all being contemporary, the
published Agora examples, not more numerous, cover the third and last
quarter of the seventh century. The one-piece amphora seems to have been
more common.39 The shape of the lekane is only attested in the Vari trench
506
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
shapes/sites
mixing
Vari Trench
Tumulus I
Sk.kr.(5)
Col.kr. (1)
oil
storage
N.-Amph.(11)
HH Amph.(2)
Lekane (46)
Louterion (3)
Vari Trench
Enclosure
Lekane (5)
Plate (5)
Skyphos (3)
Kantharos(1)
Olpe (6)
Exaleiptron (1)
Hydria (2)
Louterion (1?)
Loutr.amph. (1)
Sk.kr. (1)
Lekane (4)
Skyphos (1)
Loutr.
amph. (1)
Marathon
Trench
Lekane (1)
Cup (1)
Pyxis (1)
N.-Amph.(1)
Hydria(1)
Trench
Standed cup(2)
Corinthian:
kotyle (1)
Corinthian:
oinochoe (1)
Corinthian:
aryballos (5)
Trench
Corinthian:
kotyle (1)
Corinthian:
oinochoe (1)
Trench
Corinthian:
kotyle (1)
Trench
Corinthian:
kotyle (2)
skyphos (1)
Corinthian:
oinochoe (1)
Trench R
Olpe (1)
Loutr.
amph. (1)
Off.place.
Lekane (2)
Plate (1)
Skyphos (2)
Olpe (2)
Off.place.
Skyphos (1)
Pyxis (1)
Gaming
table, Dice
K ER A MEIKOS
Vourva
Trench I
eating
List of abbreviations
Col.Kr: Column-krater
HH Amph.: Horsehead Amphora
drinking
pouring
Loutr.amph: Loutrophoros-amphora
N.-Amph: Neck-amphora
ceremonial
Table 1 Shapes from the offering trenches and places excavated in the Kerameikos
and the Attic countryside (ca. 630 to 570 BC.)
during the late seventh century.40 The earliest lekane from the Agora dates
to the early sixth century.41
Although most of the seventh-century vases from the Kerameikos
trenches cannot have been used during an actual banquet, due to their
special features, such as the application of mourning figures or the lack of
good glaze in their interior, the quality of the firing and glaze of the Vari
shapes may imply an actual use.42 The louteria could have been used for
water libations to the dead in the form of the chthonia loutra.43 Since the
lower part of the body of the skyphos-kraters has not been preserved, libations cannot be concluded, but should not be excluded. The decoration of
the standed examples on one side follows the seventh-century tendency to
507
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
shapes/sites
skyphos-krater
louterion
neck-amphora
lekane
Vari Trench
Tumulus I
11
11
Athenian
Agora
18
10
Table 2 Shapes from Tumulus I at Vari and the Athenian Agora (ca. 630-600 BC.)
The number of the vases from the Athenian Agora is based on Moore, Philippides
1986.
forum
I, their shapes and state of preservation differ considerably. They are secondarily burnt, pointing to a trench-ceremony comparable to those taking
place in the Kerameikos.
A large number of the vases from the enclosure-trench date to the first
quarter of the sixth century. They all preserve signs of fire. Eating and
drinking shapes dominate, but pouring, oil and storage vessels were also
found. Large mixing vases, comparable to those from Tumulus I, are
absent.47 The early sixth-century shapes find close parallels among their
sympotic contemporaries from the Kerameikos.48 The reports refer also
to clay figurines of horses and birds, black and red-figured lekythoi and a
large number of white lekythoi with palmette ornaments.49 These finds are
still unpublished, but a few sixth-century black-figured lekythoi, on display in the National Museum of Athens, do not preserve signs of fire and
might have been placed in the trench as offerings to the dead. 50
alexandra-fani alexandridou
Fig. 8 Plan of the Vourva tumulus (after Stais 1890, Pl. XIII, 3).
during 1890 and 1891 and a layer of ashes, burnt bones and early fifth-century black-figured lekythoi have been connected with the cremated warriors bodies. A long brick trench, containing a layer of ashes, bones of small
animals or birds and egg shells, as well as burnt fragments of vessels, was
explored near the centre of the tumulus. The second trench, not covered
by the tumulus, yielded animal bones and vessels fragments, but the bad
state of preservation of the trench and its finds did not allow for a more
detailed description.56 An early sixth-century neck-amphora and a large
lekane are the earliest finds from the first trench.57 A pyxis and a hydria
date to the middle and late sixth century,58 while the latest find is a red-figured cup, attributed to Onesimos.59 The early sixth-century vessels, as well
as the pyxis, preserve signs of fire. This trench is an undeniable proof of
a funerary ceremony dating back to the early sixth-century and questions
510
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
alexandra-fani alexandridou
with tumulus I, has been noted and assigned to the importance of the
deceased, interpreted as a local genarches.62 Stais suggested that trench I
of the Vourva tumulus received annual offerings, while he also attempted
to interpret the chronological distance of the vases from Marathon.63 Due
to the duration of the offerings, the Vourva and Marathon trenches have
recently been seen as bothroi of cult.64
Can the offering trenches of the Attic countryside be associated with
some kind of tomb cult? The North necropolis of Vari, preserving the richest and chronological wider evidence, can contribute importantly to the
study of this practice, when placed in the broader Attic seventh-century
frame.
During this century, a number of changes in the funerary practices
took place: the number of the burials declined, adult and children were
buried in separate areas, inhumation was replaced by primary cremation
and goods were not placed in the grave, but in the offering trenches and
places.65 Unlike the evidence from other contemporary poleis, like Corinth,
offerings from the major Attic sanctuaries are poor. The Acropolis preserved only a few seventh-century vases, while the peak sanctuaries around
Attika, which flourished during the seventh century, attracted only Subgeometric drinking vessels of poor quality, in many cases bearing dedicatory inscriptions.66 An important amount of the seventh-century Protoattic pottery comes from the necropoleis, mainly the Kerameikos, while a
number is associated with the tomb cults centred on Bronze and Iron Age
graves.67 The archaeological context of the Protoattic pottery led to the
conclusion that it was specially produced for the Attic nobles, mainly destined to serve their ritual needs, either associated with mortuary practices
or with tomb cults.68 The distribution of the earliest black-figured vases
during the last quarter of the seventh century points in the same direction. Except for the sanctuary of the Nymphe on the south slope of the
Acropolis, which received a large number of black-figured loutrophoroi, 69
probably due to the special nature of the honoured deity associated with
marriage,70 the ceramic evidence from the Acropolis and other sanctuaries
remains poor. On the other hand, funerary contexts continue to attract
most of the late seventh-century vessels, many of which are monumental
and elaborately decorated. However, it is now the Attic countryside that
takes the lead, since the majority was found in the Vari and not the Kerameikos trenches.
512
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
The seventh-century trench practices have been paralleled by a number of scholars with the cults addressed to Bronze and Iron Age deceased,
attested in a number of Attic sites, mainly in the countryside.71 The Mycenaean tholos tombs at Menidi, Thorikos and Aliki Glyphada are characteristic examples.72 Unlike most of the known tomb cults, the evidence from
Menidi and Thorikos is exceptional in its duration and contents, with the
quality of the offerings pointing to wealthy groups and not to worshippers
of all social backgrounds.73 The duration of the cult, as indicated by the
finds, is the main common feature between the trenches in the countryside
and the tomb cults. In some cases, similarities between the offerings have
also been noted.74
The excavation of the Mycenaean tholos tomb at Menidi led to the discovery of a number of vessels and horse figurines placed in its dromos, dating from the Late Geometric period to the early fifth century. The offerings cannot be assigned a heroic character, but are rather comparable to
those from funerary or even domestic contexts.75 The deposit at the dromos
of the tholos tomb is reminiscent of a trench, while a number of comparisons have been drawn between the discovered shapes and those from the
Vari tumulus-trench.76 Standed louteria were common offerings to the tholos tomb. Although they have been connected with a heroic bath of funerary character for the deceased,77 the absence of the shape from sanctuaries
and other sites of hero-cult prompts for a different explanation. They were
probably used for libations, before being offered to this unidentified hero.78
Large louteria, though without a stand, were also favoured by the visitors of
the tumulus I at Vari, while the standed skyphoi-kraters can be compared
with the Menidi louteria. More importantly, in both cases the vessels do
not preserve any signs of secondary burning.
Although comparisons have been drawn between tomb cults and the
practices taking place over trenches in general,79 it is only those in the
countryside that present clearer comparative elements, on account of their
duration. The ritual burning of the vessels attested in the Kerameikos and
early sixth-century Vourva, Vari and Marathon is not found in tomb cults,
which have a votive and not a sympotic character. The trench of the Vari
tumulus I and the late seventh-century evidence from Vourva are the only
cases where the vases are not burnt, but rather presented as offerings to the
dead.
Tomb cult is a kind of ancestor cult and the Attic Bronze- or Iron-Age
513
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
deceased were probably adopted by the locals as ancestors.80 The continuation of the offerings over the trenches in the Attic countryside suggests a
comparable cult. The difference lies in the chronological distance separating the dedicators from the deceased; the cults over trenches address the
dead of the recent past that, although anonymous to us, were remembered
by the dedicators, at least during the first decades. The offerings to tumulus
I seem to have been connected with a member of the local elite, who might
also have played a prominent role in the life of the community. Luxurious
vessels dedicated by his family or wider social circle aimed at underlining
their connection with the deceased, as well as the wealth of their class. His
recognition as an ancestor might have defined the cultic character of the
ceremony, closer to the cults at the Bronze Age tumuli in Attika, which is
not found in the case of the enclosure-trench of the necropolis. The importance of the tumulus and the deceased is further underlined by its direct
association with later tombs. The stone tombs E and , as well as the
small enclosure are attached to it.
On the other hand, the trench of the enclosure does not seem to be
connected with a particular burial, since it runs along the enclosure wall,
like trench I from Vourva.81 Are then these finds offered to a particular
deceased or address to the entire group of the graves? Did the tumuli, or
maybe the enclosure, contain family groups, with the trench dedicated
to the entire family? Family burial groups are identified with difficulty
before the fourth century BC. Only three cases from the seventh and
sixth-century Kerameikos have been securely associated with true family
plots.82 It seems that Archaic burial customs did not express genealogies,
but rather social status, with the Kerameikos tumuli and those from Vourva and Velanideza probably containing members of the same or different
families, connected by social relations and not family ties.83 The lack of a
detailed publication of the North necropolis of Vari prevents from testing
the expressed theory on the excavated tumuli or the graves of the enclosure. However, since memory and burial customs, associated with the dead
kin, extend only a few generations back,84 the duration of the cult over the
enclosure-trench for almost two centuries does not point to a family, but
rather to visitors of the same social group, members of the elite.
The lack of trenches from a necropolis, excavated in Vari, 800 meters
south-east of the North, suggests that they may have been considered a
special feature destined for deceased of particular importance.85 Although
514
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
not very numerous, Protoattic and late seventh-century vases, some of large
dimensions, are not absent from the South-East necropolis. Nevertheless,
they were burnt inside the grave together with the body. The North necropolis probably was the burying place of the wealthiest and most important
members of the local community, who were also conceived and honoured
as ancestors.
In Attika, long-lasting trench-ceremonies as well as the cults centred on
Bronze Age tombs are mainly found in the countryside and seem to have
been closely connected with the wealthy local residents.86 Tomb cults have
been linked to claims on land,87 and since in most cases they are attested
in the older communities of Attika, they have been seen as a reaction of
the old and rich settled communities against the foundation of small settlements around them.88 Although the use of tomb cult as a declaration
of the Attic autochthony has been questioned,89 the continuous use of the
trenches suggests that a connection with the land surrounding the tumuli
or the tombs should not be excluded. Even if they do not constitute evidence of conflicts over land, funerary ceremonies and tomb cults are clear
indications of the wealth and power of the local nobles and could have
served as means of their self-definition.90
Conclusions
The ceramic evidence from the Vari trenches, combined with that from
Vourva and Marathon, contributes significantly to the study of the trenchphenomenon in the late seventh- and sixth-century Attika and highlights
the differences between the Kerameikos and the Attic countryside. In contrast to the evidence from the Kerameikos, the trench-ceremonies in the
hinterland, expressions of the local aristocracy, present a number of comparative elements with tomb cults. The deceased of the distant and recent
past seem to have been conceived as ancestors and were honoured through
dedications, which in contemporary poleis would have been appropriate
for the gods in the sanctuaries.91 That is the example of the dead, buried
in tumulus I at Vari. The finds do not only imply that mortuary practices
were considered ideal contexts for status display, but were also a medium
of underlining the special connection of the participants with the deceased
and the area surrounding the cemetery.
By the early sixth century, trenches in the Kerameikos decline, before
being abandoned during the second quarter of the century. By that time,
515
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
oil-vessels are placed inside the graves. However, the evidence from Vari,
Vourva and Marathon indicates that the peripheral communities insisted
on trench-ceremonies for a longer period, even reaching the fifth century
BC. Although the sixth- and fifth-century trench-offerings have lost their
earlier splendour and monumentality, they are suggestive of continuous
funerary cults that emphasize the ties of the local elite with their ancestors
and the land of the area. The case of the North necropolis of Vari is the
most characteristic, due to the exceptional quality of the ceramic finds and
the duration of the cult.
Therefore the long-awaited, final publication of the cemetery, including
all the excavation details, is crucial and should soon see the light.
acknowledgments
I am grateful to Mrs Elisavet Stasinopoulou,
Mr Giorgos Kavvadias, Mrs Eleni Zosi and the
National Museum of Athens for allowing me to
study a large part of the Vari ceramic material
in detail. I would like to thank Dr. Irene Lemos
notes
1 Eliot 1962, 35-39; Osborne 1985, 26-28;
Lauter 1991, 85; Mersch 1997, 53-58.
2 Morris 1987, 68-69. The opposite view is held
by Osborne: Osborne 1985, 26.
3 Mersch suggests a single community. Mersch
1997, 53. Lauter and Morris are in favour of
several settlements. In particular, the SouthEast cemetery has been associated with the
traces of a settlement between Vari and Varkiza, dating to 700 BC. Morris 1987, 68; Lauter
1991, 66.
4 Lauter 1985b, 63-68; Osborne 1985, 26-28;
Onasoglou 1987, 92-96; Mazarakis-Ainian
1994, 70-71.
5 Mersch 1997, 53-58.
6 Mazarakis-Ainian 1994, 65-73; MazarakisAinian 1995, 143-155; Mazarakis-Ainian
1997, 106, 116.
7 Lauter 1995b, 64.
8 Karo 1936, 123-125; Lemerle 1936, 460;
Lemerle 1937, 451; Riemann 1937, 121-124;
Walter 1940, 175-178.
9 Karouzou 1963. According to Karouzou, this
was the first volume of the publication. The
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
516
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
517
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
Whitley 1994a, 213-230. Petrakos interpreted the vases as relics: Petrakos 1995, 24.
Walter 1940, 176.
Stais 1890, 322; Stais 1893, 56.
Kistler 1998, 41-42.
Houby-Nielsen 1992, 343-374; Morris 1987,
61-9; DOnofrio 1993, 143-169; Morris 1995,
45-74.
Langdon 1976; Lauter 1985; Polignac 1995b,
75-101; DOnofrio 1997, 77-78; Christiansen
2000; Polignac 2002, 119-122.
Antonaccio 1995, 102-126; Boehringer 2001,
47-103. The term tomb rather than hero cult
with be used here, so that it can be distinguished by the later Attic practice addressed
to named local heroes. For the use of this
term: Antonaccio 1995, 6.
Whitley 1994b, 61. However, Whitley has
been criticized for selective use of the statistics from the wells of the Athenian Agora and
of not explaining adequately the presence of
these vessels in domestic contexts. Rotroff
1995, 123-124.
Papadopoulou-Kanelopoulou 1997.
Kyrkou 1997, 902; Msch-Klingele 2006, 1119.
Whitley 1994a, 223-224; Houby-Nielsen
1996, 53-54; Polignac 1996, 37; Boehringer
2001, 111.
For Menidi: Wolters 1899, 103-135. For
Thorikos: Mussche et al. 1968, 9-15. For
Aliki Glyphada: Papadimitriou 1955, 78-99.
For the evidence from Athens and Attika:
Antonaccio 1995, 102-126; Boehringer 2001,
47-103.
Antonaccio 1993, 64; Antonaccio 1995, 104109, 262; Boehringer, 2001, 97-102.
Whitley 1994a, 224-225; Antonaccio 1995,
249-250; Polignac 1996; 38.
Hgg 1987, 94-99; Antonaccio 1995, 107,
247-249.
Antonaccio 1995, 109; Boehringer 2001,
118.
Ginouvs 1962, 249.
Hgg 1987, 96; Pimpl 1997, 148; Boehringer
2001, 96-97.
Whitley explains the general practice of placing offerings in the trenches as expression
of tomb cult, without making a distinction
between the Kerameikos and the countryside.
Whitley 1994a, 218.
Antonaccio 1993, 65; Antonaccio 1995, 245246.
The trench covered by the Marathon tumulus
was not found in connection with any graves.
It may be possible to associate it with the urnvessel found in the middle of the tumulus:
518
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
bibliography
Antonaccio 1993
C.M. Antonaccio, The Archaeology of Ancestors,
in: C. Dougherty, and L. Kurke (eds.), Cultural
poetics in Archaic Greece: cult, performance, politics,
Cambridge 1993, 46-70.
Antonaccio 1995
C.M. Antonaccio, An archaeology of ancestors:
tomb cult and hero cult in early Greece. Lanham
1995.
Bakir 1981
G. Bakir, Sophilos: ein Beitrag zu seinem Stil.
Mainz am Rhein 1981.
Brann 1962
E.T.H. Brann, The Athenian Agora VIII. Late Geometric and Protoattic Pottery Mid 8th to Late 7th
Century B.C. Princeton 1962.
Boardman & Kurtz 1971
J. Boardman & D.C. Kurtz, Greek Burial Customs. London 1971.
Boehringer 2001
D. Boehringer, Heroenkult in Griechenland von der
geometrischen bis zu klassischen Zeit. Berlin 2001.
Callipolitis-Feytmans 1965
D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les louteria attiques.
Athens 1965.
Christiansen 2000
J. Christiansen, Kiapha Thiti. Ergebnisse der
Ausgrabungen III 1 (The Iron Peak Sanctuary).
Kirchhain 2000.
CVA Athens 4
M.Pipili, Corpus Vasorum Antiquorum, Athens
National Museum 4. Attic black-figure skyphoi.
Athens 1993.
Danforth, Tsiaras 1982
L.M. Danforth, A. Tsiaras, The Death Rituals of
Rural Greece. Princeton 1982.
DOnofrio 1982
A.M. DOnofrio, Korai e kouroi funerari attici,
AION 4, 1982, 135-170.
DOnofrio 1988
A.M. DOnofrio, Aspetti e problemi del monumento funerario attico arcaico, AION 10, 1988,
83-96.
DOnofrio 1993
A.M. DOnofrio, Le trasformazioni del costume
funerario ateniese nella necropoli pre-soloniana
del Kerameikos, AION 15, 1993, 143-171.
DOnofrio 1997
A.M. DOnofrio, The 7th Century BC in Attica:
the Basis for Political Organization, ActaHyp 7,
1997, 79-84.
Eliot 1962
C.W. Eliot, Coastal Demes of Attika: a study of the
policy of Kleisthenes. Toronto 1962.
Garland 1985
R. Garland, The Greek Way of Death. Ithaca 1985.
Ginouvs 1962
R. Ginouvs, Balaneutik: recherches sur le bain
dans lantiquit grecque. Paris 1962.
Hgg 1987
R. Hgg, Gifts to the Heroes in Geometric and
Archaic Greece, in T. Linders, G. Nordquis (eds.),
Gifts to the Gods: proceedings of the Uppsala symposium 1985, Uppsala 1987, 93-99.
Houby-Nielsen 1992
S. Houby-Nielsen, Interaction between chieftains
and citizens? 7th century B.C. burial customs in
Athens, ActaHyp 4, 1992, 343-374.
Houby-Nielsen 1995
S. Houby-Nielsen, Burial language in archaic and
classical Kerameikos, ProcDanInstAth 1, 1995,
129-192.
519
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
Houby-Nielsen 1996
S. Houby-Nielsen, The Archaeology of Ideology
in the Kerameikos: New Interpretations of the
Opferrinnen, in: R. Hgg (ed.), The Role of Religion in the Early Greek Polis: proceedings from the
third international Seminar on Ancient Greek Cult:
organized by the Swedish Institute at Athens, 16-18
October 1992, Stockholm 1996, 41-54.
Lauter 1985a
H. Lauter, Der Kultplatz auf dem Turkovuni. Berlin 1985.
Humphreys 1980
S.C. Humphreys, Family Tombs and Tomb Cult
in Ancient Athens. Tradition or Traditionalism?,
JHS 100, 1980, 96-126.
Lauter 1991
H. Lauter, Attische Landgemeinden in Klassischer
Zeit, MarbWPr 1991, 1-161.
Kallipolitis 1963
V. Kallipolitis, a t, A 1963, 115-132.
Lauter 1985b
H. Lauter, Lathuresa: Beitrge zur Architektur und
Siedlungsgeschichte in sptgeometrische Zeit. Mainz
am Rhein 1985.
Lemerle 1936
P. Lemerle, Chronique des fouilles et dcouvertes
archologiques, BCH 60, 1936, 460.
Karo 1936
G. Karo, Archologische Funde von Sommer 1935
bis Sommer 1936, AA 1936, 123-125.
Lemerle 1937
P. Lemerle, Chronique des fouilles et dcouvertes
archologiques en Grce, 1937, BCH 61, 1937,
451.
Karouzou 1963
S. Karouzou, .
Athens 1963.
Lioutas 1987
A. Lioutas, Attische schwarzfigurige Lekanai und
Lekanides. Wrzburg 1987.
Karouzou 1982
S. Karouzou, Le Peintre des lions et son lve, RA
1982, 33-44.
Mazarakis-Ainian 1994
A. Mazarakis-Ainian, t: a B B f a , in: P.N.
Doukellis, L.G. Mendoni (eds.), Structures rurales
et socits antiques: actes du Colloque de Corfou (1416 mai 1992), Paris 1994, 65-80.
Kistler 1998
E. Kistler, Die Opferrinne-Zeremonie : Bankettideologie am Grab, Orientalisierung und Formierung
einer Adelsgesellschaft in Athen. Stuttgart 1998.
Kbler 1954
K. Kbler, Kerameikos, Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen V, 1. Die Nekropole des 10. bis 8. Jahrhunderts.
Berlin 1954.
Mazarakis-Ainian 1995
A. Mazarakis-Ainian, Late Geometric-Archaic
Lathouriza, in: C. Morris (ed.), Klados: essays in
honour of J.N. Coldstream, London 1995, 143155.
Kbler 1959
K. Kbler, Kerameikos, Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen VI,1. Die Nekropole des Spten 8 bis frhen 6
Jahrhunderts. Berlin 1959.
Mazarakis-Ainian 1997
A. Mazarakis-Ainian, From rulers dwellings to
temples: architecture, religion and society in early
iron age Greece (1100-700 B.C.). Jonsered 1997.
Kbler 1970
K. Kbler, Kerameikos, Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen VI,2. Die Nekropole des Spten 8 bis frhen 6
Jahrhunderts. Berlin 1970.
Mersch 1995
A. Mersch, Archologischer Kommentar zu den
Grbern der Athener und Plataier in der Marathonia, Klio 77, 1995, 55-64.
Kyrkou 1997
M. Kyrkou, Nymphe I, LIMC VIII, 1, Zurich,
1997, 902.
Mersch 1997
A. Mersch, Urbanization of the Attic Countryside
from the Late 8th Century to the 6th Century B.C.,
ActaHyp 7, 1997, 45-62.
Langdon 1976
M.K. Langdon, A Sanctuary of Zeus on Mount
Hymettos. Princeton 1976.
520
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
forum
Mingazzini 1975
P. Mingazzini, LAnfora di Sophilos nella Tomba
dei Maratonomachi, ASAtene 52-53, 1974-1975,
9-13.
Papadopoulou-Kanelopoulou 1997
Ch. Papadopoulou-Kanelopoulou,
. .
Athens, 1997.
Parker 1983
R. Parker, Miasma: pollution and purification in
early Greek religion. Oxford 1983.
Morris 1987
I. Morris, Burial and ancient society: the rise of the
Greek city-state. Cambridge 1987.
Morris 1995
I. Morris, Burning the Dead in Archaic Athens,
in: A. Verbanck-Pirard and D.Viviers (eds.),
Culture et cit: lavnement dAthnes l poque
archaque : actes du colloque international organis
lUniversit libre de Bruxelles du 25 au 27 avril
1991 par lInstitut des Hautes Etudes de Belgique et
la Fondation Archologique de lU.L.B., Bruxelles
1995, 45-74.
Morris 1997
I. Morris, The Art of Citizenship, in: Langdon, S.
(ed.), New Light on a Dark Age. Exploring the Culture of Geometric Greece, Missouri 1997, 9-43.
Msch-Klingele 2006
R. Msch-Klingele, Die loutrophoros im Hochzeits- und Begrbnisritual des 5. Jahrhunderts v.
Chr. in Athen. Bern. 2006.
Mussche et al. 1968
H.F. Mussche et al., Thorikos: Rapport preliminaire sur la premire campagne des fouilles I 1963.
Brussels 1968.
Onasoglou 1987
A.Onasoglou, t a, A 42, 1987,
., 92-96.
Osborne 1985
R. Osborne, Demos: the discovery of Classical Attika. Cambridge 1985.
Petrakos 1995
V. Petrakos, . Athens 1995.
Picozzi 1971
M.G. Picozzi, Anfore attiche a protome equina,
StMisc 18, 1971, 5-64.
Pimpl 1997
H. Pimpl, Perirrhanteria und Louteria. Berlin
1997.
Polignac 1995a
F. de Polignac, Cults, territory, and the origins of the
Greek city-state (trans. by J. Lloyd). London 1995.
Polignac 1995b
F. de Polignac, Sanctuaires et societ en Attique
gomtrique et archaique: rflexion sur les critres
d analyse, in: A. Verbanck-Pirard and D. Viviers
(eds.), Culture et Cit: L avnement dAthnes
l poque archaque: actes du Colloque international
organis lUniversit libre de Bruxelles du 25 au
27 avril 1991 par lInstitut des Hautes tudes de
Belgique et la Fondation Archologique de LU.L.B.,
Brussels 1995, 75-101.
Polignac 1996
F. de Polignac, Entre les dieux et les morts. Status
individual et rites collectifs dans la cit archaque,
in: R. Hgg (ed.), The Role of Religion in the early
Greek polis: proceedings from the third international
Seminar on Ancient Greek Cult: organized by the
Swedish Institute at Athens, 16-18 October 1992,
Jonsered 1996, 31-40.
Osborne 1989
R. Osborne, A Crisis in Archaeological History?
The Seventh Century B.C. in Attica, BSA 84,
1989, 297-322.
Polignac 2002
F. de Polignac, Cultes de sommet en Argolide
et Corinthie. Elments d interpretation, in: R.
Hgg (ed.), Peloponnesian sanctuaries and cults:
proceedings of the ninth international symposium at
the Swedish Institute at Athens, 11-13 June 1994,
Stockholm 2002, 119-122.
Papadimitriou 1955
I. Papadimitriou, a
a, , 1955, 78-99.
Richter 1961
G.M.A. Richter, The Archaic Gravestones of Attica.
London 1961.
521
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842
alexandra-fani alexandridou
Riemann 1937
H. Riemann, Archologische Funde vom Sommer
1936 bis Sommer 1937, AA 1937, 121-124.
Vierneisel 1964a
K. Vierneisel, Die Ausgrabungen im Kerameikos
1963, A 19, 1964, ., 38-42.
Rotroff 1995
Rotroff, S., I., Review of: Ian Morris (ed.), Classical Greece: Ancient Histories and Modern Archaeologies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
1994. BMCR 6.2, 1995, 221-228.
Vierneisel 1964b
K. Vierneisel, Die Ausgrabungen im Kerameikos,
AA 1964, 420-467.
Scheibler 1961
I.Scheibler, Olpen und Amphoren des Gorgonmalers, JdI 76, 1961, 1-47.
Schnapp 1997
A. Schnapp, Le chasseur et la cit, Chasse et rotique
dans la Grce ancienne. Paris 1997.
Snodgrass 1982
A. Snodgrass, Les origines du culte des hros
dans la Grce antique, in: La mort, les morts
dans les socits anciennes, Cambridge 1982, 107120.
Walter 1940
O. Walter, Archologische Funde in Griechenland
vom Frhjahr 1939 bis Frhjahr 1940, AA 1940,
175-178.
Whitley 1988
J. Whitley, Early States and Hero Cults: A Re
Appraisal, JHS 108, 1988, 173-182.
Whitley 1994a
J. Whitley, The Monuments that stood before
Marathon. Tomb cult and Hero cult in Archaic
Attica, AJA 98, 1994, 213-230.
Stais 1890
V. Stais, O Tt a , AM 15, 1890,
318-329.
Whitley 1994b
J. Whitley, Protoattic Pottery. A Contextual
Analysis, in: Classical Greece: Ancient Histories and
Modern Archaeologies, edited by Morris, I. Cambridge 1994, 51-70.
Stais 1893
V. Stais, O B t, AM 18,
1893, 46-63.
Wolters 1899
P. Wolters, Vasen aus Menidi II, JdI 14, 1899, 103135.
Brasenose College
University of Oxford
UK OX1 4AJ Oxford
alexandraalexandridou@gmail.com
522
From Artemis to Diana. The Goddess of Man and Beast
Collegium Hyperboreum and Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009
ISBN 978 87 635 0788 2, ISSN 0904 2067, http://www.mtp.hum.ku.dk/details.asp?eln=202842