Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1
NePP Status: Final 01/04/2008
Implementing
procurement
cards
A guide for public
sector managers
Page 1
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Introduction:
Procurement cards
are the quickest
route to e-
procurement
process savings for
the public sector.
This introduction
explains how they
work and the
benefits they can
bring.
Page 2
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 3
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Whatever the figure chosen by other Using procurement cards will create some
organisations, each buying organisation should automatic cashable savings because they do
undertake their own research to determine the not require the organisation to raise paper
likely effect that a procurement card will have orders or reconcile each invoice by hand,
on their organisation, and use this research to however, the majority of savings will be
determine a ‘per transaction’ estimate of realised in the shape of staff time. For these
savings. savings to become cashable it will be
necessary to reduce the wage costs of the
Understanding the market organisation, either by employing fewer
Prior to approaching a bank about a temporary staff or by reducing the number of
procurement card programme it is important to full time equivalent (FTE) employees. For more
understand how the procurement card market information on realising the benefits of
works. In the UK there are three major card procurement cards see “Running a programme
acceptance brands, Visa, American Express 3: Identifying and recovering the benefits” on
and MasterCard. This means that the majority page 41.
of suppliers who can accept payments by card
will accept cards carrying one of these brands. Defining the success of a procurement card
Six Visa issuing banks have been contracted scheme?
by the OGC to provide the Government It is essential for an organisation to consider
Procurement Card (GPC) using the Visa their vision of success before implementing a
network. Under this contract, the issuing banks procurement card programme. Will the aim be
can provide all public sector bodies with a to gain efficiencies? If so, how much of this
purchasing card solution that does not charge efficiency is planned to be cashable and how
any fees for processing transactions or issuing much is planned to be non-cashable? Making
cards. Additional charges may accrue for a clear statement of the programme’s goals is
services such as consulting, cash transactions crucial to delivering a successful procurement
and advanced management information. For card programme. This statement should be
more information on how to buy a procurement part of a structured business case. For more
card programme and GPC, see “Buying a information on business cases see “Business
solution 1: procurement cards” on page 23. case 1: Analysis” on page 6.
Page 4
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Business
case:
Three steps to
building a business
case for
procurement cards,
including spend
and process
analysis, savings
estimates and
building the final
case.
Page 5
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
strategy.
3. What process is currently being used to
complete these transactions. £100 – £500 30%
Strategy
Procurement cards are a flexible tool, they can < £100 50%
be used to pay a large number of small
suppliers or a small number of large suppliers Fig 1, Correlation between invoice value and volume of invoices
depending on the strategy determined by the
organisation. Procurement cards can also be The diagram above shows the likely ratios of
used for common lower value purchases, or for lower value invoices to high value invoices in a
infrequent, high value items. They can be used typical public sector organisation. The pool of
as part of corporate e-enablement programme invoices that will be available for use with a
for many buyers or for ‘emergency only’ procurement card will be dictated by the
purchases with one or two buyers. The wide transaction limits that an organisation might
variety of uses ascribed to procurement cards place on their card programme. Count the
demonstrates the need for a strategy for using number of invoices in bands from £100 to
procurement cards. The most common
strategy for using procurement cards is to
Page 6
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
£5,000 to identify the number of invoices that combining the invoice analysis and the process
the organisation processes in each value band. analysis the organisation can draft a priority list
for the transactions that are most appropriate
to procurement cards, with frequent and highly
> £5,000 60% inefficient transactions at the top of the list and
infrequent inefficient transactions at the bottom
of the list.
£1,000 - £5,000 18%
Typical transactions that can be moved to
procurement cards are as follows:
£500 - £1,000 10% • Frequent lower value transactions.
• Transactions made by staff working off-
site, e.g. maintenance staff.
£100 - £500 10% • Travel and subsistence transactions.
• Internet purchases.
<£100 2% • ‘One off’ transactions with suppliers who
don’t need to be included in the financial
system’s database of suppliers.
Fig 2, The total value to an organisation of invoices in spend bands
• Cheque payments.
• Temporary staff payments.
Figure 2 shows a typical assessment of the • Cash transactions / imprest accounts.
cumulative value of the invoices being
processed by a public sector organisation. The Step 3: Acceptance analysis
diagram clearly shows that the total value of Having identified and prioritised the key
the spend in transactions under £100 is likely transactions that the organisation needs to
to be around 2% of the organisation’s transfer to procurement cards, it is necessary
expenditure. However, as we see in figure 1, to determine how many of the organisation’s
invoices in this value band accounts for around suppliers are able to accept payment from a
half the invoices processed by the card. Different suppliers will accept different
organisation. cards, but banks and card companies may be
able to help identify which suppliers accept
Step 2: Process analysis payment using their card schemes. It may also
Process analysis is a ‘mapping’ process that be worth approaching some of the suppliers
allows an organisation to understand how who are creating the priority transactions to
purchasing data flows through the identify whether they accept cards and which
organisation, from initial requisition within a cards they accept. Understanding which
department to logging a payment onto the suppliers accept payment by card is important
financial ledger. Staff undertaking process because it will help the organisation
analysis must thoroughly research the understand how many transactions can be
progress of each department’s purchasing moved to procurement cards immediately. This
processes in order to generate a analysis will also identify which suppliers it will
comprehensive flowchart of the different be beneficial to encourage to accept card
methods used to raise orders, process payments in the future
transactions, make payments and reconcile the
transactions. Process analysis will help an The spend and process analysis tasks detailed
organisation determine whether a transaction above are not just appropriate to procurement
can be transferred to procurement cards and cards but can be used to identify the potential
will also highlight the most inefficient savings for any e-procurement initiative.
processes in place within the organisation. By Initiatives such as e-invoicing, e-ordering and
Page 7
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 8
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 9
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Management information
A procurement card programme, when used in
conjunction with reconciliation software that
provides reporting tools, can be used to report
on a wide range of procurement activities,
including departmental, category, cardholder
and programme wide reporting. Reporting
allows project managers to see where
progress is being made, to track the use of
cards and to identify whether the programme is
meeting the targets set out in the business
case.
Page 10
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Manually update
Requisition approval
transaction log
Allocation of each
Raise a purchase
card transaction –
order
electronic
Allocation of each
Purchase order
card transaction –
approval
manual
Filing copies of
requisitions and
orders
Pack and post order
Check supplier
acknowledgement
Procurement
Non procurement card
card reconciliation reconciliation
process process
(monthly)
Allocating Checking
commitment in the cardholder
ledger system statement
Queries with
Checking supplier
cardholder
advice note
statement
Approval of
Allocating accrual in
cardholder
the ledger system
statement
Checking card
Checking supply
summary
invoice
statement
Allocating invoice Approval of card
actual cost in the summary
ledger system statement
Allocation of card
Queries with invoice
summary
details
statement
Reconcilitation of a
query
Creating a BACs or
cheque payment per
supplier
Reconciliation of a
supplier statement
Total
Page 11
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Actual Savings
Business case 3: Savings can now be calculated on a per
annum basis over three years. This allows for
Building the case set up costs and a staggered increase in the
number of card transactions to make an
Having completed the necessary analysis and estimate of the savings available over a three
determined appropriate time savings for tasks year period.
it will be possible to build a detailed business
case for implementing a procurement card Quick business case
programme. A comprehensive business case
1. Identify the top 100 suppliers by the volume of invoices
should including the following sections. they issue.
Be careful not to include suppliers that are expected to
Strategy be involved in any existing e-procurement initiative, such
The strategy should detail the reason for as marketplace.
implementing procurement cards and the
2. Call the suppliers to find out if they accept payment by
success that the organisation seeks to achieve card.
from their use. Be sure you know which card you intend to use, or make
sure you find out which brand of card the supplier can
Scope of the programme accept.
The scope of the programme is defined by the
3. Add up the number of transactions from all the card
total number of transactions that are expected enabled suppliers to determine a total number of
to be transferred to procurement cards transactions that can be put onto to cards immediately.
Transactions from suppliers that don’t take payment by
Time savings card can be added to the list, but an additional cost for
The time savings attributable to the use of a supplier adoption will need to be accounted for.
procurement card. Timings can also be given a 4. Multiply the total number of transactions by an
monetary value by estimating the amount of estimated value for the time saved on each transaction
time saved per transaction and then giving it a (£5 - £30) to create a total number of savings
fiscal value according to the equivalent cost in Remember to increase the saving if the organisation will
time for an administrative staff member. This use some automatic reconciliation software.
will generate a ‘per transaction’ cost saving 5. Estimate the cost of software and other set up fees
which can be multiplied by the number of (£3k - £30k).
transactions that are expected to be Other costs needs to include consulting fees for
transferred to a procurement card. integration and any project management time.
Page 12
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Handling
objections:
How to manage
some common
objections to using
procurement cards,
including, fraud,
spend control and
management
information.
Page 13
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 14
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 15
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 16
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Non-technical controls
Using procurement cards does not prevent
managers from using traditional purchasing
control procedures such as approval of
purchases. A full range of procedural control is
available to organisations using procurement
cards. The only aspect of purchasing that
changes with procurement cards is that
discovery of bad practice by cardholders will
occur at the end of the month, after the
purchase has been made. Whilst this may
seem to run against the grain of traditional
procurement practice, organisations using
approvals can use the approval log to identify
non-approved transactions and act
accordingly.
Page 17
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 18
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 19
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 20
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
linked to the finance system. Provided the logs Once a programme is established, it will be
are kept up to date, a full financial statement possible to review the activity in the
can be generated at any time. The setting up programme, gather evidence on the time taken
and monitoring of such a solution will obviously to manage VAT records, process weekly
require additional resource and expense. transaction logs and monitor cardholder
activity. This work can be compared against
The problem is that in almost all cases these the manual processing of invoices. Using this
issues will have to be handled by the finance evidence will help to identify whether additional
department. It is therefore easy to understand time savings are being made, or whether a
why some finance managers might view process could be improved. Remember, the
procurement card programmes a little non-fiscal benefits of procurement cards may
sceptically. However, all of this ‘extra’ work has be sufficient to the organisation to warrant their
to be offset against the benefits of using a implementation.
procurement card. The task of approving each
individual invoice for payment and logging that Use level 3 enabled suppliers
payment on the financial ledger will, in the If the challenge of using procurement cards to
majority of instances, be more time consuming process level 1 transactions, is estimated to be
than reconciling the VAT for level 1 too burdensome then it may be better to use
transactions. Cards will also remove the task of the cards with suppliers who are level 3
generating payment files, setting up BACS enabled. However, this will restrict the
transactions and dealing with payment queries programme and will likely create work in
from suppliers. Provided efficient processes supplier adoption as the organisation seeks to
are put in place, procurement cards will reduce move suppliers up to being level 3 merchants.
time spent managing payments and will also
free up buyer’s time.
Page 21
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Buying a
solution:
Details of how to
buy a procurement
card solution and
card management
software.
Page 22
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 23
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Non-GPC schemes
If an organisation wishes, they can chose to
approach any card issuing bank to negotiate a
contract for the supply of a procurement card
solution. Choosing a non-GPC solution will
offer an organisation different functionality and
the option to use MasterCard. However, this
needs to be weighed against any likely cost
and the demands of completing an OJEU or
other tender when a well managed agreement
already exists.
Page 24
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 25
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 26
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Implementing:
How to implement a
procurement card
programme,
including how to
resource the
programme, how to
prepare for cards,
how to engage with
suppliers, how to
set up the
programme and
how to roll out the
cards.
Page 27
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 28
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Efficiency manager
In order to recover cashable efficiencies from a
procurement card programme, there will need
to be some involvement from a manager who
is responsible for operational efficiency in the
organisation with the remit to restructure parts
of the organisation in order to recover time
savings made by both buyers and invoice
processing staff. This manager may have a
wide brief for managing operational
efficiencies, beyond the efficiencies linked to
procurement cards.
Involvement: strategic, workload will depend
on the wider efficiency initiatives in place
Page 29
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 30
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 31
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 32
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 33
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 34
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 35
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 36
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Running a
programme:
Guidance on how to
run a programme,
including the day to
day management of
a programme,
securing
compliance to
contracts and
recovering benefits.
Page 37
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Strategic management
Page 38
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 39
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 40
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 41
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Invoice management time savings are also cards to reduce the time spent on raising
increased when card management software is orders, by going directly to suppliers. Cards
being used as this reduces the need for can be used to replace cash transactions
manual keying of information, often from hand made by staff, reducing the risk to staff and the
written purchase orders. risk of fraud.
Material savings
It is worth noting that procurement cards can
also save money by removing the need for
postage, faxing and storage space, as well as
expensive printer cartridges and order pads.
Whilst these savings are likely to be minimal,
once accrued, they may be sufficient to merit
recording as a cashable saving.
Non-cashable savings
Using procurement cards may also create a
range of intangible or non-cashable savings
that the organisation has no intention of
recovering as a cashable saving. Giving
procurement cards to staff performing critical
out-facing tasks such as social work or
teaching allows these staff to focus on
completing their work rather than completing
order forms. Maintenance workers can use the
Page 42
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 43
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Page 44
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Transaction log
Organisations using procurement cards often
require their buyers to complete a transaction
log for every transaction they carry out. The log
ensures that a buyer keeps track of all their
purchases and can compare their monthly
statement to the log to check for unauthorised
transactions or errors.
Page 45
Procurement Cards Guide Guidance Paper Version 1.5.1
www.ticon.uk.com 0207 836 1999 01/04/2008
Credits
Ticon UK Ltd,
146 Strand
London
WC2R 1JD
0207 836 1999
www.ticon.uk.com
Page 46