Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Mark Williams
Dr Mark Simpson
Acknowledgement
First and foremost I would like to thank my Wife and best friend Carole for her
belief in me and her constant support and encouragement when I needed it most.
I would also like to thank my Parents, Sons, family, and friends who have also
dissertation.
Last but not least, I would like to give a very big thank you to Frank Whittle, Mark
Symington and Sarah Landale. They have all been a fountain of ideas,
help, support and guidance this would not have been possible.
2
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Abstract
The following study explores and examines the possible influences sports
activities may have on effectively reducing problematic drug use and the
subsequent crime related to the problem. It will focus predominantly on the 2nd
Chance Sports Programme in County Durham and review the current opinion of
The purpose of this study is to investigate specific themes connected to the use
of sport as a tool in rehabilitating drug using offenders. Firstly, it will examine the
reduction in drug use and offending behaviour. Secondly, it will examine the
social attitudes and opinions vented towards such sports-based interventions for
programmes which have embraced this concept and review both their findings
and outcomes.
A phenomenological approach will be used due to the fact that it will be asking
for their individual perceptions and experiences, and a purposive sample of four
3
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
drug using clients, two sports coaching professionals and two substance misuse
All professionals are currently working with drug using offenders on a regular
Programme and this current research study on the importance of sport and how it
offending behaviour have been strikingly similar among clients, sports coaching
perception has largely been that sporting activities do have a major role to play in
both reducing drug use and offending behaviour. However, there is also a body
study supports the argument that sport does have a major role to play in the
treatment of drug use and in reducing acquisitive crime. It will also argue that
public attitude towards such initiatives rehabilitating drug users and offenders are
extremely negative and that punishment and not rehabilitation is at the forefront
of public opinion. Finally it will argue that the cost effectiveness of these
the programme are more clearly defined. However, the study does support the
argument that drug treatment is cost effective in reducing problematic drug use
and crime.
4
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Content
Chapter 1
Introduction
1) Background 8
Chapter 2
Literature Review
3) Sports Culture 28
Chapter 3
Methodology
1) Preparation 33
2) Sampling 34
3) Interviews 35
5) Analysis 38
6) Ethical Considerations 40
5
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 4
Does it work?
2) ‘Those in Favour 50
Chapter 5
Review of Interviews
Chapter 6
1) Cost Effectiveness 74
2) Social Attitude 79
Chapter 7
Conclusion 89
Chapter 8
6
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
References 133
Glossary
DH Department of Health
FA Football Association
FF Football Foundation
HO Home Office
7
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 1
Introduction
The Background
untested, assumption that sport and physical activities can make an important
contribution to reducing drug use and crime. The provision of sporting facilities as
in several policy statements since the early 1960s, and that policy was reinforced
by the rise in youth unemployment and by the serious urban unrest in the 1980s
The UN Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs of 1961 was the first international
Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction - EMCDDA 2005). The EU Drugs Action
8
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Plan 2005-2008 asks member states to 'make effective use and develop further
Within Britain, sport-based schemes designed to combat delinquency and drug use
have won support from all the major political parties, from the police, the probation
service, and local government and, not surprisingly, from organisations involved in
promoting sport, such as the Sports Council and Sport England. On this basis,
such schemes have attracted large amounts of funding both from the government
and from voluntary sector organisations concerned with drug users and offenders;
at the moment they are of particular interest in terms of the Government’s agenda
on social exclusion.
The research undertaken as part of this study will focus on how clients and
addiction. A brief introduction to the 2nd chance programme and its origins is
The Clients and professionals involved in the 2nd Chance Sports Initiative have
9
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
approach used was ethno-methodological. Interviews did not take longer than 30
minutes and in these interviews clients were asked to briefly describe their
background, outline how long they had be introduced to the programme, how
long they had been accessing the sports provision available and how easy it was
to access the sports programmes. They were also asked to share their opinion
The sports coaching staff and the substance misuse professionals give details of
either sports coaching or substance misuse worker role. Finally their personal
opinions and impressions, gained from their experiences on using sport and
sports activities to engage and to treat problematic drug users and to address
One important point to consider when reviewing the outcomes of the professional
interviews would be that although both the sports coaching staff and the
substance misuse professionals work together and both passionately believe that
the use of sport is extremely beneficial for the clients and their well being, both
However, even though the professionals meet from different cultures and
agendas their opinions and attitudes towards the use of sport as a tool to engage
10
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 2 covers the literature review. After delving into the concept and
reviewing the relevant literature and material available this study can conclude
that there has been a limited amount of research invested in investigating the
links between sport, drug treatment and crime reduction and that a considerable
amount of the research focusing on this concept is mostly directed at youth crime
and drug addiction. There has also been a limited amount of governmental
area. However there has been some notable academic research from both these
shores and beyond which together with a small group of studies, including this
one, form the base of a large amount of the arguments and conclusions.
Chapter 3 looks at the methodology and methods used during conducting the
Chapter 4 will be divided in to the arguments fore and against the idea that sport
can be used as an effective tool in combating drug use and crime. It will discuss,
compare, argue and summarise the main findings and opinions. This study will
argue that sports programmes such as the 2nd chance programme do have a
significant role to play in both the treatment of drug use and in the reduction of
acquisitive crime.
11
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 5 reviews the research material gathered from the client and
construct the conclusion which will indicate that both clients and professionals
Chapter 6 will consider some of the main issues surrounding the cost
towards the use of such initiatives in the rehabilitation of drug using offenders.
out the possible weaknesses and limitations within it, such as the limitations in
size. It will also highlight ideas for further research and debate such as, larger
scale and more longitudinal research studies with a more defined rationale.
research study, such as, letters of invitation, research information and consent
forms. The interview questions and references can also be found in this section.
work for both professionals working in the sports activities field and those
working in the substance misuse and criminal justice fields. It hopes that it will
give useful indications as to how the clients or participants perceive the concept
and the service provision already available and how they feel it can be developed
12
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
directly involved in the programme perceive the concept and its potential.
It is expected that this piece of work, although limited, may have some
contribution in influencing those who have the privilege of policy making and
commissioning schemes and services that utilise the concept of sport as a tool in
reducing drug use and crime. However, as Weiss (1997) so poignantly suggests
‘Nobody in high office reads social science journals, far less papers or books’.
Coalter (2007:15)
Pawson (2006) cited in Coalter (2007:15) suggests that ‘As one ascends the
The study will now briefly examine the interaction between drugs and crime. This
of this study. However, it will give a brief outline of the possible links for the
Crime may result from the illegality of the drug itself, such as possession of, the
13
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Finally, it may be related to the need for acquiring monies to buy the drugs. This
A review of the literature regarding drug abuse and the criminal justice system
(Hough 1996) concluded that, despite the widespread use of illegal drugs, most
drug users are not drawn into other forms of crime. A small minority of drug users
finance at least part of their drug misuse through crime. The variety of sources
includes income, benefits, and gifts, loans, selling property, theft, prostitution and
drug dealing. This review also found that a significant minority of crime is drug-
related, where the proceeds of the offence happen to be spent on drugs, but a
The Drug Interventions Programme is a large scale Home Office funded crime
reduction programme which seeks to get drug using offenders into treatment and
14
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Many have a range of additional problems and difficulties largely resulting from
more suited to their needs and interests and to include accommodation, learning
and skills and employment as part of the essential “wrap around services”.
Since June 2005 a series of football training projects have been run throughout
sports initiative. The 8-week long projects which run for a day each week have
been supported and led by student coaches within the North East’s five main
Sunderland and Durham. Affiliated with the FA, over 400 drug service users
have to date been engaged in sporting activities through this Project. 14 service
users have gained FA coaching qualifications and 1 individual has since found
employment.
involving service users from both Durham and Darlington Drug Intervention
and Lifeline, with NECA leading from Darlington. An average of 25 drug users
took part in the football coaching programme whilst 4 women took part in
activities in the gym. Twelve Durham university students coached the service
15
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
During the summer of 2007 the 2nd Chance Sports Programme was rolled out
throughout the North East replacing the old DIP sports initiative. The programme
Sport England and Northern Rock, as well as retaining the long term funding
commitments from all of the Drug & Alcohol Action Teams (DAATs) in the North
East. The 2nd chance programme opened up to all service users and not only
DIP clients as was originally the case. It also offered a much wider variety of
sports and sports activites, such as, rock climbing, white water rafting and
archery, to name but a few. Durham University actually advertised the possibility
of over forty different sports and has pioneered rowing with the potential of
entering boat crews made up of clients in the local Regatta and other racing
events. The 2nd chance programme in County Durham currently runs weekly
core activities, such as, the Gym, football, trampolining, and kick boxing as well
earlier. Clients are regularly asked for feedback on the events and also surveyed
as to what events and activities they wish to participate. All events and activities
are organised and coordinated by the University coaching staff and the
Chapter 2 will now review the literature used in constructing the relevant
16
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 2
Literature Review
In Britain, as in many other western societies, there has been over the last two or
three decades growing concern over what has been described as 'widespread
drug use amongst very large numbers of young people' (Parker et al., 1998: 1).
In particular, concern has been expressed about the use of illegal recreational
drugs such as cannabis and 'harder' drugs such as cocaine, as well as the many
and various kinds of criminal behaviour said to be associated with drug use
(Boreham and McManus, 2003; Condon and Smith, 2003). This concern has
statistics showed that approximately 4 million people are using at least 1 illicit
drug each year throughout the UK. It is estimated that drug habits cost between
£10 and £18 billion therefore in response to the current problem the government
17
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
provision in 2008 (NTA 2007). In an attempt to address the high levels of illicit
drug use, the national drugs strategy ‘Tackling Drugs Together’ was published in
1995 and the 10 year strategy ‘Tackling drugs to build a better Britain’ 1998. This
strategy has now been review, revamped, and relaunched in April 2008 with just
The interaction between drugs and crime is complex, examining the full extent is
beyond the remit of this study. However, it will give a brief outline of the possible
links for the purpose of this dissertation, its arguments and its outcomes.
Crime may result from the illegality of the drug itself, such as possession of, the
Finally, it may be related to the need for acquiring monies to buy the drugs. This
A review of the literature regarding drug abuse and the criminal justice system
(Hough 1996) concluded that, despite the widespread use of illegal drugs, most
18
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
drug users are not drawn into other forms of crime. A small minority of drug users
finance at least part of their drug misuse through crime. The variety of sources
includes income, benefits, and loans, selling property, theft, prostitution and drug
dealing. This review also found that a significant minority of crime is drug-related,
where the proceeds of the offence happen to be spent on drugs, but a smaller
proportion is drug-driven, where the offence is committed solely to pay for illegal
drugs.
While hard and fast definitions are impossible, the term ’problem drug users’ is
generally employed by drug workers to include those whose drug taking involves
dependency, regular excessive use, or use which creates serious health risks.
users in England and Wales who could benefit from different forms of treatment.
adds that those users whom we regard as problematic typically use large
polydrug use; they generally show signs of dependency; their drug use poses
risks to themselves and others; and they are often extensively involved in crime
Problem drug users are those who could benefit from the services of drug
19
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
about crime and drug use by stating that it is simplistic to assume drug misuse
that problematic drug use often coexists with other deviant behaviour including
associated with the frequency and scale of offending but is much less often
The use of sport has never played a major part in crime reduction or drug
rehabilitation programmes for adults, though it is argued that the Positive Futures
Programme run with Youth Offending Teams (YOTs) and other simular projects
and initiatives have clearly identified the value that sport has in engaging with
hard to reach groups, such as drug using offenders, or have they? Determining
whether sports activites are an effective tool in combatting drug use and crime
Coalter (2007) has examined the presumption that sport has the potential to
and the communities in which they live. Sport is promoted as a relatively cost
effective antidote for a range of issues, such as, social exclusion, drug abuse,
20
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
A large majority of the most recent literature surrounding this concept presents a
political and historical context for increased governmental interest in what has
become known as ‘sport for good’. The literature explores the particular social
issues that governments seek to address through sport, and examines the nature
goes on to say that this is due to the assumption regarding its potential
contribution to addressing the social issues mentioned above and at the same
time being cost effective. However, these new opportunities which have been
The cost implications linked to drug use and crime, especially to the criminla
justice system are not only enormous in monetary terms but also in the price to
society in terms of human dignity. The National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA)
drug-related crime, criminal justice costs, and theft alone. When savings related
to health care are included, total savings can exceed costs by a ratio of 12 to 1.
With such savings reportedly possible it is hard not to justify an increase drug
treatment programs and initiatives. Chapter six will examine the differing views
21
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
The economic costs imposed upon society by the NTORS cohort were largely
due to their criminality. Crime costs made up a substantial proportion of the total
Detailed calculations of the crime costs after NTORS treatments were made both
in terms of offences and client contacts with the criminal justice system (arrests,
court appearances, prison stays etc). Both methods yielded similar results with
considerable reductions in crime costs after treatment. Health and social care
associated with a drop in crime costs from around £6m before treatment to
crime reduction effects. In most cases, the cost of treatment was recouped
A variety of commentators such as, (Coalter 2007 & Nichols 2007) point out that
the effectiveness of sports interventions are not easily measured and therefore
difficult to evidence. They also draw attention to the lack of a strong cumulative
body of research evidence for which to inform policy and practice. In fact, in an
22
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
era of evidence-based policy making, the cumulative evidence base for many
As for the links between sport and crime prevention (Coalter, Nichols, and
Crabbe) argue and discuss the vague and really unexamined claims regarding
sports ability to tackle such issues as anti-social behaviour, crime and substance
misuse. It is argued that this assumption is not a new one, in fact he refers to
Bailey (1978) and the Department of the Environment, white paper (1975:2)
which discuss concerns around ‘boredom and urban frustration’ and it’s
The debate about the relationship between sports participation and crime divides
schemes with limited numbers of offenders or drug users, and is often based on
the drug users or offenders. They are aimed at developing personal and social
transferred to the wider social context and reduce drug use and offending
behaviour. Coalter (1998). Taylor et al (1999), West & Crompton (2001), Nichols
23
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
‘youth at risk’ and run in specific areas for maximum effect. Coalter (2007:116)
With New Labours social inclusion agenda the significance of sport is indicated
Futures. This was established in 2002 and by the end of 2004 had received over
Directorate, Sport England, the Youth Justice Board and the Football Foundation.
Coalter (2007:116). In many circles it is still undecided whether the money spent
on these and other similar initiates are a good investment or could be used more
productively.
The initial 24 Positive Futures projects were directly targeted at 10 – 16 year olds
and little if no funds made available to engage older young people or adults.
However, there are also indications from other initiatives, especially from the
USA that show that sports activities such as, ‘midnight soccer or basketball’
seem to have been associated with reductions in recorded crime. Morgan (1998),
24
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
A Major narrative review of the impacts of sports concluded that, although there
which sport can make to the reduction of the propensity to commit crime, ‘there is
Coalter, Nichols and Crabbe amongst others reiterate throughout there literature
Nichols (2007) amongst others also asks the question ‘Can sport help create an
environment that dissuades young people from crime and how can we better
Nichols has examined eight different sports-led initiatives from around the World
Although Nichols is mostly focusing on youth drug use and crime, this study feels
that the same questions and answers can be used when directed at both adult
drug users and adult offenders. Especially as many of the most problematic drug
25
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
for crime reduction programmes has implications for other forms of programmes
earlier. Understanding these categorisations and choosing the correct type for
any future schemes may be important in the success of the scheme and
critical observers is that, despite the vast numbers of such schemes currently in
operation in the UK, there is very little evidence for their effectiveness in reducing
and preventing crime and drug ‘abuse’(Coalter, 2001; Collins and Kay, 2003;
Dunning and Waddington, 2003; Hartmann, 2001; Long and Sanderson, 2001;
Long et al., 2002; Nichols, 1997, 2004; Robins, 1990). This argument is due to a
26
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
been soft to say the least and without hard facts this concept will always be a
number of theoretical reasons why one might be sceptical about the claims made
on behalf of the effectiveness of such schemes. One frequent justification for the
use of sport in schemes where crime and drug reduction or prevention is the
main objective is that sport can create enjoyment and excitement, and thus
It is certainly the case, as Elias and Dunning (1986) have argued, that sport can
be seen as a ‘quest for excitement’. However, as Crabbe (2000: 383) has noted,
‘this is often for much the same reason that people might also choose to use
this regard, several studies have emphasised the importance that many young
people, particularly young males, attach to the use of legal (alcohol and tobacco)
and illegal drugs (such as cannabis and ecstasy) as one way in which to create
socializing in the company of like-minded friends in their leisure time (see e.g.
Measham et al., 1998; Parker et al., 1998; Pavis and Cunningham-Burley, 1999;
Shildrick, 2002).
27
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
their own sense of self-identity through social relations (Hendry et al., 1993:31-
57).
There is also evidence that sports activity can assist in the treatment of mental
health issues (see e.g. Careless & Douglas 2004, Morris & Faulkner 2003).
positions about the role and value of occupationally-linked activities in every day
life, seem to agree that engagement in physical activity has the potential to add
meaning and purpose to people’s lives. For example, Hammel (2004) argues that
purposeful activities, which would include football, have the potential to add
meaning through doing, being, belonging and becoming, while Dickie et al (2006)
suggests that it is not activity per se that makes the difference, but rather the
transactions that take place linking the person to the situation. If this is the case
and if one concedes that there is a link between problematic drug use and mental
health issues then one can only assume that this evidence also supports the
28
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
'Januform' character, for it has, at least since the late medieval/early modern
syndromes involving what one might call, on the one hand, a 'Dionysian' or
'Epicurean', that is, pleasure-centred, strain, and, on the other hand a 'Stoical' or
'Puritanical' thrust.
The latter ideology found perhaps its clearest expression in the development in
the 19th century of the mem sana in corpore sano ethos, a process which was
bolstered in the wider society by the emergence, on the one hand, of the 'rational
recreation' movement and, on the other, of what might be called the 'sport/health'
particular, with physically dangerous contact sports such as football and rugby,
involves, among other things, the idea that it is 'manly' not only to play such
sports, but also to drink beer and to be able to 'hold your ale', that is to drink
This subculture has also often included the following elements: alcohol-related
initiation rites; ritualised drinking games which had the dual function of, first,
29
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
the singing of songs and the reciting of verses which had explicit sexual themes
and in which the mocking and degradation of females and male homosexuals
Studies of athletes and football clubs found that initiation ceremonies have
become normalised within sports clubs for both male and female athletes and
abuse, ceremonies for both males and females tended to involve the excessive
While there have been fluctuations in the relative emphasis and importance
element came increasingly to the fore, a process that occurred correlatively with
and Waddington, 2003). This is important, for it explains the current pre-
30
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
vehicles of social policy. In this regard, it is important to note that such schemes
are premised on a one-sided perception of sport. That is, they emphasise the
activity in both a physical and a moral sense. Of course, such a perception is not
wholly inaccurate, but it is one-sided and an appreciation of the other side, that
is, of the Dionysian aspects of sporting culture might lead to a more realistic view
towards using such initiatives for the purpose of rehabilitating drug using
offenders, one does not have to look much further than the recent media
attention drawn on to the front pages of many national and local tabloids
regarding drug using offenders receiving free tickets for premier league football
matches.
This story typifies the position of the media and the subsequent reaction of the
law abiding public towards what they feel is preferential treatment for drug using
offenders. However, the chapter will also attempt to highlight how public opinion
can differ when involved in the debate and a rational explanation is given for this
type of intervention.
31
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
covering the concept, the study will focus on three specific themes.
Firstly the argument surrounding the question ‘Can sport be used as an effective
tool to reduce problematic drug use and offending behaviour? This will be the
main focus of argument that will be explored; however, there are two secondary
discussions that will be highlighted by the study. These are the arguments
around the cost effectiveness of these programmes and the social attitudes, both
six will attempt review the debate and construct a conclusion to the arguments as
32
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 3
Methodology
This chapter will outline the progress of the research, the underlying theory of the
considerations.
1) Preparation
Whilst preparing the research, it was decided to use a deductive approach, since
theory and social research’ (Bryman, 2004, p8). It furthermore specifies ‘how
data can be collected in relation to the concepts that make up the hypothesis’
A deductive approach was most suitable, due to personally having come across
and been involved in programmes and concepts similar to these prior to writing
this dissertation. Through being actively involved and discussing the concept with
colleagues it was decided to use this debate as a basis for the study and it began
researching into the concept of using sport as an intervention before starting the
interviewing process.
33
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
During the preparation stage, interviewing, and analysing the data, the study has
scientific model to the study of the social world’ and views ‘that the subject matter
from that of the natural sciences. The study of the social world therefore requires
humans as against the natural orders.’ (Bryman, 2004:13). This approach was
I was also aware that I would use an ethnographic approach, since I would
interview colleagues from a work setting. I have also met and spent time with the
clients before I decided to interview them and thus built up a certain degree of
knowledge about their circumstances, and a certain degree of trust so that they
setting for some time in order to observe and listen with a view to gaining
2) Sampling
34
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
accessibility’ and has a good response rate (Bryman, 2004, p100). As mentioned
before, I knew the clients I have interviewed through my professional life and
spent some time with them prior to interviewing. The Sports Coaching Staff and
the Substance Misuse professional I interviewed were people who I have worked
along side for some time and throughout the duration of my research.
However, a critique of this type of sampling is that ‘The data will not allow definite
and hopefully will, provide a springboard for further debate and research’
3) Interviews
concerned with the question of how individuals make sense of the world around
them and how in particular the philosopher should bracket out preconceptions in
his or her grasp of that world’ (Bryman, 2004, p13). Also, this philosophy, as
matter of the natural sciences and the social sciences’ (Bryman, 2004. p14).
It appreciates that ‘social reality has a meaning for human beings and therefore
human action is meaningful – that is, it has a meaning for them and they act on
the basis of the meanings that they attribute to their acts and to the acts of
others’ (Bryman, 2004, p14). This philosophy is a useful tool to understand and
35
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
interpret my interviewees’ actions from their point, regardless if they are clients or
professionals.
Two slightly different interview guides were designed to focus on the client’s
perspective, and that of the professional’s points of view and attitudes. They
were directed specifically towards the 2nd Chance Programme and the concept of
sport as a tool in both drug treatment and reducing crime. Both interview guides
scope and therefore the interviews were of a slightly more unstructured nature.
specific topics to be covered, but the interviewee has a great deal of leeway in
how to reply’ (Bryman. 2004, p321). Considering the circumstances of the clients
I intended to interview, I felt that a stricter semi-structured guide would give them
more confidence in talking about their experiences, since they felt more
comfortable when confronted with stricter guidelines and given less leeway.
The professional interview guide was slightly more unstructured to give the
guides differed slightly, they still gave the interviewees the power to decide to talk
about issues they considered as important or relevant, and the entire interview
36
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
their human character’ (Gillham, 2005, p8). It furthermore is easier to probe and
Whilst constructing both guides, I paid attention that questions were open and
ordered, and that one question flows reasonably into the other, but yet stayed
In general, interviews did not take longer than 30 minutes and usually took place
in venues that were familiar to the participants, such as, the sports facilities they
after interviewees gave their consent. The participants had the right of receiving
a transcribed version of their interview, which they indicated on the consent form
(Gillham, 2005, p14). Prior to interviewing the participants were informed of their
37
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
it had taken place. The transcription helped to code the statements appropriately,
and to make sense of the data collected. I transcribed interviews word by word,
but left out exclamations, such as ‘ehm’, and pauses. Neither did I indicate words
tone and pace get lost (Gillham, 2005, p121), which in turn might have an impact
The identity of the participants has been coded for use in referencing and to keep
their anonymity. They have been coded as follows: All the Professionals
interviewed will start with the letter (P) those who are drug workers will be coded
as (PDW) and then their number 1 or 2. Sports Coaches similarly will be coded
(PSC) and then their number. The Clients will be numbered I to 4 and put into
sex. There is only one female interviewee who will be coded (FSU1) while the
5) Analysis
38
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
After transcription carefully and systematically reviewed the data looking for
themes which I had integrated into the semi structured interview questions.
Themes such as, how did you find out about the programme? How do you think
the programme has benefited you? And how would you like to see the
programme develop?
The study could then easily compare the client’s answers and views to gain a
general overview of opinion. (See chapter 6) This method also highlighted any
new issues that may arise. The same approach was adopted for the
professional’s analysis but this time the themes were of a slightly different nature.
Themes such as, their personal and professional opinion on the utilisation of
sports activities in addressing drug misuse and criminal behaviour, or how they
The comments from the themes were grouped together and from that it was
easier to gain a broad idea of the views shown. (See chapter 6) By using the
themes it was also easier to gain a general overview and deduce a conclusion
By comparing these findings with those from similar projects using the same
concepts of sport to reduce drug use and crime, I have been able to in some way
39
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
finding) has its pitfalls. Silverman (2000) suggests that this approach
goes on to state that if using this generalisation method that one must
inspect and compare all data till your generalisation is able to apply to every
single gobbet of relevant data you collected. This he calls ‘Comprehensive data
treatment’.
6) Ethical Considerations
Ethics play a mayor role whilst carrying out research. As Gillham stresses (2005,
aware of that power and handle it with care; otherwise it is easy to exploit and
Whilst preparing, carrying out and evaluating the interviews, I adhered to the 4
main areas of ethical principles, suggested by Diener and Crandall (in Bryman,
issues I could encounter from the beginning of my research until after the project,
40
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
proposed by Miles and Huberman (in Punch, 2006, pp277-278). The ethical
principles suggested by Diener and Crandall merge into the issues mentioned by
Miles and Huberman, and made me think more thoroughly about my research
Miles and Huberman’s ethical issues (in Punch, 2006, pp277-278) are divided
into three sub-categories. Early in the project I needed to think about the
carry out the research personally, how I could ensure informed consent, and
finally, what the benefits, costs and reciprocity are likely to be.
During the project I needed to be aware of the likelihood of risks, and who might
be at risk. Furthermore, I might come across issues of honesty, trust, privacy and
confidentiality, especially since I have spent time with the clients before the
interview and would most likely spend time with them after it. I also needed to
Lastly, after all interviews had been conducted and transcription had taken place,
I had to think about the research integrity and quality. I had to reflect if the study
standards. Then, I needed to clarify the ownership of the data and the research’s
conclusions, namely, who owns the collected material, and how would the study
be distributed. Finally, I had to be aware of the possible use and misuse of the
41
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
I had to ensure that the data collected was correct and appropriate for me to
use. I also needed to decide if the data collected, regardless if it would be chosen
As mentioned before, ethics play a big part in carrying out a research study, and I
However, thanks to the support and guidance I have received I could carry out a
In concluding this chapter this study would advocate the use of realist evaluation
Chapter 4 will now explore in depth the arguments both for and against the use
of sport as an effective tool in combating drug use and crime. However, the
arguments that criticise such programmes are directed more towards the lack of
‘hard’ or significant evidence in support of them rather than the concept itself.
Furthermore, they argue that the rationale behind such programmes is in many
cases, weak and not measurable and until this is addressed it would be incorrect
42
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 4
“Does it Work”?
The critical question is: do such schemes work? In other words is there any
evidence to suggest that such schemes have a significant impact either on the
“Sport has an invaluable role to play in improving the health and well-
being of communities. It can make individuals healthier and
communities more vibrant, by reducing health inequalities, lowering
long-term unemployment, cutting crime, and delivering better
qualifications, but also by developing pride among individuals,
strengthening community spirit, and empowering communities so
that they are able to run regeneration programmes themselves”.
RT Hon Richard Caborn MP Cabinet Office (2005:4)
with the Labour government’s social inclusion policies (see e.g. Collins and Kay,
Nichols (1997) attempts to review the most commonly used rationales which can
43
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
3 3. Physical fitness.
Another two, so called, positive key points which are commonly used regarding
the relationship of sport and physical activity reducing drug use and crime are
that they reduce boredom; and decrease the amount of unsupervised leisure
time.
“It was something that you planned ahead Thursday, it was like “oh
Thursday – we’ve got sports that day.” Everyone was looking
forward to it and nobody wanted to miss it.”
(Participating Client 2006 DIP Evaluation)
“It kills time, and it’s a healthy way of killing time. It’s the whole point.
If they’re not engaged in something and doing something then they
will start sitting around getting bored, and boredom leads to mischief
(which) leads to bad habits, and that’s the whole ball game.”
(Participating Worker 2006 DIP Evaluation)
depression, distractibility and loneliness (Coalter et al. 2000; McGiboney & Carter
1988 in Reid et al.1994). In addition, there is consensus that if young people lack
stimulation and have little to do they will seek their own, often antisocial, activities
44
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
‘It gives us summit to do. It gives us summit to look forward too every
week. Keeps us a bit fitter and keeps me out of trouble, dunnit’?
(MSU 2)
they are poorly developed on a theoretical level and their relationships with each
another are not clearly articulated. Nichols suggests that it is a matter of concern
that, despite many years of funding for such schemes, no clear rationale has yet
been developed for programmes that use sport as a means of reducing illicit drug
use or criminal behaviour. Does it matter? He points out that we could, adopt the
approach which suggests that such schemes work even if we not understand
why they work. However this approach is inadequate for three reasons. Firstly,
there is no clear evidence that these programmes do indeed reduce drug use or
crime. Secondly one of the reasons for a lack of evidence is the poorly developed
outcomes of the programme with reference to their impact on drug use and crime
reduction. Thirdly, a clear rationale would inform the design of programmes and
There are also other arguments that arising from the claim that participation in
sport leads to improved self-esteem, a claim which has been made in a number
of studies such as, Collins et al (1999), Crabbe (2000), and DCMS (2001).
There are several problems here. Firstly, the increased self-esteem which may
45
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
is in the nature of sport that there are winners and losers; if enhanced self-
esteem is a consequence of winning then what, we may ask, is the impact on the
self-esteem of those who are the losers? In addition, the nature of the alleged
link between enhanced self esteem and reduced levels of drug use criminal
some situations the drug use-crime nexus can itself provide meaning and
Furthermore, there are a number of theoretical reasons why one might be sceptical
about claims about the effectiveness of such schemes. For example one of the
principle reasons why sport is used in drug prevention and treatment interventions
However, as Crabbe (2000) has noted, this is often for much the same reason that
they might also choose to use illicit drugs, become involved in criminal activity or
‘it is within this context that attempts to draw mutually exclusive boundaries
between sport and drugs use, or “good” and “bad” behaviour, become
problematic’.
46
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Secondly, Crabbe notes that sport is just one of a range of leisure options and that
the relationship between sport and other leisure options is empirically variable. For
example, football is played by over 2 million people in the United Kingdom, but
they may play football alongside other leisure pursuits which positively promote
drug use and other deviant behaviour; a good example would be the heavy
Thirdly, Crabbe notes that in terms of the degree to which sport can influence
exhilaration, confrontation, financial reward, the overcoming of fear and the joy of
celebration can also be achieved through crime and drug use. Indeed, he notes
and socially cohesive nature, it might with equal validity be noted that sport
may be licensed in ritualised fashion and given meaning through their association
drug use and crime, have frequently used sport and leisure as a major activity.
reducing either drug use or crime. For example, Writing in 1990, Robins noted
47
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
that 'research into the relation between sport and delinquency has been virtually
non-existent in the UK' (1990:1). One of the few systematic studies which existed
at that time was that by Coalter (1989) who, following a review of the literature on
the subject was unable to conclude that there is a correlation between high levels
of sports participation and low levels and frequency of delinquency among young
people in the UK. Beyond Coalter's review, however, Robins observed that there
It was in this context that Robins critically examined all the major programmes
which had then been set up with the aim of using sport and recreation as part of
designed to rehabilitate young offenders - and Robins (1990: 92) concluded that
come by'. He adds that an additional problem, was that none of the programmes
available, was generally sketchy. He also noted that 'no clear picture of aims and
objectives and their underlying rationales emerge' Robins, (1990: 88). See also
48
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Gratton and Taylor concluded that, 'hard evidence in support of this argument (of
behaviour) is difficult to come by' (1991, p. 66). There are considerable difficulties
the excitement derived from drug use or crime, however they do acknowledge
Some claim that the inherent benefits of sport are that it improves personal fitness
if one does enough of it, and if one avoids injury. (The Department for Culture,
Media and Sport 2002). It is also associated with good mental health. However, as
noted by Nichols (2007) this still leaves the question of how this relates to drug and
crime reduction. One of the most simplistic explanations for sports programmes
effectiveness in reducing drug use and crime is that while on a programme the
participant is not able to take part in crime at the same time. This obvious
programme in relation to the cost of alternatives, for example, prisons, and the long
programme might reduce crime is if the programme takes place on premises that
49
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
would otherwise be used for, and be the object of, criminal behaviour. (Crabbe, T.
2000; Coalter, F. 2007; Hartmann, D. & Depro, B. 2006; Measham, F. & Aldridge,
after-school activities to young people between the time school activities finish
and 6.0 p.m. This has resulted in a substantial reduction in vandalism to the
school premises. Cost savings from reduced vandalism have exceeded the costs
Arguments and critique such as these mentioned so far should sound a warning
crime.
There have been many valid and justifiable arguments put forward in defence of
the arguments that these types of initiatives and in fact the concept itself have little
evidence that it actually works. However, let us now move away from this level of
general scepticism and examine some of the more empirically based studies
conducted within the UK, such as, the 2nd Chance Sports Programme which has
Those in favour
50
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
local ex- and stabilised drug users with a range of sporting and personal
of observation of the project, that the participants ‘are benefiting from the
alternative focus that the sports activities provide and the need to remain “stable”
sports programme itself. Crabbe’s evaluation is, on the whole, a positive one,
information, which would provide a more reliable basis for judgements about the
51
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
As mentioned earlier, the original pilot for the now established 2nd chance
Programme was commisioned by the Home Office (HO) and coordinated by thier
North east Office (GONE). Its implimentation was through the provision of the
also been supported by the Football Association who have been actively involved
The idea was to use sport as a means of increasing client engagement and
helping to effect change in their lives. Initially the work began as a football
programme but now a whole range of sports are available. One of the important
principles is that it is a regular, structured activity, and not a one off tournament
or “afternoon out”. The structure is what helps to build a sense of purpose and
achievement.
Sven Goran Eriksson (The then) England manager says: 'Football can be a
powerful way of reaching and helping people with issues and problems. Positive
Futures is one the schemes that is doing just that. The players, everybody at The
FA and myself are proud to be associated with initiatives making a real difference
It is commonly perceived by those directly involved with the scheme and those
who supply the bulk of the funding that the programme has already shown that
there is clear evidence that sport and the accompanying improvement in health
52
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
can help to raise self-esteem and self-worth both of which are major deficiencies
It is also argued that achieving fitness and a level of proficiency in a sport can
knowledge (Rhodes et al., 2000) and for a small percentage it can offer
possibility of employment.
teaches a respect for health and the workings of the body which acts as an
excellent cognitive reinforcer for individuals going through drug treatment and
rehabilitation. It also claims that sport and health is an interest for a significant
number of men and women on the programme and can be used as a valuable
effectively, overcome barriers and develop social skills (Rhodes et al, 2000)
One of the arguements used to justify this stance is that the appeal of sport and
health can be seen by the fact that many prisoners engage in PE and sports
programmes whilst in prison and experience the positive effects, but only a tiny
53
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
drug use and social exclusion once they leave prison. Foster (2000)
Hendry et al (1993) found during a recent study of over 10,000 young people in
perceived physical and mental health, for males. This was an especially strong
relationship for males involved in team sports although the relationship was not
idea that an active leisure life can improve overall self-esteem and
mental and physical health. Put simply, leisure has a big part to play
(1997:184)
Government Office North East (GONE) compiled its first evaluation of the
individual areas of the North East, however, the findings from all five areas of the
North East were interestingly simular at the time, however, although many of the
fndings from this piece of research maintain the same attitudes and enthusiasm
to the potential of the programme there has been a decline in the levels of
54
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Findings identified that the partnership approach between the DIPs and other
participating drug services and the Universities has been successful with all the
key individuals involved taking an active involvement in the project and working
well together and that the success of the Project is dependent upon collaborative
working between drug service agencies. Also that the linked but separate
provision of drug rehabilitation in a sporting context and the use of sports within
care plans has been extremely attractive to drug service users. (GONE 2006)
The establishment of mutual respect and trust between participants, coaches and
key workers was key to the engagement and retention of the service users over
the eight-week period. The findings indicate that there are clear rehabilitative
Sport is attractive to large numbers of service users and can provide a context for
For some drug users, involvement in the Project has provided the basis of an
alternative community with a different set of ‘rules’ to those which govern habitual
drug use - service users commented on the value they placed on the regular
context” they normally associate in. However, as we have already observed this
55
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
The Programme clearly demonstrated the benefits of using the University and its
students as coaches. For the service users these include a wide range of high
standard sports facilities, an insight into education opportunities and contact with
coaches to answer related questions, the involvement of ‘non’ drug users in the
Programme which “plays down” the drug histories of participants and offers
positive role models as ‘mentors’ for the service users. The University also
On a broader scale the Programme has also highlighted the benefits to the wider
excluded group with a socially privileged group and bridging this gap develops
community cohesion. By retaining drug users in the Programme the initiative has
routes into employment. The secondary benefits to society are found as the
Here are some of the recorded comments from the key Workers and Clients
involved in the programme in 2006. Their comments support strongly the views
of those who argue that sport is an effective tool for reducing drug use and crime
although only one of the clients specifically mentions drug use and crime. The
main theme from these comments is bordom and having something to look
56
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
forward too, which is one of the main arguements used to justify such
interventions.
“With sports it gives you something to do, it keeps you off the streets
instead of robbing places or taking drugs or anything like that. It’s
interactive, and it gives you more opportunity to do things in the
future.” (Participating client GONE report 2006)
“It gave us something to do, the boredom was what it was for me -
nay more boredom on a Thursday, it took away the boredom.”
(Participating Client GONE report 2006)
“It has made me want to do more sports, yeah, definitely. It’s opened
up a whole load of more opportunities.”
(Participating Client report 2006)
In both the 2006 evaluation and within this study the service users placed a great
deal of emphasis on the benefits they considered sport brought about for them as
individuals. Broadly, the reason fell into six categories which in brief are: sport
motivates; it makes those involved less inclined to use drugs; it increases energy;
57
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
well being and it can be used as tool to engage other drug users in a positive
activity.
treatment and rehabilitation of drug using offenders comes from the Blenheim
project in London.
‘If Tim Sampey and Terry Swinton had been asked in December
2003 what they would be doing in four years’ time, neither could
have imagined that they would have just celebrated the first
anniversary of a Saturday Social club they helped to set up. At the
time they were both still hooked on heroin and desperately trying to
kick respective 28 and 10- year heroin habits. But after getting
involved with the Blenheim Project in Kensington, the pair began a
journey of recovery which culminated with the former drug users not
only beating their addictions, but also giving something back to the
community. Sampey had talked his mate into playing badminton and
at the following Service Users Drug Group meeting they suggested
setting up a badminton club for people like themselves in recovery.
They were given an initial amount of £500, to buy some rackets,
hired some courts and to start the club’. DDN (2007:1)
‘We felt strongly that the treatment system of the borough was very
good, says Sampey. ‘However at the time there was no aftercare –
and aftercare is vital. ‘When you come off drugs you have a life to
rebuild. If you are abandoned at that point you are bound to go back
onto the drugs. You have time to fill and we wanted to come up with
something that would fill that time.’ DDN (2007:1)
Although this can be used as evidence supporting the positive effect of sport on
specific individuals, it still does not evidence that sport was a major factor in
turning around their lives for the better. Furthermore, the most stanch critics may
argue that if the participants had been stable and motivated enough to organise
58
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
and participate in such an activity they may have been stable and motivated
The alternative High project run at Hindley Prison and Young Offender Institution
been brought in and began to teach a group of teenage inmates how to climb a
wall. The concept was to combine physical activities with essential life skills, such
excellent initiative for Hindley that will have very positive benefits for the young
people we care for.’ While longer outcomes of the programme will need to be
monitored, staff at Hindley are satisfied that the two-month programme fulfilled its
aims. ‘We can say with some certainty that as the programme has progressed,
each individual has gained confidence and developed new skills, says Graham
Smith. ‘Their progress becomes evident to them when they read their own
‘I learned different things like rock climbing and team work. I feel glad
that I've done it as it’s improved my confidence. When I get out I
would definitely do something like that again if I got chance, but
before doing this I wouldn't have wanted to’.
59
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Another interesting point that has arisen whilst reviewing the effectiveness of
these schemes, is that there are indications that a key factor in the success or
failure of projects was accredited to the personalities of the coordinator and the
other professional staff drawn in to work on the project. Specifically, Davis and
Dawson (1996:30) suggested that it is important that project workers should have
‘authority’ in the eyes of the participants attending these projects but it was also
important that they should not be seen as authority figures; their authority must
lie in relevant knowledge and practice and it is also important that project leaders
have a high level of skill in the core activity (see also Coalter, 2001; Collins and
This chapter has examined the argument both for and against and it concludes
that there is a strong argument in favour of the use of sport in combating drugs
and crime. However, it also concludes that the argument against is not so much
against the concept but more the lack of ‘hard’ the evidence and weakness of
their rationale. Chapter 5 will examine and comment on the research data
60
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 5
Review of interviews
This Chapter will review the research collected from the semi structured interview
of both Professionals and clients. The study will focus on the themes previously
identified, review the comments and make a general conclusion before a final
All professionals stated that they had become involved with the programme due
to there job role. The University coaching staff had been directed to assist in the
community engagement policy. The workers both welcomed the challenge and
As for the drug worker, they both became involved due to the initial programme
being rolled out as a DIP initiative with the DIP teams given sole responsibility to
get the programme up and running. Although the workers welcomed the initiative
here where issues around the extra work load heaped upon them and also as the
61
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
support from government office. This automatically raised eye brows and caused
‘In a previous life I worked for the national probation service that ran
a similar scheme as part of semi structured activities on the old
DTTO programme. Sport as ever, particularly football, is very popular
with our client group and seems to work well in occupying their time
in a constructive way’.
When asked how it had benefited their services, there was a marked difference
between the coaching staff and the drug workers around this question although
all gave positive responses. However the coaching staff focused more on the
student participation and the image of the university, where as the drug workers
‘It has most definitely given me a well needed option for a structured
activity and an opportunity to engage with some of my clients in a
different enviroment. As for the service it has given all workers the
62
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
same benefits of engaging with their clients and has given the
service a positive activity to promote itself’. (PDW 2)
‘I firmly believe that all of the clients which I have nominated to the
scheme over the duration of the project have benefited from the
scheme. I think the most reoccurring positive feedback which I hear
from my clients is that it has given them something constructive to do
and it has broken the monotony of everyday. (PDW 1)
Interestingly, when asked how they would like to see the programmes develop
there seemed to be a consensus that the programme should and would evolve
by utilising more service user involvement. The use of mentor and volunteer
the travelling and logistical issues and a more coordinated wider ranging
there is also mention of logistics again and public perception which we will be
63
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
‘Funding, high level commitment and commitment from the front line
staff to continue with the work already implemented. It is imperative
that the belief, motivation and commitment continue from front line
staff as without this the whole pack of cards falls down’. (PDW 2)
programme. It is also very much the same opinion generated from the vast
recently, such as, the GONE report (2006) Positive Futures review (Sport
England 2002), the Splash Scheme (2001) and the Summit Programme
‘I feel the scheme has also given a lot of clients the opportunity to
discover attributes they probably thought they didn’t possess, both
physical and emotional’...
64
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
A for the negative aspects of the programme, the burden on a small group
of individuals such as the DIP team and the university coaching staff
There is also a worry that without wider support from all drug services and
‘As I said earlier, I feel that other organisations within our field need
to be playing a more significant part. I sense that because it was
the DIP who played such a crucial role in setting up and
implementing the scheme, it seems the perception that the DIP is
purely responsible for the scheme has stuck.
Probation, NECA, NHS Trust, DAAT and others all need to be
adding their influence and finance to the scheme.
‘If it does not develop there is a risk that it will just fizzle out which
will be very deflating and demoralising for those who have been
regular core participants. The concept, although fantastic for those
who enjoy it only targets and benefits those who enjoy sport. What
is there for those who don’t? The programme is currently
dependent on a few passionate people who believe in it and with
out their enthusiasm may again just fizzle out.
professionals that sport is an effective tool for combating both drug use and the
65
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
effective method in relation to prison but how cost effective is debateable. There
is importantly mention to the human and social costs which are difficult if not
impossible to measure.
After listening to the professionals and evaluating there comments the study can
there clients and in doing so is benefiting society in general. They feel that it is an
66
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
use and the client’s involvement in acquisitive crime. There is a genuine belief
that it improves both the client’s physical and mental health including lifting self
esteem and confidence. During the interviews the commitment and passion
shown by the workers was more than evident which is exceptionally difficult to
measure or document but essential when trying to understand how and why
As with the professional interviews this study will examine the research data
commenting on the responses given the study will attempt to end this section by
All clients recorded that their first knowledge of the 2nd chance programme came
from their key workers at their local treatment centres. Interestingly (MSU 2)
mentions that this contact with the programme encouraged him to attend the
‘My key worker at the treatment centre told me about it and she
picked me up and took me to the bus the first time I went’ (MSU 1)
‘Me mate said about it first like, then I met the workers on the bus
and then I started too got to the treatment centre more regular’.
Surprisingly, none of the clients interviewed had experienced any similar sporting
programmes since leaving school other than the use of the gym facilities whist in
67
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
‘No, nowt like this, I’ve done sports at school and stuff but nowt like
this’.
‘I’ve been involved with this a couple of year but that’s all like’.
‘No, nowt like this, I wish there was more like this. I could do with
cumin’ here every day like’.
‘No, I’ve never been involved in anything like this, no since school
when we did different stuff. I think it’s a really good thing coz there’s
nothing round here to do especially if you’re on drugs. They should
do it more like every day not just once a week’.
The overwhelming response when asked what the 2nd chance programme has
done for them was that of relief from boredom which again confirms the general
consensus of results from other similar projects and programmes, such as the
GONE report (2006) Positive Futures review (Sport England 2002), the Splash
Scheme (2001) and the Summit Programme (2002). There is also a theme of
‘It gives us summit to look forward to and gets us out of the house,
like I said I wish there was more like this around our way for
everybody to use, especially me and me mates’.
‘It’s helped us socialise more and get us out the house, its given us a
goal about what I want to do with me self and everything, coz I
wanna do the football coaching course, refereeing course and look
68
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
for like jobs and that. The coaching courses are summit I deffo
wanna do coz I missed out last time on it’.
Again, when asked how they would like to see the programme develop the
general consensus was for more time dedicated on these sports activities. The
majority would like the programme to run on a daily basis and with a wider range
avoid travelling and a notable interest in more varied activities not just the
‘I’d make it every day me, and I’d do it in Peterlee coz that would
make it easier and save money for the bus which we could use on
other stuff. I’d like to do more tournaments other places so we meet
other people and see other places. I’d also get more choices for stuff
to do’.
‘I’d do a bit more outings, you know more outings, the lads wanna do
some other things an all which would be go but for me just a few
more outings. I enjoy it the way it is really, maybe twice a week or
more’.
‘I’d do it so we could come every day and that there was more things
going on like more stuff for the girls coz not all the girls like footie, I
do but some don’t and there should be stuff for them. I’d also go on
more trips coz they are mint, especially the white water rafting, mint’.
Most of the negative comments are in fact positive comments towards the
programme. The negative aspects mentioned are that it is only on one day a
69
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
week and that the numbers participating should be increased. Again the fact that
they would like a wider variety of activities is a positive comment towards the
comment regarding more and a wider range of activities for female clients. This is
an area which both the 2nd chance programme and all other initiatives using a
‘Don’t like the way there getting less people coming coz they might
stop it if there aint enough people coming. Another thing is I’d like to
do some different stuff and like I said before I’d like to have every
day’.
‘Not really, only that it’s not on enough and that it’s a bit far away
from my house. Maybe that more people should be coming, coz
there used to be loads more every week but they’ve stopped
coming’.
‘No, it’s done great for me, nothing at all; the people are great and
that’.
‘More stuff and more stuff for girls like they do in Sunderland, that
scheme sounds mint and we would love summit like that’.
The positive aspects of the programme highlighted by the clients are again
research studies around the affect of sport on drug use and crime. The first
argue that this type of intervention does have a significant effect in the treatment
‘Keeps me out of bovver dunnit? This is one of the main arguments but it also
70
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
raises the issue of boredom which again is a theme throughout the client
interviews and the link between boredom and subsequent drug use and crime.
Notably there is little reference hear or through the other questions as to the
‘Keeps me out of bovver dunnit? (laugh) no, seriously its good coz it
gives ya summit to do and stuff you like so that keeps your mind off
all the other stuff going on. I’ve met some mates and got a bit fitter
which has also been a good thing. I get come out and come to
Durham, it’s really nice here and the people are nice too’. (MSU 1)
‘It gives us summit to do. It gives us summit to look forward too every
week. Keeps us a bit fitter and keeps me out of trouble, dunnit’?
(MSU 2)
‘Everyone gets along, it’s a good day or a couple of hours out, I really
enjoy cumin’ and never miss it’. (MSU 3)
‘Meeting people and getting out, doing stuff that’s good for you and
stops you getting bored. I’ve also done my level 1 coaching badge
and I wouldn’t have done that if it wasn’t for this programme’. (FSU
1)
Overwhelmingly the clients questioned believe that this and other programmes
with similar aims are most definitely beneficial to both reducing drug use and
indirectly through the responses and is seemingly developing into the main issue
71
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Yeah deffo, it’s like when you’re in jail and you go to the gym all the
time which makes you feel good and takes your mind off all the crap
that’s going on. If I wasn’t here I’d be at home bored, probably think
about drugs or go out with me mates and get up to all sorts of stuff.
This gives us summit else to do that’s why I want it every day then I’d
stop getting into bovver and help with using the drugs’. (MSU 1)
‘Course they do, that’s what they are here for innit? It keeps you out of
grafting coz that’s what you do when you’re bored and on the gear.
Since I’ve been going to ESMI I’ve been off the gear and stuff like this
keeps us busy so I don’t go back on it’. (MSU 2)
‘Definitely, definitely, like me self and the other lads have played
football all our lives and this is getting us back it to it so it is really
good, definitely. Any thing beats going to jail or getting it trouble so it’s
good yeah! (MSU 3)
‘Yeah, I think so, coz it gives you something to look forward to and is
always there even when you are feeling bad. The people are nice and
I think that if these things where there every day I think it would help a
lot of people’. (FSU 1)
When asked about what other activities they would be interested in the response
can again be perceived as a positive one as the clients seemed to want more
activities to build on the current programme format. However, some of the ideas
are although interesting somewhat unlikely in the current climate due to them
being expensive and also may not be practical especially as they are not main
fishing and would give both the client and the key worker the ability to spend
some quality time together which could be beneficial in building their relationship.
I’m nuts me, i’d like to go rock climbing on real mountains not just
indoors although that was ok. I’d like to do go-karting, is that a sport?
Well i’d like to do that and sailing or rowing. We talked about just doing
snooker or pool, some of the lads used to go but its nt on any more.
Maybe they can do more indoor sports like that as well. Any thing
really, its worth trying them if you haven’t tried them before and then
you can choose afterwards, cant ya’? (MSU 1)
72
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
‘More footie would be good and I like swimming too. Me and the lads
here have talked about going on a weekend camping trip or doing
some outward bounds stuff. I like fishing but I don’t know if they would
wanna do that like. (MSU 2)
‘More things for girls and more trips out, like to the white water rafting
or rock climbing. I’d like to learn to drive; do you think they will do that?
No, more trips out, maybe camping or visiting other programmes’.
(FSU 1)
After reviewing the results of the research this study concludes that there is an
overwhelmingly positive response to the 2nd chance programme and the general
other studies the issue of relieving boredom has been highlighted by both
The following chapter will delve deeper into the discussion around cost
also examine social attitude and public opinion towards these rehabilitative
initiatives.
73
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 6
1) Cost Effectiveness
The cost of crimes committed by the high-rate offenders accounted for 95 per
cent of the total crime costs NTORS (2005:3).There were many economic
benefits from drug treatment, based solely on costs of crime. The reduced costs
treatment and demonstrated the value of addiction treatment. Even without the
costs of crime to society, the financial costs of treating drug dependent patients
of the reduced victim costs of crime, as well as cost savings within the criminal
justice system. Initial calculations based upon savings associated with victim
costs of crime and reduced demands upon the criminal justice system, estimated
74
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
that for every extra £1 spent on drug misuse treatment, there was a minimum
However, this figure is one of much debate and some observers believe it to be
Other research has produced similar findings. The National Treatment Outcomes
Research Study (NTORS) compiled by the National Treatment Agency (NTA) the
Home Office (HO) and the Department of Health (DH) concluded that the
economic costs imposed upon society by the NTORS cohort were largely due to
for only six per cent of costs. Other studies of drug treatment have found that the
benefits vary dramatically and can be between 2.8 and 18 times greater than the
costs (Ettner et al, (2006). French et al. (2004) Godfrey, Stewart, & Gossop,
Detailed calculations of the crime costs after NTORS treatments were made both
in terms of offences and client contacts with the criminal justice system (arrests,
court appearances, prison stays etc). Both methods yielded similar results with
considerable reductions in crime costs after treatment. Health and social care
75
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
associated with a drop in crime costs from £5.8m before treatment to £1.8m at
Costs to the criminal justice system are only one element of the costs of crime
and the true cost savings to society are greater than these crime-focused
more importantly there is the cost to the user themselves such as, their physical
The cost is not only enormous in monetary terms but also in the price to
drug-related crime, criminal justice costs, and theft alone. When savings related
to health care are included, total savings can exceed costs by a ratio of 12 to 1.
With such savings possible it is hard not to justify increased drug treatment
76
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Other cost-effectiveness and cost-benefit studies carried out in the US have also
crime reduction effects. In most cases, the cost of treatment was recouped
This study draws attention to the fact that all of these cost-benefit studies
a wise public investment. However, studies did not address critical questions
facing providers regarding the most cost-effective treatments. There are only a
are built in to ‘sport in the community programmes’, they tend to be applied rather
inconsistently and the emphasis is often placed upon demonstrating the ‘benefits’
afforded individual participants on the programme and not the cost effectiveness
of the programme itself. (See e.g. Crabbe, 2000; Long et al., 2002; Nichols,
77
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Assuming the consensus of the vast majority who support the theory that
crime is correct, then we must assume that sports interventions initiates as part
of the treatment programme must also be a cost effective tool, or should we?
One of the most basic theories often used to explain the benefits of sports
activities in reducing problematic drug use and especially crime is that while they
(the participants) are actively involved in a sports activity, they cannot be out
relation to the cost of alternatives, for example, prisons, and the long term impact
might reduce crime is if the programme takes place on premises that would
This study would recommend that future programmes develop and adopt a more
rigorous evaluation system which will be able to justify the cost effectiveness and
benefits of the respective scheme. This study will suggest that larger scale
78
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
rates of both groups. This method, and the use of a reconviction predictor score
developed by the Home Office, has been previously used by Nichols & Taylor
This study would also suggest that the aims and objectives be determined as to
treatment states. If however it is the quality of life and the well being of the client
that is the focus then this needs to be highlighted as the main objective and
evaluated appropriately.
The study will now examine social attitude and public opinion towards these
government and the media, as well as, how these opinions influence the
barrier that makes it extremely difficult for recovering drug users to become
accepted into the structures and networks of everyday life. The propaganda
79
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
designed to deter people from trying illegal drugs by portraying drug users as a
deviant enemy has led to a war on drug users themselves. This has resulted in
discrimination at every level. Buchanan (2004) goes on to stress that for many
drug users relapse is not attributable simply to the physical craving or a change
excluded. At the very time when recovering drug users need assistance and
social and economic life, they are often prevented by the wall of exclusion.
There seems to be some evidence that programmes can and do change the
attitudes of those involved in regard to the drug service user client group. In their
interview, Sports coach 2 (PSC 2) discusses the affect that the 2nd chance sports
‘Mixing with a client group that many of them would never have had
the opportunity to do in any other setting, this has led them to
question and understand some social issues that arise in
communities’. (PSC 2)
They go on to discuss how the programme has affected their personal attitudes
and opinions;
80
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
clinical care by clients with alcohol and drug related problems is the stigma
nature of this area of work is reflected in views about the deservingness of clients
for high quality and timely care. Yet, in spite of the common understanding of the
pervasive nature of stigma in relation to Alcohol and Other Drug (AOD) matters,
relatively little systematic effort has been directed to addressing this pivotal issue.
Drug worker 1 when interviewed had some very strong feelings about this issue;
.
‘I also feel strongly that public perceptions of the programme needs
to be improved, how we achieve that I am not quite sure, but recent
sensationalist and blatantly biased media coverage of the
programme, particularly the issues related to the awarding of premier
league football tickets for been successful on the programme needs
to be addressed’.(PDW 1)
The issue of the football tickets referred to here is a perfect example of how the
media can manipulate a relatively small innocent issue and turn it in to National
front page news. For sometime now the 2nd chance programme had been
rewarding those clients who had either been awarded the FA’s level 1 coaching
award which they had taken on the programme or achieved a high level of
attendance and been actively and positively involved with the programme with
81
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
This had only been possible via government office north east having four season
chance programme has very close links with GONE they were offered tickets four
times a year.
Some how one of the local news papers got to hear of this practice, immediately
turning a positive reward scheme into social uproar by using articles and
DRUG addicts in the area are being given free tickets to Premier League football
treatment for alcohol and drug addictions have gained sought-after tickets to
league games including the Newcastle United and Sunderland clash this
society. But the scheme was criticised as being a "reward" for people who should
be punished. (ibid)
The tickets were given by Newcastle United to the Government Office North East
(GONE), to be distributed to drug and alcohol action teams in the region. The
teams can then hand the tickets to addicts seeking to tackle their problems, even
82
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
A Government Office North- East spokesman said: ‘The tickets were given only
He said: "As part of their work in the community, for more than ten years,
Newcastle United Football Club has provided, free of charge and at their
"The tickets are provided on the understanding that they are used as part of a
package of measures to particularly help young people, who have had substance
misuse problems, and are making clear progress and showing a genuine
commitment to living a normal, structured life. The tickets are shared throughout
Government Office North- East declined to give details of how many tickets had
been given to serious offenders, but said addicts had their travelling expenses
North East MEP Martin Callanan questioned the validity of the scheme, saying:
"What about people who didn't get into trouble in the first place, who live their
lives, Work hard and pay their taxes? The MEP Martin Callanan continued:
This story became national news within a matter of days and sparked a string of
comments from the public via letters to the news papers, radio phone-ins and TV
83
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
interviews. Some comments posted on the Northern echo website show the
‘So thats where all the ttaxes i pay goes to, if these people were
publicly flogged im sure it would be a detterent for others to get
onto drugs in the future,but no that wont happen in case we go
against their human rights’.
This is exactly whats wrong with the world today. What does the kid
who's never missed a day at school or gotten into trouble get?
Probably bullied by the louts getting the free football tickets
There was very little support, if any, from the public responce and also a general
feeling of frustration and even anger from those who are connected to the
programme. This was mainly due to the way in which the matter had been
portrayed but also that GONE had not stood its ground and used the opputunity
There was a general consensus between both professional and clients that the
wished would disappear sooner rather than later. It also seems unlikely that
these complimentary tickets will be available to the 2nd chance programme for
84
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
The issue of the tickets has been a good example of both the media’s view and
that of the general public, however, there is much more to this issue than football
tickets.
Seddon’s observation leads to the question as to whether the social and public
of those who for what ever reason find themselves socially excluded in the
community.
Furthermore, it may not only be the general public that have less than positive
attitudes towards problematic drug users. There is a belief that there may also be
some differing attitudes amongst social and health care workers such as nurses
and social workers, especially when the clients are also involved in the criminal
justice system.
A report from the National Centre for Education and Training on Addiction
willingness to intervene with individuals who use illicit drugs, such as heroin or
85
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
drug users represent one factor within this wider set that may impact on health
perceived to be a negative behaviour, especially high risk drug use, such as,
binge drinking or heroin use. Individuals are often perceived to be responsible for
their drug use i.e., it is a behaviour they have chosen to engage in. This situation
contains all the ingredients for a judgement that high quality medical care may
of attitudes:
“They chose to use the drug and now they have to live with the consequences.”
just and appropriate outcome for oneself and others. NCETA (2006:4-5)
In countries that wage war on the enemy of illegal drugs, those who are given the
label ‘druggie’ or ‘smackhead’ find themselves not only socially marginalised and
isolated, but subject to hostility and distrust. The war on drugs is a war on drug
users, a civil war against an enemy within (Buchanan & Young 2000).
86
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
This observation and those already highlighted suggest that when Tony Blair
tough actions such as prison and punishment and not understanding and support
for rehabilitating drug users and offenders. The attitudes and opinions of the
media are a major factor in how the public react to individuals with any addiction
So called ‘Soft options’ such as the 2nd chance programme are deemed unfair to
the majority of citizens who have to pay for these activities out of their own
pocket are angered when these privileges are seen as rewarding drug use and
crime. Further more the fact that these so called privileges are paid for out of tax
fight drugs stated; hardly a family is unaffected by the evil of drugs . . . Drug-
related crime blights our communities. It destroys families and young lives and
won’t tolerate the menace of drugs in our communities–it cause’s misery and
costs lives. . . This new money will enable agencies to step up their fight against
drugs and the crime it breeds. It will get drug dealers off our kids’ backs and into
87
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
There is extensive work to be done regarding public opinion which needs to start
at the highest level. Although the current labour government have promoted their
social inclusion policy some aspects of that have been conflicting such as their
war on drugs rhetoric and preventing press releases as the one above. Until they
misuse and openly stand by programmes such as the 2nd chance programme
there will be a constant public scepticism and synergism towards such initiatives.
88
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Chapter 7
Conclusion
Does it work?
After investigating and examining the arguements both for and against the use of
sport as an effective intervention in combatting drugs and crime, the study will
The philosophy that engaging drug users and offenders in sports and outdoor
activities has a morally redemptive quality was very popular with Victorian social
reformers and similar claims are sometimes made today. But how effective are
Robins et al (1996)
Some exponents have argued that the basic value of sport is that it has a wide
appeal, both because it has many different forms and because opportunities to
participating in sport, after an initial introduction. However, sport has also been
criticised because those playing and leading it may not necessarily promote pro-
social values (Critcher, 2000) and ‘not all sports are characterised by a sense of
89
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
fair play and absence of criminal associations’ (Utting, 1996: 55). Therefore the
solely on drug or crime reduction, the harder it will be for evaluation to identify
drug use and offending. Therefore, the harder it will be to produce the evidence
al. 2000: 47). This is a limitation of the ability to achieve evidence based policy in
have been associated with reduced rates of drug use and offending the data on
which such conclusions are based is often not sufficient to allow firm conclusions
statistically significant or the follow up period may be too short. For future studies
much larger data set and a more longitudinal study. For example, a minimum
90
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Even where there is a claimed link between sports schemes and drug and crime
reduction, those monitoring and evaluating these programmes have been very
programmes, the evidence does not extend to demonstrating that the value of
the drug or crime reduction is greater than either the costs of providing the
programmes or the costs of dealing with crime after it has taken place and more
participants on the programme (see e.g. Crabbe, 2000; Long et al., 2002;
On this basis, Gratton and Taylor (2000:111) have recently concluded that ‘In the
meantime, government subsidies for sports programmes with drug and crime
91
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
If we leave aside this question of the impact upon drug related behaviour, it was
evident that projects might be more or less effective in their pursuit of related
Smith & Waddington (2004; 10; 279) concluded that perhaps all that can be said
is that it is at least plausible to suppose that some projects may have had an
impact on the drug taking behaviour of some of their clients; and that in respect
of some other projects it would have been implausible to suppose that they had
One major issue is that relatively few ‘sport in the community schemes’ have built
result, it is difficult to be sure about what impact, if any, they have on rates of
crime or drug use. Furthermore, the absence of any clearly articulated theoretical
rationale for these schemes means that, even where success is claimed, it is
unclear what specific aspects of the schemes account for that claimed success.
92
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
community – we need social scientists to help determine what works and why,
(Blunkett, 2000:33-34).
Gratton and Taylor (2000:111) have noted in relation to crime reduction schemes
– though the point would apply equally well to anti-drugs schemes – even if it is
does not extend to proving that the value of the crime reduction is greater than
either the costs of providing the programmes or the costs of dealing with crime
after it has taken place, and more work is needed on these cost-benefit
questions.
However, after reflecting on both sides of the argument this study acknowledges
that sport does have an effective role to play in the treatment of drug users and in
combating the acquisitive with which it is linked. One can not just dismiss the
from previous studies and schemes. There is a widespread belief that sport,
Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), (2001); Collins et al (1999); Football Task
Force, (1999)
93
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
Most drug-abuse experts and historians agree that we are in the declining phase
of a drug epidemic that began about 30 years ago. Still, drug abuse remains one
family breakdown, homelessness, desease and high health care and criminal
justice cost. Until we are able to combat the current level of drug use, addiction
and crime then individual tragedies and profound social problems will continue to
undermine the quality of our lives. Surely more effort and resources should be
allocated to re-directing or deflecting individuals away from drug use and crime
and not towards the already over-crowded and ineffective prison system.
establish some hard evidence regarding the uses for sport in combatting drug
After reviewing the arguments this study supports the argument that sports
and social development may occur and positively impact behaviour. The
evidence suggests, however, that these programs alone will not impact directly
component of a broader strategy for reducing and/or preventing drug use. They
are good tools for engaging and retaining clients into a more extensive treatment
package, which in turn will reap the benefits of reduced drug use and an impact
on acquisitive crime. This study will also argue that however well planned and
94
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
This study suggests that more thought should be taken by policy makers and
researchers towards the views of Tacon (2007) and others, such as, Pedersen
and Rieper (2008), when they suggests that to address this lack of evidence one
able to use evaluation results to design and deliver more effective projects.
Participants, in turn, will benefit from these improvements, since future projects
will be designed to meet their specific needs. The evaluation process will also
offer valuable guidance for policy-makers concerned with sport and social
95
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
methodology based on realist evaluation that can be incorporated widely into the
This study demonstrates the importance of rigorous evaluation for all those
involved in sport and social inclusion. It also identified some of the issues
currently affecting evaluation and explained the positive contribution that realist
evaluation could make. However, a more detailed exploration of this concept lies
The main objective of this study was to establish whether sport can be used as
an effective tool in reducing drug use and acquisitive crime. It has sought to
the more critical comments on policy issues and evaluation issues arising from
reduce levels of crime and drug misuse. In doing so, we have shown that there is
reducing crime or drug use (Long and Sanderson, 2001). However, there is an
over whelming philosophy (unproven belief) that some how it has a major role to
play.
96
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
The argument around the cost effectiveness of such programmes has been
difficult to gauge from this study. There are two valid and justified arguments,
however, cost effectiveness can only be measured when there is a clear rational
As for public attitudes and social perception of these sorts of initiatives, there
attitude towards this client group is rather negative, if not at times hostile. It has
also been suggested that these attitudes and opinions are not just constricted to
the general public but may also be felt amongst some health care professionals
as well as other statutory agencies, such as, the police, prison service and
probation service.
This study acknowledges the strong argument in favour of the concept that sport
is or can be used as an effective tool to combat drug use and crime. However,
there are indications sport in itself, is not the answer, but merely the vehicle and
that its main objective is not directly targeting drug users or criminals but the
issues that for many may lead to these activities being pursued. It seems that by
engage more on their terms and at their pace, also by being non judgemental
and supportive attracts individuals and motivates them to look towards change.
Sport seems to have the ability to achieve this due to its popularity especially
amongst young people but surely other activities have the potential to achieve
97
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
the same. This study recommends further and more in depth research studies in
to these arguments with a more defined rational, larger scale studies and more
longitudinal approach.
98
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Chapter 8
Appendix A
DATE
Letter of Invitation
Dear –name-,
I am currently writing my dissertation which aims to focus on the effectiveness
sports activities as a tool to reduce problematic drug use and subsequent crime
related offending. I would like to ask if you would be interested in participating in this
piece of research which I am undergoing for the final part of my MSc Contemporary
Issues in Drug Use at Teesside University.
The research will be about the views of people, both clients and professionals, who
have been actively involved in the 2nd Chance programme.
I would like to hear your views on the programme from your personal and
professional perspective and how you think it has, or has not benefited your working
practice.
Your participation is entirely voluntary. If you decide to take part, I would like to
contact you to arrange a convenient time and venue for the interview. The interview
should not take longer than 30 minutes.
Please be prepared that I will record the interview. However, you can cancel your
participation at any time. Furthermore please ask your managers permission, and
confirm that participating in this interview is not conflicting with your company policy.
I assure you that anything you divulge will be treated in the strictest confidence, and
both you and your service will be totally anonymised. None of the information you
provide will be passed on to a third person.
The information provided will be kept in a secure place until it is destroyed at the
completion of the research. If you are in any doubt, or have further questions
regarding my research, please do not hesitate to contact me at the number provided
at the top of the letter.
Yours sincerely,
Mark Williams
99
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Consent form
meeting.
Could you please fill out the slip and sent it back to me in the self addressed
100
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix B
DATE
Letter of Invitation
Dear –name-,
I am conducting a piece of research on the 2nd chance sports programme. I would
like to ask if you would be interested in taking part in research study I am doing as part of my
MSc Contemporary Issues of Drug Use at Teesside University.
The research is about the views of the people who have taken part in the programme and
will ask your opinion on, the benefits of the programme and how you would improve it.
The interview is very informal and will be in a place of your choice. Your participation is
entirely voluntary. If you decide to take part, I will contact you to arrange a convenient time
to meet up.
During the interview I would like to hear about your opinions and feels around the
programme and how you think it could be made better.
The interview will be tape recorded; however, I will terminate the interview at any time if it
makes you feel uncomfortable. The chat should not take longer than an hour.
Anything you tell me will be treated in the strictest confidence, and you will be made
anonymous. That means that your name or any other form of identification will not be
passed on to a third person, and your participation will have no impact on the services or
treatment you are receiving.
However, I need to advise you that I might have to breach this confidentiality as soon as you
tell me anything that indicates that you are at risk of harming yourself or others.
The information you give me will be kept in a secure place and will be destroyed as soon as
the research is completed.
If you are in any doubt, or have further questions regarding my research, please do not
hesitate to contact me at the number provided at the top of the letter.
Yours sincerely,
Mark Williams
101
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Consent form
meeting.
Could you please fill out the slip and sent it back to me in the self addressed
102
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix C
What happens to all the stuff I fill out and the recorded
interview?
While I’m writing my study I will store everything in a secure place so
nobody can get hold of it. After I’m finished with the project I will destroy
all the material.
103
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
104
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix D
CONSENT FORM
Project title:
Material gathered during this research will be treated as confidential and securely
stored. Please answer each statement concerning the collection and use of the
research data.
I have read and understood the information sheet. Yes No
I understand that I can withdraw from the study at any time Yes No
without having to give an explanation.
I agree to the interview being audiotaped and to its contents Yes No
being used for research purposes.
I do not want to be identified in this interview and in any Yes No
subsequent publications or use. Where used my name
must be removed and my comments made unattributable.
I would like to see a copy of my transcript. Yes No
Mark Williams
Appendix E
105
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
3. Have you ever been involved or heard of similar concepts and what were your
experiences of those?
4. In your view, how has it benefited your service and individual practice?
5. In your view how would you like to see the programme evolve and what, if
any, modifications or improvements would you make?
7. Briefly outline in your personal views on any positive aspects of the scheme.
8. Briefly outline in your personal views on any negative aspects of the scheme.
Appendix F
106
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
3. Have you ever been involved or heard of any other similar projects or
programmes and what do you think about them?
5. What would you like to see happen with the programme if you had the
chance, what would you change, improve, or develop?
8. What are for you the most positive things about the programme?
9. Do you think that programmes like this that use sports activities are any good
for helping people get away from drug use and crime?
10. What other activities or programmes do you think you and your mates would
be interested in?
Questions 2, 3 and 4 also have the purpose of getting to know the participants
history with the programme and to put them at ease. Through the questions I also
hope to reveal issues with them I have not mentioned in this interview guide, but
which might be relevant to the study.
107
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix G
Area:
Main substance:
Route of use:
108
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix H
‘My key worker told me about it and she picked me up and took me to the bus the
first time I went’
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of any other similar projects or
programmes and what do you think about them?
No, I’ve never been involved in anything like this, no since school when we did
different stuff. I think it’s a really good thing coz there’s nothing round here to do
especially if you’re on drugs. They should do it more like every day not just once a
week’.
4. What would you like to see happen with the programme if you had the
chance, what would you change, improve, or develop?
‘I’d make it every day me, and I’d do it in Peterlee coz that would make it easier and
save money for the bus which we could use on other stuff. I’d like to do more
tournaments other places so we meet other people and see other places. I’d also get
more choices for stuff to do’.
Don’t know, money maybe, don’t know if they know what I think. Maybe they haven’t
got the time and the students need time to do their stuff.
‘Don’t like the way there getting less people coming coz they might stop it if there
aint enough people coming. Another thing is I’d like to do some different stuff and
like I said before I’d like to have every day’.
‘Keeps me out of bovver dunnit (laugh) no, seriously its good coz it gives ya summit
to do and stuff you like so that keeps your mind off all the other stuff going on. I’ve
met some mates and got a bit fitter which has also been a good thing. I get come out
and come to Durham, it’s really nice here and the people are nice too.
109
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
8. Do you think that programmes like this that use sports activities are any
good for helping people get away from drug use and crime?
Yeah deffo, it’ like when your in jail and you go to the gym all the time which makes
you feel good and takes your mind off all the crap that’s going on. If I wasn’t here I’d
be at home bored, probably think about drugs or go out with me mates and get up to
all sorts of stuff. This gives us summit else to do that’s why I want it every day then
I’d stop getting into bovver and help with using the drugs’.
9. What other activities or programmes do you think you and your mates
would be interested in?
I’m nuts me, i’d like to go rock climbing on real mountains not just indoors although
that was ok. I’d like to do go-karting, is that a sport? Well i’d like to do that and
sailing or rowing. We talked about just doing snooker or pool, some of the lads used
to go but its nt on any more. Maybe they can do more indoor sports like that as well.
Any thing really, its worth trying them if you haven’t tried them before and then you
can choose afterwards, cant ya?
110
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
‘Me mate said about it first like, then I met the workers on the bus and then I started
too got to the treatment centre more regular’.
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of any other similar projects or
programmes and what do you think about them?
‘No, nowt like this, I wish there was more like this. I could do with cumin’ here every
day like’.
‘It gives us summit to look forward to and gets us out of the house, like I said I wish
there was more like this around our way for everybody to use, especially me and me
mates’.
4. What would you like to see happen with the programme if you had the
chance, what would you change, improve, or develop?
‘I’d like it to be every day and near me house, so I didn’t have to travel so far. I’d like
to go on more days out like the climbing and the rafting we’ve been on and I’d like to
do some go-carting and paint-balling stuff, that’s what’.
‘Dunno money and people to run it I suppose. The Uni’s busy with students and I
dunno if we can go anywhere else. People don’t like us going to the leisure centre
coz they don’t like mixing with us druggies do they’?
‘Not really, only that it’s not on enough and that it’s a bit far away from my house.
Maybe that more people should be coming, coz there used to be loads more every
week but they’ve stopped coming’.
‘Gives us summit to do. Gives us summit to look forward too every week. Keeps us
a bit fitter and keeps me out of trouble, dunnit’?
8. Do you think that programmes like this that use sports activities are any
good for helping people get away from drug use and crime?
‘Course they do, that’s what they are here for innit? It keeps you out of grafting coz
that’s what you do when you’re bored and on the gear. Since I’ve been going to
ESMI I’ve been off the gear and stuff like this keeps us busy so I don’t go back on it’.
111
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
9. What other activities or programmes do you think you and your mates
would be interested in?
‘More footie would be good and I like swimming too. Me and the lads here have
talked about going on a weekend camping trip or doing some outward bounds stuff. I
like fishing but I don’t know if they would wanna do that like.
112
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of any other similar projects or
programmes and what do you think about them?
‘I’ve been involved with this a couple of year but that’s all like.
‘It’s helped us socialise more and get us out the house, its given us a goal about
what I want to do with me self and everything, coz I wanna do the football coaching
course, refereeing course and look for like jobs and that. The coaching courses are
summit I deffo wanna do coz I missed out last time on it’.
4. What would you like to see happen with the programme if you had the
chance, what would you change, improve, or develop?
‘I’d do a bit more outings, you know more outings, the lads wanna do some other
things an all which would be go but for me just a few more outings. I enjoy it the way
it is really, maybe twice a week or more’.
‘Numbers have gone down and money, we’d need more money or funding, that’s the
main one’.
‘No, its done great for me, nothing at all, the people are great and that’.
‘Everyone gets along, it’s a good day or a couple of hours out, I really enjoy cumin’
and never miss it’.
8. Do you think that programmes like this that use sports activities are any
good for helping people get away from drug use and crime?
‘Definitely, definitely, like me self and the other lads have played football all our lives
and this is getting us back it to it so it is really good, definitely. Any thing beats going
to jail or getting it trouble so its good yeah!
113
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
9. What other activities or programmes do you think you and your mates
would be interested in?
‘Dunno, go-carting, I really wanna do that like and that’s the only one I wanna do, I
think’.
114
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of any other similar projects or
programmes and what do you think about them?
‘No, nowt like this, I’ve done sports at school and stuff but nowt like this’.
‘Gives us summit to do, like on a Thursday, know what I mean, coming through and
playing football or using the gym or sometimes trampolining and other stuff’.
4. What would you like to see happen with the programme if you had the
chance, what would you change, improve, or develop?
‘I’d do it so we could come every day and that there was more things going on like
more stuff for the girls coz not all the girls like footie, I do but some don’t and there
should be stuff for them. I’d also go on more trips coz they are mint, especially the
white water rafting, mint’.
‘It’s got to be money and that the key workers can’t be doing this stuff every day.
‘More stuff and more stuff for girls like they do in Sunderland, that scheme sounds
mint and we would love summit like that.
‘Meeting people and getting out, doing stuff that’s good for you and stops you getting
bored. I’ve also done my level 1 coaching badge and I wouldn’t have done that if it
wasn’t for this programme.
8. Do you think that programmes like this that use sports activities are any
good for helping people get away from drug use and crime?
‘Yeah, I think so, coz it gives you something to look forward to and is always there
even when you are feeling bad. The people are nice and I think that if these things
where there every day I think it would help a lot of people’.
115
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
9. What other activities or programmes do you think you and your mates
would be interested in?
‘More things for girls and more trips out, like to the white water rafting or rock
climbing. I’d like to learn to drive; do you think they will do that? No, more trips out,
maybe camping or visiting other programmes.
116
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix I
Durham DIP management and senior workers, particularly Mark Williams played a
significant role in promoting the scheme and making it viable.
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of similar concepts and what were
your experiences of those?
In a previous life I worked for the national probation service that ran a similar
scheme as part of semi structured activities on the old DTTO programme.
Sport as ever, particularly football, is very popular with our client group and seems to
work well in occupying their time in a constructive way.
3. In your view, how has it benefited your service and individual practice?
I firmly believe that all of the clients which I have nominated to the scheme over the
duration of the project have benefited from the scheme.
I think the most reoccurring positive feedback which I hear from my clients is that it
has given them something constructive to do and it has broken the monotony of
everyday .Clients also report improvements in self esteem and self reflection.
Clients have also noted the physical benefits of engaging in this service, which
seems to have spurred them onto, strive for further improvements.
One client in particular noted how much of a talent he seemed to have for kick
boxing and has since taken up the sport on a regular basis at a local club.
4. In your view how would you like to see the programme evolve and what, if
any, modifications or improvements would you make?
I think the process of recruiting and nominating clients needs to be improved and I
also believe the transportation of clients to the venue needs to be reviewed.
I also feel strongly that public perceptions of the programme needs to be improved,
how we achieve that I am not quite sure, but recent sensationalist and blatantly
biased media coverage of the programme (particularly the issues related to the
awarding of premier league football tickets for been successful on the programme)
needs to be addressed.
117
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Most definitely. I think as a sector we probably have a very long way to go before
public perceptions of schemes like this begins to change.
Our clients have been made out to be dirty rotten smack heads who have there
burglaries and muggings of old ladies rewarded with free premier league football
tickets!!!!
With regards the recruitment and nomination of clients, I feel that it is essential that
‘ALL’ agencies in Durham assist the DIP in promoting this activity and improve their
referral rate, as so many suitable clients are very clearly missing out.
The probation service is particularly bad at failing to promote this programme, but
perhaps that’s something for the powers that be to sort out.
With regards the improved transportation, I feel recent changes in the DIP’s lone
working policy have restricted all staff in their ability to escort clients in groups to and
from the venue.
Restrictions on funding have meant that no additional private buses could be hired to
fill this void. It seems a great shame that such a poorly thought out decision is
beginning to impact on the scheme in a bad way (in terms of retention figures).
The scheme clearly provides constructive activities for clients to engage in, which it
could be argued is keeping them out of crime, at least whilst they are at the
scheme!!
I feel the scheme has also given a lot of clients the opportunity to discover attributes
they probably thought they didn’t possess, both physical and emotional.
I feel the scheme has breathed confidence and improved self esteem into the clients
and has enabled them to review their own lives, and in some cases has triggered
thoughts and actions about real sustainable change.
I also feel that the extensive range of activities which is now available to our clients
is fantastic.
As I said earlier, I feel that other organisations within our field need to be playing a
more significant part. I sense that because it was the DIP who played such a crucial
role in setting up and implementing the scheme, it seems the perception that the DIP
is purely responsible for the scheme has stuck.
Probation, NECA, NHS Trust, DAAT and others all need to be adding their influence
and finance to the scheme.
118
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
119
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
‘I got involved at the very start of the programme when the DIP were organising the
football programme and tournaments’
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of similar concepts and what were
your experiences of those?
‘I have been involved in football projects to engage with hard to reach groups
previously when working for the National Association for the Care and Rehabilitation
of Offenders (NACRO). Football was a popular method for engaging with disaffected
young males’.
3. In your view, how has it benefited your service and individual practice?
‘It has most definitely given me a well needed option for a structured activity and an
opportunity to engage with some of my clients in a different enviroment. As for the
service it has given all workers the same benefits of engaging with their clients and
has given the service a positive activity to promote itself’.
4. In your view how would you like to see the programme evolve and what,
if any, modifications or improvements would you make?
‘I would like to see the programme expand into a multi – sports, multi – activity
programme open to all service users, such as, alcohol and mental health clients as
well as carers. I would employ several individuals to coordinate and run the multi –
activity programme and invite more involvement from the universities and local
authorities. I would like to see the programme rolled out throughout the country with
the ability to visit and compete with other areas, maybe regional and national
tournaments’
For any future growth, long term substantial funding is needed as is a commitment
from all parties. I passionately believe that the programme should be directed and
lead by service users which will be integral to the programmes long term success’.
‘Funding, high level commitment and commitment from the front line staff to continue
with the work already implemented. It is imperative that the belief, motivation and
commitment continues from front line staff as without this the whole pack of cards
falls down. If the programme continues not to involve service user involvement and
take inspiration and guidance from this source the concept risks petering out and
losing interest by service users’.
‘The positives of sports initiatives have been well documented. The concept can be
linked to motivating individuals towards change, lift their self respect and esteem.
120
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Improve both mental and physical health and relieve boredom which is commonly
linked to drug use and criminal activity’. These sorts of programmes are good for
engaging hard to reach groups and give the worker an opportunity to establish a
stronger relationship due to sharing interests and experiences. I feel workers should,
if wanted, participate and share the experience with their clients’.
‘If it does not develop there is a risk that it will just fizzle out which will be very
deflating and demoralising for those who have been regular core participants. The
concept, although fantastic for those who enjoy it only targets and benefits those
who enjoy sport. What is there for those who don’t? The programme is currently
dependent on a few passionate people who believe in it and with out their
enthusiasm may again just fizzle out.
‘Yes, most definitely! This is a great intervention and one which needs to be
developed, expanded and improved to accommodate a greater number of service
users. It should be open to all service users offering a wide range of activities. As for
cost effectiveness, I think that by engaging with these individuals and by supporting
them there is a far greater chance that they will address their drug using and
offending behaviour than by incarcerating them and excluding them from society.
You have to look at the human cost and not just at the monetary costs although I do
believe that the cost of such schemes will out way the cost on both the criminal
justice sysem and the national health service for which this group are currently a
massive burden’.
121
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of similar concepts and what were
your experiences of those?
2nd Chance was the first project of this type that I have been involved in, although it
has acted as a catalyst to get involved with similar projects
3. In your view, how has it benefited your service and individual practice?
Benefit is to the students as it gives them an opportunity to work with groups that
they would not normally work with and wider their social awareness. Good for the
university around a PR point of view and also to attract funding.
4. In your view how would you like to see the programme evolve and what,
if any, modifications or improvements would you make?
‘Piloting a mentoring and work experience scheme. I think the programme evolves
itself over time and from this you find out what changes are required’.
‘Time constraints on the staff currently working on the programme as one to one
support is important and money is always an issue’
'Positive for students as they get good life skills and experience, open their eyes to
the world a bit. Positive for clients as we can see marked improvement of their life
skills in a majority of the cases, good feed back from majority of clients, gives them
something to do and keeps them busy and focused. Breaks down barriers and
preconceptions
Have had minor trouble with theft but don’t feel this is an issue.
Yes, sport is an important tool that can help to improve people lives by improving
their wellbeing mentally and physically. It can build confidence, self worth and self
122
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
esteem leading to better social interaction and better job opportunities. The obvious
benefits of fitness from the programme are important for a group of people who may
have had ill health for an extended period of time and need this sort of support the
get themselves back in to a healthy lifestyle. It is not a cure in itself but used
alongside a structured programme of care I believe it can help improve the drop out
rate and add value to these other services.
Weighed up with the cost of keeping a prisoner in jail for a year or the high cost of
extended treatment the 2nd chance programme is value for money.
123
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
After an initial talk from Tony Wright (Government Office North East), it was decided
to run a pilot project at Durham University. The project initially focused on football
and recruited clients from Durham, Bishop, Peterlee and Darlington. The Team
Durham Community staff recruited student volunteers to deliver the football
coaching, this was led by a level 2 qualified coach.
2. Have you ever been involved or heard of similar concepts and what were
your experiences of those?
When we started the project we hadn’t heard of any other schemes, however now
we are involved in the scheme other projects have come to light.
3. In your view, how has it benefited your service and individual practice?
‘It has made me personally more aware of what goes on outside of my circle of
friends. It has challenged many views that I held about drug use and how recovering
drug users can be reintegrated into society and the support that they can access
along the way’. (PSC 2)
‘I would hope that the scheme has broken down a number of barriers and
stereotypes, clients now see Durham University as a place where there are people
who are interested in them and do want to help them improve and step on. Students
and staff see that helping clients making that step on in life is of benefit’. (PSC 2)
4. In your view how would you like to see the programme evolve and what,
if any, modifications or improvements would you make?
I would like to see greater involvement from the University as a whole, we are
hoping to get this working by offering clients from the scheme volunteer work
placements in departments within the University from estates and buildings,
catering, library services etc. This is still someway of implementation, but a whole
University approach would undoubtedly make the project stronger and give us more
opportunities to apply for more funding.
Short of building new facilities at Durham University I don’t think I would change
much else!
124
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
We are still in the stages of talking to all the departments to arrange volunteer work
placements, I think it is very important that we get all the necessary paperwork
completed and make sure all the If’s are dotted and the tm’s are crossed to make
sure the placements are worthwhile and could lead onto permanent work.
Seeing someone develop throughout the 3 years we have had the scheme at
Durham has been rewarding, from arriving in a poor state of health with little self
confidence to leading some aspects of the sessions and taking responsibilities for
other users is great to see.
It has also been good to see how the scheme has developed across all 5
Universities, the regional tournaments have been a great success and have grown
beyond what we thought was possible at the start of the scheme.
Seeing students and clients mixing is also a bonus of this scheme and many of the
students have stories of clients they have seen while on a night out and have had a
chat and a catch up.
We have had issues with a few clients who may or may not have been dealing with
other clients while at the University. This made some members of University staff
question why we were supporting the scheme. On the plus side a number of other
clients who were here on that day were embarrassed and apologised for the
behaviour of the other clients
Thefts occurring while the Second Chance clients are on site, the culprit was found
and not allowed to return to the scheme, again the other clients apologised for the
behaviour of this one guy. As a reaction to this theft, security was tightened up and
since then there have been no other incidence.
Sport is a normal activity and therefore can go along way to proving to family of
recovering drug users that they are doing something normal with their lives.
‘As a competitive sports person myself I get a buzz from taking part in physical
activity, I wonder if that buzz/kick can go someway to replacing the same feeling
drug users get when taking drugs. It also focuses the mind on achieving a goal,
through team work and individual discipline – it also makes you tired and helps you
sleep better and a number of the clients have said that sport helps them to do that’.
‘The cost effective side of the question I am not so sure about as I don’t know all the
figures, though I do feel that sometimes our programme isn’t cost effective when we
hire buses and 2 people are on them and then we hire coaches to deliver sessions
and only 3 people turn up to those sessions. But on the other hand if those 3 people
125
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
are getting their lives back on track and are not taking up time through use of
emergency services, prison and probation services and eventually they get back into
work and start paying taxes then that can only be a good thing’. (PSC 4)
126
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Appendix J
None
6. Aim(s) of Project:
Examine the influence of sports-based activities and interventions in reducing drug using and
offending behaviour amongst service users accessing the 2nd Chance sports programme and a
critical review of previous schemes using similar concepts.
7. Briefly describe the design of the project:
Fully transcribed semi structured interviews of four service users and four professionals participating
in the 2nd chance programme. Plus a critical review of existing research material from similar
schemes and concepts.
I will use a phenomenological approach whilst preparing and conducting the interviews.
Phenomenology is defined as a ‘philosophy that is concerned with the question of how individuals
make sense of the world around them and how in particular the philosopher should bracket out
preconceptions in his or her grasp of that world’ (Bryman, 2004, p13). Also, this philosophy, as
Interpretivism, recognises the ‘fundamental difference between the subject matter of the natural
sciences and the social sciences’ (Bryman, 2004. p14). It appreciates that ‘social reality has a
meaning for human beings and therefore human action is meaningful – that is, it has a meaning for
them and they act on the basis of the meanings that they attribute to their acts and to the acts of
others’ (Bryman, 2004, p14). This philosophy is a useful tool to understand and interpret my
interviewees’ actions from their point, regardless if they are clients or professionals.
I have designed two slightly different interview guides, one designed to focus on the clients
perspective and opinions, and the other designed to focus on the professional’s points of view and
127
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
attitudes directed specifically towards the 2nd Chance Programme and the concept of sport as a tool
in both drug treatment and reducing crime. Both interview guides will be of a semi-structured nature;
however, the professionals will be given more scope and therefore the interviews will be of a slightly
more unstructured nature.
In a semi-structured interview the ‘researcher has a list of questions or fairly specific topics to be
covered, but the interviewee has a great deal of leeway in how to reply’ (Bryman. 2004, p321).
Considering the circumstances of the clients I intended to interview, I felt that a stricter semi-
structured guide would give them more confidence in talking about their experiences, since they felt
more comfortable when confronted with stricter guidelines and given less leeway.
The professional interview guide was slightly more unstructured to give the professionals the
opportunity to dwell or even expand on topics they might deemed as important or relevant (Bryman,
2004, p321).
Though the interview guides differed slightly, it will still gave the interviewees the power to decide to
talk about issues they consider as important or relevant, and the entire interview will become more
of a conversation (Bryman, 2004, p321).
This qualitative approach can be a very appealing research strategy, ‘because of their human
character’ (Gillham, 2005, p8). It furthermore is easier to probe and clarify. Additionally, it gives me,
the researcher the opportunity to show appreciation and understanding, which was particularly
important for my clients, as it encouraged them to talk more openly about their circumstances. This,
furthermore feministic approach, is entirely different from the traditionally male structured
interviewing culture. It allows me to approach participants with a certain ‘openness’, demonstrate
‘emotional engagement, and the development of trust’ (Punch, 2006, p173).
Whilst constructing both guides, I will make sure that questions are open and ordered, and that one
question flows reasonably into the other, but yet stayed flexible enough to alteration. I will also
consider language issues, and how I could adopt a language that would be easily understood,
especially by clients.
In general, interviews will not take longer than 30 minutes and usually take place in venues that are
familiar to the participants, such as, the sports facilities they attended or at their local treatment
centre. All interviews will be audio-recorded after interviewees have given their consent. The
participants have the right of receiving a transcribed version of their interview, which they indicate
on the consent form (Gillham, 2005, p14). Prior to interviewing the participants will be informed of
their rights and confidentiality issues.
128
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
10. State how participants will be selected:
All 8 participants will be individuals associated with the scheme. There will be 4 clients and 4
professionals. The professionals will represent both the substance misuse workers and the sports
coaching staff. As for the clients it will be the first 4 clients who complete the invitation forms and
return them to me; however I am hoping that one of the clients will be a female and may make
amendments in the selection to accommodate for this.
11. Has statistical/methodological advice been sought on the size and design of the
Project? YES / NO
12. What procedure(s) will be carried out on the participants? (Explain in terms
appropriate to a layperson)
Semi structured interviews, audio recorded and fully transcribed
Throughout the process I need to be aware of the likelihood of risks, and who might be at risk.
Furthermore, I might come across issues of honesty, trust, privacy and confidentiality, especially
since I have spent time with the clients before the interview and would most likely spend time with
them after it.
I also needed to think about issues of anonymity, and how I could provide it, as well as, the integrity
and quality of the research.
I also need to be aware of the possibility of the data collected, regardless if it would be chosen to be
published, would cause harm to that participant or organisation in the future.
I see no risks to the researcher. All interviews will take place in a safe environment and all clients
have already been fully risk assessed before acceptance on to the programme.
The research has been agreed with both my employer and all of the participating agencies and
services. Also the relevant consent forms will be collected from the clients before commencement.
N/A
15: If there is doubt as to a subject’s ability to give consent, what steps will be taken
to ensure that the subject is willing to participate (e.g. assistance of independent colleague/
Next of kin or other means.)
Whilst preparing, carrying out and evaluating the interviews, I will adhere to the 4 main areas of
ethical principles, suggested by Diener and Crandall (in Bryman, 2004, p509), which are ‘Harm to
participants’, ‘Lack of informed consent’, ‘Invasion of privacy’, and ‘Deception’. Furthermore, I was
aware of the ethical issues I could encounter from the beginning of my research until after the project,
proposed by Miles and Huberman (in Punch, 2006, pp277-278). The ethical principles suggested by
Diener and Crandall merge into the issues mentioned by Miles and Huberman, and made me think
129
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
more thoroughly about my research and its ethical impacts, on both clients and professionals .
Consent forms will be completed prior to the interview as well as the interviewees being given
information sets in advance of the interview date and time. The interviewees may also have a
nominated person present if they so wish. They will also be made aware that they may pull out or
stop the interview at any time and the material already recorded will be destroyed instantly.
The participants have the right to receive a transcribed version of their interview, which they indicated
on the consent form (Gillham, 2005, p14). Prior to interviewing the participants were informed of their
rights and confidentiality issues.
16: What information will be given to subject(s)?: (Attach copies of letters or information
Sheets to be given to participants.)
See attached.
All relevant documentation including consent forms and audio tapes will be kept in a secure filing
cabinet until deemed not to be needed. I will destroy all audio tapes directly after transcription,
however, for the destruction of the written transcripts and the consent forms I will take guidance from
my course leader (Dr Mark Simpson) as to the soonest possible date for there destruction. This
maybe on completion and acceptance of my dissertation.
N/A
130
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
19: Does the project involve any other disciplines and/or Ethics Committees?
YES / NO
(If YES, please state which and what approval has already been obtained - attach
Documentation.)
No
No
21a): Will the project receive financial support from outside the University Teesside?
YES / NO
No
N/A
21c) If YES, have any restrictions been imposed upon the conduct of the research?
YES / NO (If YES, specify the nature of the restrictions)
N/A
No
23: Are there any other points you wish to make in justification of the proposed study?
24: I have read the University’s guidelines on ethics related to research, and to the best
of my knowledge and ability confirm that the ethical considerations overleaf have been
assessed. I am aware of and understand University procedures on Research Ethics and
Health & Safety. I understand that the ethical propriety of this project may be monitored
by the School’s Research Ethics Sub-Committee.
(Please complete the following as appropriate) Please Tick
I have appropriate experience of the general research area.
I confirm that I have Research Ethics Training required by my School.
I confirm that as Supervisor that I will monitor progress of the project.
• I confirm that the project complies with the Code of Practice of the
following Professional Body:
25:
Signature of Staff Researcher: _______________________________ Date: _________
OR: Signature of
131
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
OR:
b) The School Research Ethics Committee is unable to reach a conclusion, and the
Case is referred to the University Research Ethics Committee.
The Chair of the School Research Ethics Committee must send a copy of an APPROVED Request
for Ethical Approval Form to: The Secretary, University Research Ethics Committee, Research &
Development Office, and University of Teesside. The original of the form should be kept in the
School. The ORIGINAL of a REFERRED Request must be sent to the above address for action
and the Director of the School notified.
SECTION C: APPROVAL / REJECTION by University Research Ethics
Committee
EITHER:
a) On behalf of the University Research Ethics Committee, I now authorise the above
project:
132
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
OR:
b) The University Research Ethics Committee is UNABLE TO APPROVE the project for
the following reasons:
References
133
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Coalter, F. (1998) Leisure Studies, Leisure Policy and Social Citizenship: The
Failure of Welfare or the Limitations of Welfare? Leisure Studies 17:21-36.
Coalter, F. (2001) Realising the Potential of Cultural Services: The Case for
Sport. London: Local Government Association.
Coffield, F. & Gofton, L. (1994). ‘Drugs and Young People’. London: Institute
for Public Policy Research.
134
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Collins, M., Henry, I., Houlihan, B., and Buller, J. (1999) Sport and Social
Inclusion: A Report to the Department for Culture, Media and Sport,
Loughborough University, Institute of Sport and Leisure Policy, available at:
http://www. sportdevelopment.org.uk/collins1999.pdf
Collins, M. & Kay, T. (2003). Sport and Social Exclusion. London: Routledge.
Condon, J. and Smith, N. (2003) Prevalence of Drug Use: Key Findings from
the 2002/2003 British Crime Survey. London: Home Office.
Crabbe, T. (2000) ‘A Sporting Chance? Using Sport to Tackle Drug Use and
Crime’, Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy 7(4): 381–91.
Department for Culture, Media and Sport (2001) Building on PAT 10:
Progress Report on Social Inclusion, London, DCMS, available at: http://
www.sportdevelopment.org.uk/reportonpat10. PDF
Department of Culture, Media & Sport (2002) Game Plan: A strategy for
delivering Governments sport and physical activity objectives, London:
Cabinet Office.
135
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Ettner, S.L. Huang, D. Evans, E. Ash, D.R. Hardy, M. Jourabchi, M. & Hser,
Y.I. (2006). Benefit-cost in the California treatment outcome project: Does
substance abuse treatment “pay for itself”? Health Services Research, 41(1),
192-213.
French, M.T., McCollister, K.E., Kébreau Alexandre, P., Chitwood, D.D., &
McCoy, C.B. (2004). Revolving Roles in Drug-Related Crime: The Cost of
Chronic Drug Users as Victims and Perpetrators. Journal of Quantitative
Criminology, 20(3), 217-241
136
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Hoover, N. (1999) National Survey: Initiation Rites and Athletics for NCAA
Sports Teams. New York: Alfred University.
Hough, M. (1996) Home Office: Drug misuse and the criminal justice system:
a review of the literature, Drugs Prevention Initiative Paper 15
Jupp, V. & Barron, L. (1999) Sport and crime, in: The Case for Sport
(Newcastle: Institute of Sport, University of Northumbria).
Long, J. and Sanderson, I. (2001) ‘The Social Benefits of Sport: Where’s the
Proof?’ in C. Gratton and I. Henry (Eds) Sport in the City, pp. 187–203.
London: Routledge.
Long, J., Welch, M., Bramham, P., Hylton, K., Butterfield, J. and Lloyd, E.
(2002) Count me in: the Dimensions of Social Inclusion through Culture and
Sport. London: Department of Culture, Media and Sport
137
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Morgan, D. (1998) ’Sport off the Streets: A Preliminary Analysis of the Need
for “Reczones“ in the 3Ds Area of Bolton’ ‚ paper presented at Sport v youth
Crime Conference, Reebok Stadium Bolton.
Nichols, G. (2007) Sport and Crime Reduction: The role of sport in tackling
youth crime. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group. London & New York.
NTORS (2005) Drug misuse treatment and reductions in crime: Findings from
the National Treatment Outcomes Research Study. Gossop, M.
138
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Popper, K. (1945). The Open Society and its Enemies, Volume 2 Hegel and
Marx, London: Routledge
Seddon, T. (2006) Drugs, Crime and Social Exclusion. Social Context and
Social Theory in British Drugs &Crime Research. Brit. J. Criminology. (2006)
46, 680–703Advance Access publication 680. © The Author 2005. Published
by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Centre for Crime and Justice
Studies (ISTD).
Shildrick, T. (2002) ‘Young People, Illicit Drug Use and the Question of
Normalization’, Journal of Youth Studies 5(1): 35–48.
139
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
Trujillo, C.M. (1983) The effect of weight training and running exercise
intervention programs on the self-esteem of college women, International
Journal of Sports Psychology, 14, pp. 162-173.
Wilkins, N.O. (1997) ’Overtime is Better than Sudden Death’, Parks and
Recreation.
140
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
141
G7086401 Drugs,Crime & Sport
142
G7086401 Drugs, Crime & Sport
143