Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
A: I would consider running a battery of tests, doing some different types of observation
and having her parents observer her at times too and report back their findings. Since this seems
to be a very complex case, and it has to do with more than just people, but also perhaps locations,
it would be a good choice to do some observations at her preschool. Maybe talk to/interview
people who took care of her before she was adopted.
Q: Although you need more information to begin treatment, what factors might you take
into consideration in designing an effective intervention for this family?
A: There could be something going on in the home between the parents or between one
of the parents and the child; definitely possible that there is something going on at her preschool;
being that she is adopted there could be something in her past that is surfacing, or it could be a
normal childhood fear that has gotten out of control or a medical/psychological issue that is just
appearing and needs to be dealt with. I would definitely keep up with the family counseling and
individual counseling too, if needed.
Q: If you were preparing to diagnose Clara, you would refer to the DSM-IV classification
system to evaluate her condition on five separate axes. What type of information would go into
each axis? (You are not asked to enter a diagnosis, only describe the kind of information that
would be entered in each axis.)
A: Axis I would include any determination of anxiety or mood disorders. (Comer, 2005)
Axis II would list any issues with mental retardation or personality disorders. (Comer, 2005, p.
84) Axis III is for listing any medical conditions that might be currently or chronically involved.
Axis IV is for listing any special psychosocial or environmental problems (Comer, 2005, p. 84)
that might be contributing to the issues at the present time. And Axis V is for listing the patients
GAF score, which is the global assessment of functioning score which is based on how well they
are doing psychologically, socially, and occupationally.
Q: Do you think that diagnosing Clara would be beneficial or harmful? Explain why.
A: I dont think that you can answer that question without getting more information from
all the persons involved. If you try to diagnose without all the information then you could
mislabel Clara and that could potentially cause issues for the rest of her life. However, by not
getting to the bottom of things, the current situation could also spiral way out of control and there
could be serious consequences for her or others. Yet, if you can gather all the data and the
issue(s) becomes fairly obvious and is something that is fixable or can be dealt with, then yes, I
do believe that diagnosing would be helpful, but only if the case is absolutely clear.
Conclusion
I found this to be a very interesting example, which sort of paralleled one that I
experienced with my son when he was about 3. It was very interesting to research the various
tests and tools that are used in the assessments and to see how they are put to use to try and
determine, or help determine, what is going on with an individual. I can also see how difficult it
can be to look at all the different issues and try to determine which one a patient actually has,
since some of them seem very close and many of the symptoms overlap. I am very interested in
learning more about all these processes in my bachelors program.