Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Acknowledgement
August 9, 2009
Well we, when writing this acknowledgement would like to acknowledge first
to Allah.
1
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Letter of Authorization
August 9, 2009
Course Instructor
For Summer Semester 2009, you are assigned to prepare a report on the
Internet Banking & EPS.
Yours sincerely,
2
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Letter of Transmittal
August 9, 2009
Course Instructor
We have attached a copy of the report on the Internet Banking & EPS. This
report is a summary of our findings from the research we conducted during
the summer semester of 2009. We were assigned this report by you in the
month of June. We are pleased to report that we have completed the project
on schedule.
Sincerely,
__________________ ______________________
talhasuhail@gmail.com syed.taha@live.com
0321-3893608 0321-2080126
3
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Executive Summary
We have used questionnaires and focus group to collect our data. The
questionnaire was formulated in such a way that it caters to all our
hypotheses.
The later part of the report includes the findings we observed from our
results and limitations that we faced during our work. We have further given
suggestions for the Internet banking in Pakistan in general.
4
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PG
S.NO CONTENTS
NO.
1 Introduction 6
3 Literature Review 11
4 Research Problem 15
5 Research Objectives 16
6 Hypothesis 17
7 Research Methodology 18
8 Hypothesis 1 19
10 Comparison of Banks 24
12 Hypothesis 2 26
13 Analysis 29
14 Findings 40
16 Annexure 44
5
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Introduction
One of the major forces behind the changes happening to business today is
technology, which is creating new products, services market opportunities and
developing more information and system oriented business and management
processes.
6
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Internet banking involves consumers using the Internet to access their bank
account and to undertake banking transactions. At the basic level, Internet
banking can mean the setting up of a web page by a bank to give information
about its product and services. At an advance level, it involves provision of
facilities such as accessing accounts, funds transfer, and buying financial
products or services online. This is called “transactional'' online banking.
There are two ways to offer Internet banking. First, an existing bank with
physical offices can establish a web site and offer Internet banking in addition
to its traditional delivery channels. Second, a bank may be established as a
branchless, Internet only or virtual bank. Broadly the levels of banking
services offered through Internet can be categorized in three types: (i) The
Basic Level Services use the banks websites which disseminate information
on different products and services offered to customers and members of
public in general. It may receive and reply to customers queries through e-
mail (ii) In the next level are Simple Transactional Websites which allow
customers to submit their instructions, applications for different services,
queries on their account balances, etc, but do not permit any fund-based
transactions on their accounts (iii) The third level of Internet banking
services are offered by Fully Transactional Websites which allow the
customers to operate on their accounts for transfer of funds, payment of
different bills, subscribing to other products of the bank and to transact
purchase and sale of securities, etc. Most of the banks providing Internet
banking products and services offer, to a large extent, an identical and
standard package of banking services and transactional capabilities.
A website plays very significant and key role in Internet banking. Websites
should be able to convey all the information for both current customers and
potential new customers via the Internet. If the content of the site fails to
pass sufficient information on account capabilities, then the site is not
fulfilling its objectives. The bank’s website provides a better way for
communication.
7
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
8
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Though efforts are being made to increase the number of on-line branches, it
is still a capital intensive proposal. It is getting popular in urban areas, but
has not become common in rural areas, mainly due to low literacy level in
the country. However, some analysts believe that with the passage of time,
confidence in the system and increasing use, traffic to branches in urban
areas will go down considerably.
One factor prohibiting use of the newly offered services is, its high cost. The
banking sector terms this nominal, keeping in view the level of convenience.
Saying this, they still believe that cost can go down further with the
increased use of these facilities. It is also believed that while the use of these
facilities is low due to apprehensions about security, clients take refuge
behind high cost.
A factor slowing down the process in this area is capital intensive nature of
these operations. The investment in technology by the commercial banks is
affecting the payout to shareholders as well as the depositors. The banking
sector experts term this only a brief phase.
9
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Electronic banking has been around for some time in the form of automatic
teller machines and telephone transactions. More recently, it has been
transformed by the Internet, a new delivery channel for banking services
that benefits both customers and banks. Access is fast, convenient, and
available around the clock, whatever the customer's location (see illustration
above). Plus, banks can provide services more efficiently and at substantially
lower costs. For example, a typical customer transaction costing about $1 in
a traditional "brick and mortar" bank branch or $0.60 through a phone call
costs only about $0.02 online.
10
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
The flip side of this technological boom is that electronic banking is not only
susceptible to, but may exacerbate, some of the same risks—particularly
governance, legal, operational, and reputational—inherent in traditional
banking. In addition, it poses new challenges. In response, many national
regulators have already modified their regulations to achieve their main
objectives: ensuring the safety and soundness of the domestic banking
system, promoting market discipline, and protecting customer rights and the
public trust in the banking system. Policymakers are also becoming
increasingly aware of the greater potential impact of macroeconomic policy
on capital movements.
Literature Review
INDIA
India is still in the early stages of E-
banking growth and development.
Competition and changes in technology
and lifestyle in the last five years have
changed the face of banking. The
changes that have taken place impose
on banks tough standards of competition and compliance. The issue here is
– 'Where does India stand in the scheme of Ebanking.' E-banking is likely to
11
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
The impact of E- Banking in India is not yet apparent. Many global research
companies believe that E-banking adoption in India in the near future would
be slow compared to other major Asian countries. Indian E-banking is still
nascent, although it is fast becoming a strategic necessity for most
commercial banks, as competition increases from private banks and non
banking financial institutions.
Despite the global economic challenges facing the IT software and services
sector, the outlook for the Indian industry remains optimistic.
The Reserve Bank of India has also set up a "Working Group on E-banking to
examine different aspects of E-banking. The group focused on three major
areas of E-banking i.e. (1) Technology and Security issues (2) Legal issues
and (3) Regulatory and Supervisory issues. RBI has accepted the guidelines
of the group and they provide a good insight into the security requirements
of E-banking.
BRITAIN
Through online banking you can get loan and mortgage facility by just filling
online applications, you can check your account balance any time and the
bank statements can be viewed online also.
12
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
You can verify the transactions and many banks supply information of
transactions for the last few months. Paying of bills is also very easy these
days with online banking.
Bank of Scotland as well as Halifax is the two of United Kingdom’s very well
known banks. They have been long known for the trustworthy services. They
have many branches and their internet services are also good.
The Northern Bank is a renowned bank and in their website you will find all
the relevant information. Through the website of Co-operative Bank you can
get the necessary details of their working methods.
Through the internet banking you can get the services of insurance, private
loans, investment plans and all of these can be done through simple online
application.
Some of the other banks which provide useful assistance through their
internet banking are those of HSBC; NatWest; One Account, The; Standard
Life Bank; Barclays; Nationwide; First Direct; The Co-operative Bank’s
internet bank – smile; Abbey and many other but you can get the assurance
for good customer service.
Internet banking has gained huge popularity among the people of United
Kingdom. Many of the banks in United Kingdom are being explored for the
functions of buyer empowerment and also for the attributes of the internet
banking.
Online banking has long been an important area of interest so many studies
are done to make new developments to meet the various expectations.[1]
[1] http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-the-united-kingdom/
UNITED STATES
13
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
you have made. Internet banking in the United States has quite a good
impact on the people there.
According to a study report around 53 million and possibly more than that if
not less Americans are using the benefits of banking online, the ratio being
one out of four for adults.
But there are many bank users who don’t trust financial institutions for
banking online for the sake of protecting their account. They are only
focusing on the negatives rather than the positives. Though online banking
reduces on road robberies but personality thievery, various scams and other
online robberies has led many people not to trust the institution.
Recent studies say that for this reason 40% of the users that may be almost
same to nearly 70 million or more adults having bank accounts do not have
faith in online transactions.
In spite of the negatives involved, worries and security faults it has not
succeeded totally in turning away people for the benefits associated with it
are more worthy. The users without any theft concern are making high
balance transactions showing great loyalty and trust on their institution.
They are also sharing their experience on the benefits of online banking to
their family and friends and referring them to do the same. This has led to
the growth of internet access and is estimated to grow itself as people start
becoming more internet savvy and technologically literate.[2]
[2] http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-australia/
AUSTRALIA
14
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
There is no denying the fact that favorable conditions prevail in Australia for
further growth and development in the internet banking sector. The good
communication systems that are all the more improving have helped out the
internet banking process. And the reality that majority people know how to
operate a computer is another boost to the internet banking facility.
‘ABA Industry Standard’ has mentioned some provisions for internet banking
in Australia. The scope of services that the banks must provide if they are
supplying internet banking facility are those of:
Initially only two out of fifty-two banks in Australia had started the internet
banking facility. But gradually the number has increased subsequently. Some
of the most successful banks of Australia are those of Commonwealth Bank;
Advance Bank; Metway; ANZ; National Australia Bank; Bendigo Bank Limited;
Citibank Australia; Deutsche Bank; Macquarie Bank Limited and many more.
Internet banking has made all the banking functionality easy and effective.
The fact that needs consideration is that the customers must not sacrifice
with the privacy of their transaction information.[3]
[3] http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-the-united-states
15
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Research Problem
The Internet Banking in Pakistan has not been able to make its mark since its
inception. It has undergone many challenges and threats and the main
reason for that is the lack of education and research and development in this
particular field. The government has not yet taken any significant steps
rather than just passing an ordinance in order to provide the banks a greater
platform to grow their horizons in
the field of internet banking to
meet the global benchmark.
However, UBl has emerged as the
only bank in Pakistan with wide
range of product and services for
its consumers of all levels along
with few other banks. Even the way
banks in Pakistan market their
other products and services
through advertisements; there has
not been a great deal of focus for
marketing the e-products and
services. Other than that not even a related work force of information and
technology and the machinery to is available nor even looked in by banks to
focus in this area.
The other major hurdle that banks come across is the lack of awareness
among general public and the consumers or customers of the bank. This is
because lack of education and information available to them. However it’s
the responsibility of the banks to educate their customers and shift them
toward the modern banking system and to make them understand its
advantages and importance which banks in Pakistan fail to do so.
16
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Research Objectives
The main objectives of this study are:
Objectives of a project tell us why project has been taken under study. It
helps us to know more about the topic that is being undertaken and helps us
to explore future prospects of the topic. Basically it tells what all have been
studied while making the project.
17
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Hypothesis
Hypothesis 1;
• Is UBL the benchmark in e-banking in Pakistan?
Hypothesis 2;
• Has internet banking penetrated in the minds of the customers?
18
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Research Methodology
Secondary research data are data that have been collected for some
other related research study previously conducted. Not much research
studies have been done related to this topic but some relevant secondary
data has been observed. Through internet research, some important points
have been acquired from some articles about Internet banking around the
world specifically India, Britain, United States and Australia. Other secondary
data has been collected from reputable research journals and some relevant
internet search engines such as Yahoo and Google. We have conducted a
series of semi-structured interviews to determine the business student’s
attitudes towards e-banking.
19
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Hypothesis 1;
• Is UBL the benchmark in e-banking in Pakistan?
Exploratory Research
Here, research is designed to allow an investigator to just look around
with respect to some
phenomenon, with the aim being to develop suggestive ideas. The purpose is
to gather as much
information as possible concerning a specific problem. Exploratory research is
often used when a
problem is not well known, or the available knowledge is not absolute. The
technique that is best
suited for information gathering when performing an exploratory research is
interviews.
Therefore, data was gathered from 19 different banks with the help of all the
classmates who searched the data through internet and through personal
interviews form personnel in different banks assigned to them.
20
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
My Accounts
21
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Download Statement
Real -time account statements can be viewed,
printed and e-mailed. Customers can specify the
date range for viewing the account statement
and also graphically analyze account statement.
22
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Pay Anyone
23
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
• Utility Bills
• Mobile Bills
• UBL Bills
• UBL Funds
• Investments
• Online Shopping
Alerts
Customers can set alerts to track movements in the listed
accounts. The customer can assign a target for alerts.
Alerts can be of the following types.
Balance Alert
Statement Alert
Transaction Alert
Cheque Tracking Alert
Low/High Balance Alert
24
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
[4] https://www.ubl.com.pk/ebank/features/
25
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
26
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Findings
The data collected shows that the hypothesis considered proved to be
correct because UBL right now the only bank with most e-services and
products for its customers. Though it has many rivals like Dubai Islamic
Bank, MCB and Standard Chartered Bank which are providing almost the
same services but UBL has excelled by providing NRP services which Dubai
Islamic bank is not. So it makes UBL leader in internet banking in Pakistan
and therefore we can say that today UBL is the benchmark through which we
can compare other banks from.
Conclusion
UBL is the leader in internet banking in Pakistan today. There are many local
and other international banks with great reputations and with bigger
clientele but are not providing much e-services and products. The main
reason is that consumer’s trust lies more in conventional banking because of
slow web interface, lack of knowledge, fraud and other risks associated.
27
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Hypothesis 2;
• Has internet banking penetrated in the minds of the
customers?
Sample design
Sample Size: - 30
Questionnaire: -
A questionnaire consists of a set of questions prepared to respondents for
their answers. Because of its flexibility, the questionnaire is by far the
common instrument used to collect primary data. Closed Ended as well as
Open Ended questionnaire were used in my market research.
Drafting of a Questionnaire: -
The formulation of the questionnaire, i.e., the structure and the disguise to
be used in the questionnaire depends upon the kind of information that is
desired. Questionnaire was prepared over a period of 5 days by intensive
brainstorming. A copy of the questionnaire has been attached as an
annexure to the project.
Since my objective was to derive out the maximum information out of the
passengers without making the whole exercise boring and troublesome, I
decided to keep majority of the questionnaire close-ended.
28
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
In order to generate and sustain the interest of the respondents, the initial
questions pertained to the gathering of simple information like the
knowledge of internet banking, the choice of their bank and the main areas
of their transactions. Since, I had to balance the twin objectives of gathering
maximum information and at the same time retaining the interest of the
customers, I was compelled to squeeze in a lot of questions and club them
up in a single question.
LIMITATIONS
People have more faith on the conventional banking system rather than the
internet banking
2. BUSY SCHEDULE.
People were mostly unwilling to talk because of their heavy schedule or they
get annoyed with the phone calls or even if they are asked about this face to
face.
3. RISKY PROFILE.
Some people think that transferring money is having a lot of risk and rather a
waste of time so they don’t want to transfer their money in from their
respective accounts
4. FRAUD
The very common difficulty in online trading is Fraud which can be faced by
any customer. Fraud can take place in many ways like stolen of Password,
29
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
online fund transfer to some other account, hacking etc. So some strict
guidelines or actions should be taken by RBI in order to stop this kind of
fraud which prevails online.
6. LACK OF KNOWLEDGE
30
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
ANALYSIS
(a) Yes
(b) No
31
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) UBL
(c) HBL
(d) MCB
(e) Others
32
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
It was witnessed that today MCB has the largest customer base and
after MCB, HBL has the highest customer base .Multi-national banks
are also making their presence noticeable in the Pakistani scenario
(a) Yes
(b) No
33
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Yes
(b) No
34
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
35
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Yes
(b) No
36
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Yes
37
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(b) No
It’s pretty tragic but most of the respondents are unaware of the
techniques which can be taken up for any type of fraud.
(a) Yes
(b) No
38
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Yes
(b) No
39
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Most of the respondents felt that they are not properly educated of
internet banking and its benefits to them.
10. Would you prefer using net banking instead of visiting your
bank every now and then?
(a) Yes
(b) No
40
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Convenience
41
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(b) Speed
(c) Transparency
(d) Time
FINDINGS
42
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
An old Chinese saying goes: If you don't know where you are
going - you will never get there.
43
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Benefits for the bank should always reflect benefits for the
customer of banking services.
44
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
Recent studies show that banks in the USA lost 20% of their most
valuable customers in favor of non-bank FI flexible enough to offer
diversified services and products.
Identifying profitable customers
SUGGESTIONS
The first and most obvious step they should take is to see to
it that the basic problem fueling dissatisfaction have been
addressed.
45
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
CONCLUSION
From all of this, we have learnt that information technology has
empowered customers and businesses with information needed to
make better investment decisions. At the same time, technology is
allowing banks to offer new products, operate more efficiently,
raise productivity, expand geographically and compete globally. A
more efficient, productive banking industry is providing services of
greater quality and value.
46
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
The major driving force behind the rapid spread of e-banking is its
acceptance as an extremely cost effective delivery channel. But on
the flipside, it is associated with risks such as reputation risk,
security risk, cross-border risk and strategic risk, which are unique
to e-banking. Banks need to have an effective disaster recovery
plan along with comprehensive risk management tool is significant
not only to the bank but also to the banking system as a whole.
Internet has created plenty of opportunities for players in the
banking sector. While the new entrants have the advantage of
latest technology, the good-will of the established banks gives
them a special opportunity to lead the online world. By merely
putting existing service online won’t help the banks in holding their
customer close. Instead, banks must learn to capitalize their
customer’s different online financial-services relationships
Annexure
QUESTIONNAIRE
(a) Yes
(b) No
47
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) UBL
(c) HBL
(d) MCB
(e) Others
(a) Yes
(b) No
(a) Yes
(b) No
48
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Yes
(b) No
(a) Yes
(b) No
(a) Yes
(b) No
9. Does your bank educate you about the net banking services
being offered?
(a) Yes
(b) No
10. Would you prefer using net banking instead of visiting your
bank every now and then?
(a) Yes
(b) No
49
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
(a) Convenience
(b) Speed
(c) Transparency
(d) Time
Personal Information
Name:
Age:
Phone No:
Occupation:
References/Bibliography
Website
http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-australia/
http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-the-united-kingdom/
http://pcinternetbanking.com/internet-banking-in-the-united-states/
50
Internet Banking &
[E-BANKING IN PAKISTAN] EPS
www.qla.net.pk
epubl.luth.se
http://ezinearticles.com/?A-Brief-History-of-Internet-Banking&id=353450
http://www.expresscomputeronline.com/20020916/indtrend1.shtml
E-Finance by Avinash Shankar
www.ubl.com.pk
51