Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Vs.
Conventional
Banking
A comparative
study on
Submitted by:
ID: 1330563060
Department of M.B.A
Submission Date
April 17, 2015
Letter of Transmittal
August 20, 2013
Nusrat Khan
Assistant Professor
North South University
Subject: Submission of the report on Islamic Banking Vs. Conventional Banking: A
comparative study on Exim Bank Ltd & Eastern Bank Ltd.
Dear Sir,
This is our pleasure to submit a report on Islamic Banking Vs. Conventional
Banking: A comparative study on Exim Bank Ltd & Eastern Bank Ltd Which we
were assigned. We have tried our best to prepare this to be as informative and
relevant as possible. To prepare this report we have reviewed some books, articles,
journals and downloaded some information from internet. We believe that the
knowledge and experience we have gathered during this course completion period
will immensely help us in our future professional life. We have concentrated our
best efforts to achieve the objectives of this course as well as report and hope that
our endeavor will serve the purpose. We considered your remarks and instructions
very carefully while preparing this report. We tried the best to follow your schedule,
format and discipline.
Thank you for your kind consideration.
Sincerely yours,
Nusrat Binta Nasir ID:09304123
North South University
Executive Summary
A Bank is an economic institution whose main aim is to earn profit through
exchange of money& credit instruments. It is a service oriented as well as profits
oriented organization. The Bank divides its operation mainly three parts- General
Banking, Foreign Exchange and Investment. The banking sector of Bangladesh is
passing through a tremendous reform under the economic deregulation and
opening up the economy. Currently this sector is becoming extremely competitive
with the arrival of multinational banks as well as emerging and technological
infrastructure, effective credit management, higher performance level and utmost
customer satisfaction. Bank has a significant role in the economic development of
the country. The successful banking business ensures the growth of the economy by
the effective uses of the funds. In order to developing the national economy, banks
keep in mind going for lending, maintaining safety, liquidity & profitability.
The report has been prepared on focusing Investment Activities of Exim Bank
Limited to compare with the activities of Eastern Bank Limited (EBL) whereas Exim
bank is serving as an Islamic bank and EBL is based on traditional banking.
Exim Bank Limited and Easter Bank Limited were introduced in Bangladesh as a
banking company under the Company Act 1913(Indian) and 1994 in Bangladesh.
Exim Bank commenced on operation on 2nd June 1999 and Eastern Bank
commenced on operation on 16th August 1992. Numerically both of the banks are
just another commercial Bank, now operating in Bangladesh, but the finders of
Exim Bank committed to make different & a little bit special qualitatively. This bank
has new vision to fulfill & a new goal to achieve & try to reach new height for
realizing its dream. We have done this report on the investment activities but
mainly focusing on the differences between Islamic banking and conventional
banking in comparing Exim bank with Eastern Bank Ltd. This is basically included
Investment and loan activities to show how this department works differently.
The 1st chapter contains the origin, objectives, limitations etc. of the study, 2nd
chapter is about the overview of EXIM Bank Ltd, 3rd chapter is about the overview
of Eastern Bank Ltd, 4th chapter is focused on the difference of investment banking
of EXIM Bank and EBL. At the end chapter 5 is all about the findings and conclusion
of the report.
CHAPTER -01
Introduction
1.1
Background of the Report
Bank is very old institution that is contributing toward the Development of any
economy and is treated as an important Service industry in the modern world.
Economic history shows that development has started everywhere with the
banking system and its contribution towards financial development of a country
is the highest in the initial stage. Modern banks play an important part in
promoting economic development of a country. Bank provides necessary funds
for executing various programs in the process of economic development. They
collect savings from large masses of people scattered throughout the country,
which in the absence of banks would have remained ideal and unproductive.
These scattered amounts are collected, pooled together and made available to
commerce and industry for meeting the financial requirements. Todays modern
banks are not only providing traditional banking but also expanding the many
financial services. In todays world the life of the people directly or indirectly are
within the arena of banking whether conventional or Islamic banking. Although
Islamic banking is not a newer concept in Bangladesh as it has started its
operation since 1983, very few people are aware about its operation. But things
are changing. Islamic Banking is also getting popularity in the country which is
the main focal point to this report shown the differences between Islamic and
conventional banking. In this regard, Exim bank ltd as an Islamic bank is not
same as EBL as a traditional bank.
1.2
1.3
Statement of the Problem
In general sense we mean bank as a financial institution that deals with money.
On the basis of functions bank can be categorized like Central bank, Saving
bank, Invest bank, Merchant bank, Commercial bank, etc. but when we use the
term bank it generally means commercial bank that collects the deposits from
surplus unit of society and then lends the deposits to the deficit units of the
society.
For the economic development of a country bank plays a vital role, but
traditional commercial banking Systems are interest based and Islamic finance
and banking interest is prohibited. Islamic finance refers to financial system that
complied with the Shariah. In this regard to establish a banking system that run
according to Shariah, the concept of Islamic banking arises. Though the regular
banking system and the Islamic banking system operate in different mode of
investment, there is confusion that both systems have merely any fundamental
differences. This confusion arises a question that is there actually any difference
between Regular banking system and Islamic banking system. Thats why It is
the key area that how Islamic banking and general commercial banking is
different in respect to Investment or credit which has been shown on studying
Exim bank ltd and EBL.
1.4
Objective of the Study
Broad Objective
We were instructed from our finance course lecturer Nusrat Khan to submit a
report on a comparative study on Exim Bank Ltd & Eastern Bank Ltd focusing
conventional and non-conventional banking system.
Specific Objectives
The specific objectives of this study are as follows:
To have an overall idea about Islamic banking system that claims to be
based on the Quran and the Sunnah.
To know the principles of Islamic banking system and conventional
banking and how it is operated.
1.5
Methodology
In this report we used secondary data those data that have already been
collected for the purposes other than problem at hand. In this report the external
data is used to collect the information about the financial growth of Exim Bank
Ltd and Eastern Bank Ltd. The external data have been collected from the
external source such as published materials, internet etc.
Annual Report, Audit Reports of Exim Bank Ltd and Eastern Bank Ltd.
Relevant books, Research papers, Newspapers and Journals.
Website of both the banks.
Bangladesh Bank Report.
Bangladesh Economic Review.
Unpublished data from the branch.
1.6
Limitation of the Study
It is not easy task to collect data and information about our requirement. So the
study suffers from various limitations, some of these are mentioned below:
In the study areas, the authorities are not willing to express accurate data
easily for the reason of their confidentiality.
Due to time limitation many of the aspects could not be discussed in the
present report.
Because of the limitation of information some assumption was made. So
there may be some personal mistakes in the report.
Almost all the personnel were apparently too busy to assist us with their
valuable support.
The study was limited only to the EXIM BANK Limited & EBL.
CHAPTER -02
Organization Part 1
Overview of EXIM Bank Ltd.
2.1 Historical Background of EXIM Bank Limited
EXIM Bank Limited was established under the rules & regulations of
Bangladesh bank & the Bank companies Act 1991, on the 3rd August 1999
with the leadership of Late Mr. Shahjahan Kabir, founder chairman who had a
long dream of floating a commercial bank which would contribute to the
conglomerates, including the top rated corporate borrowers from forwardlooking business outlook and innovative financing solutions.
Capital
The bank started with an authorized capital of Tk. 100 million in 1999 and as
on 31st December 2004 paid up capital stood at Tk. 627.75 million. The paid
up capital stood at Tk. 2677.75million as on 31st December 2008.
Analysis of Capital Structure
Capital structure of EXIM Bank has changed from year to year. The
components of the capital structure are paid-up capital; proposed issue of
dividend, share premium, statutory reserve, proposed cash dividend, retained
earnings and other reserve. Authorized and paid up capital of EXIM Bank:
S
L
PARTICULARS
PAID UP CAPITAL
TOTAL CAPITAL
SURPLUS/SHORTAGE OF CAPITAL
TOTAL ASSETS
TOTAL DEPOSIT
INVESTMENT AS A % OF TOTAL
DEPOSIT
INVESTMENT (GENERAL)
8
9
1
0
1
1
1
2
2010
6832.2
7
13957.
4
2011
2012
2013
11566.
35
21198.
7
5258.5
6
195452
.52
165733
.25
113070
.98
94949.
4
129874.4
2
107881.2
1
10514.
86
18214.
31
1561.1
4
167056
.63
140369
.66
98.26%
92.42%
84.22%
86.79%
118219
.99
63950.
48
143847
.38
60119.
38
84.22%
86.79%
4.27%
3.67%
93296.
65
55098.
36
9223.56
16109.56
99699.63
54929.92
3476.0
1
2009.37
2157.6
3
1913.3
9
7.10%
9.15%
9.96%
10.21%
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
2
0
97901.
97
15169.
01
109707.5
20166.92
3.54%
1.65%
131147
.17
35909.
46
159705
.77
35746.
74
1.94%
2.63%
1.45%
1.06%
183.79
312.38
EPS
3.77
2.18
2.05
1.65
3.54%
1.65%
1.45%
1.06%
P/E RATIO
11.34
12.76
10.14
7.8
Investments (General)
Total Investment (General) of the Bank stood at Tk.143,847.38 million as on
31 December 2013 against Tk.118,219.99 million as on 31 December 2012
registering a growth of 21.68%. As on 31 December 2013 Classified
Investment to total Investment ratio was 3.67% which was 4.27% as on 31
December 2012. Bank maintained required provision against Investment
(General) for the year 2013. Investment (General) has increased significantly
over the years due to the existence of innovative Investment products.
INVESTMENT (GENERAL)
160000
143847.38
140000
120000
118219.99
100000
80000
60000
93296.65
99699.63
68609.91
40000
20000
0 2009
1
2010
2
Mode-wise Investment
2011
3
2012
4
2013
5
SL
PARTICULARS
2012
1
2
3
BAI-MUAZZAL
BAI-MURABAHA
BAI-SALAM
IZARA BILL BAIA
(COMMERCIAL)
IZARA BILL BAIA (STAFF)
45404.59
21436.73
3368.18
IN MILLION TAKA
GROWT
2013
H
56154.57 23.68%
22458.66
4.77%
4175.05
23.96%
43007.03
53085.45
23.43%
1066.05
369.75
1701.43
575.26
59.60%
55.58%
1948.42
2290.71
17.57%
4
5
6
7
BAI-AS-SARF (FDBP)
MUSHARAKA DOCUMENTARY BILL
(MDB)
766.7
2079.89
469.48
1079.52
10
QUARD
383.05
118219.
99
246.84
143847.
38
TOTAL
171.28
%
129.94
%
-35.56%
21.68%
SL
PARTICULARS
2012
INVESTMENT INCOME
17307.83
12271.79
5036.04
AMOUNT IN MILLION
GROWT
2013
H
20417.5
17.97%
15458.8
25.97%
8
4958.62
-1.54%
2023.68
2020.16
-0.17%
1025.98
8085.7
2751.35
5334.35
1645.9
3688.45
1530.82
2157.63
1.87
1177.05
8155.83
3227.94
4927.89
1680.57
3247.33
1333.94
1913.39
1.65
14.72%
0.87%
17.32%
-7.62%
2.11%
-11.96%
-12.86%
-11.32%
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
CHAPTER -03
Organization Part 2
To become the bank of choice by transforming the way we do business and developing a truly
unique financial institution that delivers superior growth and financial performance and be the
most recognizable brand in the financial services in Bangladesh.
EBL dreams to become the bank of choice of the general public including both the consumer and
the corporate clients. It has adopted a new logo that looks very dynamic in its attractive colors
that reflect all the changes that are taking place in EBL.
We will deliver service excellence to all our customers, both internal and external.
We will constantly challenge our systems, procedures and training to maintain a cohesive and
professional team in order to achieve service excellence. We will create an enabling environment
and embrace a team-based culture where people will excel. We will ensure to maximize
shareholders value.
The EBL Management Team or Management Committee (ManCom) comprises of a group of fifteen
people and each of them comes with an international working background and are committed in
leveraging their experiences to take EBL to greater heights by ensuring top line revenues with dynamic
capabilities.
EBL ManCom is unique in being able to envision the need of the business by bringing in a mixture of
advanced technology solutions know-how and revamping the organizational make- up for maximum
profitability.
The objective of EBL ManCom is to drive the business to maximize the operational excellence and
efficiency through acquisition of talent, developing systems, processes and people and through blending
in of these to let customers revel in with fulfillment and permanency.
SERVICE EXCELLENCE
OPENNESS
TRUST
COMMITMENT
INTEGRITY
RESPONSIBLE CORPORATE
CITIZEN
Over the years, the Bank has shown its resilience facing odds and challenges under
volatile operating environment. The year 2014 was no exception. Some of the
major challenges that affected the financial industry were low credit appetite,
excess liquidity in the market and rising trend of NPL. In face of these challenges,
the bank deployed a strategic repositioning or realigning of business concentration,
took an approach of cost rationalization, and gave more emphasis on service
excellence (0-5 Days service delivery commitment) and product innovations
Operating Income (+7%)
The banks total operating income comprise of two major items: net interest
income (NII) and non-interest income (NoII). In 2014, NII accounted for 40%
while NoII accounted for 60% of total operating income (33% from investment
income, 26% from fees, commission and FX income and 1% from other operating
income). Investment income increased signifi cantly by 61% in 2014 to BDT 3,343
million (Investment income share in total operating income increased from 22% in
2013 to 33% in 2014) while our net interest income decreased by 18% in 2014 to
BDT
4,009 million (NII share in total operating income decreased from 52% in 2013 to
40% in 2014)
Net Interest Income (-18%)
Round the year 2014, bank experienced a mismatch between loan and deposit
growth, which affected our net interest income. In 2014, bank interest income
decreased by 11% while bank interest expense decreased by 8% for following
reasons:
Interest Income (-11%)
Banks interest income from loans, the principal component of interest income,
decreased by 11% or BDT 1,647 million mainly for following reasons:
Although loans and advances increased by 15% to BDT 118,291 million at
year-end 2014 from BDT 102,910 million at year-end 2013, there was an observed
stagnancy in credit growth during first half (H1) of 2014 and a positive turnaround
from the third quarter of 2014.
Weighted average return on loans and advances decreased to 12.43 percent in
December 2014 as compared to 14.57 percent in the previous year mainly due to
lower credit appetite and rise of NPL (interest income is transferred to suspense
account on classification).
Interest Expense (-8%)
CHAPTER -04
Investment Division of EXIM bank Vs. Loan & Advance of
EBL
4.1 Investment Division of EXIM Bank Ltd.
For any bank, loans and advances constitute the largest portion of asset
section in Balance Sheet. Investment division of financial institutions plays a
vital role in developing the national economy. Without such support
development for a country like Bangladesh were difficult to imagine. The
main objective of EXIM Bank Limited is to boost up the economy by proving
adequate support to the market through its investment division.
Investment Products
Corporate Finance
Commercial Finance
Industrial Finance
Project Finance
Lease Finance
Syndicate Finance
Hire Purchase Finance
Real Estate Finance
Loan and Investment Policy Of EXIM Bank
In a bank all loans are its investment but all investments are not loans. Banks
make both loans and investment for different purposes. The dual purposes of
loans and investments are liquidity and profitability. More loans mean more
risks and more profit while more investments mean more liquidity but less
profit. Investments are made in more liquid and less profitable instruments
while loans are made at higher profit on less convertible security. Investments
are generally made in government instruments with strong liquidity. More
investments in highly secured and liquid instruments would ensure safety
with less profit while more loans could make a bank vulnerable but very
profitable. Thus a balance between liquidity (investment) and profitability
(loans) needs to be arrived at judiciously by each and every bank.
General Policy Guidelines
EXIMBank makes loan to reputed clients.
Encourages lending to socially desirable, nationally important and
financially visible sector.
Satisfactory security and collateral is required including source of
repayment both primary and secondary source.
Overdraft
Cash Credit
Term Loan
Staff Loan
Bills Portfolio
Packing Credit
Bank Guarantee
Commercial Loan
Commercial Loan
Single/individual
Joint holder
Proprietorship firm
Partnership firm
Private Limited Company
Mode of Investment
1. Mudaraba
It is a form of partnership of profit where one party provides funds
while the other provides expertise and management. The first party is
called the Sahib-al-Maal and the latter is referred as the Mudarib. Any
profits acquired are shared between two parties on a pre-agreed basis,
while capital is due to the breach of trust by the mudarib
2. Bai-Muazzal
Bai-Muazzal may be defined as a contract between a buyer and a
seller under which the seller sells certain specific goods permissible
under Islamic Shariah and the law of the country to the buyer of an
agreed fixed price payable at a certain fixed future date in lump sum
or within a fixed period by fixed installments. The seller may also sells
goods purchased by him as per order and specification of the buyer.
3. Bai-Murabaha
Bai-Murabaha may be defined as a contract between a buyer and a
seller under which the seller sells certain specific goods (permissible
under Islamic Shariah and the law of the land) to the buyer at a cost
plus agreed profit payable in cash or any fixed future date in lump sum
or by installments. The profit marked up may be fixed future lump sum
or in percentage of the cost price of the goods.
4. Musharaka
Musharaka is a contract of partnership between two or more
individuals or bodies in which all partners contribute capital,
participate in the management, share the profit in proportion to their
capital as per pre-agreed ratio and bear the loss, if any in proportion
to their capital/equity ratio.
5. Izara Bill Baia
Izara bill baia is a special type of contract which has been developed
Loan Disbursement
Loan is allowed for a single purpose where the entire amount may be
required at a time or in a number of installments within a period of short
span. After disbursement of the loan amount, there will be only repayment by
the borrower. A loan once repaid in full or in part, cannot be drawn again by
the borrower. Entire amount of loan debited to the loan account in the name
of the customer and is paid to him through his STD/CD Account. Sometimes
loan amount is disbursed in cash.
EBLs capital market operations are conducted by Investment Banking Unit. IBU capitalizes the
huge growth potential therein and diversifies the business to maximize the risk adjusted return.
This unit makes investment in the capital markets and contributes towards fee-based income and
capital gains by taking acceptable level of risk.
EBL Investment Banking Unit, within a very short span of time, has been active in doing the
followings:
EBL revised structure and strategies to meet the challenges of rapidly evolving technology based
banking services, growing competition in the financial service industry, changes in customers
need. These changes are designed to promote growth, enhance customer services, enrich asset
quality, arrange low cost funds and maximize banks earnings.
EBL made concrete plans to restructure the entire gamut of Eastern Bank Ltds banking
standards and its transaction viz corporate, consumer, treasury, trade services etc. This enables
the bank to operate with greater efficiency in all respects thus resulting the better revenue
generation compared to past years.
In 2002 EBL made significant progress in upgrading our asset portfolio by booking high quality
accounts (blue chip local corporate and multinational). The effort was ongoing EBL also
introducing new monitoring standards, credit approval guidance and initiated the process to
establish a separate credit administration unit to ensure greater control. This brought better
management of asset relationships.
The loans and advance of the bank stood at tk 11,861 million indicating an increase of 3.65% as
against tk 11,288 million of preceding year.
The loan facilities that offered by EBL are:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Real Estate loan: REL, which are secured by real property-land, buildings and other structures
and which includes short term loans for construction and land development and longer term loans
to finance the purpose of farmland, homes, apartments, commercial structure and foreign
properties.
Financial institution loans: FIL includes credit to bank, insurance companies, finance
companies and other financial institution..
Agricultural loans: AL extended to farm and ranch operation to assist in planting and
harvesting crops and to support the feeding and care of livestock.
Commercial and industrial loans: C & IL granted to business to cover such expenses as
purchasing inventories, paying taxes and meeting payrolls.
Loans to individuals: Loans to individuals, including credit to finance the purchase of
automobiles, mobile homes, appliances and other retail to repair and modernize homes, cover the
cost the medical care and other personal expenses, either extended directly to individuals or
indirectly through retail dealers.
Miscellaneous loans: ML, which includes all those loans not classified here, including
securities loan.
Lease financing receivables, where the bank buys equipment of vehicles and lease them to
its customers.
CREDIT ASSESSMENT
A thorough credit and risk assessment is conducted prior to the granting of loans, and at least
annually thereafter for all facilities. The results of this assessment are presented in a Credit
Application that originates from the relationship manager/account officer (RM), and is approved
by Credit Risk Management (CRM). The RM is the owner of the customer relationship, and is
held responsible to ensure the accuracy of the entire credit application submitted for approval.
RMs are familiar with the banks Lending Guidelines and should conduct due diligence on new
borrowers, principals, and guarantors.It is essential that RMs know their customers and conduct
due diligence on new borrowers, principals, and guarantors to ensure such parties are in fact who
they represent themselves to be. The bank has its established Know Your Customer (KYC) and
Money Laundering guidelines which are adhered to at all times.
Credit Applications summarize the results of the RMs risk assessment and include, as a
minimum, the following details:
Amount and type of loan(s) proposed.
Purpose of loans.
Loan Structure (Tenor, Covenants, Repayment Schedule, Interest)
Security Arrangements
In addition, the following risk areas are also addressed:
Borrower Analysis
The majority shareholders, management team and group or affiliate companies is assessed. Any
issues regarding lack of management depth, complicated ownership structures or inter-group
transactions are addressed, and risks mitigated.
Industry Analysis
The key risk factors of the borrowers industry are assessed by the RM. Any issues regarding the
borrowers position in the industry, overall industry concerns or competitive forces is addressed
and the strengths and weaknesses of the borrower relative to its competition should be identified.
Supplier/Buyer Analysis
Any customer or supplier concentration is reported in the credit application, as these could have
a significant impact on the future viability of the borrower.
Historical Financial Analysis
An analysis of a minimum of 3 years historical financial statements of the borrower is presented
in banks specified format. The analysis should address the quality and sustainability of earnings,
cash flow and the strength of the borrowers balance sheet. Specifically, cash flow, leverage and
profitability must be analyzed.
Adherence to Lending Guidelines
Credit Applications should clearly state whether or not the proposed application is in compliance
with the banks Lending Guidelines.
Mitigating Factors
Mitigating factors for risks identified in the credit assessment is identified and reported in the
application.
Loan Structure
The RM makes sure that the amounts and tenors of proposed financing are justified based on the
projected repayment ability and loan purpose. Excessive tenor or amount relative to business
needs increases the risk of fund diversion and may adversely impact the borrowers repayment
ability.
Security
A current valuation of collateral is obtained and the quality and priority of security being proposed
is assessed. Loans are not granted based solely on security. Adequacy and the extent of the
insurance coverage are also taken into consideration.
Name Lending
In this case bank also follows the prudential guidelines which says Credit proposals should not
be unduly influenced by an over reliance on the sponsoring principals reputation, reported
independent means, or their perceived willingness to inject funds into various business
enterprises in case of need. These situations should be discouraged and treated with great
caution. Rather, credit proposals and the granting of loans should be based on sound
fundamentals, supported by a thorough financial and risk analysis.
APPROVAL PROCESS
The approval process segregates the work of Relationship Management/Marketing from the
approving authority. The responsibility for preparing the Credit Application rests with the RM
within the corporate/SME banking department. Credit Applications are recommended for approval
by the RM team and forwarded to the approval team within CRM and approved by individual
executives.
The recommending or approving executives take responsibility for and are held accountable for
their recommendations or approval.
CHAPTER -05
Findings & Conclusion
7.1 Findings
Since this report focuses on the differences between Islamic banking and
conventional banking studying two different banks (EXIM bank ltd as an
Islamic Bank and EBL as conventional bank) It finds out numerous differences
in various areas. These are;
Differences of philosophy & principles
Terminology: Exim bank Ltd vs. EBL
Loan and credit department in Exim bank Ltd is termed as investment
division whereas is loan and advance in EBL. The following table shows
same division used in different terminologies:
Modes of Investment in EXIM Bank
Limited
Mudaraba
Bai-Muazzal
Bai-Murabaha
Musharaka
Izara Bill Baia
Wazirat Bill Wakala
FDBP (Foreign Documentary Bill
Purchased) LDBP (Local Documentary Bill
Purchased)
BAIM (hypo) Vs. Cash credit
Overdraft: Exim Bank Ltd Vs. EBL
Conclusion
Reference