Management Control Systems

!
!

!
!
!
|

"

#$|
#"
%

$
"

&' (
' )*+
+

,
-!
! ./0
! /0
! +/$10
!
2/
0

|3
$

#

+

2
3.

(

3&
-4
-4
-4

53#
)

"

*

,
1

63# ,

-

'
#
)
)/20
;

,
)
7
)
)

)
8
,
9
,
:

-2

4 -#

#
)

,

!
,
+.2
<

-2
-
,

7
+
7
)

,
,
+
|3
3
3
53
63
m3
3
=3

)
./0
&2
-4

/
0
|3
3
3
53
63
m3

'"
'
2

&

3 +2
=3 *
>3 +
|?3
"
||3
@@

| 3 .
=
_
!

! +
$

2$
"

>
_
!
4

where
how @

!
! )
! *
)$$
$"$

3This is because Corporate HQ, in the related diversified
firm, has the ability to transfer core competencies from one
business unit to another3
|?
_
!
4

&

)
*
-

&

2
+"
9$-
,$
+
,
||
_
!
*4
7
|0 0
&"7*
'7
+,

&
882

2 7*
7*

_
!
7! 7

D
(
D
D
AB

AC2B

A
B

A.B

(
(
D
(

|
_
!
7! +
&,"
)7
D
#

(
9
nvest
Strongly
9
nvest
Selectively
9
nvest
Selectively

Earn/
Protect
,
(
Harvest/
Divest
Earn/
Protect
: 2
Dominate/
Delay/Divest
(
Harvest/
Divest
(
Harvest/
Divest
92
7
|5
_
!

1!
! 9:
! D7*":
! 97*%:
,

!
#<
|6
_
! #
!
,6
Threat of

+

Bargaining
Power
ntensity of
#

Bargaining
power
Threat
From

|m
_
! #
!
,6

! 6
2@6

! .6

! *

_
!
! ,
&6

"
)!

8

|=
_
!
! ,

44
.

.

(

244
&4
#

#

|>
_
!
!
<
<

#
")

&<
22

3
?
_
!
!
<
,
.

2

8
(
E4 -$D)$#&
_
!
!
<

-$21!
|3
$/0:
3
/0
:
3

/0:
53 |$ :
7$
$7*44
3

#
24

#$
1!

924
:
:

# -') (-
&')

+"

#

92! 2
'

#
,

-') (
' &)'(;&+

)! ,$ $
5
4
-

'
#
)
)/20
;

,
)
7
)
)

)
8
,
9
,
:

-2

!
"#
$

+'

2

,|

,

,

)

)7

)

!
#

+'

7*F

7*;

,

7*G

2

,

2

,

2

!
#
%

+"'

-

-7

-

,F

,;

,G

&

.
7*4
3D
3
&

>
-

.
,
,
/0

.

)

$

.

3
&

|

&7*
!

7* 7*
7*
7*
!

$7* 4 77*
! 7
)
4 7

)
/)
0

3
)

)
"

)
!

)
3*
$/0
/0
#
'
92
)
AB

5
)
!

)
#
3-
"$

1
)
!
! ++

+
)
+doing things right)

+
)
%doing right things)
& %"@)

,

/0
/0
)
4 &
'

#
/0
'
92
/0
+"! -

v
vvv
vv v
v v
E4 |3#
3'
3'

)
4 &
'

#
'
92
/0
/0
+"! ).-

v "'
vv v
v v
)
4 &
#

#
/

0
'
92
/0
+"! 2-

vv _v
v v
>
)
4 &
#

#
'
92
/0
/0
+"! 7*

$
v v
5?
)
4 &
,

#
/0
'

/0
+"! 7*

vv
v v
5|
)!
"
,
++
.+
+

.

#84 8
'

'

7
7
2
7

7
.

/
0
7AB
.

/

0
.2
/%
@0
-
.

"
)!
,
,
,

)

"3

"3
#84 8
'
/0
/"0
'

/0
/"0

7
2

"
"
"
)
!
.+
%
7! 2

&2 !
7'1
#7
G77
!
&-!
! .2

55
)
!

!

.
(2
7

AB
.
H
56
)
!
).!$

.

(2
7

').

7! ! ! !

).

I).

-$4

-$
,

81"

! )."$
)

+/
0
5m
)
!
2
!
(

&)
"

"
2!

$
AB
2"I
2"

A'4B

5
)
!
,

2
4

5=
)
!
,

#1
C2
DC442
+
&
+
#
&

5>
)
!
,

.

(
)1
#DC
#4

4
&4
6?
)
!
,

!

!

.

,7&
, &
6|
)
!
#

.

4 actual cash held at HQ much less than that would have been required as
an independent company
)! whether to include at SP or COGS?
#! how to deal with creditors?
92
! treatment of current liabilities 2 extreme treatments
-" ! which value to consider? Problems with depreciation
(! preference for leased assets over owned assets so as to reduce
capital charge
#! exclusion from computation of assets employed
#! Capitalization of items like R & D and its repercussion on EVA
if capitalized, very less incentive to cut such expenditure as it would only reduce
a part of if by way of capital charge
)! ,
#! )'#8+<
,
)#
+<

)#

3
+<
2
3

)#3

3
+< 3#

,&"3

+<
)#
+<
)#
,

<-
|???$)#
+<

<-
|???$)#
+<

)#

+<

6

)!
,#! )#
)#
! #!
)#3
! $

! #

65
)!
,#! +< )#
5
! +< $2)#2
)#/ ?I0)#/?I0

/|?I03Ro creates a bias towards little or no
expansion in high-profit business units while at the same time low-profit units are making
investments at rates of returns well below those rejected by high-profit units
! *)#3&
+< 3
! .3-2$
39)#3
! +< )#
%23&7*
$+< 3
66
,,
|3 )

3 .
3 -
53
63
m3 -
6m
7!
7
'
7.
7

#
#

)
7
,
,
7!
&
! &

-""
-
#G7
$1$2
#
! #

! #

! #3<
23
! #44
2
6=
7!
G
#$G77
/de novo0
1

&G77

122! should the activity
under review be performed at all? What should the quality
level be?
#
3D3
6>
&,4
#
$2
3
&
3
'&,!
&7*

&
&7*%
#
m?
&,4
-&,

23
!

2
&4
#"
&,$

&4!
&,4
"3
&2
42
m|
&,4

!

,! !
|3 ,2

3 7*
,
23
2

&,4
Comparative usage of the TP methods by fortune 1000
Companies as per survey by Vijay Govindarajan

:

&,4

!

.,/ 0

7
.DC

&

2
m5
, !
7

.J
,2!
J) %

-

&

#
#
-
-

m6
, ! 7

! .4
,
-
4

&
"

&

"

+"
)#$+< $,

$
+
.

&1

#1
1
.

1$

1
$
3
D
7

3
mm
7
/ 7
04
$7
7
42
8

3&3-
"$
!
&1'D

3 7

3
# 7
E4
!
!
!
!
!
-4
,
2
,"
+44
7
/ 7
04

,
&

J

$

$
7'D
D$(
D
7

(

)
)

(
@'D

@'D

m=

.1
(
4
! &

m>

!
,

,
'

2
,
,
&,

,
?

!
-

&
)2
&

!
D
'

.
"
&4
,
#1

71$

D112

-
"

!
'

-

,

'

2$
8

2
&2$
$$3,
3
23 2
2
3-
3
! .

,
-

#

,
&

&2

&2
2

&

2

C

C#
9

7
7

77
.
7

3 2
3
'
3
'
3
*3
'3

+
,8
$

$

+
+
6

$$
3
& 2$
2$
3
4
2"3
D213
#
2
3

Management Control Systems

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Management Control Systems

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

E4 -$D)$#&

+doing things right)

, ! 7

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

Management Control Systems

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Management Control Systems

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate



 E4 -$D)$#&

+doing things right)

, ! 7

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

E4 -$D)$#&

+doing things right)

, ! 7