Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Construction
Strengthening the Weak Links
Premium restructuring another bid to clear clog, may not be enough to
improve project viability
The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) has given the principal approval for
restructuring premium payments for certain projects with the aim to improve project
viability and ease cashflows of already strained developer balance sheets. The deferred
premium payments would help concessionaires to use cashflows from the initial few
years for equity commitments for the project. However, it may not be sufficient to improve
viability of projects due to aggressive bids. In our view, the cancellation and re-bidding of
projects would be a prudent option [recently the National Highway Authority of India
(NHAI) cancelled four BOT projects, which are set to come up for re-bidding] against
premium restructuring, which is likely to face challenges.
Authority aims to clear the clog: Maintain Buy on IRB, Ashoka Buildcon
In the last 2 years, the road sector did not witness any awarding or construction activity.
A large part of the construction work did not keep up with execution run rates, which led
to project delays, mainly due to EC FC clearances and the limited ability of prospective
bidders to mobilize additional equity and competitive bidding, making the project
cashflows unviable to support premium payments. Heightened risk perception about BOT
projects causes financial institutions to be reluctant to take additional exposure in
highway BOT projects.
In this scenario, we maintain a Buy rating on IRB infrastructure and Ashoka Buildcon
because of their strong road-asset portfolio and stable order-books. With a minimal
funding requirement, these companies remain well-funded for exploiting new
opportunities as and when the NHAI awarding activity picks up. We retain a hold rating on
ITNL, given its high parent leverage, along with decelerating high margin fee income
could mean rising interest cost pressures, thereby causing deterioration in profitability.
Sector Update
Emkay
Construction
Sector Update
Concessionaire
Rampur- Kathgodam
Lucknow - Sultanpur
Agra - Etawa by pass
Hospet-Chitradurga NH-13
Cuttack-Angul NH-42
Solapur - MH/KNT border NH-9
Shivpuri-Dewas
Raipur - Bilaspur
Vijaywada - Gundugolanu
Obdedullganj-Betul
Solapur - Bijapur
Aurangabad-Barwa Adda
Rajumundary - Gundugulanu
Jalgaon - Gujarat/MH Border
Amravati - Jalgaon
Jind-Punjab/Haryana Border
Kota - Jhalwar
Sangareddy to MH-KNT Border NH-9
Hospet-Bellary NH-63
Kishangarh-Udaipur-Ahmedabad
Anandpuram - Vishakhapatnam - Ankapalli
Coimbatore Mettupalayam
Barwa Adda Panagarh
ERA-Sibmost
Essar-Atlanta
Ramky Infrastructure
Ramky Infrastructure
Ashoka Buildcon
Coastal-SREI
GVK
IVRCL A&H
Gammon Infrastructure
Transstroy
Sadbhav
KMC
IVRCl A&H
L&T
L&T
Unity Infra
Keti Constructions
L&T
PNC
GMR Infrastructure
Transstroy
Transstroy-OJSC
IL&FS Transportation
Total
Length Km
Bid date
93
123
125
120
112
100
332
126
104
123
111
222
121
209
275
69
88
145
95
555
58
53
123
8,500
10,790
13,460
10,450
11,240
9,230
28,150
12,160
17,430
9,120
10,025
24,190
17,510
19,730
25,259
4,388
5,300
12,660
9,101
53,870
8,630
5,920
1,665
340
96
1,281
630
611
280
1,809
455
576
330
756
1,350
721
1,451
1,310
102
35
800
180
6,360
820
23-Nov-11
13-Sep-11
24-Nov-11
18-Nov-11
18-Nov-11
12-Dec-11
1-Aug-11
18-Nov-11
24-Jan-12
17-Jan-12
26-Mar-12
30-Mar-12
30-Mar-12
30-Mar-12
30-Mar-12
30-Mar-12
15-Apr-11
30-Sep-11
29-Jul-11
29-Jul-11
30-Mar-12
420
10-Apr-13
328777
20712
Source:
Emkay Research
Loans provided by the NHAI, which will not reflect in developers books; however, it
would provide interim relief to concessionaire, as deferred premium payments would
help concessionaires to use cashflows from the initial few years for equity
commitments for the project, ultimately to improve project viability and ease cashflows
of already strained developer balance sheets. At the same time, the government also
wants to ensure adequate financial commitment from developers so as to ensure
timely completion of projects.
2
Construction
Sector Update
As the NHAI would be considering rescheduling on a case to case basis, smallpremium projects and premium projects, which have commenced work, are likely to
remain out of the mechanism. There is a risk that some of these developers may
litigate if they, too, are not given this premium restructuring option, causing further
delays.
The window for resolving this standoff is very short, given the upcoming elections in
early 2014. In case the standoff continues, it is unlikely that the NHAI would be able to
bid out a sizeable number of BOT projects in 2HFY14E/1HFY15E.
The prudent strategy, we believe, is to kick-start the projects that have been weighed
down due to financial closure and aggressive biddings, and re-invite them for rebidding, which would attract serious developers and discover a new premium or a grant
base.
In our view, the major persistent issue with regard to projects involves financial
restructuring, since other structural problems related to land acquisition, re-bidding for
those projects that have not achieved financial closure (though the intensity can be lower),
and asking financial Institutions to take additional exposure in highway BOT projects,
especially in those cases where the NHAI satisfies all precedent conditions, can still be
resolved.
We have noticed that developers are weighed down by economically unviable road projects
as a result of aggressive biddings and due to a lack incentives to help them keep the
projects in their kitty (in some cases the performance guarantee was not submitted which
forms 1% of the project cost). We have highlighted a list of 21 stalled projects (Exhibit 10)
on account of land acquisition issues (delay caused due to EC/FC clearances ), with
majority of them considered for premium for restructuring, part of which is likely to come up
for re-bidding . We believe the solution to kick-start these projects that are weighed down
due to financial closure is to re-invite them for re-bidding, which would attract serious
developers and discover a new premium or a grant base.
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
Contractor
(km)
Cost (bn)
Lane
1. Vijayawada-Eluru-Gundu Golanu
VG Road project
103.6
16.8
2. Rajahmundry-Gundu Golanu
IVRCL
121.0
16.2
3. Anandapuram-Vskp-Anakapalli
TRanstroytollway
4. Raipur-Bilaspur
IVRCLAssets
5. Jind-Punjab/Haryana border
UnityInfra
6. Aurangabad-Barwa Adda
KMCConstruction
7. Hospet-Bellary
PNCBetul
L&T DPL
9. Hospet-Chitradurga
RamkeyInfra
120.0
10.3
10. Shivpuri-Dewas
GVK
332.5
28.2
11. Obedullaganj-Betul
TRanstroyOJSC
121.0
9.1
Coartal Srei
100.0
9.2
13. Solapur-Bijapur
SadhbhavEngineering
110.0
9.9
14. Jalgaon-Gujaratborder
L&T Infra
208.0
19.7
15. Amravati-Jalgaon
L&T Infra
275.0
25.4
16. Agra-Etawah
RamalkyInfra
124.5
12.1
17. Cuttack-Angul
Ashoka Buildcon
112.0
11.2
18. Kota-Jhalawar
Keti Construction
88.1
5.3
19. Kishangarh-Ahmedabad
GMR Infra
555.5
53.9
20. Lucknow-Sultanpur
Essar Atlanta
125.9
10.4
21. Rampur-Kathgodam
ERA-Sibmost
93.2
7.9
59.0
8.6
126.5
12.2
69.4
4.4
220.0
24.2
95.4
9.1
145.0
12.7
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
3000
2500
2000
1500
6380
1000
479
FY14
(Sep2013)
635
2205
2693
1784
2249
2848
637
FY13
FY12
FY11
FY10
FY09
FY14
(Sep2013)
1682
753
FY08
FY12
FY11
FY10
FY09
643
500
1116
FY13
1145
FY08
FY07
1390
FY07
3360
1608
FY06
5058
FY06
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
6380
5058
3360
3055
1608
1390
1145
345
FY06
89
FY07
FY08
1116
643
123 356
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14
(Sep2013)
Completed
4/6 lane(km)
Under
Length (km)
Implementation
No. of projects
NHDP Phase-I
7522
NHDP Phase-II
6647
7514
10
5647
610
52
385
NHDP Phase-III
12109
5611
4813
89
1685
NHDP Phase-IV
NHDP Phase-V
20000^
285
4130
33
10384
6500
1584
2496
28
2420
NHDP Phase-VI
1000
1000
NHDP Phase-VII
700*
21
20
659
Misc. Projects
656
363
293
NH-34
5.5
5.5
NHDP component
SARDP-NE
Total
388
69
43
276
55528
21094
12419
226
16808
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
State
(kms)
Cost (Rs.mn)
Barwa Adda-Panagarh
West Bengal
122.9
16,650
Jabalpur-Lakhanadone
Madhya Pradesh
80.8
7,770
Bids invited
Bhavnagar-Verawal (4 lane)
Gujarat
260.0
32,400
Bids invited
Yadgiri-Warangal (4 lane)
Andhra Pradesh
99.0
9,570
Hospet-Hubli (4 lane)
Karnataka
143.3
12,930
Numaligarh-Jorhat (4 lane)
Assam
51.2
5,850
Ghoshpukur-Salsabari (4 lane)
West Bengal
154.9
22,120
Karaikudi-Ramanathapuram (2 lane)
Tamil Nadu
80.0
3,360
Bids to be re-invited
Demoh-Dibrugarh (4 lane)
Assam
46.0
4,730
Jorhat-Demoh (4 lane)
Assam
81.8
8,750
Jharkhand
Aurangabad-Vedishi (4 lane)
Maharashtra
Chandikhole-Dubari-Bhuban (4 lane)
Odisha
62.2
6,520
Parwanoo-Shimla (4 lane)
Himachal Pradesh
89.6
22,930
Chhutmalpur-Saharapur-Yamunagarh-Haryana/UP border
Uttarakhand/ UP
104.8
10,240
EPS (6 lane)
Haryana/ UP
135.0
NA
Solapur-Vedishi (4 lane)
Maharashtra
98.7
9,700
Hissar-Dabwali (4 lane)
Haryana
145.8
13,320
2,023.30
208,530
Total
78.3
2,980
189.1
18,710
Status
Work Awarded to ITNL
NA
Bids to be re-invited
No bids received, project to be restructured
Bids to be invited
Bids invited
The on-going 2- and 4-laning NHAI projects, where financial closures have been
achieved by the concessionaire, but COD has not yet been declared by the authority.
The 6-laning NHAI projects, where financial closures have been achieved by the
concessionaire, but a project completion certificate has not yet been declared by the
authority.
Completed 2-, 4- and 6-laning NHAI projects awarded in BOT mode.
All new NHAI projects under PPP yet to be bid out in BOT mode in line with case a, b,
and c as the case may be.
The provision substitution has always been in-built in the model concession
agreement:
Concession agreement for 2000: 51% during the construction period for 3 years
following COD and to hold 26% for the remaining concession period.
Concession agreement post-November 2009 (B. K. Chaturvedi Committee): 51%
during the construction period till COD, and for a period up to 3 years, the bidder can
reduce the shareholding to 33%. Thereafter, the shareholding can be brought down to
26% for the remaining concession period.
The current concession agreement provides a 51% stake during the construction
period for 2 years following COD.
However, the current concession agreement contains provision for substitution of the
existing concessionaire to lenders, and such a substitution could have been involved in
case of: (a) financial default (delays of 3 months in servicing debt), (b) concessionaire
default (lender gets 270 days to substitute concessionaire), and (c) other cases of breach
of provisions of MCA.
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
Exhibit 8: Out 47 projects tendered during FY12, only eight projects commenced construction till date
Projects
Bidder
Award date
Nagpur-Wainganga bridge
May-11
Km Type
45 BOT
Apr-12
Panikholi-Rimoli
Gayatri projects
Aug-11
163 BOT
2 laning of Kisnagiri-Tindivanam
Transitory-OJSC corporation
May-11
Vijaywada-Machhlioatnam
Madhucon projects
Nov-11
64 BOT
Kota -Jhalwar
Keti construction
Apr-11
88 BOT
Rampur-Kathgodam
Era infra-OJSC-SIBMOST
Nov-11
93 BOT
L&T IDPL
Nov-11
145 BOT
Hospet Chitradurga
Ramkey infra
Nov-11
120 BOT
4-laning Solapur-Bijapur
Sadbhav eng
Mar-12
110 BOT
4-laning of Cuttcuk-Aangul
Ashoka Buildcon
Nov-11
12 BOT
Gammon Infra
Mar-12
107 BOT
Coastal-srie Consortium
Dec-11
100 BOT
4-laning of Rohtak-Jind
Vijai infra
Dec-11
48 BOT
JSR Construction
Mar-12
22 BOT
IL&FS transportation
Feb-12
84 BOT
Beawer-Pali-indwara
L&T IDPL
May-11
244 BOT
Dec-11
Tantia-Jiangsu
Jan-11
69 BOT
Oct-11
Unity Infra
Mar-12
68 BOT
Simplex infra
Mar-12
102 BOT
Patna Buxar
Gammon infra
Nov-11
124 BOT
4- laning of Obedullnganj-Betul
Transitory
Feb-12
125 BOT
4-laning of Khagaria-Bakhtiarpur
Navayuga Engineering
Mar-12
112
4-laning of Hoskote-Dobbaspet
Transitory-OJSC Consortium
Mar-12
80 BOT
4-laining of Jalgaon-Maharashtra/Gujarat
L&T IDPL
Mar-12
208 BOT
4-laining of Amravati-Jalgoan
L&T IDPL
Mar-12
275 BOT
Jabalpur to Lakhanadone
Gannon Dunkerley
Jul-11
80 BOT
4-laning of Gwalior-Shivpuri
Essel infraprojects
Sep-11
125 BOT
4-laning of Shivpuri-Dewas
GVK Transportation
Sep-11
330 BOT
4-laning of Raipur-Bilaspur
Nov-11
126 BOT
Gammon infrastructure
Mar-12
125 BOT
4-laning to Hospet-Bellary-Karnataka/AP
Oct-11
95 BOT
Simplex infrastructure
Dec-11
127 BOT
79.3 BOT
4-laning of Gomti-Chauraha-udaipur
Mar-12
4-laning of Meerut-Bulandshahar
C&C construction
Sep-11
66 BOT
4-laning of Lucknow-Sultanpur
Essar-Atlanta(JV)
Oct-11
125 BOT
2-laning of Muzaffarpur-Barauni
Oct-11
107 BOT
Lucknow-Raibareli
Essel infratructure
Nov-11
Abhijit Roads
Nov-11
153 BOT
4-laining of Jabalpur-Katni-Rewa
Soma Tollways
Aug-11
225 BOT
6-laning of Gundugolanu-Rajamundry
Mar-12
120 BOT
6-laning of Anandapuram-visakapatnam-Anakapalli
Transtroy-OJSC corporation
Mar-12
58 BOT
Jul-12
70 Annuity
Ahmedabad to Vadodra
IRB infrastructure
Apr-11
102 BOT
KMC construction
Mar-12
221 BOT
Vijaywada-Gundugolanu
Gammon Infra
Feb-12
103 BOT
Eatawah-Chakeri (Kanpur)
Oriental structural
Nov-11
160 BOT
Agra-Etawah Bypass
Ramky Infra
Nov-11
124 BOT
6-laning of Kishangarh-Udaipur-Ahmedabad
GMR Infra
Sep-11
555 BOT
Jan-13
Mar-13
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
Leeway provided on financial net worth. The concession agreement currently provides
leeway in terms of minimum net-worth threshold, which is at 10% of the project cost as
against 25% of the project cost for BOT contracts.
DLP (defect liability period) of 2 years on completion of the project highway and
additional DLP for major bridges and structures of 3 years (total 5 years).
Defined maintenance period of 2 years after the completion of work; 1.5% and 2% of
the contract price to be paid to the contractor in the first and second year, respectively.
Incentive for the contractor for early completion in the form of a bonus.
Damages up to 1% of the project cost would be paid by the authority on account of any
delay from their side.
The contractor cannot sub-contract any work in more than 70% of the total project
length.
The EPC contract allows for a JV of maximum three players, with the lead member
responsible for satisfying 60% of technical and financial requirements (others have to
satisfy 30% of requirements). This is in addition to the weighted score exceeding the
technical and financial requirements.
Emkay Research
Construction
Sector Update
State
Rajasthan
(kms)
33.0
Cost (Rs.mn)
1,000
Status
Awarded
Parsoli-Gulabpura
Rajasthan
36.3
1,140
Awarded
Rajasthan
62.2
1,770
Awarded
Merta City-Lambia-Jaitaran-Raipur
Rajasthan
52.8
1,580
Awarded
Rajasthan
32.4
1,490
Awarded
Ambedkarnagar-Raebareilly (2 lane)
Uttar Pradesh
155.9
4,960
Bids invited
Raebareilly-Banda (2 lane)
Uttar Pradesh
133.3
3,510
Bids invited
Rajasthan
139.0
3,680
Bids invited
Bhilwara-Ladpura (2 lane)
Rajasthan
67.8
2,370
Bids invited
Padhi-Dahod (2 lane)
Rajasthan
85.6
2,790
Proposal given
Unaira-Gulabpura (2 lane)
Rajasthan
214.0
5,710
RFP stage
Sitarganj-Tanakpur (2 lane)
Uttarakhand
Karauli-Dholpur (2 lane)
Rajasthan
Biharsharif-Barbigha-Mokama (2 lane)
52.2
2,200
100.9
2,890
Bihar
56.3
1,940
Chhapra-Rewaghat-Muzzaffarpur (2 lane)
Bihar
75.0
3,050
Patna-Gaya-Dhobi (4 lane)
Bihar
127.2
10,270
Jalandhar-Amritsar (6 lane)
Punjab
20.0
4,930
Thanjavur-Pudukkotai (2 lane)
Tamil Nadu
55.2
1,700
Tirumayam-Mannamadurai (2 lane)
Tamil Nadu
77.7
2,520
Bareilly-Sitarganj (2 lane)
UP
74.5
2,970
Rajasthan
75.0
Bar-Bilara-Jodhupur (2 lane)
Rajasthan
125.0
Rajasthan
154.0
2,005.10
62,470
Total
Source: NHAI
Emkay Research
10
Construction
Sector Update
Date
Name of Project
Winners
Cost
(Rs
bn)
Apr-11
Apr-11
May-11
Jul-11
Sep-11
Sep-11
Oct-11
Nov-11
Nov-11
Nov-11
Nov-11
Nov-11
Nov-11
Dec-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
Jan-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
May-12
Jul-12
Jul-12
Aug-12
Nov-12
Nov-12
Nov-12
Mar-13
Mar-13
Ahmedabad Vadodara
Beawar-Pali-Pindwara
Barwa Panagarh
Kishangarh--Ahmedabad
Gwalior Shivpuri
Shivpuri Dewas
Lucknow Sultanpur
Cuttak Angul
Etawah and Chakeri (Kanpur)
Hospet Chitradurga
Mah/KNT- Sangareddy
Patna - Buxar
Raipur Bilaspur
Bikaner - Suratgarh
Chittorgarh Neemachah
Kiratpur - Ner chowk
Obdellagang - Betul
Amravati Jalgaon
Anadpuram- Visakhapatnam - Ankapalli
Gomti Chauraha - Udaipur
Hoskote - Dobaspet
Jalgaon - Guj/Mah Border
Jind - Punjab/Haryana Border
Kharagpur-Baleshwar
Rajahmundry - Gundugulunu
Sikar - Bikaner
Solapur - Bijapur
Bridge across Narmada (Vadodara - Surat section)
Walajahpet - Poonamallee
Goa karnataka - Kundapur
Raebareli-Jaunpur
Coimbatore-Mettupalayam
Walayar-Vadakkancherry
Kashipur-Sitarganj
Rajasthan border-Fatehpur-Salasar
Rajsamand-Gangapur-Bhilwara 87 6.8 Sadbhav Engg Ltd
Rohtak-Hissar
Khed-Sinnar
IRB Infrastructure
L&T
DSC
GMR Infra
Essel Infraprojects
GVK
Essar - Atlanta
Ashoka Buildcon
Oriental Structural
Ramky Infra
L&T
Gammon Infra
IVRCL
MBL Infra
Chetak Enterprises Ltd.
IL&FS Transportation
Transtroy
L&T
Transtroy - OJSC
Sadbhav Engineering
Transtroy - OJSC
L&T
Unity infrastructure
IL&FS Transportation
IVRCL Asset
IL&FS Transportation
Sadbhav engineering
HCC
Essel project
IRB Infra
PNC Infratech
Transstroy-OJSC Consortium
KNR Construction
Galfar Engg & Contracting SAOG
Galfar Engg & Contracting SAOG
Sadbhav Engg Ltd
Sadbhav Engg Ltd
IL&FS Transportation Networks
49.2
23.9
16.7
53.9
10.6
28.2
10.4
11.2
14.9
10.5
12.7
8.1
12.2
5.1
5.1
18.2
9.1
25.4
8.4
11.1
7.2
19.7
4.4
4.8
16.2
6.3
11.0
5.1
12.9
24.0
5.7
5.9
6.8
6.1
5.3
6.8
9.6
13.5
195
244
123
556
125
330
126
112
160
120
145
105
127
172
117
113
121
275
58
79
80
209
69
119
121
238
110
6
93
187
166
54
54
77
154
87
99
138
13
16
9
7
15
14
12
16
9
14
19
1
17
6
9
4
6
12
6
10
4
17
5
5
3
1
16
2
19
2
8
6
1
1
2
1
5
4
22
19
20
11
28
19
34
27
35
37
37
36
33
33
36
28
36
22
35
39
36
29
40
40
35
30
38
35
37
35
30
35
32
30
32
35
34
40
59%
84%
45%
64%
54%
74%
35%
59%
26%
38%
51%
3%
52%
18%
25%
14%
17%
55%
17%
26%
11%
59%
13%
13%
9%
9%
42%
6%
51%
6%
27%
17%
3%
3%
6%
3%
15%
10%
479.6
5,686
296
942
33%
Total
Players
% Final
Length
Final
prebids
(km) bidders qualified participation
Source:
Emkay Research
11
Construction
Sector Update
Traffic grow th
Q1FY14
Q4FY13
Q3FY13
Q1FY14
-4
Q4FY13
Q2FY13
Q1FY13
Q4FY12
Q3FY12
Q2FY12
Q1FY12
Q4FY11
Q3FY11
Q2FY11
Q1FY11
Q3FY13
(1.3)
-2
(0.8) (2.2)
(1.4) (1.4)
Q2FY13
0.0 (0.1)
Q1FY13
0.0
Q4FY12
1.2
Q3FY12
0.4
1.8
2.0
(2.0)
0.8
3.1
4.0
5.8
Q1FY12
3.7
Q4FY11
6.0
5.8
4.9
Q3FY11
6.9
8.0
Q2FY11
9.7
10.0
Q1FY11
12.0
-6
-8
Port traffic
8.0
6.0
5.0
6.0
6.0
5.0
5.7
3.3
3.2
4.0
2.5
2.0
1.0
0.2
(0.3)
Q4FY12
Q1FY13
(2.0)
Q1FY11
Q2FY11
Q3FY11
Q4FY11
Q1FY12
Q2FY12
Q3FY12
(4.0)
Q2FY13
Q3FY13
Q4FY13
Q1FY14
(3.8)
(6.3)
(6.0)
(8.0)
Container traffic
Emkay Research
12
Construction
Major amendments
Agreement
Sector Update
discussed
under
Model
Concession
Emkay Research
13
Construction
Sector Update
Applicable Factor
0.85
0.6
0.2
Project cost
0-2.5
30% of TPC
Above 2.5-upto-6.5
25% of TPC
Above 6.5
205 of TPC
(iii) Restriction on the Applicants on account of pending financial closure and nonperforming assets
It is proposed that applicants shall be restricted from participating in the project in case
financial closure of three or more awarded projects is pending on the date of the RFQ
submission for reasons attributable solely to the applicant. Currently, this provision is
provided in the RFP document.
For 4-laning projects: Percentage revenue sharing would start from the fourth year of
COD or thereafter (depending on the bid), and would increase by 1% every year till the
tenth anniversary of COD. Thereafter, the increase would be 2% per year for the rest of
the phase of the concession period.
For 6-laning projects: Percentage revenue sharing would start from the scheduled
project completion date or thereafter (depending on the bid), and would increase by 1%
every year till the tenth anniversary of project completion date. Thereafter, the increase
would be 2% per year for the rest of the phase of the concession period.
Emkay Research
For 4-laning projects: Bidders should quote a specific monetary amount that is payable
to the authority from the fourth year of COD, and this amount should increase by 5%
per year till the tenth anniversary of COD. Thereafter, the increase would be 8% per
year for the rest of the phase of the concession period.
14
Construction
Emkay Research
Sector Update
For 6-laning projects: Bidders should quote a specific monetary amount that is payable
to the authority from the scheduled project completion date, and this amount should
increase by 5% per year till the tenth anniversary of completion of construction.
Thereafter, the increase would be 8% per year for the rest of the phase of the
concession period.
15
IRB Infrastructure
Separating Fundamentals from the Noise
Rating
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs78
Rs158
NA/NA
-7
Nifty
6,096
Sensex
20,529
Price Performance
(%)
1M
Absolute
Rel. to Nifty
3M
6M 12M
-22
-31
-50
-1
-25
-38
-54
Source: Bloomberg
% 0
150
-14
125
-28
100
-42
75
-56
50
Oct-12
Strong cashflows from a healthy mix of operating and underconstruction assets, and moderate gearing the key
competitive differentiators in a capital-intensive business
Previous Reco
Buy
175
Dec-12
Feb-13
Apr-13
Jun-13
Aug-13
-70
Oct-13
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Construction
IRB IB
Bloomberg
3,324
10
Face Value(Rs)
332
158/ 52
52 Week H/L
Market Cap (Rs bn/USD mn)
26/ 427
3,061,331
3.7
62.9
62.9
62.7
FII/NRI
22.3
22.3
22.7
Institutions
4.0
4.0
4.0
Private Corp
3.9
3.9
4.3
Public
6.9
6.9
6.3
Source: Bloomberg
Nitin Arora
nitin.arora@emkayglobal.com
+91-22-66242491
Ajit Motwani
ajit.motwani@emkayglobal.com
+91-22-66121255
Current price implies less than 1x book value adjusted for Mumbai-Pune
The stock has corrected 34% over the last 3 months. The current market price of Rs79
(market capitalization of Rs26.2bn) implies value of 0.4x the invested book (historically
seen at 1x) adjusted for the Mumbai-Pune Expressway Project (MIPL). IRB has invested
Rs33bn in FY13 as equity investments, and loans and advances in BOT road projects.
We have adjusted the value for MIPL of Rs13.6bn (FY13 revenue is Rs4.16bn; likely to
report revenue of Rs4.39bn and Rs5.43bn in FY14E and15E, respectively), with
relatively low debt of Rs8.76 bn. MIPL (Mumbai - pune ) accounts for 24% of our SOTP
and 40% of value derived for the total BOT road assets. This is one the non-disputable
road assets, which has certainty of cashflows, with a revenue CAGR of 14% over FY1315E as against 13% during FY11-13. We understand that there have been concerns
over the recent project (Ahmedabad-Vadodara), with relatively aggressive bid & traffic
disappointment. However, we believe, Amritsar-Pathankot, Jaipur-Deoli and AmravatiTalegaon projects have potential value, as these were won in a low-competitive
environment and at high grant levels (close to 40%).
Financial Snapshot (Consolidated)
YE-
Net
EBITDA
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
FY12A
31,307
13,735
FY13A
36,872
16,333
FY14E
41,433
FY15E
44,109
(Rsmn)
EPS
EPS
RoE
EV/
APAT
(Rs) % chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
43.9
4,960
14.9
9.6
18.8
5.3
5.6
0.9
44.3
5,567
16.7
12.2
20.4
4.7
5.5
1.0
18,705
45.1
4,471
13.5
-19.7
16.1
5.8
5.7
0.9
21,184
48.0
5,636
17.0
26.1
17.8
4.6
5.9
0.8
16
Company Update
Emkay
IRB Infrastructure
Company Update
50
25
40
20
30
15
20
10
17
24
37
31
41
44
10
5
10
14
19
21
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY10
FY15E
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
5.0
4.0
3.0
4.0
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
6.0
4.5
FY11
2.0
16
5.6
5.0
5.6
4.5
1.0
-
15
13
12
FY10
FY11
17
17
13
FY12
FY13
Emkay Research
FY14E
FY15E
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
17
IRB Infrastructure
Exhibit 20: Flat EPC revenue growth
Company Update
Exhibit 21: BOT revenue to surge higher
30
25
25
20
20
15
15
26
10
5
21
17
26
24
10
20
15
10
11
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
FY14E
FY15E
Exhibit 22: Current market price implies less than 1x invested book value
CMP
No of shares
79
332
26260
13,411
12,849
33,075
1,073
32,002
0.40
Emkay Research
18
IRB Infrastructure
Company Update
FY11
FY12
FY13
Equity
Short Long
term term
Thane-Bhiwandi bypass
611
Mumbai-Pune Expressway
778
Pune-Sholapur
451
Pune-Nashik
519
12
Ahmednagar-Karmala-Tembhurni
80
80
200
Total Equity
611
611
978
778
451
451
531
519
80
80
Short Long
term term
18
Total Equity
Short
term
Long
term
Total
629
611
1212
778
451
451
451
534
519
519
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
722
222
228
5,472
6344
872
2680
3,552
434
15
1,073
80
Thane-Ghodbunder
222
707
929
222
Bharuch-Surat
872 2,297
3169
872
855
855
1,336
227
1563
1,336
566
1,902
2,611
2611
4,653
1,117
5770
4,653
847.8
5,501
500
611
295
Pathankot-Amritsar
355 1,180
257
1792
355
162 1,145
1662
774
7.9
2326.3
3,109
Talegaon-Amravati
322
57
381
322
151
828
1301
364
352
1093.4
1,810
Jaipur-Deoli
390
264
272
480.62
2924.9
4,380
Panji-Goa
311
929
1173.1
1,485
1110 315.727
1110.7
2,537
1000
33.61
2950.0
3,984
801
972.92
6,558 11578.2
33,075
Tumkur-Chitradurg
0 1,181
156
926
780
200 1,837
2817
975
1240
311.4
1,173
1484
311
1337
476
476
952
1,000
69 2,950
4019
Ahmedabad-Vadodara Expressway
MVR Infra
Subtotal - Investment in road projects
8,457 6,772
1,775
312 1,588
1900
312
1353.2
1665.2
312
957
1,269
586
587
586
587
586
587
26
26
119.4
119.5
0.09
182
182
182
182
10.1
10.2
0.09
211
211
898 1,796
2694
898 1483.81
2381.81
898
1351
2,249
32002 15,837
7,909
Hospitality subsidiary
Sindhudurg Airport
Subtotal - Investment in other subsidiaries
Total investments in subsidiaries
9,354 8,570
9,316 8,942
11,578
35,324
Emkay Research
19
IRB Infrastructure
Company Update
Valuation
Measure
Disc rate
Value
(Rs mn)
Value
/Share
EPC Business
100%
PV of O&M Contracts
100%
PER
14128
42.5
NPV
13.5%
3,178
9.6
17,306
52
100%
FCFE
12.5%
13,411
40.3
Surat Dahisar
90%
FCFE
13.5%
2,590
7.8
Bharuch Surat
100%
FCFE
13.5%
3,442
10.4
Mohol-Mandrup Road
100%
FCFE
13.5%
-37
-0.1
Kharpada-Patalganga Bridge
100%
FCFE
13.5%
226
0.7
100%
FCFE
13.5%
244
0.7
Thane Ghodbunder
100%
FCFE
13.5%
1,109
3.3
Pune Nashik
100%
FCFE
13.5%
306
0.9
Pune Sholapur
100%
FCFE
13.5%
522
1.6
100%
FCFE
13.5%
1,462
4.4
100%
FCFE
14.5%
3,268
9.8
100%
FCFE
13.0%
656
2.0
Amritsar Pathankot
100%
FCFE
14.5%
6,531
19.7
Jaipur - Deoli
100%
FCFE
14.5%
6,952
20.9
Amravati Talegaon
100%
FCFE
14.5%
2,970
8.9
Tumkur Chitradurga
100%
FCFE
14.5%
200
0.6
Ahmedabad Vadodara
100%
FCFE
14.5%
-3,731
-11.2
Goa - Kundapur
100%
FCFE
15.5%
-610
-1.8
39,513
119
Asset Operated
2,411
7.3
-8,275
-24.9
33648.7
101.2
1,650
5.0
56,137
158
Emkay Research
20
IRB Infrastructure
Company Update
Balance Sheet
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
Net Sales
31,307
36,872
41,433
44,109
3,324
3,324
3,324
3,324
28.4
17.8
12.4
6.5
25,243
29,232
32,630
37,139
17,572
20,540
22,728
22,925
Net worth
28,566
32,556
35,954
40,463
1,376
1,557
1,731
1,722
1,123
1,092
1,030
927
Secured Loans
50,455
66,349
72,259
90,491
Unsecured Loans
17,913
12,712
12,712
12,712
Loan Funds
68,367
79,060
84,970 103,203
259
259
Growth (%)
Expenditure
Employee Cost
Other Exp
SG&A
Minority Interest
FY15E
970
1,223
1,330
1,330
13,735
16,333
18,705
21,184
Growth (%)
25.6
18.9
14.5
13.3
43.9
44.3
45.1
48.0
Total Liabilities
Gross Block
57,817
57,918
91,005
2,283
2,830
3,368
3,917
Net block
55,534
55,088
87,636
92,113
24,452
49,160
36,024
48,548
186
620
620
620
28,399
27,205
17,714
16,802
1,624
2,488
2,171
1,003
EBITDA
Depreciation
2,970
4,415
5,581
6,538
10,765
11,918
13,124
14,646
34.4
32.3
31.7
33.2
Other Income
1,252
1,301
1,236
1,193
Interest expenses
5,505
6,153
7,730
7,917
Investment
PBT
6,512
7,066
6,630
7,923
Current Assets
Tax
1,552
1,530
2,221
2,390
Inventories
EBIT
EBIT margin (%)
Less: Depreciation
23.8
21.7
33.5
30.2
4,960
5,536
4,409
5,533
6.9
11.6
-20.4
25.5
15.8
15.0
10.6
12.5
-31
-62
-103
4,960
5,567
4,471
5,636
Reported PAT
4,960
5,567
4,471
5,636
PAT after MI
4,960
5,567
4,471
5,636
Misc. exp
9.6
12.2
-19.7
26.1
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
5,260
5,765
5,394
6,730
Profitability (%)
Depreciation
2,970
4,415
5,581
6,538
Interest Provided
5,505
6,153
7,730
7,917
-779
476
442
Tax paid
-1,587
-2,422
Operating Cashflow
11,369
Capital expenditure
Free Cash Flow
Adjusted PAT
Growth (%)
Net Margin (%)
E/O items
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
Sundry debtors
259
259
96,030
141
310
1,033
1,046
18,208
14,710
4,813
5,057
8,427
9,696
9,696
9,696
10,265
19,106
19,954
13,403
Current liabilities
10,017
15,996
16,844
10,293
248
3,110
3,110
3,110
18,134
8,099
-2,240
3,399
Provisions
Total Assets
Key Ratios
Other income
Investments
Investing Cashflow
Equity Capital Raised
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
EBITDA Margin
43.9
44.3
45.1
48.0
Net Margin
15.8
15.0
10.6
12.5
ROCE
14.1
12.9
12.9
12.5
-5,395
ROE
18.8
20.4
16.1
17.8
-2,221
-2,390
RoIC
24.0
22.9
20.3
17.1
14,387
16,925
13,400
-24,201
-25,456
-24,994
-23,538
EPS
14.9
16.7
13.5
17.0
-12,832
-11,069
-8,068
-10,138
CEPS
23.9
30.0
30.2
36.6
1,252
1,301
1,236
1,193
BVPS
85.9
78.4
88.7
102.2
1.8
4.0
3.2
0.0
-3,702
1,680
-25,484
-21,167
-23,758
-22,344
Y/E Mar
DPS
Valuations (x)
PER
5.3
4.7
5.8
4.6
24,457
14,815
5,910
18,232
P/CEPS
3.3
2.6
2.6
2.1
Interest Paid
-5,505
-6,153
-7,730
-7,917
P/BV
0.9
1.0
0.9
0.8
-1,319
-1,191
-1,245
-1,127
EV / Sales
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.8
EV / EBITDA
5.6
5.5
5.7
5.9
2.3
5.1
4.1
0.0
2.9
17,633
7,471
-3,064
9,188
3,518
691
-9,897
244
1.8
2.5
2.7
12,000
18,208
14,710
4,813
Net Debt/EBIDTA
3.7
3.9
4.3
4.6
15,518
18,899
4,813
5,057
-0.9
-65.4
-62.1
-13.7
Emkay Research
21
IL&FS Transportation
Higher Leverage to Suppress Earnings
Rating
Previous Reco
Hold
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs111
Rs134
NA/NA
Nifty
6,096
Sensex
20,529
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
6M 12M
Absolute
-7
-25
-39
-40
Rel. to Nifty
-9
-28
-45
-45
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
% 20
200
175
-12
150
-28
125
-44
100
Oct-12
Dec-12
Feb-13
Apr-13
Jun-13
Aug-13
-60
Oct-13
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Construction
ILFT IB
Bloomberg
1,943
10
Face Value(Rs)
194
Since fee income is a high-margin stream of revenue for ITNL and the contribution of fee
income to total revenues is expected to tumble from 17% in FY13E to 10.9% in FY15E
as per our calculations, we estimate standalone EBIDTA growth to remain muted at a
CAGR of 4% over FY13-15E, with the EBITDA margin likely to contract by 200bps and
260bps in FY14E and FY15E, respectively.
52 Week H/L
229/ 97
22/ 353
88,829
0.2
46.3
46.5
46.5
FII/NRI
43.3
43.6
42.6
Institutions
6.5
7.0
7.0
Private Corp
1.8
1.0
1.2
Public
2.2
2.1
2.6
Source: Bloomberg
YE-
Net
EBITDA
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
FY12A
56,056
14,656
FY13A
66,449
18,396
FY14E
64,185
FY15E
77,908
(Rsmn)
EPS
EPS
RoE
EV/
APAT
(Rs) % chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
26.1
4,970
25.6
14.8
20.2
4.3
8.3
0.8
27.7
5,194
26.7
4.5
16.4
4.2
8.8
0.6
19,171
29.9
4,368
22.5
-15.9
11.4
4.9
8.8
0.5
24,430
31.4
4,711
24.2
7.8
11.2
4.6
7.7
0.5
22
Company Update
Emkay
IL&FS Transportation
Company Update
Earnings highly leveraged to order inflows, high debt still remain a concern:
Maintain Hold
With robust order inflow in till FY13, ITNL has been able to deliver 17% earnings growth
over FY10-13 led by its high margin fee income. However as ITNLs earning & cash flows
are highly leverage to new order inflows, we believe sustaining such high growth rate in fee
income is unlikely. Given this backdrop of decelerating high margin fee income growth, the
high parent leverage (standalone debt at Rs53 bn with D:E at 2.2x in FY15E) could mean
increasing interest cost pressures for ITNL. High leverage in absence on meaningful rate
cuts to put pressure on standalone profitability and could mean increasing interest cost
pressures for ITNL. Dilution eminent in/post FY15E as standalone leverage unsustainable.
We have cut our target price to Rs134 (Earlier TP 150) as we have adjusted traffic for some
of the projects like kiratpur ner chowk (implied P/BV0.45x) as well as for projects like sikar
Bikaner & khed sinnar and reduced our E&C multiple to EV EBITDA of 3x from 3.5x as
construction earnings will edge lower in FY14E and construction earnings trajectory
remains uncertain as some projects faces structural issues.
8.0
7.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
-
6.9
5.7
5.6
5.7
5.7
5.2
(Rs bn)
(Rs bn)
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
FY15E
34%
21%
FY11
Fee income
3.6
3.3
3.5
3.4
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
-
169
2.1
148
144
1.6
102
50
55
33
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
Consolidated Debt
FY14E
2.5
1.8
1.5
0.9
50
40
1.1
30
53.5
1.0
0.5
41.5
37.4
15.3
18.9
FY10
FY11
20
27.3
10
0
FY12
FY13
Standalone Debt
FY14E
FY15E
Debt/equity
100.0
30
77.9
80.0
66.4
(Rs bn)
40.5
24.1
20.0
24
25
64.2
56.1
60.0
60
1.8
1.4
Net Debt/equity
40.0
FY15E
2.2
2.0
FY15E
(Rs bn)
FY14E
(Rs bn)
(Rs bn)
100
FY13
10.9%
150
FY12
15%
200
17%
18
20
15
10
19
15
12
8
0.0
0
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
FY10
FY11
Revenue
Source: Company, Emkay Research
Emkay Research
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
EBITDA
Source: Company, Emkay Research
23
IL&FS Transportation
Exhibit 31: Consolidated PAT
6.0
4.4
4.3
4.7
27.0
22.2
25.0
3.0
16.4
15.0
2.0
10.0
1.0
5.0
11.4
11.1
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
6.46
6.49
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY10
FY15E
FY11
PAT
Source: Company, Emkay Research
60
47.9
50
37.7
27.7
30
16.2
20
10
33.7
(Rs bn)
40
8.5
0
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
5.48
5.32
5.52
FY10
FY11
FY12
Revenue
Source: Company, Emkay Research
Emkay Research
FY12
ROE
(Rs bn)
20.2
20.0
3.4
(%)
(Rs bn)
4.0
30.0
5.2
5.0
5.0
Company Update
FY13
FY14E
6.98
FY15E
EBITDA
Source: Company, Emkay Research
24
IL&FS Transportation
Company Update
SPV
Holding
Valuation
Measure
Disc
Equity
Value
Stake
Value
rate
(Rs mn)
(Rs mn)
Value/
Share
BOT
Gujarat Road and Infrastructure company ltd
WGEL
Delhi - Noida
Gomti - Beawar
RIDCOR
RIDCORII
83.6%
Operational
FCFE
13%
7,525.5
6,292.1
32.4
100.0%
Operational
FCFE
14%
1,613.9
1,613.9
8.3
25.4%
Operational
FCFE
14%
6,268.8
1,589.1
8.2
100.0%
Operational
FCFE
14%
350.4
350.4
1.8
50.0%
Operational
FCFE
14%
8,130.2
4,065.1
20.9
50.0%
Under development
FCFE
15%
3,783.6
1,891.8
9.7
100.0%
Under Construction
FCFE
15%
2,846.3
2,846.3
14.7
35.0%
Under development
FCFE
15%
1,683.5
589.2
3.0
50.0%
Under development
FCFE
15%
3,288.7
1,644.3
8.5
100.0%
Under development
FCFE
15%
7,088.7
7,088.7
36.5
Kharagpur - Baleshwar
100.0%
Under development
FCFE
15%
-258.3
-258.3
-1.3
100%
Under development
FCFE
15%
2923
2923
15
Sikar Bikaner
100%
Under development
FCFE
15%
829.8
829.8
4.3
Khed Sinnar
100%
Under development
FCFE
15%
816.5
816.5
4.2
100%
Under development
FCFE
15%
623.5
623.5
3.2
47,514
32,905.4
169
94%
Operational
FCFE
13%
1,145.6
1,071.2
5.5
50%
Operational
FCFE
13%
-468.7
-234.0
-1.2
100%
Operational
FCFE
13%
-494.9
-494.9
-2.5
74%
Under Construction
FCFE
13%
537.2
397.5
2.0
26%
Under Construction
FCFE
13%
-54.9
-14.3
-0.1
74%
Under Construction
FCFE
14%
185.0
136.9
0.7
100%
Under Construction
FCFE
14%
157.2
157.2
0.8
100%
Under development
FCFE
14%
544.9
544.9
2.8
50%
Under development
FCFE
14%
1121.2
560.6
2.8
100%
Under development
FCFE
14%
1,791.0
1,791.0
9.2
4,463.6
3,915.9
20.2
14%
301.6
301.5
1.6
100%
Operational
FCFE
70%
Under Construction
FCFE
14%
1,159.2
811.5
4.2
MP Check post
51%
Under development
BV
0.75x
1,174.2
880.6
4.5
49%
Operational
BV
0.8x
100%
BV
1.0x
48%
16.3
14.0
2,722.2
14.0
1,109.3
1,109.3
5.7
1.0x
179.1
179.1
BV
1.0x
930.2
930.2
1,123.4
3,831.6
19.7
19,525
19,525
100.5
26,663.4
26,663.4
117
-37,329
-37,329
-192
37,931.7
26,018.2
134
EV/EBITDA
6.1
3,169.6
BV
1,176.0
2,635.0
3x
Source:
Emkay Research
25
IL&FS Transportation
Company Update
Balance Sheet
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
Net Sales
56,056
66,449
64,185
77,908
1,943
1,943
1,943
1,943
38.5
18.5
-3.4
21.4
24,834
34,456
38,028
41,943
Net worth
26,777
36,398
39,970
43,885
2,935
2,716
3,444
3,778
Growth (%)
Expenditure
41,401
48,053
45,014
53,478
Employee Cost
3,694
3,819
4,074
4,775
Minority Interest
Other Exp
1,704
2,016
2,016
2,016
Secured Loans
Unsecured Loans
SG&A
FY15E
3,210
4,483
4,957
5,816
14,656
18,396
19,171
24,430
Growth (%)
26.9
25.5
4.2
27.4
26.1
27.7
29.9
31.4
Total Liabilities
Gross Block
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
EBIT margin (%)
766
944
1,336
1,826
13,890
17,452
17,835
22,604
24.8
26.3
27.8
29.0
Loan Funds
Less: Depreciation
Net block
Other Income
1,238
1,414
1,591
1,769
Interest expenses
7,282
11,190
12,672
17,204
PBT
7,846
7,676
6,754
7,169
Current Assets
Tax
2,457
2,274
2,001
2,124
Inventories
21,996
8,522
44,524
56,149
4,412
2,425
5,356
2,425
6,692
2,425
8,518
3,954
6,871
6,871
7,077
30,759
29,277
37,671
46,232
210
169
311
311
Sundry debtors
8,820
7,517
10,276
12,728
2,838
4,544
1,679
4,273
17,143
14,170
19,629
22,024
Investment
31.3
29.6
29.6
29.6
5,389
5,402
4,753
5,045
19.8
0.2
-12.0
6.1
9.6
8.1
7.4
6.5
1,748
2,877
5,777
6,896
419
208
385
334
17,602
19,911
19,574
23,209
4,970
5,194
4,368
4,711
Current liabilities
15,455
17,297
17,458
21,093
2,146
2,614
2,116
2,116
Reported PAT
4,970
5,194
4,368
4,711
13,157
9,367
18,098
23,024
PAT after MI
4,970
5,194
4,368
4,711
Misc. exp
14.8
4.5
-15.9
7.8
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
7,846
7,676
6,754
7,169
Profitability (%)
766
944
1,336
1,826
EBITDA Margin
7,282
11,190
12,672
17,204
E/O items
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
Provisions
Total Assets
Key Ratios
Y/E Mar
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
26.1
27.7
29.9
31.4
9.6
8.1
7.4
6.5
ROCE
14.0
11.8
10.2
11.7
Net Margin
3,212
5,497
-11,597
-2,332
ROE
20.2
16.4
11.4
11.2
Tax paid
-2,457
-2,274
-2,001
-2,124
RoIC
13.8
11.5
9.9
11.4
Operating Cashflow
16,648
23,033
7,164
21,744
Capital expenditure
-56,318
-47,495
-1,712
-21,634
25.6
26.7
22.5
24.2
-39,670
-24,462
5,453
109
CEPS
29.5
31.6
29.4
33.6
BVPS
137.8
187.4
205.7
225.9
4.0
3.4
3.4
0.0
PER
4.3
4.2
4.9
4.6
P/CEPS
3.8
3.5
3.8
3.3
P/BV
0.8
0.6
0.5
0.5
EV / Sales
2.2
2.4
2.6
2.4
Other income
Investments
Investing Cashflow
Equity Capital Raised
-2,010
-2,917
-206
-58,328
-50,412
-1,712
-21,840
EPS
DPS
Valuations (x)
47,590
41,332
4,806
20,692
Interest Paid
-7,282
-11,190
-12,672
-17,204
-903
-786
-796
-796
EV / EBITDA
8.3
8.8
8.8
7.7
3.6
3.1
3.1
0.0
3.8
-162
-271
343
Financing Cashflow
39,242
29,085
-8,318
2,691
-2,438
1,707
-2,866
2,594
3.7
3.8
3.7
5,275
2,838
4,544
1,679
Net Debt/EBIDTA
6.8
7.6
7.7
6.8
2,838
4,544
1,679
4,273
67.2
26.5
93.4
87.8
Emkay Research
26
Ashoka Buildcon
Scalable with assured growth
Rating
Previous Reco
Buy
Buy
CMP
Target Price
Rs47
Rs86
NA/NA
-5
Nifty
6,096
Sensex
20,529
Price Performance
(%)
1M
3M
6M 12M
Absolute
-3
-13
-24
-40
Rel. to Nifty
-6
-16
-32
-45
Source: Bloomberg
Rs
% 10
72
-2
64
-14
56
-26
48
-38
40
Oct-12
Dec-12
Feb-13
Apr-13
Jun-13
Aug-13
-50
Oct-13
Source: Bloomberg
Stock Details
Sector
Construction
ASBL IB
Bloomberg
790
Face Value(Rs)
158
83/ 41
52 Week H/L
Market Cap (Rs bn/USD mn)
7/ 122
11,528
0.0
67.5
67.5
67.4
FII/NRI
N/A
N/A
0.0
Institutions
18.4
18.4
18.3
Private Corp
6.4
6.4
6.5
Public
7.7
7.7
7.8
Source: Bloomberg
Nitin Arora
nitin.arora@emkayglobal.com
+91-22-66242491
Ajit Motwani
ajit.motwani@emkayglobal.com
+91-22-66121255
ABL enjoys a 1.5x (ex Cuttuck Angul, Chennai ORR, T&D orders of Rs11.5 bn ) visibility
on FY13 construction revenues with order backlog of Rs21.9bn however including
recently won road project Chennai ORR and two T&D orders , the order book provides
reasonable visibility of 2.7x on FY13E construction revenue. It also remains lower
bidder for road project Mudhol-Maharashtra border project (est project cost of Rs3.2 bn),
however have not received LOA for the project. On account of recently won projects
where major ramp in revenue to starts getting reflect in FY15E we expect construction
revenue CAGR of 6.4% over FY13-15E. We also believe that the that the exclusion of
Cuttuck Angul project (not included in the ACL portfolio) which had cost overruns of 67%, gives further scalability to bid for new projects to be given states like Andhra ,
Karnataka, & Maharashtra.
(Rsmn)
YE-
Net
EBITDA
EPS
EPS
RoE
Mar
Sales
(Core)
(%)
APAT
FY12A
15,000
3,250
21.7
1,248
7.9
FY13A
18,527
3,719
20.1
999
6.3
FY14E
18,406
4,001
21.7
1,046
6.6
FY15E
21,947
5,257
24.0
1,017
6.4
EV/
(Rs) % chg
(%)
P/E
EBITDA
P/BV
23.8
12.9
6.0
7.4
0.7
-19.9
9.6
7.4
8.2
0.7
4.7
9.5
7.1
10.5
0.6
-2.7
8.4
7.3
9.7
0.6
27
Company Update
Emkay
Ashoka Buildcon
Exhibit 36: EPC Revenue to propel higher
18.0
16.0
14.0
12.0
10.0
8.0
6.0
4.0
2.0
-
Company Update
Exhibit 37: Toll revenue CAGR 13.4% over FY13-15E
5.0
4.0
3.0
14.8
10.3
14.7
16.8
1.0
5.5
2.6
2.9
3.0
FY12
FY13
FY14E
3.7
4.0
FY12
FY13
FY14E
19.4
21.7
20.1
21.7
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
1.7
1.9
FY10
FY11
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
FY15E
25.0
6.0
20.0
5.0
4.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
4.3
2.0
11.4
13.0
15.0
18.5
18.4
3.0
21.9
5.3
2.0
1.0
8.0
2.1
2.5
FY10
FY11
3.3
0.0
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
FY15E
8.0
30.0
7.0
25.0
6.0
20.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
5.4
6.5
15.0
7.3
5.7
2.0
3.9
26.9
10.0
4.9
24.0
5.0
1.0
-
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14E
FY15E
FY10
FY15E
Rsmn
Source of funds
1,500
FY13 Cash
1,000
1,919
1,000
2549
Debt repayment
2,695
Total
6,195
Surplus/(Shortfall)
Rsmn
338
4,806
(1,389)
Emkay Research
28
Ashoka Buildcon
Company Update
IPO of ACL
Sale to others or swap into the individual asset SPVs. In case of a shortfall in realizing
the guaranteed returns even after swapping into the SPVs, SBI-M can increase its
stake in ACL to a maximum of 49% however; no provision to swap into the parent
company, ABL which we believe is a key positive for the shareholders of ABL.
We believe that investment is a value creating proposition considering the interest rates are
currently holding up for road project financing at 12-13% and availability of equity capital
ensures timely project completion and faster cash generation from the BOT assets. We
dont believe that 12% capital protection rate a concern considering the IRR of ACL
projects under ranges between 13-20%.
Exhibit 43: NPV of ACL portfolio
NPV
Dhankuni - Kharagpur
100%
3732
6241
Sambhalpur - Baragarh
100%
1216
2228
2562
2937
3360
3861
4438
Belgaum - Dharwad
100%
860
972
1484
2008
2563
3145
3981
Pimpalgaon - Nasik
26%
1008
1242
1408
1612
1789
2090
2340
Jaora - Naigaon
38%
2615
3001
3385
3877
4392
4908
5402
Durg - Chhattisgarh
51%
99
362
580
738
922
1183
1468
Chhattisgarh - Bhandara
51%
56
65
81
100
129
192
260
Total
Emkay Research
29
Ashoka Buildcon
Company Update
FY15E
Earlier
Revised
change
Earlier
Revised
change
Sales
19,875.0
21,947
10%
EBIDTA
5,008.0
5,257
5%
EBIDTA (%)
25.2%
24.0%
-5%
APAT
689.0
771
12%
EPS
4.4
4.9
12%
Cost of Equity
Eq value
Stake
ABL value
14.8%
15%
15%
15%
3,417.2
1,215.7
859.8
3,875.5
9,368.20
4,103.1
372.1
110.4
13,953.8
1,533.6
594.1
328.0
841.4
432.8
88.1
97.5
-
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
26.0%
0.0%
37.5%
51.0%
51.0%
3,417.2
1,215.7
859.8
1,007.6
6,500.3
1,538.7
189.8
56.3
5,468.2
1,533.6
297.0
328.0
841.4
432.3
88.1
97.5
-
21.6
7.7
5.4
6.4
41.2
9.7
1.2
0.4
38.8
9.7
1.9
2.1
5.3
2.7
0.6
0.6
-
17.4
3,635.3
0.1
23.0
17,886.7
9,103.5
58
17,887
3,861
344
9,447.5
3,861
2
60
24
21,747.9
13,308.0
86
15%
14%
15%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
14%
17.4
3,932.8
100.0%
50.0%
100.0%
100.0%
99.9%
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
5.0%
100.0%
Source:
Emkay Research
30
Ashoka Buildcon
Company Update
Balance Sheet
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
Net Sales
15,000
18,527
18,406
21,947
701
675
675
675
15.2
23.5
-0.7
19.2
9,640
9,832
10,877
11,894
11,750
14,808
14,405
16,690
10,341
10,507
11,553
12,570
431
502
594
723
630
2,787
2,681
2,483
17,069
23,469
34,684
43,700
Growth (%)
Expenditure
Employee Cost
Other Exp
SG&A
Net worth
Minority Interest
Secured Loans
FY15E
310
482
678
1,031
Unsecured Loans
3,250
3,719
4,001
5,257
Loan Funds
Growth (%)
28.9
14.4
7.6
31.4
10
21.7
20.1
21.7
24.0
Total Liabilities
28,050
36,763
48,918
58,753
20,761
20,275
20,275
56,883
4,503
5,275
6,626
8,216
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
EBIT margin (%)
Other Income
17,069
23,469
34,684
43,700
850
1,324
1,351
1,590
Gross Block
2,401
2,395
2,651
3,667
Less: Depreciation
16.0
12.9
14.4
16.7
Net block
16,258
15,000
13,649
48,667
26,780
96,100 106,756
80,636
354
294
269
323
Interest expenses
1,144
1,395
1,428
2,558
Investment
2,052
2,824
3,584
4,401
PBT
1,610
1,295
1,492
1,433
Current Assets
7,362
9,672
8,843
10,103
Tax
451
685
591
662
Inventories
2,770
5,399
4,629
4,984
1,467
862
1,089
1,425
500
518
251
266
2,624
2,893
2,875
3,428
28.0
52.9
39.6
46.2
Sundry debtors
1,159
610
901
771
12.4
-47.4
47.7
-14.4
7.7
3.3
4.9
3.5
89
389
145
246
25,689
87,624
84,706
85,846
1,248
999
1,046
1,017
Current liabilities
25,689
87,624
84,706
85,846
157
Reported PAT
1,248
1,156
1,046
1,017
-18,327
-77,953
-75,863
-75,744
PAT after MI
1,248
999
1,046
1,017
Misc. exp
23.8
-19.9
4.7
-2.7
26,763
35,971
48,125
57,960
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
FY12A
FY13A
FY14E
FY15E
1,610
1,451
1,492
1,433
Profitability (%)
850
1,324
1,351
1,590
EBITDA Margin
21.7
20.1
21.7
24.0
1,144
1,395
1,428
2,558
Net Margin
7.7
3.3
4.9
3.5
46
-85
ROCE
10.8
8.3
6.8
7.4
21,595
61,230
-2,356
-104
ROE
12.9
9.6
9.5
8.4
-456
-702
-591
-662
RoIC
41.8
-7.3
-4.2
-8.2
7.9
6.3
6.6
6.4
E/O items
Growth (%)
Cash Flow
Provisions
Total Assets
Key Ratios
Y/E Mar
24,874
64,999
1,323
4,815
-27,632
-69,694
-10,656
-10,488
-2,758
-4,695
-9,333
-5,674
CEPS
13.3
14.7
15.2
16.5
-274
BVPS
65.5
66.5
73.2
79.6
-586
-772
-760
-817
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
-28,218
-70,740
-11,416
-11,305
PER
6.0
7.4
7.1
7.3
P/CEPS
3.5
3.2
3.1
2.9
P/BV
0.7
0.7
0.6
0.6
EPS
DPS
Valuations (x)
148
11,798
4,238
-4,395
11,215
9,016
-1,144
-1,395
-1,428
-2,558
EV / Sales
1.6
1.6
2.3
2.3
EV / EBITDA
7.4
8.2
10.5
9.7
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Others
Financing Cashflow
Net chg in cash
39
47
3,242
6,008
9,826
6,506
-102
267
-267
15
1.6
2.2
3.0
3.5
602
500
518
251
Net Debt/EBIDTA
5.1
6.2
8.6
8.3
500
767
251
266
Emkay Research
31
Construction
Sector Update
Emkay Research
www.emkayglobal.com
32