Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
POSITION PAPER
Plaintiff by the undersigned counsel and unto this Honorable
Court, most respectfully submits this position paper and avers the
following to wit:
PREFATORY STATEMENT
The Plaintiff in this case are the heirs of
Condonuevo.
The Defendant is Golden Knight Security Agency.
Solomon
STATEMENT OF FACTS
The plaintiffs are the heirs of Condonuevo who was killed in a
hostage incident in First Optima Realty Corp. building on F. Roman
Street. Condonuevo was a lawyer who held on the first floor of the
said building. Charlemaene Aton was the security guard on duty
employed by the Golden Knight Security Agency. Condonuevo was
taken as hostage and later killed by Aton.
The lawyer was about to leave the building when he could
not find his car keys. He vented his frustration to Aton which
turned into a heated argument. The fight between the two men
turned into a hostage situation, with Aton drawing his service
firearm, detaining Condonuevo and holding him at gunpoint inside
his small law office. The hostage situation lasted for more than 10
hours. Towards the end of the hostage incident, the guard shot
the lawyer in the head with a .38-cal. revolver before shooting
himself also in the head.
ISSUES
1) Whether or not Aton was negligent
POSITION PAPER
Plaintiff by the undersigned counsel and unto this Honorable
Court, most respectfully submits this position paper and avers the
following to wit:
PREFATORY STATEMENT
The Plaintiff in this case are the heirs of
Condonuevo.
The Defendant is Golden Knight Security Agency.
Solomon
STATEMENT OF FACTS
The plaintiffs are the heirs of Condonuevo who was killed in a
hostage incident in First Optima Realty Corp. building on F. Roman
Street. Condonuevo was a lawyer who held on the first floor of the
said building. Charlemaene Aton was the security guard on duty
employed by the Golden Knight Security Agency. Condonuevo was
taken as hostage and later killed by Aton.
The lawyer was about to leave the building when he could
not find his car keys. He vented his frustration to Aton which
turned into a heated argument. The fight between the two men
turned into a hostage situation, with Aton drawing his service
firearm, detaining Condonuevo and holding him at gunpoint inside
his small law office. The hostage situation lasted for more than 10
hours. Towards the end of the hostage incident, the guard shot
the lawyer in the head with a .38-cal. revolver before shooting
himself also in the head.
ISSUES
1) Whether or not Condonuevo acts contributed to his death