Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
v.
Paycana
GR
No
179035|
551
SCRA
657
|
16
April
2008
|
Tinga,
J.
Princess
Trisha
Joy
Z.
Uy
|
Law
110-Criminal
Law
II
|
Grp3
Paycana
stabbed
his
pregnant
wife
several
times
and
ended
up
killing
his
wife
and
the
unborn
child.
The
elements
of
unintentional
abortion
is
in
the
ratio.
Facts:
! Paycana
Jr.
was
charged
with
parricide
with
unintentional
abortion
to
which
he
pleaded
not
guilty
! He
claims
it
was
self-defense,
that
the
wife
attacked
him
first
and
so
he
had
to
retaliate
and
he
ended
up
killing
his
pregnant
wife.
Witness
version:
! Paycana
came
home
early
in
the
morning
carrying
with
him
his
tools
of
trade
as
a
butcher
(knife,
bolo,
sharpener)
! He
stabbed
his
wife
14
times.
! Due
to
the
shouting,
Tito
(wifes
father)
went
to
the
place
to
see
his
daughter
lying
near
the
door.
! Seeing
that
the
accused
was
armed,
he
stepped
back.
! Angelina
(Paycanas
daughter)
says
that
Paycana
held
her
mothers
neck
and
stabbed
her.
Paycana
version:
! He
got
the
knife
from
the
wife
who
stabbed
her
first
! They
had
a
fight
the
night
before
! He
wanted
to
separate
and
while
on
his
way
out
the
wife
stabbed
him
and
so
he
got
the
knife
from
the
wife
and
stabbed
her.
! He
claims
he
was
not
aware
of
the
number
of
times
because
he
was
dizzy
from
blood
loss
Issue/Ratio:
WON
the
acts
were
done
in
self-defense.
No
RTC
is
better
suited
to
ascertain
if
it
was
indeed
self-defense
based
on
the
facts.
The
lower
court
has
appreciated
all
the
facts
and
circumstances,
and
have
seen
and
heard
the
witnesses.
SC
has
no
reason
to
disturb
its
findings.
unlawful
aggression
-
belied
by
the
witnesses
and
medical
findings
that
injuries
to
Paycana
were
self-inflicted
and
superficial.
reasonable
means
-
14
times!
This
shows
effort
to
kill.
Elements
of
unintentional
abortion
(1)
pregnant
woman
(2)
violence
upon
same
pregnant
woman
w/o
intending
abortion
(3)
violence
is
intentionally
exerted
(4)
fetus
dies
as
a
result
of
the
violence
This
is
a
complex
crime
because
one
act
resulted
to
two
felonies.
The
unborn
fetus
was
also
killed
when
the
accused
stabbed
his
wife
several
times.