7B English Education 10 December, 2013 Exploring Drama
Commentary Writing: The Comparison between Antigone and Macbeth
This analysis will compare two Greek tragedies; Antigone and Macbeth. It covers the summary, the main theme, the settings and the main characters. The purpose of commenting the plays is to understand deeply and to find out the similarities and the differences between Antigone and Macbeth. Antigone is about a young woman who is brave to break the rules made by King Creon. She demands justice over her brother improper burial but in the end she dies. Macbeth is about a man who is ambitious to be a king. He kills King Duncan because of the prophecy he heard from the three witches and his wife, Lady Macbeth. In the end, however, he dies because of his greediness. Antigone and Macbeth are categorized as tragic drama because both of those dramas end with death. Both of them bring powerful meaning for the readers that every act has their consequences. And those consequences should be faced by the characters as a result of their action. So the theme of both dramas is that people have to learn the hard way from their mistakes. The theme is expressed in the end of the plays. In Antigone by Sophocles, King Creon and Antigone have to get their punishments from their actions. Creon has to lose his family (Haimon and Eurydice) because of his bad decisions over the rules in Thebes. There is no happiness because there is no wisdom in his decision. Antigone also faces the consequence because of burying her brothers body and finally she commits suicide. Her death is followed by Haimon and Eurydice death. The sad ending is the consequence of Creons decision of his rules. In Macbeth by Shakespeare, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth get their punishments because of their ambitions. Lady Macbeth uses her gender to explode her ambitions through Macbeth. She uses Macbeth to get what she wants by questioning him about his manhood. Lady Macbeth and three witches make Macbeth becomes powerful person to be a king by killing Duncan. But, ambitions have consequences. It can be seen in the end, they die. They do not have opportunity to enjoy what they have achieved because of their bad ways to get it. If we analyze deeply to the issue of both drama, we can summarize that all of them are related to the power. The issue of power comes up because of their decision to use power without wisdom or in bad ways. In Antigone, the power is had by Creon and it involves political issue. Creon explains how he will be a tough ruler because of his loyalty to Thebes. He always believes that state is supreme in here because he says It is the city that protects us all. He proves his tough by denying Polyneicess burial because he is a traitor for Thebes. Antigone as a sister of Polyneices breaks this rule because her belief that the God law is the highest law in the world, so she has to bury her brothers body. She knows the result of 1
Annisa Dwi Puspita (1000531)
7B English Education Aulia Arifaturrochmah (1002709) 10 December, 2013 Dewi Indah Setyowati (1006366) Exploring Drama breaking his rule, she will cost her life. But at the end, she has no power in here because she faces a man who has power as a king. Creon uses his power as a king without wisdom, and it results with unhappiness and loneliness. It is stated in the last play There is no happiness where there is no wisdom; No wisdom but in submission to the gods. Big words are always punished, and proud men in old age learn to be wise. It symbolizes that power without wisdom is mistake that will result no happiness. In Macbeth, the issue of power is also dominant because the three characters: Macbeth, Lady Macbeth, and three witches. Lady Macbeth and the witches hold this power. They use this power to manipulate Macbeth. They manipulate Macbeth in different ways. Lady Macbeth uses her gender to influence Macbeth by asking Macbeths manhood to get what she wants. She influences him to kill Duncan, so he can be a king. The witches also hold power to manipulate him by telling about the future and his fate. Through the power from them, Macbeth tries to be the man who holds more power as a king. But his ambition as a king has consequences because his attitude to get the position in bad ways. His ambitions cause his death and Lady Macbeth commits with suicide. It means that they who achieve their goal in bad ways will have no opportunity to enjoy it.