Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
indeed the key to bridging income gaps and that if more individuals could
attain a higher level of education, problems such as income inequity
would cease to exist.
EDUCATION:
Purpose
Skilled
workforce
Equip students with necessary skills for them to compete in the global
marketplace/ prepare youths for workforce (technical skills/practical
knowledge)
Laos Revolutionary Youth Unions vocation program that targets rural
youth and teaches them skills such as baking, hairdressing that can be
applied to various industries.
Barefoot College in Tilonia: Social work & research centre in India has
trained 2 generations of uneducated villagers to become health workers,
mechanics and more.
Sweden has one of the highest spending on Research Development in
higher education sector at 0.9% of GDP More access to education
In UK, the Higher Education Innovation Fund (HELF) is vital in
encouraging the higher education sector to increase their capability to
respond to needs of business and the wider community. The long term
aim of this funding is to improve Northern Irelands innovation
performance as a key element in raising productivity and delivering
economic growth / vital in building capacity in English universities for
knowledge transfer, knowledge exchange and commercialization
activities that will ultimately benefit Englands economic and social
standing.
Character
Building
Cultural
Literacy
Functions
Social Mobility
Political
development of
country
and organizations.
Characteristics of education systems (flaws)
Elitism
Qualifications
SUPPORTING:
Britain In managing their number
one risk, 72% of employers believe
skills and experience were critical,
whereas only 36% believed formal
qualifications were a critical control
measure.
Over 95% of the wealthy in the world
admitted to having abandoned their
education in order to make it in the
real world of business.
Stress
OPPOSING:
Britain Employers
differentiated importance of
qualifications for different
categories, and 89% of
respondents classified formal
qualifications as essential for
technicians, professionals &
managerial staff.
SUPPORTING
Singapore - Top 5% of PSLE
students consistently come from 95%
of primary schools, not just from a
few prestigious schools
Financial assistance schemes such
as Edusave Merit Bursary and
Opportunity Funds are critical in
ensuring students are not denied
opportunities in progress due to
financial circumstances.
-
OPPOSING
America:
A study was shown that
the gap in standardized test
scores between affluent and
low income students have
grown by about 40%.
The imbalance between
the rich and the poor children
in college completion has
grown about 50%.
Wealthy elites pay
exorbitantly high prices and
rely on informal personal
connections to send their
children to Ivy League
institutes
UK Poorest children do
much worst at school on
average as compared to
better off classmates. 27% of
poor children get 5 or more
good GCSE passes as
compared to 55% from better
off families.
Females in
education
system
EMPOWERMENT OF WOMEN
Mothers are primary socialization
agents: an educated mother is more
likely to instill a thirst for education in
her children, setting up a positive
cycle of education for generations to
come
Rajasthan, India With a low female
literacy rate, Rajasthan is burdened
with widespread practices like child
marriage, female feticide, rape, and
sati (rite where women burn
themselves at their husbands
funeral)
On the other hand, Kelaya, India with
high female literacy rate is devoid of
such rampant social norms.
GENDER DISCRIMINATION
In South Asia, women only
have half as many schooling
years as men
Of 130 million uneducated
African children, 60% are girls
In Afghanistan, certain cultural
norms only allow female
students to be taught by
female teachers. Due to the
lack of qualifies female
teachers, many girls in
Afghanistan remain
uneducated.
In Iran, about 77 university
courses are exclusive to men
only. The government also has
Exams
Budget on
education
Overemphasis on
education
A typical East Asian high school student often must follow a 5 a.m.
to midnight compressed schedule, filled with class instruction
followed by private institute courses, for up to six days a week.
Asian parents, nearly without exception, demand that their children
attend an elite university. Parents are typically involved in the
smallest minutiae of their childrens education. The goal of this
parental fervor is not simply to guarantee their child a good job and
economic security, but also to gain them entrance into an elite
educated class with better marriage prospects and prestige. An
invisible caste system still prevails.
In Korea, as in many East Asian countries, the greatest determinant
of elite university acceptance falls on one test on one day the
national university entrance exam. On this day, the country
effectively comes to a grinding halt. Subways are mandated to run
more frequently, aircraft are restricted from flying over test centers,
workers are told to begin their day later and late exam takers can
call a special number for a police escort to take the student directly
to the testing site.
10% of married couples now live apart. Families who separate for
the sake of education have become so commonplace, to the extent
that the phenomenon has bequeaths those families with a title of
their own goose families, because they must migrate to reunite.
Making
changes to
society
What is Elitism?
The interpretation of Elitism can be as follows: feeling that oneself is superior than others
in terms of academic, physical
capability etc than other people. People who are elitist often have a narrow and warped
mindset that they themselves are better than others just because they may be superior
in one aspect of life. This is apparent in Singapore, especially in the academics, which
can be seen in the evidences substantiated.
1. Newspaper article by Sandra Leong, an ex-Raffles student
In this newspaper article, it exemplifies how Raffles Junior College students, who never
get a chance to mix with others may
start to develop cynical views on those who may not be well-off in studies or have a
good job. This article highlights that those
from elite schools may start to develop an 'exclusionary attitude' and may feel that those
who attain less than what is viewed to be
good may be ostracized.
2. Wee Shu Min incident
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Wee Shu Min elitism controversy occurred in October 2006. Wee Shu Min,
daughter of parliament member Wee Siew Kim and a then-eighteen year-old student on
Raffles Junior College's scholarship programme, found herself in controversy after
posting on her blog what were viewed by some Singaporeans to be elitist, nave, and
insensitive statements against heartlanders.
Dismissing the views of Derek Wee who voiced concerns on job security and age
discrimination on his blog, she shot back with a take-no-prisoners diatribe, calling Derek
a "stupid crackpot", belonging to "the sadder class" and overreliant on the government.
Her post also called for Derek to "get out of my elite uncaring face". Her response
triggered an avalanche of criticism, as it came on the heels of the sensational suicide of
an individual (said to be facing financial difficulties) at Chinese Garden MRT Station. As
a result, her name topped Technorati's search terms for a week. She has since
appeared to have apologised on another blog and shut down her own.
Response
In response to the scandal, Wee Siew Kim stated that he supported Shu Min's point in
principle and that "people cannot take the brutal truth," but he and Shu Min's college
principal also expressed disappointment and counselled her to be more sensitive
towards others. Wee also claimed that his daughter's privacy had been violated. Critics
pointed out however, that he appeared to have endorsed her elitist remarks and failed to
address values such as empathy and humility, and that he was apologising for the tone,
but not the content of his daughter's response. Furthermore, the government had
previously made it clear that there was no such thing as Internet privacy with the
imprisonment of bloggers under the Sedition Act just over than a year earlier, and that
Wee Shu Min should be old enough to take responsibility for the consequences of her
statements.
Scholarly paper
Examining Meritocracy and Elitism in Singapore
INTRODUCTION
Singapore has always taken pride in being a meritocracy and its embrace of meritocracy
has been the cornerstone of the nations success story. Over the years, Singapores
meritocracy has emphasised on equality of opportunity over equality of outcomes;
shaping a relatively level playing field where the most capable and hardworking
individuals regardless of ethnicity or social classes have an equal opportunity to rise to
the top. While the State has always heralded the success of meritocracy, the systemic
flaws and failures that were once side-lined in the public eye are becoming increasingly
prevalent and visible today.
The central research question is how meritocracy shapes the Singapore elite and in turn
how the elite shapes meritocracy in the country. In this paper, the elite is defined as the
class of English-educated Singaporeans who subsequently rises to the top as the
political and bureaucratic elite, unless otherwise specified.
II.
MERITOCRACY AND ITS DANGERS
Those individuals who possess merit are identified at an early age, selected for an
intensive education and prepared for their future roles. Beyond differentiating social
roles, a meritocracy also entails a system of rewarding merit and positive results with
incentives and rewards. However, the greatest virtue of meritocracy is its idea of equality
of opportunity. According to John E Roemer, there are two prevailing conceptions of
equality of opportunity today. The first argues for society to level the playing field so
that the disadvantaged could compete on fair grounds with the rest. The second is the
non-discrimination principle where all individuals who have the required attributes
relevant for a job should be judged on an equal footing along with the rest with respect to
the relevant attributes.
III.
THE SINGAPORE ELITE
Adhering to Hayes Principle of Difference, Lees firm belief in eugenics meant he saw
the elite as the product of genetic ordering and unequal distribution of talents within
society.
As Singaporeans move up the education system into secondary schools and junior
colleges, the scholars are continuously sorted from the commoners and the would-be
future elite are herded together into a small number of elite institutions. The best are
offered the coveted Public Service Commission Scholarships, Singapore Armed Forces
Scholarships and those at the top of the pyramid of public service would then be
absorbed into the elite Administrative Service and made mandarins.
IV.
SOCIAL IMMOBILITY WHITHER THY SINGAPORE DREAM?
Rags-to-success stories are becoming increasingly rare. When based solely on income
from work per household member and after accounting for government transfers,
Singapores GINI coefficient has progressively risen from 0.425 in 2000 to 0.446 in 2010.
Feeling the impact of these figures on the ground, 70 percent of 400 respondents in a
Straits Times survey stated they were concerned about the income gap between the rich
and the poor and an even larger 83 percent agreed that the income gap affects social
mobility. In todays society stratified by meritocracy, globalization and economic forces,
the Singapore Dream has become an increasingly elusive concept that is often beyond
reach of Singaporeans from the lower strata of society.
V.
FAMILY PEDIGREE AND EDUCATION PERFORMANCE
The ability to achieve success in todays world is no longer dependent on an individuals
sole merit but is increasingly path-dependent on an individuals family background which
has a high correlation with his educational attainment. Then Minister Mentor Lee Kuan
Yew once shared some glaring statistics where more than half of students studying in
top schools like Raffles Institution, Anglo-Chinese School (Independent) and Nanyang
Girls High had fathers who were degree holders a stark contrast as compared to
13.1% at Chai Chee Secondary (which had the highest percentage amongst four
schools where data was obtained). Lee attributed this phenomenon to the more
favourable learning environment at home shaped by better-educated parents,
highlighting the increasing deficiency of the system in ensuring and realising
meritocracy.
Apart from Lees eugenics argument, naturally students with better-educated parents
were also bound to come from families with better socio-economic backgrounds. Bettereducated parents would have a higher earning capacity that accompanies their jobs and
qualifications. The higher earning capacity also translates into higher amounts of
disposable income that could be channeled into their childrens education and
development enrolling in tuition, paying for premium co-curricular activities (CCA) and
enrichment courses. According to a 2012 survey published by Blackbox Research, 67
percent of Singaporeans have had children enrolled in tuition at some point in time while
only 20 percent in the lowest monthly household income bracket of $4,000 and below
have had their children enrolled in tuition.The disparity is a clear reflection of the lesser
accessibility to tuition for households without financial means. For respondents with
children enrolled in tuition, an alarming 51 percent spend more than $500 a month per
child.
Based on Professor Changhui Kangs research findings, a 10 percent increase in private
tuition expenditure would translate to an improved test result of 0.56 percentile.[31] [32]
In a nutshell, the inequality of resources and access to resources has meant that a
disproportionate number of people have unequal ability to benefit from the supposed
equal opportunities associated with a meritocracy, thereby leading to the unequal
outcomes.
VII.
The worrying social phenomenon of education reinforcing the social divide instead of
functioning as a social leveller did not go unnoticed by the Prime Minister when he
acknowledged the growing stratification of Singapore society in Parliament during the
debate on the Presidents Address in 2011. He recognised that the children of
successful people are doing better, the children of less successful people are doing less
well. When Lee Kuan Yew openly acknowledged that an individuals pedigree and
network were now the keys to success in Singapore, he also indirectly admitted the
systemic flaws of meritocracy and that the egalitarian society he had sought to build had
reached a tipping point. The entrenchment of the elite, growing social immobility and
increasing distance of the less well-to-do from achieving the Singapore Dream was not a
perception but a true reality when the Prime Minister openly admitted that fewer children
from lower-income families are rising to the top of the heap.
X.
CONCLUSION
The very success of the meritocratic system has led it to abandon its original egalitarian
ideals. The Iron Law of Meritocracy has set in Singapore where the growing social
inequality and the entrenched elite have successfully subverted the mechanisms of
mobility. Instead of traditionally moving up the ladder by merit, family pedigree and elite
socialisation are now the game changers that concentrated influence and consolidate
the elites power for perpetuity. Against the backdrop of widening social divide, if this
tension between the elite and non-elite, rich and poor, English-educated and Chineseeducated becomes mismanaged, we edge closer towards Youngs apoloclapytic vision
and the Occupy Wall Street movement could well be a harbinger of the social unrest
that is going to befall Singapore.
EDUCATION
HOOKS
1. The function of education is to think intensively and to think critically.
The most dangerous criminal may be the man gifted with reason but no
morals. We must remember that intelligence is not enough, intelligence
plus character - that is the goal of true education. Martin Luther King
Jr, speech at Morehouse College, 1948
2. In todays world, education has taken on greater significance,
particularly as our global economy continues in its metamorphosis into
a knowledge-based one.
3. More often than not, education has also been lauded by world leaders
as the single most important solution to the multitudes of problems we
face as a global community.
4. Education is the vehicle of knowledge, self-preservation and success.
Education not only gives a platform to succeed, but also the knowledge
of social conduct, strength, character and self respect.
5. No matter what global problem you are dreading, whether it's the
elimination of poverty, whether it's the creation of peace, whether its
solving environmental energy problems, the solution whatever it is
multiple solutions, the solution always include education, never is it
without an education component and sometimes cannot be done
without education. Nicholas Negroponte, well-known professor and
visionary scholar.
OPPOSING VIEWS
Main purpose of education is to be rich in the future. DISAGREE.
There are two views to this statement. The first view considers the purpose of
education to equip students with the necessary academic qualifications and
skills which would aid students in earning more money. In this fast paced
society, many working people undergo tremendous amount of stress to
pursue higher standards of living. Many think that having a good education
would guarantee a high paying job and wealth. Pragmatic people will
certainly see becoming rich as one reason why they need to study hard. With
rising cost of living, people see the need to earn more money in order to
make ends meet. Some would like to reward themselves for studying so hard
and thus tangible rewards can only be bought with money. Many people see
education as a means to enable them to get their hands on such luxury
goods/ live comfortably.
Eg: Across Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
countries, men with university level degrees are 18% more likely to find jobs
than those with only a secondary school diploma. Lifetime earnings also
increase with each level of education attained. People who are more
pragmatic, they invest heavily in education hoping that they will be able to
secure high paying jobs see the sciences and maths subjects as a mean to
get into prestigious courses etc
Evaluation (oppose opposing view): Education plays a key role in
providing individuals with the knowledge, skills and competences needed to
participate effectively in the workforce training students for high-demand
jobs. Workforce of today require higher skill level not just technical skills
but strong communication and problem-solving problems which are acquired
through education. Specialized knowledge gained through education in a
better position to take up intellect jobs more opportunities for high-paying
jobs which requires individuals to have the requisite skill. The problem with
this view is the it creates a false dichotomy, that being rich should be the sole
and most important purpose of education without acknowledging that there
are greater purposes in education. Being rich shouldn't be the purpose of
education, although I acknowledge that education does help students to earn
more money. However, in the long run, the need to instill the right moral
values is more important than earning more money proper means to earn
the money high flyers may misuse the money earned. The ability to earn
more money isn't what the society needs, the society requires intellects that
have the correct sets of values create a better world make the right
positive choice and even contribute back to society. One may succeed in life
but if one has a flaw in his character, it might lead to your downfall. It might
be the more pragmatic purpose of education but wealth does not guarantee
you success or happiness in life.
PURPOSE OF EDUCATION
1.
Point 1: Education allows one to climb the social ladder
Elaboration: In an open system, a society with mobility between different
social classes, individuals can move up or down in the social rankings.
Eg: Wages and earnings tend to correlate with the amount of education a
person obtained. With a university degree, one is more likely to attain a
professional-level job in which one may earn a higher salary in comparison
to someone working in a secondary, service-based job. Workers in servicebased or labor intensive areas are deemed unskilled because a great
amount of education is not required in order to perform these jobs. Since
white collar jobs seem to necessitate more human capital and knowledge,
lessons, students are explicitly taught the values of respect and care in
their daily interactions with others. They are also taught to appreciate the
diverse strengths and abilities of the members of their community.
Students are guided to take multiple perspectives and learn to respond to
the needs of people around them.
Eg: Another example is Values in Action (VIA) and Co-Curricular Activities
(CCA). They further provide students with opportunities to engage and
interact with people of different backgrounds and abilities. Through VIA,
students are encouraged to initiate collective action among their peers to
improve the lives of others in school and the community. They learn to
appreciate diversity in the community and respect for each others
strengths and abilities.
Evaluation: Education is therefore important in the shaping of a students
character. Through the activities that students go through in school, they
are able to learn values that they have to acquire to be able to succeed in
life.
6. Education can solve major problems and affect a change in
society
Major problems in the world today include social inequality, hunger and
poverty, poor governance, and global warming. Education can provide
people with the knowledge and skills to solve these problems and
therefore affect a change in society.
Eg: An example is the Litre of Light Project, which benefited thousands of
impoverished families in the Philippines. This project was started by
student Illac Diaz, who gained knowledge in school that equipped him with
the skills to come up with this project. The project involves an old plastic
bottle filled with water, that could provide many poor families in
Philippines with light, uplifting their quality of life as many of them do not
have money for electricity, and used dangerous kerosene lamps indoors.
These makeshift solar lamps basically act as skylights, and reflect and
amplify the rays of the sun during daylight hours effectively performing
the work of indoor light bulbs but without using any electricity at all.
Eg: Vocational education in Vietnam and India --> gets poor families out
of the vicious poverty cycle. Rural youths are not confined to working in
the fields.
Eg: Lao Revolutionary Youth Unions vocation programme targets rural
youths Practical skills (IT, beauty Care) graduate with a certificate
ability to have the skills required for a job take charge of own future
Eg: Social Work and research Centre (India) unemployment rural youths
Instill and maintain solar electricity systems, hand pumps and tanks for
drinking tanks Upgrade local skills acquired through generations use
traditional knowledge as a tool to teach the goals that the conventional
government policies often have unable to achieve use local wisdom
before involve expertise from outside
Eg: Basic Education for Hard to Reach Urban Working Children Project
(Bangladesh) provide vulnerable child labourers in Bangladesh with a
basic primary school education while they continue to work Goal: