Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
According to David Harris there are five general components in writing, they are:
a. Grammar
: The employment of grammatical pattern.
b. Content
: The substance or writing ideas express the unity
c. Organization : The organization of contents or the ideas, it is coherence or
not,
it is unified or not
d. Vocabulary : The selection word that is suitable with the content.
e. Mechanic
: The use of graphic conventions of the language.
The criteria of each writing score are: Content (0-20), Organization (0- 20), Grammar
(0-20), Vocabulary (0-20), and Mechanic (0-20). So, the total score for writing
descriptive paragraph are 100.
Components
of Score
Level
Indicator
Writing
Content
Grammar
16-20
11-15
Good
6-10
Fair
0-5
16-20
11-15
good
6-10
Fair
0-5
Poor
16-20
of tenses.
Excellent Writing summary really organized,
neat,
clear,
all
of
ideas
are
Good
logic.
Writing summary is organized, clear,
some of ideas are summarized, and the
Organization
6-10
Fair
sequence is logic.
Writing summary is less organized,
one of ideas is summarized, and the
Vocabulary
Mechanic
0-5
Poor
16-20
11-15
Good
6-10
Fair
Indonesian.
A quarter of vocabularies are written in
0-5
Poor
Indonesian.
A half of vocabularies are written in
16-20
11-15
Good
6-10
Fair
0-5
Poor
In conclusion, there are some criteria to measure the students' summary writing and it
has each writing score and level of score for each criteria, such as: for (0-5) it means
that poor score, (6-10) it means that the score is fair, (11-15) it means that the score is
good and for (16-20) it means that the score is excellent. And from all the score of
each criteria it can be the total score of students' writing summary.