Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Introduction
Demand
2009
Gasoline
Diesel
28
25
86
MMB/D
11
Incremental Demand
2010 2020
12
Fuel Oil
Jet
8
7
Naphtha
LPG
Others
42
17
MMB/D
5
9
7
10
17
Base
HDXtra
Gasoline
56.9
51.5
LCO
20.7
30.9
CSO
5.7
5.1
16.8
20.8
+ 10.2%
+ 4%
Table 1: FCC unit yield data of first commercial trial of HDXtra at Frontier, El Dorado, KS
Competitive Matrix A
Competitive Matrix B
90%
80%
70%
60%
0
12
16
20
24
28
Prox-SMZ
Competitive Matrix B
The test results clearly showed the advantage of the ProxSMZ catalyst, featuring a significantly better light cycle oil/
heavy cycle oil (LCO/HCO) or bottoms upgrading ratio at
constant coke versus the competitive matrix materials.
Competitive Matrix A
Commercial Matrix Additive
3.5
3.0
2.5
LCO/HCO
Prox-SMZ
100%
Surface Area Retention, %
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
Coke, wt%
Matrix
Zeolite
Coke yield
Coke yield
LCO/HCO
Conversion, wt%
High Z/M
metals passivation
Conversion, wt%
Low Z/M
no metals passivation
Target
94
11
90
86
82
78
74
70
Flex-Tec
Stamina
0.20
0.05
Base
+ 43
2.7
1.1
Steamed Z/M
3
55
60
65
70
75
Conversion, %
Flex-Tec LCO Selectivity
Flex-Tec Coke
18
+ 6% abs.
MSA retention, %
Base
+ 19% abs.
16
Bottoms yield, wt%
Base
43
14
42
12
10
41
ZSA retention, %
Coke, wt%
LCO/(LCO+Bottoms)*100
40
6
4
39
55
60
65
70
75
Conversion, %
Flex-Tec Bottoms
Flex-Tec Naphtha
Stamina Bottoms
Stamina Naphtha
1.3
15
1.2
MCB, wt%
13
1.0
11
0.9
9
0.7
17
0.6
5
3
-120-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0
0.4
20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Time, day
MCB, wt%
76
30.0
72
25.0
68
20.0
64
15.0
60
-120-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0
10.0
20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Time, day
Conversion
LCO
30
Conversion, %
35.0
80
25
20
15
10
5
Figure 9: Unit operating data during the trial period, LCO yield
and conversion
0
-120 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20
20
40
60
Time, day
Figure 11: Unit operating data during the trial period, reduced MCB
API gravity Ecat lab testing confirms the benefits seen in the unit
operation with Stamina
90
85
80
45
75
40
70
65
35
60
30
LCO/(LCO+MCB)*100, %
Naphtha yield, %
50
55
25
-120-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0
20
40 60
50
80 100 120 140 160
Time, day
Naphtha
LCO selectivity
Figure 10: Unit operating data during the trial period, naphtha yield
and LCO selectivity
Flex-Tec
2.5
Stamina Trial
2.0
80
1.5
60
1.0
40
80
.5
20
-50
50
100
150
0
200
Time, day
MSA
ZSA
ZSA/MSA
Figure 12: Ecat data before and during the Stamina trial: ZSA, MSA
and ZSA/MSA ratio
Flex-Tec
74
3000
68
2000
62
1000
56
-100
-50
Stamina Trial
4500
1.3
4000
1.2
3500
1.1
3000
2500
-100
-50
50
100
150
0.9
200
Time, day
Nickel
Iron
Figure 13: Ecat data before and during the Stamina trial: Nickel and
Iron on Ecat
50
100
150
0
200
Calcium
Vanadium
1.4
Figure 14: Ecat data before and during the Stamina trial: FACT Ecat
activity, Calcium and Vanadium contamination
Fe on Ecat, wt%
Ni on Ecat, ppm
Flex-Tec
Time, day
Ecat activity
5000
4000
Stamina Trial
Ca , V , ppm
0
-100
ZSA/MSA ratio
2
ZSA, MSA, m /g
100
FACT, wt%
120
Base Flex-Tec
Full change-out
to Stamina
Ni, ppm
2981
3000
V, ppm
426
969
Fe, wt%
1.19
1.19
Ca, ppm
1697
1285
0.46
0.27
39
84
Na, wt%
MSA Ecat, m /g
2
1.9
1.0
ZSA retention, %
Base
+ 15
MSA retention, %
Base
+ 19
Full change-out
to Stamina
Average
Stamina
End of
Trial
Change Change
% rel.
2.2
1.8
-0.4
-18.2
5.1
5.6
0.5
9.8
5.2
5.2
0.1
1.7
17.1
16.4
-0.7
-4.1
46.9
49.3
2.4
5.1
17.3
20.4
3.1
17.9
Product Yields
9.1
4.3
-4.8
-52.7
Delta Coke
1.13
0.90
-0.2
-20.4
24.1
17.6
-6.5
-27.0
0.05
0.06
1.8
1.7
LPG, wt%
18.5
15.7
Naphtha, wt%
42.8
45.9
LCO, wt%
20.7
22.5
Bottoms, wt%
9.3
7.5
Coke, wt%
6.8
6.7
Overall, the modeling results confirm that on the basis of constant operating conditions and feed quality
the use of the new Stamina catalyst at Big West Oil led to a reduction in bottoms by almost 5% or over
50% relative and a 20% relative drop in delta coke. Liquid yields increased by over 5% total (3% or 18%
relative for LCO and 2.4% or 5% relative for naphtha). The modeling data also suggest that the flat LCO
yield seen in the operating data was largely induced by feed and operational effects. These data again
confirm the excellent performance of Stamina during this trial.
Profitability
After completion of the trial, Big West Oil performed an assessment of the impact of Stamina on the FCC
units economics. Overall, the data (Table 6) show major improvements in bottoms and cat gasoline yields,
leading to an improvement of 1.56 $/bbl.
Baseline
Flex-Tec
Trial
Stamina
Change
Baseline
Flex-Tec
Trial
Stamina
Change
vol %
vol %
vol %
bbl/day
bbl/day
bbl/day
Cat Gas
56.7%
62.3%
5.6%
5952
6543
LCO
17.8%
16.7%
-1.1%
1871
1758
-112
-$0.79
-$8,300
9.1%
5.0%
-4.1%
957
523
-434
-$1.86
-$19,564
$1.56
$16,420
Bottoms
590
Improvement
$/bbl
$/d
$4.22
$44,284
Table 6: Analysis of Big West Oils FCC unit economics before and during the Stamina trial
(based on 10,500 bbl/d throughput)
As discussed above, the actual LCO yield was found to be slightly lower on average during the trial period,
mainly caused by changes in feed and operating conditions, as confirmed by the Profimatics reconciliation
to constant conditions that showed an improvement of LCO.
In addition to the improvements in bottoms and liquid yields, the refinery data show significant
improvements in RON (+1) and LPG olefinicity, following a reduction in rare earth on the Stamina
catalyst towards the end of the trial.
10
91.5
References
75
91
65
89.5
89
60
88.5
88
LPG olefinicity, lv %
90
RON
70
90.5
55
87.5
87
50
-120-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Time, day
RON
LPG olefinicity
Figure 15: RON and LPG olefinicity, Big West Oil operating data
Conclusion
The Stamina catalyst trial in Big West Oils Salt Lake City
refinery was successfully concluded in late 2009, showing a
reduction in bottoms by over 50% at the benefit of light cycle
oil and naphtha, while the delta coke could be improved by
20% relative over the former catalysts. Overall, all the refiners
objectives for the catalyst trial of maximum conversion and
bottoms upgrading to LCO and naphtha were fulfilled. As
observed earlier for the other members of the Prox-SMZ
platform, the novel matrix technology used in Stamina allowed
for a significant increase in matrix surface area without
negatively impacting the coke yield. The novel Stamina resid
distillate maximization catalyst showed extremely high matrix
and zeolite surface area stability, even during periods of high
iron and calcium contamination. Overall, the refinery reports an
improvement in the FCC units profitability by more than
$1.5/bbl. Due to the positive outcome of the trial, Big West Oil
entered into a regular supply agreement for Stamina at the
end of the trial.
Authors
Martin Kraus, Qi Fu, and Jeff Yang
BASF Corporation
25 Middlesex/Essex Turnpike
Iselin, NJ 08830
Natalie Kiser
BASF Corporation
1111 Bagby Street- Suite 2600
Houston, TX 77002
Orson Thornton and Jon Finch
Big West Oil, LLC (subsidiary of Flying J Inc.)
333 West Center Street
North Salt Lake City, UT 84054
11
About Us
BASFs Catalysts division is the worlds
leading supplier of environmental
and process catalysts. The group
offers exceptional expertise in the
development of technologies that
protect the air we breathe, produce the
fuels that power our world and ensure
efficient production of a wide variety of
chemicals, plastics and other products.
By leveraging our industry-leading R&D
platforms, passion for innovation and
deep knowledge of precious and base
metals, BASFs Catalysts division
develops unique, proprietary catalyst
and adsorbent solutions that drive
customer success.
BASF - The Chemical Company
www.catalysts.basf.com/refining