Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Liquidity management
Of
The City Bank Limited
Page 1 of 84
Internship Report
On
Liquidity management of
The City Bank Limited
Submitted To
Md. Amdadul Hoque
Assistant Professor,
Department of Finance
Bangladesh University of Business and Technology (BUBT)
Submitted By
Zahiduzzaman
MBA Program, 16th Intake
ID # 08093201020
Major in Finance
Bangladesh University of Business and Technology (BUBT)
Page 2 of 84
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
13th September, 2011
Md. Amdadul Hoque
Assistant Professor, Department of Finance
Bangladesh University of Business & Technology
Mirpur-2, Dhaka-1216.
Dear Sir,
I am truly pleased to submit my internship report on the Liquidity management process of The City
Bank Ltd. I have gathered what I consider to be the most complete information available. This report
gave me the prospect to have a brief knowledge about the liquidity management process of The City Bank
Limited. It is a great achievement to work under your active supervision, care and guidance.
I tried my best to incorporate all the information that I have collected during the internship period. I wish
the report would fulfill your expectation and standard. I must mention here that, I am extremely grateful
to you for your valuable supervision, tireless effort and continuous attention in preparing this report.
I, sincerely hope that you will be satisfied with this report. If you have any query, I will be pleased to
answer that. I hope and pray that you would be gracious enough to accord approval to this report.
Sincerely
Zahiduzzaman
MBA Program, 16th Intake
ID # 08093201020
Major in Finance
Bangladesh University of Business and Technology (BUBT)
Page 3 of 84
Acknowledgement
Internship program is one of the important requirements for the completion of two years MBA
program. I have completed my internship from The City Bank Limited. In this regard I would
like to express my heartiest appreciation to my honorable supervisor Md. Amdadul Hoque,
Assistant professor, Department of Finance, for his care, guidance and valuable suggestions to
prepare this report.
I also would like to pay my gratitude to all of my faculty members for their constant guidance
and cooperation.
I also express my heartiest gratitude to honorable MBA Program Director, Professor M.A Hakim to give
me permission for Internship and help me to provide various guidelines about the report.
I also like to express my sincere thank to all the employees of HR & finance department of The
City Bank Limited for providing me required information about the Liquidity management
process which helped me to prepare such a significant report.
At last I feel very pleased to thank all my fellow friends for their cordial cooperation in preparing
this report.
Page 4 of 84
Executive summary
Banking is a business, which runs on the confidence and trust of people. This confidence enables
the bank to mobilize funds from various sources. The main function of bank may broadly be
divided into two categories. Firstly, borrowing money from public by accepting deposits and
secondly, lending the money to public for development of trade, commerce, agriculture and
industry. The profitability of a bank always depends on the efficient management of fund and
exploring the genuine avenues in which its resources are invested to produce the maximum
income. To ensure, that these activities will run properly, a bank must effectively manage its
liquid assets & liabilities. .
I am going to describe particularly the liquidity management process of The City Bank Ltd. So,
in whole through this report I concentrated on the liquidity management & its correspondent
issues. I divided my report in several chapters according to the necessity & similarity of the
topics.
To understand a particular management process of a bank, it is required to have a basic idea
about that I basically described the background & necessity of preparing this report, the methods
I used to prepare it & the scope & limitation I faced during preparing this reports etc. other then
these, I also stated some introductory speech to introduce my bank & the topic Ive chosen.
It contains the description & analysis of different department & activities of CBL. I tried my best
to highlight each & every department, the divisions-subdivisions, the achievement of CBl, their
recent financial position, recent performance & all basic ideas about it.
What is liquidity? As my main focus is on the liquidity management process, so it is very much
important to know the basic ideas & definitions of the fundamental issues regarding liquidity
management process. So I thoroughly illustrated the theoretical descriptions & ideas about the
liquid assets & liability of a bank, which type of assets & liabilities we should name liquid assets
& liquid liability, types of liquid assets & many other issues. It also contains the description of
the liquidity management requirements of central bank & central banks liquidity management
process. I have collected all possible information to thoroughly describe the liquidity
management of CBL. Also I analyzed different financial ratios such as current ratio, cash
position indicator, capacity ratio, loan to deposit ratio etc & Ive also done the trend analysis of
both loans & deposits. To present the liquidity position of the bank, I collected the information
about the SLR & CRR positions of CBL & also I made a graph of the liquidity gap & many other
financial calculations of this bank.
Organizations fail if they do not have access to sufficient cash to meet their short-term liabilities
as they fall due. As long as short-term assets exceed short-term liabilities, companies face
minimal liquidity problems. Fluctuations in margining requirements from lenders and trading
counterparties can cause short-term liabilities to rise sharply, precisely when assets fall, leading
to costly and sudden liquidations. Collateral haircuts, discretionary interest rates, and material
adverse change clauses exacerbate liquidity risk. Ironically, lenders make bank runs on
liquidity-stressed funds and corporations, each lender securing its own interest while collectively
Page 5 of 84
Page 6 of 84
Table of contents:
Content
Page No.
12
1.1) Introduction
13
14
14
14
1.5) Methodology
15-17
17
17
12
19-21
22-26
27
29
30-31
31-32
32
33
34-36
36
37
39
39-41
43
44
45
Page 7 of 84
45
45-47
47
48
49
49
49-50
51-52
52-54
54-56
56-58
58
59-64
64-65
66
67
67
68-69
70-72
73
74
75-76
7.2) Conclusion
77
7.3) Recommendation
77-78
Glossary
79
References
80
Appendix
81-83
Page 8 of 84
List of tables:
Content
Page No.
26
44
c. Liquidity Statement
53
55
57
57
58
h. Current Ratio
60
60
j. Capacity ratio
61
62
63
m. reserve ratio
63
69
70
Page 9 of 84
Page No.
21
34
35
f. Types of Liquidity
38
g. Liquidity Risk
40
45
43
56
Ratio Analysis
60
72
Page 10 of 84
CHAPTER ONE
(Introduction part)
Page 11 of 84
1.1 Introduction:
Banks are not ordinary intermediaries. Like non-banks, they also borrow, but they do not lend
the deposits they acquire. They lend by crediting the borrower's account with a new deposit, and
then if necessary borrowing the funds needed to meet the reserve ratio requirement. The
accounts of other depositors remain intact and their deposits fully available for withdrawal. Thus
a bank loan increases the total of bank deposits, which means an increase in the money
supply. When the loan is paid off, the money supply decreases.
A net increase in bank lending results in a shortage of reserves needed by the banking system,
which only the Fed can supply. In order to maintain control of the Fed funds rate, i.e. the interest
rate on overnight loans between banks, the Fed must provide the funds as required. It does so by
purchasing Treasury securities from the public. Bank lending has no effect on a bank's own
capital. But bank lending is limited by the capital ratio requirement set by the Fed. If a bank has
sufficient capital, it can expand its balance sheet by issuing more loans.
However if it is not holding excess reserves, it will have to acquire more in order to meet the
reserve ratio requirement. Banks therefore actively seek new deposits. Of course they prefer
deposits on which they pay no interest, like ordinary checking accounts. They also borrow from
savers who open savings accounts and investors who buy their CDs.
Liquidity is essential in all banks to compensate for expected and unexpected Balance Sheet
fluctuations and to provide funds for growth. The recent liquidity crises faced by banks and
financial institutions have brought to the fore the need to review their existing Liquidity
Management Policies, Practices and Procedures. One of the most important tasks the
management of any bank or financial service provider faces is ensuring adequate liquidity at all
times, no matter what emergencies may suddenly appear.
A financial institution is considered to be liquid if it has ready access to immediately spendable
funds at reasonable cost at precisely the time those funds are needed. This suggests that a liquid
bank or other financial-firm either has the right amount of immediately spendable funds on hand
when they are required or can rise liquid funds in a timely fashion by borrowing or by selling
assets. Indeed, lack of adequate liquidity can be one of the first signs that a bank or other
financial institution is in real trouble.
The cash shortages that banks and other financial service providers in trouble often experience
make clear that liquidity needs cannot be ignored. A Bank closes if it cannot raise sufficient
liquidity even though technically, it may still be solvent. Moreover, the competence of liquidity
managers is an important barometer of managements overall effectiveness in achieving any
financial institutions goals. So lets begin our journey and see how really important quality
liquidity management is to be success in The City Bank Limited (CBL).
Page 12 of 84
Page 13 of 84
Sources of data:
For preparing a report, someone can use basically two sources for collecting data
& necessary information. Those are,
3.2 Primary source:
A primary source (also called original source or evidence) is an artifact, a
document, a recording, or other source of information that was created at the time
under study.
3.2 Secondary source:
A secondary source is a document or recording that relates or discusses information
originally presented elsewhere. Secondary sources involve generalization, analysis,
synthesis, interpretation, or evaluation of the original information.
I had collected data from both the primary source and secondary source.
Primary source:
I have collected data from the employees of different department of The City Bank Limited by
communicate & working with them. I also collected information form observing their financial
status, their organizational culture, from different group discussion, observing the process of
managing the liquid money & assets of the bank.
Secondary source:
Analyzing all the annual reports from 2005 to 2009, I tried to identify all the elements of
liquidity and prepared the report.
Annual Reports of The City Bank Ltd of the year 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009.
The basic idea about The City Bank Ltd was taken from its website (www.thecitybank.com)
Papers & journals about the Central bank liquidity management & reservation
requirements.
Page 14 of 84
Primary data:
Primary data are collected by different group discussions, personal observation of the
organizational culture, their internal process of managing liquidity & from different statistical
measures & analysis that Ive shown later on in this report.
Secondary data:
From working in this organization, Ive got the facility to go through maximum of the record file
related to the liquidity issue. So many important data were been collected from there. Some other
data Ive collected from the website.
Other then that, it was easy for me to make a positive relation with the manager of finance
department & to collect all annual report from him. However, the annual report of 2006 was not
available there.
Page 15 of 84
Page 16 of 84
CHAPTER TWO
(Organizational Profile of The City Bank Limited)
Page 17 of 84
Under a real-time online banking platform, these 4 business divisions are supported at the back
by a robust service delivery or operations setup and also a smart IT Backbone. Such centralized
business segment based business & operating model ensure specialized treatment and services to
the bank's different customer segments. The bank currently has 87 online branches and 10 SME
service centers spread across the length & breadth of the country that include a full fledged
Islami Banking branch. Besides these traditional delivery points, the bank is also very active in
the alternative delivery area. It currently has 46 ATMs of its own; and ATM sharing arrangement
with a partner bank that has more than 550 ATMs in place; SMS Banking; Interest Banking and
so on. It already started its Customer Call Center operation. The bank has a plan to end the
current year with 100 own ATMs. City Bank is the first bank in Bangladesh to have issued Dual
Currency Credit Card. The bank is a principal member of VISA international and it issues both
Local Currency (Taka) & Foreign Currency (US Dollar) card limits in a single plastic. VISA
Page 18 of 84
2.1.a.b) Mission:
To attain highest level of customer satisfaction through extension of services by
dedicated and motivated team professionals.
Page 19 of 84
Page 20 of 84
The City Bank Limited has already introduced some new Banking products like duel currency
Credit Cards, ATM and Online services which has created attraction among the clients. The
Bank is going to introduce real time Internet, SMS and Phone Banking systems with all modern
delivery channels at an early date.
Retail Financing
CBLs credit
SME Financing
Corporate Credit
Page 21 of 84
Working capital:
Trade finance:
Short/mid-term finance:
Project finance:
Islamic finance:
Structured finance:
Cash management:
Investment banking:
Current account:
Our current account meets the needs of individual and commercial customers through our
schedule benefit.
Interest Rate : Nil
Page 22 of 84
City Shomridhdhi:
City Shomridhdhi - A unique offer from City Bank. City Shomridhdhi is an exceptional DPS
product that is distinctly more attractive than the prevalent DPS products in the market. You
receive a hefty sum at the end of the term against your monthly deposit of small installments.
City Projonmo:
City Projonmo financial safety for your future generations backed by complete immense
protection! City Projonmo is a unique monthly deposit scheme that you open for your kids to
safeguard their future against all uncertainties and risks.
City Ichchapurun:
City Ichchapurun great opportunity to earn against your savings every month! This product
allows you to earn interest and enjoy interest every month that accrues in your fixed deposit
account, no matter what the term of the deposit is.
Fixed Deposit:
If you believe in long-term investments and wish to earn higher interests on your savings, NOW
is the time to invest your money in our Fixed Deposit.
2.2.b.b) Loan:
City drive:
Owning a car is no longer a luxury. Car for your family is now a matter of fulfilling a necessity.
Appreciating that basic need, City Bank introduces City Drive, a tailor-made auto loan scheme
for individuals.
City solution:
Dream Vacation? Son's admission to a foreign university? Medical treatment? Daughter's
wedding? House renovation? Whatever the occasion or requirement may be, City Solution - any
personal loan from City Bank - is there to solve all your problems and to fulfill all your dreams.
You can access this facility from our selected branches across the country.
City express:
City Express Cash is a fully secured and revolving facility for any legitimate purpose. The
security for the loan should be ideally CBL FDR. Bank would finance against clients CBL FDR
or other banks/NBFIs security. City Express Loan is a fully secured and terminating (EMI
Page 23 of 84
2.2.d) Treasury
City Bank Treasury & Market Risk Division:
City Bank Ltd. has a dedicated Treasury team who is capable of providing all treasury Solutions.
Through our foreign correspondent business partners CBL is providing a wide range of Treasury
products. In CBL Treasury, there are four teams who are specialized in their own area to ensure
Page 24 of 84
Page 25 of 84
2009
5742.82
3671.99
2297.05
2112.24
2255.64
1388.06
818.72
1750
1571.13
4293.10
5864.23
62384.28
43486.42
10586.45
2788.07
76466.80
10446.56
13815.40
28717.80
17932.50
11.29%
799.21
708.47
4.87%
15.71
52.11
25%
729.55
14
373.25
69.71%
6.08%
Page 26 of 84
13.07%
1.23%
16.24%
87
10
2424
513
Source: Annual report-2009
Operating Income:
Operating income for the year 2009 stood at tk.4367.88 million compared to that of tk. 3380.27
million in 2008. Operating income increased by tk.987.61 million (29.22%) from 2008 primarily
due to decreased cost of deposit.
Deposit:
Total deposit of the bank as on December 31, 2009 stood tk. 62384.28 million against tk.
45034.33 million of the previous year.
Loans and Advances:
The loans and advances portfolio of the bank at the end of the year 2009 stood at tk. 43486.42
million with loans diversified in both conventional credit and finance based on islami shariah.
Export:
The amount of export business including local bills was tk. 13815.40 million in the year under
review compared to tk.14765.80 million in the previous year.
Import:
The volume of import business including local L/Cs of the bank stood at tk. 28717.80 million in
the year 2009 compared to tk.30894.10 million in the year 2008.
They have also delivered a number of growth initiatives that are crore parts of their master
strategy and these will surely well position us for the future. In 2009,we have:
Launched American Express Cards in Bangladesh which is the number 1 financial
institution brand in the globe. We are American Expresss sole franchisee for
Bangladesh.
Opened 5 new branches, 5 SME service centers and 11 SME business centers.
Increased their number of ATM from 24 to 47 providing their customer with greater
access to their money.
Relocated Head office from Motijheel to Gulshan Avenue.
Launched brokerage business.
Appointed 290 additional talented staff to their bank during the year mainly to support
the newly formed departments.
Page 27 of 84
Page 28 of 84
Page 29 of 84
Also known as "liquidity ratio", "cash asset ratio" and "cash ratio".
Page 30 of 84
Page 31 of 84
Page 32 of 84
a) Ready Market: A liquid asset must have a ready market so that it can be converted into cash
without delay.
Page 33 of 84
Page 34 of 84
The purchase of bills by the Central Bank also increases commercial banks operational reserves.
This increase in liquidity - an increase in the supply of money - causes the interbank rate to fall
and leads to a general increase in loans extended and in securities purchased. This is because the
availability of funds has increased and their cost has decreased. This supply effect accentuates
Page 35 of 84
f. Types of Liquidity
Page 36 of 84
Page 37 of 84
Strong:
Board approved policies effectively communicate guidelines for liquidity risk management and
designate responsibility. The liquidity risk management process is effective in identifying,
measuring, monitoring, and controlling liquidity risk. Reflects a sound culture that has proven
effective over time. Management fully understands all aspects of liquidity risk. Management
anticipates and responds well to changing market conditions.
The contingency funding plan is well-developed, effective and useful. The plan incorporates
reasonable assumptions, scenarios, and crisis management planning, and is tailored to the needs
of the institution. Management information systems focus on significant issues and produce
timely, accurate, complete, and meaningful information to enable effective management of
liquidity. Internal audit coverage is comprehensive and effective. The scope and frequency are
reasonable.
Page 38 of 84
Page 39 of 84
CHAPTER FOUR
(Liquidity Management-Central banks requirements)
Page 40 of 84
Page 41 of 84
SLR
CRR
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
16
18
18
18
18
18.5
4.5
5
5
5
5
5.5
In the above table SLR and CRR are shown which was increased in 2006 from 2005 but after
that year it was stable to 2009. As a result of worldwide recession and our countrys inflation
rate, BB decided to amplify the SLR and CRR to secure and develop our countrys economy.
The global financial crisis that began in mid-2007 has renewed concerns about financial
instability and focused attention on the fundamental role of central banks in preventing and
managing systemic crises. In response to the turmoil, central banks have made extensive use of
both new and existing tools for supplying central bank money to financial institutions and
markets. In the face of the widespread financial market dislocations that began in August 2007,
central banks have expanded liquidity operations, actively deploying their balance sheets to
address all three types of liquidity shortages. While the inherent cause of the current crisis may
be rooted in coordination failures and informational asymmetries and so is not new the scale and
scope of the problem have necessitated measures in some countries that are clearly
unprecedented. In particular, because institutions have come to depend on market-based sources
of liabilities, replacing lost funding liquidity now requires interventions on a scale that is large
relative to the size of the central banks balance sheet in normal times.
Page 42 of 84
Increasingly Asset Liability Management has become an integral part of Bank Management.
Banks are exposed to Balance Sheet Risk, where it is absolutely necessary for the management
of the bank to understand the existence of such risk and best manage the exposure to the risk.
The Asset Liability Committee (ALCO), comprising of the senior management of a bank, is
primarily responsible for Balance Sheet Management or more specifically Balance Sheet Risk
Management.
Page 43 of 84
Page 44 of 84
Page 45 of 84
CHAPTER FIVE
(Liquidity Management of CBL)
Page 46 of 84
Cash in hand
Balance with other banks and financial institutions
Money at call and short notice
Investments
Loans and advances
Page 47 of 84
Short-Term Liquidity
Our reporting system tracks cash flows on a daily basis over an 18-month horizon. This system
allows management to assess our short-term liquidity position in each location, region and
globally on a by-currency, by-product and by-division basis. The system captures all of our cash
flows from transactions on our balance sheet, as well as liquidity risks resulting from off-balance
sheet transactions. We model products that have no specific contractual maturities using
statistical methods to reflect the behavioral characteristics of their cash flows. Liquidity outflow
limits (Maximum Cash Outflow Limits), which have been set to limit cumulative global and
local cash outflows, are monitored on a daily basis to safeguard our access to liquidity. As of
year-end 2009 we have implemented a new reporting system which focuses on contractual cash
flows from wholesale funding sources on a daily basis over a 12-month horizon. The system
captures all cash flows from unsecured as well as from secured funding transactions. Wholesale
funding limits, which are calibrated against our stress testing results and approved by the
Management Board; describe our maximum tolerance for liquidity risk. These limits apply to the
cumulative global cash outflows and are monitored on a daily basis.
Unsecured Funding
Unsecured funding is a finite resource. Total unsecured funding represents the amount of
external liabilities which we take from the market irrespective of instrument, currency or tenor.
Unsecured funding is measured on a regional basis by currency and aggregated to a global
utilization report. The management board approves limits to protect our access to unsecured
funding at attractive levels.
Asset Liquidity
The asset liquidity analysis forms an integral piece of stress testing and tracks the volume and
booking location within our consolidated inventory of unencumbered, liquid assets which we can
use to raise liquidity via secured funding transactions. Securities inventories include a wide
variety of different securities. As a first step, we segregate illiquid and liquid securities in each
inventory. Subsequently we assign liquidity values to different classes of liquid securities. The
liquidity of these assets is an important element in protecting us against short-term liquidity
squeezes.
In addition, we keep a dedicated strategic liquidity reserve containing highly liquid and central
bank eligible securities in major currencies around the world to support our liquidity profile in
case of potential deteriorating market conditions. The strategic liquidity reserve amounts to EUR
54.9 billion as of December 31, 2009. This reserve is held in addition to the banks cash balance
and the collateral the bank needs to support its clearing activities in euro, U.S. dollars and other
currencies which are held in separate portfolios around the globe.
Page 48 of 84
Page 49 of 84
Page 50 of 84
(000 Taka)
Particulars
Assets
2009
2008
2007
Cash in hand
Balance with other banks and financial institutions
Money at call and short notice
Investments
Loans and advances
Fixed assets including premises, furniture and
fixtures
Other assets
Non banking assets
Total Assets (a)
Liabilities:
Borrowing from other banks, financial institutions
and agents
5142660.56
9850784.09
299779.17
10586452.61
43486421.80
2788065.87
3120173.30
4573690.31
220000.00
9031698.88
34420944.98
2514383.97
3477567.05
4782474.42
1830000.00
7550606.49
26788466.14
1390732.20
4312637.46
3233684.61
2935556.72
76466801.56
57114576.06
48755403.01
992651.50
2104480.29
850000.00
Deposits
Other accounts
Provision and other liabilities
59866593.87
2517686.13
7225635.78
70602567.29
43239466.44
1794868.07
5758284.74
52897099.52
38916353.90
1623280.13
4491401.99
45881036.03
5864234.28
4217476.53
2874366.99
Total liabilities(b)
Net Liquidity Gap (a-b)
Depos it
C as h
6000000
60000000
5000000
50000000
4000000
40000000
30000000
1000000
10000000
2009
2008
2007
Depos it
20000000
2007
2000000
2008
C as h
2009
3000000
Page 51 of 84
1000000
BFB
500000
2009
2007
2008
2009
45000000
40000000
35000000
30000000
25000000
20000000
15000000
10000000
5000000
0
BFB
2008
2007
L iquidity G ap
8000000
6000000
4000000
2000000
0
L iquidity G ap
2009
2008
2007
5864234.28
4217476.53
2874366.99
Page 52 of 84
CRR
2009
2008
2007
2006
Required Reserve
2688313.00
2284419.00
2171060.00
1945317.00
Actual
reserve 2849674.00
maintained
2321252.00
2201544.23
1957657.00
Surplus/(deficit)
36833.00
30484.23
12340.00
8210229.00
7821976.00
7008262.00
Actual
reserve 13050517.00
maintained
(including CRR)
10312595.00
10696769.00
8370218.33
Surplus/(deficit)
2102366.00
2874793.00
1361956.33
161361.00
SLR
3386271.00
d. CRR and SLR of CBL (Source: Annual reports 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009)
CRR
3000000
2000000
1000000
0
2009
2008
RR
2007
AR M
2006
S /D
All the four years, CBL has maintained a surplus in CRR. Although it was in a near
to steady position, but a good management of this reserve ratio indicate a good
liquidity management framework of CBL.
Page 53 of 84
SLR
15000000
10000000
5000000
0
2009
2008
RR
2007
AR M
2006
S /D
All the four years, CBL has maintained a surplus in SLR. However, it was also in a
steady amount.
j. CRR and SLR of CBL
From the above graphs it is easily imagine that CRR was increasing and SLR was also increasing
last 2006 year to 2009.
Page 54 of 84
Period
Deposit level
Changes in deposit
2009
2008
2007
2006
59866593.87
43239466.44
38916353.90
40287228
16627127
4323113
-1370874
Period
Loan level
Changes in loan
2009
2008
2007
2006
43486421.80
34420944.98
26788466.14
9065477
7632479
-4000556
30789021.98
Period
Changes in deposit
Changes in loan
Liquidity
surplus/deficit
2009
2008
2007
2006
16627127
4323113
9065477
7632479
7561650
-3309366
-1370874
-4000556
-5371430
Except the estimation in 2009, all the remaining years have negative liquidity balance. Thus the
manager is required to employ 2009 years balances in profitable investments. On the other hand,
the manager would manage the cheapest source to fulfill the deficit liquidity in years 2008 and
2007.
Name of Ratios
Ratios
Cash position indicators
0.84329: 1
Liquid securities indicators
0.1592915: 1
Risk less assets position
1.0025817: 1
Liquidity assets ratio
0.273666: 1
Capacity ratio
0.574189: 1
f. Assets based liquidity ratios
Page 55 of 84
Here, cash and deposit generate 84% of total assets which is sufficient; investment in
government securities is 16%. Cash, deposit and governments securities generate 100% of total
assets so that we can say; cash, deposit and government securities are main sources of total
assets. Cash, government securities and reserve are 27% on total assets. If we can say about
capacity ratio then we see that net loan is 57% of total assets.
II
Name of Ratios
Core deposit ratio
Deposit composition ratio
Ratios
0.7789016: 1.
0.2110333:1.
Here, current deposits are 21% of term deposit so that we can say that term deposit is greater
than current deposits. Core deposits are 78% of total assets which means 78% assets generated
from core deposits.
40287
38916
43239
59866
2006
2007
2008
2009
F . Depos its
2010
2011
A . Depos its
From this graph I find that by increasing 1 year the company Deposits is increasing day by day.
During the year 2009 there is a positive growth of the deposit. This betterment in deposit was the
result of strategic plan. So overall the deposit growth rate shows a satisfactory performance of
the company.
Page 56 of 84
30789
26788
34420
43486
2006
2007
2008
2009
F . L oans
2010
2011
A . L oans
From this graph I find that by increasing 1 year the company Loans is increasing day by day.
During the year 2009 there is a positive growth of the loans and advances. This betterment in
loans and advances was the result of strategic plan. So overall the deposit growth rate shows a
satisfactory performance of the company.
6.5Current Ratio:
Probably the best-known liquidity ratio is the Current Ratio, the quotient of current assets and
current liabilities. Current assets and current liabilities are commonly defined as falling due
within a year from the balance sheet date.
Page 57 of 84
Ratios
1.318364
1.102125
1.17803
1.311393
CR
1.4
1.2
1.318364
1.102125
1.17803
1.311393
0.8
2006
2007
2008
2009
One of the most important issues in liquidity management is to determine which proportion of
the assets should be held as a liquidity reserve and how much can be loaned out. The current
ratio is of no help in this regard. In fact, an institution that has loaned all its funds and has zero
liquidity would have the same current ratio as a bank that has not made a single loan and holds
all its current assets as vault cash. Despite its limited information value, a bank might still need
to track and publish the current ratio, simply because it is used so widely by donors and
propagated in many comparative studies of the banking sector.
From this above graph we see that in 2006, current ratio was highest but after that year it reduced
and in 2008, 2009 it increased.
Ratios
0.9212
0.9028
0.843121
0.883085
Page 58 of 84
C PI
0.95
0.9
0.85
0.9212
0.9028
0.843121
0.883085
CPI
0.8
2006
2007
2008
2009
This ratio obviously ranges between 0 and 1, where a larger proportion of cash implies that the
institution is in a stronger position to handle immediate cash needs.
The City Bank Limited was stronger in 2006 but that time it reduced to 2008 and in 2009 it
increased.
3. Capacity Ratio:
The mirror image to the cash position is captured by the capacity ratio, which should be
understood as a negative liquidity indicator:
Capacity Ratio = (loans/ Total assets)
Year
2006
2007
2008
2009
Ratios
0.648927
0.549441
0.602654
0.568697
CR
0.65
0.6
0.55
0.648927
0.549441
0.5
0.602654
0.568697
CR
0.45
2006
2007
2008
2009
Page 59 of 84
Ratios
0.861632
0.831484
0.788493
0.81584
T DR
0.9
0.85
0.861632
0.8
0.831484
0.788493
0.81584
TDR
0.75
2006
2007
2008
2009
The higher the total deposit ratio, the lower is the perceived liquidity risk because contrary to
purchased funds, retail deposits are less sensitive to a change in interest rates or a minor
deterioration in business performance.
In 2006 city bank had lower liquidity risk but in 2008 it was highest liquidity risk and in 2009 it
was moderately stronger position.
5. Loan-to-Deposit Ratio:
Many banks and bank analysts monitor loan-to-deposit ratios as a general measure of liquidity:
Loan - to -Deposit Ratio = (Net loans/Total deposits)
Page 60 of 84
Ratios
0.753137
0.660796
0.764311
0.69707
L T DR
0.8
0.7
0.764311
0.753137
0.660796
0.69707
L TDR
0.6
2006
2007
2008
2009
Loans are presumably the least liquid of assets, while deposits are understood as the primary
source of funds. A high ratio indicates illiquidity, because in this case a bank is fully loaned-up
relative to its stable funding. Implicitly, it is assumed that new loans must be financed with large
purchased liabilities. A low ratio suggests that a bank has additional liquidity, since it can grant
new loans financed with stable deposits.
In 2008 bank had higher loan amount so it was higher illiquid but in 2007 city bank had lower
ratio which suggested that it had additional liquidity.
6. Reserve Ratio:
Although there is no shortage of different liquidity indicators in the commercial banking
literature, surprisingly there is rarely mention of a ratio that compares cash assets to customer
deposits.
Reserve Ratio = (Cash assets/Customer deposits)
Year
2006
2007
2008
2009
Ratios
0.069127
0.085769
0.069281
0.082425
Page 61 of 84
RR
0.1
0.05
0.069127
0.085769
0.069281
0.082425
2008
2009
RR
0
2006
2007
One could debate whether the numerator of the ratio should be cash assets or liquid assets. The
idea of a liquidity reserve would obviously be best captured by including all liquid assets in the
calculation. However, the analogy to a minimum reserve requirement imposed by the central
bank is most obvious when limiting the numerator to vault cash and demand deposits with other
banks.
In 2007 city bank had higher in cash position and in 2006 had lower cash position but in 2009 it
was moderately well position.
Short-term investment should be made out of short-term funds and long term investment
should be made from long term funds.
Arrangements can be made to make repayments of liabilities not in bulk but in
installments. It lowers the banks risk in liability repayment and need to make a large
single repayment will not arise at a time.
Indifference and or lack of cautious and close observation to deposits and loan behavior
of the large prime customers.
If counter service is provided by efficient, skilled and well-behaved persons, then the
clients mainly depositors and installment takers of borrowers, will patiently wait without
any objection and do not complain to the higher authority about the unavailability of
money. Thus, no bad impression about the service of the bank spreads among the public.
Page 62 of 84
If bank maintains regular linkage building rapport with these institutions, they may get
regular and complete data and information from the bank with detail clarifications
regarding liquidity and other operational trends of banks. With the help of such
information and advice, understanding and reporting about banks liquidity will be easier
with clarifications.
To overcome crisis, banks should take develop connections and accessibility to the
money market players and can take advance steps to manage inter bank loans or sell
short term securities in the money market, whenever required. Thus, if liquidity crisis
arises, bank can overcome the situation by collecting necessary funds. The bank, which
sells securities with more reliability, credibility and stability, has the ability to avoid
liquidity crisis timely or even can avoid the same in more efficient way.
Management of bank by professionally skilled and experienced personnel of both
deposits and loan if done properly can avoid many problems not to speak the liquidity.
Liquidity crisis must occur if loan cannot be recovered in the right time and right amount.
On the other hand, the loan portion can be converted into debenture can be sold in the
market for cash and thereby liquidity is managed by managerial maneuvering. By
efficient and planned loan recovery and by ensuring loan conversion opportunity,
liquidity crisis can be avoided and or minimized by the experienced and professionally
trained bank personnel.
Page 63 of 84
CHAPTER SIX
(Comparative Analysis with IFIC Bank Ltd.)
Page 64 of 84
Page 65 of 84
Ownership Structure
The sponsors hold ownership of the Bank in the private sector and Government of the Peoples
Republic of Bangladesh. Sponsors and individuals now own about 62 percent of the share capital
and the Government owns a little more than 38 percent of the shares.
The Bank started with an Authorized capital of Tk. 100 million in 1983. Paid up capital at that
time stood at Tk. 71.50 million only. Over the last 19 years, the authorized and paid-up capital
has increased substantially. The paid capital stood at Tk. 406.39 million as on December 31,
2001
The Bank has built up a strong reserve base over the years. In last 19 years its Reserves and
Surplus have increased overly. As against Tk. 21.20 million only in 1983 Reserve and surplus
increased to Tk.622.53 million in 2001. This consistent policy of building up Reserves has
enabled the Bank to maintain a better adequacy ratio as compared to others.
With the active support and guidance from the Government, the bank has been showing a steady
and improved performance. In its fifteen years operation, the bank has earned the status of
leading in terms of both business and goodwill.
Distribution of Branches
The Bank covers by its activities all the important trading and commercial centers of the country.
As on December 22, 2002 it had 55 branches within Bangladesh.
Page 66 of 84
Particulars
2009
2008
Cash in hand
3153.61
1202.26
2205
2130
Investments
1058.64
903.16
4348.64
3442.09
2788.06
2514.38
Other assets
431.26
323.36
9646.80
5711.45
2104.48
Other accounts
2517.68
1794.86
722.56
575.82
Total liabilities(b)
7060.25
5289.70
1664234
4217476.53
Assets
4323.94
Page 67 of 84
Comparative position of CBL and SBL, here cash, deposits and government securities are
considered as liquid assets of two required banks. All the amounts is shown in million.
CBL
Year
2006
2007
2008
2009
Cash
(in million Tk.)
2826.39
3477.57
3120.17
5142.66
Deposit
(in million Tk.)
40881.41
40539.63
45034.34
62384.28
Govt. securities
(in million Tk.)
5873.02
7094.71
7608.21
8468.75
IFIC
Year
Cash
Deposit
Govt. securities
2006
2413.29
35612.42
3522.27
2007
2530.75
28731
6943
2008
1230.53
22043.39
3272
2009
3153.61
44220
5623.35
From these tables we can easily understand that The City Bank Limited (CBL) is in better
position than IFIC bank ltd.. Here cash, deposit and government securities position are
considered as a comparative tools from 2006 to 2009 years.
Now, I am going to present the last liquidity position of CBL and IFIC in graphs.
Page 68 of 84
C as h in 2009
6000
4000
5142.66
C as h
3153.61
2000
0
CBL
IF IC
Cash is the most liquid asset of any organization. So, when the question arises on liquidity, at
first the cash should be considered. Here the cash in hand position of two selected bank has been
considered.
In case of cash, The City Bank Limited is higher position than Standard Bank Limited.
Depos it in 2009
80000
60000
40000
62384.28
20000
Depos it in 2009
44220
0
CBL
IF IC
Deposit is one of the most important sources of income for any bank. Also it is the source of
liquid asset of a bank. So, higher the deposit rate of a bank, better it can mange its liquidity.
Here, from the graph, we can observe that, CBL has a better deposit rate then IFIC bank. So it is
expected that it will be able to manage its liquidity more effectively then IFIC bank.
Page 69 of 84
G ovt. S ec urities
10000
8000
6000
8468.75
5623.35
4000
G ovt. S ec urities
2000
0
CBL
IF IC
Here, only the short term securities have been considered. Short tern Govt. securities are almost
similar to any current asset as it can be liquidated very quickly & can be converted in liquid cash.
As CBL is again in a better position, so the CBL is also in a favorable position compared to IFIC
bank to meet any kind of liquidity crisis.
Ratios
Current ratio
Cash position indicator
Capacity ratio
Total deposit ratio
IFIC Bank
1.085
0.698
.618
0.686
CBL
1.311
0.883
0.568
0.815
Page 70 of 84
Year 2009
1.5
1
Current ratio
0.5
0
IFIC
CBL
The current ratio of IFIC & CBL is almost closed to each other. However, the city bank was in a better
position in year 2009 regarding its current ratio.
year 2009
IFIC
CBL
Cash position indicator basically indicates the total amount of cash & deposit among the total asset. As
we have seen before, CBL has a greater liquid cash amount then of IFIC. So here CBL is somehow in a
better position regarding liquidity then IFIC.
Page 71 of 84
Capacity Ratio
0.62
0.6
0.58
Capacity
Ratio
0.56
0.54
IFIC
CBL
Year 2009
The liquidity surplus or deficit basically depends on the amount of deposit & loan. If the loan amount
increases more fluently then the deposit level, a deficit on liquidity may arise. The situation above seems
like this. IFIC is loosing their deposits year by year, but their loan amount is increasing. So again CBL is
a nearby constant situation in this regard.
0.85
0.8
0.75
0.7
0.65
0.6
IFIC
CBL
IFIC
CBL
Year 2009
So, the loan to deposit level among the total asset is presented here. CBL is in a good situation & it is
maintaining the balance of its deposit & loans. IFICs loan level is increasing year by year, but the deposit
level is decreasing. It is alarming for them.
Page 72 of 84
2009
Current asset
220,555,925
316,512,305
625,436,987
999,906,522
(404,881,062)
(683,394,217)
CBL
Current asset
284,005,632
214,854,300
367,620,005
456,906,522
(83,614,373)
(205,598,693)
Net Working Capital is a measure of liquidity of a firm. It is not a ratio, it measure a minimum
level of net working capital that the firm should maintain.
The net working capital of both the banks (IFIC, CBL) in both the years are negative. That
means, they are suffering from liquid asset (cash) to meet the current liabilities. The net working
capital have been decreased in 2009 than in both the companies, IFIC and CBL. The reason is
that the increased of current liabilities much than increased of current assets.
In comparison, CBL is better position of net working capital than IFIC in both the years.
Page 73 of 84
CHAPTER SEVEN
(Findings, Conclusion & Recommendation)
Page 74 of 84
7.1
Major findings:
First of all, this is to be remembered that it is not a research report. So, the report covers an
existing banking system that has been observed in the last twelve weeks. The findings of this
report describe the tasks that take place in the Credit division of CBL. Here I mainly focused on
the problems of the credit division of the bank these findings are completely from my personal
point of view. Those are given below:
1. From my personal working experience, Ive observed that CBL doesnt have any full
bodied liquidity management framework that ensures the maintenance of its liquidity.
The situation was worse in previous years, which can be easily understood by seeing the
charts of different ratio analysis. However, they recovered their lacking by taking
different steps, but steel they are avoiding this problem. I think this is a major problem of
the bank & again they are going to face same kind of situation if they dont take
necessary steps immediately.
3. There is no sound process for identifying, measuring, monitoring & controlling liquidity
risk. The treasury department gives more emphasis on foreign exchange, Money market
activities, corporate sales & Market research. As they are handling many activities in a
single department, so it is tough for them to manage every issue very strictly.
4. Supervisors are busy with the expansion plan of the bank, rather then development of it.
They doesnt regularly perform any assessment of banks overall liquidity risk
management framework & liquidity position to determine whether they deliver an
adequate level of flexibility to liquidity stress or not.
Page 75 of 84
5. Bank doesnt have any funding strategy which will provide an effective diversification in
the source & tenor of funding. It doesnt maintain any ongoing presence in its chosen
funding markets & strong relationships with fund providers. So it may cause a liquidity
crisis & shortage of funding to maintain its liquidity position.
6. From the comparison part of net working capital, it can be observed that the CBL might
be is in a better position then IFIC, but its own current asset has decreased in 2009
compared to 2008.
7. CBL has a lot of cash in hand-which might be proved a loss of profitability for the bank
in future.
8. Another major problem of The City Bank Limited is using highly subjective judgment in
lending decision-making. Due to lack of forward looking structuring policy banks resort
to subject to judgment based on current situation.
9. As the process of sanctioning loan takes a long time to process a loan. It some times
creates bad impact in market. Many clients are switching to other banks to reduce this
processing hour.
10. Sometimes the employee to unlawfully help the client deliberately overvalues the
securities taken against the loan. As a result if he fails to repay the loan, the Bank
authority cannot collect even the principal money invested by the selling those assets. It
is also a very important factor that leads to loan default.
Page 76 of 84
7.2) Conclusion:
From the above analysis of The City Bank Limiteds liquidity management, it is easily imagined
or predicted that the liquidity position will be stronger than now because liquidity position is
increasing day by day to support profitable loans and investments. Liquidity risk was a footnote
in many treatments of risk management until the credit crisis of 2008. While the crisis may have
been triggered by bad mortgage debt, it was accelerated and brought to a head by unanticipated
cash demands that caused bankruptcies, fund dissolutions, bank reorganizations (too many to
list), forced sales, distress aversion, asset sales, and equity infusions. Liquidity risk comes from
fluctuations in the prices of either short-term assets or short-term liabilities, or both. It is
typically manifest in margin lending, futures contracts, and OTC derivative contracts. Non price
risk factors include lender-determined haircuts, subjective interest rates, material adverse credit
quality changes, me first credit terms, herd behavior, and market panic. As such, quantitative
liquidity modeling is both critically necessary and extremely difficult. Best practice liquidity risk
management takes place at the point of contracting. In the absence of contractual protections,
firms need to provide recommitted solutions to solve liquidity problems. If they wait for a
liquidity shortfall to occur, it is already too late to undo the damage.
7.3) Recommendation:
A negative financial situation characterized by a lack of cash flow. For a single business, a
liquidity crisis occurs when the otherwise solvent business does not have the liquid assets (i.e.,
cash) necessary to meet its short-term obligations, such as repaying its loans, paying its bills and
paying its employees. If the liquidity crisis is not solved, the company must declare bankruptcy.
An insolvent business can also have a liquidity crisis, but in this case, restoring cash flow will
not prevent the business's ultimate bankruptcy. For the economy as a whole, a liquidity crisis
means that the two main sources of liquidity in the economy, banks and the commercial paper
market, severely reduce the number of loans they make or stop making loans altogether. Because
so many companies rely on these loans to meet their short-term obligations, this lack of lending
has a current effect throughout the economy, causing liquidity crises at a excess of individual
companies, which in turn affects individuals.
For the more betterment in liquidity position or liquid assets and sound liquidity risk
management and supervision, the city bank can take some perfect principles which are as follow:
A bank is responsible for the sound management of liquidity risk. So the city bank should
establish a full-bodied liquidity risk management framework that ensures it maintains
sufficient liquidity, including a cushion of unencumbered, high quality liquid assets, to
survive a range of stress events, including those involving the loss or impairment of both
unsecured and secured funding sources. Supervisors should assess the adequacy of both a
Page 77 of 84
Page 78 of 84
Page 79 of 84
Bangladesh Bank
CBL
SBL
CRR
SLR
ALM
C&I
CAMEL
DRS
SMA
SME
ATM
BFOBFI
BWOBFI
L/C
Letter of Credit
Page 80 of 84
References:
Annual Report, The City Bank Limited, 2006-2009.
www.thecitybank.com.
Bangladesh Bank: http://www.bangladesh-bank.org/mediaroom/corerisks/albsrisks.pdf
Dr. A. R.Khan, Bank Management-A Fund Emphasis (june,2009),chapter 8.
Liquidityforbanks;http://www.google.com.bd/#q= liquidity+ management+ in+ banks+ in+
bangladesh&hl= en&ei= tndnTI3oPJO4cYbZ3Y8F&start= 40&sa= N&fp= 1&cad= b
GTZ(LiquidityManagement:Basiccourse),http://www.ruralfinance.org/servlet/BinaryDo
wnloaderServlet?filename= 1151660203478_LM_lesson3.pdf(2010)
Practical participation with The City Bank Ltd.
Informal face to face conversation with the employee of CBL.
Page 81 of 84
Page 82 of 84
Ratio Analysis:
Page 83 of 84
Page 84 of 84