Sie sind auf Seite 1von 38

download at wowebook.

info

International Derivatives Exhibition


Reech Capital

Advanced Pricing and Risk


Guillaume BLACHER

Management for Equity Derivatives

FOW Frankfurt March 7 - 8th 2000


Outline
Guillaume
➢ Presentation of products most actively studied in BLACHER
Reech
Equity Derivatives
Capital
download at wowebook.info

➢ Evolution in pricing exotics

➢ Choosing a proper diffusion model

➢ Numerical methods: complexity and performance

➢ Generic product description tools


Equity
Derivatives
➢ The Future of quantitative analysis
Slide 2
download at wowebook.info

products most actively studied in


Equity Derivatives
Products
Guillaume
• High variety of products in Equity BLACHER
Derivatives
Reech
• Always new products tailored to: Capital
– new market conditions
download at wowebook.info

– new tax regimes


– new corporate situation
• Among most popular:
– Cliquets
– Structured notes
Equity
– Baskets and multi-underlying products Derivatives
– Hybrid Products
Slide 4
Cliquets
• Pays the equity positive performance each Guillaume
year, defined as: +
BLACHER
æ STi+1 − STi ö
ç Reech
ç ST Capital
è i
download at wowebook.info

• Pricing:
– By Monte-Carlo: most natural but slow
– By Tree/PDE: requires a second dimension for
the strike
• Problems:
– Almost a pure volatility product
Equity
– Strong impact of smile and dividends Derivatives
• Solution: pricing by static replication
Slide 5
Structured notes
Guillaume
• Client gives up risk-free return, dividends BLACHER
and/or x% of capital to get some equity
exposure via embedded option. Reech
Capital
• Often combines many features into one
download at wowebook.info

product:
– Bond features (coupons, redemption)
– Exotic features (digitals, barriers…)
– Swap features (equity swaps)
– Multi-underlying (best of, basket)
– Path dependent features (average) Equity
Derivatives
– American style features (puttable)
Slide 6
Exotics on basket
Guillaume
• Still a lot of business on baskets, mainly with
BLACHER
path-dependent features (asian baskets) and
Reech
capped
Capital
• Example: 5Y basket option of 3 indices, with a
download at wowebook.info

knock-in in the first 2.5Y at 175% to get an extra


25% of gearing.
• Modeling correlation realistically is crucial
• Correlation cannot be hedged on a trade by trade
basis (no exchange traded correlation sensitive
Equity
options): need for creativity to build up a Derivatives
correlation - diversified portfolio
Slide 7
Hybrid products
Guillaume
• More and more products across asset BLACHER
classes:
Reech
– Best of equity / interest rate
Capital
– Interest swaps triggered by equity level
download at wowebook.info

– Debt products with FX components


• Requires
– Combination of skills for modeling
heterogeneous assets together
– Very high structuring and pay-off description
flexibility Equity
– Consistent risk management across all asset Derivatives
classes
Slide 8
Volatility products
Guillaume
• Swaps or options on: BLACHER
– realised volatility from start to maturity
Reech
– Implied volatility
Capital
• Example:
download at wowebook.info

In 6M, option pays the 1M at-the-money implied


volatility.
• Pricing mechanism differs from standard
structure:
– Mix of semi-static option hedge and dynamic
spot hedge Equity
Derivatives
– Several un-hedgeable elements that need to be
taken into account. Slide 9
download at wowebook.info

Pricing Exotics
Pricing components
Guillaume
• Several components in a pricing engine: BLACHER
Reech
Diffusion Numerical Capital
download at wowebook.info

model method

Model
Product
parameters /
Calibration description Equity
Derivatives

Slide 11
download at wowebook.info

Diffusion models (I)


Diffusion models
• All pricings should be consistent with Guillaume
BLACHER
market prices of hedging instruments:
– Current yield Reech
Capital
– Smile
download at wowebook.info

– Credit curve
• The least it should do to achieve this with
deterministic models:
– short term rate: r(time)
– instantaneous volatility σ(spot, time)
– default probability p(spot, time) Equity
Derivatives
• Those functions can be calibrated to
market instruments Slide 13
Example: volatility modeling
• The simplest diffusion consistent with a Guillaume
market skew is: BLACHER

= (r − repo − div )dt + σ (S , t )dWt


dS Reech
S Capital
download at wowebook.info

• Always exists if market prices are not


arbitrageable
• Would be unique if a continuum of prices
were given
• Significant price impact on:
– Barriers Equity
Derivatives
– Cliquets
– Basket options Slide 14
Example
Guillaume
• Pricing with smile can be critical when the BLACHER
right price cannot be reach with Black-
Scholes formula Reech
Capital
download at wowebook.info

Market smile
3
39

37
Up and Out Call option
2.5
35

33

31
Barrier price

29
2
27

25
Black-Scholes price
Strike
Maturity 1.5
Smile price

Flat smile 1
35

33
0.5
31

29
0
27 0% 20% 40% 60% Equity
Derivatives
25

Maturity Black-Scholes volatility


Strike

Slide 15
Hedging
Guillaume
• What if the smile disappears? BLACHER
Black-Scholes assumption would then apply. Our Reech
Capital
mark-to-market position would be showing a
download at wowebook.info

big loss (if we bought the barrier) or a big


profit (if we sell the barrier)

• Only makes sense if a consistent vega


hedge is used.
Equity
Derivatives

Slide 16
download at wowebook.info

Risk Management
Vega analysis
Guillaume
Volatility risk can be measured at 3 levels: BLACHER
Reech
1) Single vega number: Capital
download at wowebook.info

– Parallel shift of the Classic Vega perturbation


2%

whole smile surface


– No protection against 1%

deformations 0%

– Which European
-1%

options to buy as a Strike Maturity Equity


Derivatives
hedge?
Slide 18
Vega analysis (2)
Guillaume
2) Vega buckets: BLACHER
– Parallel shift of the skew at each tenor Reech
– Protection against time deformations only Capital
download at wowebook.info

– Which strike should we buy as a hedge?


Bucket Vega perturbation Vega bucket for an exotic
2%

1%
Vega

0%
Equity
1M 2M 3M 4M 5M 6M 7M
Derivatives
-1%

Strike Maturity Tenor


Slide 19
Vega analysis (3)
Guillaume
3) Superbuckets: BLACHER
– Shift of each individual point on the surface Reech
– Protection against any deformation Capital
download at wowebook.info

– Provides strikes and maturities to hedge with.


Superbucket perturbation Superbucket: Up&Out Call
2%

strike

1%
barrier
Vega

0%
Equity
Derivatives
-1%

Strike Maturity Mat


Strike Slide 20
Global risk management
Guillaume
• Each individual exotic has got its superbucket BLACHER
topography.
Reech
• What is really relevant is the superbucket of the Capital
download at wowebook.info

whole book, aggregating exotics and vanillas on the


same underlying: Portfolio superbucket

Sensitivities to
be hedged out
Vega

(by trading
corresponding
Equity
Europeans)
Derivatives
Mat
Strike
Slide 21
Risk Reports
Classic Report: CORRECT Report: Guillaume
BLACHER
Spot Strike
Reech
Capital

Maturity
download at wowebook.info

Time Vega Vega

Traders will try to flatten the Classic Report where


they should be trying to flatten the Correct Report:
Equity
• Equivalent for European options Derivatives
• Different for Exotics
Slide 22
Global risk management (2)
Guillaume
• This (correct) analysis should be available at BLACHER
portfolio level on all model parameters, whether Reech
they be: Capital
download at wowebook.info

– hedgeable (credit term structure, smile surface)


– un-hedgeable (instantaneous forward correlation)

• It gives today’s hedge but may not be static: need


for readjusting in the future
• Question: if readjusting is necessary, what is the
Equity
cost? Derivatives

Slide 23
download at wowebook.info

Diffusion models (II)


Cost of hedging
Guillaume
Some options exhibit a vega that varies with: BLACHER
• Spot Reech
• Volatility itself Capital
download at wowebook.info

Rebalancing vega hedge will produce systematic


cost/profit that can only be estimated will a
stochastic volatility model.
To price the cost of having... we need to model...
dVega Correlation (Spot, Vol) Equity
dSpot
Derivatives
dVega
Volatility of volatility
dVol Slide 25
Stationarity
Guillaume
• Many different ways to match current smile
BLACHER
• Choosing the wrong model means having non-
Reech
stationary parameters: Capital
download at wowebook.info

– Even when market does not change, model parameters


do
– Forward smiles not realistic

• Although the reason for choosing a model is


consistency and not ability to forecast, the cost of
rehedge will be wrongly estimated Equity
• Conclusion: try to find the model with most stable Derivatives

parameters Slide 26
download at wowebook.info

Model parameters / Calibration


Auto-calibrated models
Guillaume
• Some model can be considered as auto-calibrated:
BLACHER
“calibration” is analytical, quasi-instantaneous and
Reech
happens automatically inside the numerical
Capital
method
download at wowebook.info

• Examples:
– Local volatility in a Black-Scholes framework
– Local volatility in a deterministic volatility model
– Drift of the short term rate in an Heath-Jarrow-Morton
framework
Equity
– Instantaneous default probability if deterministic Derivatives
– etc...
Slide 28
Calibration
• More and more advanced models are not auto- Guillaume
BLACHER
calibrated
Reech
• Calibration is a long process
Capital
download at wowebook.info

• On the other hand, it is done once and for all (until


market conditions change significantly)
• Examples:
– Parameters of stochastic volatility / jump models
– Volatility in interest rate models

• Systems have to be flexible enough to let the Equity


Derivatives
calibration process happen independently from
pricing Slide 29
download at wowebook.info

Numerical methods
Trees
• Just a way to compute an expectation Guillaume
• Binomial trees obsolete (except for quick BLACHER
approximations) Reech
• Trinomial trees do the job, although they are less Capital
download at wowebook.info

efficient than PDEs.


• 2-dimensional trees technology well mastered

S2

spot spot Equity


S1
time time
Derivatives
time
Binomial Trinomial 2D Trinomial Slide 31
PDEs
• Allows for implicit discretisation Guillaume
• More flexibility on the grid BLACHER
• Better performance in general, much better for some
Reech
products (barriers for example)
Capital
• 2-dimensional PDEs technology well mastered
download at wowebook.info

• Provides option price at any time for any spot


Spot

Pay-off for an
Up&Out Call
Price PDE grid
profile
today
Equity
Derivatives
Option Intrinsic value
price Time Slide 32
Monte Carlo
• Low discrepancy series (ex: Sobol) provide very high Guillaume
convergence rate compared to standard Monte Carlo BLACHER
• Unfortunately biased in high dimension
• Dimension reduction techniques have to be used in high Reech
dimension (spectral truncation) Capital
download at wowebook.info

• Several very efficient techniques to price american style


options within simulations
1 1

0.9 0.9

0.8 0.8

0.7 0.7

0.6 0.6

0.5 0.5

0.4 0.4

0.3 0.3

0.2 0.2 Equity


0.1 0.1
Derivatives
0 0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Standard MC sampling Sobol sampling Slide 33


Complexity vs Performance
• More accurate models usually mean greater Guillaume
computation time. BLACHER

• Becomes an issue when thousands of positions Reech


Capital
have to be revalued.
download at wowebook.info

• Better understanding of models and numerical


speed-ups should precede the purchase of high-
end hardware.
• Using those instead of brutal calculation power
needs structural changes in trading systems
architecture. Equity
Derivatives

Slide 34
download at wowebook.info

Product description
Equity Derivatives richness
• Structured products and Derivatives have 3 main Guillaume
BLACHER
properties:
1) Extreme diversity of features Reech
Capital
2) All features have to be priced together
download at wowebook.info

3) Product popularity does not last forever

• This means:
– A lot of work for quants to implement new features in
the library
– Library contain high quantity of obsolete products (or
even products that have never been dealt) Equity
Derivatives

Slide 36
Generic product description
• Quants should: Guillaume
BLACHER
– spend no time implementing new products in a Library
– spend more time modeling the market parameters Reech
Capital
– spend more time improving their numerical methods
download at wowebook.info

• Structurers/Marketers should:
– spend no time waiting for quants to come up with a new
product in the Library
– spend more time studying the risks of the product
– spend more time trying new ideas
Equity
• What’s the solution? Derivatives
A generic product description language
Slide 37
The future of quantitative analysis

• Main challenge: Guillaume


BLACHER
model more sources of risk while maintaining
Reech
reasonable computation speed.
Capital
download at wowebook.info

• How is it possible?
– Better understanding of the products helps identifying
most important factors
– Some risks can be taken into account without increasing
the dimension
Equity
– More advanced numerical methods and numerical Derivatives
speed-ups are to be used
Slide 38

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen